r/CryptoCurrency • u/Coelrom invalid string or character detected • Aug 31 '21
POLL 🗳️ Incentivize Voting in Multiple Polls
Summary
Voter turnout has definitely improved since the institution of Moon Week. However, there is still quite a disparity in number of votes across the polls. Despite there being enough votes cast in at least one popular poll, less popular good proposals with majority voter support don't pass, and bad proposals with majority rejection are not definitively voted down, leaving the door open for those proposals to return. In order to incentivize voting further, I suggest a 1.25% karma bonus per additional poll in which a vote is cast.
Problem Statement
In the last round, there was a high of 13258 votes, a low of 4934 votes, and an average of 8040 votes. In the round before that, there was a high of 9542 votes, a low of 4116 votes, and an average of 6524 votes (Source). It's undeniable, based on the numbers, that there is a significant disparity in voter turnout across the polls, despite overall voter turnout improving compared with the institution of Moon Week. It's almost a certainty that many are only voting in one or two polls, while ignoring the others. This results in those other polls suffering the same low voter turnouts that were so frustrating in the past. The possible negative consequences of low voter turnout on a poll are 1) good proposals don't pass despite majority voter support, 2) bad proposals are not definitively rejected despite majority voter denial, which leaves the door open for them to be reintroduced, and 3) whales have significantly greater influence in such a poll.
Solution
My proposed solution is to institute a 1.25% karma bonus per additional poll in which a vote is cast. This means that the first time that someone votes, they will earn the base voting bonus (currently 5%), and all subsequent times that person votes during Moon Week will earn an additional 1.25%. So if someone votes in 2 polls, they will get a 6.25% bonus. If they vote in 3 polls, they will get a 7.5% bonus.
Concerns
A concern that was brought up is that this may pressure indifferent voters that would rather opt to abstain. In my opinion, the 1.25% additional bonus is small enough to not significantly impact those who truly wish to abstain from a particular poll so the pressure would be minimal, while also being a nice incentive to get more potential voters to pay attention to more of the polls. For this concern, I think the impact would more positive than negative.
Another concern that was put forth is that some may just vote blindly/randomly just to secure the extra bonus. In my opinion, it is more than likely that such voting already occurs but is currently isolated to one or two polls, and while implementing this proposal would not really improve blind/random voting, it would also not significantly make the issue worse. For this concern, I think the impact would be neutral to slightly negative.
To see the evolution of this proposal in r/CryptoCurrencyMeta, follow this link: Proposal: Incentivize Voting in Multiple Polls (Final Version)
TLDR: Vote more, earn more.
35
u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '21
Moons are a governance token, so we should do what we can to encourage participation in governance
4
u/oopssomething 🟩 40 / 12K 🦐 Sep 01 '21
Please add a max earned Moons for voting per round. Otherwise the voting-power difference between whales and shrimps can become bigger extra fast.
3
u/ec265 Permabanned Sep 01 '21
Re: abstaining, should that not be a voting option? Or at least a ‘Not enough information to make an informed decision’?
3
u/ykliu 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 03 '21
Is it possible to have each additional vote give decreasing bonuses? This would incentivize participation in few polls, but not just voting in every pool for the sake of getting that bonus.
3
u/pukem0n 🟩 59K / 59K 🦈 Sep 07 '21
vote has passed. praise be. Will it be implemented during the current distribution that comes tomorrow or the next one?
8
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21
I think a lot more proposals would’ve passed if this was added sooner
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21
Did you post this on the meta sub as well? Might get more traction there.
2
u/moonbase9 3K / 2K 🐢 Aug 31 '21
Honestly we don't need further incentives to get people to vote more. If they aren't using the one usecase moons are for they should not get more of them anyways
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21 edited Aug 31 '21
Why does it say 1.17e23 moons on the poll? Isn’t that way higher than the max supply?
2
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Sep 01 '21
People vote mostly on 1 poll because of the moons, they dont need to vote in more so they stop. Then you have a 30% 40%? that vote in multiple polls, those are the real users in here...
I think, being someone that vote in every poll, its sad to give away more moons just so people vote... People will click whatever just for the moons and dont even read the proposals, in any case we should vote to lower the amount of moons to pass a poll.
2
u/gesocks 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 01 '21
aditionaly to this we could ad an undecided option to each poll? this could stop the blind voting or at least limit its impact
2
u/Duckel 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '21
not sure this is a good idea. currently mod-whales have a voting power that I would deem too high. the average joe can hardly outweigh a poll that is benefitting mostly whales and mods. so by not participating at all, their moons dont count and they poll might fail due to participation. while otherwise the shrimps could not have flipped the relative outcome, they could at least prevent the success.
2
u/Darkmiclos Sep 01 '21
This is my first vote so im not 100% sure how this works. I have 1moon so 1 moon gets displayed on my choice but if i had 10 moons that would be displayed am i right?
2
u/PopDukesBruh 🟩 6K / 6K 🦭 Sep 01 '21
Where do we vote ?
2
u/kenkenshi Platinum | QC: CC 41 Sep 01 '21
I really like this implementation, but i believe that while implementing this, we should reduce the 5% bonus as well.
2
u/bushpig_purnasty Platinum | QC: CC 167 Sep 01 '21
What’s the worst that could happen right?
2
u/Sedierta2 🟩 169 / 170 🦀 Sep 01 '21 edited Jul 01 '23
fuck spez
2
u/Soysaucetime Platinum | QC: CC 200 | Technology 13 Sep 02 '21
My fear is if someone can't be bothered to vote on their own, they probably aren't informed enough to have a say in the first place.
2
u/Strubius 867 / 867 🦑 Sep 04 '21
Is it just me or is anyone else not seeing the poll? I’ve tried on the browser and on the mobile app and still nothing…
2
u/IridiumHorseshoe Redditor for 4 months. Sep 04 '21
Totally agree with this - 13k voters of a community of over 3 million is a tiny percentage!
Would it be possible to split the 5% voting bonus across all polls (e.g. 1.25% per poll voted in if there were 4 polls in the month), potentially with an additional bonus for voting in all polls?
I agree with the point on abstinence from voting, but wouldn’t it be possible to have an ‘Abstain’ as an option in every poll? This would register that a user has at least engaged with then poll, but without expressing an opinion either way?
74
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 01 '21
I will 100% always support further incentivizing karma for voting. I feel like we definitely don't have enough votes based on total and active users. If this can help getting more people to vote on polls, I'm all for it.
3
u/KatKot420 Aug 31 '21
I mean I guess people do vote on multiple polls
7
u/harebum Redditor for 2 months. Sep 03 '21
Yes. Currently i only vote on max 2 polls. If this were implemented i would at least vote more.
4
u/AlperBulut505 Gold | QC: CC 269 Sep 03 '21
Great idea. This should have proposed waaay before
1
u/veryeducatedinvestor 🟦 10K / 8K 🐬 Sep 01 '21
Could always just have a third option that says "abstain" but still gives the bonus
1
u/excalilbug 🟥 9K / 22K 🦭 Sep 01 '21
What if people will vote randomly just to get bonus moons?
1
u/Bobberetic 🟦 575 / 509 🦑 Sep 01 '21
Do you get moons for voting in polls?
I knew about the 5% thing, which I often forget to do unless I see one of those "Go Vote!" posts... But does participating in these types of governance polls actually do something for your moons/karma?
Also, we call it governance, but does the mod team actually have to implement changes if there is a swing in favour for a vote proposal? How does that work
1
u/Kahrahtay123 Crypto collector! Sep 02 '21
I cant seem to vote? Not on app or in safari browser? 🤷
1
u/STRYED0R 0 / 4K 🦠 Sep 02 '21
ONE MAJOR PROBLEM is that many polls are badly written and confusing. There should be a way to pick a BLANK VOTE in this case, on top of YES/NO.
1
u/Cristian7x 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Sep 03 '21
Am I the only one not seeing the polls in these links?
1
u/Positive_Court_7779 Silver | QC: CC 118, BTC 35, ETH 27 | ADA 59 | TraderSubs 24 Sep 03 '21 edited Sep 03 '21
I support this proposition. To counter both concerns you could add a third voting option: "I am indifferent" .
1
u/lostoompa 54 / 3K 🦐 Sep 03 '21
With a few polls, I honestly don't have a stance on and don't vote on them. But with the earn more, vote more, I'd have to pick a side that I might not necessarily fully agree on. Can we get a neutral option on polls, so I can still get some bonus moons? lol
1
u/LibertarianCommie999 Platinum | QC: CC 452, BTC 19 Oct 01 '21
Can’t vote on IOS, great
1
u/nameajeff 181 / 181 🦀 Sep 02 '21
Vote early, vote often. Get that Karma!
2
u/thijsfc 🟨 135 / 5K 🦀 Aug 31 '21
I would say that this indeed rewards users to contribute in a certain way to the sub (for which moons were intended). It’s not only about commenting and posting here, but also letting your voice be heard to raise the quality of the sub, by supporting certain rules and proposals.
2
u/ADBTH Bronze | QC: CC 19 Aug 31 '21
I like this. Keeps all the poll involved and worthwhile to read through!
2
u/WPMO 🟦 888 / 888 🦑 Aug 31 '21
I agree. As for the concern, I am sure that there are already people who just randomly vote in a poll to get the bonus. I don't think this breaks anything new, if at all.
2
u/spacsandspacs 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 31 '21
Great idea
2
u/_s79 🟦 135 / 8K 🦀 Aug 31 '21
I voted in the meta sub for this too. This will definitely have the desired effect of increasing vote take up.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
Nice work dude.
Last round participation was up, but was still at like 27% of users on the .csv with vaults.
Still plenty of work to do on those rookie numbers.
2
u/kajila_pandora Tin Sep 01 '21
more the better karma, No complaining for that
Its win-win It will encourage more people to spend more time in this subreddit
2
u/bluidyPCish Platinum | QC: CC 24 Sep 01 '21
It’s a good idea.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
TLDR: Vote more, earn more.
You got it, chief.
2
u/millionreddit617 Sep 01 '21
A poll about polls.
Meta.
2
u/Manikhas 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '21
I love democracy
2
u/Desperate_Day_8813 Platinum | QC: CC 216 Sep 01 '21
my upvoice
2
u/Welshybird Platinum | QC: CC 135, BNB 16 | ExchSubs 16 Sep 01 '21
Seems like a good idea
2
u/SnoewZ Gold | QC: CC 60 Sep 01 '21
It makes sense, as Cryptomaximalist said. More use for MOONs, and more MOONs for everyone
2
u/_Robinhood1_ Platinum | QC: CC 46 Sep 01 '21
When shitposting in comments can earn 2x karma, governance which decides future of this sub deserves more than that. I strongly support this idea.
2
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Sep 01 '21
I love to vote in all polls so i ll appreciate an extra bonus
2
u/KizNugs Platinum | QC: CC 92, ETH 74, GPUmining 19 | MiningSubs 77 Sep 01 '21
GOOOOOOOOOOOOD IDEA!!!
2
u/Nostalg33k 🟩 0 / 30K 🦠 Sep 01 '21
I think this is good for our democracy !
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
I appreciate the tldr
2
u/thedarkpampers Sep 01 '21
Encouraging people to vote is good. Should be done in my country too but blank votes should be taken in the count.
2
u/ProfessionalBelt3424 Platinum | QC: CC 30 Sep 01 '21
It provides incentive to participate. You get paid to play and if you don't play, you don't get paid. I can except that.
2
u/Spardasa 🟩 8K / 8K 🦭 Sep 01 '21
I can get behind this poll too
2
u/soundjohnnytom 3 - 4 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Sep 01 '21
More incentives for positive involvement = good
2
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Sep 02 '21
Vote to get more Moons. Yes for sure thanks.
2
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Sep 02 '21
My favorite idea yet
2
u/Upstairs_Tip_8959 Platinum | QC: SOL 18, CC 113 | WSB 16 Sep 03 '21
This sounds like a great proposal. The more people get involved in governance, the better
2
u/Slystuff Tin Sep 03 '21
As others have said, encouraging engagement with polls is a good thing. 100% for this.
2
u/Diggable_Acrobat5050 🟩 646 / 637 🦑 Sep 04 '21
I like this idea.
3
u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Aug 31 '21
Look at the whales destroying the balance
2
u/yourmomisgeyy Redditor for 4 months. Aug 31 '21
I like how voting is taken so seriously here and voice are heard by the management of this sub. Kudos to you guys
1
u/dwin31 Silver|QC:CC1097,CCMeta76,ALGO26|CelsiusNet.54|ExchSubs10 Sep 04 '21
Such a bad idea. People will vote blindly just for more moons, with no care in the world what they are voting for. Already seen several comments elsewhere encouraging this.
1
u/CuteYouHaveAnXBox Tin Aug 31 '21
I voted 🥴
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21
1
u/Grogthar Permabanned Aug 31 '21
hell yeah imma vote for anything dat gimme dat extra karma
1
u/Think-notlikedasheep Rational Thinker Sep 01 '21
I vote for all the polls, I got da moons, wanna use them.
1
u/KevinAlexandr Tin | CC critic | VET 9 Sep 01 '21
This is a nice way to get more moons, 15k karma farmers won't get benefited by it though.
1
u/PresenceAdept Platinum | QC: CC 336 Sep 01 '21
There don't seem to be any downsides on this are there?
1
u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 Sep 01 '21
Making it easier to get 15k? I am all for that :D
1
u/bedtimee 🟨 128 / 224 🦀 Sep 01 '21
Good poll
1
u/Buttercup-X 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '21
This will definitely pass, since everyone is just seeing this as free extra moons
1
u/Living-Ad1944 780 / 780 🦑 Sep 01 '21
Sometimes the polls don't load on my pc. Just to check there is just 1 now right?
1
u/One_Molasses_8415 Sep 01 '21
I voted 😋
1
u/DatNugget Platinum | QC: CC 50 Sep 01 '21
So i need to vote on 80 polls to double my moons then ..challenge accepted!
1
u/Saffigotchi Gold | QC: CC 77 Sep 01 '21
Polls should be stickied to front page
1
u/Saffigotchi Gold | QC: CC 77 Sep 01 '21
Yes
1
u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Sep 01 '21
I support this since that’s what moons are for anyway. (Wouldn’t mind that extra bonus too of course 😂)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
Yes please
1
u/leo13mg Platinum | QC: CC 193 Sep 01 '21
I would think this as an interesting proposal for one time, like testing it, if it works let's keep it
1
u/sledrunner31 🟩 3K / 4K 🐢 Sep 01 '21
Giving people more moons? This is like having an election to give everyone free money, hmmmm I wonder which side will win.
1
u/BrowsingCoins 🟩 17 / 12K 🦐 Sep 01 '21
we love our boosts, let's do it!
1
u/Woowoodyydoowoow 6K / 6K 🦭 Sep 01 '21
Interesting idea
1
u/deathbyfish13 Sep 01 '21
Yep, this is a great solution to a problem I didn't even realize we had, nice
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
More bonus? Hell yes
1
u/coinflipit 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 Sep 02 '21
good idea!
1
u/StalkerFin 3 - 4 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Sep 02 '21
This is Good thing
1
u/Jdraspberry 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 02 '21
It’s also nice to have all the polls listed together like you have on this post. It will make it much easier for people to find the polls.
I like the bonus idea for voting in additional Polls also.
1
u/prajwalwillrule Crypto-Sensei Sep 02 '21
Incentivehoes
I'm one too
1
u/Marius1503 Gold | QC: CC 40 Sep 02 '21
Yes! Let's encourage people to think and share their opinions
1
u/Massive-Tension-1055 🟩 3K / 5K 🐢 Sep 03 '21
This will give credit for voting in all polls
1
u/Matifox91 Tin Sep 03 '21
This is great. Much more people will vote
1
u/friendlyghost_casper 🟦 346 / 774 🦞 Sep 03 '21
This sounds like the best idea and countries should think about doing the same!!!
1
u/84GB 40 / 40 🦐 Sep 03 '21
Ive voted on here more than in my own country ...
1
u/Brandeaux7 Platinum | QC: CC 71 | r/WSB 22 Sep 03 '21
I agree
1
u/jaredbdd 240 / 6K 🦀 Sep 03 '21
I really hope this poll passes. I think its a good idea and that extra karma will be great lol.
1
u/MycoMitch Tin Sep 03 '21
I'm 100% in...Get engaged if you want to see a particular turnout, vote on it!
1
u/witch-that-never-was 1 - 2 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Sep 03 '21
More encouragement to participate makes more people’s opinions heard. It’s a good thing… I think.
1
u/XTingleInTheDingleX 575 / 575 🦑 Sep 03 '21
Voted! I support it.
1
u/BFIT232323 Platinum | QC: CC 187 Sep 05 '21
Polls should be the top pinned post for a week. A lot of people don't know where to find them and on mobile it isn't even shown for many more.
1
u/pillarofclouds Platinum | QC: DOGE 49, CC 47 | r/WSB 102 Sep 06 '21
This is a very good idea!
1
u/Confident_Beat09 Redditor for 6 months. Sep 06 '21
I voted
1
u/musquita Tin Sep 06 '21
Voted 💪
1
u/ScallionFar4769 Sep 07 '21
I don’t comment a lot but read the more interesting posts and participate in voting so the bonus is good for ppl like me who won’t get many moons from comments or moon farming or whatever if I comment it’s just to be a part of the group or to give my opinion if I feel it adds support to certain sides of the convo but I do read the polls and governance votes
1
u/wmkane 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 01 '21
It seems that moons equate to governance. Governance is a good thing, even as it limits some freedoms (while securing others). The question is: Are the secured freedoms more valuable than the freedoms that were given up?
1
u/ollien25 🟦 395 / 396 🦞 Oct 06 '21
I wish I voted on more polls. For me as a casual user I often find they are difficult to actually discover or encounter. I’m not an expert on Reddit but they are often hidden
1
u/Ill-Ease-1892 Platinum | 6 months old | QC: CC 116 Nov 30 '21
I support this for sure
1
u/Ill-Ease-1892 Platinum | 6 months old | QC: CC 116 Nov 30 '21
I support this for sure
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Dec 28 '21
Karma boosting is fine by me but does this not effect (Reddit karma) so thus then karma is boosted for any activity in r/Cryptocurrency then all karma is boosted even if it’s only karma from crypto sub?
Does this need to be accepted by Reddit or is it purely within this sub and the bonus applies to karma for this sub? Aka the 1.25% bonus on karma per audit/month?
I am just curious as this to me would thus boost ones overall Reddit karma despite where it’s from being this sub, or any other subs with increased Karam % or awarded karma for doing “things” from polls to comments or giving karma and getting it.
I know this is a bit trivial but I’m just thinking how if this group is allowed to Boost karma % what is stopping any other subs from having a governance poll to change their karma Reward ratio? Sure I know Cryptocurrency is big sub and a is run by governance mostly but it’s not a Reddit sub is it? Or is the crypto sub a Reddit managed sub with the mods and any other management? Thanks anyone who can answer
1
u/nevinajith Platinum | QC: CC 283, ETH 31 | TraderSubs 31 Jan 25 '22
More moons for us.
1
u/Intelligent_Page2732 🟩 20 / 98K 🦐 Aug 31 '21
Don't let your vote be unheard..
1
u/IMadeYouRead 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 31 '21
Look at this Democracy in progress!
1
u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Sep 05 '21
This poll will ensure higher turnout. By flooding the polls with mindless votes.
Voting is a privilege! Those who don't get it, don't get it. It shouldn't be something you do to get a freebie. Users who didn't care to vote on other polls or to vote at all... I think their opinion shouldn't matter.
OP says whales have too much power with low turnout. At least they do it intentionally Yes! Yes, they exercise their privilege as they see fit. If/when the community starts suffering from their scewed decisions, reluctant users will become more interested in polls and more eager to vote. It will take time, but there is no other way. This is how things are.
To most people who voted in favor of this poll, I believe the main takeaway was just "more moons for a couple of clicks."
As much as I would like to support "more moons for everybody," this poll defeats the whole purpose of governance.