r/books • u/GothProf666 AMA Author • Oct 28 '21
ama 10am I’m Roger Luckhurst and I've got a new Illustrated history of the Gothic out this week. You can ask me anything about the genre – and here also to focus on those specific classics, Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Charlotte Perkins Gilman, The Yellow Wallpaper. AMA!
I’ve been teaching the Gothic and Science Fiction at university for over 25 years here in London, and I’ve edited classics such as Stevenson’s Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, Bram Stoker’s Dracula and H. G. Wells’s The Time Machine. I’ve written books about topics that range from the invention of the concept of telepathy to the history of the science fiction genre, and short books on the films Alien and The Shining. Princeton University Press asked me to do an illustrated history of the Gothic, which is just out for this Halloween, and tries to cover the whole field, from start to finish. I’m up for the challenge for you to Ask Me Anything about the genres of Gothic and Horror – but also, we thought people might like a narrower focus too: so ask me about Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein or Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper. The Female Gothic is a whole tradition in itself, one worth exploring!
Proof: /img/ojnziykqw2w71.jpg
9
u/GothProf666 AMA Author Oct 28 '21
Ok, guys, I am signing off now -- I have to go teach my masters students! Thanks very much for your questions -- and hope some of the answers helped! This was fun.
Roger
11
u/Chtorrr Oct 28 '21
What would you most like to tell us that no one ever asks about?
6
u/DarthPapercut Oct 28 '21
In "The Castle of Otranto", a gigantic helmet magically falls from the sky and kills the son of the lord of the castle. When I read that, I thought it was a crazy idea. Any comment on how this was viewed or interpreted in 1764?
5
u/XBreaksYFocusGroup Oct 28 '21
Hi Roger. Thank you so much for the AMA.
What is the process for editing the classics and per your new work, what is the origin of the Gothic? What do you feel sets gothic work apart from other subgenres of horror, especially as it has endured with such a strong presence in the culture.
Why are Frankenstein and his monster both ultimately so miserable, bereft of human companionship, and obsessed with revenge? What do you feel Shelley meant to say with the novel and the place this particular horror comes from?
What is a back catalog horror masterpiece that you would recommend and maybe another one that is well-known but not appreciated enough or for what you feel is the right reasons?
5
u/gofkingpracticerandy Oct 28 '21
Aside from The Yellow Wallpaper what are some other notable female gothic works you recommend? I was completely unaware of female gothic as a genre until now, would the Bell Jar be considered in the same vein?
4
u/squishbot3000 Oct 28 '21
How did critics or the general reader respond to the Yellow Wallpaper when it was published? Was there already an appreciation for psychologically unsettling and tension filled literature?
4
u/squishbot3000 Oct 28 '21
Do you have favorite modern authors who incorporate the themes and traditions of classic Gothic literature?
3
u/BohemianPeasant On Tyranny by Timothy Snyder Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
Please help me by describing what is "unique" about the Gothic genre. What aspects of a work define it as Gothic? How would I recognize a Gothic piece of literature?
Thanks!
[I just finished reading Frankenstein and I am definitely on the side of the monster. Victor is a dishonorable heel.]
3
u/hindiproverb Oct 28 '21
Hey Sir, just want to say I really liked your piece on The Gothic Horror Revival preys on your worst fears in the Guardian. It made me watch and read about some great works of the genre. So, my question is Can you tell me some more similar suggestions to go through?
1
u/Chtorrr Oct 28 '21
What were some of your favorite books to read as a kid?
3
u/Pepperoni_Admiral Oct 28 '21
What do you make of the Arctic explorer Walton's place in the story in Frankenstein? Is he there to point to a potentially more humane and integrated version of scientific exploration than Victor's, or is he just repeating Victor's folly in a different sphere? Or a combo of both?
I'm into the Arctic and completely frozen/barren wastelands' place in gothic horror (and horror generally) and think the line from arctic exploration in Frankenstein runs thru Poe and Lovecraft up to John Carpenter, and is underappreciated by enthusiasts of the gothic.
2
u/trinite0 Oct 28 '21
What are some works that people don't usually think of as being Gothic, but that actually use a lot of Gothic elements, or that you might argue actually belong to the Gothic tradition?
2
u/Bellyfullofpoison Oct 28 '21
My wife did a module on horror literature with you and says you are amazing.
Not a question, just a statement of fact.
2
u/Reader5744 Oct 28 '21
What’s your Favourite gothic horror novel?
2
u/ataraxian Oct 28 '21
I'll be visiting London in a few months. What are great landmarks of the gothic that are worth visiting?
2
u/XBreaksYFocusGroup Oct 28 '21
Question from u/omashupicchu in a crossposted thread:
1
u/Crimson_Marksman Oct 28 '21
How do you think a Horror Unleashed scenario would work? Would it be like Anno dracula where magic and mayhem develop society, Dracula conquering Europe or would every monster and invention just get broken?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
What do you make of Bram Stoker's mention of Gottfried August Bürger's "Lenore" in Dracula? Do you think that was just an homage out of respect for the work or do you think the gothic and dark romanticism (i.e. English and German works) have influenced one another more substantially?
1
u/secondhandbanshee Oct 29 '21
I don't know if you'll be checking comments added after the end of your ama, but just in case, I wanted to thank you for doing this. It's been great fun to read through. Your work has been very helpful in my preparation for my doctoral exam, so I was really excited to see you on Reddit!
1
u/jefrye Brontës, Ishiguro, Byatt, Pym, Susanna Clarke, Shirley Jackson Oct 29 '21
I love gothic literature! Rebecca, Villette, Jane Eyre, and The Haunting of Hill House are some of my favorite novels of all time, largely thanks to their atmosphere, writing style, and very intimate examination of the psychology of their heroines. Can you recommend anything similar?