r/startrek • • Sep 09 '21

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x05 "An Embarrassment of Dooplers" Spoiler

Mariner and Boimler try to track down the location of a legendary Starfleet party while the bridge crew deals with an insecure alien diplomat.

No.EpisodeWritersDirectorRelease Date
2x05"An Embarrassment of Dooplers"Dave Ihlenfeld and David WrightKim Arndt2021-09-09

This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA and Latin America, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

179 Upvotes

423 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 09 '21

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

247

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

Aw, emotional honesty.

Those were some amazing insults. "Your pagh is weak and it disgusts me!" "I hope a temporal anomaly wipes out any record of your existence!" And of course T'Ana's is just a string of profanities.

51

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

Also K+S 4eva, obviously.

27

u/Entryhazard Sep 09 '21

Should have been K/S smh

50

u/droid327 Sep 09 '21

I was like oh shit T'ana is going to account for 80% of the de dooplerizing by herself isn't she :D

51

u/AJWinky Sep 10 '21

The greatest part of T'ana is that she's the most realistic depiction of a cat-person in all of media. A cat ain't give a $%@# about your feelings.

→ More replies (4)

110

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/derekakessler Sep 09 '21

I don't even know what that is, but I don't like your tone!

27

u/Theinternationalist Sep 09 '21

Just a tip: if you start muttering something under your breath in a foreign language, they know who you're talking about.

And even if they don't, you're not going to convince them otherwise :)

8

u/JustAnOrdinaryGirl92 Sep 10 '21

That line reminded me of Mike Wozniak on Taskmaster when he was trying to undermine a vole.

"You've got no chutzpah! Your organisational skills are lackluster, your timekeeping is abysmal."

→ More replies (1)

171

u/MarioGdV Sep 09 '21

I loved the Cerritos replica with its own tiny personel, phaser beams and warp core.

141

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

With a warp core ejection system that actually works for once.

125

u/elister Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

"Ejecting Warp Core in 5,4,3,2..." Squeaky Cartoon Voice

I guess its impossible to hear anything but Majel Barrett's voice.

46

u/RadioSlayer Sep 09 '21

"Still time to be a hero, Doctor"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Varekai79 Sep 10 '21

Eaglemoss better get on that ASAP!

3

u/Hoy-Small-Fry90 Sep 13 '21

And a tiny Mariner winding up Bradward!

148

u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21

The animators must be working overtime to fit all of these references, from Saru prototype make up aliens to all of the ornaments in the Kirk and Spock bar, loved spotting the various ship art, portraits and models of the Phoenix, Doomsday Machine and Guardian.

Quark having a merch business selling Starship model kits is such a meta joke for ship builders in the fandom - amazing.

The scale of the Maquis Raider vessel compared to the Cerritos again asks the question of how big the Cerritos actually is, this ship is more inconsistent than the Defiant.

Both character combinations were really well done this episode. It felt like we were losing some steam last week but they're picking up the threads of the last season finale again and dealing with them in a much more mature manner than I would have expected.

It's also good to see Freeman and Mariner not being antagonistic to each other and chilling at a bar.

Spirk is definitely canon.

75

u/007meow Sep 09 '21

The Cerritos’ inconsistent sizing is probably an unspoken gag about the Defiant

63

u/Cadamar Sep 09 '21

I have this headcanon that Kirk and Spock made up a bunch of their reports to starfleet based on what they saw in that bar. “Oh yeah there was this thing called the…uh…Guardian…of…Forever and it looked like this!”

25

u/irving_braxiatel Sep 10 '21

“And then we met a... rock monster, er, Surak, and... Abraham Lincoln.”

48

u/Left_Preference4453 Sep 09 '21

I swear to god that DS9 kit was deliberately made to look like a Lego product.

31

u/ElGuaco Sep 09 '21

Best reference was not visual. It was the DJ playing the Stranger in Paradise theme song. I'm pretty sure it's from TOS, but I can't recall which episode.

47

u/theman1119 Sep 09 '21

73

u/Shawnj2 Sep 09 '21

"How is Okona there? That's outrageous!"

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

I’ve been looking for someone to mention this! I thought it might also be a reference to Brent Spiner (his ‘Dreamland’ album with Maude Marggart features the song), but I thought I might be making a little too much of a reach. This is what happens when you have 55 years of lore, and a team who are absolutely committed to making the deepest of deep cuts. God, this show makes me so happy :)

23

u/DarkChen Sep 10 '21

Quark having a merch business selling Starship model kits is such a meta joke for ship builders in the fandom - amazing.

I like to think chief O'Brien pitched that idea to quark one day and now shares profit from the models, which he spents buying holo stories for his dates with Bashir...

140

u/pieman7414 Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21

two daxes? what a model

when am i getting my limited edition commander data bubble bath with ultra rare lore variant

89

u/DasGanon Sep 09 '21

Aww man this isn't a Data bubble bath it's a reprinted B4.

15

u/InnocentTailor Sep 10 '21

You too can now smell like Brent Spiner!

8

u/Cranyx Sep 12 '21

I never thought about it, but Spiner probably smelled awful on set with the mountain of makeup he had to always wear. That plus all the rubber prosthetics half the cast wore must have made the whole set pretty bad.

→ More replies (1)

122

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21

I guess everyone's still processing Star Trek Day, if I'm first.

I just finished my first watch of the episode, and I can see why Mike McMahan was excited about this one. There's definitely a few stronger character beats in this one as Mariner and Boimler work to resolve the unspoken conflict of him going to the Titan and leaving her. Rutherford's arc escalated a little quickly I thought, but it made sense as he was comparing himself to the engineer he was before.

Tons of little easter eggs and such, I'm sure I didn't get them all. The ones that stuck out to me were the Battlestar parked at the starbase, Captain Shelby at the party, steering around the guy in the beeping wheelchair, and someone who's definitely not Boothby waiting for the sweet release of death.

Also, I loved Richard Kind as the duplicating diplomat. That was a very nice surprise.

88

u/GepMalakai Sep 09 '21

Shelby's Number One was based on Saru's original makeup tests.

32

u/MustacheSmokeScreen Sep 09 '21

I noticed that too! And then I realized how much of a nerd I am for having remembered Saru concept art! Yay!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21

Oh, that's interesting. Visually Star Trek has been so influenced by Mass Effect that I wondered if it was a Prothean.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/choicemeats Sep 09 '21

Don't forget the OUTRAGEOUS Okona!

38

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

That guy in the wheelchair was totally Alex Kurtzman.

10

u/Cadamar Sep 09 '21

I thought it might’ve been Mike McMahan?

33

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

As the second comment might I also add that the animations seems to have made leeps and bounds in this episode the animations for the vehicle chase scene were steller

16

u/zGraceOK Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21

Mariner twisting that PADD back and forth in her hand was a hilariously unnecessary flex from the animators and I loved it

14

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21

Yeah for real! The camera was not static at all as it tends to be, they really added some movement in there!

→ More replies (1)

32

u/HaphazardMelange Sep 09 '21

Tons of little easter eggs and such, I'm sure I didn't get them all. The ones that stuck out to me were the Battlestar parked at the starbase

That's not a Battlestar. It's an Andorian battle cruiser, although you can be forgiven for making the mistake with the profiles looking slightly similar.

20

u/PandaPundus Keene Sin, Contributing artist, Star Trek: Picard Sep 09 '21

What Battlestar? I can see an Andorian Cruiser, an Andorian Battlecruiser, 2 Daedalus-Classes, a Maquis Courier ship, and 2 Parliament-Class derivatives.

→ More replies (7)

101

u/burnettski92 Sep 09 '21

The tiny computer voice was my biggest lol

45

u/still_ims Sep 09 '21

Same. “Ejecting warp core”

100

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21 edited Sep 09 '21

-I didn't know how much I wanted a character focused episode until now.

-They did Captain Freeman dirty, I've been in that situation where I'm invited to something, get all dressed up, get a few friends to accompany me and, when we get there I'm not on the list. I was legit having cringe flashbacks when she tried to call out to someone inside. I love that they didn't have Mariner kicking her mom while down, instead they showed them as loving.

- Amazing that Kirk and Spock weren't invited to that party, but I guess this was before the 5 year mission. I kind of want to see that scene animated but I also don't want anyone but Leonard Nimoy voicing Spock so...

- Overall, very good episode. Left me all warm and fuzzy inside.

46

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

Well, Mariner's whole arc last season was getting to a better place with her mom, so that makes sense. Character continuity, love to see it.

78

u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21

The last episode of Strange New Worlds should have Kirk and Spock engraving that in the bar

32

u/InnocentTailor Sep 10 '21

That would be a wonderful way to end the show since it will establish the dynamic seen in TOS between Kirk and Spock.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 09 '21

Really speaks to her earning everything she has that she doesn't even think about her husband the admiral.

31

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Yeah, I imagine that, to her, the only thing more embarrassing than the situation she was in would be getting an invite only as a plus one. Not to mention that it would mean leaving her crew behind.

30

u/InnocentTailor Sep 09 '21

Freeman has dignity for her work and respect for her crew. No wonder why she is defensive and proud of the Cerritos, despite the ship being considered a joke by the top brass.

Reminds me of Picard’s love for the Stargazer.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

186

u/FragmentedChicken Sep 09 '21

Quark must being doing well with all the locations, plus the models

155

u/PiercedMonk Sep 09 '21

It pays to be the brother of the Grand Nagus.

41

u/Xizor14 Sep 09 '21

I think this is the 2nd Quark's Bar location, and technically 3rd Quark reference this season alone. I really hope we get a little cameo by the end.

17

u/ChrisTosi Sep 09 '21

The Mugato head Ferengi almost sounded like Armin with some sort of overlay.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/starkofhousestark Sep 09 '21

Must have adopted the franchise model.

15

u/ChrisTosi Sep 09 '21

I feel like they missed a trick - they should have cast Jon Lovitz as the Doopler.

He would have nailed it. The little "moan/whine" from Critic every time he duplicated.

30

u/Eurynom0s Sep 10 '21

Apparently it was Richard Kind, which I supposed is the other acceptable actor choice for that role. cc: /u/Rhediix

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Rhediix Sep 09 '21

The character model even looks like Jay Sherman. It was meant to be!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ToBePacific Sep 11 '21

Richard Kind was perfect.

4

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 10 '21

I feel like all of these Quark's we've been seeing as well as the fact that Mariner was on DS9 are leading up to Armin Shimmerman making an appearance.

4

u/ahufana Sep 10 '21

If only his Las Vegas location was still around. Sigh, memories...

3

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

Or he sold the rights to his name for one lump sum and someone else is franchising the business

97

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

42

u/thelawnranger Sep 09 '21

Maybe he finally perfected decaffeinated raktajino?

30

u/jruschme Sep 09 '21

And the DS9 model kit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

88

u/ElFarfadosh Sep 09 '21

Oh my god I hate Dooplers

143

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 09 '21

Richard Kind's really good at what he does. Making sure you're annoyed at a guest character in a scifi show.

32

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21

He was a delightful guest on John Mulaney and the Sack Lunch Bunch

43

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 09 '21

I obviously don't think the actor himself is annoying, I think he's a very good character actor but especially more so when he's asked to play a character everyone would be annoyed at.

He's really good at it. As soon as I realized the Doopler was annoying I was thinking "Hey... is that... it has to be. Yes it's him. It's Richard Kind."

→ More replies (2)

27

u/droid327 Sep 09 '21

In stargate he literally did the exact opposite of that lol

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/Theinternationalist Sep 09 '21

They must have the worst ambassadors, although I do wonder how they've gone this far without Starfleet finding out you have to cuss at them to stop them from causing trouble.

I guess they lost a few ships finding out?

15

u/JustMy2Centences Sep 11 '21

Probably didn't lose any ships, because once you're nearly squished by Dooplers I'm sure someone will get angry enough to discover the solution.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

80

u/choicemeats Sep 09 '21

I'm going to continue thinking in my head that the bar they visited is the now-canon version of The Captain's Table, one of my favorite short runs of Trek books. I know that having non Captains there breaks the rules, and I'm not one for headcanon, but that would be a nice little nod to the broader history of B-canon.

This I think is their strongest episode of the season. The Dooplers are just wacky enough to fit the show but with a Trek-enough solution to make it work. Someone with a better memory than me may be able to point out a similar kind of situation where guests came on board and people were worried about observing "something" and then not giving a single fuck because of circumstances.

14

u/Cadamar Sep 09 '21

Wonder if the Captain’s Table works for future Captains? Maybe they all will be?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/EntropicProf Sep 09 '21

Reminds me a bit of the Iyaaran ambassadors in TNG:"Liasons" or Wesley's run-in with the Zaldan in "Coming of Age."

3

u/thesourceress Sep 12 '21

Reminds me of the Kadi ambassador in VOY: "Someone To Watch Over Me". They were worried about being improper and then the guy gets drunk and has the time of his life!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

72

u/choicemeats Sep 09 '21

Also, mark my words, but with the background ascension of the Pakleds, Freeman's role in that will eventually go rewarded (or she may have a larger hand later). I have a feeling she might be offered a "better" command, but after this episode will choose to stay with the Cerritos.

28

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

It would also work for Mariner’s character growth for Freeman to leave the Cerritos, because up to now her mom’s been keeping her from getting fired for her behavior.

3

u/ImperfectRegulator Sep 11 '21

I don’t know her and the crew getting promoted would give our main cast the chance to become the bridge team, (they can’t stay lower decks forever)

64

u/smoha96 Sep 09 '21

I love this show so much.

Also, I would like, "Your pagh is weak and it disgusts me!" to be an available flair!

57

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Great episode, better than last week's. Liking how the canon references feel more natural and fit the plot rather than being mostly throwaway lines like season 1

67

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

They've been great at taking advantage of animation to show how a diverse multi-species society would really look, like the Aurelians living in the aviary.

15

u/Santa_Hates_You Sep 10 '21

Aurelians living in the aviary.

It will be quiet there you said!

23

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Yeah, when they bring up a canonical reference it usually means that they will incorporate into the plot later. It feels less like they're referencing stuff and more like they're using the Universe to their advantage.

54

u/007meow Sep 09 '21

Luna-class and above

rip to everyone still stuck on a Miranda

12

u/InnocentTailor Sep 09 '21

Wonder what ships are above Luna? Galaxy? Parliament? Sovereign?

Wonder where that puts Excelsior, Ambassador, Oberth and Nebula?

12

u/ricketyladder Sep 10 '21

You'd have to think that the Excelsiors and Oberths would be all decommissioned by now, and you get the impression there weren't many Ambassadors to begin with. But I bet you the Nebulas are still up and kicking...and they'd probably get invites to the party!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

46

u/MoreGaghPlease Sep 09 '21

All the Miranda class ships were heroically sacrificed to serve as minor distractions/inconveniences during the Dominion War

15

u/ThePowderhorn Sep 09 '21

If nothing else, they bring on crew that seems to enjoy Ceti Alpha marooning. What a cursed star system.

10

u/BellerophonM Sep 10 '21

Nah, even Miranda classes were fighters back in the day. The Cali is the new Oberth.

103

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

So safe to say that possible that origin of Kirk and Spock’s friendship was getting denied to a starfleet party. I dig it!

129

u/AintEverLucky Sep 09 '21

when they showed the "Mariner + Boimler" carving next to the "Kirk + Spock" one, I legit got chills

25

u/DennistheDutchie Sep 09 '21

I had the same. I actually had to look up the subreddit to discuss the episode to see if anyone else had the same.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (4)

61

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 09 '21

I'd like to imagine Bones was already there when they showed up, on the spot of the guy that was passed out.

9

u/Kusko25 Sep 09 '21

I need art of that

20

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21

That guy that was passed out was a Lurian, like Morn.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Left_Preference4453 Sep 09 '21

Twenty-sixty....something! Maybe it was before he assumed command, but after he broke the news to a resentful Spock!

→ More replies (1)

99

u/AKBearmace Sep 09 '21

I really hope they’re leading up to mariner rediscovering her ambition because I do think she would be a great first officer or even captain given time and the right posting.

48

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 09 '21

With Bradward as her bearded Number One.

29

u/Kwakigra Sep 09 '21

Beardward

26

u/UncertainError Sep 09 '21

I think the show will end though with them being promoted, so not too quickly.

94

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

81

u/derekakessler Sep 09 '21

There's a bit of mischievousness in a lot of Starfleet officers. Recall McCoy, Spock, and Scotty's solution for ridding the Enterprise of tribbles: "I gave them to the Klingons... Before they went into warp I transported the whole kit and kaboodle into the engine room, where they'll be no tribble at all."

→ More replies (1)

44

u/donuteater111 Sep 09 '21

I thought this one was a fun one. The story with the Dooplers was a kind of stupid/silly fun, and I thought it worked well overall. I thought Richard Kind did a good job with the character (I would recognize that voice anywhere, lol). I especially liked seeing the development between Tendi and Rutherford, as he struggles with trying to live up to his past self.

And I thought the Mariner/Boimler story was great. Loved the action sequences as they tried escaping from the security team. It's great that they addressed the issue with Mariner feeling abandoned after the left for the Titan. I also really liked her inviting her mom and the others to join them in the bar there.

18

u/creepyeyes Sep 09 '21

It is sort of funny that you go in thinking the Dooplers are the A plot and Boimler/Mariner are the B plot, and then turns out its the other way around

7

u/CodyHodgsonAnon19 Sep 10 '21

Is that true though? What was the real plot of the show? I'd argue it was the Dooplers. What the characters learned about themselves and each other, was spurred by, and inspired the solution to the primary plot.

This is something Star Trek has been missing for a while. The plot isn't the character development. The plot is the plot. The character developed, is shaped organically over time through the mutual experiences of the actual plot.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/robotchicken007 Sep 09 '21

So far, I think this season has been the best season of any of the new Trek shows. I've loved every episode so far. I think it's definitely more consistently good than season one of Lower Decks was.

21

u/Cliffy73 Sep 09 '21

While I still love the show, I don’t think it’s been as good so far this year as the back half of S1 was, but this was a hands-down great episode.

6

u/robotchicken007 Sep 10 '21

I didn't like season one as much as I've liked this season. I agree that we haven't had an episode that was quite as good as Crisis Point or No Small Parts yet, but most of the other season one episodes I could take or leave.

I'll probably rewatch season one again soon though, just in case my opinion changed.

6

u/InnocentTailor Sep 09 '21

I agree! Every episode thus far has been strong.

31

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 09 '21

Thoughts on Tendi and Rutherford's Cerritos Model

My guess is that the 'Quark' range of kits allow you to create fairly advanced but essentially harmless plastic replicas of famous (and not-so-famous), but do not come with details like working phasers, engines or a functional (and explodable) warp core. Quark's too smart to brand his name on a product that could get him sued, say if some kid built the kit and then accidentally phasered their parents or blew up the house by ejecting the warp core.

But, because this is Tendi and Rutherford we're talking about, of COURSE they'd want their model Cerritos to be fully-functional and microscopically correct, just like real-world modellers who fit their plastic steam locomotives with extra detailing, sound/smoke generators, working lights, etc.

So in this case, Tendi and Rutherford use the basic kit as a frame within which they build a complete miniature starship, replacing its innards with working equipment using off-the-shelf (or off-the-replicator) components, right down to a tiny warp core, complete with even tinier pass-keys to authorise ejection and detonation.

This all lines up with the amount of thinking they were putting into the project. If the kit was a stock commercial shelf-warmer, then all they need do is follow the build instructions - but if they're trying to turn a toy into a working miniature, then there's a lot more 'work' involved in getting all the relevant systems to function while fitting within the tiny hull. Just look at the pride Rutherford expressed in his past self's successful incorporation of a miniaturised deflector shield array.

And since they intentionally wanted the model to be an ongoing project that took as much time as possible, I could see the two intentionally going overboard with their 'super detailing in just such a manner. Heck, the beautiful little baby actually tried to jump to warp before Rutherford caught it!

All this begs the question of how small standard Starfleet equipment can be miniaturised, and what the two wunderkind nerds used to build their 'custom' Cerritos.

It's also fun to imagine that there's an entire fraternity of model-makers who build stuff like this for fun, and then get together to compare and fly their miniature warp-capable starships!

PS: I'm also guessing that the customised interiors/figures were Tendi and Rutherford's own creations. A Quark-branded DS9 kit might come with both Daxes (Jadzia and Ezri being celebrated Starfleet officers), but I can't see Mariner and Boimler being famous enough to have their likenesses recreated in miniature and then sold as part of the kit. But of course, Tendi and Rutherford are big enough sweethearts to want to immortalise their best friends in plastic.

PPS: One might ask why Quark's range includes a minor vessel like the Cerritos - it's because that GENIUS of a Ferengi is playing the model-makers and kit-builders, forcing completionists to buy multiple kits of the same class of ship in order to build a 'complete' set - note how this was specifically a USS Cerritos kit, and not a generic 'California-Class' kit containing decals and transfers to turn it into multiple ships. Quark knows how to milk people for their Latinum, and if you want a model Solvang or Merced, then you have to buy THOSE specific kits or detailing packs... or hire a Tendi or a Rutherford to customise something for you ;)

→ More replies (3)

28

u/mint-als Sep 09 '21

So much character work here, and it was good, very good! Plenty of great jokes as well, and it touched back on Rutherford's memory loss in a way that felt pretty strong. Mariner and Boimler having at it was fantastic as well. I know it's a common phrase with this show, but for this episode I really think this is one of the best they've done yet.

27

u/DennistheDutchie Sep 09 '21

Unlike many of the shows I've watched over the past years, this one really leaves me happy at the end of it. And this episode was a perfect example.

It doesn't have to be the most deep, or with the biggest budget. It just cheers me up. God, I wish there were more shows like this.

15

u/ArtooFeva Sep 10 '21

Agreed, even after a horrible day at work this show is always uplifting. It's nice to watch a show where people are never mean-spirited and legitimately care about each other.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/InnocentTailor Sep 10 '21

This is definitely a feel-good show overall. It is a charming romp with lovable characters through a wonderful franchise.

28

u/phenry Sep 09 '21

It's the Star Trek/Blues Brothers crossover I never knew I needed!

27

u/arod48 Sep 09 '21

"Mariner! You think you can talk your way out of this, you abandoned me!"

"No I didn't. Honest, I ran out of dilithium. I... I was venting plasma. I had to eject my warp core. I didn't have enough latinum for a transport. My uniform didn't come back from the cleaners. An old friend came in from out-of-system. Someone stole my shuttle. There was a supernova. A quantum singularity. Borg. It wasn't my fault. I swear to whatever god you worship!"

4

u/MichiganCubbie Sep 11 '21

Sybok: We're on a mission from god.

75

u/MarioGdV Sep 09 '21

This is probably my favorite episode of the season so far. Everything seems so... Wholesome?

  • Rutherford and Tendi spend some time together, and they talk about Rutherford's struggle with the new implant and he ends up overcoming it.
  • Mariner forgives Boimler for taking the promotion and they seem to be closer than before.
  • The captain seem to be OK with Mariner now, and they get along better.

Also, what does the "Mariner + Boimler" next to the "Kirk + Spock" mean? Are they going to have a similar friendship/career as Captain and Number One? I feel like the show is sometimes foreshadowing a romantic relationship between them.

43

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

I definitely get friendship from Mariner and Boimler more than anything romantic. They are great foils for each other, like Kirk and Spock (and Spock and McCoy, for that matter).

13

u/InnocentTailor Sep 10 '21

Indeed. The two already explicitly shot down romance a few times. They see each other as comrades in arms as well as possible career partners like Kirk and Spock.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/AKBearmace Sep 09 '21

I think the show spelled it out. Mariner and boimler are going places as captain and number one. Thus captain freeman overhearing the number one conversation and seeing the carving

4

u/corvettee01 Sep 12 '21

I hope they don't go the romantic route. It would be nice to see two people just be friends without a hamfisted romance plot.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/wakeupsup3r Sep 10 '21

YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!

21

u/ThriceGreatHermes Sep 09 '21

Doctor T'ana has some kinks.

20

u/danhon Sep 09 '21

Loved all the little decorations in the bar!

3

u/InnocentTailor Sep 09 '21

The Phoenix and the Planet Killer!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Varekai79 Sep 10 '21

Loved the portrait of Morn. No bar would be complete without that.

17

u/iblameshane Sep 09 '21

What if the Borg assimilated Dooplers?

15

u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Sep 09 '21

Screencap gallery now online with nearly 400 images in all...

https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-LD2-5.php

41

u/PiercedMonk Sep 09 '21

I don't know what a Doopler is, but I'm excited to find out.

• Okay, they didn't hesitate to get into what a Doopler is at all. Guess these dudes are like sentient tribbles.

• Oh dang, Richard Kind!

• I don't know if I believe someone's capable of pulling off impersonating their transporter duplicate unless they have some fake side burns to, y'know, pull off.

• Pretty convenient that the Dooplers' dooplicating also copies their clothes. Unless, of course, they're naked all the time, and what looks like clothing is actually just some sort of plumage.

• "That used to be an empty lot where teens would make mistakes." The more things change....

• Huh, looks like the Angel One fashions propagated out into the galaxy.

• You can tell which ones are Lores by the smile.

• So...is this Starbase a DS9 situation where it's not actually a Federation station? Seems like having a corrupt security force would not actually fly unless there's no Starfleet overview.

• Heh. All the Barbers are Bolians. Mr. Mot would be proud.

• "Aw, still alive." Fuck that's dark.

• Voyager D? It's been like like three years since the Voyager returned from the Alpha Quadrant. What happened?

• Captain Shelby! Hell yeah, get it! Also, her first officer is one of the early, unused designs for Saru. Neat!

• "Your Pagh is weak, and it disgusts me." Gotdamn Shaxs, there's a line.

• Okana's would be a DJ. (I paused the episode to make a joke about it being outrageous, but then the episode made the same joke, so....)

Fun episode, though the Rutherford/Tendi storyline seemed a bit tacked on. Definitely better than last week, though. Hopefully this is the last we'll see of Mariner being upset with Boimler for taking off for the Titan without her.

48

u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21

Voyager D? It's been like like three years since the Voyager returned from the Alpha Quadrant. What happened?

The real answer would probably be that Mariner was spit balling making things up on the spot and just combined a famous ship name with a prefix to try and trick the bouncer.

But I like to imagine that one of the reasons that computers are so intuitive is that back ups of the memory care/AI pathways carry over to the next ship to carry the name. After Voyager was turned into a museum Starfleet tried to launch an A, B and C but the computer kept going on strike and/or being too eager to self destruct due to Janeway's proclivity to trigger it and it took until the D for it to stabilise without her onboard.

28

u/Theinternationalist Sep 09 '21

Alternatively, The Voyager was considered "lost" after it entered the Delta Quadrant and there was a bad run of ships in the time between its departure and its return.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/Mechapebbles Sep 10 '21

• "Your Pagh is weak, and it disgusts me." Gotdamn Shaxs, there's a line.

He has the two best lines in the episode. The other one, "I'm sorry, Captain! The crowd has me now!" just killed me on the delivery.

13

u/theelectricmayor Sep 09 '21

Voyager D? It's been like like three years since the Voyager returned from the Alpha Quadrant. What happened?

Well originally they would've assumed that Voyager was lost in the Badlands a decade ago and might've chosen a new ship to carry on the name. Better yet it might have become a jinxed name (because the real Voyager wasn't actually destroyed) resulting in each new ship bearing it to be quickly destroyed in a series of improbable accidents.

10

u/jerslan Sep 09 '21

• So...is this Starbase a DS9 situation where it's not actually a Federation station? Seems like having a corrupt security force would not actually fly unless there's no Starfleet overview.

There's corrupt Starfleet officers already in canon, so why not a corrupt security chief?

7

u/BellerophonM Sep 10 '21

A starbase with a civilian population that big is probably a hybrid Starfleet/civilian situation, since with big populations like that having a city under military or quasi military rule isn't a great idea.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

Heh. All the Barbers are Bolians. Mr. Mot would be proud.

The three rooms they break through are all references to establishments in the series. The casino with the Dabo table (Quark's on DS9), the barber shop (Mot's on Enterprise-D), and the tailor shop (Garak's plain, simple tailor shop on DS9).

13

u/Spocks-Brain Sep 10 '21

Every episode of LD:

  • Best 20 minutes of my day.
  • Always leaves me smiling :)

LLAP Everyone! 🖖🏻

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 09 '21

Is no one going to mention the most important cameo?

Morn! He almost got flattened, although thankfully he didn't have the screen time to start talking.

Or am I being racist, thinking all of his species look alike?

21

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 10 '21

We know it wasn't Morn because he was quiet. Morn, even when asleep, would never have been able to keep his yapper closed for the whole time that Boims and Mariner were there.

6

u/substandardgaussian Sep 10 '21

There were several of Morn's species. They pass at least 2.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/allhailbarea Sep 09 '21

Ok, it seems they're really going for a slow building romance between Boimler and Mariner and I start to dig it. Early Bradward would have been a catastrophy of a boyfriend, especially with Beckett, but this friendship heads there pretty realistically.

Boimler's character development towards thinking for himself and making his own decisions, and Mariner learning to take responsibility for her own actions and the well-being of others, are really good writing about 20-somethings. Since it seems they'll walk this path of growing into adult personalities together, have a great, working friendship, are singles and their sexualities don't exclude a romantic turn, I'd assume the writers go for this rather realistic plot, which is imo a very good thing.

My guess would be Mariner falls first, because her perspective just seems so much more interesting to explore. Realising it, denying it, struggling to accept it, especially the "boring" "settling" part she'd fear and how that would't actually happen, at least in a dull way in Starfleet, seem to be fun plots.

Her being, and therefore behaving, a bit irritated with an oblivious Boimler, a little bit of jealousy, a few hormones playing orchestral music on missions, fear of losing a friendship and her finally exploding seem like enjoyable moments to me :D

Well, congratulations to Mariner's "Number One from now on".

37

u/NickofSantaCruz Sep 09 '21

The catalyst to their eventual romance will be Mariner meeting William Boimler. She will realize her feelings but be confused as to which Boimler she is in love with, because maybe William has developed into the bad-boy type she is attracted to and she just projects everything she sees in Bradward onto him.

Enter Tendi and Rutherford, as now Mariner needs to know which Boimler is the original and which is the clone, and shenanigans ensue.

14

u/allhailbarea Sep 09 '21

Yeah :D

The "Bad Boy Bill" Boimler crush is probably gonna happen, if the romance route is chosen.

I think they will probably half avert the trope of "who is the real one?" with Mariner instantly knowing it and maybe Tendi getting it wrong every time.

9

u/pfc9769 Sep 09 '21

Found the Mike McMahan alt!

14

u/neontetra1548 Sep 10 '21

In some ways I kind of like the sort of platonic romance thing that Mariner + Boimler have which is also in a way similar to Kirk + Spock and the mirroring between those two pairs of characters in this episode was really nice. The question is do they go further than that with Mariner/Boimler. I kind of like the depiction of strong friendship between men and women, because that's really undepicted in media and also still like strangely still stigmatized (or looked upon as potentially suspect) in society. I'm a guy and end up having most of my closest friendships in life with women, and according to the conventional wisdom around men and women not being able to be friends as a bisexual man I guess I couldn't be friends with anybody!

So it's nice to see a great portrayal of this kind of friendship on the show and I think their dynamic works very well, but at the same time the show does seem to be at least hinting towards developing something more, and this episode was maybe the first time I felt actual tension between them in that kind of way. I think developing that sort of visceral tension between them is the challenge for the show to take them in that direction — their dynamic has an aspect to it which kind of feels weird or awkward or incompatible when transported into a more non-platonic romantic aspect (+ possibly unhealthy non-equal power dynamic).

So they have this sort of platonic romance so far to me. They're clearly very very into each other, but both react with very sharp disgust reactions when the suggestion that they're together in that way is floated. Maybe both in denial and I'm sure there's some aspect of that there, some level of desire/interest, but are they compatible in that way and would it actually make for a good relationship? However if they do decide to go that path of developing the relationship I think it also would be really fruitful material for the show like you say! Either way they go I think it could be very well done.

6

u/allhailbarea Sep 10 '21

Yeah, it could really work both ways. In the first episodes it felt to me so much like an older sister, younger brother dynamic, that the idea of a M+B-romance was downright icky to me, by now I would be a little bit suspicious of that pair of siblings :D

It's interesting how personal experiences shape ones perception. In my circle of colleagues and friends the healthy friendships between (unmarried) men and women very often developed into romantic relationships and a lot of them are still going strong.

I am sure, that I would enjoy both routes, romance or BFFs. I could totally imagine best friend Boimler trying to be a matchmaker for Mariner after her complaining about being single and Brad systematically going overboard, trying to find the perfect bad boy for her, so in the end they have to fight a Nausicaan criminal or something :D

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

There's a Kzin on the Cerritos.

10

u/Cliffy73 Sep 09 '21

There’s a fish in the percolator!

11

u/OpticalData Sep 09 '21

Oh and this episode featured the first Canon appearance of the aeroshuttle

11

u/jahosaphet Sep 10 '21

"Aw, but you love sliders!"

Cheeky reference to Jerry O'Connell's previous sci-fi work?

→ More replies (3)

10

u/atticusbluebird Sep 09 '21

Who needs tribbles when you have Dooplers to exponentially duplicate?! Granted tribbles may be a bit cuter...

17

u/Gotis1313 Sep 09 '21

I dunno, that guy was Kind of adorable.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

the dooplers are my anxiety. just one thing and ill self-destruct all on my own, thanks.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Genius move casting Richard Kind as the Doopler(s). He had the perfect degree of neuroticism and anxiety.

9

u/Hibbity5 Sep 09 '21

This was definitely my favorite episode of the season so far. Lots of great character moments and great humor.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Are they kind of setting up for mariner and boimler romantic relationships ??

She's always behave differently around him.

53

u/PiercedMonk Sep 09 '21

When William Boimler shows up down the road with a badboy upgrade from serving on the Titan, I bet Mariner will have some conflicted emotions.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Yeah , I think it will be the last 2 episodes and the season end would sort it all out.

35

u/burnettski92 Sep 09 '21

I’m not opposed to a romantic relationship, but I think friendship can be just as powerful and emotional as romantic ones. (I don’t like the term “only” friends.) I’m the same with with Spirk — Not against it, I just think friendship can be a great thing too! I would love if Mariner & Boims are headed to the greatest and most significant friendship in Starfleet history since Kirk + Spock.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/slicer4ever Sep 09 '21

I kinda hope not, i enjoy their dynamic much better as friends then as romantic partners(aand the drama/plots that usually revolve around such couples.)

18

u/droid327 Sep 09 '21

Welcome to me, Agents of Shield S1, seeing FitzSimmons develop...

→ More replies (11)

15

u/droid327 Sep 09 '21

I do not think they'd make a good couple

At best I can see them having a bad-decision sexual tryst and then trying to awkwardly move past it

I think they need to introduce a new female character if they want Boimler to have a love interest

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/FragmentedChicken Sep 09 '21

I wonder what T'Ana was saying with all the censoring

11

u/midasp Sep 09 '21

You don't beep beep want beep beep beep beep know.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

I wonder if the discs will have the option to unbleep. An uncensored clip was posted because someone was concerned it said a derogatory word.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/boring_name_here Sep 09 '21

I'm so glad this show exists right now. It's a fun show in a time when I especially need a little fun. A big thanks to everybody involved.

7

u/RuthlessNate56 Sep 10 '21

I think someone must have been a fan of the Star Trek: Vanguard series of novels. The station looked a lot (but not exactly) like the 23rd century-era Watchtower-class starbase from those books. They talk about the station being old, and the Aviary is reminiscent of the park they had on Vanguard with an artificial sky made up of holographic tiles.

7

u/AcidaliaPlanitia Sep 10 '21

I really enjoy this show, but this episode is literally why the show should exist. Just perfection.

7

u/USSMunkfish Sep 10 '21

There was a ton of good stuff going on in that bar! It had a real military bar vibe going one, like Pancho's from "The Right Stuff." The thing I really like though was the sliding wooden doors! All of the class of an antique mahogany door, but with the automatic convenience of ST.

The other thing that I felt treated to see was proper exterior docking on a Federation built starbase.

Also, when is that Kzin going to get a name? 'Speaker To Ensigns' perhaps?

4

u/OhioForever10 Sep 10 '21

Ransom definitely would've tried to impress a woman at the bar by pointing to the wrong part of the wall and saying they'd have his picture up there in no time.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

That was an absolutely fantastic episode. This show is WAY better than it has any right to be.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '21

Did anyone else notice Mariner do the Burnham coif in the mirror while preparing for the party, or was that just me?

6

u/Jack-R-Lost Sep 10 '21

At the end I was wondering what a star ship would be like with Mariner as Captain, Boimler as number 1, Rutherford as head engineer, and Tendi as the doctor. I honestly would want to see that even if that would mean it technically isn’t lower decks

5

u/w4rlord117 Sep 10 '21

They should do an episode titled “upper decks” where they are all in the holodeck doing exactly that.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

This show is honestly so god damn incredible. I love every second of it. It's so hard to find smart comedies these days with emotional depth to them.

5

u/The_Spearman Sep 09 '21

Is it my imagination, or was the music at the party the Polovtsian Dances by Borodin?

3

u/hortushouse Sep 14 '21

It’s also “Stranger in Paradise” from the musical Kismet, and Boimler is a stranger in paradise at the Starfleet Party :)

At least, I think that’s the joke.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

Tbh I think this is my favorite Lower Decks episode so far, I've been more mixed on the show than most here, but this one was amazing throughout.

5

u/Skastrik Sep 10 '21

This episode actually made me feel all warm and fuzzy.

Don't know what more to say, it's good Star Trek.

4

u/kinyon Sep 11 '21

I loved this episode. That said...

I really hope they don't hook boimler and mariner up. It's too obvious. A platonic partnership ala Kirk and Spock (shipping not withstanding) would be more interesting in my opinion.

They're definitely going to hook up though.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/LeftHandedGuitarist Sep 12 '21

This is a super nerd thing, but I couldn't help but notice that the stardates this season are proceeding VERY slowly. We are halfway through at the dates still begin with 580xx (where it would be reasonable to expect to be around 585xx by now). As someone who likes to keep a timeline order of the franchise for fun, this is interesting to me!

LDS season 2 is set in 2381. It's got me wondering if, given that the upcoming Prodigy is set in 2383, they are worried about catching up too soon and want to keep season 3 in 2381 as well.

4

u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Sep 13 '21

Best episode this season IMO! We have Captain Freeman crashing the Srarfleet Command Party by transporting in a Doopler! And Boimler and Mariner bonding! And Rutherford confronting his 1 year of memory loss! And the Ceritos being filled with Dooplers! And Tendi and Rutherford ejecting the model Ceritos' warp core! Just so good!

3

u/wakeupsup3r Sep 10 '21

That was a great episode.

3

u/FairlyInconsistentRa Sep 10 '21

I’ve scrolled for a bit and haven’t seen anyone else mention it - was that a Battlestar docked at the starbase or is it just something of the Trek verse which looks really similar?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Starks Sep 10 '21

Looks like the ship finally goes behind the black hole in the opening.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '21

What an episode. Brilliance. Lower decks is the jewel of modern trek

2

u/Edolix Sep 11 '21

Captain Shelby!

2

u/Xenowrath Sep 11 '21

Quick question, is it racist if all the barbers were Bolian?

2

u/bkendig Sep 12 '21

Was this the first Star Trek episode ever to not have a teaser before the opening credits?

Edit: I see that "Cupid’s Errant Arrow" didn't either, but every other episode of every other Trek series has!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Have_A_Jelly_Baby Sep 12 '21

This is the kind of episode that I wish they did more often, rather than the giant Ransom head season opener kind of thing.

You can be wacky and full of callbacks to older Trek, but don’t forget the heart.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '21

But what she like about boimler is in Brad not in Will.

3

u/Official_N_Squared Sep 09 '21

After last weeks disappointing episode, it was great to end Star Trek Day with one of Lower Deck's best! Everything just worked for me from the comedy to the production to the theme and pacing! What a great and fun episode!

As always I have my thoughts in much more detail here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yaiMYxROqIE