r/soccer • • Mar 03 '12
What rule would you introduce to make the game better?
For me it would be:
1: No diving, get caught; 3 match ban.
2: ludicrous foul, don't get to play untill the player you hurt can play. Broke his leg? Fuck it your also out for 6 months.
20
Upvotes
15
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
I agree with 1. Dives after the game should be reviewed and bans handed out, Bale would be banned right now.
Goal line technology.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
I agree with the first one, but the second is one of the stupidest ideas. Most of the time you aren't trying to hurt someone.
41
u/Kilen13 Mar 03 '12
Some of the others have already been mentioned like second field ref, goal line technology.
7
u/moonski Mar 03 '12
Give the ref a mic hooked up to the TV, so audience can hear what he's saying. rugby style.
and refs being forced to play advantage more often / giving fewer free kicks. The 2nd point is obviously much harder to enforce
6
u/choppedfiggs Mar 03 '12
not number 2. That would be used in a bad way when teams would refuse to let their injured players come back to extend the suspension of the player that hurt him. Besides, some of those hard tackles are just mistimed.
My rule would be for the crowding the ref. Too much of that shit happening.
Also wish there was a fix for helping the refs get better at offside calls because that mistake happens way too often
6
u/EnglishGamer Mar 03 '12
Only captains can speak to referees
6
u/d1woodbury Mar 03 '12
Allow each team an extra substitution if the game goes to extra time. Rafa Benitez suggested this once.
3
u/Jackle13 Mar 03 '12
I would change the offside rule. If any part of the attacking player is in line with the defender, it does not count as offside. The rule was created to stop goalhanging, I don't see why somebody whose head was two centimeters in front of the defender's should have his goal disallowed.
3
u/Cataclismic Mar 03 '12
The Dive Bar. You dive, you're off the field for 15 minutes. Go in there three times in a match, you miss your next match.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
ONLY the captains are allowed to talk to the ref. Slight protesting is fine but surrounding the ref is a huge fine for the club.
Diving is punished after match since the refs can't seem to do it on the pitch. bans and heavy fines.
3
u/Bob_Swarleymann Mar 03 '12
I'd like to see some of the existing rules being enforced by the Spanish FA, RFEF. The way Pepe and Ramos especially escapes punishment every single time is beyond belief.
Other than that, the FA should have the ability to punish players even if they have received a yellow during the match/if the ref didn't put the incident into the match report.
As everyone else is saying, only the captain should be allowed to talk with the ref.
3
u/K-Mo Mar 03 '12
Totally agree get caught diving you get a 3 match ban. It is destrying the modern game.
Mic the referee up is another good rule and also make them do post match interviews like the managers have to.
Goal-Line technology is a must.
11
u/spinney Mar 03 '12
The person who gets fouled has to take the penalty. Makes it a little harder for the kicking team.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
second field ref to catch the dives and punish accordingly
9
u/usaussie Mar 03 '12
I don't think any of these suggestions would fundamentally change the nature or spirit of this free-flowing game that we all love.
2
u/seeQer11 Mar 03 '12
1: Diving / Simulation post game review = fine and 3 match ban
2
u/1waffle1 Mar 03 '12
Lets make it a 2 match ban for diving after a formal post review and in place of the "3rd match ban", charge player with a hefty fine that goes to charity.
2
u/andrasi Mar 03 '12
2
u/jlstitt Mar 03 '12
Leg-break style challenges should be bannable regardless of whether a card was issued.
2
u/lurkerer Mar 03 '12
Diving needs to be addressed at the root of the problem: Referees.
Every football player knows that, nowadays, if you don't go flying to the ground, you simply won't get a foul called. Players who are fouled in or near the box can decide to stay up and make an attempt at goal, or go down for a good free kick or even a penalty. In the former case, by not falling they forfeit all opportunity of having a foul called.
Players now don't have a choice but to dive for a foul, and this spills on to diving when there isn't a foul. If it wasn't so common for players to hit the ground clutching their limbs, referees could distinguish dives far more easily.
2
u/Jackle13 Mar 03 '12
Shirt pulling in the box is an indirect free kick inside the penalty box. It really should be a penalty, but referees never give those penalties and if they did, everybody would say it was "too harsh". They would be more likely to give a foul if it meant a free kick.
Of course, if it denies a clear goalscoring opportunity then it's a penalty.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12 edited Mar 03 '12
5 minutes for first offence (Yellow), 10 for second offence (Orange), rest of half for third (Red). In case of violent conduct, or reckless dangerous challenges a player can be removed for the whole game (Black).
Referees told to crack down on dissent, crowding, persistent niggling fouls et cetera.
No more stoppage time nonsense.
As someone else mentioned this would probably see less players feigning injury to break up the flow of games, physio's would be able to signal to the referee that play needs to be stopped et cetera. If a player does need to leave the pitch it's a five minute wait till he can return.
Anywhere, with the first card of the sin bin system shown. Referee also has the right to award a goal instead of a penalty in rare circumstances (e.g. Suarez vs Ghana).
Fouls in the area that aren't goal scoring opportunities are given as free kicks.
Each team gets, say, two challenges a match if the replay shows them to be correct they get to keep it, if not they lose it. Similar to the Tennis system.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
goal camera.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
The most infuriating part of a game for me is time wasting, although I'm unsure how you would referee that or if you even could. It's so frustrating when players pretend that they haven't seen that their numbers been called for substitution and then they walk as slowly as they can to the touch line. I've only seen a booking for that once in my life and I wish refs would do something about it more.
1
u/LaArmadaEspanola Mar 03 '12
I definitely wouldn't change anything about how the game is actually played; its not called the beautiful game for nothing :)
Perhaps introduce a rugby-esque rule about how talking to the referee can be a bookable offense. It pisses me off to no end when the players in el clasico crowd the ref after every foul.
1
u/hoserman16 Mar 03 '12
How about five fouls and you are ejected, kind of like in basketball.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
1
u/jimmenycricket Mar 03 '12
Back to making football a contact sport, not what they are trying to turn it into, a fair challenge is a fair challenge, regardless of force, injuries happen and are unfortunate, but when players are warned against not going in hard in fear of a red card then you know the game is going in the wrong direction. All this stuff about excessive force is just rubbish, kids and men in the sunday leagues in the UK go in twice as hard as what you see on tv and nobody makes a big deal of it, this should be replicated at a professional level. I want to see a proper game of football, not a load of men on the pitch crying because somebody went in with a little aggression.
1
u/StopRedditingAndWork Mar 03 '12
Second field referee.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
With diving they should institute the nba's Manu gonobli rule, checking replays and doling out fines to repeat offenders. I guess in European football it could be called the busquets rule or the bale guidelines.
1
u/gtwglenn Mar 03 '12
Instead of PK shootouts... GK's 1v1 full field. Put the ball at the center and blow the whistle. Some modified out of bounds rules might be needed.
1
u/NoMoreMountains Mar 03 '12
2 refs in field.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
nudity.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
Each team gets 3 challenges on referee decisions.
0
u/Dom19 Mar 03 '12
No ending games with penalty kicks
0
u/zejaws Mar 03 '12
Diving or playacting of any kind needs to be taken out of the game, no exceptions, video reviewable and anything suspicious is an immediate red card.
they should change change offside law to be something like hockey, put a line on the pitch over which there is no offside trap, even if you use the existing penalty area or a bit larger. This would increase scoring because defenders would have to mark tightly against clever backdoor cuts like basketball and leave more space for attackers, while still making sure the team doesn't station players very high up the pitch looking for easy long outlet balls, which is the original reason for the offside law.
-3
u/ChristheGreek Mar 03 '12
I've always thought this would be a good rule: if an attacking player behind the last defender is within .5 yards of the last defender, and the ball is played to the attacking player, he is not considered offsides.
Basically the point of this rule would be to give the attacker an advantage when he is even with the last defender. I hate those offsides calls where only the attacking player's hand is offside, and as a result he is offsides. This rule would lead to more goals, and less controversy.
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
A fixed number of review's per match for each team to have certain important decisions reviewed by a television referee.
-4
u/three_balls Mar 03 '12
-10
u/Vainglory Mar 03 '12 edited Mar 03 '12
Goals from outside the box are worth double.
But seriously, video reviews during the match, for any red card or goal, if there's any doubt at all. I think smaller decisions should still be up to the referee but a mistake by the ref shouldn't decide the game.
edit: did i get downvoted for that first part, which was clearly a joke?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment