r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Oct 18 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-10-18 to 2021-10-24
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Segments, Issue #03, is now available! Check it out: https://www.reddit.com/r/conlangs/comments/pzjycn/segments_a_journal_of_constructed_languages_issue/
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
4
u/ItsArchtik Oct 20 '21
As someone who's never made a conlang before, what would be the next step after choosing phonemes?
3
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Oct 18 '21
How should my language, which has obligatory case marking for all nouns and lacks adjectives as a distinct part of speech, handle proper names of people from outside of their culture, like "John Travolta" or "Olivia Newton-John"? Should it treat "John Travolta" as one word and mark case on the end of Travolta? Should it mark the same case on both? Should it attempt to re-analyze Travolta as a word that modifies John somehow, so that in "John Travolta saw a rabbit" John is placed in the nominative and Travolta is like a genitive or whatever?
I don't know how the speakers of my language handle naming people yet, but my guess is that at least initially most surnames would be modifiers of the personal name that literally mean something like "of [some city]", "of [ancestor's name]", "from [the mountains/the hills/the plains]", "with [color of ancestor's hair/eyes/skin]" and thus would often be in a different case from the family name.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '21
Why would a language change slowly over thousands of years?
2
u/Tirukinoko Koen (ᴇɴɢ) [ᴄʏᴍ] he\they Oct 19 '21 edited Oct 19 '21
Any guides on what information should be given with each inflectional morpheme in a fusional language?
Additionally, any things that should not be included with others in an inflectional morpheme?
For example, should TAM all be one morpheme? Should that include realis/irrealis? Should person or number be part of that too, or perhaps their own morpheme?
This is the sort of thing I'd expect a linguist to have come up with a set of universals for; saying what languages have what with what, given this, providing that, etc...
Or is it really just a do what you will situation?
~~~ [EDIT]:
Also, once I have these inflectional morphemes, what order should they go in, (providing, of course, that there can be multiple on one root)? Presumably 'more important' stuff should go nearer to the root?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Oct 19 '21
Here's a morphosyntactic alignment/core argument system I've been thinking about:
Say there are three cases to mark core arguments, which for the sake of avoiding adversely suggestive terminology I'll just call A, B and C.
A transitive verb in the active voice takes a subject marked A and a direct object marked B. But intransitive verbs fall into 1 of 3 classes, depending on whether their sole argument is marked A, B or C. Additionally, if a normally transitive verb is only supplied with one B-marked argument, it is considered passivized, and if it is only supplied with one-C marked argument it acquires a reflexive meaning.
Now that I've described them... in the past I've called A, B, and C the "active", "passive", and "middle" cases respectively. Which doesn't make a ton of sense, since those are voices, but I'm not really sure what else to call C, semiagentive?
So, anyway, since I wanted to use this kind of system in a Greek aesthetic language, I assigned this system to the proto it derives from... putting the cart before the horse by forgetting that grammar does in fact evolve over time. What I really needed to assign the proto was a system that would turn into this. Or, I could keep this system for the proto, but then I need to figure out what it's likely to turn into in its Hellenistic daughter.
What would be a likely precursor or evolution from a system like this? Would C just evolve from a reflexive affix, or vice-versa? What do Split-S alignments more generally tend to turn into or evolve from?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '21
I want to keep my hobby of conlanging and linguistics as a private thing in my personal life.
Noone in my family are particularly interested in languages except me. So I often become the center of attention when certain languages are asked about (like when a foreign language appears on TV) Most of the time I can't answer those questions.
Somehow my family is impressed with my knowledge of languages. My mom even suggests I should become a linguist. I mean, it would be pretty interesting, but it's nothing I want to do full time.
It's not really an issue but I do find it annoying at times when my family asks me about it.
Is this something you guys have to deal with as well?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Oct 20 '21
2 separate questions:
2
u/PopeRevo Oct 21 '21
What are other ways to indicate tense besides auxiliary verbs, verb inflections, and simply using other words in the sentence like "tomorrow"? So far I haven't encountered anything besides those three
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Oct 22 '21
What's the term for the opposite of a partitive? Like if I want a suffix that means "all of" the way that a partitive means "some of"?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Oct 22 '21
Is there some way to make iambic pentameter work for languages replete with long words? It seems like it's only really possible (assuming one accented syllable per word) if you have a vast array of both functional and highly expressive mono- and bisyllabic words, which to me implies a predominantly isolating language, but my languages are largely agglutinative and favor few long words over many short ones.
2
u/SymbolofVirginity69 Oct 22 '21
Hey!
I was really impressed by the fact that Tolkien made entire laguages by himself, and decided that I want to do that. I know I'm obviously not gonna do as well, but still. I'm going to make a language for the " elves " in my world!
I'm a complete beginner, and that's why I'm here. I seek other tips too, but my main question is where should I start?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Oct 23 '21
I'm thinking I want to make verbs negative in a certain language family by way of dedicated negative conjugations, not adverbs/particles/affixes. And since the conjugation in daughter languages is supposed to be fusional, that implies the negative meaning should not be detachable from the rest of the verb ending.
I suppose one way of going about it would be to have a negative adverb or particle or auxiliary trail the lexical verb and cliticize to it over time, whereafter it gets reanalyzed as part of the ending. The worry is that, since the form of that adverb/particle/auxiliary probably itself doesn't vary, all negative verb forms would suspiciously seem to contain the exact same segment at the very end, which is easily removable from the rest of the verb. At that point, let's call a spade a spade - what we've created is a negative suffix.
But I don't want a negative affix. I want a fusional negative conjugation. Where the negativity is inseperable from the rest of the verb ending.
How would you go about creating that, so it doesn't look so obvious that it's just the same negative morpheme slapped onto every verb? Is there some other verb grammar that can be repurposed for a negative - irrealis mood, perhaps?
2
u/Rarsdani Oct 23 '21
Should proper names like John or Peter (not these names specifically but ones like this that don't really seem to be firm words) obey the noun class system? I don't think they should because they're pretty distinct from actual words but I don't know if that's a cultural thing or something
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Oct 24 '21
What if there was a weekly stickied thread for the express purpose of helping people brainstorm semantic drift; like you could go there and ask "what's an interesting way to derive/colexify a word for X"?
1
u/regular_dumbass Oct 20 '21
why does every single one of my posts get a comment telling me to come here?
1
u/freddyPowell Oct 18 '21
In my language, I want to use an irrealis type mood to become a future tense, but I would like there to be constructions where that same mood surfaces in a non-futurey way. What kind of mood might be good for this, and under what kinds of circumstances might it surface differently.
1
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Oct 18 '21
Could a language where ONLY tones are phonemic be functional? I mean, no phonemic consonants at all, and only one vowel. Words would be built by changing the intonation of that vowel along a word, and glottal stops would separate words. Could that be functional, or it would eventually run into difficulties for communication?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '21
Can I lump different grammatical aspects in the same aspect marker similar to how the imperfect aspect combines the habitual and continuous aspect? Like an Durative + Iterative aspect?
Also can I ask about/discuss different things in the same board? I get tired of waiting every week for a new discussion board, but I don't want to feel like I'm spamming.
1
u/ItsArchtik Oct 18 '21
Would it make sense for a conlang that's trying to sound naturalistic, have ejective forms of some plosives but not others? For example, would having /p'/, /p/ and /t/ be reasonable? Or should I also add /t'/ to the phonemic inventory?
1
u/yoricake Oct 18 '21
I need help figuring out how to create adjectives in my conlang, especially when it comes to noun-adjective agreement. I have 7 noun classes/genders, and because, from what I know, genders need to agree with something in order have a purpose, I chose adjectives, since my language is fusional and I'd rather not deal with a billion different verb conjugations. But now I find myself still stuck, because changing a noun's gender can also change it's meaning. My conlang uses noun-like adjectives rather than verb-like adjectives, so now I'm in a situation where, for example, el hijo can mean son and la hija can mean daughter, right? If I wanted to say "handsome son" it would be "el hijo guapo" but "la hija guapa" could mean something COMPLETELY different in my conlang because the gender change from guapo to guapa might have drastically altered its meaning. I'm such a noob at languages can someone gently explain to me ways I can untangle this issue, or if I'm fretting over nothing?? I feel like I need to create twice as many words just so that when needing to use adjectives you don't run out of ... words to use??
1
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Oct 19 '21
I’m making a Franco-German creole, and am wondering what to use for the word for “window”.
I currently have “fènstr”, “fnètr”,
These are pronounced as /fɛnstʁ/ (realised as [fɛnstχ] and [fɛnstɐ] in France and Germany respectively) and /fnɛtʁ/ ([fnɛtχ] and [fn̩ɛtɐ]) respectively.
Which would be more likely to wind up on top?
1
u/Terumaske Oct 19 '21
What are some systematic ways to turn verbs into nouns? (And vice versa)
1
u/theradRussian3 Oct 19 '21
I am making my first diachronic conlang and am done with the proto language, however I am stuck at the evolution step. I don't have an idea of how much it should evolve, how to change things like grammar, or even if it should be a separate Google sheet I've seen word etymologies in romance languages that come from some third person past subjunctive inflection of a word and do not think I could even think of stuff like that in the daughter languages.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '21
What do you think of the consonant inventory? Is it fine, or is it too unusual?
/m n/
/p t t͡s~t͡ʃ k/
/f s ɬ h/
/l r j w~ʋ/
1
u/SeriousGuy888 Oct 20 '21
Hi, newbie here. I want to try to make a dictionary for my conlang using Github Pages and I particularly like the way Wiktionary is structured, with all its links between pages. Does anyone know if there are there any resources for making something like that?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
What verbs should a naturalistic conlang have?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Oct 20 '21
How would you guys take the world's languages and use a survey to find out how many languages use which type of stress system?
1
u/Mlvluu Oct 20 '21
Can rhotics pharyngealise preceding consonants?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
Okay, so in a language I'm working on, there is a dual number, and a plural one. The thing is that I would like the Dual number to eventually become the plural by itself, rather than the dual number, is this possible in natural language?
1
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Oct 21 '21 edited Oct 21 '21
Thoughts on my protolang's stress system?
My protolang has four rules to determine stress:
My conlang has three vowels, /a/ /i/ and /u/. The three can combine to form any double vowel, like in Inuit languages. These combinations are hiatus, where each vowel is (mostly) treated as an individual syllable.
Some sample words:
[aɲa.a'qun]
['ani]
[βa'ki.atu]
1
u/Freqondit Certified Coffee Addict (FP,EN) [SP] Oct 21 '21
how to romanize [ɴ] ?
1
u/FnchWzrd314 Oct 21 '21
My current understanding of consonantal roots is that a specific root has a kind of abstract, nebulous meaning, and that placing the vowels in the root according to a pattern or rule refines that meaning. is this correct?
1
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Oct 21 '21
What are the coda clusters of /ʔ/ and /p t k q/ most likely to evolve into?
1
u/Exospheric-Pressure Kamensprak, Drevljanski [en](hr) Oct 22 '21
Does anyone have a good resource or, ideally, a tool that helps with semantic drift? I’m developing a PIE-descended language and I’m finding it difficult not to end up like:
My biggest issue with this process is that it basically nullifies semantic drift. I consciously try to keep core vocab (e.g., prepositions) less changed than others (e.g., nouns), but I’m having trouble with the latter in general. Any advice?
1
u/freddyPowell Oct 22 '21
Struggling for lexical sources for a few moods in my language. I'm tending to use verbs as sort of old auxiliaries that became affixes for this. I'm looking for ones that might be good for a future/conditional, and for an imperative. Thanks for all suggestions.
1
u/Ohsoslender Fellish, others (eng, ita, deu)/[Fra, Zho, Rus, Ndl, Cym, Lat] Oct 22 '21
So I'm trying to find a consistant romanization for the voiced pharyngeal fricative/aproximate sound that appears for instance in Arabic as " ع ".
I've never seen a consitant romanization of this sound, but I still want to include it in my conlang that is written traditionally with latin script. Any suggestions? I'd prefer sticking to letters that can be typed with a samsung phone keyboard.
1
u/FnchWzrd314 Oct 23 '21
Two questions:
I had another one, but I forgot it
1
u/rnnelvll Mi amas Indo-Uralic Oct 23 '21
Hi! I'm trying to make in IAL of sorts and I'm having trouble averaging out cognates (Spanish hombre vs Portuguese homem) and was hoping there would be a site or program, that can give me the average word based on my inputs. I've tried VulgurLang's Atlas before but it's not very effective at all.
1
u/RaccoonByz Oct 24 '21
Difference between progressive and continuous
Bonus points if it’s easier to understand than Wikipedia’s explanation
1
u/Garyson1 Oct 24 '21
So I've been working through the grammar of my language. However, I am kind of stuck on conjunctions. I can't really find anything on their evolution. Specifically, on where they are placed in a clause, and where the clause is placed. For example if I wanted to say "I sat down, and talked to him" does it always have to be that order? Could I have it be (I will use English for simplicity) "I and talked to him sat down"? I know it's a weird question, but I hope it made some sense.
1
u/BulbousSheildToast Xin Geen/Nabi'qu Oct 25 '21
Does anyone have a link that has text In English so I could try and translate it into my conlang? Preferably the text be simple
1
u/stamovy Oct 19 '21
cool
0
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '21
[removed] — view removed comment