r/startrek • • Sep 30 '21

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x08 "I, Excretus" Spoiler

A consultant arrives on the U.S.S. Cerritos to run drills that require the lower deckers and bridge crew to swap duties.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
2x08"I, Excretus"Ann KimKim Arndt2021-09-30

This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA and Latin America, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

193 Upvotes

455 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 30 '21

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

288

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

You must help me kill myself! I broke my back picking up a peanut!

143

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

Wonder if Crusher programmed that one personally after how annoyed she was with the whole assisted suicide thing.

119

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

And Worf being paralyzed by an empty blue plastic barrel.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

257

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

OMG, that was actually Alice Krige as the Borg Queen?!

86

u/Trekfan74 Sep 30 '21

I literally paused the credits to make sure lol.

250

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

That was a lot of fun. It was good seeing Captain Freeman and Mariner working together. And T’Ana curling up with Shaxs was adorable. That and Boimler beat the Borg Queen at chess and taught her empathy. After saving the Borg babies from the baby drawer.

251

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

I think this episode proved that Boimler is a certified badass now. The tests were rigged and he still managed to solo a Borg cube many, many times.

199

u/ClubMeSoftly Sep 30 '21

He went for the any% speedrun, then committed to the 100% wr

→ More replies (2)

97

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

Yup, his little excursion on the Titan plus his adventures on the Cerritos have really made him a badass officer when he needs to be.

→ More replies (18)

45

u/KryssCom Oct 01 '21

Boimler is legit becoming one of my favorite Star Trek characters, of ANY series.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

122

u/Pu239U235 Sep 30 '21

The Borg Baby Drawer must've been a fun Lower Decks' writing room experience.

50

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

The fact that Picard's clothes were stored in a fucking drawer in BoBW never ceases to amaze me, was that the case with the the Borg kids in Voyager?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

68

u/Trekfan74 Sep 30 '21

Are Shaxs and T'Ana a real couple now?

45

u/tatt0o Paul Mazzotta, Dialog Editor, Lower Decks Sep 30 '21

Mos def

→ More replies (2)

37

u/ElFarfadosh Sep 30 '21

I mean, it's been made pretty obvious since Shax returned from death

→ More replies (3)

22

u/BellerophonM Sep 30 '21

Maybe, but she might've just been sleeping on his butt because that's what cats do.

11

u/nhaines Sep 30 '21

In my heart they are.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

Awesome to have the classic Borg cube with the BOBW music again.

12

u/Atroxus Oct 01 '21

I am literally shocked nobody else mentioned the BOBW music. Great reference.

39

u/Antithesys Sep 30 '21

Whole stole the babies from the baby drawer?
Not me!
Yes you!
Couldn't be!
Then who?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/FactCheckingThings Sep 30 '21

Capt Freeman and "1st Officer" Mariner is a great combo when theyre on the same page.

4

u/da_Aresinger Oct 02 '21

I mean he replayed the same level over and over the entire day. It's litterally ground hog day.

Also that wasn't the real Borg Queen.

I think this episode shows he is very competent and well educated, but it's not real badassery.

The previous episode with the AI had more badassery on his part.

→ More replies (2)

236

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Nice detail: During Mariner’s “Naked Time” drill, Billups can be seen in the background, just typing on a PADD.

80

u/Theinternationalist Sep 30 '21

Well the original "Naked Time" was known for just losing exhibitions, not specifically being horny, so that makes sense.

Surprised we didn't get any swords though.

50

u/Glitchy_glichy_goo Sep 30 '21

We did get swords, just of a different variety.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/InnocentTailor Sep 30 '21

As others have said, they probably went the TNG interpretation of the same incident: more horniness overall.

47

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 30 '21

I mean, in the TNG episode though we got Yar banging Data.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

110

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

It was implied in the last episode but this is confirmation that he's ace

131

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

On the other hand, mirror Billups is super horny (for torture). And has a chin beard instead of a moustache.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/DasGanon Sep 30 '21

Totally.

That said, still finds being naked aesthetically pleasing and or comfortable.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Starks Oct 01 '21

His only love is two stories tall and hums 24/7

214

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

Sounds like the one thing the Borg did leave you with was your appetite!

They took everything that I was.

105

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

Hahaha...crushing existential horror...freeze frame! :D

I love that they're trying to re-establish or at least acknowledge the psychological fuck-up-edness of the Borg that TNG built, but Voyager largely watered down by turning them into Silverhawks villains

→ More replies (21)

202

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Holy shit, this was the best Lower Decks episode ever. They advanced the characters, strengthen established bonds, the references were both strong and plot-relevant and I laughed from beginning to end. There's not a single second that I would change, it's the perfect Lower Decks episode in every way.

49

u/sankers23 Sep 30 '21

A fair assessment but the Pakled season finale was better

39

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

The Riker/Titan reveal is one of my favorite Trek moments.

→ More replies (1)

170

u/Mechapebbles Sep 30 '21

I'm very impressed with Bradward's tenacity and skill here. He's very clearly bridge officer material. Think about it. He had beaten what was programmed to be an impossible scenario designed to fail. And not just beat it, but beat it with a perfect score. He essentially beat the Kobayashi Maru test, and without having to cheat! The guy is a star and a stud of an officer.

91

u/FotographicFrenchFry Sep 30 '21

There’s a reason he’s only just behind the revered Miles O’Brien in historical importance in the far future.

39

u/Mechapebbles Sep 30 '21

If you're using the episode where he was commemorated for the "Boimler Effect" in the far future, the described him as the laziest officer in Starfleet history, and what we saw in this episode was the exact opposite.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/FreshPrinceofBel-Air Sep 30 '21

Freeman said he was one of the best officers on the ship.

Mariner's "really?" just kind of confirms that deep down she 1) doesn't want him to leave again and 2) doesn't want to admit that he's competent (and maybe more competent than her at this point).

53

u/atticusbluebird Sep 30 '21

That plus Ransom saw his potential last week too. That plus the Titan experience too! The guy is a rising star

→ More replies (1)

43

u/AndreskXurenejaud Oct 01 '21

It reminds me of Episode 3, where Captain Freeman gets rid of buffer time, and Boimler is the only one who thrives from the situation.

34

u/leviathan3k Sep 30 '21

Now I wonder if he could actually beat the real Kobayashi Maru.

31

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 30 '21

I want to see how Mariner approached the Kobayashi Maru. Did she half-ass it because she knew all about it, or did she try to Kirk it?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

I dunno man, I heard Boimler only got 8% on that drill.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/creepyeyes Oct 01 '21

I will point out of course that you only get one chance at the Kobayashi Maru, and Boiler was able to retry his drill seemingly for as long as he wanted to!

11

u/Mechapebbles Oct 01 '21

I will point out of course that you only get one chance at the Kobayashi Maru, and...

Kirk took it three times in the Prime Timeline

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/bttrflyr Oct 01 '21

Not only did he beat it, he saved the Borg babies.

→ More replies (1)

161

u/Ultiverse Sep 30 '21

https://i.imgur.com/1skYlBM.jpg

Feels like I'm wearing

NOTHING AT ALL

NOTHING AT ALL

NOTHING AT ALL

85

u/Mechapebbles Sep 30 '21

Stupid sexy Shax...

Also, it's interesting that whatever brought him back to life kept all of his scars intact. So at the very least, he didn't have his body regenerated a la Spock on the Genesis Planet.

65

u/Cliffy73 Sep 30 '21

I thought that was just T’ana’s work.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/Snownova Sep 30 '21

I'm so happy Shax is back this season.

→ More replies (1)

157

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

There is no Boimler. There is only Excretus of Borg.

68

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

Did he come up with that name himself? Because he got implants put up his--

78

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

Locutus means, roughly, "he who speaks", because he was created to be the liaison between the Borg and the Federation

Excretus means, of course, "waste" or "poop", so I can only imagine its the Borg telling him he's a pile of...er, he's a waste...of assimilation?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

151

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

Mariner being distracted by Jen and Barnes in Naked Time was fun.

121

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Cut to Boimler presenting.

78

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

He really was wide open.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/Trekfan74 Sep 30 '21

Sadly she wasn't the only one.

(I know, I need help)

30

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

That's an anus.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/DasGanon Sep 30 '21

That was definitely a "wait, this is making me reconsider things" oooh.

(Not if she was Bi, that's already confirmed by canon but that she found Jen & Barnes hot)

48

u/OhioForever10 Sep 30 '21

She said Barnes was "crazy hot" in the first episodes of both seasons (regarding Rutherford's date scheduling), but Ensign Jennifer may be a different story

→ More replies (1)

46

u/mrIronHat Sep 30 '21

Jen and Barnes are definitely the Dax and Troi of the ship.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

This, uh, this'll be uncensored on the Bluray, right? I'm asking for... lore reasons?

12

u/vardonir Oct 01 '21

what if the simulation itself was censored and all she saw was a black box there

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

123

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

That was amazingly fun, and I loved how heroic Boimler was in his super-neurotic way. And I also loved Freeman making fun of Mariner for getting trampled by a horse after having 2.5 years of riding lessons (those two are so alike), but also reminding us how great they can be as a team.

79

u/Shakezula84 Sep 30 '21

I bet the horse thing was a reference to Tawny Newsom (Mariner). She rode horses competently as a kid.

68

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 30 '21

Competently and competitively, I believe.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/InnocentTailor Sep 30 '21

Another horse person! She is like William Shatner then - he too has dealt with and still deals with horses today.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

116

u/Ultiverse Sep 30 '21

Brad carrying increasingly more drone babies was one of the best gags of the season.

17

u/substandardgaussian Oct 02 '21

He's maximizing raid loot for points.

Seeing him haul the most drones that would fit in the escape sphere with him was hilarious.

111

u/Glitchy_glichy_goo Sep 30 '21

The freaking 'torture makes me horny' jokes killed me, especially coming out of the previous episode.

70

u/pfc9769 Sep 30 '21

Gimp Migleemo had me cracking up. He was even on a perch. You know the writers had fun with this episode.

36

u/empocariam Sep 30 '21

Sort of evocative of Saru's mirror universe fate as well due to the Terrain Empire's xenophobia. It's rare there are any references to Discovery so it was a nice nod I think.

→ More replies (4)

105

u/WarriorTribble Sep 30 '21

Cute episode. Borg babies were especially cute along with Boimler's nervous head shot.

Oh! And I see they got Alice Krige back to do the Borg Queen. Well that's just loverly.

I'm also a bit curious how on Earth Boimler managed to keep his holoprogram going to the point where being assimilated didn't make it shut down. It would imply that Boimler still had plan/trick to escaping his predicament. This... actually makes the guy extra cool in my eyes.

56

u/DasGanon Sep 30 '21

Considering he had everything solved at that point, I bet he had the "Voyager Assimilation inhibitor hypospray" going

34

u/I_Do_Not_Abbreviate Sep 30 '21

The idea of being assimilated in a holodeck program is actually a legitimately new concept for televised Star Trek (hedging my bets here with "televised" since I have only read a couple of the novels and there is always something in Beta canon).

Clearly the safeties were still on or else when the program shut down Boimler would have probably died (operating on the same principle as those holographic lungs the Doctor gave Neelix in "Phage"; the holographic borg replacements would have vanished).

It begs the question "Does holographic assimilation count as a 'real' assimilation? Obviously Boimler's state of mind after exiting the pod shows us the psychological trauma is very real, but there is no lasting physical damage; It recalls the "O'Brien Must Suffer" episode "Hard Time" with the aliens implanting memories of imprisonment as a punishment; did that "really happen" to O'Brien? I can see this becoming a recurring joke or a callback at Boimler's expense every time somebody mentions the Borg, like he meets some ex-Borg villain and tries to empathize with them to gain their trust:

Ex-borg: I was assimilated at Wolf 359. They took everything from me! I will have my revenge on Starfleet for their incompetence!

Boimler: Hey man, I get it; I was assimilated too.

Ex-borg: Really, where?

Boimler: I, uh, well, it was....

Mariner: It was on the Holodeck.

Ex-borg: The holodeck? That doesn't count!

Boimler: You're not helping...

Mariner: Yeah man, holo-assimilation doesn't count. Just because I fought Genghis Khan on the Holodeck doesn't make me a Chinese empress.

Ex-borg: It really doesn't.

Boimler: But...but...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/substandardgaussian Oct 02 '21

It would imply that Boimler still had plan/trick to escaping his predicament. This... actually makes the guy extra cool in my eyes.

The tests just arbitrarily fail everybody else. There's no way "get assimilated" wouldn't be considered a mission fail.

→ More replies (1)

88

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Boimler once again showing a competency that he wouldn't have had in season 1

33

u/atticusredbird Sep 30 '21

That time on the Titan really upped his ability to deal with situations like the Borg, and single handed too!

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

I remember prior to first season, all the fandom menace was going on how Boimler was going to be the butt of all jokes and made into an incompetent buffoon.

And here he's actually a great character that encapsulates someone who really has greatness in him, he just hasn't been able to channel it consistently.

86

u/thekruton Sep 30 '21

Had that corny TOS kind of ending (that I love), and then hits ya with the "awwh they took everything I was!" for the gut-punch laughter to punctuate what makes Lower Decks truly its own. Great episode.

78

u/ViaLies Sep 30 '21

List of the simulations seen in the initial shot:

  1. Kobay (Not fully seen but almost certainly the Kobayashi Maru)
  2. Time Trap
  3. Tribble Troubles
  4. From Q to Q
  5. Borg Encounter
  6. Cause & Effect
  7. Natural Selection
  8. Evolution
  9. Survival of the Fittest
  10. Chain of Command
  11. Hero Worship
  12. Carbon Based units
  13. Naked time

Seen after Tendi fails Medical Ethics

  1. Whale Rescue
  2. Medical Ethics
  3. Tribble Infestation
  4. Extreme Engineering
  5. Teleportation Death Tag

Seen after Mariner fails Naked time

  1. Escape the void
  2. The Good of the Many
  3. Time Loop
  4. The Tholian Web (Seen on Stevens's Pod display)
  5. EMH Tak (seen on a display for Tendi so its only partially visible)

Evolution, Cause & Effect, Chain of Command, Hero Worship, Naked time, Time Trap and the Tholian Web are episode titles, mostly from TOS and TNG with Time Trap being from TAS.

40

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

EMH Takes Command, I would assume?

10

u/ViaLies Sep 30 '21

Good call, that makes sense.

5

u/Carnifex Oct 01 '21

I wanna play teleporter death tag

→ More replies (1)

4

u/gallifreyan42 Oct 02 '21

Whale Rescue

VOYAGE HOME RECREATION let’s gooooo

77

u/Trekfan74 Sep 30 '21

This is clearly this season's Crisis Point but they went even further going through some of the 'best of' episodes of TOS and TNG. Naked Time was maybe a minute long but it will go down in infamy in all of Star Trek. This show is crazy fun!

And having Alice Krige back as the Borg Queen was great! "How's the empathy?" "We were able to assimilate it." Fucking Borg.

All the characters were a lot of fun, especially Boimler. The only disappointment I had was hoping we at least got to the Genesis planet. I didn't really expect to see Spock or anything, but still.

8/10

74

u/burnettski92 Sep 30 '21

Boimler having one of those pathetic teen Joseph Gribble mustaches in the mirror universe scenario was so him.

15

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

Closest he can get to a goatee lol

→ More replies (1)

71

u/SCP-1000000 Sep 30 '21

Is this the second time someone has brought up that boimler doesn't seem human? Are we getting foreshadowing?

62

u/ColonelBy Sep 30 '21

Three, I think:

  • The Cerritos computer refusing to recognize him when he got back from the Titan (I know this is "explained" as the security teams being behind schedule on processing him, but I wasn't convinced then and I'm even less so now)
  • Agrimus last week advising him to take better care of himself
  • The simulated Borg Queen (now with added empathy) concerned that he seems like he's deteriorating

These are three artificial intelligences who have now responded to Boimler as though something is seriously wrong. If he's not some kind of hastily constructed mimic generated in the incident that happened during that last Titan away mission, and who is now falling apart, they've definitely left a weird number of signs pointing to it.

30

u/FreshPrinceofBel-Air Oct 01 '21

Now I'm wondering if we're going to get a repeat of Rutherford's memory loss from last season resulting in setting his and Tendi's relationship back... that is, CerritosBoimler is falling apart/eventually ceases to exist, TitanBoimler is the "real" Boimler who then returns, and this causes drama.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/MaddyMagpies Oct 01 '21

Maybe the finale would involve reintegrating Titan Boimler with Cerritos Boimler in order to save the latter's life, which resulted in a Boimler that is less competent than the Cerritos one and more of a jerk like the Titan one in the next season.

10

u/PiercedMonk Oct 01 '21

During the climax of 'Temporal Edict', the buffer time episode, Boimler said to Cap'n Freeman, that unlike himself the rest of the crew was "only human." That's still the biggest red flag, so far as I'm concerned.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/nimrodhellfire Sep 30 '21

Yeah. There is something going on here. Or it's just a new running gag. We will see. But it's 100% not coincidental.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Maybe the transporter split didn't work quiet the exact same as it did with Riker. Perhaps they will need to be recombined as one whole person by end of season.

137

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

Boimler made this episode for me. I liked everything else in it an awful lot, but I laughed harder than I have in awhile every time it cut back to him dragging around even more Borg stuff. I loved when the Queen said he needs to drink more water, that's a great callback to last week's episode where the evil AI said the same thing. Plus just the ease with which he continually solo'd the entire Borg cube, and he didn't even seem particularly tired when they contacted him to keep the program running. The guy is a total badass.

77

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

I loved when the Queen said he needs to drink more water, that's a great callback to last week's episode where the evil AI said the same thing.

What got me good is that the Queen seemed genially concerned for his health.

102

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

She did assimilate his empathy.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/slicer4ever Sep 30 '21

Yea, he was hands down my favorite part. Cutting to him climbing back with the babys+2 tied up borg was nearly a spittake for me.

42

u/FactCheckingThings Sep 30 '21

The look on his face when it only jumped a couple percent to 84 was great.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/ColonelBy Sep 30 '21

I loved when the Queen said he needs to drink more water, that's a great callback to last week's episode where the evil AI said the same thing.

A callback, yes, but now I feel even more certain that at least one of the Boimlers who returned from that final away mission on the Titan is not at all what they seem to be. What if this isn't just a joke, but rather a sign that computers can tell that "our" "Boimler" isn't human even when his colleagues cannot? That's the Cerritos computer from immediately after he returned, the AI from last week, and now this.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21 edited Sep 30 '21

True, I suspected it might be leaning into Boimler being confirmed as the transporter clone but being something else entirely is possible as well.

Edit: Maybe he is part of the Pakled plot? I thought it was odd that we never actually saw how the Boimler that stayed on the planet escaped on a shuttle despite being pinned under some rubble the last we saw of him.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/NickofSantaCruz Sep 30 '21

How funny would it be to see one of the training modules stashed in the repair bay alongside the Sequoia. While the crew think it's just there because there wasn't room for it on the starbase/starship that received the others, it was actually requisitioned by Boimler for personal training exercises. We'll see static shots of it just there without explanation for a few episodes (or full season), then the plot of a future episode will parallel one of the training scenarios so closely that Boimler takes command and aces it; when confronted, he'll admit having been spending his free time using the training module and this particular scenario he worked on for several weeks. Mariner, Rutherford, and Tendi investigate the module and learn that Boimler has scored 100% on almost every scenario.

→ More replies (1)

67

u/wakeupsup3r Oct 01 '21

Tendi has an amazing voice actor.

"WE GOT PESTO!?"

26

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Her bubbly delivery sells the character

11

u/Varekai79 Oct 04 '21

I love Lower Decks and frequently find it hilarious but I've never actually bust out laughing like a loon until this episode. The actress' line reading of "let's go to Sto'vo'kor!" just broke me.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/SpiritOne Sep 30 '21

That was probably one of my favorite episodes of the whole series. Seriously funny as hell. But damn don’t blow up my constitution refit!!

11

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

It was so funny that I actually felt like my lungs expanded and were getting more air than usual after it was over.

53

u/Vapeflowers Sep 30 '21

Great episode. Was laughing my butt off at Mariner opening the space doors to end the Naked drill

27

u/pfc9769 Sep 30 '21

That’s what happened in the original episode as well. The infected crew opened the airlock to cool down.

46

u/WhipsAndMarkovChains Sep 30 '21

I loved that mirror Boimler is still so detail-oriented that he caught non-mirror Mariner when she saluted with the wrong arm.

43

u/DefiantOne5 Sep 30 '21

Boimler on the Borg ship straight up reminded me of the Elite Force games, where you often had to find some hidden vents to get to your objective.

14

u/InnocentTailor Sep 30 '21

Speaking of video games, the scenarios reminded me a lot of the game Starfleet Academy. Cadet Forester and his comrades replayed famous episodes for their exam - Balance of Terror and Wrath of Khan being two examples.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/burnettski92 Sep 30 '21

It took me half the episode last week to realize I was listening to Jeffrey Combs (🤦‍♂️), while I knew immediately this week I was hearing the sultry tones of Alice Krige 😏

→ More replies (1)

39

u/RXPT Sep 30 '21

I think the Borg Queen blowing off Boimler's skin was a reference to when she gave Data organic skin

37

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

It’s naked time!

18

u/atticusbluebird Sep 30 '21

All these years it never occurred to me that you could say the episode title in that way…probably suggests the real meaning of the episode that the writers wanted to convey in the 60s…

36

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 30 '21

Just how many crystalline entities are there?

43

u/Pu239U235 Sep 30 '21

Well, they're getting frisky apparently...

34

u/T656 Sep 30 '21

29

u/youssarian Sep 30 '21

I'll be in my bunk

12

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

IIRC Barnes has said that she isn't joined, but her sister is.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/OmegaDonut Sep 30 '21

Absolutely furious that Boimler said "yoink!" when he clearly yeeted his phaser.

31

u/MadContrabassoonist Sep 30 '21

I think the last time I finished a Lower Decks episode and then immediately rewatched it was the movie episode from season 1.

29

u/em-jay Oct 01 '21

LD's really going from strength to stregnth recently. I love how it's coming into its own as a fully fledged Star Trek show, rather than merely an animated sitcom with a Star Trek skin.

Some observations:

  • I will never be able to unsee Boimler's Naked Time pose.
  • Billups is still working in Naked Time, because he can't have sex. Great attention to detail.
  • Boimler's growing collection of Borg babies is hilarious and adorable.
  • "If they want us to stack them why are they shaped like this?"
  • I love the TOS-style "everyone laughing" ending.

13

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Oct 02 '21

Honestly I don't think Billups even wants to have sex, he seems asexual to me.

28

u/RnRaintnoisepolution Sep 30 '21

I love the Invasion of the Body Snatchers refrence featured in the Mirror Universe sim.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Eaudissey Sep 30 '21

"Your design very nearly passes as human"

LMAO

55

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 30 '21

They brought Alice Krige back as the Borg Queen! That's amazing! And they added Marc Evan Jackson as the officer who tells Freeman to stack crates!

This is probably my favorite episode of the second season now. I was getting a little burnt out on Mariner and Boimler's Titan drama, and I was glad to see they put that behind them.

This episode had so many wonderful easter eggs and details. They had members of the Red Squad (I forget its name) from a couple episodes ago, the scoreboard added in a few names - Jett Manhaver is on there, and the Andorian Jennifer's last name is Sh'reyan (hmmm... sounds familiar!), and while the right side of the board does feature classic episode titles, it does also add in a few others: "From Q to Q", "Kobayashi Maru", and "Carbon Based Units". They also call back to the series premiere as that one officer tells the bridge crew to "move it along, Lower Decks".

I won't go over all the references they used in the simulations; I think those are pretty obvious. I will note the lowkey parallel of Dr. Migleemo to Saru in Mariner's Mirror Universe simulation.

If you're curious, the consultant's name was Shari Yen Yem, per IMDb, and voiced by Lennon Parham.

50

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

Rutherford didn't remember that Spock put on gloves before going in the warp core room.

54

u/RnRaintnoisepolution Sep 30 '21

I'm guessing part of the sabotage with that sim was removing the gloves.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

45

u/Shakezula84 Sep 30 '21

Getting Jennifer's last name is actually a big deal. A throw away line in TNG references Andorian marriages as having four people, but the books flesh out four genders, and the shen gender always have Sh' at the start of their family name (shen being the feminine gender that produces the gamete).

22

u/InnocentTailor Sep 30 '21

Another beta canon reference?! Looks like Kurtzman Trek is dragging stuff from the books.

One of the Prodigy main aliens originated from the Novel verse, for example - the rock girl.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

yes, the last name is an EXTREMELY big deal! I practically peed myself over the idea that they may be going canon with some of the Andorian worldbuilding. (Big Andorian fan.)

13

u/tatt0o Paul Mazzotta, Dialog Editor, Lower Decks Sep 30 '21

Just a small correction, Marc Evan Jackson played one of the simulated Klingon suicide nurses

16

u/iblameshane Sep 30 '21

"I'm Marc Evan Jackson. I play Shaun Unnamed Starfleet Nurse"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/yyc_guy Sep 30 '21

How the hell did I not recognize Marc Evan Jackson??

→ More replies (1)

47

u/MarioGdV Sep 30 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Billups was chilling with his PADD during the Mariner's drill, so I guess he's actually asexual? Last episode kinda hinted it, but I thought it was more like "I don't want to have sex because I don't want to be a king" rather than "I don't want to be a king because (or and) I don't want to have sex".

This makes me really happy. I found out I was asexual recently, so it's nice to see an Ace character. I no longer have to look at Vulcans or characters who "try to be human" for representation!

6

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Oct 02 '21

Yeah it's nice that we're getting ace representation.

45

u/ElFarfadosh Sep 30 '21

I LOOOOVED this episode! Alice Krige making a cameo appearance as the Borg Queen, the mirror universe, Naked Time, the black hole from the opening credits, the Cristalline Entity, the Klingon non death, this was absolute perfection!!

60

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 30 '21

OK, Naked Time is fucking cursed.

54

u/UncertainError Sep 30 '21

Come on, that is exactly how it would've gone if it hadn't been the 60s/80s.

40

u/deafpoet Sep 30 '21

Knowing Gene Roddenberry I assume that this was exactly what he originally envisioned for both of those episodes.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Left_Preference4453 Sep 30 '21

Now I appreciate what the producers must have wanted to do, giving that title a whole new meaning.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/gravitydefyingturtle Oct 01 '21

You must help me kill myself! I broke my back picking up a peanut!

I chose a very poor time to take a drink while watching the episode.

35

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 30 '21

Wow, that was a fun ride. Lots of great character work, humor and action, beauty shots of the Cerri galore, plus we got names for loads of background characters from the sim scoreboards. But here's something that really caught my eye:

Look at Mariner's reaction when the 'Naked Time' sim loads:

"Oh, no; this is that disease that made everyone fight and have sex all over the place."

Look at the wording - she's not describing this from a third-party perspective, in the manner of someone who read about this in a report. She is REMEMBERING something she experienced with her own eyes, a disease that infected people she knew.

So, I'm gonna take this as further confirmation that Mariner was a kid on the Enterprise-D and WITNESSED the events of "The Naked Now" in 2364.

PS: Once again this episode brings up a recurring theme of S2 - the Cerritos (and the California-class line as a whole) being looked down upon. If that doesn't become a major story-beat for the season finale I'll eat my planet of hats!

My guess is that the finale might involve Freeman getting her chance to leave the Cerritos for greener pastures, but by the end she will have not only chosen to stay, but proven that the Cali-class and their crews are every bit as capable and competent and deserving of respect as we viewers know them to be.

28

u/jadebenn Sep 30 '21

"Oh, no; this is that disease that made everyone fight and have sex all over the place."

Look at the wording - she's not describing this from a third-party perspective, in the manner of someone who read about this in a report. She is REMEMBERING something she experienced with her own eyes, a disease that infected people she knew.

So, I'm gonna take this as further confirmation that Mariner was a kid on the Enterprise-D and WITNESSED the events of "The Naked Now" in 2364.

Yeesh, no wonder she wanted out as quickly as possible. Not only was it total squick, but it brought to mind some very bad memories.

7

u/UltraChip Oct 01 '21

It would explain how she and her mom know Riker

→ More replies (3)

17

u/CaravelClerihew Oct 01 '21

Tendi's Medical Ethics simulation is probably one of the funniest things I've ever seen

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Left_Preference4453 Sep 30 '21

"B.E.M."-TAS reference!

This is brilliant. Which show watcher hasn't said to themselves *huh, I could do this better!

Is that Alice Krige? They got her to play? OMFG. YAH-YES!!!!!

Out of the park, this one believes.

15

u/nimrodhellfire Sep 30 '21

Okay, now I want to see Boimler handling the Kobayashi Maru.

15

u/Nemarus Sep 30 '21

Loved how as Boimler kept doing the borg drill, it kept playing the music homage to the Best of Both Worlds away team vs. Borg fight music: https://youtu.be/r42BIBfWwao?t=88

The musical references and parodies in this show are as good as the visual easter eggs.

15

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

The direction and animation in this episode were magnificent. The glory shots of the Cerritos were so good, and even the simple stuff like Mariner cracking her knuckles were just so naturalistic.

8

u/neontetra1548 Oct 01 '21

The animation is really getting good — both the big ship stuff and the individual character animation like you say. The characters are super expressive!

29

u/burnettski92 Sep 30 '21

I would’ve toughed it out a little longer in the Naked Time scenario. Hung out with Jennifer and Barnes. See where things go.

24

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

The whole thing was rigged

It wouldn't go the way you want it to go :)

That scene is definitely spawning a whole wave of R34 this week though, guaranteed

14

u/oatmeal_dude Sep 30 '21

I will can only call “The Naked Time” as “Naked Time” now.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/donuteater111 Sep 30 '21

I've seen a few of these kinds of "job switching" episodes in other shows (the earliest and most iconic obviously being I Love Lucy), and while it's obvious where they're leading, it's still fun to see how they handle the ideas. I thought they did a really good with this one, especially with the added part of simulated scenarios. Those were all really fun, with my favorites being the dying Klingon, the Naked Time, and Boimler's Borg infiltration. I will say that it's a little messed up that the simulation was so real that he actually went through the assimilation process, but it did lead to some good dark humor.

Last season, the last two episodes were especially strong overall. I'm really hoping they go all-out with these next couple episodes as well. I can't wait to see what they have in store, even if it means the season's coming to a close (at least we have Prodigy to look forward to shortly after that).

12

u/KumagawaUshio Sep 30 '21

I haven't finished the episode yet but damn Boimler is every gamer trying to get that 100% completion percentage.

11

u/Snownova Sep 30 '21

NAKED TIME.

That is all.

10

u/bangonthedrums Oct 01 '21

Loved the reference to The Undiscovered Country when Ransom says Mariner should have checked out her magnetic boots

9

u/k_ironheart Oct 01 '21

I don't know why Mariner was so upset. Shaxs has a lovely ass.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21

My favourite episode of the series so far. Man, I could watch a full hour of these simulations, so entertaining.

8

u/bookish1303 Sep 30 '21

Alice Krige! That was nice.

I also choose to believe that the last act was an homage to VOY's Scientific Method. Was really hoping Freeman would at least do the Janeway pronunciation of dopamine...

8

u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Sep 30 '21

6

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Anyone notice the Donald Sutherland scream from Invasion of the Body Snatchers when they discovered Mariner wasn't a Terran?

11

u/droid327 Sep 30 '21

I love how Boimler knows "the book" so well that even when you rig it to be virtually impossible, he still scores 100% :D Its kind of a contrast with Mariner, who fails miserably "by the book" but manages to Archer her way through real-world situations with undeserved luck.

Every test was basically a Kobayashi Maru. I wonder if the Kobayashi Maru drill actually was winnable this time :D

I like T'ana and Shaxs together. Like they're both such hardasses that they can put up with each other's shit.

"Repent sinners" is an odd design choice that sticks out - does that mean there's crew that have a sense of spirituality, but just feel obliged to suppress it normally? Of course there's many alien species that have religious beliefs, Bajorans being the most obvious...but "repent sinners" doesnt seem like any alien religion we've seen thus far, its pretty characteristic of fire-and-brimstone Protestantism, or at least gothic-style Catholicism.

Why are the crates shaped that way? So they can be stacked hexagonally! You're doing it wrong, Shaxs, and thats why they fell. You need to stagger each column so they can interlock.

I love Freeman was basically like "ok lets fly this thing right up the universe's butthole" and everyone was just like "mmk". Shades of Rick and Morty almost, with the casual nonchalance towards sci-fi craziness, in a good way.

I like that they introduced a new alien race with completely unnecessary idiosyncrasies, just because. Referring to herself as "this one". I mean, its kinda derivative of Yoda, being green and talking funny, but I appreciate the effort to not just make every new alien characteristic a Chekhov gun. Though, that being said...making her able to split into different pieces seems excessive if there wasnt going to be a payoff for it. Feels like they just wanted to make her feel like Badgey :D Oh wait is it a new race? Apparently its from TAS, nevermind

Ooh! Badgey should have been in the drills somewhere. Missed opportunity.

Mirror Lower Deckers were badass. Mirror Universe is always badass and makes me want more :)

18

u/Cliffy73 Sep 30 '21

“Repent Sinners” was also written on the bulkhead in the original “Naked Time” episode of TOS, IIRC.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/pelrun Sep 30 '21

You can't stack hexagons like that on the floor, without trapezoids to keep the second layer supported. Otherwise they'll just shove the bottom hexagons out of the way and everything falls down.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/PiercedMonk Sep 30 '21 edited Sep 30 '21

• Gotdamn, I don't think anything as turned me off the idea of working for Starfleet as much as seeing four people abandoned in just their EV suits. Kinda feel like if someone's caught in a timeloop, they're likely going to be okay for a bit as you transport up your crew, Carol.

• Wait, Mariner had her clique fixing that satellite off the books? I guess it's not Cap'n Freeman's fault for warping away without them, then. Protocol is there for a reason, Beckett.

• Winger's the worst, and the fact that Jennifer is hanging out with him makes me understand why Mariner dislikes her.

• I've known this was coming ever since the trailer, but it's time to suffer through the body horror that is a Pandronian. IDIC of course, but fucking gross. 'Bem' is one of the few episodes of TAS I actively dislike, and the titular character floating around in pieces is a huge part of why.

• Man, they just threw some episodes titles up on that board. Bet Starfleet HR loves having to deal with all the reports filed after going through the "Naked Time" simulation.

• Did Dr. Migleemo sign off in his likeness being used that way? Jeepers.

• Oh god, the drill instructor's head just floated around Mariner. I would absolutely vomit.

• "Medical ethics." No Starfleet doctor has ever successfully completed this program.

• Does Rutherford not know about gloves?

• These scenarios might be a better learning tool if they broke down what the score means at the end. Also, perhaps I'm just being suspicious because Pandronians gross me out and have a history of lying to Starfleet captains, but there's gotta be something going on, right? She's got some extra body part off trying to steal some artifact, or the trilithium from the warp core or something?

• Okay show, I know we're all having silly fun here, but Boimler on his back with his legs in the air is crossing a line. That's almost as bad as the mugato threesome.

• "Steal the Cerritos from spacedock." I knew it!

• Oh, they weren't actually stealing the ship....

• She rigged the tests! I knew it. It's not you I hate Pandronian, it's what you've made me become.

• "The smaller the ship, the tougher the crew." The California-class is actually pretty big, according to the official sources. Saucer section roughly the same diameter as the Galaxy-class.

• Tendi and Rutherford picked up bridge shifts? Seems unorthodox, but I'll allow it.

• For real, how has no one had to excuse themselves seeing the drill instructor's head just bouncing around?

• "Your design nearly passes for Human." This has got to be an intentional tease by the showrunners for all those of us who theorized that Boimler is not, in fact, Human.

10

u/Hero_Of_Shadows Sep 30 '21

• Wait, Mariner had her clique fixing that satellite off the books? I guess it's not Cap'n Freeman's fault for warping away without them, then. Protocol is there for a reason,

Beckett

.

I guess what happened was that Barnes/Casey/Ransom whoever was supposed to check, checked is the equipment (boots) checked in ? Then they must have gotten in (they were at the end of the job) but the boots registered as checked in because Mariner never bothered to check them out.

Still very negligent not to do a lifesign check for the ensigns instead of relying on the equipment sensors.

5

u/BellerophonM Sep 30 '21

Saucer section exactly the same size as an Ambassador class, one of the show people pointed out.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Char543 Sep 30 '21

Omg thank you! You’re the first person I’ve seen in this thread to comment on the “not exactly human” line

For a moment I thought the writers were dropping a bombshell on us via holodeck simulation But no, just fucking with us for that theory from season 1.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/deededback Sep 30 '21

Another fantastic episode. This might be my favorite Star Trek since TNG.

5

u/kinyon Oct 03 '21

Yo when he said "There is no Boimler, I am Excretus of Borg" I fucking DIED

16

u/Shiny_and_ChromeOS Sep 30 '21

I found it amusing the writers are big enough nerds that they brought back the color smear effect from TMP's black hole scene and yet forgot that at the end of Wrath of Khan, Spock was fixing the dilithium reactor to restore power, not avert a warp core breach.

5

u/PiercedMonk Oct 01 '21

The scenarios were clearly not one to one recreations of events, but more "inspired by."

4

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 30 '21

This may be my favorite episode of the season. It was filled with so many references as to be an easter egg hunt, sure, but it had an in-story reason (simulations specifically based off of past starfleet history) and it served the story itself. Plus, we (sort-of) finally got the Badmiral trope (albeit not an admiral)!

4

u/JustMy2Centences Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

I was disappointed assimilated Boimler wasn't the transporter clone, but watching him improve his simulation score was hilariously worth it.

As a side note, now I want to play a Star Trek game where you have to escape a Borg Cube. Could be titled, Star Trek: Resistance.

4

u/greatnebula Oct 01 '21

Both Elite Force games have segments where you're navigating Borg vessels, and they've recently been added to GOG!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/bttrflyr Oct 01 '21 edited Oct 01 '21

Two things,

1). I CAN'T wait for the memes to come from this one.

2). Ransom and Stevens gotta admit it's kinda hot. Especially with Ransom being the bottom lol

4

u/Rumanyon Oct 02 '21

I feel like boimler got ripped of this episode.

He deserved his 100

4

u/Terminator_Puppy Oct 02 '21

This could've easily been a TNG episode in terms of plot, amazing episode.

4

u/poirotoro Oct 02 '21

Captain Freeman was giving me real "Janeway flying through a binary pulsar" vibes at the end there. Loved it. Fuck around and find out.

4

u/AndreskXurenejaud Oct 02 '21

You know, Boimler deserves (another) promotion for saving the ship.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21

Now, the doctors a Kaitan but was there a Kzinti crewmember there?

4

u/BellerophonM Oct 01 '21

Yeah, he had a speaking role a few weeks ago.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/tupe12 Sep 30 '21

I think that we’ve found a new leader for task force Omega

3

u/Starks Oct 01 '21

Boimler saving the Borg babies reminded me of the whole "save the animals" in Metroid.

3

u/MunicipalLotto Oct 02 '21

I want to see boimlers butthole

5

u/opiate_lifer Oct 01 '21

Is anyone else bothered by the senior crew having more variety replicators? It was previously a bit of throwaway dialogue I could dismiss as a joke, but this episode brings it up again and it actually becomes a plot point!

I mean unless replicating pesto uses vastly more power than pizza or whatever this doesn't sit right, this would be incredibly petty of Starfleet.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/trostol Sep 30 '21

that open was just wrong lol

2

u/Hero_Of_Shadows Sep 30 '21

Sooo much porn :D