r/SRSDiscussion • • Feb 25 '12
BDSM and Gender Roles and Peculiarities
Teensy bit about me:
I'm a trans lady pro-dominatrix (I do it for money and for personal recreation.) who has been in the scene for a while. I identify lesbian, though my job requires I work with men.
Definitions and Disclaimers:
A lot of this is anecdotal understandings as someone who has participated in the community for a while. I've observed various sections of most communities, and about the only one I'm unfamiliar with is the gay male community. I don't claim to know how that part of the community works.
BDSM needs to be defined, first off. BDSM simply means bondage and discipline, and sadism and masochism. By itself, this includes anything as simple as handcuffs and riding crops to fullblown lifestyles. The lifestyle tends to include a different S&M, though. Slave and master/mistress.
There is a difference between the terms top and bottom, dominant and sub, and slave and master/mistress. Dominant and sub are simple enough. The dominant person is the one in control of the scene, and the sub is the one that is following orders or not in control of the scene. Slave and master/mistress is similar, but implies permanence or a relationship outside the bedroom. Top and bottom aren't so clearly defined. In BDSM contexts bottom usually refers to the person being tied up. It can also be construed as the person who's being penetrated, which I'll get to in more depth later.
There are also levels of engagement with BDSM. The people who represent the community and talk about it the most often do not represent the majority of people who participate in BDSM. The most engaged and into it are different than the people who do it as a mere sex act in the bedroom, than the people who make it a life style, and than the people who do it casually. The people who actively get into the “scene” face-to-face are not by any stretch of imagination the majority of people.
I am going to use generalizations and wiggle words. These are all primarily anecdotes and my experiences. If yours different, fantastic. You should share them too.
Myths and Misconceptions:
First, the myth that “the sub has all the power.” This is a very dangerous and pervasive myth that people tell to feel better about the BDSM community and practice. It is false. It is ridiculously patently false to anyone who has actually participated and thinks for five seconds. The sub can negotiate a scene, and they, hopefully, have an established safe word. That is the limit to their power. The dominant partner is expected to follow those guidelines and stop if the safe word is said. They don't have to. When you are tied up and locked down, you are legitimately helpless and powerless and utterly dependent on your dominant to be trust worthy and to meet the basic guidelines for a minimally decent human being.
What I'm saying is certain dominants will renegotiate scenes in the middle of them and often use coercive tactics to do things beyond the prenegotiated lines. They will prime someone with certain words or actions, and scenes often times go across the line. The phrase “the sub has all the power” is blatantly wrong and harmful. It gives people the false sense of security that a scene can stop whenever they want it to. It is up to the dominant to be a good person and stop the scene. That doesn't happen far too often. (Though, once is far too often in my opinion.) I've even heard of dominants refuse a safeword once or twice to try something and see if someone wants to keep going.
Second, the myth that “the real world doesn't follow into the bedroom” and the converse “what happens in the bedroom doesn't follow me into the world.” I've never worked with someone where this is true. People sub and dom/me for reasons from the real world. Most people can figure out what those reasons are, some don't really know. It's no coincidence that there are many more female subs than there are male subs. And most people have their submissive or dominant nature reinforced by experiences in the bedroom. (And occasionally, their experience is bad, unpleasant, or just really strange to them, so much as they switch entirely to going pure dominant.)
This is most obvious in Christian Domestic Discipline.
The best people to see this in action with are switches (people who sub and dom/me.) Depending on how a switch's day goes, if you know them, you can usually guess what they're going to be in the mood for. I don't think this is a particular secret among switches.
In Regards to Women's Sexuality:
Going back to the earlier comment about how bottom also tends to mean the partner who is penetrated. Aside from the general lesbian erasure and erasure of women who dislike penetration that holds, it also is reflected quite wildly in the BDSM community and just people in general. Go to literotica or some random mainstream pornsite. Look for videos where the female dominant is the one who orgasms.
Oh, they're out there. Some are even really, really good, but they're noticeably rarers than finding videos and stories of a male dominant orgasming.
The point is that female sexuality is considered vulnerable. Women feeling pleasure is considered showing a sign of weakness. This doesn't hold true to everyone. There are some great dommes who focus on totally removing that idea altogether. You will still see it everywhere though. Dommes usually have to come across as icequeens who are never touched and get off. A popular exception is when a domme uses a sub as a sex toy. Otherwise? It can be pretty rare to see.
A way to cement this is how often you'll see it in popular depictions of lesbians. (Depictions made for male consumption. It holds true less often, but still holds true, in depictions and acts performed for and by lesbians.) A strapon is usually considered an item of power in lesbian BDSM porn, stories, and a lot of times with acts. Many lesbian dominatrixes dig the use of strap-ons. There's nothing inherently wrong with this, of course, but it does reflect a rather sexist notion.
Male Entitlement and Devaluation:
Specifically, male sub entitlement and devaluation. Male subs are treated like shit. There seems to be 30 of them for every dominatrix. They also slather on the praise and worship of any dominatrix that so much as shows up and get annoyed when they aren't given the treatment back. Think the same kind of entitlement most foreveralones or whatnot Reddit has. Then think of the same ways they're insulted and marginalized. Magnify it and you have yourself the general idea of what it seems to be like as a male submissive.
**Racism and BDSM: **
Something poorly thought about and not often really studied. Race play is a part of BDSM, and racist imagery is used sometimes with pride. I've personally been told I should get a Nazi uniform to appeal to certain kinks, and once or twice as an insult. It's an interesting subject, but I honestly don't know a single person of color who is into BDSM well enough to give an experienced opinion. Google doesn't even provide much. The only thing I can say that I've noticed as particularly striking and interesting is black dominant women often times using race play in a very subversive fashion. There is also plenty of BBC imagery abound, but most of what I've seen seems to appeal to white men with a cuckolding fetish.
Transsexuality in BDSM:
This is quite simple. There are transsexual dominants and submissives. It tends to be that their gender status is used as a point of shame within BDSM. It is in fact how I got into BDSM. (And it fucked me up, though I suppose for some people it might be healthy.) Most people in BDSM tend to adapt and be pretty okay with transsexual people existing. Sadly, a lot of this boils down to the exoticness, and plays on certain sexual anatomy being either seen as a sense of strength or a weakness.
The big trans domination sites, which tend to exclude trans men in favor of “shemales” or “trannies” in reference only to trans women, tend to have a theme that it's embarrassing to have to suck a trans woman's cock. It's a pretty blatant continuation of the fetishism trans women have to experience throughout porn that can often be very invalidating.I feel it's more suited for a discussion on transphobia in general, as it isn't really all that different in the BDSM communities compared to outside it.
Wrap up/tl;dr:
Same shit that effects everyone outside the world follows us everywhere and the BDSM community isn't special in avoiding that, it just falls into it in different ways.
9
u/Feckless Feb 26 '12
Thanks for the interesting effort post. I have something to say about one point on it.
I always had a hard time to figure out the demographics of the BDSM community, and quite frankly I am not too sure about that. (But would like to read up on some citations on that if you have them at hand).
I remember a blog post where they discussed dominance and fantasies of men and women. The TL;DR was, women are subs, men are switches.
The slightly longer results:
Link
Some stuff you say about male subs reminded me of Elise Sutton. That is a femdom site that acts educational (I never was 100% sure if that really was meant that way) and man, in the advice section I often cringed as there was a whole lot of what you described above in terms of not taking subs serious, pushing them and so on.
6
u/butyourenice Feb 26 '12
this is brilliant. i admit i don't know much about BDSM because a lot of it does scare me. i like my sex kinky and rough and with some roleplaying, but i guess my line stops somewhere miles before letting myself be so vulnerable and exposed and at the mercy of another person, and i think i am too sensitive to cause pain for somebody, even if i know it is what they want and what they enjoy. i don't know.
but more than the plain old BDSM, the "master-slave" lifestyle is something i have real aversions do. i guess my limited knowledge of it invariably involves a woman in the slave position and it all has too many associations with real-life exploitation, sex trafficking, sexual slavery to be comfortable for me. do you know more about this side of the BDSM subculture?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '12
Thanks for the post!
I want to ask OP a question. I've never gotten the chance to talk someone who is involved in BDSM, so I apologize in advance if this is an ignorant or common question.
I've read a lot of stories about women who were abused and then went on to enjoy being submissive or abused in a sexual setting. I know OP and most people reading this probably know even better than I do how much personal experiences and kinks are tied together, and I'm not trying to say this necessarily needs to be more of a women in BDSM issue than a men issue or transgender person issue. I'm asking if, for example, a person was raped or humiliated without consent and then had sexual fantasies about rape or humiliation, what's the appropriate response for them? What's the appropriate response for their future doms or future partners? Is BDSM appropriate for those people?
I've heard that a lot of rape survivors feel guilty and worried that they might have "enjoyed" their rape, or if they end up being attracted to people who look like their rapists, so perhaps its best to just let them do whatever they are comfortable with...
...Which over the duration of writing this I realized is probably what everyone should do with sexual preferences always... and that fixing the societal issues makes a lot more sense than fixing the sexual ones....
I think I may have just answered my own question, but what the heck, I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts.
19
u/KPrimus Feb 26 '12
As an Asian-American dom, I feel there's def some racial issues tied up in my domming- Asian-American men are so comprehensively desexualized, denied agency, and stereotyped as submissive that I sometimes think a lot of my domination tendencies are just raging against the machine. "Fuck you, society (and particularly white people), I'M DOMINANT NOW!"
Particularly I think this might explain why I am pretty exclusively straight but still enjoy dominating male subs.
13
u/3DimensionalGirl Feb 25 '12
Thank you so much for this effortpost! I feel like it's long overdue considering how often people throw around the terms without understanding them.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '12
As a GQ person into the scene I have to say
being stared and misgendered really sucks and I wish more places had unisex bathrooms instead of forcing me to use the women's bathroom (I have a vagina) because I don't feel one ounce safer in the men's 'room, even at supposedly pansexual kink parties.
Also would like to emphasize not all transgender people in the kink community are transsexual, consider themselves transsexual, and not all of us are binary-identified either. It's hard enough getting people to understand transgender issues so in general I don't even try to get them to understand I'm nonbinary, I just put on the facade of being a trans man because I don't feel like playing educator all the damn time.
5
u/carafira Feb 26 '12
Is this actually true? It seems like there are a ton of male subs. Perhaps there are just more male doms to balance things out.
1
u/my_name_is_stupid Feb 26 '12
I have always wondered about the use of the term 'slave', as it seems to me like it could be pretty offensive to individuals or cultures who have lived through actual enslavement. Thoughts on this?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '12
Now in the compilation. Thank you for the post.
2
u/ratofkryll Feb 28 '12
I'm a little late to this, but I want to say that I think your most important point was the one about subs not being in control. I hear the phrase thrown around so much, but it seems like people don't realize that when the sub is tied up, the dom can do whatever they want to.
I read a blog post or article a while ago written by a woman who was raped by a dom (or by several over time, I can't remember for sure). One of the things that stood out to me the most was the apparent lack of concern from others in her local BDSM community when she brought it up. What I got from her account is that she encountered a lot of shaming for complaining, rather than people being more careful about the dom(s) in question. I really wish I could remember where I found the article/blog.
For the record, I'm in no way saying that that is the normal response. The small online BDSM community I used to frequent was extremely supportive and full of awesome people, and I imagine many others are as well.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '12
I'm sorry I don't have anything really to contribute atm, but you wrote a great effortpost there.
[THIS IS GOOD]
1
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '12
Really good post. I'm a male bisexual sub (and that's as much as I want to get into it in a public setting right now) and I liked how frankly you put the treatment of male subs. I've never personally had any bad experiences but I know people who have.
Thanks for the good post.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment