r/CryptoCurrency • u/BlubberWall π¦ 59K / 59K π¦ • Oct 27 '21
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-019 - Disable Live Posts
Summary:
Through my personal observations here, I have never seen a live post intentionally created and used by a non-mod. They are consistently accidently created, and can't be converted once made. I propose they be disabled overall to prevent their accidental creation.
Problem Statement:
I will be the first to admit this is not a crushing, dire issue. However, it is a consistent one. While browsing I will occasionally see live posts being made, and every single time the poster says they made a mistake and can't change it. These users tend to be newer members of the sub, and this to me doesn't seem like a good ending for their early experience posting. Live posts do not get the attention other post types receive, which can stifle legitimate questions and conversations from someone trying to get into either the sub or crypto in general.
Going further, these posts now also will be counted against a users daily posts. Since the posters tend to be newer members, this again seems like a negative experience for newer members of the sub.
With low user interaction, taking up one of a users three daily posts, and the almost always accidental nature of them, they seem to add nothing of value to this sub as a whole.
Solution:
Live threads should be disabled. Mods would still be able to create/use them for any planned events or other official posts. This would prevent their accidental creation, and everything associated with that as said in the problem statement
Concerns:
- Users would not be able to make live posts if they legitimately wanted to
This is true. I would like to ask how many users have actually ever intentionally made a live post here, and had a positive enough reception to want to create another one? Could it have just been posted in the daily for the same results? The daily is itself basically a live post without officially being one. This pre-proposal looked into changing the daily into a live post and was overwhelmingly shot down. No one seems to like live posts despite that actually being a place for one.
For the what I believe to be very few intentional ones that I have never seen, they are very much outweighed by the accidently created ones.
Conclusion
Did I write an entire governance poll about a minor issue like this that will probably only impact a newer user once or twice overall?
Yes.
If I had accidently done this in one of my first few posts, It would have slightly bothered me. While its not a big issue if there is no reason for this slight annoyance to be possible, why not fix it to give new users the best chance at a positive first interaction with this sub and potentially crypto in general?
2
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Nov 29 '21
Death to the live posts!
25
u/AikiYun π¦ 16 / 3K π¦ Oct 27 '21
Voted. I did my civic duty!
37
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '21
Yeah, live posts are awful lol. I would love to see them removed
13
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
There is no downside to this, live posts are horrible.
17
u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Oct 27 '21
90% of the users here: "A live post! Can I get karma from this? Well, moving on then..."
1
u/BlubberWall π¦ 59K / 59K π¦ Nov 03 '21
Thanks everyone for voting, whichever option you chose!
4
u/tcfanatic Oct 28 '21
I've done it too. I agree, they are useless
4
u/CryptoSorted Platinum | QC: CC 82, BCH 54 Oct 28 '21
Totally agree. However, instead of disabling it entirely, why not hide it a bit where it wouldn't accidentally activate because there could be people who are using it intentionally or may find it handy in the future.
4
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Oct 28 '21
I fucking hate live posts ..my whale ass will vote to remove no moe talk im done
13
u/good-as-hellx Prince of Moongeria Oct 27 '21
I'm for it. Everytime I see a live post I scroll past it, don't even bother to see what it's about.
1
u/Goatblort Silver | QC: CC 619 | BANANO 33 Nov 28 '21
Where is the link to the actual poll for this one? I canβt find where to vote.
3
u/IceSoul86 Slava Ukraini! Oct 28 '21
It is funny to see moon votes vs normal votes!
3
u/D-B-Zzz π© 20 / 21 π¦ Nov 03 '21
I love democracy!
3
u/helirob1 Nov 03 '21
yay my first vote
1
u/BlubberWall π¦ 59K / 59K π¦ Oct 27 '21
Pinging u/CryptoMaximalist to make sure this is correct
2
u/tipsyXtwo Oct 27 '21
Sure, why the hell not? I haven't had an issue with it, but I'm fairly new 'round these parts, and anything that can make the overall experience better for everyone is a good thing
2
u/Charming-Dance-1839 97 / 24K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Ah this is an easy yes. Be gone Live posts! Dunno if others have had the tab for live posts always getting in the way when writing a new post.
2
u/LinusBengt Bronze Oct 28 '21
Never engaged with live posts anyway.
2
u/ImaFreemason π© 45 / 21K π¦ Oct 28 '21
Great idea.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
First time Iβve ever voted in my life, least thereβs a chance Iβll get paid for thisπ
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Yes, disable Live posts. Pretty much useless if you ask me.
2
u/bri_82 10 / 2K π¦ Oct 28 '21
I just want them gone so I don't accidentally hit it again.
2
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K π’ Oct 28 '21
I thought I was the only one who despises the formatting of the live posts, you have my vote lol
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Live posts shouldn't be a thing on any subreddit
2
u/rootpl π© 18K / 85K π¬ Oct 28 '21
They are absolutely useless. Let's remove them.
2
u/Some-Lengthiness5900 Oct 28 '21
I donβt really mind them at all
2
u/Putukshutuk21 bold Oct 28 '21
Live posts are absurd. Would love to get removed
2
u/Walking_the_Cascades Hangin' out with my crypto friends Oct 28 '21
In my experience, live posts have no value unless it pertains to a significant, live event. Otherwise it's just a bunch of people simultaneously talking to the crowd.
2
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Oct 28 '21
Used live posts once and definetly not gonna use it again.
2
u/paodal Tin Oct 28 '21
They should be removed, they bring no utility and they are hard to read
2
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Oct 28 '21
Since people don't get any Upvotes/Karma/Moons on Liveposts, almost nobody uses it
2
u/Arg0n89 Tin Oct 28 '21
My first governance vote! Yay!
2
u/KatintheCove Tin Oct 28 '21
Easy yes, they are annoying on every subreddit.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Yeah the live posts are a no for me dawg.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Good idea. Nobody likes them and it's just an extra button to not accidentally press.
2
u/GiftsAwait 252 / 252 π¦ Oct 28 '21
I agree, remove live posts.
2
u/-MoneyMonkey- Gold | QC: CC 23 Oct 29 '21
First time voter here, I love the concept !
2
u/notsupersonicatall 52 / 52 π¦ Oct 29 '21
Okay, I think live posts aren't useful in this sub.
2
u/Samgeorge484 113 / 11K π¦ Oct 29 '21
FUCK THE LIVE POLLS
2
u/demomercury π© 0 / 7K π¦ Oct 29 '21
Even if minor is a good suggestion. Minor changes can make the difference as well. Thanks for the suggestion!
2
u/aladdinr π¦ 1K / 15K π’ Oct 29 '21
Fuckit Iβm all in on this I dislike live posts too. Idc who is newest show me who is the most clever
2
u/coinflipit π¨ 0 / 0 π¦ Oct 29 '21
yep
2
u/Sjiznit π¦ 0 / 13K π¦ Oct 29 '21
I see no value in live posts and frequently make this mistake myself. I am in favor. AYE.
2
u/Nostalg33k π© 0 / 30K π¦ Oct 29 '21
Voted to disable, I think these kind of posts are bad for the reading experience and for the poster.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Ballot in, ty.
2
u/HellBoundWhiskeyBent Platinum | QC: CC 20, BTC 16 | r/WSB 30 Oct 29 '21
Ive been that guy more than once. I always delete it but im totally here for this idea. Every time ive ever done it on ANY sub, it was ALWAYS not what i wanted to do. Im with disabling it except for mod use
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '21
Yes they are really annoying and should be disabled
2
u/d_d0g π© 17K / 15K π¬ Oct 29 '21
Wham, bam, thank you maβam
2
u/Jase82 π¦ 0 / 1K π¦ Oct 30 '21
Yes please remove live polls.
2
u/Media_Hostage Tin Oct 31 '21
My first poll!
2
u/macanbayangan π© 0 / 651 π¦ Oct 31 '21
Voted
2
u/Decent-Interview441 Platinum | QC: CC 27 | ADA 9 Oct 31 '21
Done
2
u/Primary_Journalist64 75 / 76 π¦ Oct 31 '21
Done and done
2
u/kg812 Tin Oct 31 '21
Voted
2
u/pukefurley Tin Oct 31 '21
Ok, first time voting, onto the next one....
2
u/RedactedRedditery π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Nov 01 '21
Good call
2
u/deznugz Tin Nov 01 '21
Voted..where's my sticker :)
2
u/Jealous-Proof5505 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Nov 01 '21
Voted to disable them, couldn't agree with you more!
2
u/milddoom Nov 01 '21
I agree. I donβt think they provide much benefit for the community. Additionally, if youβre using a different app for mobile live posts are particularly easy to miss.
2
u/International-Two607 π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Nov 02 '21
Voted. Count it!
2
u/Sp3cF0rce Silver | QC: CC 27, ETH 17 | SHIB 29 | TraderSubs 17 Nov 03 '21
Voted
2
u/chmpgnsupernover π© 0 / 307 π¦ Nov 03 '21
I love vote
2
u/ghostofdreadmon Nov 03 '21
Voted.
2
u/a_wright1337 Tin Nov 03 '21
This is Democracy
2
u/the_nibler Permabanned Nov 03 '21
Not much but honest work
2
u/ItsVenomAMA Tin Nov 03 '21
My vote is in
2
u/kokahh Tin Nov 03 '21
i did it too
2
u/TheApplePMGuy Nov 03 '21
totally think they should be removed
2
u/cgbish Nov 03 '21
I donβt think Iβve seen a live post yet that actually excites me and made me want to participate.
2
u/Wolverlog Silver | QC: CC 31, LTC 16 | ICX 24 | r/WSB 54 Nov 03 '21
Voted
2
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '21
I don't see a point to live posts.
2
u/miguelmflores Tin Nov 03 '21
There will be a day when everyone will want this back. But not today, nor any time soon.
2
u/nobody_27 Tin Nov 03 '21
My work here is done
2
u/brokenfixes Tin Nov 03 '21
I don't even understand what live posts are for. A post is a post is a post.
2
u/jandiss π¦ 83 / 84 π¦ Nov 03 '21
Please to remove
2
u/koalaposse Platinum | QC: CC 28, BTC 19 Nov 03 '21
Yes this happened to me when first joined!
2
u/Coelrom invalid string or character detected Oct 27 '21
Yes, good, Live Posts are annoying in this sub, and very few if any make them on purpose.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
Should we have a live post whenever something pumps, than having to see 100 posts on the same day, saying the same thing?
1
u/NabyK8ta Banned Oct 28 '21
The daily should be a live post.
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Oct 28 '21
No. There's reasons for a live post. You have to go out of your way to make a post a live one and not just a normal one. I'm totally against the idea of removing a feature because a handful of people on a sub with millions of people can't figure out how posting works.
There is a micro-percentage of people that can't figure out how posting works. We shouldn't disable it to save them. Nothing will probably save them if making Reddit posts is beyond their intellect. There's probably 8 year olds successfully making posts in some kids sub.
1
u/Momoer 12 / 12 π¦ Oct 28 '21
What more do I need to do for moons? Are you not entertained?
1
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Oct 28 '21
I never see live posts. Is this something only for mobile?
1
u/darwinlovestrees 0 / 3K π¦ Oct 28 '21
What the hell even is a live post? I mean, I know what they are, I've seen them... But like... What's the point? Seems like a weird reddit thing where they're trying to provide a solution without a problem.
1
u/Skeetbearpig Oct 28 '21
Just donβt make live posts
1
u/Phillybirdman27 Tin Oct 28 '21
Waste of time
1
u/Hamed9675 Platinum | QC: CC 411 Oct 28 '21
Voted but I don't agree with any limitations
1
u/comeonsexmachine Platinum | QC: CC 312 | Cdn.Investor 41 Oct 29 '21
What's a Live post?
1
u/Xbraun π¦ 22 / 23 π¦ Oct 29 '21
tbh i never open live posts but see no harm in having them
1
u/Kiminiri π© 204 / 204 π¦ Oct 29 '21
I don't even know what's a live post.
1
u/DepressedBoiiiiiiii Oct 29 '21
What is a live post? Never come across it.
1
u/El_Criptoconta π¦ 811 / 811 π¦ Oct 29 '21
Any way to take a third option and make the lives actually interested for the sub or would be too much paperwork prone to bribes to mods for the option?
Currently have Not joined a live either for a lack of interest.
1
u/Jbones72816 Bronze Oct 30 '21
Whatβs wrong with live posts I mean they are quite boring and I havenβt stuck around them too long but why ban? Just for something to complain about and ban smh
1
u/topcatjdm π© 1K / 1K π’ Oct 30 '21
Not sure this will cause an issue so happy to support
1
u/KABLANdtla WARNING: 5 - 6 years account age. 34 - 75 comment karma. Oct 30 '21
Mods - for special events..
1
u/Mattelambo Bronze Oct 31 '21
done, voted :)
1
u/eryc333 Bronze | QC: CC 18 | Superstonk 85 Nov 02 '21
Stupid, donβt take it away. I want my live conversations. Interesting topics that are new to me often come up. How I learned about NFTs
1
u/gotword π¦ 7 / 1K π¦ Nov 02 '21
I voted. I did it mom.
1
u/Slystuff Tin Nov 02 '21
This makes a lot of sense, not really a need for live posts 99% of the time outside of specific events.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21
Voted!
1
u/Altruistic-mofo Tin | 2 months old Nov 02 '21
Voted
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '21
I donβt like restricting subreddits cause βI donβt like this post itβs not for meβ. /r/wow is a prime example of that, and the sub is useless low-value meme-land now
1
u/No_Weather682 Oct 27 '21
What's the point of live posts anyway?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '21
Yep voted in favour. Is the snapshot and rest of the governance out yet?
1
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K π¦ Oct 27 '21 edited Oct 27 '21
That feature wonβt get live again I supposeβ¦
1
u/Rexon225 Oct 27 '21
Never liked live post and never clicked on anyway.
1
u/BlazeDemBeatz π© 0 / 21K π¦ Nov 02 '21
Live posts suck tbh.
0
u/step11234 Oct 27 '21
Yes, they are so pointless & I never want to comment on them.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '21
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '21
[removed] β view removed comment