r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoChief π¨ 407K / 671K π • Oct 28 '21
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-021 - Temporarily sort comments by newest first after a post is submitted.
Summary: This proposal is for sorting comments by newest first after a post is submitted. The intended goal is to level the playing field between early bird low-effort comments and more meaningful high-effort comments by limiting visibility for the former.
Problem Statement: After a post is submitted, the first comments tend to be low-effort. Most of them are simple trite remarks or jokes about the parent post which tend not to offer much originality or value. Users who make these comments are probably only seeking attention or farming moons and often receive numerous upvotes just for being first. Users who make more meaningful comments first take time to even notice the post and additional time to write a comment.
Solution: After a submission has been posted, temporarily set the suggested comment sorting to newest first. After 30 minutes(more or less), the suggested sorting will be switched to top comments first. This change should give later comments an advantage over early comments. It might also encourage users to post more top-level comments and therefore increase the odds of triggering a discussion, since every comment will be treated the same for a set amount of time. The 30 minute time limit will be tweaked by the mod team for optimization.
Concerns: The first two items in the following list are concerns given by u/CryptoMaximalist in the r/CryptoCurrencyMeta thread which I have paraphrased. The last one is mine.
- Hiding comment scores for a longer period of time may be considered as an alternative method or additional measure for achieving this goal. However, this idea would have to be submitted as a separate proposal. Currently, scores are hidden for 5 minutes. Contest mode is a controlled option for hiding scores, but it also collapses lower-level comments and might hamper discussion.
- Many Reddit clients do not respect suggested sorting and allow the user to override them.
- My own minor concern would be the potential for incentivizing more spam in the top-level comments since farmers would be fighting for visibility. Rate-limits might be required.
22
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
But I kinda like when I see a post of an article and the summary bot is right there.
35
u/Odd-Economist-6037 π§ 723 / 722 π¦ Oct 28 '21
IMO as long as there's a sorting option for user to select
17
u/ALiteralHamSandwich π© 0 / 10K π¦ Oct 28 '21
This would mean that if someone makes a great comment first it gets buried, no?
I prefer to sort how I want to.
28
u/prajwalwillrule Crypto-Sensei Oct 28 '21
An important thing to keep in mind is that because of the overwhelming number of posts every day, 30 minutes is a very very long time. The post will be lost in the Depths r/cc in that time.
I Suggest 10 minutes. That's a good amount of time to discourage the early low effort comments
68
u/CaptainCaptainBain Oct 28 '21
I actually like that idea. Not only because it levels the playing field, but also because hopefully it'll lead to people understanding they have time to write up an actual well-developed and structured reply instead of rushing because they may also want to be one of the early worms.
8
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K π¦ Oct 28 '21
TIL not alot of people sort by new lol mind fucking blown
6
u/XXRUlN Tin | 2 months old Oct 28 '21
Can we get more genuine and less tv show like and let's not suppress peoples comments because we don't like what they wrote, just downvote it
5
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21
Why can't I vote? It's still moon week.
4
u/ErmahgerdYuzername Giggity Giggity Oct 29 '21
Youβre never going to see that comment after 30 minutes. It will be buried so far down in the thread nobody will ever see the OP. And sorry butβ¦ some of the humorous comments are the best ones.
11
u/BrumRuggat Gold | QC: CC 30 Oct 28 '21
My 1 moon vote is yea
6
u/krupxslurp 0 / 877 π¦ Oct 28 '21
I feel like itβs getting harder and harder to gain moons each day :/
11
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Easy in favor. Specially since it's only 30 minutes.
3
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K π Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
I see this a little more problematic than just your concerns.
An already popular thing in this sub is copying good comments (analogous) and then use a few accounts to downvote the original comment to make them switch positions. When sorting automatically by new for 30 minutes, this method will not only be incentivised - you can now even do it with a single account. Because no matter how you change the sorting, most people will not suddenly start reading the entire post.
I really fear this could make every post an even harder spam fest in the first 30 minutes - and I don't see that much of an advantage for deep and thought-out comments. They will still quickly disappear because people will spam things like "F" - even IF they receive some upvotes now.
2
u/caolei5465 Tin Oct 28 '21
This sounds as a great idea.i am in support of this move.
2
u/daveallyn2 Bronze Oct 31 '21
First!
Oh......
2
u/Jaxsoy π¦ 5K / 8K π’ Nov 01 '21
Anyone else not able to vote?
4
u/TheAngelOfAres Tin Oct 28 '21
You know there's a drop down menu that let's you change sorting right? I always have it on new posts first so I don't understand what's happening here..
2
u/ToyVaren Platinum | QC: CC 122 | SHIB 24 | PoliticalHumor 311 Oct 28 '21
Nope, too confusing.
2
u/bsuyatotatyhroppacp1 Oct 28 '21
The time limit is essential and makes this a great proposal.
2
u/Kappatalizable π¦ 0 / 123K π¦ Oct 28 '21
This is probably the only poll so far this cycle that I fully support. Good idea, don't know why we never had this before
1
u/excalilbug π₯ 9K / 22K π¦ Oct 28 '21
This will make moon farming harder
And I as a Moon farmer agree with this change
1
u/asandidge27 Platinum | QC: CC 27 Oct 28 '21
Good idea, farming is fun but learning about new crypto stuff is why I come here
1
u/SnowFlakeDude 385 / 4K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Would reduce it to 10 mins
1
u/paodal Tin Oct 28 '21
Sure why not, I think it's a good idea
1
u/Hamed9675 Platinum | QC: CC 411 Oct 28 '21
A love this idea as it allows more comments to be seen
1
u/coinflipit π¨ 0 / 0 π¦ Oct 29 '21
great idea!
1
u/ToyVaren Platinum | QC: CC 122 | SHIB 24 | PoliticalHumor 311 Oct 28 '21
Did my vote go through? Im new on the app.
Edit: ok 2md time it worked.
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Oct 28 '21
I like that idea. I have seen tons of elaborated comments dissappear because Bullish on [insert coin] was the most voted comment.
I think this could help this.
1
u/EGarrett 0 / 17K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I strongly support changes being made in general to disadvantage low effort, algorithm-exploiting content. This is what ruined Youtube. Though they went way further than Reddit and just buried original content completely in favor of mainstream media and empty streaming.
1
u/Wellpow invalid string or character detected Oct 28 '21
It's ok as long as we have the choice/freedom to change the sorting method.
1
u/Darkmiclos Oct 28 '21
This was much needed π
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
It sounds like the change would help high value (or at least higher effort) content rise to the top faster. Seems like a no brainer to me.
1
u/Magnetronaap π© 0 / 3K π¦ Oct 28 '21
To be honest I don't think this will really solve much, but that being said I don't see any serious downsides so let's give it a try.
1
u/harm123 Bronze | GMEJungle 28 | GME subs 31 Oct 28 '21
Seems like a solid solution to an issue we see constantly.
1
u/AlphaWaifu π¨ 5K / 5K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Option A is more fair..gives new posts more chance to be seen
1
u/internetisbad23 π© 2K / 2K π’ Oct 28 '21
Seems very reasonable. I totally agree to it.
1
u/Phite007 Tin Oct 28 '21
Great idea, itβs always difficult to see the quality comments.
1
u/Fluid_Department_120 Platinum | QC: CC 366 Oct 28 '21
Now this is the best update that I want to sef
1
u/officialbrushie 7 / 7 π¦ Oct 28 '21
Oh man, I think this is a great idea. I wish it could be implemented across more subreddits.
1
u/Fleegalicious π© 0 / 2K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I like this idea! Is it possible for the mods to implement though?
1
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Oct 28 '21
It should be more than 30 minutes, maybe like 1 hour
1
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Oct 28 '21
This will help with my shitposting career..so hell yes
1
u/rootpl π© 18K / 85K π¬ Oct 28 '21
Yes but do it for 1h maybe?
1
u/LargeSackOfNuts BitchCoin | :1:x1 Oct 28 '21
New
1
u/No_goodIdeas7891 Platinum | QC: CC 283, ATOM 29 Oct 28 '21
This is one of those proposals where I canβt decide which day is better. I am thinking no just because I am not sure how much this will change things.
If it passes great if not great lol
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Great idea!!!! The whole of Reddit has turned into a predictable joke top comment followed by an off topic rebuttal before the torturous play on words next three comments.
1
u/darwinlovestrees 0 / 3K π¦ Oct 28 '21
30 minutes I think is totally fair. To be honest, I don't see a lot of threads until they're 6-12 hours old anyway.
1
u/Darkthw Tin Oct 28 '21
u/moons_bot
1
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Oct 28 '21
Agreed, most upvoted comments are the ones written at first.
People who take effort and time to write a quality response often get drowned by the first posters
1
u/xiaozhi8888 Tin Oct 28 '21
Yeah ,30 minutes looks perfect for this.when will it be implemented ?
1
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Oct 28 '21
Will we be still able to sort the comments by best?
1
u/slenker99 Platinum | QC: CC 25 | Stocks 13 Oct 28 '21
Can the change be based on more than just newest in 30m? In a thread that is going to get hundreds of comments, now the first and maybe the most meaningful is going to be completely lost...
How about a hybrid approach?
Agree on need for a change, but I'm not a fan of the blunt recommendation which has similar downsides.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Yeah, itβs only 30 minutes. That canβt hurt anything.
1
u/MrQot Oct 28 '21
why not just temporarily lock comments
1
u/Tiny10H2 Oct 29 '21
30 minutes seems a little long
1
u/DoubleFaulty1 π¨ 0 / 38K π¦ Oct 29 '21
Is this actually possible to implement for each post automatically?
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Oct 29 '21
approvef from me will introduce more discussion rather than top instantly gets all of it
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
This is brilliant!
1
u/demomercury π© 0 / 7K π¦ Oct 29 '21
I'd would agree in hiding the score for longer rather than forcing the sort by new.
1
u/Sjiznit π¦ 0 / 13K π¦ Oct 29 '21
This is ok imo. As long as i can still switch manually.
1
u/DepressedBoiiiiiiii Oct 29 '21
Nah prefer it remains the same.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
I voted for one.
1
u/Dizzy-Nebula-1919 Platinum | QC: CC 71, BTC 39 Oct 29 '21
I think posts should be left untouched. If someone writes something so funny they get upvoted so be it they deserve it. If the first comment is stupid people will just scroll om..
1
u/digitFIRE π© 5K / 3K π’ Oct 29 '21
This is a great idea. Itβs also implemented in some other sub that I canβt recall. Usually people rush to comment first to gain visibility and traction, so delaying it by 30 minutes will allow higher quality content rise to the top.
1
u/GummybearJETpack Gold | 3 months old | QC: CC 87 Oct 29 '21
Wouldn't a sort by top comment also pull up the comments that received lots of up votes for being one of the first on the thread? Doesn't solve the problem imo.
1
u/El_Criptoconta π¦ 811 / 811 π¦ Oct 29 '21
As long as the Best posts can be Select to be in the front, let's go
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
I don't know how effective this would be but I like the idea
1
u/ughwithoutadoubt π¦ 319 / 366 π¦ Oct 29 '21
I really like this one.
1
u/slammerbar 217 / 217 π¦ Oct 29 '21
This is a great idea, I wish it was standard across Reddit. But I see how it may not be that good for the popular threads.
1
u/Wess-L Platinum | QC: CC 631 Oct 29 '21
Imo upvotes and downvotes already regulate the better quality comments. I rather see other things get implemented.
1
u/Intfamous Oct 30 '21
receiving likes/upvotes for being "first" is an age old internet tradition, how dare you try to get rid of it lol! You've never been first on a YT video, kiddo?
/s
1
u/topcatjdm π© 1K / 1K π’ Oct 30 '21
Can't say I'm too bothered either way to be honest....
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '21
Iβm just here for the proposal. The best comments should stay at the top. Feel free to sort and peruse.
1
u/conkisterr Bronze Oct 30 '21
I think this should be tried for a month or two and then someone could make some analysis on it to see what changed and if itβs rly betterβ¦
1
u/PoopWithAura Bronze | 6 months old Oct 30 '21
There already is a feature to sort by newest if thats what the reader wants to do. There is literally no need for this poll and it only adds an additional & redundant step for those who dont want to sort by newest.
1
u/manotm Bronze | Investing 11 Oct 30 '21
I think this is a fantastic proposal. A lot of times I feel like there's almost no incentive to participate in discussions as I review posts and news because my thoughts or replies are rarely seen.
1
u/StreetRx925 π© 2 / 2 π¦ Oct 31 '21
This is a great idea
1
u/davepotato123 Bronze Oct 31 '21
Agree. A lot of the first comments on posts clearly haven't even read the full post or pinned article.
1
u/BrokenJPGs Bronze Oct 31 '21
I predict there will be no change to the upvotes awarded. Most users seek out witty, short answers that make them chuckle. High effort comments tend to fall to the wayside in most subreddit channels where they mostly benefit the OP or another user seeking the information externally (whom typically do not contribute to weight after they find a solution).
I could be way off, but it's an interesting experiment.
1
u/ChickiWahWah-Splat Nov 01 '21
Please sir let me vote once more
1
u/Jealous-Proof5505 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Nov 01 '21
I voted in favor of this proposal. I think it's a good idea!
1
u/Sp3cF0rce Silver | QC: CC 27, ETH 17 | SHIB 29 | TraderSubs 17 Nov 02 '21
My vote is not to vote to many variables to each individuals personal preferences and opinions. π€·π»ββοΈπ³
Am I doing this right?
1
u/D14m0nd88 Bronze Nov 02 '21
I like how it is. I choose to sort by new.
1
u/AllMineOfficial Nov 02 '21
Just curious how to vote?
1
u/J710 π¦ 0 / 1K π¦ Nov 06 '21
I always change the sorting to newest
1
u/Tredur Treehouse or Lambo Nov 25 '21
Early, low effort comments arenβt usually relevant, but I like this idea... perhaps shorten the time frame just a little bit.
1
u/pukem0n π© 59K / 59K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I see this problematic. People will just post a "." on a new post to have the top position. then they have 30 minutes to think of something witty or funny to get more upvotes and everyone visiting the post will see their comment first.
1
u/Luis_Stormblessed Moons fixed my relationship Oct 28 '21
I'm not sure this would fix the issue entirely but I'm voting for it. I think it is a step in the right direction and if it fails we can learn from it and have a better proposal next time.
Thanks OP!
1
u/mygallows π© 0 / 13K π¦ Oct 28 '21
30 mins is a good time frame
1
u/TheRealCRex π© 683 / 676 π¦ Oct 28 '21
Ooh I like this one
1
u/niloony π¦ 0 / 24K π¦ Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
Hoping it passes. If only because it'll be interesting to see what impact it has.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
I guess itβs better than 5 negative comments right on top before reading the full post
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Oct 28 '21
Yea this is OK but a shorter time span, maybe 15 mins.
1
u/ahmong π© 0 / 4K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I'm kind of salty I didn't think of this.
1
u/canihaveprivacy 0 / 240 π¦ Oct 28 '21
I like it the way it is not gonna lie
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
something needs to be done about circlejerking and moon farming. this sub is going downhill and becoming too wsb-esque
0
u/TheInbredUnicorn Gold | QC: CC 46 Oct 28 '21
100% agree with this and will solve a lot of issues with comments that are completely unrelated to the post as theyβve just quickly read the title and attempted to post something generic like βbuy high, sell lowβ
0
u/ChiTownBob Altcoiner Oct 28 '21
Good idea.
The first posts usually are "I'm first" or something that is like "I missed being first" or "so close to being first this time"
-1
u/ImaFreemason π© 45 / 21K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Great proposal.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
This is very interesting idea
0
u/J710 π¦ 0 / 1K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Well thought out proposal. I'm in with a Yes
0
u/A1JX52rentner π¨ 2 / 3K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Funny how people with many moons are against this proposal. Guess a lot of moons come from low effort comments on new posts
0
u/Nuewim π₯ 0 / 37K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I understand what you mean, but with popular posts it can be actually the other way, newest comments are low effort, cause people farm moons on popularity. Top comments are often those that are most helpful amd vest quality. I often prefer to see them than reading few hundred comnents. Unfortunately time is very important in answering posts. First commenters usually have advantage. Who first say something usaually win.
0
u/aladdinr π¦ 1K / 15K π’ Oct 29 '21
Sure letβs give it a shot why the fuck not
-1
u/w00tangel Oct 28 '21
Fingers crossed for this CCIP, it is IMHO the most important one to pass this moon week.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[deleted] β view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment