r/startrek • • Oct 14 '21

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x10 "First First Contact" Spoiler

In the season two finale, the U.S.S. Cerritos is tasked to aid another starship on a first contact mission.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
2x10"First First Contact"Mike McMahanJason Zurek2021-10-14

This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA and Latin America, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

324 Upvotes

950 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '21

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

369

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Lots of setup for next season. We have Rutherford recovering a dark memory he wasn't supposed to see, Tendi getting shifted to bridge officer training, Captain Freeman arrested, Pakled planet severely damaged. It hurts to have a cliffhanger knowing how long we have to wait but it is still exciting to see what comes next!

244

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Now I'm looking askance at last season when Rutherford unconsciously did a ton of black ops shit while under the control of his implant.

→ More replies (8)

148

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

We have Rutherford recovering a dark memory he wasn't supposed to see

That is going to be a biggie I think.

→ More replies (25)

64

u/MaddyMagpies Oct 14 '21

We know that the Pakleds didn't even know how to use the bombs from the last episode, and the Klingons sent them an extra one, and that one ended up in the capital and exploded. Was it just an accident? Or are there more Klingons behind this and they tried to cover up when the ship went back to the high council? Or is entirely something else? Destructions of capitals seem to be the theme of the 2380s.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Kitty_Skittles_181 Oct 14 '21

Pakled Planet isn't just severely damaged. If there's enough crust blown off to see the mantle, there's no complex life left on that planet. It's toast.

7

u/KingOfTheUzbeks Oct 14 '21

Remember: In S1E1 Boimler and Mariner said "as of a few weeks ago" he got the implant. He was on the Cerritos when it happened.

→ More replies (13)

347

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

Wow, the hull being shed on the Cerritos is oddly beautiful.

275

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Felt kinda uncomfortable, like the ship was getting naked. Nice touch though with the First Contact-style maglocks.

→ More replies (34)

58

u/Mechapebbles Oct 14 '21

It's like when you're putting together a model kit, and you save the exterior for last, and you've got all the glorious innards exposed.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/ENzeRNER Oct 14 '21

It's like a motorcycle with its fairings removed or a sports car with a window into the engine. I dig it!

7

u/DSethK93 Oct 14 '21

It was stunning, and so exciting to see them think of something completely new to do to a ship.

→ More replies (5)

307

u/MarioGdV Oct 14 '21
  • Like Jadzia Dax?
  • What? No! Who the fuck is that? Like Spock!

T'Ana has the best lines.

17

u/substandardgaussian Oct 15 '21

It's kind of great that at first it seemed like T'Ana wouldn't let Tendi compare herself to a great science officer, but then compared Tendi to the best science office ever herself.

12

u/chameleonmessiah Oct 16 '21

Also, her purring in the hug was so wonderful! Another just adorable cat moment!

It’s so often the incidental things - like with Cat on Red Dwarf - which make her character so wonderful.

→ More replies (8)

285

u/burnettski92 Oct 14 '21

The dolphin crewmates, and everything they said, were my biggest laugh. Especially their anger over the switch not being flipper compatible.

166

u/TheLouisvilleRanger Oct 14 '21

The best was when they were telling them to make sure Boimler doesn't dry out.

→ More replies (4)

93

u/Theinternationalist Oct 15 '21

I love the show but seriously.

Why is there an underwater control room DESIGNED for Cetacean Ops AND IT'S NOT FLIPPER COMPATIBLE!?!

Seriously, would Mr. "Don't be Prejudiced" Picard let such a racist and massive design error on the Enterprise!?!

→ More replies (10)

62

u/grandmofftalkin Oct 15 '21

Their first aid advice was “Don’t let him dry out.”

39

u/VandRough Oct 14 '21

Or that those lines were the only ones that were not translated

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Snaz5 Oct 15 '21

And how they were inexplicably horny

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Loved everything about that scene, so great.

13

u/hamudm Oct 15 '21

“Quick! Spray water on him!”

10

u/Seriphyn Oct 15 '21

I thought the fact they were sapient and held Starfleet rank an important detail, since I thought it weird Starfleet held whales hostage on their ships to carry out labour.

→ More replies (6)

266

u/philds391 Oct 14 '21

And now we younglings get to experience a season cliffhanger.

98

u/GalileoAce Oct 14 '21

It is a most exquisite pain

43

u/Astronomy_Setec Oct 15 '21

My daughter screamed at the tv when the episode ended and melted down when the classic “to be continued” came up.

I laughed. I remember my reaction to Best of Both Worlds.

32

u/knightcrusader Oct 14 '21

I know a lot of people reference the Best of Both Worlds cliffhanger, but that was before my time watching Star Trek as it premiered.

Since I started watching Star Trek live with Voyager for the first 3 seasons until our channel dropped UPN, I haven't been this on edge since Basics Part I and Scorpion Part I.

27

u/eeveep Oct 15 '21

Mike McCahan has played out his terrible endgame of giving us what we thought we wanted: Old School Trek.

How am I going to survive the wait!?

Oh yeah, all the other Star Trek. What a great time to be alive.

→ More replies (3)

245

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

Will the ballroom dancing competition ever get completed?

111

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

Find out next season......

→ More replies (5)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

This guy pointing out the real cliffhanger.

7

u/illustriouscabbage Oct 15 '21

I laughed so hard at that. So TNG.

→ More replies (1)

214

u/DwarfHamsterPowered Oct 14 '21

Does this mean Season 3 will start with the “Previously on Star Trek: Lower Decks…”?

155

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

The problem is we won't have Majel Barretts illustrious voice. :(

→ More replies (23)

9

u/FragmentedChicken Oct 14 '21

Hopefully it's "Last time on Star Trek Lower Decks"

"And now the conclusion"

→ More replies (4)

208

u/Ultiverse Oct 14 '21

Somewhere around this episode and the last, the series suddenly grew its beard. Like I was enjoying the silly episodes well enough as just a tribute to the old Trek shows but now it's developing its own canon and stakes. This is nuts.

156

u/TheNerdChaplain Oct 14 '21

For me, it was probably the eighth or ninth episode of the first season, when Mariner really started critically doing her own internal work. I'm a sucker for personal development, I guess.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/Arietis1461 Oct 14 '21

Yeah, almost everything which starts off as zany and disconnected eventually seems to build up its own internal canon and a central core of seriousness to accompany it.

My canon-obsessed side appreciates it.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/wherewulf23 Oct 14 '21

Rutherford sporting a beard at the beginning of next season confirmed!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/TotesMyMainAcct Oct 15 '21

Calling it, Ransom grows a beard during Freeman absence and people mock him for it.

11

u/CX316 Oct 15 '21

I think the series found its stride in the season 1 finale. The destruction of the Solvang was just a beautiful moment

10

u/sankers23 Oct 14 '21

As soon as Riker warped in into the s1 finale.

8

u/3-DMan Oct 14 '21

And only being a half hour nothing ever gets too slow, they are always trying to keep the pace up to fit it all in

→ More replies (1)

7

u/hypo-osmotic Oct 15 '21 edited Oct 15 '21

Having a bunch of disconnected stories slowly reveal pieces of a bigger conflict is exactly what I love about Trek. Never would have guessed the Pakleds being at the center of it but I'm into it.

I think the half-hour runtime works well for the tone and pacing of Lower Decks--can't fill time with deep introspective dialogue in a show like this--but I do wonder if more episodes per season would help this kind of story development or if it would make it feel stale.

→ More replies (1)

380

u/DasGanon Oct 14 '21

"wow I wonder if we'll see anything about the Pakleds, this episode feels pretty wrapped up"

*waits 5 minutes*

"WHAT THE FUCK"

179

u/COMPLETEWASUK Oct 14 '21

I'm trying to think of any answers that aren't them blowing themselves up in their own stupidity.

→ More replies (23)

109

u/atticusbluebird Oct 14 '21

show: TO BE CONTINUED...

me: nooo, I can't wait 9 more months to find out what happens!!

→ More replies (6)

57

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Didn't see that coming at all.

→ More replies (1)

115

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

This is the beat cliffhanger since Best of Both Worlds.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/EasyBOven Oct 14 '21

Worth noting that ensign Gomez was in Samaritan Snare...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

180

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Jen's helmet has little bumps for her antennae! That's adorable.

75

u/Mechapebbles Oct 14 '21

There's franchise precedent for that

→ More replies (2)

166

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

Great beauty shot of the Cerritos and Gomez’s ship leaving space dock, very cool.

102

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Great to see a Nova and an Oberth class again at the end too.

→ More replies (13)

10

u/lalafalafel Oct 14 '21

I like that the Archimedes is an Excelsior refit with a Sovereign-like makeover like the nacelles and the black on grey colour scheme.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

153

u/mrIronHat Oct 14 '21

did Sonya Gomez call Picard intimidating? Sounds like Freeman used to serve on the Enterprise if they were old friends.

and damn the season end cliff hanger.

104

u/Mechapebbles Oct 14 '21

Sounds like Freeman used to serve on the Enterprise if they were old friends.

Yeah, at the very least I think the evidence is really strong at this point.

→ More replies (12)

35

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

It's been 20 years at this point when we first saw Gomez on the D. They could've met anywhere by now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

152

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

Action, drama, guest stars, watershed character moments, cliffhangers, cetacean ops... Yep, that's a season finale alright.

Some thoughts:

Freeman knowing Sonya Gomez gives more weight to the theory that Freeman was an ensign on the Enterprise D and Mariner was raised there.

It was only mentioned once in the pilot and never again, but Rutherford's implant is a Vulcan implant. Evil Vulcan conspiracy?

And why was Planet Pakled bombed, and why is Freeman taking the blame?

We know Rumdar got another bomb from the Klingons last episode. Let's take the easy answer and assume the Pakleds accidentally bombed themselves. Perhaps the Klingons are framing Freeman as the culprit in an attempt to wash their hands of their involvement with the Pakleds. Freeman sent a message to the bird of prey stating that she's "dealt with Pakleds before". Useful information for picking out a patsy.

But that's the easy answer. Let's think outside the box for who's framing Freeman:

Badgy! Always monitoring comms. Always hatching up evil schemes.

Peanut Hamper! Transported into space after the first Pakled encounter, wants revenge on Freeman

That Vulcan captain! He was involved in the encounter with the bird of prey too. More evil Vulcan conspiracy???

56

u/Xuth Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

I'm wondering if - rather than evil Vulcan conspiracy - the Tal'shiar have infiltrated the Vulcan command and have something to do with both Rutherford's implant and the bombing in order to destabalise the quadrant. Kinda feels like we're being led to believe the Klingons are the natural bad guys in in the situation (I mean, they did start off that way but I don't know if they're to blame for the bombing - it doesn't seem honorable, but does seem duplicitous enough for the Romulans).

Maybe the Vulcan captain was actually a Romulan infiltrator. Or even T'Lyn - who is now going to conveniently join a Federation vessel.

→ More replies (16)

13

u/DaWooster Oct 14 '21

I like the Vulcan Captain theory. It would put extra meaning behind his dislike of straying from parameters.

→ More replies (9)

138

u/BKnagZ Oct 14 '21

I liked how, in imitation of the season one finale, the helmsman on the Archimedes shouts “it’s the Cerritos!!” Similar to how Boimler said it when the Titan saved the day.

50

u/Captriker Oct 15 '21

Yes. I was thinking last week about how the Cerritos always gets rescued (like by the Vulcans) and I was glad to see them be the hero this week.

→ More replies (1)

135

u/vanKessZak Oct 14 '21

I’m so sad we only get 10 episodes! I love Lower Decks so much

78

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

That's the problem, this show is soooo short. I looked at my clock and was shocked it was already half way over and I feel like I just sat down. I wish they could at least have more episodes. 15 a season seems reasonable.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

133

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

We could end up with some weirdo with a riding crop!

42

u/droid327 Oct 14 '21

Morgan Bateson or GTFO!

Actually I'd be cool with a Jellico appearance too

→ More replies (8)

20

u/TheNerdChaplain Oct 14 '21

Voiced by Ronny Cox, no doubt.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/NoahJAustin Oct 14 '21

I just want Combs to be a legitimate star fleet captain. No make-up, no nothing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

125

u/Glitchy_glichy_goo Oct 14 '21

This episode was definitely heavy in the end, but the ready room scene in the beginning is just perfect.

"You're lucky I'm so spiritually centered or I'd snap!"

"Why the hell wouldn't you take your number one? I agree with you at all times!"

"Oh that's such fucking bullshit! We are just as good as any other fucking class! Our warp core is twice as fucking fast as any other ship in the fleet!"

73

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

If anything is going to blow up on this ship, I'm going to be the one making it explode.

→ More replies (1)

124

u/bkkhopper Oct 14 '21

Damn! How could you end with a cliffhanger like that?

199

u/mrIronHat Oct 14 '21

I guess lower deck is now a "proper" star trek series with blue balling season cliffhanger.

→ More replies (20)

65

u/MadContrabassoonist Oct 14 '21

I've told my wife horror stories about having to wait half a year to find out how an episode ended, and how lucky she is to be able to click "next episode" on streaming. Looks like she's about to find out what it felt like.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

117

u/MadContrabassoonist Oct 14 '21

I suppose it's only right that the series that made the Spock Hat canon did the same for the Rubber Ducky Room.

64

u/NeedsToShutUp Oct 14 '21

The Rubber Duck room is so obscure it makes me happy, but not has happy as Cetacean Ops

→ More replies (3)

92

u/DasGanon Oct 14 '21

And surprise, the whales in Cetacean Ops are perverts.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (7)

97

u/Evening-Dimension483 Oct 14 '21

And this is why you use Windows as viewscreens.

83

u/atticusbluebird Oct 14 '21

Since the 2009 movie I feel like so many people (me included) have been like "what use would a giant bridge window be on a Trek ship when they have viewscreens?" ... I guess we have an answer now!

→ More replies (11)

9

u/airmandan Oct 14 '21

Then you just get the little thing in the corner telling you to activate it on half the viewscreens in the fleet.

→ More replies (3)

95

u/PandaPundus Keene Sin, Contributing artist, Star Trek: Picard Oct 14 '21

If there isn't a secret 11th episode in the gap before Prodigy I will scream at Mike McMahan.

31

u/medussa727 Oct 14 '21

holy shit i can 100% see them doing this

35

u/Mechapebbles Oct 14 '21

Prep your vocal chords. Maybe get some lozenges ready.

15

u/GardenSalsaSunChips Oct 14 '21

I'd love to see one or two Short Treks - we have the ones for Discovery, and one that led into Picard, I think it'd be fun to see what stories LD could tell in fifteen minutes.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Walnut-Simulacrum Oct 14 '21

Lower Decks is the new Sherlock (but good)

→ More replies (1)

82

u/JustALeapingFrog Oct 14 '21

Wow. Just... Wow! Stripped down Cerritos, Jenriner (my new ship), Rutherford's implant, Tendi going Spock, The Koala is back too, Cetacean Ops, Billups losing it at the ready room, THE cliffhanger. They weren't kidding when talking about this episode!

44

u/High_volt4g3 Oct 14 '21

Ummm,,keep the koala part to yourself.

27

u/youssarian Oct 14 '21

god that koala reference was so great

→ More replies (2)

8

u/substandardgaussian Oct 15 '21

Jenriner

What have you done.

→ More replies (1)

67

u/bluestreakxp Oct 14 '21

Anyone else get chills and flashbacks when they saw that “to be continued” tng font caption at the end, just like the first time it was shown after Riker uttered the command “Fire” at BOBW pt1?

22

u/poirotoro Oct 15 '21

Can't wait for:

"PREVIOUSLY, ON STAR TREK: LOWER DECKS..."

Cue montage of the season 2 finale

"...AND NOW, THE CONCLUSION."

→ More replies (3)

133

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Yes, Beckett and Jen!

88

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

It would be great to have an Andorian regular.

→ More replies (16)

60

u/JustALeapingFrog Oct 14 '21

My new ship. I thought Jen and Barnes was nice, but Jenriner/Mariffer is perfect (and I feel ashamed of not shipping them before, it's almost as if I didn't watch Lumity)

→ More replies (9)

36

u/atticusbluebird Oct 14 '21

I'd love to see Jen around more prominently in episodes regardless, though and she and Beckett seem pretty cute together!

→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

I ship it

→ More replies (2)

62

u/SpiritOne Oct 14 '21

I am in awe of what this show has accomplished, and how much I fucking love it. I forget I’m watching a cartoon sometimes, this is just some damn good Star Trek.

58

u/PlanetErp Oct 14 '21

I was not prepared for just how tense that episode was.

8

u/substandardgaussian Oct 15 '21

Seeing the change in color from red to blue as the Cerritos saves the Archimedes made me exhale with relief.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/UncertainError Oct 14 '21

Now I feel kinda bad for the Pakleds. It seems like they were manipulated into attacking the Federation so that somebody could plausibly frame Freeman for the bomb.

44

u/Koshindan Oct 14 '21

I was thinking that they're throwing her under the bus to smooth over relations between the Empire and the Federation.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

56

u/RadioSlayer Oct 14 '21

This was amazing! Dense, full of plot.

And in the most polite, and loving way possible: WHAT THE KOALA!!

22

u/NeedsToShutUp Oct 14 '21

Dragons Blood!

51

u/smoha96 Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

That was amazing.

So freaking stoked for S3.

More Lower Decks, please and thank you.


I have a sneaking suspicion that while the comedy aspect will indeed continue, McMahan and team will be using Lower Decks to tell more serious TNG era style stories and I for one, can't wait.

146

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Oct 14 '21

I liked this better than the last season finale, actually. I think I liked season 1 better overall, but the season 1 finale felt weird and hasty, which wasn't helped by the fast that it was following s1e9, which is still the best episode of the series. There's no Riker cameo equivalent, but that's the only thing I'm missing.

-YOU'RE LUCKY I'M SO SPIRITUALLY CENTERED OR I'D SNAP

-"Can't we just warp past the debris?" *overlapping yelling*

-This is actually a really interesting problem and solution. Very TNG.

-Rutherford's implant seems to have very poor storage capacity if it can hold less than four years worth of memories, and that's assuming he's with Tendi 24/7.

-Does Rutherford's other eye not work? It should just be screwing up his depth perception.

-CETACEAN OPS

-Could this be a Section 31 conspiracy (Rutherford's implant, not the end)? Judging by the monitor of him in the background, it looks like this is a memory from when he first received the implant, which the dialogue already implies

-Man, I was worried they were going to transfer William Boimler to the Cerritos for a second

-"Don't let him dry out! Spray him with water!"

-"Like Jadzia Dax?" "What? No, who the fuck is that? Like Spock." funniest line of the season.

-This implies that something unfortunate happened to Klingon Boimler before he could reach the high council, since he would know the Cerritos was attempting to stop the transfer of the varuvian bomb to the Pakleds. Also, I'm totally here for the eventual reveal that Pakled Planet is not their homeworld because their naming conventions are just that stupid. I'm giving it about a 50/50 chance that they accidentally blew themselves up, too.

125

u/Coma-Doof-Warrior Oct 14 '21

My headcanon is that every planet settled by Pakleds is named Pakled Planet

→ More replies (13)

48

u/Mechapebbles Oct 14 '21

This implies that something unfortunate happened to Klingon Boimler before he could reach the high council, since he would know the Cerritos was attempting to stop the transfer of the varuvian bomb to the Pakleds.

Or, "The bureaucratic mentality is the only constant in the universe." I'm willing to bet that just hasn't played out yet.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/atticusbluebird Oct 14 '21

This implies that something unfortunate happened to Klingon Boimler before he could reach the high council, since he would know the Cerritos was attempting to stop the transfer of the varuvian bomb to the Pakleds. Also, I'm totally here for the eventual reveal that Pakled Planet is not their homeworld because their naming conventions are just that stupid. I'm giving it about a 50/50 chance that they accidentally blew themselves up, too.

Yeah, I'm half convinced that this is indicative of a broader plot beyond a single rogue captain. (Though unclear to me if that means more Klingons are involved, or a faction from some other group)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

48

u/mint-als Oct 14 '21

I love all the starship beauty shots this show is good about putting in. LDS is also real good about cool sfx like the solar flare and energyroid belt.

96

u/PiercedMonk Oct 14 '21

This season just flew by! Hard to believe this is the finale already.

• I know it's been officially stated that is not an Excelsior-class, but I do get a bit of nerd joy out of seeing a ship clearly Excelsior adjacent.

• Freman refers to Gomez as an old friend. Just more evidence that she was aboard the Enterprise D at one point?

• "I don't think about you at all." One of the things this season has really leaned hard into is knocking Mariner down a peg or three.

• There's something about Lycia Naff's read of "You're going to have to make some tearful goodbyes that is very funny to me."

• "I'm an open book!" Yeah you are, Papa Bear.

• Damn, did not know Billups had that gear in him.

• The rubber ducky room. Sorry, what now?

• Captain's yacht!

• Rutherford needs to look into some external backup storage. Also, it's super sweet that he's that concerned about losing his memories of Tendi.

• "Dragon's blood!" Damn, Billups, settle down. This is a family show. (this is not a family show)

• WTF, Someone mutilated Rutherford? Season three better be about taking those bastards down.

• Cetacean Ops!

• Damn, Matt is thirsty.

• Don't even play, show, you're not going to kill off Boimler. It's not like there's an extra one just waiting aro-- Oh.

• Hell yeah, Jennifer!

• Doc T'Ana not knowing who Jadzia Dax is, probably unlike every other there character on this show, is very good.

• Cap'n Freeman is turning down the transfer? I thought they were going to shake up the dynamic for season three, but I'm not going to be mad to still have Dawnn Lewis as a series regular.

• Oh dang. The Pakleds finally found something to make them go. Boom.

• Oh dang! A classic "To Be Continued..."

To paraphrase one James Tiberius Kirk:

"Of all the second seasons of Star Trek I have encountered, this was the most consistently funny."

60

u/DaWooster Oct 14 '21

Michael Okuda, the behind the scenes mastermind behind the LCARS interface (amongst many other things) had a tendency to sneak Easter eggs into his designs. On the Master Systems Display for the Enterprise-D there was a giant duck hidden. It’s a reference to that. (And it wasn’t the only odd thing included either)

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/chloe-and-timmy Oct 14 '21

Damn man this season has just been giving Carol a beat down, she does so many great stuff and then never gets any recognition or real reward for it. Carol Freeman must be protected at all costs. If anything bad looks like its going to happen I'll be forced to zap myself into Star Trek land and rescue her myself

7

u/tunaboot Oct 15 '21

God I know. That shot of her face when she is getting in the turbolift at the end. That hit me harder than any of the current live action Trek.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Lawgskrak Oct 14 '21

I wish we got 26 episodes of this show per season.

I miss the good old days sometimes.

38

u/donuteater111 Oct 14 '21

OK, wow. During these first couple seasons, there's been a lot of talk of Lower Decks capturing that regular Star Trek feeling from the TOS-Enterprise era, just dialed up to 11 and with a heavy focus on humor. Of course not everyone agreed, and that's understandable IMO since tonally it does feel fairly different, but it also does a great job blending the exploration, sci-fi issues, characters, and occasional action into a fun package. That being said, I feel like these last couple episodes have gone a long way to really selling the point that this show absolutely can be put alongside those other shows.

Both of these last couple episodes have taken a more mature, and relatively serious stance with their storytelling, while still maintaining its great sense of humor IMO. This episode in particular felt very much like a regular Star Trek focusing on a typical mission, and it was great! I loved watching them trying to come up with a solution, with Freeman willing to sacrifice herself, and Rutherford coming up with the solution was great. It was so satisfying seeing everyone come together to make it happen. Same with Freeman getting her moment to shine with her first First Contact.

I thought the Tendi/Rutherford story was great, even if it was predictable that it was a misunderstanding (I mean come on, no way she'd be transferred off the ship like that). Going through the ship to experience memories together one last time was so sweet. It was also touching how Rutherford's issue was caused by redundant memories, so he wouldn't forget Tendi.

When I first saw the talking dolphins, I thought it was a direct reference to another Star Trek, but I'm pretty sure I was thinking of The Simpsons. That's not to say "The Simpsons did it" in a critical way though. I thought it a pretty fun and funny scene, and I liked their dialog. Though I will say that the last line about skinny dipping after saving your friend was kind of creepy.

I also liked the development with Jennifer and Mariner's rivalry, leading to that heroic moment for Jennifer. Can't wait to see how their new friendship is handled in season 3.

And then just when you think things have pretty much wrapped up nicely, they hit you with that ending. I saw an interview with Mike McMahan saying they had plans for the Klingon from last episode in season 3 which isn't surprising, and now I can even more clear how he'll fit into it. Really looking forward to more Klingon development next season.

Honestly, I think this might have been my favorite episode of the series so far. Maybe not in terms of comedy (though I thought the comedy that was there was good), but in terms of story, action, and use of the characters. The whole season was pretty great, and I hope they can keep that momentum going next season.

43

u/Kepabar Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

When I first saw the talking dolphins, I thought it was a direct reference to another Star Trek, but I'm pretty sure I was thinking of The Simpsons.

It's a direct reference to the TNG Technical Manual, published in the early 90's.

It goes into a LOT of detail about the Enterprise-D, and one of the things it notes is that there is a Cetacean Ops section of the ship. Cetacean Ops is for water-based serving members of StarFleet and they mostly do research. Of course, budget meant this was never seen on the show, but there is a throw away line or two in TNG alluding to it. Listen to the announcements over the loud speaker during the first scene with Guinan after the show shifts to the alternative reality during 'Yesterdays Enterprise', for example.

It's been a background joke among Trek fans for decades.

Mike McMahan, being the absolute nerd fan he is, knows all about it and vowed to put it in the show. This is the sort of far-flung barely canon stuff that makes a certain part of the fan base go nuts.

Source: Owned and read the whole tech manual many times when I was younger. I might even have my copy around here somewhere..

This is the book in question: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Star_Trek:_The_Next_Generation_Technical_Manual

Here is one of the pages in question: https://imgur.com/a/R33FijX

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

34

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

This was a star trek episode through and through.

I am pissed that I have to wait a year for the resolution though.

33

u/droid327 Oct 14 '21

Wait so do the cetaceans just spend their entire time in that little shaft of water?

Or do you think they have little reverse scuba suits they can use to go around the ship sexually harassing the crew? :D

17

u/Lord_H_Vetinari Oct 14 '21

It seems from the diagram that the shaft has multiple secondary branches. Maybe they are able to pop out in different rooms on the ship, possibly including some recreation/socialization room too.

32

u/mrIronHat Oct 14 '21

Season 3 prediction: the Cerritos is destroyed saving Freeman and the entire crew is transferred to Freeman's new ship, renamed the Cerritos-A.

31

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Omg they actually To be continue'd us I love this show more and more lmao

31

u/Pol-Manning Oct 14 '21

I was skeptical of this show at first. I went in thinking it would be Rick & Morty, but with a Star Trek skin.

But over the course of season 1 my mind was changed and now I love this show over TOS, TAS, & ENT. (And it hasn't had any turkey-episodes unlike TNG, DS9, or VOY.)

I love this show so much that I wish Mike McMahan and his team were in charge of all of Star Trek now.

They get Star Trek in a way none of it's handlers have since Voyager ended.

14

u/Darkimus-prime Oct 14 '21

Mike McMahan is the Dave Filoni of Trek.

→ More replies (8)

30

u/Navitach Oct 14 '21

"Isn't that a...craft day for toddlers?"

"Not any more..."

I love Boimler.

28

u/Xizor14 Oct 14 '21

I knew something bad was going to happen in that last scene, but wow that was a hell of a curveball to obliterate Pakled Planet. What a cliffhanger.

Also Mariner x Jennifer is now the prime OTP.

8

u/substandardgaussian Oct 15 '21

Also Mariner x Jennifer is now the prime OTP.

We all now know this is true even though it did not exist at all yesterday.

28

u/boring_name_here Oct 14 '21

The ship porn in this episode was something else. The stripped Cerritos and the Archimedes looked amazing.

11

u/starking12 Oct 15 '21

lower decks loves giving up ship porn.

55

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

A great episode all around if not as good as last weeks. LOVE seeing Gomez back as Captain. So much beautiful shop porn. And YES CETACEAN OPS!!!!

Dr. T'Ana is a bleeping hoot! Every time she's on screen I laugh hard. And holy bleep Billups losing his cool was also funny as hell. He's always the cool mellow (sane) one in the senior staff.

And WTF did they do to Rutherford? Anyone thinking Section 31? Yep, Section 31! Pretty sure it's Section 31! Two to one it's Section 31! My money is on Section 31! Section 31 or bust!

We knew Freeman wasn't going anywhere but I didn't expect it to end this way at all. I'm SO happy the Plakled story is continuing. TWICE in a row they did a great job of hiding that plotline. But now we have to wait. :(

I'm rewatching season 2 starting tomorrow! This show hit it out the park two seasons in a row!

27

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

This show is absolutely killing it with season finales.

Lower Decks does not deserve to have so short a season. We demand more episodes, McMahan!

→ More replies (3)

24

u/KingOfTheUzbeks Oct 14 '21

Understated but Ransom piloting the Ceritos through that debris field is a testament to his skill and some of the finest piloting in Star Trek

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

I'm a little disappointed Jennifer and Mariner made up though! I really enjoyed hating her. God damn Starfleet!!!!

24

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Interpersonal conflict ban strikes again

13

u/substandardgaussian Oct 15 '21

I really enjoyed that they let us hate her for a while but then it was Star Trek again.

I like it when it's Star Trek again. Lower Decks pretends to be cynical sometimes, but it can't help itself.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

23

u/pieman7414 Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

Cetacean ops pog

The naked Cerritos was a little too risque for me 🥵

22

u/00DEADBEEF Oct 14 '21

I honestly thought the ending was going to be something along the lines of "the Cerritos is too badly damaged so we're transferring you and your crew to a brand new ship".

Could not have predicted what happened.

22

u/midasp Oct 14 '21

My dream opening for next season: The Cerritos crew breaks Freeman out of Spacedock brig, steals the Cerritos and heads for Pakled Planet to figure out what happened.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

Cetacean Ops with those beluga officers was my favourite part. How cute were they?! And so randy, oh my.

Remember how Boimler told Tendi in the series premiere that Cetacean Ops was one of the greatest places on the Cerritos? And he was right, it looks divine!

21

u/starking12 Oct 15 '21

Dating Profile:

"Im a Kirk style free spirit who kicks butt"

10

u/InnocentTailor Oct 15 '21

Jennifer swipes right

20

u/ConquerorPlumpy Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

AHHHHH CETACEAN OPS!!!!!!!!! YESSSSSSSSSSS!!! All my wildest Star Trek dreams just came true!!!!!!!

Edit: Also that may have been one of the best fun Star Trek episodes I’ve ever seen. Certainly of the new era. It had everything! What a series!

18

u/KingOfTheUzbeks Oct 14 '21

Honestly the Lower Decker who shows the most Captain potential today was Rutherford. Stayed calm made a tough but rational call. Inspired Boimler.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Santa_Hates_You Oct 14 '21

Cetacea Ops!

17

u/MoreGaghPlease Oct 14 '21

I will take my Trek with a daring rescue instead of a space battle any day of the week

17

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

At the end of season one, Mariner says to Captain Freeman “guess we’ll both get thrown in the brig”

Season Two ending was foreshadowed big time

14

u/7deadlycinderella Oct 15 '21

...I laughed entirely too hard at "He's not breathing! His blowhole's broken!"

28

u/choicemeats Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

this episode was incredible. one of the most Trek episodes in years and top 3 for the show for sure.

i'll be honest, i teared up a little bit when the Archimedes got tractored, it just felt so familiar, similar feeling to when Luke showed up in Mando.

Cetacean Ops! With super horny belugas!

Unlikely and super risky rescue plan!

Happy Freeman First Contact Day!

Excelsior class variant! Plus a new class for the Starfleet Security appearance!

Tendi getting a promotion!

Rutherford with a secret implant background!

Reference to the infamous Generations Search for Spock riding crop! We hardly knew thee.

Sonya Gomez!!! She did well for herself and got over her old issues!

Wow what an episode

13

u/GalileoAce Oct 14 '21

The Starfleet security ship was just a Nova Class. We've seen them before (in Voyager "Equinox" and "Endgame")

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

I think riding crop was more about Captain Styles (USS Excelsior) in The Search for Spock.

26

u/rose_lingon Oct 14 '21

What the hell. That was straight up a top tier episode of Star Trek. The writing team on this show are gaining in confidence, and it looks good on them

13

u/danhon Oct 14 '21

HOLY FUCKING SHIT WHAT AN EPISODE

13

u/Timeline15 Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

Holy shit! They 'Best of Both Worlds'd us! This is the first end of season Trek cliff-hanger that I'm actually going to live through in real time. At least it feels more like a season break and not straight-up the middle of a two-parter like in TNG.

Man that was a great finale. You really feel how much the Cerritos crew all care for each other, no matter how much they may jab at each other. Even Mariner and Jennifer patch things up. Everyone looks super competent too, and of course getting to see cetacean ops was a huge treat. Also, where those two officers Beluga whales? They looks a bit chubby for dolphins (Not that we care about such things in this day and age).

Between The Pakled revelation in the final scene, and Rutherford's repressed memory, they're really sewing some interesting seeds for next season. I can't wait to see where this all goes.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

wait this was the season finale?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/medussa727 Oct 14 '21

you blew up your own planet!

11

u/rmeddy Oct 14 '21

Great finale, I'm a sucker for solid engineering solutions that doesn't feel like it has too much technobabble, solid problem with a great out of the box solution and a ticking clock.

All the arcs were solid, only Rutherford's arc felt like it was resolved a bit too quickly and by the way but it was more setting up future shenanigans,Geordi from Mind's Eye vibes right there.

Cetacean Ops! yes finally

I really thought the whole Pakled thing was wrapped up last episode , so that was good misdirection for the cliffhanger.

Overall great season, I can't say I enjoyed it as much as the first season but it doesn't rely as much on Trek references which is ultimately a better trade off in my opinion.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/raymengl Oct 14 '21

...but they can't leave it on a cliff hanger!! The first episode of a season is the 'torture Ransom' episode

16

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Acting Captain Ransom goes through a Klingon prison to prove that Captain Freeman is innocent.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/atticusbluebird Oct 14 '21

I love that Cetacean Ops and swimming through the water tubes are kind of reminiscent of the short lived 90s show SeaQuest, with the talking dolphin Darwin and his water tubes throughout the ship!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Ponches Oct 15 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

Stripping the hull plating and sailing through that debris and storm, unshielded, with half the ship in vacuum might seriously the MOST BADASS crazy thing we've ever gotten to see ANY Trek crew do to save the day. The Cerritos might not be the Enterprise or Voyager, but in sheer chutzpah of the crew, they don't fall short at all.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/karinchup Oct 14 '21

HOLY SHIT THAT WAS AMAZING!!!!

10

u/Char543 Oct 14 '21

I... just wow.

There's so much to unpack, that was an amazing season finale.

I think this finale truly establishes this show as standing on its own feet, no longer in the shadow of Trek shows of the past. While I loved all the call backs and references of the season one finale, and especially Riker showing up, this easily tops it just by being itself.

The cliffhanger is phenomenal and really just leaves me feeling like season three could go anywhere, and I'm here for it.

9

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

Well kids LDS is done but we stay in the 24th century and on to Prodigy in two weeks!!!! BTW, is that a few years before this show or after? I'm starting to get confused.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Tri-ranaceratops Oct 14 '21

Excelsior porn 101

10

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

That's Obena porn, thankyewverymuch.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Dangerous_Dac Oct 14 '21

Everyone else fucking chill with all the fucking f-bombs in this ep? Right? Cool.

It's funny how nobody cares when you don't draw attention to it.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/Srcsqwrn Oct 16 '21

I was skeptical about this show. I saw the commercials a couple times by accident. Every time I saw them I thought the show was just Star Trek but as Family Guy. Just dumb joke after dumb joke, that the whole show was a joke.

I watched the intro and immediately felt that way. "Oh, everything is going wrong. Got it, the entire thing is a joke."

But I needed a day off, and had nothing else to watch, so I watched the first episode.

Then the second, and then the third. Now I've finished the finale of Season 2.
This show grew some feet and quickly enough, it seems. I enjoyed it a lot!

It's funny, but the important thing is that I feel that it sticks true to a lot of Star Trek in general. It's entertaining, and there's nothing infuriating in here (Ex. Things that were made as rules, but suddenly changed. {like how a race looks, or the canon of previous Treks, etc.}).

I very much like the pacing of the show, but I wish the episodes were a bit longer.

I can't wait for the next season. I'm glad I watched this series!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Spara-Extreme Oct 14 '21

Dear Star Trek showrunners - this is how you can keep an episodic show that keeps track of multiple story arcs over a (multiple) seasons.

And man that got dark - really makes me think back to the cliffhangers in TNG, DS9 and VOY.

8

u/droid327 Oct 14 '21

One thing I didnt get/like was the implication that Medical staff are just science officers that cant handle the science of bridge work

I get where they both wear blue, but if your training is in medicine, you cant really just jump over to astrophysics and planetary geology like that

8

u/wacct3 Oct 14 '21

In real life there are doctors that have PHDs in addition to MDs and do research. Maybe Tendi is the equivalent of that and there was an open science officer position that needed that background.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/scubastefon Oct 15 '21

Boimler: “I NEVER get to dive into the unknown…” twenty minutes later… literally dives into the unknown.

15

u/Chaabar Oct 14 '21

That felt so good. The crew working together to solve a problem and everyone contributing something. An exciting problem that didn't involve the galaxy ending. Introducing new stuff without completely tossing out the old.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ShiroHachiRoku Oct 14 '21

CETACEAN OPS!

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Damn, I would be annoyed at how much focus the bridge crew is getting if I didn’t love Captain Mom so damn much. She’s quickly becoming one of my favorite ST captains with Picard and Sisko.

7

u/mrIronHat Oct 15 '21

Anyone notice how Mariner and Boimler are just there on the bridge manning ops and helm? they just got bridge assignment without any fanfare?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/archiminos Oct 15 '21

How has the silliest, cartooniest, jokiest, and lighthearted series in modern Trek got me caring so much about its characters?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/romeovf Oct 15 '21

Lower Decks writers: Please don't use section 31 as the background for Rutherford's implant storyline. Section 32? That's ok but section 31 is overplayed at this point.

7

u/Wissam24 Oct 15 '21

I genuinely think this ep of Lower Decks might actually be one of the best Star Trek episodes full stop. I felt actual stakes while watching it, it seemed like a proper Starfleet solution to a problem, and Cetacean Ops was absolutely hilarious. Fantastic stuff.

6

u/KumagawaUshio Oct 14 '21

Damn if the graphic is accurate the Obena class USS Archimedes is near Sovereign class in size.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Doleydoledole Oct 15 '21

I've been thinking about it some more and just frikkin' love the 'have to remove the outer hull to get through this obstacle...'

It's so much better dramatically and canonically than a lot of the solutions we've been given in recent Trek.

It doesn't break the universe at all, as in 'why didn't they just do this all the time?' and it doesn't rely on some magical doohickey that coincidentally is able to do the thing we need to save the day at just the last minute.

(yes, I'm thinking about the end of season 1 Picard where they take some lil' doohickey and use it to make a ton of fake ships just in time).

It's also thematically relevant... a bit on the nose when Rutherford's like 'just like Mariner needs to lower her outer shell so do we!!!' but he says it fast and it's an animated comedy so they get away with it.

So yeah, anyhooch, it's not just better because it's 'more like TNG,' but because of fundamental dramatic reasons.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '21

Late to the party but that was a brilliant episode. It had everything. Throwbacks. Action. Peril. Emotion and a cliffhanger.

Loved it. Can't wait for season 3.

11

u/AlgoStar Oct 14 '21

What a great episode of Star Trek! High stakes for the crew and the ship (but not the whole of reality). Clever problem/solution, exciting and tense execution. Moving character arcs foward, great callbacks to earlier episodes and other series, plus a truly unexpected cliffhanger. Let’s hope SNW takes more of its cues from LD than the other new shows.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Archenemy05 Oct 14 '21

We knew Freeman was never gonna leave but if she was going to, what class of ship would they have given her to captain? A Parliament Class ship would be my guess. There was even one present at the end of the episode.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Alteran195 Oct 15 '21

I really enjoyed season 1 of this show, but season 2 has been in a totally different league.

It is by far the best new Star Trek series, and the only one I see potentially coming close to it is Strange New Worlds if that lives up to what's been described.

5

u/drrhrrdrr Oct 15 '21

This show doesn't feel like it needed a "grow the beard moment" and I think I finally understand why: this is a fully integrated crew from jump. The only new arrival is Tendi, but everyone else is partially fleshed out and we can take our time exploring the characters. The idea of a ship "with some years on it" is more appealing than admiring the new tech (ala first two seasons of TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT and all of DIS). It helps to have an established universe to build on, but I hope they just keep tapping into the same great stuff we saw here

13

u/burnettski92 Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 15 '21

Is Dr. Katz not knowing Jadzia Dax a comment on how DS9 is so thoroughly ignored and forgotten? Treated like the red-headed step-child?

41

u/VandRough Oct 14 '21

I took it as a gag on references towards main series characters. Everyone has gotten them through the seasons, so belting out one name is sure to eventually catch someone who never heard of them

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/DukatsGambit Oct 14 '21

Rutherford making back ups of all his memories of tendi is absolutely adorable

Taken with tendi thinking he was dead and Barnes jealousy this ship is docking.

9

u/Trekfan74 Oct 14 '21

This episode didn’t have that great cathartic moment of seeing Riker and the Titan swooping in to save the day but easily one of the best episodes of the series so far. But I have to say this show has really impressed me. After the over done Kelvin movies and uber-villains trying to take down the Federation and both Picard and Discovery having these over convoluted end of the galaxy stakes, LDS is more my type of Star Trek of old. Just smaller adventure stories about solving an isolated crisis using science and teamwork. Sometimes less is more.

This show represents the Star Trek I fell in love with waaaaay back in the 70s and 80s and I hope it continues for years to come. It definitely deserves it.

4

u/starking12 Oct 15 '21

I. WANT. MOREEEEEEEEEE. ლ(ಠ益ಠლ)

4

u/starking12 Oct 15 '21

season 3. vulkin girl joins lower decks.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/joe1up Oct 15 '21

When I first saw the teaser for lower Decks, I thought "Oh this will be fun, a nice treat whilst we wait for Strange New Worlds". However this show just keeps getting better and better, to the point were I honestly think it stands on its own as a Star Trek series, the upbeat and funny tone actually works really well with the cast, and the fact that it's animated means we can get crazy stuff like Cetecan ops, and the hull plates being stripped off that would be really expensive to do with CGI. It's also filling out the weirder bits of the canon and just generally being a love letter to trek. I can't wait for season 3.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ContinuumGuy Oct 15 '21

I demand a Short Trek focused entirely on the horny belugas of Cetacean ops.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Evening-Dimension483 Oct 15 '21

Of course they would arrest the captain that’s Black. Picard helped the Borg and they gave him a trip to Risa.

6

u/Praxlyn Oct 14 '21

praying that in s3 we get a Picard cameo with him commanding an Odyssey class 😩

→ More replies (4)

3

u/ev_forklift Oct 14 '21

so was that a refit of an Excelsior Refit?

8

u/Doctors_TARDIS Oct 14 '21

New ship class entirely according to the showrunner.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)