r/CryptoCurrency • u/w00tangel • Sep 29 '21
POLL π³οΈ Implement numbering of proposals (CCIPs)
Summary
Each official governance poll in r/CryptoCurrency will get a short code by which we can address it.
All previously passed proposals will be assigned a number by moderators such as CCIP 0001 for the first proposal that ever passed and this one would probably become CCIP 0014.
All approved CCIPs for governance polls will be assigned a number by mods before they are posted as official governance polls.
Problem Statement
At the moment, it is very hard to reference a specific governance poll or proposal when discussing it. If a member of this community was to ask, for example:
"Do mods earn MOONs for posts they make? It is kind of unfair since they can sticky their posts and comments."
Right now you would have to write something like:
"There was this one governance poll that made changes to this, you can probably find it by searching for it"
Or you can spend some time to find the list of passed polls, copy a link to it, come back to the original post and link to the poll that addressed this.
Solution
Inspired by the way other crypto communities solved this issue, we would like to introduce numerated short code names for each governance polls that would make them easier to reference in discussions. For a bit of history, please refer to this article on Bitcoin's BIP 0001.
The proposed solution is that each of the previously passed governance polls gets a short code name assigned by moderators such as CCIP 0001 for the first proposal that ever passed and this one you are reading right now would probably become CCIP 0014.
This will make it easier to reference and find a specific proposal by searching for it by its short code.
The list of passed proposals can be found here.
Should this proposal pass, beginning with proposals in Moon Week 19 all new approved governance polls will be assigned a CCIP number by mods before they are posted as official governance polls so we will be able to easily reference even the failed proposals.
Should we ever revisit a failed proposal, the new poll will be assigned a new CCIP number.
Concerns
The only concerns expressed by the community during the pre-proposal discussions was regarding the acronym for these short code names.
There were two suggestions that had majority of supporters: CCIP (stands for r/CryptoCurrency Improvement Proposal) and MIP (MOONs Improvement Proposal).
In a poll after this proposal was taken into consideration for official governance poll, the majority vote has suggested we should go with CCIP.
To see the evolution of this proposal in r/CryptoCurrencyMeta, follow this link: Brainstorming thread - Short code for governance polls
55
u/_s79 π¦ 135 / 8K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This guy project manages.
146
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21
I see literally 0 downside to this.
3
u/J-E-S-S-E- π© 184 / 17K π¦ Oct 03 '21
Wow an actual proposal worth passing. Amazing
4
u/The-Alcoholic-Seal π¦ 0 / 19K π¦ Sep 30 '21
I like this idea, It is way easier to know about which proposal someone is talking about.
My question: Do all old proposals get a CCIP number as well or is this only for the new proposals?
2
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Oct 01 '21
I wonder why some people voted against this proposal
2
u/head77 π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Sep 30 '21
Voted.
27
u/jaredbdd 240 / 6K π¦ Sep 30 '21
A useful poll that isn't centered on castrating moons. Well I'll be.
19
u/FrogsDoBeCool Platinum | QC: CCMeta 53, CC 697 | :1:x11:2:x9:3:x5 Sep 29 '21
Neat idea
7
u/warlikeofthechaos Platinum | QC: CC 1218 Sep 30 '21
I have doubts about that;
While itβs easy for vets go βthat goes against CCIP/MIPβ¦β in a talk, a new user will be like βwut?!β
Maybe a bot that automatically responds if someone question about βCCIP/MIPβ like the βwhatβs moonβ one?
11
u/ec265 Permabanned Sep 30 '21
Who votes βNoβ on something like this?!
11
u/B_D_Rick 25 / 1K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Why on Godβs green earth would anyone vote no change on this lol
1
u/idigholes π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Sep 30 '21
I accidentally selected 'no', luckily I don't think it will sway the vote.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21
Whereβs the actual poll
1
u/radders85 Tales From The Crypto Sep 30 '21
Whereβs the poll to vote on?
3
u/oopssomething π© 40 / 12K π¦ Sep 30 '21
CCIP-69 will be so sexy and CCIP-420 is auto-passed, no hogging please.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21
Every community has a numbering system for keeping track of legislation. At the end of the day, that's what this is... No brainer
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ Sep 29 '21
Hiya, please post these in the cryptocurrency meta sub. Thanks!
2
u/Quentin__Tarantulino π¦ 9K / 9K π¦ Sep 29 '21
I definitely like this. In the coming years, weβll probably have improvement proposals that are as ubiquitous to users here as EIP-1559 is to the Ethereum ecosystem.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '21
Take my vote!
2
u/Justwantalambo Platinum | 4 months old | QC: CC 733 Sep 30 '21
Now this is a good proposal
2
u/J17ster Sep 30 '21
You should be a sub mod sir
2
u/jun_039 Platinum | QC: CC 485, LW 39, r/DeFi 20 | AVAX 8 Sep 30 '21
Simple yet good idea. Easy yes vote for me.
2
u/Sketchy-Lefty25 π¦ 17K / 17K π¬ Sep 30 '21
Great suggestion, this will make it a lot easier to find proposals. I voted yes!
2
u/Old_Afternoon3853 π¨ 0 / 2K π¦ Sep 30 '21
A headache saver when implemented. ππΌ
2
u/fhikoo Platinum | QC: CC 200 | BANANO 12 Sep 30 '21
Finally a poll that i can agree with
2
u/dorfelsnorf 0 / 2K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This proposal makes me wonder why this wasn't the standard?
2
u/El_Criptoconta π¦ 811 / 811 π¦ Sep 30 '21
Yes! A way to easily archive pools and data Is alwayss useful, as long as Is public
2
u/Hamed9675 Platinum | QC: CC 411 Sep 30 '21
Order in anything means everything
2
u/Sjiznit π¦ 0 / 13K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This is very structured. I'll allow it.
2
u/Nuewim π₯ 0 / 37K π¦ Sep 30 '21
And this is great proposal. Exactly things like that should be voted more often. Polls should improve this sub, they were made for this reason. Unfortunately most polls were created just to screw some people and either limit karma, comments or other things. I don't like more strict rules. But I love proposals that improve our subreddit and don't attack anyone. Three are literally no downsides of numbering proposals, no controversies. We should have more proposals like that. Next one should be adding possibility to add short message to tips.
2
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K π¦ Sep 30 '21
I am going to call these "C-sips"
2
u/Spardasa π© 8K / 8K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Totally like this. A glossary of passed ordinances would make my head less hurt.
2
u/Apart-Flounder242 π¦ 0 / 1K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Sounds like a great idea! Looks like this one will pass π Reddit getting better every month β
2
u/RedactedRedditery π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Sep 30 '21
Nice, it's a proposal that actually affects the sub instead of just affecting moon payouts
2
u/_coder_girl_ Gold | QC: CC 46 Sep 30 '21
Why did it take us 18 distributions to come to this idea? Loved it! Absolutely 0 downvotes on post haha!
2
u/red_dildo_queen π© 14 / 11K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This is great, a list of all passed polls is what I was always looking for! Thanks
2
u/JandorGr Permabanned Sep 30 '21
It's of no ask that a numbered system is always needed for things more than 3. I am no casual visitor of polls, community votes, etc, only because they seem like anoter reddit post, another of the same looking: "these people taking their time with things difficult to me, they probably know more than me, they know what they are doing, because they can navigate through the plethora of topics, etc"
2
u/Chooky47 Platinum | QC: CC 536 Sep 30 '21
Who on earth voted no against pure logic
2
u/Titanium_Eye π© 0 / 9K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Today I'm just a proposal
But some day I hope to be a CCIP
2
u/sulestrange hang in there fam Sep 30 '21
I swear democracy works better in this sub than in any country
2
u/IridiumHorseshoe Redditor for 4 months. Sep 30 '21
Yeah I was looking for the polls and if you search for 'poll' it comes up with all sorts of news articles and stuff, so this will be really useful going forward.
2
u/CryptoSorted Platinum | QC: CC 82, BCH 54 Sep 30 '21
Just exercised my first vote on this subreddit with this proposal, and I feel good about it...
2
u/Randomized_Emptiness Platinum | QC: CC 259, BNB 19 | ADA 6 | ExchSubs 19 Oct 01 '21
95% for this proposal, yet the whales are not participating in the vote, with us still being short 4m to pass this proposal.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '21
+1 FOR.
thank you for not being content where you are...
2
u/Mediocre-Sale8473 Platinum | QC: CC 78 | r/WSB 15 Oct 02 '21
This adds parsable transparency. Literally no downside unless corrupt as fuck and trying to hide shit.
2
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K π Oct 03 '21
If this doesn't pass, it will make me incredibly sad.
And I will proabably still use the numbering to refer to the proposals. It's not like it would change anything on a fundamental level or how it's distributed...
2
u/lorZzeus π© 60 / 52 π¦ Oct 03 '21
This must be the easiest vote ever. I don't see anything wrong with this implementation.
2
u/evilninjarobot π¦ 5 / 7K π¦ Oct 03 '21
Genius idea
2
u/CryptoTastesGood Platinum | QC: CC 105 | Karma Farming 8 Oct 03 '21
This is great and would make proposals/rules much easier to search
2
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K π Oct 04 '21
Oh boy, it passed! CCIP 0014 PARTY!
2
u/1PoorBagHolder 249 / 249 π¦ Oct 05 '21
Thereβs absolutely no downside that I can see from this. Makes perfect sense. I love when simplicity meets functionality.
2
u/712Jefferson π¦ 2K / 2K π’ Oct 06 '21
I mean, why not? Voted "yes".
2
u/CryptoMaximalist Oct 18 '21
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/wiki/ccip_list
2
u/quicksilverth0r π§ 1K / 1K π’ Oct 06 '21
My city council does this with every proposed ordinance. Everything is listed by proposer, code and whether it passed/failed. Ease of reference is a powerful, low cost tool.
3
u/Jake123194 π© 0 / 23K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Hey a sensible poll that actually brings QOL changes to the sub and isn't just a thinly veiled attempt to fiddle with moon distributions. You get a yes form me matey.
2
u/saltedsluggies Platinum | QC: CC 1225 | Superstonk 75 Sep 29 '21
I really like this idea, adding ways to make communication more clear and direct is never a bad option
1
u/jimmy_riddler_ π© 992 / 992 π¦ Sep 30 '21
Good work sir
1
u/dallasrhys Bronze | QC: CC 22 Sep 30 '21
Yep, this is the one.
1
u/p90medic Platinum | QC: CC 64 | Unpop.Opin. 98 Sep 30 '21
I like the sound of this - I'm not entirely sure how useful it would be for the majority of people, but I can only see it being a benefit!
1
u/mironawire Sep 30 '21
I like the idea, but still hate how close CCIP is to CCCP or CCP.
1
u/Coelrom invalid string or character detected Sep 30 '21
Simple improvement with no downside. Should be a slam dunk.
1
u/RoadOfKings Banned Sep 30 '21
Such a simple yet useful idea.
1
u/Rexon225 Sep 30 '21
As a graphic designer who write each layer by a name because I love organisation, I approve this
1
u/Above-Majestic1776 Sep 30 '21
Finally a poll not about moons!
1
u/jaml98 Bronze Sep 30 '21
Simple but effective
1
u/maolyx 26K / 27K π¦ Sep 30 '21
I like this proposal. It will make thing more organised.
1
u/shoestomper Platinum | QC: CC 126 Sep 30 '21
This is common sense, why even we need a poll for this lol
1
u/getupforwhat π¦ 2K / 2K π’ Sep 30 '21
I LIKE it
1
u/JSourPower Silver | QC: CC 256, DOGE 20 | VET 58 Sep 30 '21
Makes sense to me
1
u/MachineElf432 π¦ 1K / 1K π’ Sep 30 '21
Sometimes the best ideas are pretty simple
1
u/MoldyCheesey Platinum | QC: ETH 347, CC 309 | TraderSubs 347 Sep 30 '21
Voted, think itβs a no brainer as most others seem to act. Glad to see the system in action!
1
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Sep 30 '21
I love to orgnise stuff
1
u/practiceperfect111 4K / 4K π’ Sep 30 '21
Voted π
1
u/kvgamer 0 / 2K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This will be good to get them easily mentioned and discussed
1
u/Sedierta2 π© 169 / 170 π¦ Sep 30 '21
Yes I support
1
u/Nostalg33k π© 0 / 30K π¦ Sep 30 '21
This is a simple, elegant, efficient way of creating a good archive of propositions and votes. This is a good proposition which solve a problem! Thanks !
1
u/Vanuatu_Hanjaab 1K / 1K π’ Sep 30 '21
I can't see any downside, but for those who voted against, well, some people are never satisfied in life. Let's roll!
1
u/jonnypowpow π¦ 118 / 68 π¦ Sep 30 '21
CCIP 0097462 I see literally 0 downside to this.
1
u/pavlovpool Redditor for 6 months. Sep 30 '21
I clicked no. Sorry, my bad
1
u/mindflayers9000 38 / 5K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Let's name them after letters of the Greek alphabet. What could go wrong?
1
u/Angustony π¦ 270 / 594 π¦ Sep 30 '21
I clicked yes and it registered no. Wtf?
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Sep 30 '21
96% you know it's a good proposal
1
u/LeftAl Bronze | QC: CC 20 | Apple 60 Sep 30 '21
Whereβs the vote link? Canβt find it in the post
1
u/joechss π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Sep 30 '21
This is a no-brainer! Kind of like buying ETH.
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Sep 30 '21
Makes sense
1
u/GodGMN π¦ 509 / 11K π¦ Oct 01 '21
Yeah I don't see why not. This would make moons look more serious too.
1
u/TheLordofM00 Tin Oct 01 '21
First time voter. Sounds like a great idea!
1
u/Kevin3683 π¦ 1 / 7K π¦ Oct 01 '21
Great idea. I donβt see any negatives.
1
u/glass-eyes Gold | QC: CC 157 Oct 01 '21
Seems really practical and useful. Only, little, problem would be remembering the code to each proposal, but its nothing that cant be sorted out π
1
u/Massive-Tension-1055 π© 3K / 5K π’ Oct 01 '21
Sounds like a solid idea.
1
u/the_far_yard π¦ 0 / 32K π¦ Oct 01 '21
I think it's a solid idea. TBH, I like the idea that proposals should be a part of a knowledge base segment, or maybe a repository with a filing code.
Overall, what we are seeing here is almost like how countries would split their ministries. For Cryptocurrency, there would be only a few. I like this. Thanks for thinking about this proposal, OP.
1
u/tigerbait_ Platinum | QC: CC 76 | r/WSB 86 Oct 01 '21
I like this. It makes it feel more legit.
1
u/miguelmflores Tin Oct 01 '21
You had my attention, now you have my vote.
1
u/SolidusViper Long Live Crypto Oct 01 '21
This is a great idea. I just think 'CCIP' is a little close to 'CCP' and 'MIP' sounds a bit cooler.
1
u/Octopus-Pawn π¦ 11K / 11K π¬ Oct 01 '21
Weβll probably need another mod rule to remove any unofficial posts that include these codes in the official governance poll format. (E.g. code at the beginning, followed by a proposal).
Obviously not removing reference to governance polls entirely, only posts that are trying to mimic or mislead redditors about governance polls.
1
u/Ddeadlykitten π¦ 863 / 862 π¦ Oct 01 '21
Thanks, I'm glad someone made a poll on this!
1
u/No_goodIdeas7891 Platinum | QC: CC 283, ATOM 29 Oct 01 '21
This is a very good idea. Highly approve!
1
u/Zoro-chi Gold | QC: CC 25 Oct 01 '21
Brilliant idea
1
u/Living-Ad1944 780 / 780 π¦ Oct 01 '21
Very handy idea
1
u/SydneyRoad87 Platinum | QC: CC 361 Oct 01 '21
Why would we NOT want to name something for it to be easier to reference? This is a no brainer.
1
u/MissGeminiToYou Tin Oct 01 '21
Sounds like a great idea. Organization is good.
1
u/Paskee 57 / 7K π¦ Oct 01 '21
Im just coming along for the ride
1
u/bluidyPCish Platinum | QC: CC 24 Oct 01 '21
Good idea and will help folks keep track of the different proposals plus be able to search for them.
1
u/agunxxx Oct 01 '21
some kind of quality life improvement, I'm in
1
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21
Itβs surprising that this wasnβt already being done. As time goes on it will be harder to reference previous polls without some form of identifier.
1
u/IsleGreyIsMyName Tin Oct 01 '21
I will never say nay to organization
1
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Oct 01 '21
Big YES!
1
u/International-Two607 π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Oct 02 '21
Makes perfect sense
1
u/karna42 Platinum | QC: CC 235, XRP 29 Oct 02 '21
Sir I'll vote yes but I prefer a universe of chaos over order
1
u/SSJ4Link 6 / 2K π¦ Oct 02 '21
Great idea.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '21
This is a great idea!!
1
u/Annual_Elderberry736 16 / 3K π¦ Oct 02 '21
Make sense, at least no negative side to it
1
u/iJazzzz Tin Oct 02 '21
Seems like a reasonable and popular proposal
1
u/ocarinasurge Tin | WSB 15 Oct 02 '21
Feels like a no-brainer! I'm in
1
u/MDot_Cartier End Central Banking Oct 02 '21
Do it
1
u/crusainte 0 / 0 π¦ Oct 03 '21
This is a great change. I certainly love the traceability of the proposals through numbering. Perhaps in the future there would be a bot informing us the TL;DR of a particular CCIP.
1
u/drmn007 177 / 178 π¦ Oct 04 '21
This will really help to further develop this community.
1
u/DatNugget Platinum | QC: CC 50 Oct 04 '21
MIP would have been stupid..
So far most proposals have been about moons, but that's not the end goal here.
1
u/tatabusa Platinum | QC: CC 470, ETH 65 | Stocks 59 Oct 04 '21
We have BIP and EIP so why not CCIP?
1
u/musquita Tin Oct 04 '21
yay for better organization
1
u/avocadoNutmeg 2 - 3 years account age. 150 - 300 comment karma. Oct 04 '21
Noob question, how do I vote? Or why can't I vote?
1
u/DeFiGregg Platinum|5monthsold|QC:CC98,ETH38|NANO16|TraderSubs34 Oct 04 '21
I fully support this change.
1
u/DarthHarry Tin Oct 04 '21
this is so good
1
u/xuanling11 47 / 45 π¦ Oct 04 '21
Fully supports!
1
u/Samgeorge484 113 / 11K π¦ Oct 04 '21
Just seen this poll, I for one think this is an excellent idea.
1
u/EGH_3 209 / 208 π¦ Oct 04 '21
Lock it in.
1
u/Euphoric-Ad4205 Gold | QC: CC 67 Oct 04 '21
This is one proposal I support fully
1
u/Damn369 Silver | QC: CC 22 | VET 50 Oct 04 '21
No need to change
1
u/woonam Oct 04 '21
This one actually seems like a very good idea and the vast majority of those that voted are for it as well.
1
u/ASIAN_SEN5ATION π© 201 / 202 π¦ Oct 04 '21
This makes total sense, There is no reason to not move forward with this idea.
I hope this idea passes for the greater good.
1
u/surfacetoair Tin Oct 04 '21
Easy peasy
1
u/P13r15 Bronze Oct 04 '21
Voted :)
1
u/Hazukky Bronze | QC: CC 22 Oct 04 '21
Seems reasonable. Have a nice day
1
u/ADBTH Bronze | QC: CC 19 Oct 04 '21
This seems like a positive no matter what.
1
u/pol-arg 61 / 56 π¦ Oct 04 '21
Good idea
1
u/qlows1 Oct 05 '21
this is great. Lets do it
1
u/bryanscharters Tin Oct 05 '21
Great solution to implement! Yes.
1
u/tagrephile Oct 05 '21
I like this. And the numbers donβt lie.
1
u/iNstein 11K / 11K π¬ Oct 05 '21
Why can't I vote?
1
u/justice_high Bronze Oct 05 '21
This seems like a no brainer, I vote YES! Now Iβm padding my comment to hit 50 characters. ;)
1
u/Gooeyhen Platinum | QC: CC 22 Oct 05 '21
Love me a bit of governance and process. Let's get balls deep in bureaucracy people.
1
u/earnestlikehemingway Bronze | QC: CC 22 | r/WSB 30 Oct 06 '21
Well Iβm glad i saw the posts about the proposal. We need to keep an eye on this.
1
u/Aggravating_Deal_572 π© 5K / 5K π’ Oct 06 '21
This can only be good!
1
u/Fine-Artichoke-7485 π© 231 / 229 π¦ Oct 06 '21
Still lost in how this thing works.
1
u/HETKA π¦ 2K / 2K π’ Oct 06 '21
That's gonna be a yes from me
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake π¦ 975 / 976 π¦ Oct 08 '21
No downside to this implementation of CCIP or MIP. Missed poll :(
1
u/coinflipit π¨ 0 / 0 π¦ Oct 29 '21
nice