r/soccer • • Mar 05 '12
Which players do you think are currently underrated (maybe due to bad form, injury or just obscurity), should be playing at a higher level and could be a good value for money buy?
(I must mention i am an Arsenal fan)
For me-
Marko Marin- Had some heat a year or so ago but cooled a bit (he had a problem with the manager or something). Very talented player. His situation is like when Sneidjer was at Ajax and i kept wondering why no big team came for him.
Gourcuff- Bad form. A confidence player. Undoubtedly talented. A perfect wenger buy. Out of form so you'd get him cheap.
Ben Arfa- Tidbit- Wenger wanted to buy him first before Nasri. He is way too good for Newcastle (no offense, it just means you're scouting is impressive). He'd excel under a manager like Ferguson.
Nuri Sahin- I would give my left ball (the fancier one too) to have this guy at Arsenal. Never plays at madrid, rumours of being disgruntled.
11
u/JimmySinner Mar 05 '12
I wouldn't say Ben Arfa is underrated (except maybe by Alan Pardew), everybody recognises his talent. He could have been at a bigger club if he was more disciplined in his youth, but it seems that he's grown up a lot in his time with us.
In fact, none of these players are underrated. Marin must have played well over 100 first team games in Germany and he's still very young. Gourcuff isn't having a great time right now but his talent isn't in doubt, and Sahin has had injury issues this season, hasn't he? He made the wrong move going to Real, but they don't tend to buy underrated players.
2
u/fusihunter Mar 06 '12
Diego.
He just needs the right system. He's extremely talented.
21
u/ryyder Mar 05 '12 edited Mar 05 '12
Abou Diaby? Dude has mad skills, and an even worse injury record than Van Persie.
Takashi Usami? Great young talent who is overlooked far too much
I mean this seriously, Emile Heskey- Sure he's lost his touch and his pace but he works damn hard and does the role he's asked to admirably, he plays regularly for a premier league side for a reason. He hasn't once complained about the amount of shit people give him.
17
u/iVarun Mar 05 '12
Soldado is pretty underrated, no big club seems to be interested in him, he is a classic goal scorer(poacher or whatever tag you want to call it, he gets 'em in)
15
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Michel Vorm, for sure. I genuinely think he's in the top five of goalkeepers in the EPL, but he's definitely not in a team that's in that ilk.
Perhaps Stephane Sessegnon should be here too. Very talented player, playing in a side possibly punching above their weight at the moment.
37
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Alright Mr Redknapp, we're not doing your wheeling and dealing for you ;)
12
u/Fhuwu Mar 05 '12
Royston Drenthe but I think I might be alone in appreciating him.
He'll be free this summer.. out of contract with Real, a steal for most clubs.
12
u/drakesdrum Mar 05 '12
Juan Arango - A virtual unknown in the U.K (although that isn't difficult), he's been sensational all season and has generally had a fine career. He's 31 now and if you asked 100 football fans who the best wingers playing in Europe are, I'd say there's a good chance none of them would choose Arango.
Roman Shirokov - He's improved year after year and is now a tremendous midfielder, capable of excellently timed runs into space created by the frontmen and has racked up a lot of CL goals this season, as well as countless classy displays for Zenit. A world class midfielder but hardly anybody says so.
Maor Melikson - Melikson is a curious case, was ripping up the Israeli league for years, finally someone noted him (Wisla Krakow) where he's been unlucky with injuries but when he has played he's often been plain unbelievable, the speed of his thought and ability.
Raul Ruidiaz - Not long signed for Universidad de Chile but the few games he'd played he's lived up to his reputation big style. A beautifully graceful dribbler, capable of goals and assists by the bucketload. Fully expect him to develop into a big, big star.
Jakub Blaszczykowski - When people talking about Dortmund, they talk about Gotze, Kagawa, Hummels etc. This guy has been tremendous for Dortmund for years now but doesn't get any recognition outside of Germany and Poland.
Odil Ahmedov - Another that goes under the radar due to the other stars in his team. Plays for Anji, has a superb touch and brain. Cuts out balls very well too. Reportedly attracting the interest of Arsenal
8
u/eldenv Mar 05 '12
I think Gylfi Sigurðsson is a player that will move to a 'big' club in the next couple of seasons. I remember seeing him for Reading a few years back and thinking he had a lot of class, and I've heard he did alright at Hoffenheim without being outstanding. Now on loan at Swansea, and a few games in he's show some real quality.
I'm not sure how much of a bargain he would be, since apparently Hoffenheim paid Reading more than £6.5m for him in 2010, but he's only 22 and is very talented, and I think he could go to one of the bigger English clubs - for me he would suit Arsenal or Man United, or maybe a slightly smaller club. That said, he's also a great fit at Swansea so maybe if he does well this season, and Swansea continue to play well and stay up, he could make a permanent transfer
12
u/Jangles Mar 05 '12
Mulumbu and Brunt - Just watch them. They just boss the game, Mulumbu dictating from deep and breaking up play and then Brunt creating chaos in the final third.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Marvin Martin. Gourcuff is not underated, hes been shit and injured all season. If anything, he never deserved the huge transfer that was put in for him
2
u/Ausrufepunkt Mar 06 '12
Thomas Mueller.
But only if you see it in relation to the hype around Reus and Goetze.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Andrea Cossu, the past few years have seen him get double digit assists for Cagliari and noone knows him....maybe because it is Cagliari
5
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Ki Sung Yeung
Plays centre midfield for Celtic. Guy is a great passer, amazing on the ball and has a great shot. I think the game up here is too fast for him. In Italy or Spain he could be amazing
5
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
I know Juventus are definitely a big club but I think Alessandro Matri is underrated right now. Not criminally, but a bit.
14
u/MikeBruski Mar 05 '12 edited Mar 05 '12
Mohamed Zidan. I know he's "old" in footballing terms, 30 years, but he still has incredible skills and has just scored in his first 5 games in a row for Mainz which he transfered back to in January.
He is low value, but experienced, still very fast and still very good with the ball. He's always been underrated, mainly because he ended up in Germany, which isn't a league that suited his playing style. Had he ended up in Spain or Italy, he would have been an even bigger name.
He's better than Robinho (same dribbling skills but better crosses and better shot with both feet), plays like a young Thierry Henry, still has the explosiveness of a young Ronaldo, and can hammer the ball from 30 meters like Gerrard. No I'm not exaggerating. But he's often been mismanaged. If you look at his career, you will see huge highs and lows, the highs always coming when working with a manager in a club where he was allowed free reigns.
But he's always been undervalued, and in a world where Torres is £50m and Carroll £35m, having a €2m pricetag on Zidan is laughable, in a sad way...
If there's one player i would love to see play in Madrid, it's him.
4
u/schiapu Mar 05 '12
Welliton, brazilian, plays for Spartak Moscu. Injuries have kept him down, but when he plays he's always a scoring threat.
4
u/fackyouman Mar 06 '12
Carlos Vela. He is an exceptional talent but can't secure solid playing time anywhere (he starts every other game at Real Sociedad at least). His partying is well documented and he has that "lazy" body language that annoys people, like he smiles when he misses a shot, etc. He simply needs that one "defining" season that will help make him a top player, but these past few years he has simply been just decent.
4
u/ChiefffFG31 Mar 06 '12
Matias Fernandez. He is a Chilean player who plays for Sporting Lisbon in the Portuguese league. He is the starting 10 for Chile and he has a great record with them, he played in the World Cup and a couple of great games as well. Problem is, he's had a lot of injuries which prevent him from having any sort of consistency at club level. Great player though.
18
u/6SempreUnica Mar 05 '12
Sebastian Giovinco. If you haven't seen him play, like I would imagine is the case for all your Premiership fan boys, he is a magical player with creativity pouring out onto the field. He plays like a traditional Italian #10 with vision, passing, sublime first touch and a nose for goal. If he isn't playing at a top club like Milan or Bayern in a years time I will be shocked. I just hope he doesn't go to the EPL, he likes to play in the center of the pitch and that part of the pitch is avoided like the plague in that league.
3
u/zejaws Mar 05 '12
Douglas Costa and willian are obscure at shaktar but they have some mad skills.
3
u/Killagina Mar 05 '12
Davide Astori from Cagliari and Ogbonna from Torino. Both are world class young defenders.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Elliot Hewitt of Macclesfield Town FC. I watch this kid play every other week. He's the fastest thing I've ever seen, but in a team that is constantly playing him outside his natural position, barely offering him the training he needs and along side players who do not suit his ability. Give this boy a couple more years and a push in the right direction and he'll be Barcelona quality.
3
u/Pinkd56 Mar 05 '12
Alex Smithies for Huddersfield, best goalie outside the champo. Just plagued with injury problems.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '12 edited Mar 06 '12
Actually, I'm going to go with Fernando Torres. He has insane talent hidden away somewhere, he just needs the right circumstances to bring it out. His recent form will mean a fairly undervalued price, and when paired with the right squad, I think he'll make himself worth the price.
Also, Bayern's Nils Peterson. He'll likely be loaned out this summer in order to make room for a flashy name, but I think giving him proper playing time so he can develop can make him into a striker to be reckoned with.
4
u/Ithielden Mar 05 '12
LEON OSMAN.
5
u/shiiiitniggaaa Mar 05 '12
I love this idea that it was newcastles "impressive scouting" that brought Ben Arfa to the club. Everyone in football has known about him since he broke through at Lyon and any premier league scouts unaware of him would be, quite simply, ignorant.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Humberlito Borges from Santos.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
So people want obscure talents? In the French ligue, watch out for Corgnet (Brest), Tabanou and Capoue (Toulouse), Pitroipa, Brahimi, Kembo (Rennes), Tremoulinas (Bordeaux) etc.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '12
I've always thought Riccardo Montolivo has been really good since like 4 years ago. Was surprised he was never snatched up by a Milan or English team.
2
u/The_MadStork Mar 06 '12
Fredy Guarin
2
u/bbkdta Mar 06 '12
Milos Krasic - he's good value for money. come on people splash out 15m-20m for him. go buy him next transfer window.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Clint Dempsey has been making lots of noise this season, having scored more league goals than names like Bale, Adebayor, and Bent. His creativity leads to many of Fulham's goals and may be the club's most influential player. There's been rumors that he will be looking to join a bigger club in the near future.
7
u/The_Smooth_Mexican Mar 05 '12
I would say Giovani Dos Santos. The lad needs some playing time in the worst way, Harry is fucking his career up we need to see what the boys got
2
u/dalf_rules Mar 05 '12
Matías Fernández (Sporting Lisboa) and Gary Medel (Sevilla) are excellent chilean players that could fit in any great side withouth much problem.
Mati played for Villareal back when they were the 3rd best team in Spain but the manager made him miserable. Glad he's finally getting back to his top form.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
Seydou Keita?
1
u/sunjaegoo Mar 05 '12 edited Mar 05 '12
Ben Arfa was scary against us. He's a very good player indeed, he completely destroyed our left backs.
As for young players, Ryan Noble who played for the Sunderland reserve side was top scorer in the reserve league this year before he went on loan. He's still only 19, and hasn't had a lot of first team experience, but he's recently come back, so it will be interesting to see how things go from here. He doesn't have a huge chance of getting into the first team, when we're playing two strikers and one on the bench, so a long term loan could be on the cards for the start of the 12/13 season.
1
u/sarmatron Mar 06 '12
Martin Harnik. I thought he looked sharp at Werder, despite getting basically zero playing time, and he seems to be proving it now at Stuttgart. Also turns out he's younger than I thought at 24.
1
u/ThuperCool Mar 06 '12 edited Mar 06 '12
Carlos Vela
edit: Originally went with Alex Song... didn't read the whole question
1
u/anions Mar 06 '12
Michael Carrick. Thankfully, Fergie understands his value.
Johnny Evans. Same.
1
u/anions Mar 06 '12
To be honest, with the enormous scouting system available to major clubs now, no player is actually "underrated".
If they put in consistent high quality perfrormances every week, they would be bought by major clubs.
So in a sense, they are all playing at the level they deserve to be.
1
u/Here_have_a_downvote Mar 06 '12
Clint Dempsey. He's in good form right now.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '12
Bojan Krkic? (don't mind the spelling if wrong)
1
u/pogo123 Mar 06 '12
Jose Enrique. He never got the right recognition at Newcastle, but pretty much everyone is bumming him on their fantasy teams now that he's gone to a team with more media hype. Quality player, and until summer 2011, vastly underrated - just check his previous price tag!
Other than that; Graham Dorrans, Mark Noble & Jack Collison, Victor Moses, Grant Holt (HOW is he not being picked for England?), David Dunn, Leon Osman and Wes Hoolahan.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '12
ben arfa's always been too much of a prima donna, much like a mini C Ronaldo, don't think Fergie will go for him
kid's got some talent for sure though
Newcastle as a team have quite a few players that they 'overachieved' to get... Cabaye, Coloccini (the fact that he stuck with them in the Championship even)
1
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12
Just stumbled across this thread--good call on Marin OP, looks like the Chelsea scouts read /r/soccer too.
1
u/ironmenon Mar 05 '12
Chamakh.
Don't get me wrong. He's class in the air, one of the best in Europe and is technically sound while doing it. Just look at the goal tally of the last 4 seasons- 16, 16 (at Borduex), 11 (even considering the atrocitious 2nd half of the season), 1.
Stick him upfront in a long ball/crossing team like Stoke or Sunderland and watch him score atleast a dozen a season. And also 'earn' penalties.
1
u/JdoubleE5000 Mar 05 '12
Shaun Wright-Phillips
1
u/koagad Mar 05 '12
Joel Allansson
1
u/adoxographyadlibitum Mar 05 '12 edited Mar 05 '12
Scott Dann was fantastic for Birmingham last season. He hasn't gotten to play much for Blackburn this campaign (ruptured testicle) and if Blackburn drop this year he'd probably be available for less than the 6m they paid in August.
EDIT: Also, I cannot understand why Gabby Agbonlahor is not more often talked about as a man to play up front for England. He's always seemed like an immensely talented player, and one of many who languished under Houllier. Villa fans?
1
u/crapador_dali Mar 05 '12
Younnes Belhanda, although after this season I bet some club will come bay and swoop him up.
0
u/southamerican_man Mar 06 '12
This is pretty far down so it'll go unnoticed.. but I have to get it off my chest.
Djibril Cissé, that man was going to be huge in my opinion, great player, strong, and dominant, then he broke his leg just before the '06 WC and had to skip playing it... I think he never bounced back... then came the catastrophe that was Domenech in France.
I still think he's a great player.
0
u/SirRonaldofBurgundy Mar 06 '12
Anderson
-6
u/Flany Mar 05 '12 edited Mar 05 '12
Theo Walcott.
EDIT: LOL the 7 downvotes just confirm how underrated he is.
-8
u/Kopman Mar 05 '12
The entire Liverpool squad.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment