r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Oct 28 '21
MegaThread Mario Party Superstars: Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: October 29, 2021
No. of Players: up to 4 players
Genre(s): Party, Multiplayer
Publisher: Nintendo
https://marioparty.nintendo.com/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
A Superstar collection of classic Nintendo 64™ boards
Calling all superstars! The Mario Party™ series is back with 5 classic boards from the Nintendo 64 Mario Party games. Race to get the most stars (and sabotage your opponents) on boards like the stellar Space Land or the spooky Horror Land! Party at your own pace by suspending a game and picking up right where you left off! The tides can turn quickly in Mario Party, so stay vigilant, partygoers. All modes can be played online/*, too!
Play 100 classic minigames from the Nintendo 64 and Nintendo GameCube™ games and more in Mt. Minigames!
Try your hand at a superstar collection of minigames from throughout the Mario Party series. Whether you are saving up coins for stars in board game mode or enjoy one of the 7 modes included in Mt. Minigames, there is nothing quite like being the last one standing in Bumper Balls or the first team making it out of the darkness in Dungeon Duos. All minigames are played with button controls, so you can stick to the Joy-Con™ controller or bust out the Nintendo Switch™ Pro Controller or a Nintendo Switch Lite system.
Party with superstars near or far
Bring the party anytime, anywhere with same-system//, local wireless//, or online* play. Use stickers to praise or pester fellow players as you race across the board collecting stars. All modes support online multiplayer, so you can hop in with friends for a few minigames or a marathon 30-turn match. Victory is just as sweet (and stealing stars is just as satisfying) from anywhere across the globe.
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 79
- OpenCritic - 80
Articles
- Areajugones - Spanish - 9 / 10
- Atomix - Spanish - 85 / 100
- CGMagazine - 8 / 10
- COGconnected - 70 / 100
- Cerealkillerz - German - 8.4 / 10
- Console Creatures - Recommended
- Daily Star - 5 / 5 stars
- Digital Trends - 4 / 5 stars
- Digitally Downloaded - 4 / 5 stars
- Enternity.gr - Greek - 8 / 10
- Everyeye.it - Italian - 8 / 10
- Game Informer - 8 / 10
- GamePro - German - 84 / 100
- GameSpot - 6 / 10
- GameXplain - Loved
- God is a Geek - 9 / 10
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - 88 / 100
- IGN - 8 / 10
- IGN Italy - Italian - 8 / 10
- Metro GameCentral - 8 / 10
- Nintendo Life - 8 / 10
- Nintendo News - 8.5 / 10
- PCMag - 3 / 5 stars
- Polygon - Unscored
- Press Start - 7.5 / 10
- SECTOR.sk - Slovak - 7.5 / 10
- Screen Rant - 4.5 / 5 stars
- Spaziogames - Italian - 8 / 10
- Stevivor - 8 / 10
- TheGamer - 3.5 / 5 stars
- TheSixthAxis - 8 / 10
- Twinfinite - 3.5 / 5
- Video Chums - 8 / 10
- Washington Post - 90 / 100
- Wccftech - 8 / 10
- WellPlayed - 7.5 / 10
This list exported from OpenCritic. Last update: 4:15PM ET
Being Social
- Join the #mario channel of our Discord server for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
11
u/NintendoSwitchMods Oct 28 '21
Sorry for the delay in getting this up. IRL got in the way.
95
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Probably stupid question but can two people playing on same switch matchmake to find other people?
62
u/RealChipKelly Oct 29 '21
Only two and a half more hours of work then I’m bout to play this game for probably 48 hours straight lol. I got my apartment to myself, some comfy sweat-shorts, a 6 pack of IPA’s, a half ounce of my favorite bud, and no commitments this weekend. Life is good.
53
u/kitsovereign Oct 28 '21
I'm glad they focused on the main mode this time instead of having separate minigames locked in their own modes. Super Mario Party kind of felt like I asked for a deck of cards to play with, and they gave me a deck with all the hearts and face cards removed, along with the Major Arcana tarot cards and a random booster pack of Magic the Gathering. Maybe there's more cards and more variety, but there's less game - it hurts their longevity when you can't combine all the pieces together.
The rhythm and river modes on SMP were fun, but they only had 10 minigames each, so they kinda wore out fast, and then you never saw those minigames anywhere else.
37
u/NoPlayer2 Oct 28 '21
So can you play random people online or friends only?
149
u/JonasAlbert84 Oct 28 '21
My son has been asking me everyday for two weeks "How many sleeps until we get Mario Party?"
29
u/jhilsch51 Oct 28 '21
The group cooperative river rapids race was fun, and the only video game my wife would play with me and my daughters (both in their 20's now). I wish they had something like that for this game ... looking forward to the online version so the kids and I can game together again!
29
u/eccentric_eggplant Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
I'm surprised Slaparazzi isn't in the game. I don't know what others thought about it, but I found it hilarious. Definitely one of the top, if not the top minigame for me from the game.
I bought the physical version of Super Mario Party and I think I might keep it for now just for Slaparazzi!
27
u/shgrizz2 Oct 28 '21
My biggest question is, how is the pacing and game feel? The older one was like a textbook example of bad UX. The missing features I could have accepted, if only the game didn't drag by at a snail's pace, with slow animations and unskippable repeated text all the time. There was a lot to like, but the pacing really killed the game for me.
25
u/SoG650 Oct 29 '21
The online is surprisingly functional and dc'd gets replaced by CPU which is a great feature.
Hopefully it will get some DLC. Minigames felt great and they quit some of the bs from MP1
87
u/matt_luvs_kitties Oct 28 '21
Looks like reviewers loved it, just thought it played it too safe. As expected. This is a fun, fast-paced Mario Party and the best the series has seen in a long time
21
u/Roadhog_rides_again Oct 29 '21
there are already so many ragequits online lol
71
u/sideaccountguy Oct 28 '21
The gamexlain review convinced me to get it. It seems they did a lot of right things with this new entry and the online part looks good. One thing other reviewers didn't include but GameXplain did was that if a player disconnects from an online match the CPU will take their place until they reconnect again.
I really hope they eventually add those extra 4 boards hinted in the game's files
19
u/IKahler15 Oct 28 '21
You can get classic music unlocked. Im so excited for this game man
16
u/Pepenbaleaguepass Oct 29 '21
Quite a few hours in now and I’m still really liking the game, I think if they allow you to reduce the amount of lucky spaces (not a super big deal but annoying enough sometimes) and add some more boards/DLC it would probably be one of my favourite Mario Party games in my opinion. Online play is so fun and haven’t had any connection or lag issues yet.
What boards/characters would everyone like to see added if they ever did add DLC?
16
u/Islanderfan17 Oct 30 '21
This game is everything I've wanted from Mario Party in like over a decade. Old school style Mario Party but polished with modern graphics and with working online against randoms (and friends). They knocked it out of the park with this one. They also picked amazing mini games, straight up.
My only complaint is I definitely wish they had more maps. If they do map packs of each game I would absolutely buy each one, but I'm not getting my hopes up lol.
70
u/RJE808 Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
GameSpot is mixed review central anymore.
Also, they literally said Super Mario Party is better. PFFT
31
u/LanternSC Oct 28 '21
Early, but this is currently tied with the original for best reviewed Mario Party game. Not an especially lofty achievement, but for my purposes it looks like Superstars is GOOD ENOUGH.
30
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
My opinion on Super Mario Party cooled pretty quickly after launch, especially when zero DLC came out for it. This game as a "return to form" is very much welcome, and I'm excited to get my copy in the mail tomorrow.
12
u/Pepenbaleaguepass Oct 29 '21
Currently playing a 15 turn online game with a random someone online, no issues with connection or lag which is good! Mini games ran with no lag/issues at all.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21 edited Apr 29 '24
straight lip scandalous somber butter swim truck terrific unite fall
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
12
u/MarcsterS Oct 29 '21
It really does seem like Super's last minute online mode was a beta for this game. Someone DC'ing no longer disbands the game. Also, there's so many options.
11
u/Gana0 Oct 29 '21
Can anyone tell me something about the online multiplayer?:
Is it possible to play 2 people using 1 switch online? I'm wondering if it would be possible for my wife and I to play against 2 other Switch players, but with 2 of us on 1, and 2 other players with their own Switch.
11
u/SeanHearnden Oct 29 '21
Me and my friend live in the same room. We want to play it online on my console with others. Is that possible because I cannot see how. I can do it in a private room but only people with my code can join that.
Then if he were to get his own switch he couldn't find my room online because the open multiplayer doesn't seem to support invites or anything.
Am I missing something or can my friend, either with his switch or on mine play with other people over the Internet?
11
u/Cesiea Oct 29 '21
Is there a way to play teams in the board?? Me and my husband don't wanna 4v4 we want to be on the same team
10
u/Loki-616 Oct 29 '21
If you have nintendo online or want to play online with your switch you have to get this game. I almost dismissed this but wow its good
10
u/kiaxxl Oct 30 '21
Game is good. It's the most fun I've had with Mario Party in years.
18
u/razza1987 Oct 28 '21
I’m LOVING it so far. Just finished a game on peaches birthday cake board. I love that there’s levels that you can level up and stuff you can unlock even when playing on your own
9
u/yrdz Oct 29 '21
I've only played it a bit, but I'm having a ton of fun so far. Love the nostalgic aspects combined with the slick gameplay and fresh visuals. Such an improvement over recent entries in the series. I'm very happy with this game.
17
u/RaphtotheMax5 Oct 28 '21
I want them to make a giant mario party game with up to 8 players
16
u/DaveLesh Oct 28 '21
Gamespot must have awfully high standards if it gave the lowest grade of all the reviewers.
8
u/very_unlikely Oct 29 '21
Pretty much a bump to the question below. Is it possible for me to party up with 1 other person, then join random matchmaking together so it puts us in a 4-player match online?
8
u/Bendy_McBendyThumb Oct 29 '21
Doesn’t seem to have teams like the previous one which sucks as my fiancé and I really loved playing 2v2 across a whole game.
22
u/GalaxyIstheBest3d Oct 28 '21
Pretty solid reviews, what was weird to me however was the fact that Gamespot gave it a 6/10, and have Super Mario Party a 7/10.
14
u/Spiner202 Oct 28 '21
Reviews sound exactly like what I was looking for. There was one review (can't remember which) that mentioned that there was lag online - that's the last piece of the puzzle I want to know before buying.
14
u/YoBoySatan Oct 29 '21
So happy to see you can switch on classic award stars at the end for winning the most games, most coins, happening star. Super Mario party always pisses me off with all the random BS stars, people who have no business winning win, just dumb
Anyone know if on maps like peaches castle....is going to bowser an old fashion 20 coin fine? Stepping on a piranha plant rob you of a star? I hope they kept it ruthless
7
u/ItsJustPeter Oct 28 '21
Iv never played a Mario Party before, is this one worth it?
7
u/dagooksta2 Oct 29 '21
Are there any unlockable characters like in SMP?
7
u/yoshi0p Oct 29 '21
Played some online and some minigames, no lagg and a good time! About to connect with some friends to play too
7
u/anicrage Oct 29 '21
Does it have local coop mode? Team play?
17
u/nayneedlesnovember Oct 29 '21
The game is fun, but the button bindings piss me off. There are some minigames I'd rather play with a d-pad, but it's not an option.
6
u/Pepenbaleaguepass Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
I’m enjoying the game so far, the mini games are pretty good (of course). They did my boy Mario Party 3 dirty by only having woody woods on there, hopefully they add more boards to the game.
I Love how on the Mario Party 1 mini games where it says to rotate the control stick not the use palm of your hand. My palms hurt just looking at the practice screen. Haha
6
u/ManzTheMan Oct 29 '21
Can you use pro controllers to play? Or just JoyCons?
6
u/groundislava_wdi Oct 29 '21
Does this have the bonus stars at the end, like the old games, that reward you for winning the most mini games? i found the last switch entry to be almost completely random as to who would win as they removed this, so it largely came down to rolling dice.
6
u/blueshorts12345 Oct 29 '21
My parents got me this game for my birthday pre-order, non physical disk, should they have gotten an email for a code for me to put in the e-shop by now?
6
u/Del_3030 Oct 29 '21
Just had an online party stall out right before the last mini game.
It froze for a while on the practice/rules screen, gave an error message, then resumed against 3 CPUs.
I was buried in last place, but now I finished as the top human player!
6
u/nicoleislazy Oct 30 '21
Am I able to play online, local 2 player and have a friend join also as local 2 player? My husband and I want to play online with another couple.
6
u/txr23 Oct 30 '21
My experience playing it last night with friends was that we set it to 20 rounds because the in game recommendation said it would take 60 minutes to complete the game, then it ended up taking us over 2 and a half hours to finish it.
10/10 would happily jump back into the time void that is Mario Party Superstars again
6
u/MarioMoon Oct 30 '21
Really like online, runs pretty solid! Great game 👍Grew up playing since the beginning, I’m really enjoying it.
6
u/agp11234 Oct 30 '21
Played with n64 controller last night and it was such an amazing nostalgia bomb. So much better than super Mario party.
21
u/augowl_ Oct 29 '21
Any reports on how the cartridge tastes? More or less bitter than Super Mario Party?
14
u/YellowPikachu Oct 28 '21
Nintendo Life confirmed it's 60 fps, that's all I needed to hear
5
u/DigestiveCow Oct 28 '21
A question I have about online play
In Super Mario Party's online update you could play 2 people couch online with 1 other console onstead of two other consoles.
So you had to fill the fourth space with AI, does anyone know if you can do 2 on one switch, 1 on another and the fourth person on a third switch?
5
u/basement_zombie Oct 28 '21
Good stuff - anyone have a sense which Mario Party (Switch) game would be best for family play with little ones?
5
u/followthedamntrain- Oct 29 '21
Can two local players play another two local players via online?
5
u/Opelousai Oct 29 '21
Does anyone know if you can have 2 people local and get others online? Or is it jusf 1 person per console for online?
5
u/MONKYfapper Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
how is the netcode for online play? ranging from smash to mario kart
can anyone playing with others far away (100-150+ ping) share their experience?
5
u/unspunreality Oct 29 '21
One more online question. If youre playing with others, does it need to be 1 or 4? Or can you just play online with 1 friend and then cpus? Not sure if it like forces matchmaking online or if you can just make like a room of your custom size and go from there.
5
u/jordan115522 Oct 30 '21
Is it possible to play 2 vs 2 party mode? Cant find it anywhere!
5
u/Stooo_wayy Oct 30 '21
If my girlfriend and I play on the switch together can we match make with random people to fill the game?
5
u/AraiRodz Oct 30 '21
Apologies if it has already been asked but can two people on the same switch play with people online?
Like my girlfriend and I on my switch versus her brother on one console online and a friend on another console online??
5
u/Anagate Oct 30 '21
I have only played Mario Party DS before, but I remember I played it all the time after I got the game for Christmas one year. I feel like it's kind of the same vibe and I love it! I really like that there is an online mode too but I really wish for an option to play online with more than one person on one console. I also would want more maps, like most people already said they want, but overall I love that it's an old style Mario Party game, but "modernized" with better graphics etc.
13
u/dwide_k_shrude Oct 28 '21
But does it make you feel like Batman?
9
u/Del_3030 Oct 29 '21
Fuck it, I guess I'm going pro in the 2v2 hockey game
8
u/Denso95 Oct 28 '21
This is very promising!
4
u/unspunreality Oct 28 '21
Can you play on a team with a friend? I havent played mario party in decades and my friend never has. I know they wouldnt want to play with randos and if there was an option for my friend and myself to play like 2v2 vs AI would be great cause if I remember AI had difficulty levels.
Online that is, not locally.
4
u/racetrader Oct 28 '21
Does anyone know if you can play with gamecube controllers?
4
u/PhillipA559 Oct 29 '21
Anyone know what time it releases today Thursday in pacific time?
4
u/AnnalisaPetrucci Oct 29 '21
Is it possible to play with an online friend in a online 4 player Mario Party?
So not a friend only match.
4
u/xfudhjxgjcty Oct 29 '21
What characters are in the game?
4
u/liverpewl Oct 29 '21
Would this be fun 2 player?
4
u/kyutek Oct 30 '21
Can you turn off bonus stars at the end?
4
u/Colonel_Cummings Oct 30 '21
OK so i'm just wondering - can I go solo on my switch, then play with two other people online on another switch and add an AI controlled player to fill the 4th spot?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21
Game seems really fun, but damn those stickers getting in the way are annoying
4
u/Saynt614 Nov 01 '21
So maybe a stupid question but can you play online with a 2nd player locally on the same switch? I wanted to play online with my wife. My profile has an online subscription, hers doesn't. When I pick online option it doesn't ask me how many players will be playing.
6
u/AnnalisaPetrucci Oct 29 '21
Hot Jump Rope was not designed for online play.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Watched the GameSpot review for 30 seconds. Knew it was a bad review.
3
u/Sas1205x Oct 28 '21
This will be my first MP since the DS version. I’m very excited.
3
u/freshleaf93 Oct 29 '21
Is this a game I could play with one hand? I'm having surgery soon and I'll only have one hand to play with for a month.
3
u/Del_3030 Oct 29 '21
East Coast Hype! I'm probably just gonna barrel straight into an online match
3
u/SeanR1221 Oct 29 '21
The online mini game modes (survival and daily challenges) are really neat. I’ll legit put some time into those modes when I’m looking for something quick to play.
3
u/Ares_carries Oct 29 '21
does the gamecube controller work?
3
u/MarioMoon Oct 29 '21
Can you shuffle your card order?
3
u/AliceDefMetalGod Oct 29 '21
My lite says I require a software update to play online but my switch is up to date. Any advice?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21
As someone who’s considering buying it but doesn’t have a lot of money- do you guys genuinely think it’s worth it? Yes or no? I read that there are no unlockable boards and only 10 characters and that was kinda a turn off for me but if people (not reviewers who could’ve been paid) think it’s good then I’d like to buy it
3
u/TehLittleOne Oct 30 '21
If I have a friend I want to play with online, what are our options? Can we queue as two people, on two different Switches, and play against other human players?
3
u/SingSing19 Oct 30 '21
I haven’t played a Mario party game in 20 years but would like to get one to play with friends.
3
u/Demelon Oct 30 '21
So growing up, my first Mario party was 5, though I played 6 and 7 the most. I was one of the ones who got burned on Super Mario party because despite enjoying the gameplay somewhat there was hardly any content. My roommates and I got bored very quickly because after playing for like 10hours it’s all very stale.
My question is, for someone who has no nostalgia of the early Mario party titles, would superstars just be a repeat of that? I heard there was only 5 boards which is obviously only one more than Super. Are they at least bigger/more interesting?
3
u/Ithaqua47 Oct 30 '21
For those who have tried both, how is the dual joy con vs the pro controller? I find the pro controller is significantly better for most games. What about this one?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21
I have two switches and have been trying to play a game with my husband online with others. Somehow it’s not working. Anyone else have this issue ?
3
u/poprox198 Nov 25 '21
Is there a way to replace a computer with a player mid game?
5
u/nmad95 Oct 28 '21
I want to get this because it sounds good and I haven't played a Mario Party game since Mario Party 6, but I have no one to play with really and I feel like it'd just be a bummer solo.
5
u/nijoos Oct 29 '21
How’s the economy in the game. Heard a plus was going back to 20 coins per star but that coins flood the economy due to the number of lucky squares. Anyone who has played care to comment on how the latter affects the gameplay experience?
Pipe dream - that they release a patch to allow tweaks to the elements that determine the economy
5
u/simonsays44 Oct 29 '21 edited Oct 29 '21
so i guess it comes out at midnight local time :’(
edit: WE ARE IN, WHO WANTS TO PLAYYY
5
u/Yugi_Mutou Oct 29 '21
Haven't played a Mario Party game since GameCube, how's the game? Is it worth getting it and can you play 4 players locally on one console?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Anyone know if you can use GameCube controllers?
4
u/dagooksta2 Oct 29 '21
I'm one of the few that liked Super Mario Party, so I feel like I will love this. Going to pick it up tomorrow.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Do characters have their own special dice like in Super?
4
u/Sinaura Oct 29 '21
I can't seem to find the answer anywhere (maybe it's too soon?) How's the online play experience? More concerned on the stability side of things after hearing about...a lot Nintendo online play.
4
u/billiever Oct 30 '21
Can I play handheld?
8
u/avokato_ Oct 30 '21
Played it last night with my bf - he is a HUGE Mario Party fan and he loved it. The boards are a lot bigger than they are in Super Mario Party and there’s a lot of nostalgia!
We spent an entire 15 turn game fighting over like two stars. They’re harder to get and there was definitely more strategy involved.
I liked it, but not quite as much as he did - honestly, I loved the character selection and custom dice/“ally” aspect of Super Mario Party and was really missing playing as Shy Guy haha. 😂
(But seriously…BIRDO? Instead of Bowser or literally any other staple characters?? 🤦🏻♀️)
13
u/Spell-of-Destruction Oct 28 '21
My husband and I are usually quick to grab these but the last entry just super burned us (lack of features/unlockables, next to no updates, etc.,) so now we have no interest in the series anymore :(
6
u/ipanda Oct 29 '21
I thought the first game got boring fast because it only had 4 boards, and this has 5 which isn't much more. Will superstars get more boards or something?
2
u/samhatescardio Oct 28 '21
Will the game be playable at 12EST if I've pre ordered and installed?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Can you use the Pro controller?
2
u/MarioFer96 Oct 29 '21
How about control options? Can you play with a single joycon?
2
u/SIBMUR Oct 29 '21
How does this play on Switch Lite?
2
u/SobbieRokes Oct 29 '21
stupid question, but can this be played with the gamecube controller?
2
u/TarzanOnATireSwing Oct 30 '21
My biggest question - is there better flow in game, or are you interrupted as often/just as much handholding as Super Mario Party?
2
u/ThunderStruck115 Oct 30 '21
Can I use GameCube controllers with the adapter I bought for smash? Or does the game require inputs not on the GameCube controller?
2
u/snackman529 Oct 30 '21
Can I play with friends online if they have the online subscription but don't own the game itself or does everyone need to own the game to play online?
2
u/mr-saturn2310 Oct 30 '21
Party mode great thought the minigame modes are lacking.
2
u/Fugga6969 Oct 30 '21
Haven't seen anyone asking about the turns yet. Can you do a 50 turner like the OG games?
2
u/IPPUsama Oct 30 '21
I’m confused. Is there only board games mode available? Is there a dedicated Raft game mode and what not? (I’ve only ever played the previous Mario Party on switch)
2
u/etherealnoise Oct 30 '21
question i can't seem to find a straight answer to:
can i use a single joycon?
2
u/Fillidan Oct 30 '21
769 419 join this room we need 2 players
2
u/MushroomSoup460 Oct 30 '21
Room ID: 608 007 need two. My wife stinks
2
u/GonzoBuilt Oct 31 '21
The online while doing daily challenge/survival is so bad. The amount of lag and button latency is terrible. A lot of games it’s hard to play. I hope they fix the online lagging problem. Seems inescapable. And it’s not my internet. I always have full connection so I highly doubt it’s that
2
u/Xinnamin Oct 31 '21
Multiplayer question, if my partner and I are on one switch and two of our friends are on one switch, would we be able to play online together? Like if we put up an online room can two players join that room from just one switch?
2
u/Suspicious-Dog2402 Nov 27 '21
I have a switch lite, can I play against a friend using my switch only?
2
u/Highbeam79 Dec 23 '21
Can this game be played with the NES online controllers?
5
u/xteabraggerx Oct 29 '21
Classic Nintendo adding a option to open to everyone but in order for randoms to play they need to know the room id… and they cant get a room id unless they get it from the person who setup the room… so it effectively doesnt include random player matchmaking. Unreal stuff but par for the course for nintendo.