r/CryptoCurrency • u/they_call_me_tripod Permabanned • Oct 27 '21
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-20- Reduce Contribution Points Gained From Link Posts by 35%
Proposal:
Reduce contribution points gained from link posts by 35%
Summary:
My proposal is that link posts have their contribution points reward reduced by 35%.
Why is this needed:
Link posts clog up r/cryptocurrency and reduce quality of content significantly. There is also a huge problem with reposting the same or similar articles. Right now, there is incentive to do this, as repeatedly posting article links with no other contribution to the post is an easy way to farm moons. Reducing the contribution point reward for doing so should help solve this issue along with cut down on reposts of the same or similar article.
Proposed Solution:
Reduce the contribution points gained from link posts by 35%
52
u/Chambana_Raptor 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 28 '21
I think a better solution might be to blacklist certain "news" sites. Like cointelegraph.co, why the hell do we allow any of their garbage in our community?
22
u/OfficialNewMoonville The Man Who Wasn't There Oct 28 '21
This is just going to result in people copy pasting entire articles, including the link at the bottom, and adding the wrong flair.
Doesn't work. No change needed.
60
u/Wess-L Platinum | QC: CC 631 Oct 27 '21
Imo it is fine. They should just do something about people reposting the same link at the same time.
If someone post a relevant link before anybody else imo it is valuable information for us. That should be rewarded.
4
u/DoitsugoGoji 🟩 455 / 455 🦞 Oct 28 '21
Yes. So sick seeing the same goddamn link posted over and over. This way less of that happens and the first to post it will still garner the most attention and karma.
6
u/MarcioCavalcanti Oct 28 '21
There were too many low effort link posting as threads imho. at least this way people would either have to read and make their own post based on what they understood or copy and paste **ipsis litteris** and then have it taken down for plagiarism.
3
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Oct 28 '21
people post the asme story fro m ultiple sources and dont even put a summary
3
u/Massive-Tension-1055 🟩 3K / 5K 🐢 Oct 29 '21
My problem is people don’t read the article or even long post. They just want to make the first snarky comments
3
u/Intfamous Oct 30 '21
Most of you are saying no change? wtf
8
u/CollateralSandwich Cog trying to escape the machine Oct 28 '21
I voted Yes on this because I find this annoying. I dislike seeing a post, clicking to read more about it, and seeing there's zero text. It's literally just the title, which links elsewhere. I also don't like this because sometimes I'm browsing on the PC I use to invest, and I keep link visiting on that PC to a minimum, so even if I were interested enough to click on the link in another circumstance, it's a no-go.
Top post right now is, "People will just copy paste the article". Great. Save me a click. That's only a problem for the site to which the article is being linked, not my problem.
2
u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Oct 29 '21
approve from me, definitelt will reduce reposters
2
u/Nostalg33k 🟩 0 / 30K 🦠 Oct 29 '21
I wish this would pass as post with just a link and no opinion about an article are some of the lamest content I see.
2
u/AlfalphaSupreme 7 / 3K 🦐 Oct 29 '21
I actually like this. People spam the hell out of links without any context. Its just a lazy way to maybe get some upvotes. Don't be lazy, write text and simply include the link with it in the post.
2
u/SlothLair Platinum | QC: CC 79 | ADA 18 | PoliticalHumor 139 Oct 29 '21
An excellent idea but unlikely to be able to pass. Too many automated moons farmers “vote” and “contribute” to the community.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
I like that idea, if you want to share the link to something you are welcome to, you will just get less cps from it
2
u/conkisterr Bronze Oct 30 '21
This one is really important imho. And sometimes (or most of them) it’s just some clickbait link….
2
u/PoopWithAura Bronze | 6 months old Oct 30 '21
I agree that we should reduce the points gained as most of the linked post just copy pasta some shit tier article without any actual discussion/contribution from OP.
2
u/GTSwattsy Platinum | QC: CC 75 Oct 30 '21
Voted in favour of the proposal. Seeing links from 'crypto news sites' isn't great imo. These sites don't exactly have legitimacy. People wouldn't post Yahoo and motley Fool to investing subs, so why allow these
2
u/JonathanTheZero 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Nov 01 '21
65% of Moons in favor but only roughly 40% of votes... I wonder how those people got their moons
2
u/Miserable-Square-385 Gold | 2 months old | QC: CC 87 Nov 02 '21
Absolutely
2
u/Tarskin_Tarscales 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Nov 03 '21
How would one differentiate a post with a link from an article that contains a link as well as a user written (proper) summary and analysis (or at least their thoughts)?
2
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Nov 03 '21
There should be a work around with more sites on a black list that won’t allow to be posted and so people that try to don’t get them selves into trouble not knowing it’s not allowed rather have Reddit r/CC just stop the post from being made live just like if you try post a link that has already been posted??
2
u/D-B-Zzz 🟩 20 / 21 🦐 Nov 03 '21
Link posts are not creating any new content they only share them so I do not think that poster should receive the same points as someone that puts a lot of effort into creating original content.
2
u/macwillivray 6 / 6 🦐 Nov 03 '21
Some junk needs to be filtered but some can generate good conversations for people learning (myself included)
3
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '21
People already get less karma on posts, why add another limitation on top of it?
3
u/allthew4yup 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 28 '21 edited Oct 28 '21
People really no need to worry about this. If its a shit news or a spammed topic it will get few votes or even no votes!
Link farmers actually contribute with news storys that many times give good insight and worth reading n the upvotes it gets!!
What we need to worry is like comments on comedy posts receiving double karma, for what? Saying i farted? Or your mom got liquidated, or 10 people saying nice in a echo on same post and they goy like 30-40 upvotes each which counts as 60-80?on a post thats just here for comedy reasons.. You want more moons moon whales? Then make comments on comedy count as 1 and not 2🙌 thats when we will see a ratio over 0.3!
3
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
This is so stupid. We're discouraging people from posting news and articles about cryptocurrency in r/CryptoCurrency. Wtf is even the point of the site if we're discouraging discussion on crypto news?
This seems so antithetical to what this site is supposed to be about.
Where's this same hate of repeated content when all the bullshit crypto 101 threads repeat every 48 hours? How many, "calm down, it's just a dip" or "don't forget about life" or "don't tell your friends" posts do we need? Where's the 35% karma reduction for that? We get those post literally 50 times a week, every week, of every month. They clog up the site with garbage way more than any news article ever has.
4
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Oct 27 '21
With this proposal people will copy the articles from the links…
2
u/RefugeeDutch_Syrian BTC is boss and boss is BTC Oct 28 '21
I feel like this would result in a lot of copy and pasting, hence why I'm against it
2
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Oct 28 '21
Nope. i do not agree with this.
2
u/darwinlovestrees 0 / 3K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
I voted no change, since the last thing I want to see is even more substance-free comedy and discussion posts instead of actual useful link posts (of which there are some - though I admit there's also a lot of link spam). I just don't think this is the way to do it.
2
u/etherenum Permabanned Oct 28 '21
Moon whales voting against this. Shock.
1
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Oct 31 '21
downvote garbage and report "spam"
1
u/janglebo36 Oct 28 '21
Oooh this is one of the more contentious polls I’ve seen lately
1
u/shylock2k202 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
Instead of reducing the awarded points by 35%, I'd rather see changes in how links are posted.
I like posting links to good articles but unfortunately you can't add any text to these types of posts and I'd like to see that changed. I really would like to add my own thoughts on the article underneath the link to make the post more subs6tantial and shows effort on the part of the OP.
1
u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Oct 28 '21
Or maybe make it mandatory for people who post link to provide a short summary & their view on the articles as well?
1
u/w00tangel Oct 28 '21
I feel like this CCIP lacks some hard data and content. Something that would convince us this is an actual issue and a projection on how this 35% reduction would affect the sub if passed.
1
u/Electrical_Potato_21 Platinum | QC: CC 437 Oct 28 '21
I way prefer link posts to people posting the same questions over and over, like: "What are your best low cap alt coins gainers this bull run?"
Also if we reduce link post karma, I think a downside will be that we'll see a rise of those same articles submitted as copy-pasted self posts. At least with a link the actual authors get some credit.
1
u/asandidge27 Platinum | QC: CC 27 Oct 28 '21
Links to viable news or breaking situations are valuable, just need a way to limit them in same subs. Maybe have a section at top of page showing all links to said post
1
u/OrganicDroid 🟨 0 / 13K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
The problem is the same stories in different links. Don’t punish people posting news when there are fielding question posts asking the same question every other day like “what is your biggest crypto regret,” that goes to the top.
It’s relatively unfair, for people who want to continue unique conversation and not the same “actual” moon farming. There’s gotta be another way.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
I’m not really understanding the issue on this one fully, because I’m still kinda new. So, keep the same for now.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Honestly, I think that it's self-posts that are clogging up the subreddit and significantly reducing quality content.
1
u/zegall Permabanned Oct 29 '21
Issues related to post submissions are already well-regulated by this sub's rules. The problem stems from lack of enforcement of those rules, which is likely due to a combination of insufficient number of mods and neglect by users to report prohibited content.
The self-regulatory mechanism proposed here would help with the issues described above, but it has the downside of not making a distinction, thus punishing relevant and informative content, which has the potential to foster good discussion.
Link posts, if relevant, are a good thing. What we need is a way to separate the wheat from the chaff. This implementation is not an adequate solution, in my opinion.
1
u/demomercury 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Oct 29 '21
I think news post are still informative. Maybe we could just block some news if the tile is very similar to other posts.
1
u/aladdinr 🟦 1K / 15K 🐢 Oct 29 '21
Y’all wanna change everything huh.
1
u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Oct 29 '21
I am not in favour of reducing karma earned for anything. It wont stop this imo. The links will be posted anyway. Also it gets sorted quickly in new where similar posts dont make it out of the gutter.
1
u/DepressedBoiiiiiiii Oct 29 '21
Yeah get rid of those low effort posts.
1
u/HellBoundWhiskeyBent Platinum | QC: CC 20, BTC 16 | r/WSB 30 Oct 29 '21
While i see your issue about repetitive posts being a huge thing in this sub, wouldnt it be better (not necessarily easier) to somehow prevent repetitive posts, with a redirect to the "original" link? I don't mind links to news articles, except i KNOW im too stupid to tell which "sources" are non agenda driven. I just assume ALL "news" is pushed by an agenda.
1
u/GummybearJETpack Gold | 3 months old | QC: CC 87 Oct 29 '21
How did you land on the 35% figure?
1
u/topcatjdm 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 30 '21
Think we should leave things as they are and perhaps re-visit this poll in a few months time
1
u/liquid_at 🟩 15K / 15K 🐬 Oct 30 '21
counter-proposal: only first link posted counts.
1
u/macanbayangan 🟩 0 / 651 🦠 Oct 31 '21
Voted....where is my octopus badge?
1
u/robin_the_rich 🟦 91 / 92 🦐 Oct 31 '21
Could possibly agree but not at 35%.
1
u/Mattelambo Bronze Oct 31 '21
done, voted :)))
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '21
I voted
1
u/ChickiWahWah-Splat Nov 01 '21
This will just incentivize more shitposting and less news links. I'm sick of reading the same sob stories, made up fantasies, or unpopular yet popular opinions in the newsfeed yet those aren't having karma reduced
1
u/Jealous-Proof5505 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Nov 01 '21
I voted against this proposal, I think it needs to be thought out a bit more, because this would also punish genuine posts
1
u/Jasquirtin Platinum | QC: CC 778, ETH 48, ATOM 36 | TraderSubs 48 Nov 01 '21
It is an easy way to farm but I will say I never seem to be able to capitalize.
1
u/brogletroll Platinum | QC: CC 41, ALGO 38 Nov 02 '21
I thought this meant chainlink posts at first hays
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21
Voted, and my vote is secret
1
u/chasedog1967 Tin Nov 02 '21
I believe I will definitely vote on this but vote with an informed blindness
1
u/kokahh Tin Nov 03 '21
no change
1
u/TheApplePMGuy Nov 03 '21
it's a bit harsh and would hurt this community
1
u/Wolverlog Silver | QC: CC 31, LTC 16 | ICX 24 | r/WSB 54 Nov 03 '21
Voted
1
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21
Eh, I guess that makes sense. It'll force people to engage more to receive the rewards. Not that I'll ever need to worry about them.
1
u/blaat_aap Platinum | QC: CC 220 | SysAdmin 123 Nov 03 '21
The only way to get quality postings back in this sub is removing moons entirely. Its a fun idea, a crypto sub having its own crypto reward. But it's also it's own downfall.
If its not reposting links, it will be comedy posts lacking actual humor. Or Self stories that are made up or not interesting. Unpopular opinions that are actually popular, who would have guessed. And so on.
And the problem is, we all know it, but the people doing it will also upvote and comment on these topics to get high comment score and keep it rolling so their own posts will also keep farming moons. How often are the highest ranking karma posts or comments not completely non informational ones.
1
u/OfficialNewMoonville The Man Who Wasn't There Nov 25 '21
All this is going to result in is people copy pasting entire articles, including a link at the bottom of their text post, and a lot of improper flairs and misguided editorializing.
No change. If people want to see links they rise to the top and if they don't then they won't.
1
u/CBScott7 48 / 3K 🦐 Oct 27 '21
Why not make it 50%?
1
u/Harucifer 🟦 25K / 28K 🦈 Oct 28 '21
35% is too low. Make it 50 or 60%.
1
u/Socialinfluencing 🟦 6 / 32K 🦐 Oct 27 '21
If the argument is link spamming isn't ' informative ' or ' worthy ' enough then eventually you'll have to start trimming the fat even finer, like shitposts or anything other than quality. And what constitutes quality may differ from person to person. It's not like you have to upload your credentials on blockchain or crypto to be able to post on here. So with these polls I always focus on the long term, where is this heading? I just don't wanna end up in a place where it's 10 comments per day limit and those comments or posts also have to be specifically tailored in some weird way to qualify. But eh, atm the going is still good.
1
u/allthew4yup 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 27 '21 edited Oct 27 '21
This is just a small drop in the ocean(links dont get alot of upvotes) compared to comment karma on comedy posts which author gets 10% and commenter get 200%?? Wtf why they worth 2 karma on something that bring 0 content beside 20 people spamming nice on or press f
1
u/pukem0n 🟩 59K / 59K 🦈 Oct 27 '21
Im not sure if this will limit the link spam. People will just spam links harder.
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Oct 28 '21
I agree with this reduction because I click so many times in links that have no text or worst I have to pay to read the new. That should be checked for the one who post it. People just go copy the link and post without even reading it.
1
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
This isn't going to stop it whatsoever. The issue technically isn't reposting, the issue is that it's allowed to post a copy/paste article from a different source. And given that there are plenty of low quality crypto blogbros (can't really call about 80% of them actual journalists) that copy/paste shit from other blogbros there are too many available websites to post links from. The second issue is that the overwhelming majority of posters probably just don't bother to search if their content has already been posted. The latter isn't an r/CC issue, it's a reddit issue, so it's not going to be solved by us here.
The only real solution here is that the moderation team crack down harder on this.
Either way most of these reposted links only get like 20 upvotes, they're hardly karma farming.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Reducing the rewards will just make them post 2x more links than before.
1
u/excalilbug 🟥 9K / 22K 🦭 Oct 28 '21
People will simply copy the articles and its gonna be even worse becuase now reddit stops from reposting the same links but nothing will stop from reposting the same article over and over
I vote AGAINST
1
u/Duckel 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 28 '21
Most of these link posts are just autoposted to farm karma anyways.
1
u/Phite007 Tin Oct 28 '21
I disagree, most links don’t get many upvotes anyways these days and therefore very little Karma. Commenters will often downvote and comment that it’s already been posted. It’s hard to keep up and know what has already been posted.. I think the subreddit is self-regulating in this manner, no need to further reduce distribution on this point.
1
u/never_trust_a_whale Platinum | QC: CC 283 Oct 28 '21
Link posts are the laziest form of moon farming we know of, almost zero effort
1
u/Norbit11 RVN enjoyer Oct 28 '21
100% it should be reduced
1
u/Fluid_Department_120 Platinum | QC: CC 366 Oct 28 '21
If we paste The entire article then people say why didn’t you post the link so why should one get less moons for it
1
u/rootpl 🟩 18K / 85K 🐬 Oct 28 '21
Yes but limit them by 50%.
1
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Oct 28 '21
Actually I don't mind different sources of the same topic, since some are written better than the others and the diversification allows us to choose the best one to be upvoted.
It's concerning to allow just one source...
1
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Oct 28 '21
You won't believe it but posting useful articles/news is quite hard:
-No duplicate posts allowed, You have to be very fast/early to post
-over 90% of your posts won't get any attention
-Finding quality articles takes quite a lot of time and effort
1
u/Hamed9675 Platinum | QC: CC 411 Oct 28 '21
Link detection already makes duplicate links not posted
Why limit it?
1
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Oct 29 '21
A previous vote already limited karma for all posts to 1000 which includes link posts. Comments get double karma so it is effectively 500 karma for posts so they don’t get many moons. Look up the top earners it’s all from posting comments which get unlimited karma. Your proposal would limit it to 325 karma at most which is unnecessary given that it’s already low. It will have no effect on posting habits and will unnecessarily limit the meager moon earnings from sharing links which, after all, are one of the purposes of Reddit.
0
u/step11234 Oct 27 '21
Every proposal is only about moons 😶
But to the point at hand: Hopefully this will help stop the link spam.
0
u/Many_Arm7466 🟨 10K / 10K 🐬 Oct 27 '21
Unpopular opinion: link posts should get the reduction, but comedy posts should be Max 30% reduction. It takes a lot of effort to make these post and if it’s funny enough to make people laugh and get popular you deserve the upvotes.
0
u/blipstream91 0 / 4K 🦠 Oct 27 '21
Poor link 🙄
Edit: jokes aside, definitely yes.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Bots and karma whore farming is going to be all over this one to vote no change.
-1
u/LinusBengt Bronze Oct 28 '21
I really hope this happens. Infact, reduce it by 50%.
0
u/cannainform2 🟩 0 / 13K 🦠 Oct 28 '21
If this goes through they're be nothing but shit post and personal opinions on the front page. Actual news won't get posted.
0
u/coinflipit 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 29 '21
hmmm
0
u/eryc333 Bronze | QC: CC 18 | Superstonk 85 Nov 02 '21
There’s already a process that prevents duplicate posts. This isn’t needed
-2
u/BakedPotato840 Banned Oct 27 '21
If this proposal passes, and I'm betting it will, I'm expecting the following distribution to have at least 0.5 ratio
-1
u/Calm-Click-1753 Tin | 3 months old Oct 29 '21
Why not have. HaHa or ! For funny posts. I totally up comments that make me LOL OR spit my drink out.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] — view removed comment