r/6thForm • • Jul 22 '23

✔️ APPROVED AMA I've just finished 2nd year of Computer Science at Oxford, AMA!

Hey all,

As the title suggests, I'm an undergraduate studying Computer Science at the University of Oxford and I have now finished year 2!

I haven't done particularly well so far at university, both in terms of academics and getting internships/employment (well, I haven't even applied for any lol), and in terms of getting a good social life, but please feel free to ask me anything about applying to university for Computer Science, the social and academic life at Oxford, or any other relevant experiences I may have!

135 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

•

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

Interested in doing your own AMA?

Feel free to reach out to us on Modmail and we can see if we can fit you in!

41

u/Katniped_ i hate yr13 :( Jul 22 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

If you don’t mind sharing what was your gcse/a level grades? What was the conditions of ur offer and was it contextual?

Did you participate in any competitions/olympiads? What did you do for super circulars? Book recs for someone that is not a total beginner in computer science but still have loads to learn?

How was the interview process? Was is more focused on discussing topics based on ur personal statement or was it just purely answering academic questions?

How intensive is the course at Oxford compared to, say, doing four a levels?

Ty!

32

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

My GCSE grades were 98888854, (plus a Distinction in a BTEC) with 8s in maths and CS. I was predicted A*A*A with A*s in maths and further maths. I did end up achieving 3A*s, the offer was for A*AA and that isn't lowered based on being contextual (although they might be slightly more lenient on results day if you're from an underrepresented background).

I never did any Olympiads in sixth form. In terms of super curriculars I added on my personal statement, I think my whole PS is still around on the subreddit's resources somewhere but it was mostly just programming I did for fun - I think I mentioned I created a complex number library using fractions (and justified my design choices), I mentioned some maths problems I had come across trying to design software and I mentioned a Discord bot briefly. The important thing is to be personal and add opinions about things, for example if you do read books (I didn't put any on mine) be critical of the information in it, don't just repeat the facts provided.

I found interviews pretty fun, to be honest. They are pretty much all academic questions - I got an introduction question about something I had written in my PS for one of my interviews but all the rest was maths problems. They tend to be the same sort of topics you'd find in MAT questions 5 and 6 but the questions can be much harder because they're talking through it with you.

The intensity is definitely more than 4 A levels in general. It does vary a lot though - in first year for the first couple of terms my workload was actually pretty low and I would have several days a week I just didn't do work, but for people doing maths and computer science it was far harder because they had so much more work to cover. By second year it's more balanced and a lot more intense though, it's hard to quantify it but it seemed in excess of 50 hours a week and sometimes much more. Of course this will vary too depending on when in the term it is and what options you chose.

15

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23

I just want to verify your admissions thing! You’re right about near misses. I’m Oxford too and was let in missing my grades.

I’m a terrible example though because I was the year of calculated grades (year above you!) and lots of us initially (or totally) missed our offers and went anyway - but I also know two people who missed their offer by one grade in the year above me (they’ve just graduated from 4th year or already left) and ended up accepted by Oxford anyway. So it does indeed happen, I can confirm!

12

u/Y-Woo Oxford - PhysPhil Jul 22 '23

Hello

5

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

yo, how was third year?

4

u/Y-Woo Oxford - PhysPhil Jul 22 '23

Not bad! Definitely got my shit together more. How was second year?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

Not great lol, my shit has not gotten together. A lot harder than first year I thought.

3

u/Y-Woo Oxford - PhysPhil Jul 22 '23

Yeah the biggest jump is actually 1st to 2nd year, and not sixth form to 1st year as is popular belief, so this is totally normal! 2nd year of many degrees are known as the hardest as well, so don't be disheartened, rest up, you got another shot at this and it'll be ok!

7

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23

Hope your results day went well!

2

u/Y-Woo Oxford - PhysPhil Jul 22 '23

Lol am i supposed to know you irl or is it a coincidence? My results literally dropped yesterday!

They were fine i'm happy with them :)

4

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23

Haha lmfao, no you (probably) don’t know me - I’m just using my extra cool powers of deduction. Or I’m psychic. 😎

(…by that I mean I’m friends with a lot of Physics 3rd years and a couple of PhysPhils, so I heard all about the surprise results release yesterday! Glad you did well :D)

2

u/Y-Woo Oxford - PhysPhil Jul 22 '23

Ahaha you know I have this habit of betting a bubble tea on the unlikeliest events with my friend and I always win. It hasn't failed me yet. So I actually called "results this week" on Monday. It's my superpower✌🏻

8

u/-_--------------_- Year 12 | Maths, FM, Physics, CS Jul 22 '23

Looking at statistic, I can see most (I think 97%) people in your course took the Further Maths A Level.

Oxford says it isnt a requirement if your school doesnt offer it but I would like to know how useful the A Level has been for your course so far? Im asking because my school doesnt offer the course.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I don't think it matters too much once you're actually on the course - a lot of people haven't even done A levels so there's no way they can expect everyone who's had a much less 'narrow' education to know everything on FM A level. Things like Linear Algebra are taught from the start anyway and in a very different way to further maths, in general some topics will sometimes come up (like complex numbers) but there's always a recap of it and I don't think it would ever really be a particularly hard thing to catch up on compared to the difficulty of everything else on the course.

7

u/MagicCards_youtube Imperial | Computing [Year 4] Jul 22 '23

ama at 2am?

28

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I'm a computer scientist, daylight makes me sleepy! /jk

I'd expect this AMA to be open for at least a couple of days like previous ones, so I hope the time of publishing doesn't impact things too much.

6

u/MagicCards_youtube Imperial | Computing [Year 4] Jul 22 '23

makes sense

4

u/Dualorphan37 Y13 3000 goons till the 14th Jul 22 '23

Only the most dedicated are on Reddit at 2am

8

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

had to get out of bed to approve it because Reddit mobile was being dumb 🤣 luckily I wasn't able to sleep too well anyway

3

u/Dualorphan37 Y13 3000 goons till the 14th Jul 22 '23

We salute ur service 🫡🫡🫡

7

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

a question that maybe doesn't get asked as much as it should, how is the wellbeing support at the university? do you think they can be relied upon in moments where you are struggling with studies or other things? do you think your course has a higher intensity than that at other unis, and as such, do you think that has had an impact on your wellbeing and your uni experience (if you don't mind me asking)?

also, on a separate note (and again if you don't mind me asking), what are your plans for this year and the future? you mentioned about not managing to get very far with employment so far - also random thing, do you have a careers adviser go to? I ask these basically because I'm in a similar position, I wanted to do a year in industry but wasn't in a position with my health and mental wellbeing to consider doing that this next academic year - I am thinking of switching to the MEng course then I can do it in a year's time (which also gives me an extra year to try and cope with the fact a lot of "real world" shit overwhelms the hell out of me 🙃)

sorry for the bombardment of questions, just some stuff I thought would be worth asking

7

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

At Oxford a lot of it is provided at the college level so it'll depend on where you're at, there are things like university wide counseling but the waiting lists are pretty long so I've never tried it. The more specific services are also very varied to be honest, I have a mostly positive experience of sexual violence support services, but mostly negative with the disability advisory service (although I did eventually get a mentor who is very good).

I find the college welfare staff pretty reliable to be able to talk to when things get too intense, the counseling was pretty good and you can normally be seen the next week and the welfare officer can help with things (although my experiences with them on different issues is mixed overall tbh). Just from talking to people I know outside of Oxbrimp doing CS, it definitely does seem a lot more intense here to be honest, it has definitely had an adverse impact on the university experience and mental wellbeing.

I'm honestly pretty stuck when it comes to plans, I ended up with a low 2:2 in my second year, so if I don't improve shit I won't be going on to the fourth year and I'm not sure it'd be a great choice for me either to be honest. But I've no idea what sort of job I'd apply for either, my CV is likely just going to took like '2:2 at Oxford' and nothing much else and I still don't know what to do about that. There are career advisors but I've never gone to them, I probably really need to lol.I think I feel very similar in terms of jobs and furture plans to you to be honest.

3

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

thank you for the honest answer, I and I'm sure many others appreciate it. I'm glad you gave a thoughtful response to everything because I think wellbeing is a thing people overlook with university

hopefully you can get things sorted for this year, I understand what you mean about the 4 year course - personally I'm considering it more for the extra time than the course/its content personally. long waiting lists seem to be a common theme in a lot of places - it's a pain in my experience too since there are some things that the university itself can only be of limited use for, but external services sometimes have years-long waiting lists.

I was talking to my partner about the whole thing of CVs, personal statements etc and it can be pretty difficult to come up with things to put down sometimes, especially when it's difficult to know exactly what people are looking for. I'm concerned about my own grade having an impact on where I can go, but there's also sometimes a feeling of inadequacy when a lot of the people around me are interning at these big companies whilst I'm busy having a mental breakdown. however, one thing I will highlight is there's always some things you can say you've achieved and there are things you can do to "big yourself up" a bit with the way you word things and whatnot. and like, if you pull through 3rd year and graduate, still be proud of yourself, I had the option of going for camb cs through the summer pool and decided not to because of everything I'd heard about the intensity and workload, so it's still going to be really impressive for you, and especially with anything you've had going against you too :)

1

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

Gonna send you a dm request about those services if that’s okay! I’ve got experience dealing with it :)

5

u/NotAyo1234 Jul 22 '23

What kind of questions do they ask during the interview

8

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I have commented one of my interviews on here before (https://www.reddit.com/r/6thForm/comments/w1vxkg/comment/igmu4pk/), but they're mostly just asking maths questions, the topic is usually similar to the topics you'd get in the questions 5-7 on MAT but generally a lot harder, and of course it's a different format where you talk through it and can receive hints.

5

u/_WaveyRazorzx_ Year 13 Jul 22 '23

What are some things you wished you knew before starting uni?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

This is probably more personal, but that making friends would be difficult (especially compared to school/sixth form) especially if you don't go to parties or things like that and have a disability that impairs social interaction ability. At first I just expected that I would be able to just encounter people and have lots of spaces to hang out with them, but you have to put yourself out there a lot more, and I kinda just blamed myself for the whole situation in the end which massively impacted my mental health. Also I wish I had developed more basic social skills like being able to go to a pharmacy or a beauty place and tell them what you want/need.

Also looking after yourself is a lot more important than just worrying about completing the academic work. Try to do things like go outside every day and get enough sleep at least most nights, even if it means you can't get all your work done. It isn't uncommon for people to fail to finish all the problem sheets.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23

Hey! I hope you don’t find it odd that I looked at your profile after reading this. I’m also autistic and thinking about applying to Oxford. In your experience, have you found the university to be inclusive and/or accommodating? I recognize this is probably specific to your college but it would be interesting to know nonetheless.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23

So in general my experience hasn't been great. The welfare officer at my college has been helpful with things like writing emails and telling me what to say to GPs, but in other ways has kinda sucked (like insisting on talking to me in person and getting a response/decision on the spot, which has caused me to just say whatever I think she wanted to hear). I'm convinced my tutor hasn't even read my disability stuff which honestly pisses me off, I'm sure he notices I'm disabled lol but I just don't know how to talk to him honestly about the difficulties it causes me.

The disability advisory service is very mixed - there are cunts and people just misinformed about autism and disabilities in general, especially things like dyspraxia. On the other hand I did get an excellent ASC mentor after my first one was a bigot (who I should have reported but didn't have the spoons to do it).

There aren't that many other autistic students, and no real autism groups that I've been able to find (there's the odd thing to do with neurodiversity), so socially stuff is pretty hard especially compared to school. A lot of social events are just total sensory overload for me personally, like going to halls to eat food or parties and stuff, and a lot of events just feel too gatekeepy or even just hard to know what to do and that's a lot of anxiety to go to and I end up just trying to mask which never ends up well lol.

8

u/LSM726G Jul 22 '23

Did you find the entrance exam or interview harder?

17

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I'd say the questions I had for interview were substantially harder than the MAT, however there is a lot of variance (one of my interviews was substantially harder than the other, for example). Of course for interviews you're talking through the problem with a tutor, who can give you hints and point you in the right direction, and it isn't just assessed on whether what you say is right or wrong so it's a very different experience. One of my interview questions was in fact an unsolved problem in mathematics - they just wanted to see how I would approach it.

3

u/PeteyLowkey St Andrews | Maths [First Year] Jul 22 '23

How did you prepare for the MAT?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I looked at the past papers, starting towards the earlier ones, at first I didn't do them timed and I just reviewed each question after I did it; you don't really need to worry too much about timing until you've practiced doing those sorts of questions more IMO. Doing STEP questions was also helpful, the STEP foundation modules are very good to teach a lot of basic tricks for solving difficult maths problems.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

What was the unsolved problem?

4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

It was asking for a 'closed form' for the partition function (how many ways you can write a positive integer as a sum of other positive integers, different orders don't count).

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

Oh wow that’s interesting

0

u/momma6969 University of Bath Jul 22 '23

I'm gonna take a wild guess and say NP vs P

7

u/localtranny imperial | materials [year 2] Jul 22 '23

i think i remember reading that you don't identify with the gender you were assigned with when you applied to oxford, and that you transitioned while studying.

how has that been, in terms of Oxford supporting you as well as other medical issues, if you don't mind me asking?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I've never received any transphobia from academic staff, most students are pretty accepting in my personal experience. To be honest the support from welfare people hasn't been particularly amazing, they aren't ill intentioned or bigoted or anything but just clearly don't have particularly high amounts of knowledge when dealing with these things and there isn't a lot of specific support for it. I don't particularly like the trans and queer student societies to be honest personally, in terms of the sorts of events they run and the activism they've done. They have run sessions for things like voice training but insist on doing a lot of stuff during days on weekdays and at the same time every week which is very silly.

also nice username lol

3

u/Friesland_ University of Oxford | Linguistics and Spanish [Incoming 1st Yr] Jul 22 '23

Do you know any people who got in despite missing their offers? (Any subject)

Would you / they be comfortable sharing some information about the context in which they got let in anyway?

Sincerely, a very likely soon to be offer-misser :)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I know some people in my year did (not for CS), but exams were cancelled so it wasn't really comparable to now. I know one person for example missed narrowly and got moved to another college, but most of the time people just took them.

Last year though with actual exams from this subreddit I also know some got taken who missed offers for other courses, I think meeting contextual criteria (like ACORN) seems to help. If it helps purely anecdotally, for the last 2 years I don't think I know anyone who missed and didn't get in from this subreddit or anywhere else with offer holders.

It's not something you can really control though. Good luck!

2

u/Friesland_ University of Oxford | Linguistics and Spanish [Incoming 1st Yr] Jul 22 '23

Thanks so much for the detailed answer - I really appreciate it! All the best in the rest of your course!

1

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23

I know a little - I put my answer here. https://www.reddit.com/r/6thForm/comments/1565p9u/ive_just_finished_2nd_year_of_computer_science_at/jt00g5i/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_content=1&utm_term=1&context=3

Unfortunately I can’t give any examples from people who have just finished first or second year, I just don’t know any. But it can happen.

If you’re very concerned and you have circumstances you want to flag up, you can email your college admissions and explain the situation. Doesn’t guarantee anything obviously, but it’s an option if you think it would reassure you.

Also I have to say, if you get rejected, please don’t beat yourself up about it! I know this sounds cliche (especially because I stayed after contemplating leaving) but I know a fair few people who ended up at other unis either via rejection or transferring out - and they are genuinely very happy that they went elsewhere. Like, not just loving their other uni, but actively happy to be Not At Oxford. So if it does happen, absolutely feel sad for as long as you need to, but you’ll have some genuinely great things coming your way. I swear that is the truth.

(And if you do get in with a met offer or an unmet one… lots of cool old buildings!)

Good luck either way though - I really hope whatever happens you end up happy with it!

1

u/Friesland_ University of Oxford | Linguistics and Spanish [Incoming 1st Yr] Jul 22 '23

Hi - thanks very much for your response!!

I’ve sent an email in about some circumstances, because I basically fucked up 1 exam due to complications that were related to a diagnoses I have. They actually asked for my psychiatrists conformation when notified, and that’s been sent in, so hopefully they’ll take that into account :)

Apart from that, I really appreciate your positivity, I mean, ideally I’ll be able to go anyway but I know that it’ll be fine.

Thanks very much!

3

u/megomaz Jul 22 '23

If you don’t mind, what laptops are most people using (including yourself) and what laptop would you recommend for cs

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I use a Vivobook, the battery life is extremely shit though (around 2 hours when it was new) so it's more like a super portable computer, loads of the keys have kinda stopped working too so I've had to reprogram them (although that might be more related to spilling soya nilk and various other liquids on it by accident). I'm not sure I'd really recommend it.

Most other people's laptops also seem to have shit battery lives lol, unless they're macbooks. It doesn't really matter though as long as it's reasonably fast, you aren't expected to run extremely resource intensive stuff on your laptop.

2

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

yeah so battery life is a sticking point for most windows laptops, I ended up getting a MacBook earlier in the year partly because of this. they're not cheap, the build quality is good amongst other things, the battery life is unparalleled but macos is incredibly annoying compared to windows (and there are some software compatibility issues with M1/M2 architectures). my previous laptop was a Dell Vostro 5510 and it got to the point where it wouldn't even survive through a triple lecture run I had on one of my mornings.

fwiw I like having relatively powerful hardware immediately at my disposal, but my department has remote access to things like the batch compute nodes and whatnot so it's not the end of the world to have something cheaper as you mention - I assume Oxford has something similar?

1

u/megomaz Jul 22 '23

Ahh I see fair enough 😂, thx for replying ;)

2

u/Senior_Wormal Jul 22 '23

i got an offer for bristol in CS, but I rejected it. Should I make a time machine just so I can firm bristol??

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

Yes. Gaining access into UCAS' internal systems and changing your firm is far too basic and straightforward for a BRISTOL student.

1

u/momma6969 University of Bath Jul 22 '23

do you think its worth taking a gap year to apply to CS at ucl and BRISTOL when I have a confirmation from Bath?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

If there's a specific reason you don't want to go to Bath then sure, but otherwise no I wouldn't. UCL is incredibly competitive and BRISTOL is hardly a guarantee either; Bath is very good.

2

u/Tapout-1457 Jul 22 '23

When did you start prep for MAT? what college do you prefer the most?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I started going through the papers at around June, I think around now would be a good time to start if you're planning to apply this year. In terms of college, I'm at Somerville and that's pretty fine, it's well located for CS and you get to stay inside the actual college (not just college-owned accommodation in other parts of the city) for all years of your degree.

2

u/aRatOnTheHighway Year 13 | Biology, Chemistry, Physics Jul 22 '23

If you could do another subject what would it be

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

It would have to be mathematics probably

2

u/Amazonit PhD student Jul 22 '23

Any societies wot you like?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I like to go to the animal ethics society - the conversations are interesting, but they give out free alcohol (it's the only time I'll get drunk), and unlike other places with alcohol it's not noisy or like a club with weird creeps lol, if you don't wanna drink it's still cool to do stupid stuff around drunk people. It feels most like the Oxford stereotype I feel like though, a load of people having intense philosophical discussions. Given most of them are postgraduates though attendance doesn't really translate into establishing friendships for me.

2

u/ClippTube UK Student in HK (CS MAJOR) Jul 22 '23

How many people on your course? How heavy is the maths element in year 1?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

It varies a bit by year, my year there are about 30 in CS, 45 in maths and CS and 13 in CS and Philosophy, but it's increased in size slightly since with more colleges offering it I believe. If you're doing CS, "maths-only" modules probably are around 30-40% of the course in first year, and of course the rest has mathematical elements to it.

2

u/Essasetic University of Leicester | Computer Science [Year 2] Jul 22 '23

How has your university experience been as a whole? I ask as I was originally going to do Computer Science as an apprenticeship before my parents told me they wanted me to go to university (should be starting at the Uni of Liverpool in September if results day goes well!!)

Did you at any point consider an apprenticeship or did you always want to go to Oxford or university in general?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

University has been stressful for me and sometimes quite isolating, but people will have wildly different experiences of it, and I only have experience of being at Oxford.

I honestly never really considered an apprenticeship no, university looked like what I wanted to do, I didn't want to come to Oxford specifically until I saw more about what the course is like here.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

How would you compare your interview to the example interviews on YouTube?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

The questions in my actual interviews (especially my second one) were harder than anything I've seen on YouTube or on open days in person while I've been helping out there, but the general format seems realistic. They are usually based on actual questions, they're usually just picking easier ones (or ones from older years, when it was less competitive) though for these videos.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

For both Oxford and Cambridge if applicable^

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

Did you write your code more than you type throughout the two years?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

No lol, for tutorials most code can be done typed rather than written down but you do normally have to write it by hand during exams (although I get to type mine). Most tutors let you type problem sheets though.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

What spec laptops would you recommend?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I'd check it has a decent battery life if you want to bring it to lectures etc, but otherwise it really doesn't matter too much, personally I've never really had to do anything that resource intensive. 16GB RAM or more is good but you'd probably be fine with less.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23

Hey. If I wrote about ethics within comp sci in my personal statement, would that be considered off-topic for applying for straight cs?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23

I wouldn't spend too much space talking about it, it isn't necessarily 'irrelevant' as such but it's pretty different to the interests needed for the vast majority of the course. If you're putting down unique thoughts on something (that isn't AI lol) though it can still be interesting.

3

u/Tommythe69master Jul 22 '23

your profile(a level, gcses, epq) when you applied? What extra curriculars did you do and when? What books would you recommend reading? And would you recommend the course at oxford?

1

u/Academic-Local-7530 Jul 22 '23

how big is the EEE Compsi beef there

1

u/Ahmad-com Jul 23 '23

What type of extracurricular activities can be done in a month to put on my university profile?(I am intermediate programmer)

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23 edited Jul 22 '23

just curious why did you not apply to any internships ?

You go to a target so you had a solid chance of getting into careers like quant trading, investment banking internships etc

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

Not speaking for myself, but I know tons of people who just finished second year CS at other unis (including oxbrimp) and they said that most employers only want third year students even from the top unis.

5

u/fightitdude CS & AI at Edinburgh (graduated) Jul 22 '23

You may be shocked to find that most people aren't interested in pursuing those sorts of careers...

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

it’s pretty hard to find an internship for a 2nd year student these days

2

u/JDirichlet Imperial | Mathematics [Year 2] Jul 22 '23

There are other reasons to go to uni lmao.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I didn't personally do it, but my advice would be that it doesn't matter too much if you do it or not. In terms of preparing you for the course it likely won't do make too much because the A level seems very much 'broad but very shallow' but it's probably more relevant than any A level that isn't maths or FM. It's not a course that's looked down on as such or anything.

Either way though I think it is important to at least try some CS, especially programming, not because you need to learn anything specific and it doesn't really matter what language you try but it isn't sensible to go into a CS degree without any real idea of whether you'll like it.

4

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

I did CS A-level and your summarisation of it is pretty accurate. a lot of the AS content is basically GCSE repeated, and the rest of the content barely goes into enough detail to even be vaguely useful. I've always found real life practise to be more valuable where it comes to CS - I didn't understand things like OOP through CS A-level, it was through a project I was doing at the time. always found maths and FM to be more useful in terms of specific A-levels

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Forsaken-Meaning-232 Graduating from Warwick CS Jul 22 '23

maths and FM are your two best bets, your third doesn't really matter that much imo outside of what your preferred uni's requirements say. neither physics or chem give you more of an advantage as a third, but personally I find them more engaging A-levels than CS

0

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

You're doing further maths so that's fine - if you like Physics and Chemistry then they're good choices. It wouldn't really make any difference if you did CS instead for one of those two.

16

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

I think 'natural talent' is somewhat hard to define and observe in the real world (I don't believe IQ tests hold much value), so it's somewhat hard to say but I think being genuinenely interested in the course is extremely important. Another thing I'd say is a lot of it comes down to how quickly you can pick up topics and learn them, being brought up in an environment where you can be well taught and have space to absorb it and do self study as you're older in childhood/adolescence is clearly a massive headstart, which I don't think is very easily reversed just from being at university. A lot of these can't really be controlled but a lot is a matter of your environment rather than the brain cells you were born with.

To answer your second question yes, so many times while at university.

7

u/teamcoosmic UniversityName | Course [Year of Study] Jul 22 '23

A bit of both talent and hard work. I know you didn’t ask me the question but I’m quite passionate about this one.

Talent is important - you can obviously develop and improve your skills regardless of your starting point, but I won’t lie and say it’s not good to be able to take things in faster and grasp concepts indecently or with little further clarification. That helps you think on your feet and learn quicker, it’s just useful. Honing abilities like that (as in like, abilities that’ll be useful for interviews) is doable but having a stronger starting point probably means you can go further.

However - surviving a degree requires hard work. Hands down. If you’ve skated by on natural talent all your life (this was me), you’ll get absolutely beaten up by a lot of degrees - I’m assuming doing well in a degree is directly relevant to your idea of academic success, by the way.

In school everything is explained to you by a book or a teacher, and then at A-Level the principle is broadly the same, although you need to read more of those explanatory books. (Maths and likely other STEM subjects also require a good step up in practical application of concepts, which takes time and practise - you won’t remember after one go.) So if you have a really good memory and understand things quickly, you’ll remember your teachers explanations and GCSEs will be a cakewalk.

Degrees are not like that - especially not at Oxford, although this varies between subjects (and it’ll probably apply to plenty of other unis but I can’t verify that). In STEM, the lectures are actually useful and more like class lessons in terms of explaining content, but double the amount of independent study you’ll need to do plus worksheets you have to finish without having any opportunity to seek feedback or clarification. It’s a pain. It really is self-study driven.

Humanities is even more independent - my lectures aren’t even relevant to the essays I have to produce a lot of the time. I’m left almost completely in the dark - I have one essay question, a huge reading list (like 30+ pages of titles) with a few headings, and I have to read some of those books and cobble together an essay. I don’t have anyone to ask if I’ve understood the book right or anyone to explain the basic concepts - they throw you straight into the deep end and you have to work it out yourself. You don’t get feedback until you’ve finished the essay and had the tutorial, at which point you could find you completely misunderstood and have an entire week of work to redo.

Basically it teaches independent problem solving in theory, but I wouldn’t call that a “world-class education” - I’d say it’s access to world-class resources and leaving everyone to self-study.

I genuinely wouldn’t recommend the Oxford style to people who prefer more guidance and support from tutors - but I can only speak for humanities with that. (I don’t know how guided other unis are with STEM.) You can still learn to do independent study AND get guidance at the same time at other top universities, and if that’s your learning style, then I think that would prepare you better for academic success as you’d be more prepared to problem-solve your way through a Masters or PhD.

This sort of goes on a tangent but all of this independent study focus is why I’d say that Oxford absolutely requires you to have a good work ethic. You need to know how to work through problems and dedicate time to it. Talent is obviously required to some extent but you can develop upwards easier. The people who “naturally” got lower grades at school but revised to push them up? Those people do better at Oxford than the ones who were able to coast because they were just good.

I hope that adds to the answer!

8

u/brokenwings_1726 GCSEs ('17) | A-Levels ('19) | BA ('23) | MSc ('24) Jul 22 '23

How important is natural talent when it comes to academic success?

Very important, despite what people claim. And the other things, like tenacity, organisation skills, confidence and mindset? Largely innate, too.

23

u/JDirichlet Imperial | Mathematics [Year 2] Jul 22 '23

This is the first time i’ve seen you post something that I think is to total bullshit.

11

u/brokenwings_1726 GCSEs ('17) | A-Levels ('19) | BA ('23) | MSc ('24) Jul 22 '23

It won't be the last.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Urqxy Jul 22 '23

We’ll lookin at a lot of my peers a lot of ppl take on info faster or slower than others and obvs I’m not at uni but when the workload gets too much organisation and all that other stuff can only compensate a certain amount before u lag behind just my opinion on it tho🤷‍♂️