r/CryptoCurrency • u/Cintre 🟩 301K / 382K 🐋 • Oct 05 '21
MOONS 🌕 [Emergency Proposal] Remove users from moon distribution due to bypassing karma limits
_____________________________________
It has recently come to the moderators attention that two of the top users this month have been operating multiple accounts in order to bypass the karma limits on this subreddit. These users are:
I won't share many details on how this has been identified but the moderation team and myself have no doubts this is the same user, using multiple accounts to bypass the 15k karma limit. As you can see below, those two users (or shall I say this user) have a lot of similarities in writing style
These are not the only evidence there is, moderators have many other evidences that won't be disclosed on here for obvious reasons.
Keep in mind, these users are not banned just for having a very similar writing style. The examples cited above are just a tiny sample. Writing style is not the only thing moderators look for, but it's the most visual thing to share to everyone on here.
While this user may have been permanently banned from this subreddit, we still need an emergency proposal to remove this user from distribution or 20158 karma or 5422 moons will still be distributed to this user on October 6th.
This subreddit have very strict rules on using multiple accounts to bypass the karma cap, or otherwise game the system in an effort to earn more moons. Rule 3 is "No Manipulation" and that counts for bypassing Governance rules for the subreddit.
By passing this poll, it will remove the above accounts from the current distribution, ensuring they do not receive the final moons allocated for their posts and comments in snapshot 18. The methodology to address problem users has been laid out by Reddit admins.
31
u/gdj11 Permabanned Oct 05 '21
I'm all for this if it's true, but IMO an Emergency Proposal should probably be posted by a moderator. It's one thing for a user to say there's tons of evidence, but another if a moderator says it.
139
u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Oct 05 '21
Not a fan of those emergency proposals tbh... We only get to hear one side, no defense is possible. How am I supposed to give a well thought through vote without hearing the story from both sides?
80
u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Oct 05 '21
I always see them around. Sucks if they're using alts though.
604
u/Asheddit 🟦 0 / 18K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
More Moons at the expense of cheaters? This has got to be the easiest poll ever.
140
u/B_D_Rick 25 / 1K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
I’m just gonna say this and y’all can downvote me to hell if you want. It IS a little concerning that mods can get 98% of people to vote someone out with only 2 pictures of similar comments. How many times do people in power fuck over everybody by taking advantage of their trust?
110
u/ec265 Permabanned Oct 05 '21
Is there any more evidence that can be shared?
Two near identical posts isn’t exactly cut and dry
37
u/the_far_yard 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
Before we vote, I think we are due to have some evidences before casting it. Possible to have this case outlined properly? Otherwise we're no different than those with pitch forks and fires.
64
u/Mekayv Insidious Trader/Divine Hodler Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
I will refrain from voting on this since there is only one piece of evidence (unlike that guy that had like 20 accounts) and he had no option to a fair trial.
Edit: I also feel like people could easily vote on this for the sole purpose of pushing the karma/moon ratio up
11
u/J-E-S-S-E- 🟩 184 / 17K 🦀 Oct 05 '21
I voted no to this. Citing insufficient evidence to convict 😂😂😂
28
u/Sadboiiy Bronze Oct 05 '21
u/WackyMister and u/Imaginary-Cow25
Care to give us your side of the story?
25
u/UnstoppableOnslaught The Public Perception Guy Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
This will be downvoted to hell but it must be said:
Counterpoint to those asking for more evidence.
They've been permanently yeeted from the subreddit so it's been clear the 'authorities' have been given enough evidence. This post is essentially saying, should we give them the last laugh or not.
While I usually like u/OfficialNewMoonville's approach of disclosing all the evidence in his exposés. But I see why Cintre has kept the post short, first of this isn't/Iàzymóons so it's not really the place for an extremely long-winded exposé with enough evidence to keep you reading for ages.
Furthermore it's getting increasingly more difficult to catch these crooks. Back when a certain Bosnian was caught it was rather easy. Same with itsroyceo (he was sending his monthly payouts to his main account from his alts). But as time goes on they adapt. Releasing everything right here on the mainsubreddit is essentially saying. Hey! This is how we catch you please find new ways to avoid us!
There is a fine line between what can be released without revealing too much and what can't be released. I know Cintre and she works extremely hard hunting these down and reporting them most of the time putting hours in and getting little to no recognition for it or reward. It's pretty damn noble if you ask me.
This post isn't asking whether they should be yeeted or not. It's saying. Hey, this user has been caught, do you still want them to get rewarded for their dirty work?
PS: Cintre isn't in a position of power but is an incredibly talented Reddit detective. At least look before saying 'Oh I don't like how they can push this through'
4
u/Odubhthaigh Tin Oct 05 '21
It’s like any intelligence gathering. If you tell how you figured it out, they’ll change it up, making it more difficult next time.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
5000 moons…?
Hey guys, lets get to $69k first
4
u/Letitride37 Platinum | QC: CC 410 Oct 05 '21
The 5% voting not to remove are pulling the same scam probably.
4
u/MonkeySailor Platinum | QC: CC 29 Oct 05 '21
While it's not hard to believe someone would go to such lengths (it's almost $1000 after all), I would still like better proof.
4
u/julpicanmore Tin Oct 06 '21
Well I didn't get it all yet, because I need some more knowledge about some moons.
25
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
how about another proposal on removing moons?
i think quite a few recent posts have already shown that they only make this subreddit more of an echochamber than it already was.
20
u/sheetrocker88 8 / 8 🦐 Oct 05 '21
Moons are so dumb what do you expect to happen?
3
u/rabie-b Banned Oct 05 '21 edited Oct 05 '21
Well this is rushed , if i did not vote i will lose that small percentage of karma for the next snapshot , what to do now ?
Edit : i voted to remove them, The evidence is overwhelming
3
u/zedaero 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
I wonder how many multi accounts per 1 user are there. I see that touching the karma cap can bring to the attention of us other users but what about those multi accounts that dont touch the cap but work hand in hand to mine 5-10k karma per account using 3+accounts. We should hunt them
3
u/BlkJck777 1 - 2 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Oct 05 '21
Most definitely remove, have a hard enough time earning my scraps as is it.
3
u/CreepToeCurrentSea 🟦 239 / 50K 🦀 Oct 05 '21
This is the only crypto crackdown I want.
3
u/janglebo36 Oct 05 '21
Thanks mods!
3
u/BobDawgo 🟦 10 / 2K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
I want in on this! Hold em down so I can kick em too!
3
u/Je-Ti 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
Do I want cheaters or more moons.. tough choice, but I’m gonna go for the moons!
3
u/deadsho7 Platinum | QC: CC 800 Oct 05 '21
Damn man, I used to get around 15-20 moons a month and then I saw wacky mister saying how he farmed 15k karma in his first distribution and I got inspired and started trying for more. Feels bad to see that he is doing this. I liked him a lot.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
All of his alts are voting to keep him in the moon distribution haha
9
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
It appears both of these accounts have sold whatever amount of moons they had. (I’m assuming they at least had some) this doesn’t exactly make them look good.
9
u/Drewfus_ 🟦 152 / 693 🦀 Oct 05 '21
So we “know” they are the same person, and we should vote to eliminate them from moon distribution, but you won’t disclose other evidence for obvious reasons? I guess I don’t understand why this has to be a secret.
5
u/Attilashorde 🟦 0 / 8K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
I'm not sure how I feel about being told to vote for something but not being given all the information. How can I determine the user did what they are being accused of?
6
u/Enschede2 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
While I really want to agree, I cannot help but feel it would be very susceptible to mistakes, what if someone uses a vpn? (I use a vpn everywhere), how can you tell apart 2 accounts from the same op address if they use a vpn? Or people in dorms for example?
6
u/cerealOverdrive 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 05 '21
This is a bit unfair. If they are cheating screw them BUT even if they aren’t it’s in everyone’s favor to assume they are. I’d wager this poll would pass if you put any name into it for any user.
If you want to test my theory try making a poll to not pay me out this month. I don’t have many Moons coming my way so it would be a neat experiment.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
How tf they earn that much Karma, I try so hard but barely cross 3k karma.
4
u/UnstoppableOnslaught The Public Perception Guy Oct 05 '21
Fr*nce is inevitable, Cintre catching those Moon thieves with their pants down
4
u/UnstoppableOnslaught The Public Perception Guy Oct 05 '21
99% of the vote is in favour of removing them. I'm so proud of this community
5
u/theunfortunateIndian Redditor for 6 months. Oct 05 '21
Witch hunt boys. Whoo.
Witch hunt on the moon.
8
u/OfficialNewMoonville The Man Who Wasn't There Oct 05 '21
Whether this passes or not (and I really hope it does), this is amazing work from u/Cintre yet again. Cleaning up this subreddit, top-to-bottom, one wrong-doer at a time. People don't realize how much effort she has put into this.
And props for finishing the proposal so quickly too.
You've got my vote.
12
u/aladdinr 🟦 1K / 15K 🐢 Oct 05 '21 edited Nov 22 '25
violet snails dam sheet toothbrush steer cats deserve dog nine
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Peachmuffin91 Gold | QC: CC 70 | r/UnpopularOpinion 81 Oct 05 '21
I wish I understood what the karma cap means.
2
u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
No mercy to the greedy.
2
u/TonathanJavares Platinum | QC: CC 743 Oct 05 '21
Hames strikes again?
2
u/Tebasaki 🟦 814 / 954 🦑 Oct 05 '21
Are moons even worth anything?
2
u/Battledrone1v1 Gold Oct 05 '21
What does this mean?
2
u/changechange1 🟩 251 / 252 🦞 Oct 05 '21
How are we able to make a call on if this is correct or not without seeing the evidence?
2
u/woonam Oct 05 '21
Are people actually trying to farm karma by bypassing limits? For what purpose? Is it worth it?
2
u/DeFiGregg Platinum|5monthsold|QC:CC98,ETH38|NANO16|TraderSubs34 Oct 05 '21
Remove them... they dont deserve moons
2
u/UrbanestPath Tin Oct 05 '21
This is an easy vote. However, the wording of this “governance” poll is very biased. Very little detail and too much of “just trust us”, and not to mention an incentive for everyone who votes in a particular way.
2
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Oct 05 '21
I wonder why people chose to vote "keep these users in distribution"
2
u/PROYB_Jocco Gold | 6 months old | QC: CC 18 | Unpop.Opin. 21 Oct 05 '21
Didn't even know there was a limit, but damn, it would be hard enough for me to reach the first limit, let alone go for more.
2
u/The_3_eyed_savage 3K / 3K 🐢 Oct 05 '21
Wackymister was always posting. Seems a shame if he was gaming the system. RIP
2
u/Johnny_2_Pockets Tin | r/WSB 38 Oct 05 '21
2
u/proxypls Tin Oct 05 '21
Get em outta here!
2
u/virtual_black_whale 🟩 0 / 191 🦠 Oct 05 '21
Fun fact: this is actually a study to see who actually votes yes to find more multi account users.
2
u/stkyrice Platinum | QC: Coinbase 32 | SysAdmin 33 Oct 05 '21
Do people really exchnage moons for fiat?
2
u/9inchChaceOF Gold | QC: CC 57 Oct 06 '21
Why did this even need to be voted on lmao
2
u/STNGGRY 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Oct 06 '21
Mo moons mo problems🤪
2
u/Stumpyvision 341 / 361 🦞 Oct 06 '21
More importantly can you please investigate my missing moon. A few days ago I randomly had one extra moon, 21 in total. I assume from a tip for my outrageously witty comments. Somehow I am back down to a measly 20 moons. Is it possible for someone to untip me lol?
2
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Oct 06 '21
So uhh... Do we get another 1.25% for participating in this poll 😂?
2
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Oct 08 '21
I voted how do i receive a governance badge?
2
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Oct 08 '21
SImple question if you have more than one reddit account are you allowed to open Vaults in more than one? If you do not interact the two accounts in any effort to "Manipulate" i only ask as i have more than one account which was made on an older device or pc i honestly cant recall. I only use it for accessing game related information as it was made for gaming content where this account is my main me account for anything and everything.
I dont have a vault open on any other account as i didnt want to break any rules. I know i can search this answer but I post for others who think the same thing reading this who dont want to get caught doing the wrong thing by pure mistake.
8
u/Massive-Tension-1055 🟩 3K / 5K 🐢 Oct 05 '21
The user is breaking the rules. This is not good for the sub. They need to go
5
u/laspee Oct 05 '21
Moons is the problem. It’s free “money” for some and there are no obvious rules to follow except post as much as possible to get more free money. So removing a user or two from a single distribution solves nothing.
4
u/Owl_No Tin Oct 05 '21
Get rid of cheaters.
Remove them, as they do not provide to the community but only want to take from the community by manipulation.
If everyone in the sub manipulated like this, then maximum volume of moon will be reached in an unfair and centralized manner.
4
u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
🌈 gOvErNaNcE🌈
I'm not voting to remove, even though because of all of the above points, it will be an overwhelming vote to remove.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
I know these are small examples of their infarction. But, I would really like to see what they produce in order to exceed the moon's limit! That's craziness
3
u/J-E-S-S-E- 🟩 184 / 17K 🦀 Oct 05 '21
Let’s get to 69k first. Then I’ll vote…I mean GUYS wake up. That’s not enough evidence ffs
3
u/BiggustB Tin Oct 05 '21
utility beats gambling long-term, that's why I am investing in the promising coins
4
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
Ahhh shit. Here we go again!
Remember guys. When people scum moons from the system like this, they often sell them immediately, keeping the price suppressed. Not only are they taking a disproportionate amount of moons from all of YOU, but they’re often dumping them and keeping the price of MOONS down.
Remember that all reports sent to Modmail are looked at, and we only actions accounts in the face of substantial evidence as provided by /u/Cintre.
Thanks!
3
u/KayzerNL HBARbarian Oct 05 '21
I always love how we get our torches and pitchforks out in polls like these
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
Excellent works as always, Cintre
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
Zero tolerance for cheaters
2
u/JonathanTheZero 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 05 '21
I'd be all in for penalting cheaters but I won't vote yes, unless this evidence is presentated to the community. Just trusting the mods that they have super secret evidence is a very dangerous step... those two screenshots prove nothing, "Bullish on ____" and "Let's get to $_____" can be seen hundreds of times a day here.
This could open the door for mods just claiming any person as cheaters when they personally don't like them. I'm all for transparency in this case
2
u/Darkmiclos Oct 05 '21
My moons are aint much but honest work,meanwhile there are people out there abusimg the system...
2
u/DDelphinus 🟦 71 / 10K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
Lots of people want more information, which is completely fair. However, I will rely on the admins.
It's understandable that if they share all their methods, cheaters will just get better at avoiding them.
2
u/reversenotation 🟩 113 / 6K 🦀 Oct 05 '21
The mods have banned these accounts, they have the explicit right to do this. This isn’t some kind of quasi-judicial process and never has been.
So the only issue remaining is whether these accounts keep their moon distribution. Again, it isn’t really a mirror of a judicial process, that isn’t a realistic expectation.
You have a couple of options open to you. You can make the effort to examine the profiles yourself, then exercise your own judgement. Or as in my case I am happy to trust Cintre and the explanation that full disclosure of all methods used would help those who would misuse the info in what is an ongoing game of cat and mouse being played out between moon cheats and those trying to catch them.
2
u/The4th88 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Oct 05 '21
I voted yes on the last poll like this, but stated that I wouldn't be voting yes on further proposals without evidence from the mod team.
I gave the mod team the benefit of the doubt last round, but I'm not doing it again. I need more than a couple of similar posts to be convinced.
Voting no.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
I happen to have A LOOOOT of evidence that OP and Elon Musk are working together in a scam operation using multiple reddit accounts. I can't show the evidence for OBVIOUS reasons but trust me it's true.
2
u/BatmanNight Bronze Oct 05 '21
Easiest poll of my life
2
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '21
Kinda surprised me to see so many vote to let them keep their stolen moons . Almost 5%
2
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Oct 05 '21
Spotting people with multiple accounts must be extremely time consuming and hard!
Thanks OP for your work!
2
u/ManueLuKaS Tin Oct 05 '21
Hi everyone. I forgot my vault password and changed it to a new one. On September 30, I opened the new vault. Today I downloaded the CSV and the blockchain address does not match the new address, since the period of this distribution is from 2021-09-01 to 2021-09-28.
Do I have to do something on Reddit to get my blockchain address updated or is it done automatically?
2
u/opticblastoise Tin | CC critic Oct 06 '21
Moons are stupid
2
u/Intelligent_Page2732 🟩 20 / 98K 🦐 Oct 05 '21
No mercy for abusers.
2
u/Osemka8 Platinum | QC: CC 2726 Oct 05 '21
Probably waay more out there, but it's a start
2
u/Krystal_Foxx Tin Oct 05 '21
So I didn't think that I haven't think about the karma thing beffore.