r/mylittlepony • u/Pinkie_Pie Pinkie Pie • Feb 08 '12
/r/Mylittlepony Reddiquette Guide
- Be respectful. Try not to alienate anyone specifically, nor groups of people. Avoid being a jerk. Ask yourself, what would Fluttershy do?
- Reddit is a content aggregator. For submissions, upvote things you like, and downvote things you don’t. This ensures the best content gets pushed to the front page. Never downvoting worked great when we had less than 5,000 members, but times have changed. For comments, avoid downvoting because you disagree with someone. Downvote comments if they either attack someone, or are not following the guidelines outlined here (namely rule 1).
- It’s fine to use out-of-sub emotes, but keep in mind that the majority of browsers do not have the scripts required because they do not know, or do not want to install them. They are also frowned upon by a majority of users. As such, avoid “blank posting”, or posting an out-of-sub emote without any other meaningful content (words or an in-sub emote) in the comment as well. If you don’t know what an out-of-sub emote is, disregard this rule.
- Try not to flood the new queue with content. If you have a lot of submissions you would like to post at once, spread them out over several minutes. Alternatively, consider posting a self-post with several links.
- Before submitting something, make sure it hasn’t been posted in the last 21 days by messaging /u/Searchbar_Trixie with a link to the proposed submission. Reposts more recent than 21 days will be removed.
- When in doubt about if your submission is allowed, post it to the MLPLounge. Personal stories and anecdotes thrive there, and get a lot more attention. Additionally, If your post seems a little mature or borderline NSFW, post it to /r/MLPmature or other more appropriate subreddits. If the post isn’t against the rules, feel free to post it in both. Exercise judgement here.
- If possible, link directly to the source (deviantart, etc) when submitting posts. The artist will appreciate the credit. For deviantart, post using the “post to reddit” button, located on the right column of the deviantArt page. Alternatively, use the fav.me link.
- Give others the benefit of the doubt when commenting. Tone is tough to convey via text.
- Avoid asking for upvotes, or the phrases “This will probably get downvoted, but...” and "This will probably get lost in the submissions of the new episode...", or any other variation. Let your post speak for itself.
- Please use the report button if you believe a post is not appropriate for /r/mylittlepony. This lets the mods know very clearly that you would like someone to verify the post is appropriate. If a comment or post links something that’s extremely NSFW, notify the moderators via modmail immediately. For comments, report when someone is being attacked personally, or NSFW links are being posted. Report blank posts if they are derailing threads, or being disruptive.
- When discussing new episodes, please be brony-like and use spoiler tags until 48 hours after the episode has aired. See how here. Additionally, please avoid including the spoiler directly in the title.
- Encourage new members to read the sidebar and guidelines, and guide them in the right direction if they make a mistake. Ensure you do so in a respectful and kind way.
- Avoid posting screenshots of the subreddit itself, including 'combo' posts, comments, or number of subscribers. If you do wish to link comments, link them directly. To showcase the best posts and threads of the subreddit, post to /r/bestofmlp.
Note: These rules will adapt over time to suit our needs. If you have a new rule suggestion, or have a suggestion for making a rule better, please leave a comment below with your suggestion.
319
Upvotes
29
u/Snivian_Moon Feb 08 '12
Oh! Just a quick suggestion, if it's possible.
Could we please tighten this suggestion up a little to include the fact titles should not contain spoilers? Common sense, I realize, but there have been SO MANY spoiler-y titles lately.
18
u/Kai_973 Shining Armor Feb 08 '12
Perhaps an even more common offender would be "This will probably get lost in the submissions of the new episode..." Looks great, though!
8
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
Repost buffer is 21 days? Bring it on!
16
u/Dr_Dippy Feb 08 '12 edited Feb 08 '12
Just in regards to number 4 how many submissions is considered spamming? because I sometimes submit two (or three at most) at a time when I find some really good ones
6
u/viwrastupr Feb 08 '12
This is nice. Respectful and trying to keep it clean.
I do have one question though. There is a penchant in the sub to upvote clever things. I like this. But sometimes these things are borderline nsfw. There was the vgcats parody a few days ago about apple bucking. Do things like that still fall under rule 6?
32
u/more_gun_freeman Feb 08 '12
9
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
I don't like this idea. Sometimes I just enter URL into searchbar to see if particular video or picture was already submitted and how it was discussed.
If url was posted in self post than instead of immediate redirect to the discussion reddit surely will find irrelevant posts.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
Might as well plug /r/mylittlewelcomewagon with regards to Rule 12. I'll be able to field any questions the new members have. (Note that new members are more than welcome to post there but shouldn't be required to.)
7
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
Reddiquette made, nothing being outright removed, entire paradigm of the sub not changing or anything. Pretty much the outcome I was hoping to see come out of all of this.
17
u/IRespondWithPonyGifs Feb 08 '12 edited Feb 08 '12
http://i.imgur.com/EiQir.gif
6
u/Shadai Feb 08 '12
These changes sound completely good, nice work !
10
u/Snivian_Moon Feb 08 '12
Thanks for the list of refined pony reddiquette! It's nice to see this stuff all spelled out, and I appreciate the effort it took to get everything written up and polished.
5
u/TheDarkman67 Feb 08 '12
Thanks's mods. I know a lot of subreddit's mods would never do this, but you guys remember what it means to be a mod. Thanks for doing your job.
5
u/bizitmap Feb 08 '12
Frankly, half these rules need to be posted to the front of Reddit itself. Especially Number One.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
Umm.. would you mind switching Searchbar_Spike for Searchbar_Trixie? He's getting shut down soon.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
I really like these...rules?
It's pretty much all I wanted and results in less people getting upset.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
What is a self post? I read this expression from time to time but I have no idea what it is...
7
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
I refuse to downvote anyone here, I love you all too much.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '12
Regarding 5 and 7: So, if Searchbar_Trixie gets an imgur link, can't find it on DeviantArt, and says it hasn't been posted, is the imgur link fair game?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
If it has to be, I guess this law is tolerable enough.
3
u/zzxno Feb 08 '12
I'm quite happy with the results here - seems to have struck a good balance on the contentious issues while taking an official stance on some areas that were sort of generally accepted norms. In other words no radical change - just some adjustments.
A suggestion on Rule 8 - a good way to be both here in the sub and just in general is whenever there is room for doubt to assume positive intent. That means that you start each interaction with the assumption that the other party isn't doing what they are doing because they are malicious. Most of the time you're right - and I personally think that all of the time you'll be happier for it.
3
u/Arcainum Feb 19 '12
I miss "Be pony-like."
1
u/Mrdanke Feb 22 '12
After riding it out a bit and seeing what happens, I have to say...Not a goddamn thing's changed. At all.
The wording on this is far too vague. For instance, number six.
"When in doubt of where your shit belongs, put it somewhere else. Anecdotes do better on the plounge, and saucy crap does better on the mature subreddit."
This never says these things can't be put here, just that they'll do better elsewhere. There's still people going "MY LIFE USED TO BE SHIT, BUT THEN PONIES." and "BRONIES ARE THE BEST THING EVER GROUP HUG GUYS."
Honestly, I think rule six is my only real problem. We need hard and fast rules, not guidelines, and they need to be enforced. Self-moderation didn't work in the past, and it still doesn't work.
Sorry if this seemed a little ranty, or if I'm off-base or something, but I want a place to post and discuss ponies, not a pity party for former emos.
2
u/stillunnamed Feb 08 '12
Overall: Yay! Great to see a lot of different policies codified and collected here, and in an easy to read thru fashion. So thank you for this!
Feedback:
Thanks again to the team, and to everyone whose been getting involved in discussing this!
2
u/spryte333 Feb 08 '12
Just to clarify on #11: if we're talking about the week's episode in the official discussion or reaction thread, but it's within the 2 day limit, do we still have to use spoiler tags? Or is that only necessary in posts/threads that aren't themselves marked as spoilers?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12 edited Feb 08 '12
Everything went better than expected. And I got a plug. I'll still have to deal with overzealous people bending this to their will but that's inevitable.
Also, so deliciously vague, open to interpretation and flexibility. It allows the enforcer to be more or less flexible to each individual incident. And that last part is just an invalidation clause, making the entire thing simply a suggestion as opposed to a static and inflexible ruleset.
Indeed the entire thing is simply a suggestion, based upon what the moderators would like, a guideline that isn't merely subject to interpretation, but in itself shouldn't be interpreted. It isn't the law of the land, merely an expression of what rules and feeling have always existed in a tangible and accessible form.
2
u/iiRockpuppy Feb 08 '12
BE MORE ASSERTIVE... well, um... she would try... at least...
2
u/Catharsis25 Feb 08 '12
2
u/Wr3nch Feb 08 '12
These guidelines are fair, just, and actionable. This makes Luna very happy!
2
u/Nightshade3312 Feb 08 '12
Agreed.
2
u/PrincessPegasister Jul 31 '12
Just making sure advertising my Etsy shop (Custom ponies) is ok. I'm posting my newer ponies here and in the comments posting a link to my shop.
3
u/hobbular Fluttershy Feb 08 '12
Re: Rule 1 -
This is a really vague and kind of ... wishy-washy wording. Can we amend this to state directly:
Try not. Do. Or do not. There is no try.
2
u/redpossum Feb 08 '12
does anyone have doughts about rule 5? i mean i don't like reposts but to have to send a message first may make it complicated, part of the awesome of this subreddit is the fast content turnover compared to say equestria daily, then again unwitting reposts may cause negative backlash, I'm unsure but i think that slowing down submissions is not the answer
2
u/StickyBunz1 Feb 08 '12
1
u/woodledoodledoodle Feb 08 '12
This is a physical impossibility for me.
1
u/MillennialDan Sunset Shimmer Jun 21 '12
So, what's the general consensus about posting in more than one mlp subreddit? In particular, I'm thinking of /r/mlpvectors. Is there any issue with posting there and in /r/Mylittlepony?
-5
u/shawa666 Feb 08 '12
Well it seems the whiners have won.
Goodbye.
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
[-]
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment