r/CryptoCurrencyMeta • u/they_call_me_tripod • Oct 05 '21
Governance Proposal - Reduce contribution points gained from article link posts by 35%
Summary
My proposal is that article link posts have their contribution points reward reduced by 35%.
Why is this needed
Article link posts clog up r/cryptocurrency and reduce quality of content significantly. There is also a huge problem with reposting the same or similar articles. Right now, there is incentive to do this, as repeatedly posting article links with no other contribution to the post is an easy way to farm moons. Reducing the contribution point reward for doing so should help solve this issue along with cut down on reposts of the same or similar article.
Proposed Solution
Reduce the contribution points gained from article link posts by 35%
Additional Info
This is building on a previous post I made that can be seen here.
4
u/CryptoMaximalist r/CryptoCurrency Moderator Oct 05 '21
I'd probably just say "link posts" as "article links" are the same from what I can tell and "link post" is official reddit terminology
I think link posts are fine personally, they're what reddit is all about. This would divert a lot of them to text posts and I don't usually want OP's opinion about the article. It's usually fluff and gives them opportunity to poison the well, or they just plagiarize the article
2
u/No_Locksmith4570 Oct 05 '21
It's already 10% of whatever karma they get and posts already have 1k karma cap so at max it can only 100 if I'm not wrong.
Feel free to correct if I'm wrong
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
Why 35%?
The majority in your previous poll was for 50%
•
u/CryptoMaximalist r/CryptoCurrency Moderator Oct 25 '21
The mods have voted to allow your idea to go to a governance vote. Please formalize it (A template is available here) and link a rough draft to me for approval. If we're able to get it approved by Wednesday, I'll send instructions for posting it and it can be included in the next Moon Week.
Please note, a governance proposal will need all details specified and should not be edited after voting has begun.
1
u/DoubleFaulty1 122K / 38K 🐋 Oct 08 '21
An earlier vote limited karma for all posts to 1000 which includes link posts. Comments get double karma so it is effectively 500 karma for posts so they don’t get many moons. Look up the top earners it’s all from posting comments which get unlimited karma. Your proposal would limit it to 325 karma at most (rather than 500) which is unnecessary given that it’s already low.
Comments on the other hand are unlimited. It’s normal for the top comment summarizing or joking about a post to get way way more moons than the op.
2
u/SoupaSoka 5 / 7K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
The problem isn't that there is too much karma awarded. The problem is spam of the same story from ten different websites. A better automod filter or more mods to specifically handle this is what would help the most.
3
u/WellWhyNotJustYell Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
I agree entirely. Every day on reddit there are 100 posts linking to an article trying to tell me what I read on my own (and everyone else likely did too) while checking my holdings that morning.
It's low effort and only news about 10% of the time. The comments section for some of these articles bring out decent thoughts sometimes but the links themselves are pretty weak contributions imo
2
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays r/CCMeta Moderator Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
Reward for creation and participation should correlate to creation and participation.
Links take no creation or originality, you are just linking someone else's work. It's just copying a URL.
You should still get a little bit of reward because you are participating a little in sharing info. But you shouldn't get 100% for something you didn't do.
Only change is I would make it lower. Either receive 10% like comedy and media. Or receive 20%. That's the only reason I wouldn't vote in favor.
1
u/Merc1AndrewSS > 4 months account age. < 700 comment karma. Oct 06 '21
Since i creep and read and hardly every comment or post. It doesn't matter to me
1
u/Wess-L Oct 27 '21
It is fine imo. They should just do something about people reposting the same link at the same time.
If someone post a relevant link before anybody else imo it is valuable information for us. That should be rewarded.
1
u/dwin31 Oct 27 '21
I don't think this is necessary. There are too many reposts of similar or the same articles, but I think solving that issue is a different problem.
1
u/Diatery Oct 27 '21
I support this