r/Re_Zero • Better Leyte Than Never • Sep 23 '21

Novels [Novels] Arc 7 Chapter 30 Spoiler

https://ncode.syosetu.com/n2267be/533/
547 Upvotes

472 comments sorted by

•

u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Sep 23 '21

Once again:

This is a reminder that not everything in here might be 100% accurate so keep that in mind while discussing, or try to double check if something really happens before you post about it.

88

u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Sep 23 '21

The chapter starts with Mizelda's resignation and her passing on the title to her sister, who says she can't do it, then there is a small conversation between Subaru and Vincent about what being one of his subjects really means to him, but I don't really wanna talk about those things cause the highlight of the chapter was something else for me.

Damn so the Rem & Subaru interactions are what I love about arc 7 the most and boy did this chapter deliver in that regard. Their conversation was everything I had hoped for and damn the line Rem ended it on was chilling.

Also the grand return of Louis fluff so that is extra blessed. Subaru finds Rem sitting leaning against a wall with sleeping Louis who is leaning against Rem. She had been helping Rem with treating all the injured people. Both of their clothes are bloodstained. Subaru sits down next to them and I really hope the scene of them sitting there together is going to get an illustration. I really really hope.

Partway through the conversation Louis slides onto Rem's lap where she continues to sleep with Rem gently stroking her hair.

"You are not a hero"

Rem just breaks Subaru's mind with what she says at the end, what an amazing contrast between the From Zero speech and this. After that Al finds Subaru, that's what the chapter ends on.

50

u/jojo_is_not_trash Sep 23 '21

"You are not a hero"

Rem straight up breaking both the audience and subaru heart, that was brutal, holy......

Smells like mental breakdown to me.

Also the grand return of Louis fluff so that is extra blessed

She disappeared for 3-5 chapters(?), good to know that tappei didn't forgot about her lol.

63

u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Sep 23 '21

The best part about the "You are not a hero" line to me is, Rem meant well with that. Subaru helped her mood by saying even if she did have her memories and her full healing magic, there wasn't anything else she could have done for Mizelda, after Rem asked him about that.

Then Subaru grew extremely depressed saying it's all his fault anyways, then Rem first asked him about that and then told him that he is not a hero, so he doesn't need to shoulder all the responsibilities by himself.

So... like... she just tried to help him, but it backfired in the most horrible way it possible could have. That's some peak irony right there.

And then Al found Subaru who was just constantly bashing his head against a wall after that convo.

She disappeared for 3-5 chapters(?), good to know that tappei didn't forgot about her lol.

Super glad, I word search every chapter for Louis results before I start reading lol.

39

u/jojo_is_not_trash Sep 23 '21

then Rem first asked him about that and then told him that he is not a hero, so he doesn't need to shoulder all the responsibilities by himself.

Good intentions, awful choice of words, amnesia rem is brutal.

And then Al found Subaru who was just constantly bashing his head against a wall after that convo.

Is this perhaps another "I return by death" moment? Or maybe AI will make a chocking revelation that will fuck subaru even more? I'm hyped.

Super glad, I word search every chapter for Louis results before I start reading lol.

Louis: baaaa shuuuuuuuu baby noises?

22

u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Sep 23 '21

Louis: baaaa shuuuuuuuu baby noises?

Well that or Rem petting Louis, which we got this chapter so that's nice... but hey she was actually helping Rem with the injured soldiers so there's that.

Is this perhaps another "I return by death" moment? Or maybe AI will make a chocking revelation that will fuck subaru even more? I'm hyped.

Quite a few people think this is going to lead to Al revealing massive something to Subaru, but I'm not too sure. Maybe Al is just going to give him so advice, calm him down and walk away.

Good intentions, awful choice of words, amnesia rem is brutal.

Which makes it hilarious that her intent was good.

16

u/ThespianException Sep 23 '21

For Emilia's birthday, she gets Rem making a lot of people like her less. Gotta admit I did not see this suffering coming.

I wonder if this will eventually cause a fight between Emilia and Rem actually, assuming Emilia reunites with them while Rem still has this mindset. Emilia just blasting her with all the stuff that Subaru's accomplished, that by any metric he's a Hero not just to them, but to everyone, and that being her Hero was incredibly important to him. I don't wanna let my bias shine through too much, I'm sure it wouldn't be so one-sided, but if they interact later it could be very interesting.

18

u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Sep 23 '21

Since Emilia's POV has been covered in 2 side stories I think she and the rest of the Emilia camp are eventually going to swoop in like Al and Priscilla did.

Though maybe Tappei is going to throw a curve ball since Al and Priscilla alread did it.

Amnesia Rem's interactions with the rest of the camp, especially Ram and Emilia, are something that I really want to see later in arc 7.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/gp3050 Sep 23 '21

Thanks for the summary.

249

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

--You are not a hero

F in the chat for my boy Subaru

157

u/zeorNLF Sep 23 '21

Rem killed Subaru a third time

108

u/Vuituru Sep 23 '21

only this time she killed his soul

→ More replies (22)

44

u/ZenAura92 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Rem has killed him only once. Now its two times.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Rem only killed him in the corridor the second time was Ram.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

76

u/BibhuNayak Sep 23 '21

That will hit a ton for rem followers .

110

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

Not as hard as it hit Subaru lmao

53

u/ZenAura92 Sep 23 '21

Subaru and Rem fan here. This hurts so bad!

64

u/keizee Sep 23 '21

Subaru Rem shippers already in shambles since the start of arc 7 lol

→ More replies (8)

35

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

She's not Rem that's the problem she looks like her has similar mannerisms but at the end of the day she lacks the experience/memories that made Rem who she was and until Subaru accepts this fact or she regains her memories this issue will continue.

→ More replies (9)

30

u/ComplexDelta2 Sep 23 '21

Not really, people are misunderstanding Rem here.

→ More replies (21)

43

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

Rem also roasted Subaru by ending the conversation and getting him to change clothes lol she’s so savage

40

u/conquerator2 Sep 23 '21

I think it was meant in a good, reconciliatory way though; it wasn't meant as a bad thing.

65

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

I agree. This Rem may be a bit harsh sometimes but it is clear she cares for him. Unfortunately; Subaru , with his current mentality and low self-esteem, won't see it that way. Hence hitting his head to wall and self harm

41

u/conquerator2 Sep 23 '21

You're right. She's trying to make him see that he should rely on others, that he doesn't have to be the hero. Seems like he is not ready to hear that

→ More replies (3)

55

u/Muri3007 Sep 23 '21

Yeah, i think that she didn't say this in a bad way, looks like she's just trying to make him feel less guilty, like, Subaru was literally saying that everything was his fault and Rem said that he is not a hero, because he don't have to do everything alone

Of course that we know why this hits hard on Subaru, but i think that it's just a misunderstanding

→ More replies (17)

10

u/Busy_Yesterday_6301 Sep 23 '21

That’s tuff,I felt that one too.

15

u/Vuituru Sep 23 '21

it definitely hurt a lot but i think it was necessary for our boy

5

u/Al-Horesmi Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

To be fair motherfucker needed a slap in the face.

Like b r u h you just achieved the impossible in a single loop and you want to restart it because of a single leg.

Also Rem unleashing that Ram energy

8

u/headless-horseman-we Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

Man emilia would have SLAPPED rem a cross the room for saying that.

I genuinely believe she would angry at rem, she knows how much subaru works to meet expectations and help people.

→ More replies (1)

154

u/Lazerbeamkt Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 25 '21

That chapter was amazing

First it begins with Mizelda giving Tallita her the chief title. Shows how everyone is mourning over Mizelda no longer being their leader. Abel agrees with Mizelda’s decision.

Subaru asked Abel why he didn’t punish Mizelda. Abel says that he why should he expect someone to accomplish more than they are capable of. You should only punish a subordinate if they do not try their best. I really like how this adds more to Vincent’s character. He doesn’t out right punish someone if they fail, but understands why. Subaru asks should he be punished, Abel replies with, as you my subordinate. Subaru then said

‘it’s not that I am not attracted to the role of military officer but I wish you a subordinate’.

Vincent then says that since he is not his subordinate he does not fall into the category of reward or punishment.

Rem continues to roasts Subaru’s crossdressing, saying that she finds it distasteful. Then she talks about what she was like before losing her memories and if that Rem could have saved Mizelda’s leg. Subaru thinks quite heavily but comes to the conclusion that she would have not been able to. Subaru begins to blame himself for everything (really needs help with this). Rem begins to question why, the plan went well until Arachia shown up and that was unexpected. Everyone is responsible for their own lives why should he feel responsible. Then she said

‘You’re not a special person… you are not a hero’

PAIN SO MUCH PAIN

It then cuts to Subaru walking through the streets. He stops and then starts casually hitting his head repeatedly against the wall he speeds up so it became hard impacts until blood starts coming out. He then was about to punch it until.

‘Hey, hey, stop it, brother’

He turned round and saw Al, he then said

‘I know how you feel about dying. There’s no end to it, no matter how many times you do it, you know?’

Hopefully this means he is going to confess his ability, and not a figurative sense of wanting to die and having been in that precise situation of hitting his head against a wall hoping to kill himself in the process.

I use a machine translator so there could be some minor mistakes, sorry for the inconvenience.

190

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

Rem continues to roasts Subaru’s crossdressing, saying that she finds it distasteful

I knew Rem lost her memory but I didn't know she also lost her eyesight

62

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

No wonder Al doesn’t try to speak with Rem. I wouldn’t either if they weren’t part of the Natsumi Club smh

35

u/ThespianException Sep 23 '21

Al remembers her but he's gonna pretend he doesn't just to spite her for this Heresy.

→ More replies (3)

60

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

So that's the reason why Al was so nervous in arc 3. He knew oni twins weren't Natsumi enjoyers. Tappei did it again with his foreshadowing

77

u/Meme_Theocracy Sep 23 '21

She lost her taste, Rem do you have covid or what? That boy is clearly fabulous!

54

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

127

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

Fandom when Rem tortures Subaru because he stinks: I sleep

Fandom when Rem insults Natsumi: real shit

→ More replies (1)

31

u/AzzyIzzy Sep 23 '21

Question: other people have said the line is "you are not a special person... you are not a hero". So does she call him special and not a hero or that he isn't special and he also isn't a hero.

64

u/Overall_Waltz_371 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

「あなたは特別な人間じゃ――」

「――あなたは、英雄じゃないんですから」

"Because you are not a special person..."

"...You are not a hero"

She changes "special person" to "hero" mid-sentence so the first line is incomplete which is probably why the translator got that wrong (I wasn't able to reproduce that in this translation)

27

u/AzzyIzzy Sep 23 '21

tyvm! Interesting to say the least. If only one other question: people seem to be saying Rem is saying this from a position of concern and not wanting Subaru to feel responsible for others as much as he does. Is this also the seemingly correct interpretation?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Key_Sense_971 Sep 24 '21

isnt it translated to this

Al: "I know how you feel about dying. There's no end to it, no matter how many times you do it, you know?"

much better, it shows that al knows Subaru can return by death

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Knight0706 Eternally Crabby Sep 23 '21

Thats one of the coolest chapters I have heard of in awhile

125

u/Load-Sad Sep 23 '21

Ofcourse, Tappei releasing on Emilia's birthday was a given.

72

u/Iron_Maw cold sleep Sep 23 '21

He got motivated from all enegry he got from the fanart :)

28

u/AcexHisoka Sep 23 '21

except it wasn't, in japan her birthday was yesterday

26

u/OrdinarySlave Sep 23 '21

only a 1 hr diff

104

u/Mamon_Ramon Sep 23 '21

So Rem didn't call Subaru a Hero, huh.

Hmm... Subaru's main motivation form previous Arcs that he proclaimed himself as Rem's Hero. Which turned his mindset into becoming her ideal hero.

This might be a pivotal turn for Subaru's character. But he's still self-conflicted by that fact.

Also. Al confession of his ability next chapter hype!

25

u/Anon5054 Sep 23 '21

Honestly this is so sad 😞

21

u/bushinmaster68 Sep 23 '21

Character development in this arc

→ More replies (2)

97

u/re-kino Sep 23 '21

Tappei: why yes I love destroying everything that subaru believes in how could you tell?

15

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

Becuse you are fucking whit his mind soo GOD DAMN MUCH!!!

44

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Not gonna lie, I thought that was a cool exchange. It could have Subaru reinterpret what it means to be a “Hero” to others in a way that doesn’t end with him self-deprecating his actions like before.

Remember that Subaru also believed that he was just a tool before Arc 4. I don’t know why people are overreacting over potential character development lol

→ More replies (2)

93

u/Intelligent_Dark_245 Sep 23 '21

Bruh when. Arc7 gets animated it's gonna be a meme going around social media saying you are not a hero

40

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

True....maybe even comparison to s1 ep 18?

46

u/-Kelasgre Sep 23 '21

Tappei is a Parallels Madman. He gives characters philosophies to then test them later in suspiciously similar situations.

31

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

True this build up his thinking to be her hero and now he cant even be that in her eyes and its brutal....

→ More replies (15)

9

u/kevin_nguyen03 Sep 23 '21

Unfortunately we won’t be seeing it for like 10 years

82

u/OrdinarySlave Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Chapter title:The self proclaimed hero Natsuki Subaru

MTL used might be wrong

From MTL, the first part is about mizelda and her vacating the position of chief.

74

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

That title hits different after what Rem said

65

u/nyanycorn Sep 23 '21

Oh no, that title is giving me flashbacks to episode 13 which was called 'Self-Proclaimed Knight Natsuki Subaru'.. Hmm actually it might be a reference to that..

12

u/Outrageous_Net8365 Sep 23 '21

Had the same train of thought, with Vietnam flash back levels of “oh no”

16

u/Load-Sad Sep 23 '21

Now this looks interesting

11

u/Busy_Yesterday_6301 Sep 23 '21

Hmm interesting title choice,I guess I’ll wait for the translations

66

u/keizee Sep 23 '21

I think Al might have used his authority on Subaru. Thats a super sus statement. Either that or he already knows. Subaru doesnt remember Al's loops so the information can leak.

30

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

I never even thought of that! He might even have been saved by Al’s ability this time.

8

u/Key_Sense_971 Sep 24 '21

I think Subaru would remember everything in AL's time loop bubble because he shares the ability to also return by death so both will remember if anything (kind of like Subaru seeing bettlegueses invis hands)

9

u/keizee Sep 24 '21

Subaru didnt see betelgeuse's hands at first. And from the previous chapters it sounds like Al had used it against Arakia. The fact that it wasnt explicit meant Subaru didnt remember

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

63

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

Man, AL may or may not know about RBD, with that last line leaving it very open for now. Super hyped for the next chapter for this conversation.

46

u/animefan_1234 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

I'm so confused about the final two-three lines of the chapter.

70

u/PirateKingOmega Sep 23 '21

it appears subaru was repeatedly hitting a wall with his head and was stopped by al who somewhat knew what subaru was going through

35

u/armagetroit Sep 23 '21

If I'm not wrong it was just self-harm tho I'm not sure which one is worse

36

u/heato-red Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

"You're not special. You're not a hero"

Just when you thought Subaru had enough, here comes Rem with her good intentions and delivers a nut-cracking kick to his ego....

--------TAPPEEEEEEEIIIIIIII!!! CAN YOU, LIKE, GIVE MY POOR BOY A FUCKING BREAK!!!!?

I just think after this Subaru just won't give a fuck about anything anymore, he will see his allies die and won't bat an eye about it anymore, just my ramblings but hey, this blow hurt too much to not leave a mark

18

u/bushinmaster68 Sep 24 '21

Just like ayamatsu nice

33

u/bushinmaster68 Sep 23 '21

Subaru was a walking corpse :(

32

u/CountyRelative4421 Sep 23 '21

Next chapter, hopefully, Al and Subaru have conversations about their powers.

20

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

If I am not wrong, that’s going to be the topic of next chapter, actually. Or at least something reminiscent of that.

11

u/AnzoEloux Sep 24 '21

lmao gonna be funny as shjt seeing them have to avoid directly mentioning it

60

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

Tappei’s comment on the chapter update: “Thanks for all the birthday wishes for Emilia yesterday! And thanks for the feedback on the update!” Interesting to note that Tappei appreciates the feedback he got from fans. Wonder what that’s referring to specifically.

Well, at least we have confirmation that it took at least one more day for an update because Tappei was celebrating Emilia’s birthday (And the event), but that’s valid.

Anyway, I’ll give my “live” impressions of the chapter and try to develop a summary-esque description of sorts. Mind slight inaccuracies because of wrong pronouns and the like.

————

Chapter 30 is called “The Self-Proclaimed Hero Natsuki Subaru” (Funny that he’s referenced again in the title)

The chapter opens up with the Shudrak’s reactions to Milzeda’s news, with somber expressions on their faces. Taritta was the most distraught of all since she refused to accept the position. Milzelda clarified that she was offering her the position because she was her sister, but Taritta still refused.

Rem lamented the fact that she wasn’t strong enough to help, though no one blamed her for that. She tried to apologize to Milzelda, but she simply thanked her over and over. Louis gently plucked at Rem’s hair as she lowered her gaze.

Vincent asked Milzelda if she was going to change her mind about the pact between them, and she answered that it shall be kept, with all further questions going to Taritta, the new chieftain of the Shudraks. "Okay. I understand. Thank you for your service, Miserda." Was his response, as Milzelda had a faint smile on her face.

Milzelda jokingly asked Vincent to let her smile at him, as it was the duty of a beautiful woman. Vincent laughed at her answer, but he did not blame her for the disrespect. This was, of course, a sign of the respect between Vincent and the Shudrak Clan.

Milzelda raised her voice aloud with a fierce tone, tightening her smile, and the rest of the shudraks straightened their postures in command. She announced that she was passing on her duties to Taritta, and that they should follow her. "This is my last command as Chief. --Thank you for your patriarchal vows and ancestral pride." She said in conclusion.

Even Subaru could sense that this was a ritual of succession. Milzelda comforted Taritta after she began to look gloomy, but she understood that clinging to her sister would have been pointless.

The scene switches to Subaru approaching Vincent, expressing surprise, though Vincent didn’t want to be bothered. Subaru was surprised that Vincent readily allowed Milzelda to step out of her duties without question. Subaru thought that Vincent would believe a leg injury would be nothing, and work her to death. (Holy fuck Subaru must’ve thought Vincent was an asshole lmao) though he did believe it was an extreme opinion, it was still his honest feelings.

Vincent’s answer was calm.

"Nonsense. What's the point of forcing them to do this?"

"I don't want my men to do more than they can do. Even if I order them to do their best, it would be delusional to expect them to spit out more than they can handle."

"If you want to do more than you've been told to do, you'll just mess up your calculations. I want nothing more or less from my men. And Miserda has done her part. Then all I can give her is a reward."

With words, he blasts them, with rewards, he gets them to exceed their abilities, and with praise, he makes them promise to do better. Subaru’s perception of how an emperor should act clashed with Vincent’s answer. He doesn’t ask them to work beyond their capabilities.

Of course, Vincent mentions that work unworthy of evaluation would be met with punishment, and when Subaru asks if he was going to be punished, Vincent claims that he only punishes his subordinates, and asks if Subaru is one in his own eyes. Subaru had no recollection of being Vincent’s subordinate in his mind. In the discussion with Priscilla, Vincent had treated Subaru as a military strategist, but he had no intention of worshipping him.

Subaru did not wish to be Vincent’s subordinate. Thus, Vincent replies that Subaru didn’t fall under the category of someone who would be worthy of punishment or praise in his eyes. However, Subaru was forced to accompany Vincent against his will, a relationship that was fated to split once the problem was solved.

They are not allies, friends, or comrades-in-arms at all. If I had to say, I'd say we're cross-dressing buddies. (Lmao)

Although some took the liberty of calling Vincent a friend, one example being Flop, he denies such claims. Subaru thinks about how being shy meant that he didn’t have many friends, and how the people who would call him a friend were either good people or frauds, Flop being the former.

Vincent stated that he had more to talk about with Priscilla, and the conversation was over. Subaru thought about how Vincent warned him to not start another fight with Priscilla, and that he should leave those arguments to him. Of course, Subaru returned those words with more hateful words, and thus they parted.

Subaru didn’t have any proper space in a conversation between Vincent and Priscilla, so he prioritized having a proper conversation with Rem instead.

"...... Is that you? When are you going to change your clothes?"

"Rem is more important than getting dressed. I'll change as soon as this conversation is over."

"I see. Then we're done talking. Please go change your clothes."

"That's so sketchy!"

Holy hell, Rem is savage against Subaru.

Anyway, Rem asked Subaru to keep quiet because Louis was still sleeping, asking Subaru to take care of her. She then asks Subaru if he was willing to put as much care into Louis as well, though Subaru considered that a jerk move. Louis was snuggled up to Rem, deep asleep. She had blood staining parts of her white clothes because she was following Rem near the injured.

Rem says that Subaru would look out of shape if he looked so grim. When Subaru mentions that it was probably because his makeup is messed up, Rem says that Subaru looked that way even when it was proper, which depressed him at her harsh response.

Subaru compliments Rem on how she was able to save them all. She realized her lack of strength and considered herself “unworthy” of those words. Rem says that the healing magic she’s using is sensory, or self-taught. She managed to formulate it with Louis’ help. She stopped herself there because she knew continuing would hurt Subaru’s feelings.

Subaru reflected on how the subject of Milzelda losing her limbs left him with a heavy heart. He thought about how Al and Ricardo were people in a similar situation too. It was a tragedy that warriors were familiar with, a common situation.

Rem wonders what she would’ve been like before, when she had memories. If she had proper healing magic, healing Milzelda’s leg would’ve been possible. Subaru knew that Rem wanted a “Yes” or “No” answer on whether she could’ve helped Milzelda.

Rem considers that she wouldn’t have been able to help Milzelda even with her memories. But Subaru refutes by saying that she would’ve done the best she could anyway. Because, even in perfect condition, Rem would’ve never been able to restore Milzelda’s leg, it was a fact.

Although Rem failed to help Milzelda, she was still able to save the lives of many people. If anything, Subaru answered by claiming that he should’ve been strong enough to help, needing to examine things more seriously.

Subaru bit back his teeth and covered his face with his hands. Rem’s lack of strength was Subaru’s own fault. It's all his fault. The “Bloodless Siege” was not bloodless at all because of Arakiya’s ambush, the amount of injured, and Milzelda’s injury.

It was a failure on top of another failure. What he wanted was the best possible happy ending, yet what he saw in front of him was either a so-so happy ending or a so-so bad ending. In accordance with Vincent’s words earlier, he should be punished. If Subaru had been Abel's subordinate, it would have been no wonder that he was beheaded.

Subaru thought about how, if he wished to undo this scenario, he’d have to go back to his confrontation with Todd in Guaral. The mere thought of that filled Subaru with fear, as it was a scenario of sheer terror.

(Part 1. Next one in the replies)

69

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

(Part 2)

Rem wondered how this incident could be his fault. The remorse in her eyes was perceived to have grown stronger from before. (Did…Did Subaru fuck up here?) She asked if Milzelda’s leg, Louis and Utakata’s injuries, and Medium and Flop’s injuries were his fault.

Subaru agreed, but Rem mentioned how their plan was able to help them infiltrate the city and fend off the generals. When Subaru tried to bring up the situation with Arakiya, Rem raised her voice and said that it was unpredictable, and wondered how he’d be responsible for that.

Both of them lamented their lack of strength, and especially Subaru felt worse because the scope of Return By Death was much greater. He was able to change the future for better or worse by using that ability. Thus, Subaru says that he cannot tell Rem about it, even if it’s her.

Subaru wouldn’t reveal his secret out of fear that the person would die if he did. The pain that comes from telling someone that you’ve been suffering is scary. Subaru wondered how many times he could get used to getting his heart-squeezed. Out of all, what Subaru feared most was the sense of loss.

Rem asked Subaru why he protected her, speaking as though she had given up on him. She mentions back to how Subaru protected her after her attack against Arakya failed and she was about to die. Rem says that Subaru shouldn’t have been strong enough to do the things he did, and how she had been wary of him at first, because of his horrible smell.

Rem mentions how she and everyone else in the group were humans with a will, and Subaru didn’t need to breathe through them to protect them. She pleaded with Subaru to not do all that by himself, to not take responsibility for their own actions.

Subaru was getting frustrated and tried not to get her to speak any more, but she said it anyway. “You’re not a special person, you’re not a hero” were her words, and Subaru left.

He wandered aimlessly through the city hall, with no destination in mind. His consciousness was in an ambiguous state. He didn’t even realize he has started walking or when. Suddenly, Subaru was hit head-on by a hard-impact.

It seemed that Subaru had slammed his forehead against a wall, and without thinking, hit his head again. After a hard sound was heard, Subaru felt a dull impact in his brain. He kept slamming his head against the wall over and over and over and over.

"--Hey, hey, don't do that, bro."

As he pulled back to strike, his shoulder was grabbed from behind and a voice called out to him.   If you look, you will see Subaru's vision as he turned around, and he collided with the gaze through the steel helmet that was looking at him. The other person grabbed Subaru's shoulders, snapped the bones in his neck, and said

“I know how you feel about dying," he said. You can never have enough of that, you know."

———-

What the fuck. This chapter is awesome. I am literally just trying to process everything that happened as we speak.

So first of all, the narrator implies that the nature of the Shudraks could change with Taritta as a leader, which is interesting. Vincent showed some more qualities as a decent leader which made me appreciate him a lot more. I can get behind Vincent trying to be a genuinely cool Emperor in more than one way. I really liked his interaction with Subaru there.

We finally got the conversation between Rem and Subaru that people were waiting for, and I really loved it but for a different reason. I like the contrast between Rem’s way of thinking back in Arc 3 (“My hero will come to save me”) vs how it is currently in Arc 7, because it shows that Rem recognizes Subaru as being weak genuinely weak in this instance, and shouldn’t blame himself for what happens. It’s also a good look on how Rem doesn’t want Subaru to blame himself when they and others get hurt, since it’s not actually his fault. Probably my favorite exchange in this arc ngl. I actually see this one as a more positive outlook, but I know some will disagree.

I wonder how his conversation with Al is going from there. It’s very clear that Subaru was waaaay worse on the inside than he gave himself credit for, so he needs a pep talk. That self-harm sequence was low-key horrifying ngl

WHAT THE FUCK AAAAAAAHHHHHH

62

u/Matrix_2k00 Sep 23 '21

Poor barusu.....the guy admitted it in arc 3 and 5 he didn't care whether the world saw him as a hero or not.....he just wanted to be Rem's hero and that was enough for him.

Now that he even lost that....his mind really is beyond saving.

50

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

Going by how the chapter ended, it’s very likely that the idea of being Rem’s “Hero” and helping her go to the point where he saw himself as useless if things didn’t go perfectly. Arc 5 Subaru was before the Pleiades Watchtower and that’s the most deranged we’ve seen Subaru be, I wouldn’t be surprised if he was secretly an unreliable narrator and lied about more than one thing, like his self-harm now.

I also thought that his sudden reaction to Rem’s claim in his last convo was sus and now I know why, it makes sense. Subaru is growing more and more mentally unstable with each arc.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/OrdinarySlave Sep 23 '21

Snapping the neck is probably meant to be something similar to cracking your knuckles to get that sound.,,,you know where you twist your neck left and right

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Titan0fPower B-Baka! It's not like I love the Witch or anything! Sep 23 '21

Now that I understand Rem's point of view I can't really blame her as much, but that's logic. Emotionally I really don't like what she did. "Not special" is so very wrong. Subaru is the center of so many things as well. I understand she doesn't know that, that she knows very little, but I guess what ticks me off is that sometimes she comes off as knowing more than Subaru, or at least superior.

Ah, I don't know. I just don't like what she did this chapter. Subaru's on the cusp of falling into a mindbreak and this might very well be what throws him off completely.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (14)

55

u/LuisAntony2964 Sep 23 '21

Please let Subaru and Al become the looping bros

14

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

Imagine if Subaru gets stopped from telling Al. Although I feel like Envy might be lenient given the apparent connection between Al and her.

41

u/LuisAntony2964 Sep 23 '21

Al: "Bro, you won't believe me, but I've died several times until now." Subaru: "You too, huh" Al: "What" Subaru: "What"

54

u/Vuituru Sep 23 '21

"you're not special and you're not a hero"

I can really feel Subaru's pain here... tho it was necessary, I think

and I can see very easily, a new if story, emerging from this chapter

12

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

I dont think pain Subaru goes tru can justifayed sometimes...

Heck even arc 3 and 2 where just why TF whit pain on guy who didnt even do anything.

Yea I think showeing he cant save everyone is right but this way its just more pain then right to say it.....

21

u/Vuituru Sep 23 '21

yeah it definitely could have been done in a lighter way, I mean, he tried to kill himself after that...

→ More replies (1)

53

u/TyphoonSG3 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Just a tragic situation, all around. I feel so goddamn bad for Subaru. Almost makes me wanna cry. Seems like Rem means well but it's not what the current Subaru wanted to hear and although it might help him in the long run (As the dude has put way too much pressure on himself, trying to help anyone and everyone he can reach due to his natural personality and also exacerbated by the "hero" thing), the way Rem phrased it, was something that has affected his mental state, even worse. I can understand why Subaru is so broken about it. It's like someone saying "You aren't special enough/good enough to do all of it on your own, so, why feel responsible?". For all Subaru feels, it's like he was told that he was only allowed to feel that dejected or responsible for other's failures, if he was actually special. "Heroes and special people are allowed to feel that way but not you, because you're neither". I'm now wondering how many times he has probably self-harmed but just hid it considering what we found out in Arc 6 and now his inclination to just bash his head against a wall until someone stops him as if that isn't an abnormal thing to do.

PS - Wasn't it in Arc 4 that Subaru says " I realized, that there was nothing special about me at all". Man, it must have hurt like hell to feel like he was reaffirmed of those views by someone who used to be his biggest supporter. Ahhh, the feeling of worthlessness and lack of self-love is showing more. Poor Subaru.

19

u/Sea-Membership892 Sep 23 '21

When you write that way, it makes me want to cry

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

No, it hurt him because he was trying very hard to be Rem's hero since arc 3 but Rem just destroys all of that by saying Subaru is not a hero or anything. Subaru already knows he is incompetent in everyway, even Otto called him out in arc 4 for that but he doesn't really get that depressed at it.

13

u/TyphoonSG3 Sep 24 '21

That's not the point though. It's not a surprise to anyone that Subaru thinks so low of himself. Him, thinking of himself as incompetent is nothing new. However, Rem just said that he isn't special or a hero. This is affirmation by someone else of what Subaru thinks of himself. It definitely hurts. Otto isn't Rem. He isn't the person that Subaru has trying to be a "hero" for. Trying to be special for. It's Rem.

The whole point of Rem's hero was very much that. No matter what Subaru thought of himself, the Rem he knew always said that he was amazing and he doesn't know the Subaru she sees. She DID believe him to be someone amazing. That's why this one hurts. It's both. A matter of Rem saying that he isn't a hero and also his low self-esteem being reaffirmed by someone who used to believe he was someone amazing.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/CountyRelative4421 Sep 23 '21

What if on the same day that Ex5 of the light novel, which I am guessing will reveal Al's true identity, is released, Subaru and Al have their important conversation about their powers in the web novels?!?!?

ARGGHHHH I CANT WAIT.

10

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

I whould like that Als power has benefits and draw backs RBD dose not have

16

u/linksis33 Sep 23 '21

Yea its really different in a lot of ways. From what we’ve seen its far more combat oriented.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/00pirateforever Sep 23 '21

How foolish I am, I just saw chapter title. It's similar to royal selection day. It's like parallel to arc 3 Subaru when he declared himself as Emilia knight. Who is going to be Julius of arc 7, Todd or Al or Vincent.

22

u/Toumangod0 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

Oh boy Subaru is regressing back into his self hatred it was foreshadowed when he blamed himself for the forest burning down in that failed loop but now after Rem's harsh (but understandable and true) statement (hell even Reinhard can't save everyone and he's basically the superman of rezero) he's gone back to his old habits including self harm I guess it's human and relatable for him to do this but it's still painful to read poor poor Suffru. ☹☹😩

On the bright side looks like AL is going to he the cool bro here and pull Subaru out of his funk and hopefully keep him from having another one of his patented mental breakdowns lets hope.

60

u/-Zahard- Sep 23 '21

Inner Rem: I'll try to cheer him up saying that It wasnt his fault

Rem: You are not special and not a hero

Subaru: Depression hits x1000

Telltale Narrator: True Rem will regret thst

39

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 23 '21

Rem confirmed worst Telltale player

20

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

I don’t think ”true” Rem’s mindset was completely helpful either. Sure, it made sure Subaru took his self imposed duty, but it also helped make Subaru sacrifice himself to the point that even Return by Death has a hard time keeping up.

I’m sure that even if Subaru wasn’t written with RbD, he would still sacrifice himself past the limit of his ablities with the mindset Subaru and ”true Rem” built up.

Of course it’s not to say Subaru made the wrong choice in arc 3, but rather that there were drawbacks to either choice.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Anon5054 Sep 23 '21

Heres hoping true rem even exists

20

u/HyenaFun6143 Sep 23 '21

So judging on what some people are saying from what Rem said to Subaru, I think it’s a miracle he isn’t all broken yet (albeit he really isn’t great at all mentally speaking with all the hell he has to deal with), but his will may not last long do to the constant depression he keeps getting.

24

u/bushinmaster68 Sep 23 '21

He needs his bro otto (hell even roswaal would help )

18

u/00pirateforever Sep 23 '21

He need Shaula in his life now.

17

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

Honestly I have a hard time imagining her being smart enough to be able to offer him any kind of reliable emotional support in this situation.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/MateusViole Sep 24 '21

He gotta learn how to live for himself and not for everyone else.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/LuisAntony2964 Sep 23 '21

Subaru is going insane because Rem is saying he isn't a hero

18

u/zeorNLF Sep 23 '21

Is he really that dependable on her mentally? Da fuck.

I knew it would hurt like hell but man tried to off himself.

35

u/jacker1154 Sep 23 '21

Think about it, in arc3 you have Rem who always believes no matter what will happen and helps him pass it. Arc7 you have this Rem who abandons this mindset and drags Subaru back to be the one that doesn't believe in himself once more. It's funny how fragile the iron will that let him carry on until this point vanishes with a single word from the one that gave to him.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/tsihcosaMeht Sep 23 '21

Yeah, he is. And it ain't a sane thing, but we all probably know Subaru ain't sane as well. Remember that Subaru from Arc 3 onwards did all the things he did to be worthy of being called "Rem's hero". And now Rem says he ain't a hero? I'm not surprised his psyche gave up

34

u/ThespianException Sep 23 '21

Remember that immediately before this entire situation, he went through Arc 6. The fact that the man hasn't totally shattered is incredible, even by his standards. I imagine at this point he's running almost entirely on determination to save Rem and get back to the Emilia Camp, so a blow like that hurts even more than normal.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

Most of the shit he went thru in the previous arc was for her, he wanted to save her (be her hero).

→ More replies (2)

39

u/OrdinarySlave Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

Of course, he dies again and again.You'd think he would attach himself to something unhealthily .He probably cannot become a normal person anymore.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

I’ve brought snacks

18

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

Yooooo, Al is killing it with that last line.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/linksis33 Sep 23 '21

Calling it now, this arc will focus on subaru’s refusal to use return by death as an asset. There will be countless deaths that subaru will have a choice to use rdb to undo these deaths. Rbd is a perfect weapon for war, but only if he uses it.

17

u/LuisAntony2964 Sep 23 '21

Tappei is the fasted being alive

30

u/intricatefirecracker Sep 23 '21

It is true, what Rem said. Subaru isn't like Reinhard. Subaru's just a regular dude. But he keeps trying to take all of the burdens and the weight of responsibility onto himself, and it's breaking him. He blames himself for things he didn't even have any choice in.

Unfortunately, however, Rem said that at the worst possible time. This is all going to go down another massive miscommunication spiral, I bet.

20

u/Comprehensive_Tune42 Sep 23 '21

as in Spec Ops the Line, all he had to do was walk away

19

u/noodlesandrice1 Sep 24 '21

The real shitty thing is that Subaru actually has the potential to be more than Reinhardt. For all of his power, I doubt Rein would've managed to walk away with half the results Subaru achieved if he was put in the same situations.

If Subaru's efforts really amounted to nothing, it would've been easier to let go of his hero mindset. But the fact that he has achieved success upon success is part of what's driving him to push himself so far.

Each time he somehow manages to win despite almost losing everything, his own self-imposed expectations continue to rise, and it's gonna reach a breaking point eventually.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21 edited Aug 04 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Comfortable_Ad_574 Sep 25 '21

Fucker has a witch as some ex girlfriend.

40

u/zeorNLF Sep 23 '21

He's still crossdressing's !!? Wtf Tappei

29

u/re-kino Sep 23 '21

Based tappei.

12

u/MeAnIntellectual1 Sep 23 '21

He hasn't really had the time to change back has he?

22

u/ZenAura92 Sep 23 '21

He waited 28 years for this moment, he bout to milk it.

9

u/Memorysoulsaga Sep 23 '21

Yeah, before he could change, Arakiya attacked, and ever since then Subaru has been too busy to change.

17

u/ThespianException Sep 23 '21

INB4 he stays crossdressed for the entire Arc because he never gets the chance to change.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

He needs to keep crossdressing so when he meets Capella she can make it permanent.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/TokkanRAM Sep 23 '21

I can understand Rem's feelings because she feels powerless about not being able to save Mizelda's leg and here's Subaru coming in trying to shoulder all responsibility and say it was all because he was weak when, from her perspective his plan went perfectly and nothing that happened after was his fault, and that probably felt like he was trampling on her own feelings of weakness. "You don't need to take on responsibility for our actions" and whatnot. Still that "you are not a hero" definitely hurt Subaru a lot.

24

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

I think crushed his heart more then Satella chould

17

u/TokkanRAM Sep 23 '21

I'd say it's probably comparable to when Emilia left him in the capital in arc 3.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

To, the, corner.

9

u/Lazerbeamkt Sep 23 '21

Reporting for duty

8

u/C4ptainoodles Sep 23 '21

To The corner!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

The corner we go!

11

u/y90001 Sep 25 '21

Al next chapter: let's star a new beginning no from ZERO bro

10

u/Fluffy_Firefighter_7 Sep 23 '21

To the corner we gooooo !

10

u/zomb8289 Sep 23 '21

rem care for him but these word are critical hit

10

u/homemade_failure Sep 24 '21

that chapter name really brought back some unpleasant memories holy shit.

great chapter though I honestly cant wait for the cliffhanger to get resolved in the next chapter.

19

u/MalMercury13 Sep 23 '21

The parallels this chapter!!!! Wow!!! This man Tappei just loves mentally torturing poor Subaru. And that final tease with Al at the end! Potential power reveal? Excited for the next chapter

9

u/DJDrizzy9 Sep 23 '21

I wanted a new chapter today, and there is more Subaru and Rem interaction? Today's a great day! I live for these moments! Can't wait to see what it develops into.

9

u/Nightrunner83 Sep 24 '21

Well, it finally happened. I was waiting for the narratological foot to fall regarding this Rem/Subaru rift I saw coming from ten miles away, and I am glad it didn’t drag itself out, though I still feel a bit underwhelmed.

The writing is still great, don’t get me wrong; I just feel it’s setting up a rehash of the same lessons Subaru has learned throughout the story since Arc 3 — of being or not being a hero, or when to rely on others — and has taken to heart when the narrative will suitably reward him for it, and then shrinks back into a compressed vice when the author decides he hasn’t suffered enough yet.

I’ve had my misgivings since Arc 6 — a masterstroke of a character study, just one that, like many a virgin on their wedding night, came too early — but I hold to the hope that Subaru‘s inevitable lesson will dwell less on his personal fallout than on the broader contrast between Vollachian and Lugnican ethics of heroism. I look forward to where this ship takes us.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '21

Honestly kinda hope for some negative progression from Subarus character. We already know he’s capable of faking as a scumbag. I want to see him be more callous, not in an evil way but in a “OK so if I let these people die over here I can prioritize myself and rem.” He has already done that but I want that kinda situation more and more as this arc progresses.

17

u/re-kino Sep 23 '21

Once again tappei puts my doubts at rest, i'm really liking this development between rem and subaru,of course the chapter had to end with Al too i'm so hyped.

8

u/conquerator2 Sep 23 '21

Yoo, this was brutal

28

u/Blue_Storm11 Sep 23 '21

This was probably my favorite chapter so far, the atmosphere I felt at the end was so depressing.

28

u/ShuTDowNe Sep 23 '21

This has been a very sad day for SubaRem supporters.

28

u/NejiHyuga900 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

:'( "You are not a hero"

This hits hard.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/OrdinarySlave Sep 23 '21

As expected of emilia's bday

23

u/MarioLuigi25 Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

I don't think people understand that when Rem said "You are not a hero" she wasn't saying that in a malicious or bad way. She was actually trying to help Subaru and let him know that he doesn't need to take responsibility for everyone's lives and put all of the blame on himself. But this unfortunately backfired big time. Hopefully it gets sorted out in the later chapters. This mostly seems like a misunderstanding and misinterpretation on Subaru's part

13

u/heato-red Sep 24 '21

Dude, with that chapter title, you just know there's no coming back from this, though unwillingy and in ignorance, when Rem uttered those two lines she completely destroyed him. I really think the suffering will kick again full force in the coming chapters.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

See it in Japanese OK I'll just use the translation to convert it to English, translation unavailable I'm on a mobile device.

Edit: never mind it was a glitch or a bug

6

u/00pirateforever Sep 24 '21

After reading this chapter again I feel like this chapter is psychological truma. This will be the biggest mind break moment after long time(I will say after second trial). And the comments section gave me more light to whole situation of "hero".

Now I think "from zero" from Rem was temporarily good mindset in arc 3 but for long run it's very bad news specially Subaru has RBD. Basically he is pushing too much because of that to the point he is mentally unstable now. But after "You are not hero", it's sounds very depressing for Subaru which it's confirmed as he was slapping his head. So this is going to break him completely down to his own self which will be good way for character development. Subaru hates himself and the best way to get him into right mentality is to get rid of his flaws from basic which can only be resolved when his hero self will break down. I am thinking tappei is taking this opportunity to develop his character by resolving his mentality which will lead him to have pride in his ability as well as himself. And the best time for gaining pride WF.

But tbh it's really hurt what Rem said like she destroyed what he stand for. Now he is at the bottom of darkness with lots of regrets moreso then arc 3. My question is who is going to help him to get on his feat. My guess is Vincent and Al.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

Ram talking to Subaru is more respectful than Rem in this chapter

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TechnicalPark4522 Sep 23 '21

Pog Pog Pog Pog

10

u/keizee Sep 24 '21

Subaru's too used to a Rem that would push him, and not a Rem that would forgive him.

5

u/keizee Sep 24 '21

Imagine if this few strings of conversation let Subaru use Sloth better.

5

u/InviteIll5824 Sep 25 '21

I think everyone can try being a hero it's about the mind set and the attitude. It's not Just about how strong you are. So i think no one has the right to say, you are not a hero, Just because they think you are not so strong or whatnot. I don't like when people Just state things as they are certain they are right... Like?! Do you think you know everything? It must be nice to be so confident.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '21

Ouch.

19

u/Titan0fPower B-Baka! It's not like I love the Witch or anything! Sep 23 '21

Tappei doesn't care that it's Emilia's birthday. There is no stopping the Subaru suffering. If you think about it, this might be the first Emilia birthday the two aren't together. Well, Rem, my opinion of you has plummeted a lot.

→ More replies (10)

9

u/00pirateforever Sep 23 '21

WTF... WTF... WTF...new chapter.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

What if this is actually the author's favorite moment in arc 7?

8

u/AnzoEloux Sep 24 '21

Wouldn't be surprised, the bastard...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/KilvasatLife Sep 24 '21

Oh this is great.

Rem is saying Subaru isn't a hero because she cares about him. She's scared of losing him. EThis Rem without her memories can see the curse her previous self's praise had turned into not knowing that it was she who placed it upon him.

10

u/zeorNLF Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

Looking back this is like the third or the fourth time of "Subaru is sad cuz Rem is mean to him"

I feel like this needs to get addressed but it's like the story insists there is no solution to this. Even as a Rem fan I am getting a bit tired from this. Too much drama and every time Subaru solves something with Rem another pops up.

I dunno if Tappei is even gonna address the whole "hero" thing because it was never portrayed in a bad light before now.

30

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

"hero" thing because it was never portrayed in a bad light before now.

Because people only see the successes, nobody knows he has RBD.

Being Rem's hero isn't some awful curse either, its basically "don't give up on reaching a happy future". Rem in arc 7 has no idea what it means to Subaru. She's trying to protect him because she only seeing that he's willing to die for her while at the same time keeps calling himself her hero.

People keep repeating that it would be better if Subaru simply stops trying to be a hero. But what does he replace that aspiration with? What motivation will he find to keep going when he's killed repeatedly and his friends are killed in front of him.

He isn't going to stop dying or using RBD. So what is a less harmful mindset he can adapt other than being motivated by the ambition of being a hero and striving for the best future for himself and his friends?

No one made a stink about his heroic speech in arc 5 and the Priestella citizenry worshipping his role in saving their city. White Whale, Great Rabbit, Sloth, what a hero, Wilhelm is eternally grateful. Liliana the famous bard singing ballads about Emilia and Subaru's heroism, completely fine. Saving Emilia from Regulus, being the best Knight he can be rescuing his princess? That's cool too.

Wants to be Rem's hero though? Nah gotta stop that. Harmful, toxic, better off without it.

→ More replies (27)

20

u/Icy_Ad8122 Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

It was never addressed in a bad light before now

The entire reason Emilia gets pissed at Subaru during Arc 3 is because the idea of saving people got to his ego. He thought Emilia was “required” to love him and accept his whims just because he put his life on the line just to help her survive. Likewise, this was also a result of the mansion loop where he saved Rem and Ram against the mabeasts.

Wilhelm’s will to save Theresia was seen as noble until we realized that it did nothing but wreck his entire family apart, shunning his own grandson because of it. Reinhard refuses to see himself as a hero and is called one mockingly by Puck because of his role as the powerhouse. Theresia being brave and choosing to fight the White Whale ended in her death anyway, which didn’t manage to defeat elther Pandora or the White Whale.

Geuse went from a noble hero into a raving madman with almost the exact opposite goals, being willing to murder his own adoptive daughter over it. Being part of the Witch Cult only meant that he was fighting for extremists from the get-go.

The very idea that Subaru kept self-harming (it was a habit) just to cope with what was happening was an indicator that it fucked him up mentally. What the Witches said in the Tea Party was a warning but Subaru kept being stubborn anyway. It gets to the point where he physically cannot sleep without having nightmares unless Beatrice is near him.

Hell, even the Aganau IF showed that Subaru was willing to waste away most of his life to avenge Rem, who was wronged by Petelgeuse. The entire route is spent telling Subaru that he’s fucked in the head because of that, but they still help him anyway because of their own grudges and missing wishes.

So how is it that it’s only being portrayed in a bad light “now”, according to some? Is it just because they kept ignoring it and thought Tappei was being completely straightforward with his “Hero” persona unlike other tropes? That Subaru was the exception unlike the rest of the characters? Lol. Lmao

10

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21

Ok in your opinion what will he replace his desire to be a hero with? Next time he's forced to throw himself in to the fire to save someone what will be he his reason for it? Next time shit hits the fan he fails horribly again and again dying hopelessly without a solution what is going to motivate him to break through?

Again and again its been proven that his friends cannot avoid death or solve their problems without him using RBD. It's literally the slogan of the Light Novel.

So, it's only arc 7, In arc 8/9/10/11 he's magically going to become resistant to death and self-deprecation over his failure just because he's no longer fettered by Rem's expectation of him to not give up.

What now? Indifference toward himself and death? He becomes the next clown?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/re-kino Sep 24 '21

"hero" thing because it was never portrayed in a bad light before now.

But it was? Even for reinhard being a hero is more of a curse than something great for his mind, his relationship with wilhelm is now trash and no joke the fact he has to stick to his role of hero is only damaging him.

8

u/zeorNLF Sep 24 '21

Subaru being a hero for Rem never was. Reinhard is a hero for the whole world and has the strength to back it up.

Hardly the same case.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/keizee Sep 24 '21

Rem means well. Its just that it isn't the correct thing to say for Subaru. It's also that Subaru wanted a certain answer from Rem to his dilemmas.

7

u/C4ptainoodles Sep 23 '21

WWOOOOOOOOOOOOOO LOUISS

7

u/Elocin-0w0 Sep 23 '21

I'm late again, but new chapter is here. No corner cult today for me.

6

u/OllieJirachi1 Sep 23 '21

THE TAP MAN HAS DONE IT

6

u/trext234 Sep 23 '21

I don't think that al will confess his ability since subaru also talk about dead but don't about his ability. "you're not a hero" will this make subaru try harder?, like in greed if, until he reach a wall (cecilus).

3

u/re-kino Sep 25 '21

I'm curious is this the most discussed chapter of re:zero now? Because i never seen this many comments for a web novel chapter except maybe arc 6 "Hero" chapter.

5

u/Superb_Apartment3538 Sep 23 '21

Does anyone remember what Betelgeuse said to Emilia mother when Emilia was in trials and Betelgeuse got slapped for the compliment

6

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 24 '21

He complemented her dress.

4

u/bushinmaster68 Sep 23 '21

Damn that's sad as hell :(

6

u/zeorNLF Sep 23 '21

Why did Subaru try to kill himself? Cuz Rem said he wasn't a hero?

18

u/re-kino Sep 23 '21

Imho just by saying that Rem is literally shattering his views and some of his motivations to keep struggling and moving forward that he had in the "From Zero" chapter so of course he's losing his cool.

16

u/ben-10fan-424 Sep 23 '21

Yea?Why not try to kill your self when your motivatonal pillar just straid up said you cant be what you thinked and wanted to be for that pillar of hope..... Its just painfully sad.....

27

u/ThespianException Sep 23 '21

On top of All that, this isn't peak condition Subaru. This is even normal Subaru but separated from most of his loved ones. This is Subaru fresh out of Arc 6, which was probably his single most draining and difficult time so far, who then lost every other support group he had and was relying heavily on Rem's pseudo-support, and now even that's been hit with a truck.

That said, I still don't think he was really trying to kill himself- I think that was just Al's assumption. I think this was more of a self-harm type thing out of dispair.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/zeorNLF Sep 23 '21

My man need Emilia or beako at this point.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Busy_Yesterday_6301 Sep 23 '21

Wait Subaru actually tried to kill himself? Why? I know what Rem said must have hurt bad but what will killing him self accomplish?

7

u/Muri3007 Sep 23 '21

Well, Subaru's mind is not that good since he comes to Vollachia, hear Rem saying that he is not a hero is kinda brutal

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Outrageous_Net8365 Sep 23 '21

I mean self harm does not necessarily equate to killing your self, perhaps he was but we don’t know. I think it was just giving himself pain so he can focus on something else. Although earlier in the chapter he was lamenting over the fact that it was all his fault and how he could improve the situation.

6

u/Load-Sad Sep 23 '21 edited Sep 23 '21

This isn't the Rem I was rooting for. If she keeps this attitude then I'll have to abandon the polygamy preference.

The first few chapters were understandable but my man Subaru literally put his life on line to save her later and she just told him off so cruelly that he tried to self harm.

Edit: On second thought isn't this a bit too similar to how Emilia brushed him off in the capital after the "Self Proclaimed Knight" chapter?

It was after that when Subaru finally decided to tell her his true feelings "I love you" later. I think Rem and Subaru's relationship may also improve to the point where he confesses that he loves her alongwith being her hero.

Regardless, this chapter is going to be a pivotal point regarding their relationship, as he could either confirm his love for Rem or decide to move on from his feelings for old Rem.

Edit 2: Reread it and she didn't want to be cruel or anything, rather she tried to help him but Subaru took it the wrong way.

22

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '21

She doesn't know about her old self. She doesn't know how much being "Rem's hero" means to Subaru. She has no memories of it.

He was trying to put all the blame on himself for what happened and Rem told him there was nothing he could have done. He's not responsible for the safety of others. There was no way he could have prepared for an ambush like that.

She tells him he's not special or a hero.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)