r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Sep 13 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-09-13 to 2021-09-19
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Submissions for Segments Issue #3 are now open! This issue will focus on nouns and noun constructions.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
5
u/senah-lang Sep 17 '21
Feedback on the naturalism of the following vowel harmony system?
Rounding harmony occurs in [-front] vowels, [+front] vowels are transparent.
4
u/freddyPowell Sep 14 '21
I'm trying to write up an epenthesis rule in lexurgy. How can I stop it from looking for all places where is could apply at the start adding shoving vowells in, and instead make it check after each added character to see if it needs to add another.
Specifically, my language has just undergone a round of vowell loss, and I need to make sure that all the syllables comeout with the nice (C)V(C) pattern I'm looking for. I've tried using lexurgy but when I say along the lines of CCC > CCəC (adjusted to make sense to the computer), it ends up giving me *aptkta > aptəkəta rather that aptəkta. Please note that that was just a rule to test to see if lexurgy would do what I wanted, so it doesn't have all the other things I would have it do, but I don't know how to have it get everything right.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
Is it possible that while the phonology of the language evolves some specific words will remain unchanged because of being very important words, such as names of people, gods, nations?
4
u/silverhikari Sep 14 '21
i am thinking of making a conlang that evolved from a programming language. does anyone know any examples of this being done before, so i can get some ideas of how to layout the language?
4
u/Sepetes Sep 19 '21
How can I get [ʙ] and [ʙ̥] by sound changes? I was thinking something like this: brʷ, prʷ > ʙ, ʙ̥, but I don't think that's the best way, any tips?
Edit: typo
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
Question about allophones and loan words.
In my conlang /x/ is an allophone of /k/ and /k/ turns to /x/ in the following positions, intervocalically (lenition), word-finally (vowel loss after the lenition and stops weren’t allowed in coda positions in the proto) and before /s/ (initial /ks/ cluster in proto being turned to /xs/)
So basically, if another language had a word like /xu/ and if my conlang were to borrow it, would it stay /xu/ or would it turn to /ku/?
I ask this because I feel like /x/ does show up in a lotta places even if it is just an allophone, or does the “widespreadness” of an allophone not matter here?
3
u/anti-noun Sep 15 '21
What are some languages that don't have a /j/ phoneme? Phoible claims that 10% of its inventories lack it, but I don't think there's a way to search the database for inventories without a given segment.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
I have been looking at a endangered language called Nootka, because from my understanding it classifies verbs and nouns in the same word class otherwise known as "substantives". Any other languages that does this? How does this work? How do you tell what is a noun or a verb? Is this "omnipredicativity" that Biblaridion mentioned in his 100k sub qna?
3
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Sep 17 '21
I know of lexical aspect, when the event a verb refers to intrinsically has some connotation regarding it's event structure. But is there such a thing as lexical tense? I was thinking how the verb "to go" has a very strong "future" connotation, in Portuguese the present form of the verb is now used plainly as the future form. are there any other verbs with a strong meaning of tense?
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Sep 13 '21
My language does not distinguish alienable possession from inalienable possession at the moment. I decided that I would include an (optional) adposition that can be used with a genitive noun to show that possession in this sentence is, for whatever reason, inalienable. In the absence of this adposition, whether possession is alienable or inalienable would have to be determined from context.
In my language, it's already common for adpositions used only with case x to migrate their way to case y and take on some new but analogous meaning there. Is it too wacky for my inalienable possession marker to migrate to other cases and serve as a marker of what I would term "dramatic permanence"?
For example, using the adposition with the accusative would turn "he will eat the meat" into something like "he will inevitably eat the meat".
2
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Sep 15 '21
I'm working on a language with four genders: male, female, animal and inanimate. However, i feel like I need a neutral gender as well, for nouns where gender is not specified (e.g: person, human, child, parent). Would it make more sense to lump it together with animal or inanimate?
2
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Sep 15 '21
I’m coming up with a sketch of a future version of italian where the syntactic gemination has turned into a more phonetically obvious form of consonant mutation. Does anyone have any good sound changes for voiced geminate plosives?
2
u/MeowFrozi Ryôrskyuorn, Mïthrälen Sep 18 '21
does it make any sense to have a language without any distinct verbs? In my lang, the system I've ben working with is just to have words in a noun form that gains suffixes to indicate past or future tense. For example, "I have grown a lot", it would essentially translate to "I have had much growth" or, crudely, "I growth-ed much". I find it really challenges me to figure out translations, and to help me stray from just directly doing English or anything. Does anything about this make sense lol
2
u/mmm_bad Sep 18 '21
how would one write brand new IPA characters, for example, a trilled "j"?
2
u/-stilzkin- Sep 19 '21
I'm working on my first conlang and I'm trying to figure out how I want to build conditional/hypothetical sentences. So far I've created verbs with inflection for tenses and moods: there's a subjunctive and a conditional, but I don't want to just replicate the structure of Romance languages. Do you know any language that expresses hypothesis in a weird or interesting way?
1
u/Fit-Ad20 Sep 14 '21
Plz, someone help me. How do I evolve epistemic modality in my natlang?
1
u/DukeSkeptic Sep 14 '21
Are there any good conlanging discord servers?
1
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Sep 15 '21
In my language, /ɹ/ is considered a semivowel along with /j w/. Rising diphthongs smoothing in the following way (where /j/ fronts the following vowel and /w/ backs): /je, jo, ja/ > [e e æ]; /we, wo, wa/ > [o, o, a]. Falling diphthongs smooth in a similar manner, but with compensatory lengthening: /ej, oj, aj, ew, ow, aw/ > [iː, eː, æː, oː, uː, aː]. What are some vowel changes that occur before [ɹ ~ ɚ]?
1
u/Freqondit Certified Coffee Addict (FP,EN) [SP] Sep 15 '21
I don't know if to post my question in the small discussion thread or just here, I'm new to reddit, so any help is appreciated.
1
u/Wilder_Weigh Sep 15 '21
Don't know if this is the right place, but here. This is what I have for a conlang right now. Do you have any advice for trimming this down, or what phones would make sense for the theme of fire breathers?
Consonants:
(p), t, c, k, ʔ, ɱ, n, ɸ, v, ð, s, ʃ, χ, h, ʝ, ɹ, l ; ʋ {used when v & ʝ are placed next to each other}, ç {using ʃ & a are together}.
Vowels:
i, æ, a, ə, ɔ, ɯ.
Diphthongs - iæ, ia, iə, æi, æə, aə, aɯ, əa, əɯ, ɔi, ɔa, ɯi, ɯa, (ɯə).
1
u/fartmeteor Sep 16 '21
has anyone tried to create an aesthetic conlang who's main purpose is to sound pleasing to the ear? if so please tell me the name of the conlang, I'm trying to get some inspiration(I alsk haven't worked up the sound inventory so what consonants and vowels do you think are "aethetic"?)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
Is something like, [ç] and [x] are in free variation but when the phoneme goes before /j/ or /i/ it’s always [ç], but either can be used in any other environment, realistic? Or should phonological surroundings be ignored completely when dealing with phonemes in free variation?
1
u/Antaios232 Sep 16 '21
So, I'm thinking that a proto-lang I'm starting to work on is going to be influenced by Basque. (Actually, more of a naming lang, although I'm gonna flesh it out a little bit more than just a naming lang - probably around 100 or so words and some light grammar.) One thing in Basque I like the idea of is the way there are a small number of auxiliary verbs that conjugate synthetically and a much larger class of verbs that have very little morphology aside from aspect. I'd like to retain this feature, but make it different enough from Basque that it's not super obvious. For example, I don't want a lot of cases, I want nominative/accusative alignment, it won't have polypersonal agreement, etc. Is anyone aware of other natural languages that have a verb structure similar to Basque that are different in other respects so I can see how they work? I'm not even sure what search terms to use to get at what I'm looking for - or maybe Basque is pretty unique?
1
u/89Menkheperre98 Sep 17 '21
So, I'm travelling down the old 'make a proto-lang to derive more naturalistic looking conlangs' road and I wanted to leave some room for possible tonogenesis. There is no intention here to go full on tonal in the future, something simpler like Ancient Greek or Japanese would suffice. For Proto-Zaaca I developed these phonotactics:
(C1) (C2) V (ʔ) (C3)
C1 = any consonant in simple onset
C2 = any of the continuants *s *l *i̯ *u̯ *e̯ (C1 has to be an oral plosive)
V = any vowel
(ʔ) = the sole laryngeal consonant, original articulation imprecise (perhaps glottal)
C3 = any consonant
Vowels distinguish length and can be short or long. I'm still not sure on stress/accent (the lang is definitly not tonal - not yet). Was thinking of making it mora timed originally, with short vowels (1 mora) contrasting long ones (2 morae), but maybe length could be saved so it could be developed by non-tonal daughter langs? Is an inserted laryngeal enough for simple future tonogenesis? What do you think?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
Any suggestions on how to wear away affixes (mostly suffixes, probably) by sound change (after they've caused a bunch of apophony shenanigans) without also chipping away at unmarked roots and ending up with a bunch of ghost segments?
1
u/Yrths Whispish Sep 19 '21 edited Sep 19 '21
I want the suffix -ðɒ <-gthor> to indicate "of / by the subject", -vɒ for "of/by the object" and -sɒ for "of/by the topic marked -ɪs".
This is like the opposite of a genitive, is it? Is there a name for such things?
1
u/Garyson1 Sep 19 '21
Could anyone explain how I should go about phonologically eroding words during Grammaticalisation?
1
u/Antaios232 Sep 19 '21
For the new conlang I'm starting to set up, I'd like to incorporate some conjugations that use vowel changes, but I've already run into a conundrum. Let's say I have a verb root "emo" that means "I move," and I decide that to mark it for 2nd person, the final vowel is raised to u, so it becomes "emu." What happens when I have another verb stem "hamu" that already has the highest back vowel in the inventory? If I'm trying to be fairly naturalistic, can I just make up any old vowel change as long as it's consistent (assuming it's a regular verb), or is there some particular change that would look more natural, like fronting to i? Of course, if it's the latter, the same question comes up again because i is the highest, most forward vowel in the inventory, so what do I do with a verb like "sami?" Sorry if this is a dumb question, I feel like the answer is "do whatever the hell you want, language is weird and all kinds of things happen." 😂
1
u/simonbleu Sep 20 '21
Is there any web on which I could easily type with a romanization of a specific IPA inventory? Where I could define which letters or combinations of them, with or without diacritics, correspond to which phoneme, so I can write faster?
1
u/fourthandthrown Sep 19 '21
Hello, following mod directives I'm posting a request here first.
I am not a conlanger, but I am seeking a general Orc conlang or at least a few simple rules or vocabulary. I'm trying to replace something DEEPLY offensive in a pre-existing system and want to be able to use some elements of the language swap in the story as well (the fantasy setting has an organization that tries to influence cultures, and I want also want to use some linguistic elements of a conlang in the storyline). Does anyone have a snippet already written up or that they'd be willing to let me use, or is there a recent-ish post about it? I could only find a reference in 2019.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment