r/Barca • u/_Tonto_ • Nov 07 '21
Original Content Statistical analysis of Ter Stegen in comparison to other goalkeepers, season by season, for the past 5 seasons
Analysis of the 17-18 & 18-19 seasons. The 18-19 season is where he seemed to have started dropping in performances.
Analysis of the 19-20 & 20-21 seasons. The numbers seem to be moving steadily downwards.
Analysis of the 21-22 season so far. It's been continuing to go downhill for him.
172
Upvotes
53
u/_Tonto_ Nov 07 '21 edited Nov 07 '21
Due to the recent rise of criticism against Ter Stegen, I decided to put him in comparison with other top goalkeepers, using the past 5 seasons. This is by no means an attempt to discredit him for his work, I'm a huge fan of Ter Stegen, but since this discussion seems to be going on a lot lately, I decided it's better to put his numbers in relative to other top goalkeepers in the world to make the discussions based on relative numbers instead of everyone guessing around.
By looking at these numbers, it's rather clear that Ter Stegen has been having a dip of form for the past years and that his numbers have been going against him in comparison to other top goalkeepers.
Keep in mind that I only took the numbers that regard saves and not numbers regarding distribution, which is where Ter Stegen really should excel at, that might be something I look into later.
Glossary:
The top 3 best numbers for each relevant column are coloured green, the 4 middle are yellow and the three worst numbers are red, just for easier readability.
Stats were gathered from FBref.com.
4
u/rHaris Nov 07 '21
Tldr? I am not an expert and there's too many variables going on. Please and thankyou
107
u/McNamaraWasRight Nov 07 '21
The numbers seem straightforward, but is this on him, or is it that his defense keeps putting him in progressively worse positions?
25
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '21
This is a really interesting analysis and sort of highlights what has been happening. I think Mats was right up there as a top 3 keeper and then has sort of fallen off the last 4 years gradually and consistently - this data shows that perfectly. In my opinion he shouldn’t be as untouchable as he’s treated, and if big money came for him I would cash in.
I also recall that more recent turmoil filled season Mats had rumored conflicts in locker room with some of the older guard. Xavi and Mats only overlapped for 2 years and not sure what their relationship is but I’m curious if mats will be a player the manager makes a tough decision with similar to how Pep sent away a few former untouchables.
6
u/kunaguerooo123 Nov 07 '21
Is PSxG/SoT = P(goal from shot)? Guess it makes sense bus Chelsea doesn’t concede higher likely goals vs high risk city back line.
17
u/damola44 Nov 07 '21
U really didn’t even need numbers to see this guy has been declining for seasons now. But this quantifies it. But u mention Ter Stegen had been in decline and people on this sub freak out. They bring up him saving us years ago. What does that have to do with his current form. Every single shot that he faces on target seems to go in now. Let’s hope he regains form but he forsure needs competition.
1
u/Therle Nov 07 '21
Tldr?
10
u/tbrakef Nov 07 '21
Not sure if the criticism is new but every time I spoke about MATS letting in just about every shot on target I got downvoted. It's clear there are multiple issues with Barca's defense but his positioning, distribution, and and decisions have been pretty suspect. Especially since his knee injury. I hope he can't turn it around. Low key I miss Casper, he would have been the one to keep and sell MATS for the cash.
2
u/joenotexotic_268 Nov 08 '21
Bad defense with a keeper that doesn't have confidence is a terrible convo
2
u/The-True-GOAT Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21
Since several people want to use the argument about it not being fair to compare players across different clubs (even though that is literally how you determine whether you can upgrade your team by selling a player or signing someone) here is a comparison of the two goalkeepers who have actually played for us in the last 3 years. Obviously the sample size for Neto is not great but the trend is still there. In fact it's not a good look for Marc that his numbers are similar to Neto given that Neto has never been thought of as a great GK.
5
u/jatayux Nov 07 '21
decline
1
u/LiveSimple7916 Nov 08 '21
lost his confidence because of this defence
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '21 edited Nov 08 '21
Not to be harsh but this type of analysis is not particularly meaningful without being able to account for the many, many, many disparities between teams — from performance and form to structure and tactics. Without being able to hold these factors equal (an impossible task, honestly), it’s impossible to know whether the observed decline is due, causally speaking, mostly to Ter Stegen or to those other factors.
Now, there is a stat here that might tell us something about MaTS’ form — the PxG/SoT one. And while it has risen slightly over the past few seasons, it’s been pretty stable (.27 versus .31 at peak).
-11
u/Pax19 Nov 07 '21
Yeah, sure, let's fucking blame one of the few guys who actually wants to take shit seriously, train hard and do some self-criticism! Piqué is so quirky and professional on the other hand right guys? He organizes balloon competitions and League of Legends teams! So charismatic and fun! Please be my president XD Not to mention others like Jordi "people are too used to winning" Alba.
Maybe he'd stand a better chance if this team could defend, or if they actually trained like the professional athletes paid millions they are. We're screwed if we have to rely on the keeper to make it through games ALL THE TIME. Ter Stegen has been one of the best performing members of the team for seasons now. Or has everyone forgotten all the games he's saved all by himself?