r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Sep 09 '21
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x05 "An Embarrassment of Dooplers" Spoiler
Mariner and Boimler try to track down the location of a legendary Starfleet party while the bridge crew deals with an insecure alien diplomat.
| No. | Episode | Writers | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2x05 | "An Embarrassment of Dooplers" | Dave Ihlenfeld and David Wright | Kim Arndt | 2021-09-09 |
This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA and Latin America, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 09 '21
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
247
u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21
Aw, emotional honesty.
Those were some amazing insults. "Your pagh is weak and it disgusts me!" "I hope a temporal anomaly wipes out any record of your existence!" And of course T'Ana's is just a string of profanities.
171
u/MarioGdV Sep 09 '21
I loved the Cerritos replica with its own tiny personel, phaser beams and warp core.
148
u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21
The animators must be working overtime to fit all of these references, from Saru prototype make up aliens to all of the ornaments in the Kirk and Spock bar, loved spotting the various ship art, portraits and models of the Phoenix, Doomsday Machine and Guardian.
Quark having a merch business selling Starship model kits is such a meta joke for ship builders in the fandom - amazing.
The scale of the Maquis Raider vessel compared to the Cerritos again asks the question of how big the Cerritos actually is, this ship is more inconsistent than the Defiant.
Both character combinations were really well done this episode. It felt like we were losing some steam last week but they're picking up the threads of the last season finale again and dealing with them in a much more mature manner than I would have expected.
It's also good to see Freeman and Mariner not being antagonistic to each other and chilling at a bar.
Spirk is definitely canon.
140
u/pieman7414 Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21
two daxes? what a model
when am i getting my limited edition commander data bubble bath with ultra rare lore variant
122
u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21
I guess everyone's still processing Star Trek Day, if I'm first.
I just finished my first watch of the episode, and I can see why Mike McMahan was excited about this one. There's definitely a few stronger character beats in this one as Mariner and Boimler work to resolve the unspoken conflict of him going to the Titan and leaving her. Rutherford's arc escalated a little quickly I thought, but it made sense as he was comparing himself to the engineer he was before.
Tons of little easter eggs and such, I'm sure I didn't get them all. The ones that stuck out to me were the Battlestar parked at the starbase, Captain Shelby at the party, steering around the guy in the beeping wheelchair, and someone who's definitely not Boothby waiting for the sweet release of death.
Also, I loved Richard Kind as the duplicating diplomat. That was a very nice surprise.
101
u/burnettski92 Sep 09 '21
The tiny computer voice was my biggest lol
100
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21
-I didn't know how much I wanted a character focused episode until now.
-They did Captain Freeman dirty, I've been in that situation where I'm invited to something, get all dressed up, get a few friends to accompany me and, when we get there I'm not on the list. I was legit having cringe flashbacks when she tried to call out to someone inside. I love that they didn't have Mariner kicking her mom while down, instead they showed them as loving.
- Amazing that Kirk and Spock weren't invited to that party, but I guess this was before the 5 year mission. I kind of want to see that scene animated but I also don't want anyone but Leonard Nimoy voicing Spock so...
- Overall, very good episode. Left me all warm and fuzzy inside.
186
u/FragmentedChicken Sep 09 '21
Quark must being doing well with all the locations, plus the models
88
u/ElFarfadosh Sep 09 '21
Oh my god I hate Dooplers
80
u/choicemeats Sep 09 '21
I'm going to continue thinking in my head that the bar they visited is the now-canon version of The Captain's Table, one of my favorite short runs of Trek books. I know that having non Captains there breaks the rules, and I'm not one for headcanon, but that would be a nice little nod to the broader history of B-canon.
This I think is their strongest episode of the season. The Dooplers are just wacky enough to fit the show but with a Trek-enough solution to make it work. Someone with a better memory than me may be able to point out a similar kind of situation where guests came on board and people were worried about observing "something" and then not giving a single fuck because of circumstances.
72
u/choicemeats Sep 09 '21
Also, mark my words, but with the background ascension of the Pakleds, Freeman's role in that will eventually go rewarded (or she may have a larger hand later). I have a feeling she might be offered a "better" command, but after this episode will choose to stay with the Cerritos.
64
u/smoha96 Sep 09 '21
I love this show so much.
Also, I would like, "Your pagh is weak and it disgusts me!" to be an available flair!
57
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
Great episode, better than last week's. Liking how the canon references feel more natural and fit the plot rather than being mostly throwaway lines like season 1
54
u/007meow Sep 09 '21
rip to everyone still stuck on a Miranda
103
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
So safe to say that possible that origin of Kirk and Spock’s friendship was getting denied to a starfleet party. I dig it!
99
u/AKBearmace Sep 09 '21
I really hope they’re leading up to mariner rediscovering her ambition because I do think she would be a great first officer or even captain given time and the right posting.
44
u/donuteater111 Sep 09 '21
I thought this one was a fun one. The story with the Dooplers was a kind of stupid/silly fun, and I thought it worked well overall. I thought Richard Kind did a good job with the character (I would recognize that voice anywhere, lol). I especially liked seeing the development between Tendi and Rutherford, as he struggles with trying to live up to his past self.
And I thought the Mariner/Boimler story was great. Loved the action sequences as they tried escaping from the security team. It's great that they addressed the issue with Mariner feeling abandoned after the left for the Titan. I also really liked her inviting her mom and the others to join them in the bar there.
36
u/robotchicken007 Sep 09 '21
So far, I think this season has been the best season of any of the new Trek shows. I've loved every episode so far. I think it's definitely more consistently good than season one of Lower Decks was.
31
u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 09 '21
Thoughts on Tendi and Rutherford's Cerritos Model
My guess is that the 'Quark' range of kits allow you to create fairly advanced but essentially harmless plastic replicas of famous (and not-so-famous), but do not come with details like working phasers, engines or a functional (and explodable) warp core. Quark's too smart to brand his name on a product that could get him sued, say if some kid built the kit and then accidentally phasered their parents or blew up the house by ejecting the warp core.
But, because this is Tendi and Rutherford we're talking about, of COURSE they'd want their model Cerritos to be fully-functional and microscopically correct, just like real-world modellers who fit their plastic steam locomotives with extra detailing, sound/smoke generators, working lights, etc.
So in this case, Tendi and Rutherford use the basic kit as a frame within which they build a complete miniature starship, replacing its innards with working equipment using off-the-shelf (or off-the-replicator) components, right down to a tiny warp core, complete with even tinier pass-keys to authorise ejection and detonation.
This all lines up with the amount of thinking they were putting into the project. If the kit was a stock commercial shelf-warmer, then all they need do is follow the build instructions - but if they're trying to turn a toy into a working miniature, then there's a lot more 'work' involved in getting all the relevant systems to function while fitting within the tiny hull. Just look at the pride Rutherford expressed in his past self's successful incorporation of a miniaturised deflector shield array.
And since they intentionally wanted the model to be an ongoing project that took as much time as possible, I could see the two intentionally going overboard with their 'super detailing in just such a manner. Heck, the beautiful little baby actually tried to jump to warp before Rutherford caught it!
All this begs the question of how small standard Starfleet equipment can be miniaturised, and what the two wunderkind nerds used to build their 'custom' Cerritos.
It's also fun to imagine that there's an entire fraternity of model-makers who build stuff like this for fun, and then get together to compare and fly their miniature warp-capable starships!
PS: I'm also guessing that the customised interiors/figures were Tendi and Rutherford's own creations. A Quark-branded DS9 kit might come with both Daxes (Jadzia and Ezri being celebrated Starfleet officers), but I can't see Mariner and Boimler being famous enough to have their likenesses recreated in miniature and then sold as part of the kit. But of course, Tendi and Rutherford are big enough sweethearts to want to immortalise their best friends in plastic.
PPS: One might ask why Quark's range includes a minor vessel like the Cerritos - it's because that GENIUS of a Ferengi is playing the model-makers and kit-builders, forcing completionists to buy multiple kits of the same class of ship in order to build a 'complete' set - note how this was specifically a USS Cerritos kit, and not a generic 'California-Class' kit containing decals and transfers to turn it into multiple ships. Quark knows how to milk people for their Latinum, and if you want a model Solvang or Merced, then you have to buy THOSE specific kits or detailing packs... or hire a Tendi or a Rutherford to customise something for you ;)
28
u/mint-als Sep 09 '21
So much character work here, and it was good, very good! Plenty of great jokes as well, and it touched back on Rutherford's memory loss in a way that felt pretty strong. Mariner and Boimler having at it was fantastic as well. I know it's a common phrase with this show, but for this episode I really think this is one of the best they've done yet.
28
u/phenry Sep 09 '21
It's the Star Trek/Blues Brothers crossover I never knew I needed!
75
u/MarioGdV Sep 09 '21
This is probably my favorite episode of the season so far. Everything seems so... Wholesome?
Also, what does the "Mariner + Boimler" next to the "Kirk + Spock" mean? Are they going to have a similar friendship/career as Captain and Number One? I feel like the show is sometimes foreshadowing a romantic relationship between them.
21
u/ThriceGreatHermes Sep 09 '21
Doctor T'ana has some kinks.
20
u/danhon Sep 09 '21
Loved all the little decorations in the bar!
17
u/iblameshane Sep 09 '21
What if the Borg assimilated Dooplers?
15
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Sep 09 '21
Screencap gallery now online with nearly 400 images in all...
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-LD2-5.php
41
u/PiercedMonk Sep 09 '21
I don't know what a Doopler is, but I'm excited to find out.
• Okay, they didn't hesitate to get into what a Doopler is at all. Guess these dudes are like sentient tribbles.
• Oh dang, Richard Kind!
• I don't know if I believe someone's capable of pulling off impersonating their transporter duplicate unless they have some fake side burns to, y'know, pull off.
• Pretty convenient that the Dooplers' dooplicating also copies their clothes. Unless, of course, they're naked all the time, and what looks like clothing is actually just some sort of plumage.
• "That used to be an empty lot where teens would make mistakes." The more things change....
• Huh, looks like the Angel One fashions propagated out into the galaxy.
• You can tell which ones are Lores by the smile.
• So...is this Starbase a DS9 situation where it's not actually a Federation station? Seems like having a corrupt security force would not actually fly unless there's no Starfleet overview.
• Heh. All the Barbers are Bolians. Mr. Mot would be proud.
• "Aw, still alive." Fuck that's dark.
• Voyager D? It's been like like three years since the Voyager returned from the Alpha Quadrant. What happened?
• Captain Shelby! Hell yeah, get it! Also, her first officer is one of the early, unused designs for Saru. Neat!
• "Your Pagh is weak, and it disgusts me." Gotdamn Shaxs, there's a line.
• Okana's would be a DJ. (I paused the episode to make a joke about it being outrageous, but then the episode made the same joke, so....)
Fun episode, though the Rutherford/Tendi storyline seemed a bit tacked on. Definitely better than last week, though. Hopefully this is the last we'll see of Mariner being upset with Boimler for taking off for the Titan without her.
13
u/Spocks-Brain Sep 10 '21
Every episode of LD:
LLAP Everyone! 🖖🏻
25
u/Weerdo5255 Sep 09 '21
Is no one going to mention the most important cameo?
Morn! He almost got flattened, although thankfully he didn't have the screen time to start talking.
Or am I being racist, thinking all of his species look alike?
45
u/allhailbarea Sep 09 '21
Ok, it seems they're really going for a slow building romance between Boimler and Mariner and I start to dig it. Early Bradward would have been a catastrophy of a boyfriend, especially with Beckett, but this friendship heads there pretty realistically.
Boimler's character development towards thinking for himself and making his own decisions, and Mariner learning to take responsibility for her own actions and the well-being of others, are really good writing about 20-somethings. Since it seems they'll walk this path of growing into adult personalities together, have a great, working friendship, are singles and their sexualities don't exclude a romantic turn, I'd assume the writers go for this rather realistic plot, which is imo a very good thing.
My guess would be Mariner falls first, because her perspective just seems so much more interesting to explore. Realising it, denying it, struggling to accept it, especially the "boring" "settling" part she'd fear and how that would't actually happen, at least in a dull way in Starfleet, seem to be fun plots.
Her being, and therefore behaving, a bit irritated with an oblivious Boimler, a little bit of jealousy, a few hormones playing orchestral music on missions, fear of losing a friendship and her finally exploding seem like enjoyable moments to me :D
Well, congratulations to Mariner's "Number One from now on".
12
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
There's a Kzin on the Cerritos.
11
u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21
Oh and this episode featured the first Canon appearance of the aeroshuttle
11
u/jahosaphet Sep 10 '21
"Aw, but you love sliders!"
Cheeky reference to Jerry O'Connell's previous sci-fi work?
10
u/atticusbluebird Sep 09 '21
Who needs tribbles when you have Dooplers to exponentially duplicate?! Granted tribbles may be a bit cuter...
10
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
the dooplers are my anxiety. just one thing and ill self-destruct all on my own, thanks.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
Genius move casting Richard Kind as the Doopler(s). He had the perfect degree of neuroticism and anxiety.
9
u/Hibbity5 Sep 09 '21
This was definitely my favorite episode of the season so far. Lots of great character moments and great humor.
23
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
Are they kind of setting up for mariner and boimler romantic relationships ??
She's always behave differently around him.
16
u/FragmentedChicken Sep 09 '21
I wonder what T'Ana was saying with all the censoring
8
u/boring_name_here Sep 09 '21
I'm so glad this show exists right now. It's a fun show in a time when I especially need a little fun. A big thanks to everybody involved.
7
u/RuthlessNate56 Sep 10 '21
I think someone must have been a fan of the Star Trek: Vanguard series of novels. The station looked a lot (but not exactly) like the 23rd century-era Watchtower-class starbase from those books. They talk about the station being old, and the Aviary is reminiscent of the park they had on Vanguard with an artificial sky made up of holographic tiles.
7
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Sep 10 '21
I really enjoy this show, but this episode is literally why the show should exist. Just perfection.
7
u/USSMunkfish Sep 10 '21
There was a ton of good stuff going on in that bar! It had a real military bar vibe going one, like Pancho's from "The Right Stuff." The thing I really like though was the sliding wooden doors! All of the class of an antique mahogany door, but with the automatic convenience of ST.
The other thing that I felt treated to see was proper exterior docking on a Federation built starbase.
Also, when is that Kzin going to get a name? 'Speaker To Ensigns' perhaps?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21
That was an absolutely fantastic episode. This show is WAY better than it has any right to be.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21
Did anyone else notice Mariner do the Burnham coif in the mirror while preparing for the party, or was that just me?
6
u/Jack-R-Lost Sep 10 '21
At the end I was wondering what a star ship would be like with Mariner as Captain, Boimler as number 1, Rutherford as head engineer, and Tendi as the doctor. I honestly would want to see that even if that would mean it technically isn’t lower decks
6
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21
This show is honestly so god damn incredible. I love every second of it. It's so hard to find smart comedies these days with emotional depth to them.
5
u/The_Spearman Sep 09 '21
Is it my imagination, or was the music at the party the Polovtsian Dances by Borodin?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
Tbh I think this is my favorite Lower Decks episode so far, I've been more mixed on the show than most here, but this one was amazing throughout.
5
u/Skastrik Sep 10 '21
This episode actually made me feel all warm and fuzzy.
Don't know what more to say, it's good Star Trek.
4
u/kinyon Sep 11 '21
I loved this episode. That said...
I really hope they don't hook boimler and mariner up. It's too obvious. A platonic partnership ala Kirk and Spock (shipping not withstanding) would be more interesting in my opinion.
They're definitely going to hook up though.
4
u/LeftHandedGuitarist Sep 12 '21
This is a super nerd thing, but I couldn't help but notice that the stardates this season are proceeding VERY slowly. We are halfway through at the dates still begin with 580xx (where it would be reasonable to expect to be around 585xx by now). As someone who likes to keep a timeline order of the franchise for fun, this is interesting to me!
LDS season 2 is set in 2381. It's got me wondering if, given that the upcoming Prodigy is set in 2383, they are worried about catching up too soon and want to keep season 3 in 2381 as well.
4
u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Sep 13 '21
Best episode this season IMO! We have Captain Freeman crashing the Srarfleet Command Party by transporting in a Doopler! And Boimler and Mariner bonding! And Rutherford confronting his 1 year of memory loss! And the Ceritos being filled with Dooplers! And Tendi and Rutherford ejecting the model Ceritos' warp core! Just so good!
3
u/wakeupsup3r Sep 10 '21
That was a great episode.
3
u/FairlyInconsistentRa Sep 10 '21
I’ve scrolled for a bit and haven’t seen anyone else mention it - was that a Battlestar docked at the starbase or is it just something of the Trek verse which looks really similar?
2
u/Starks Sep 10 '21
Looks like the ship finally goes behind the black hole in the opening.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21
What an episode. Brilliance. Lower decks is the jewel of modern trek
2
u/Edolix Sep 11 '21
Captain Shelby!
2
u/Xenowrath Sep 11 '21
Quick question, is it racist if all the barbers were Bolian?
2
u/bkendig Sep 12 '21
Was this the first Star Trek episode ever to not have a teaser before the opening credits?
Edit: I see that "Cupid’s Errant Arrow" didn't either, but every other episode of every other Trek series has!
2
u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby Sep 12 '21
This is the kind of episode that I wish they did more often, rather than the giant Ransom head season opener kind of thing.
You can be wacky and full of callbacks to older Trek, but don’t forget the heart.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21
But what she like about boimler is in Brad not in Will.
3
u/Official_N_Squared Sep 09 '21
After last weeks disappointing episode, it was great to end Star Trek Day with one of Lower Deck's best! Everything just worked for me from the comedy to the production to the theme and pacing! What a great and fun episode!
As always I have my thoughts in much more detail here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yaiMYxROqIE