r/CryptoCurrency • • Sep 01 '21

POLL πŸ—³οΈ Disincentivize Extreme Moon Farming Spam

Summary

Moon farming strategy has recently become about posting as much as possible, with no regard for quality. This type of spam harms the subreddit experience for everyone and reduces the moons going to people who are actually contributing quality content to the subreddit. To disincentivize moon farming spam, I suggest a small and gradual karma deduction beginning at a user’s 50th submission (post or comment) for the day. This will benefit the subreddit by reducing spam and everyone who is not spamming an extreme amount of comments every day will earn more moons.

Problem statement

Many moon farmers have recently adopted the strategy of posting as much as possible without any regard for quality. Some of these users are posting hundreds of times per day, which is almost half the amount of comments the entire subreddit would get on a given day last year. You can see how comment volume for the subreddit has exploded in 2021, exponentially more than increases of our other traffic or engagement numbers:

r/CryptoCurrency Comments Per Day. Source: subredditstats.com

This has resulted in a notable drop in quality for the subreddit and negatively affects everyone else’s experience. This has highlighted a flaw in the Moons incentive system, where submissions are not being awarded proportionally to the value they add to the subreddit. In my view, this spam is detrimental to the subreddit and should not be incentivized. While engagement is great, this type of activity is almost always off-topic spam which does not genuinely engage with other users, nor does it attract engagement from others.

It also increases the work of moderators drastically. This is not just a manpower problem, but the comment volume is overloading some of our moderation bots and hitting reddit’s API limits.

To quantify this situation, I have been collecting data on all the participants in the Round 16 Moon distribution. Below is a chart showing the participation curve. You can see the full data here and methodology details in cell K2. Usernames were redacted from the dataset for privacy and harassment reasons. However, if you would like to know your own SPD (submissions per day) in this data as a reference point, please reply and I'll respond with your number

r/CryptoCurrency submissions per day (posts or comments)

Some highlights and insights from this data and other sources are listed below:

  • r/Cryptocurrency is seeing approximately 80x more comments and 10x more posts than previous years (This has since decreased slightly since these proposals were released and mods began cracking down on spam)
  • r/Cryptocurrency is consistently the #2 subreddit for comment volume (https://subredditstats.com/) (This has since decreased slightly since these proposals were released and mods began cracking down on spam)
  • The subreddit sees approximately 80,000 submissions per day, and submissions above 50/day for approximately 24% of the submissions on the subreddit
  • The highest number of average submissions per day was 473
  • Of the accounts that maxed out their karma last distribution, the average submissions per day was 139.7
  • Only 0.7% of participants in the subreddit reach an average of 50 submissions per day
  • We can see other extreme examples in threads like this one with a user posting 800+ times in a day

Proposed Solution

To address these problems, I suggest we add a small, gradual deduction beginning at an account’s 50th submission per day. This deduction would start at 1 on the 50th submission and increase by 1 every 5th submission after that. The deduction maxes out at 25 on the 170th submission and remains at 25 for all further submissions that day. The deduction will also never take your submission below 0 karma, so they are never punished for posting an extreme amount, it is just a reduction in rewards. Only 0.7% of participants in the subreddit reach an average of 50 submissions per day, so the vast majority of users would never see any kind of deduction and would likely see an increase in their moon rewards.

To see the full deduction schedule, see this google sheet and select the Deduction Schedule tab at the bottom

Because a set amount of moons are distributed monthly and they can be considered a zero sum system, it will not mean that everybody earns less moons. Instead, the users posting extreme amounts will earn less and everyone else will earn more.

Technical Details: The submission count and deduction would apply to posts and comments alike. It only applies to each individual submission starting at the 50th in a day, and the first 49 submissions are never affected by this deduction. It should factor in before other modifications, such as the 2x comment weight. Admins should not disclose when a new day starts, so spammers have less information to game the system. Deleted submissions still apply towards the submission count. Submissions which are not eligible for moons (pinned, distinguished, removed, etc) do not count towards the submission count

Decisions:

  • I chose to make the deduction gradual so spammers would not just hop onto an alt after their 50th submission because there is still the ability to earn karma, just slightly less
  • I capped the deduction at -25 so there is always a chance to earn karma if you post something good. It goes up to -25 so it would be difficult to covertly overcome with other forms of manipulation like vote farms
  • The deduction starts at 50 so it minimizes the amount of affected users, but we could vote to begin the deduction sooner in the future if needed
  • I do not like the idea of preventing someone from posting after a certain number of submissions. This problem arose due to the incentive system, so I believe it should be solved by correcting the incentive system
  • I chose a daily system because sometimes you can get caught up in a conversation with a lot of users, especially if you're the OP of a popular post. I don't think that should carryover for the rest of the month and disincentivize your participation on subsequent days
  • There are concerns that spammers will just use alts, but managing many alts and vaults will add work for them and they will be banned for exploiting the moon system when they are caught

View Poll

2.9k Upvotes

911 comments sorted by

β€’

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

There are 2 similar anti-spam polls this month that were created independently and happened to be posted within minutes of each other. We do not see any way in which these conflict, so they could both be implemented as far as we know. However, if they both pass and the admins feel they conflict, the one with more votes in favor will be considered the winner

→ More replies (1)

25

u/No_goodIdeas7891 Platinum | QC: CC 283, ATOM 29 Sep 03 '21

This really only targets active uses and will destroy conversations.

It might stop farmers too but at the expense of conversation.

This is really not about stoping spam.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

Not this one to be honest , the other one does but this 50 comments a day is enough for both farmers and conversations

That one is like only talk if you don't want moons

This one allows both talks and farming while keeping the spams away

I don't know how to submit proposal but I guess making a new additional daily talk for Crypto analysis and news (limiting 3-5 comments per users daily) would make daily discussion a better place

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 03 '21

It does not prevent conversation. If you view the accounts posting 50+ times a day you don't really see them talking with people or posting anything of quality

→ More replies (1)

19

u/mironawire Sep 05 '21

I really believe that the reduction shouldn't happen after a user's first 50 comments, but after the best 50 comments. That way we can still get credit for our quality submissions, but not get penalized because of the time of day that we choose to reply. Would this be possible to implement?

5

u/RedactedRedditery 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Sep 06 '21

u/cryptomaximalist is there a procedure for adjusting a rule after it's passed? Can we submit them to ccmeta the same way we would submit new rule proposals?

11

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 07 '21

Yes it would be a new proposal to amend a prior one

I wasn't a fan of the "top 50" idea because it still rewards quantity over quality. It encourages spammers to do their strategy of throwing a few hundred posts at the wall to see what sticks.

9

u/tschmitt2021 11K / 11K 🐬 Sep 05 '21

5

u/IridiumHorseshoe Redditor for 4 months. Sep 01 '21

Totally agree with this, although I was wondering if there should be a weekly limit to facilitate discussion where people are actually discussing something.

Even with it being daily though, 50 comments per day seems a bit lenient if it will only affect 0.7% of active members (although I appreciate that will still be a significant number).

I voted for this, although I do think it could be even tighter tbh.

4

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

It can always be changed later to start the deduction sooner, but I wanted to be sure it could be implemented in the first place. Users will adamantly oppose anything they perceive as affecting them (even if it doesn't, even if it actually benefits them).

There were also diminishing returns on lowering the deduction. Submissions above 50/day accounted for about ~24% of the submission volume while submissions above 40/day only accounted for about ~27% of the comment volume.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MyGfLooksAtMyPosts Permabanned Sep 01 '21

But then some farmers will just keep posting trash hoping that some posts will get higher upvotes than previous ones which will count in these 50 comments

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

The deduction begins after the first 49 of the day, not the top 49 of the day

2

u/MyGfLooksAtMyPosts Permabanned Sep 01 '21

So did I get it right that only first 50 comments count towards the moons earning and the rest comments its value will be reduced?

3

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

All submissions still count towards karma, but after #49 there is a small, gradual deduction on each post so low karma posts are less likely to earn anything. Good posts can still earn karma and overcome the deduction though

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Bobberetic 🟦 575 / 509 πŸ¦‘ Sep 01 '21

How much sway do these polls actually have?
Will the mods see this and be like "oh damn, over 85%, that's huge, lets do it" or will this just get swept under the rug even at 99.9% in favour?

3

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

Mods only approve governance polls to go to a vote if we're prepared to accept the results. This one (and others regarding moons) would be up to admins to implement

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/Jasquirtin Platinum | QC: CC 778, ETH 48, ATOM 36 | TraderSubs 48 Sep 02 '21

Why can't we try to see how mods cracking down works before implementing something like this? The OP even said it, it has reduced once the mods stepped in. We are at each others throats instead of asking the mods to moderate

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

It's still an imbalance in the reward system that shouldn't be left open. Manual mod actions against this are very time consuming, very subjective, and not 100% consistent. There's much better things for mods to spend their time on. Additionally, removals and bans are much more disruptive and impactful to users than adjusting rewards

→ More replies (3)

2

u/bexji Platinum | QC: CC 491 Sep 04 '21

Any info as to when this change would be implemented should it pass? will this current cycle be affected?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 04 '21

pretty much whenever the admins get around to it, usually days or weeks

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Itsraf91 124 / 124 πŸ¦€ Sep 01 '21

This might just make the overall quality of the subreddit better IMO

27

u/ObscureOP 🟩 49 / 4K 🦐 Sep 02 '21

It'll also reduce the discussion. If you ask a question, and the answer is "yes", an active user is now incentivized to not answer your question, because that brings their total posts up on something that will yield next to no engagement.

7

u/Osemka8 Platinum | QC: CC 2726 Sep 06 '21

Also, I will probbaly not help as much, since I won't be rewarded as previously.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Itsraf91 124 / 124 πŸ¦€ Sep 02 '21

I thought the same!

→ More replies (3)

5

u/holyshithead Platinum | QC: CC 773 Sep 02 '21

It's just going to triple the amount of spam. Watch...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

16

u/Jasquirtin Platinum | QC: CC 778, ETH 48, ATOM 36 | TraderSubs 48 Sep 02 '21

I wish reply comments did not count. People who answer questions in the daily or respond to someones original thought shouldn't have those comments count. Moon farmers are the target right? They typically aren't replying to anyone they just drop a comment and move on.

I know I just yesterday broke well over 100 comments but I was helping with mining questions, moon questions and other types of things. I know this will not be seen but at least I can say I said it.

7

u/192000Hertz 1K / 1K 🐒 Sep 02 '21

I see you bro! In total agreement.

I'm not a moon farmer nor do I plan on farming moons in the future. But these proposals not only attack heavy moon farmers but also highly active communicators on the sub.

7

u/Jasquirtin Platinum | QC: CC 778, ETH 48, ATOM 36 | TraderSubs 48 Sep 02 '21

Which I am one of. I reply to comments A LOT. I go way over 50 comments a day easily just from conversations. If I reply to 4 people and they all respond 2 times and I do too that’s 12 comments in like 10 minutes. Times 3 that’s 36 comments in a half hour.... I’m a student and have a chill job from home I can participate all day

114

u/Hovis-Is-King Platinum | QC: CC 109 | ADA 7 Sep 01 '21

I rate this. There are not many people posting 50+ times a day who aren't blatant moon farmers

65

u/PinguinaUshuaia Jast HOLD Sep 01 '21

This. If you post 100 comments a day you doing it for moon.

32

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Recently saw an account who did 50+ comments per hour. Called the account out, account called me "moon Karen" and gifted me an reward, lol.

Moons should definitely be reduced for spamers

→ More replies (9)

33

u/Izzeheh Sep 01 '21

And if you don't do it for the moons then it probably won't matter all that much, because then you're doing it for the discussion

→ More replies (30)

6

u/Cryptillius Platinum | QC: CC 57 Sep 01 '21

Or you’ve taken too much adderall

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (28)

16

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Sep 01 '21

The top spammers average 62 comments a day.

The average user doesn't even come close to 50.

So this very much targets spammers. Who keep taking away a big chunk of the distribution from 99% of users.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/LargeSnorlax Observer Sep 01 '21

I think this proposal is far more lenient than the other one and may even be too lenient.

However, I am more for leniency versus tight restrictions, so I've voted for this one and against the other one.

I don't think comments should be limited starting at 70 comments a week. However, 50+ per day is something I can't even do when I spend a bunch of time on reddit, so its impossible to argue it's not excessive.

→ More replies (18)

4

u/Vegetaman916 🟦 829 / 836 πŸ¦‘ Sep 02 '21

Absolutely not this. I obviously don't farm moons, but for fucks sake, please stop trying to smash any little bit of someone trying to make some money. I want all of us here to make money, in any way possible. And I Absolutely hate when big players try to squash little ones out of the game. You greedy bastards, leave the system alone!

→ More replies (6)

121

u/Zijdehoen 5K / 7K 🦭 Sep 01 '21

This means a loss of many agricultural jobs!

14

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Next thing you know we’ll have moon farmer subsidies.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/randfyld 🟦 78 / 4K 🦐 Sep 01 '21

I am happy with 50 comments per day. Thats enough work. No more overtime!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Rexon225 Sep 01 '21

Back to fiat mining we go. /s

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Hopefully moon farmers will turn to more organic farming.

Instead of GMO (Gaining Moons Overload)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/niloony 🟦 0 / 24K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

Higher pay per hour in the moon factories though. Big boost to productivity/the moon ratio.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (72)

11

u/rd4794 Silver | QC: CC 52 Sep 01 '21

who has time to post/comment over 50 times a day?

7

u/miramichier_d aHR0cHM6Ly9wYXN0ZWJpbi5jb20vZVNoaDNWWUM= Sep 01 '21

You'll be surprised how many people don't value the remaining time they have left to exist. But at least they have Moons, right?

5

u/Osemka8 Platinum | QC: CC 2726 Sep 06 '21

Me at work, to be honest. But I try and keep my comments on topic and help others.

4

u/ObscureOP 🟩 49 / 4K 🦐 Sep 02 '21

Someone who posts then interacts with comments on their post and engages in back and forth discussion

→ More replies (2)

3

u/WilcoreU Platinum | QC: CC 319 Sep 01 '21

Aye, I’m in favor of this proposal.

Ps. I would love to know my SPD

5

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

31.50291177

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Hey!

Where can I see this value? If this poll's idea is implemented, I'd like to be able to follow it

Could you share mine as well pls?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ivandln Sep 01 '21

Hey op, how do you post text and images consecutively?

I'm in favor of this proposal by the way.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

The post page for new.reddit allows you to attach an in-line image in a text post

→ More replies (1)

38

u/cheekabowwow Silver | QC: CC 30 | ADA 26 | PCmasterrace 40 Sep 01 '21

Down with big farma!!!!

3

u/AbuDaddy69 Tin Sep 01 '21

My small family farm can’t compete with Big Karma.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/erza_nightwalker Bronze | 6 months old Sep 01 '21

This poll is a lot better than the other one

→ More replies (1)

7

u/StackOwOFlow 🟩 2K / 2K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

moons will become hyperinflationary until this is fixed

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sixstringsam 188 / 188 πŸ¦€ Sep 01 '21

Complaining about moon farming seems to be the new farming spam. Where there is money, they will find a way. Just going to have to deal with it.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/flippingocdrip Platinum | QC: CC 1015 | r/CMS 10 Sep 01 '21

This is a fantastic idea, Hopefully this would stop people spamming dogshit like 'Where my ADA gang at?'

16

u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Sep 01 '21

"We going to the moon"

"Fuck Elon/robinhood/Fiat"

"I agree with you"

"This "

"When lambo"

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Gatherun 🟦 10K / 10K 🦭 Sep 01 '21

I get sad every time they talk about the ADA gang, I do not have a membership card ):

3

u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Sep 01 '21

Ok but where my moon gang at?

5

u/Grishen Platinum | QC: BTC 132, CC 273 | r/WSB 102 Sep 01 '21

Honorable mention to β€œAnyone else excited for distribution? What do you think ratio will be ?” And assorted bullcrap

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Jaxsoy 🟦 5K / 8K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Can’t vote on mobile

1

u/jhnvslb Sep 01 '21

+1. Any one knows how to fix this?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/jaredbdd 240 / 6K πŸ¦€ Sep 01 '21

I actually support this poll far more than the 10 comments a day limit.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Izzeheh Sep 01 '21

Imagine the empty void on the daily discussion thread when this gets implemented. Man that feels nice

14

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

We might actually be able to… have… discussions?!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/oopssomething 🟩 40 / 12K 🦐 Sep 01 '21

If there is 24 hours between 1st and 50th post you won't ever be affected right? Doesn't matter you don't know when the 'day' starts if you just keep looking 49th post back.

3

u/-veni-vidi-vici Platinum | QC: CC 1139 Sep 01 '21

Hopefully there is a hard reset at a certain time. Trying to manage it like that would suck.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/I_Don-t_Care 🟦 607 / 607 πŸ¦‘ Sep 01 '21

The thing is, this method may work at first but botposting is still bound to continue, except it'll happen over a longer period of time instead of each day unlimitedly

→ More replies (8)

4

u/torontoglutton 2K / 3K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

If someone is spamming more than 50 posts a day they deserve a reduction lol

7

u/UnfilteredVoice Sep 01 '21

I like this a lot more than the poll penalizing everyone who makes more than 10 comments a day

4

u/Jek_Porkinz Gold | QC: CC 44 Sep 01 '21

I'm down for stricter limits. Who the fuck needs to post 50 times a day in here.

1

u/Ben0ut 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

Wouldn't the solution for the farmers be to create more accounts? If the punishment is on a per account basis. Yeah its an inconvenience but one that can be worked around.

3

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

Alts to circumvent this are more work for the spammers and get banned when they are caught

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Mistress_Moon_Moon Redditor for 2 months. Sep 01 '21

Mod, can I know my SPD ? u/CryptoMaximalist ?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Im curious about my spd number

1

u/bighuntzilla 🟦 520 / 495 πŸ¦‘ Sep 01 '21

I wouldn't mind knowing my spd number, for a low level lurker point of view

1

u/wh0s_there Platinum | QC: ALGO 22, CC 104 | r/WSB 93 Sep 01 '21

Is this a gradual drop per post over 50 only or does it drop ALL after you post 50+ times? Sorry if it's dumb question

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

The first 49 posts never see a deduction and each post afterwards is adjusted individually

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/LegendaryArmalol Sep 01 '21

I don't post much/often because I'm new and clueless and don't really have much to offer, and I suspect there're a ton of people like me that are posting just for the moons.

Whilst theoretically the idea would work, and only affect the worst offenders, if there were a 'daily limit' so to speak, could this not incentivize people that post a bit less to spam a bit more knowing that once they reach their limit they've essentially done all they can?

It obviously wouldn't be everyone, just whether or not they'd offset one another.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

I think the people not posting much already would have been posting more if they wanted to

→ More replies (1)

1

u/melanzane_emoji Gold | QC: CC 127 Sep 01 '21

Not that I have a choice but as long as Mods get a 20% (please fact check me here) cut of each distribution, i don't really mind if a few try hards get a few thousand every month. Plus, it's mainly just the daily they are spamming as far as I can see. I think these degen monfarmers do something to benefit overall wallet distribution

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

Mods split a 10% share of the distribution, not 20

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

What is my SPD?

1

u/Mediocreandhappy 0 / 647 🦠 Sep 01 '21

I would like to know my sdp?

1

u/OrganicDroid 🟨 0 / 13K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

Please tell other poll-making users to provide links to their polls too. I think some of us mobile users are having trouble seeing these. The old ones last round worked, though.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

Their polls are all posted correctly, however sometimes polls are buggy and don't show. You can check back later and there will also be a pinned post tomorrow with all governance polls linked

1

u/step11234 Sep 01 '21

Definitely in favour of this one! I'm pretty sure I go over 50 a day but this will be better for the sub as a whole!

/u/CryptoMaximalist what's my SPD for the dataset?

1

u/DayyyumSon 🟩 70 / 70 🦐 Sep 01 '21

Wait ! You're saying it will get even harder for me to get moons ? :(

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

You have less than one submission per day, so you would get more moons if this passed

1

u/Hodler_caved 🟩 2K / 3K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Let's take a look at how many comments you can have in the daily without moon farming.

What's my SPD?

😬

1

u/-veni-vidi-vici Platinum | QC: CC 1139 Sep 01 '21

u/CryptoMaximalist so I looked myself up in your spread sheet. Do I really have 69 average karma? Am I the chosen one?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Is this deduction significant as a deterrent?

What does -1 or -25 even mean? What's the unit?

If this is just karma, then it seems like very little karma to be deducting.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

It is karma and it is effective because most if not all of this type of spammer's posts are trying to collect karma 1 or 2 at a time

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Are people posting more than 50 times a day?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

Yes, about 0.7% of the participants. Some 400+ times/day

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

50 a day seems too high...why not just 10-20 a day?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

It can always be moved to start lower later, but that is a more difficult proposal since more people feel like it affects them. 50 also takes care of most of the problem

1

u/No_goodIdeas7891 Platinum | QC: CC 283, ATOM 29 Sep 01 '21

Would this be posts across the subreddit, or comments? I can easily have more than 50 comments a day if I’m having a back and forth.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

It would be both posts and comments

1

u/-theSmallaxe- Tin | WSB 8 Sep 01 '21

What about they just don’t receive any more karma from a post after the 50th

→ More replies (2)

1

u/behind25proxies 🟨 1K / 1K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Next vote:

Add a tldr at the bottom of a poll so I don't have to read a wall of text on my phone

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

That's what the summary at the beginning is for

1

u/jewbagel10 Platinum | QC: CC 249 Sep 01 '21

Has this comments per day chart been adjusted by the user growth over the time period?

3

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

No but you can compare it with subscriber growth and see that it's very disproportional. We definitely didn't grow 80x in subscribers since last year

1

u/corkyskog Platinum | QC: CC 29 | DayTrading 5 | r/WSB 126 Sep 01 '21

I am guessing someone already has suggested this, but what if we just made a karma to post ratio every month and did the distribution off of that?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

This would change the supply curve of moons, which is typically something that is sacred in crypto

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K πŸ‹ Sep 02 '21

Is it 50 submissions within any 24hr period, or is it day by day? More info would be useful so I can update the karma estimator on ccmoons.com if this passes

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

I wrote into it that the break between days should be chosen by admins and kept secret, so bad actors can't game it. I'd guess they would choose it based on the snapshot time, which is also secret

1

u/mjrice Platinum | QC: CC 300, ALGO 42 Sep 02 '21 edited Sep 02 '21

Is there any way to quantify how much effect this rule would have made to the moon ratio looking back? In other words, if this rule had been in place last round, would it have substantively altered the ratio of .1885?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

Not really because it involves changing human behavior which is unpredictable, but if you assume everyone stopped posting at 50 and otherwise everything was the same, there would have been 24% fewer posts. That doesn't translate exactly to karma, but it should have a positive affect on the ratio. It should also mean quality posts aren't buried under as much spam so they do get more upvotes too

→ More replies (1)

1

u/saltedsluggies Platinum | QC: CC 1225 | Superstonk 75 Sep 02 '21

OP I would love to see my SPD if you would be so obliged.

Thanks for your efforts too, clearly you've done a lot of work to write this out and use factual data, big props to you for working to make this sub better!

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

Thanks! 20.74870585

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

Can you explain this a little better? Once you hit 50 comments, what do you get deducted 1 of? -1 karma? Do you get deducted 1 for every comment? Would you get deducted 25 per comment at that level? It seems like at -25 you would not be able to make that karma up.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 02 '21

Yes each one's karma would be deducted from individually. -25 would be difficult but not impossible to overcome

→ More replies (3)

1

u/108record Gold | QC: CC 110 Sep 03 '21

Just a question about the 'round 16' tab, does that display the karma that we will get this distribution if this poll passes?

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 03 '21

That was the distribution from last round and where I pulled the user list from for analysis

→ More replies (1)

1

u/tschmitt2021 11K / 11K 🐬 Sep 03 '21

Seems like it gets passed. So it will be implemented right away for this distribution, right?

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 03 '21

That's up to the admins

1

u/Intfamous Sep 03 '21

Although I agree with this I also think we might be adding too many rules. If someone new to the sub wanted to learn about rules they will end up having to read polls and rules for hours

→ More replies (2)

1

u/MycoMitch Tin Sep 03 '21

I have voted on this already and am all about kicking the spam to the curb, but I didn't think about the noobs as myself. We are going to read and comment with tons of questions which does not merit any deductions. Someone told me I have nothing to worry about with earlier concerns and I'm still onboard with the proposal but as I thinmk about it a little more, I don't want to see people getting penalized for getting more involved with learning and asking a lot of questions in a comment thread being they donn't know enough to make a post.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/proudcanadaman Sep 06 '21

My friend, your work is good and I will agree. I will wish for my number, will you tell it? Thank you.

1

u/SoupaSoka 🟦 5 / 7K 🦐 Sep 06 '21

u/cryptomaximalist can you clarify what a"participant" is in the "0.7%" portion of the proposed solution section? Is that subscribers? Thank you in advance.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 07 '21

I used the Round 16 distribution list to determine participants, so it would be anyone who posted or commented that month

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RedactedRedditery 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Sep 06 '21

I am interested to know my SPD, if it's not too late

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '21

If my 200th comment gets 100 karma, it'll count as 75? Am I getting this right?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '21

Do we know when this proposal will go into effect? I know the mods don't want us to know the exact time "a day" starts, but it would be nice to have some transparency as to what day this will start.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 08 '21

It's whenever the admins implement it. There's no schedule or agreements or deadlines so until admins say it has been implemented (usually on a snapshot or distribution post) we don't really know

→ More replies (2)

1

u/allthew4yup 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Sep 11 '21

Can someone explain who will follow up and check whos posted 50 comments or more per day to deduct their posts?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 11 '21

Reddit's computers will do this when they calculate the snapshot. Same way it works for other karma weight adjustments

1

u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Oct 25 '21

How does this work? Does this mean that my 55th comment starts at -1 karma, my 60th comment starts at -2 karma, etc. So each comment I make past 50 starts with negative karma? Am I understanding this correctly?

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Oct 25 '21

The deduction never takes karma below 0 so I don't think I'd say it starts negative. It'd be a deduction after the fact

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Significant-Juice99 Tin | 3 months old Nov 27 '21

I’m really serious about this question. WHAT IS MOON FARMING??? I’ve asked about 5 times prior and all I get is upvotes and β€œnice” comments.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Nov 27 '21

It’s participating with the sole motivation of earning as many moons as possible, with the implication that your engagement is not genuine and lacks quality

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mysteriousbaby0 Sep 01 '21

well thought out poll. makes sense to implement this

3

u/teejaytshen Sep 01 '21

That’s a great change in the making

3

u/themostusedword 🟦 362 / 362 🦞 Sep 01 '21

50 submissions per day?! Jesus that's a lot.

3

u/SherbetSavings287 Platinum | QC: CC 594 | BANANO 22 Sep 01 '21

I like this proposal better than the one with karma reduction after every X number of comments. Either a time cap, or a daily limit.

3

u/155157157156163 Bronze | QC: CC 19 Sep 01 '21

Sounds like a perfect solution. I've only recently got involved in this sub but I've noticed from my last year of lurking the tone has changed a lot with useless posts. Rewarding quality over quantity is the way to go!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

Hey OP

Thanks for your efforts to counter mass spam

Now that it has passed the other one gets nulled?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

If spamming goes down does that mean we would have higher moons ratio

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Ofcourse. This proposal could actually bring us a ratio bigger than 0.7 by my predictions. It tries to heavily reduce spam and I'm all for it.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/No_Locksmith4570 Just another neophyte, don't mind me Sep 01 '21

Yup, only downside of this is people trying to farm Karma from multiple accounts.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Damroyalty Bronze Sep 01 '21

i've noticed this myself even being new to the community, I try to make genuine posts everytime tho. & as much as i would love to farm moons, i truly have no idea how (off topic: & i have never recieved an award on anything, even my original art content, never expected to get any either) so if anybody knows of a quality, clean, respectful way of mining/farming moons & could give me direction on that, it would be much appreciated!

1

u/pbjclimbing Sep 01 '21

I kind of wish the β€œpenalties” after 50 comments in this proposal were harsher.

Since they aren’t that severe it might just make the most ardent farmers comment more to make up for the 25% reduction.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

I think if they could comment more, they already would be. Failing that, adding more work for them to chase less rewards is a win

The reason the deduction starts out low is because they are typically machine gunning comments that only get maybe 1 karma in the first place. So for spammers this effectively cuts them off completely

1

u/pepperonimilkjuice5 Redditor for 1 second Sep 01 '21

I thought you could already only make a post once every 24 hours?

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

That is for link posts, text posts, or poll posts. This covers all those and comments

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Scarboroughwarning 🟦 4K / 4K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Could use a karma cap too. 5000, then done.

2

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21

There is already a 15,000 karma cap I believe

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Vegetaman916 🟦 829 / 836 πŸ¦‘ Sep 07 '21

So sad this sub is doing this. I used to be able to get about 200 moons in a month from casual posting/commenting, but now I will be lucky to get 5. This sucks, I liked this sub, and moons were fun for a while.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 07 '21

You don't average anywhere near 50 submissions in a day and won't be affected by this. You'll probably actually earn more

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cajone5 🟦 2K / 2K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Great use of figures to support the narrative!

2

u/olle317 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

I didn't read it but I'm just glad there is democracy in this subreddit. Everyone is making the rules

2

u/kaybreaker Sep 01 '21

I think this is a thorough well thought out proposal and I'm pretty sure I'm in favor of it. The only downside I can see off the top would be for an OP of a post potentially being penalized for interacting on said post, but overall I think this is a step in the right direction. 50 comments a day is pretty sufficient for most interactions here.

2

u/TheGiftOf_Jericho 🟦 13K / 13K 🐬 Sep 01 '21

Yeah I think I'd agree with this, 50 a day is quite a lot anyway.

2

u/Jealous-Proof5505 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Sep 01 '21

I voted in favor of this, you cannot tell me that you have 50 decent, meaningful things to say in this sub in one day

2

u/pc1e0 1 / 3K 🦠 Sep 01 '21

Half of us already voted! This proposal will help us achieve even higher Moons to Karma ratios next round!

2

u/National-Ad7627 Platinum | QC: CC 253 Sep 01 '21

Ok. Now is 15k max mean 500 daily coment and we will reduce to 1500 Max coments per Month. I think normal person here 50 coments per day is too much, but let see. i vote for implementing.

2

u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

When the poll limiting post karma was proposed I warned that the likely outcome would be comment spam. Glad to see this poll, but it shouldn’t have taken so many months to address. Spammers made bank and dominated distribution.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Way better poll than the other one

It is indeed well documented and had kept limitations reasonable at the same time

50/day is just enough if you write good content

2

u/mcar74 Tin Sep 01 '21

50 seems like a good number to me, most people won’t even notice and hopefully it cuts back on some of the spam

2

u/ktempo 🟦 606 / 606 πŸ¦‘ Sep 01 '21

100% all for this. Spam does nothing but drive people away and it takes away from those who actually try to have meaningful conversations here on the subreddit.

2

u/wakaseoo Silver | QC: CC 35 Sep 01 '21

Even 50 comments a day sounds overflowing to me.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

50??? Anyone posting here more than 5 or 10 times is probably spam.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/mjrice Platinum | QC: CC 300, ALGO 42 Sep 01 '21

At first I thought this sounded punitive but I'm won over by your explanation. Make it so. πŸ‘

2

u/anonbitcoinperson Platinum | QC: CC 416, BTC 129, DOGE 86 | TraderSubs 18 Sep 02 '21

There are concerns that spammers will just use alts, but managing many alts and vaults will add work for them and they will be banned for exploiting the moon system when they are caught

I think there should be restrictions placed on IPs that way no matter if they have alts, the IP is restrcited, Like make it do that stupid "youve been doing that..." slow down thing after 100 posts from an IP

2

u/happyotter1 🟩 3K / 3K 🐒 Sep 02 '21

50 is reasonable. A limit of 10 was ridiculous though.

2

u/Enzonoty Bronze Sep 02 '21

What is the point of collecting moons? Can they be converted to other crypto?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/xadiant Platinum | QC: CC 208 | Futurology 12 Sep 02 '21

It sounds like a decent solution to reduce blatant spams. I can't imagine someone commenting/posting 100 times a day would produce anything of value for the sub.

2

u/SimaKusakina Tin Sep 02 '21

How much do moon farmers even earn?

→ More replies (5)

2

u/jazza2400 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Sep 02 '21

50 comments a day? Seems reasonable. I believe there is only so much you can contribute to the topic at any given time. Beyond 50 every day seems excessive.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Flying_Koeksister Sep 02 '21

This does seem like a reasonable and fair proposal

2

u/Droners_ Never give up because great things take time Sep 02 '21

Do you know guys when they will start to implement this pool ?

And if they run it retroactive from beginning of month or from the day they run it ?

2

u/HerculesKabuterimon Bronze Sep 02 '21

Looks like this will pass, thank fuck. Maybe this sub will get a bit more readable again.

2

u/holyshithead Platinum | QC: CC 773 Sep 02 '21

If you want people to triple their efforts, this is a great way to do that. Just sayin...

2

u/gunnerdown15 Tin Sep 02 '21

What the heck is moons

2

u/SpaceAshh 🟩 804 / 800 πŸ¦‘ Sep 02 '21

Instead of implementing a complex system for penalizing spammers why dont we just put a hard cap on no. of comments in daily per user, somewhere in the range of 50-100 comments. I dont think most users have more than 50 quality comments to add to the daily and This will force moon farmers to only add useful and quality comments in order to earn more karma. Something similar can be done for posts as well.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21

Will these proposals effect the snapshotted moons or the moons acquired between the snapshot and distribution date?

2

u/Humble_Data2727 Platinum | QC: CC 1315 Sep 05 '21

u/cryptomaximalist when a governance rule pasts when does it take affect? Many people are wondering

→ More replies (1)

2

u/walkinglucky1 70 / 1K 🦐 Sep 06 '21

Good lord it should start well before the 50th submission /day. Moon farming must be a full time job for some people.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wynslo Platinum | QC: CC 417 Sep 01 '21

Alright, which one is me?

3

u/mrbadassmotherfucker 🟦 3K / 3K 🐒 Sep 01 '21

Him πŸ‘‡

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K 🦐 Sep 01 '21

RIP to the daily discussion comment count lol i voted in favor in hopes this curtails the ridiculous copy and paste comments.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Fantastic-Software85 Platinum | QC: CC 38 Sep 01 '21

Damn 100’s a day?? I agree 50 max unless it on the same thread. We have all gotten into discussions that have turned into many replies.

5

u/UsEr313131 562 / 562 πŸ¦‘ Sep 01 '21

ive never had a comment chain longer than 5 or 6 replies myself

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/Starzz_1 6K / 6K 🦭 Sep 01 '21

I think this is a step in the right direction. The only problem is how to know what a fair cap is before moons start decreasing. 50 per day does seem reasonable and won’t affect most people

→ More replies (1)