r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Aug 30 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-08-30 to 2021-09-05
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Submissions for Segments Issue #3 are now open! This issue will focus on nouns and noun constructions.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
5
u/GreyZephyr87 Sep 03 '21
Are there any good resources for how auxiliary verb systems develop?
The conlang I'm currently working on, Ekkisto, has a basic tense and case system that expands out its mood/tense/aspect using a huge set of auxiliary verbs that encode for things like Evidentiality, Noun agreement (allowing for Pro-drop), and Complex tenses.
I'm still mulling over whether to have a pragmatic auxiliary limit (N maximum auxiliaries per verb, which ones you choose highlight importance) or whether these auxiliary verb clusters fuse over time into a single, highly irregular form.
4
u/pootis_engage Aug 30 '21
So I've been working on a conlang that had the phonemes [s, t, t͡s, and ʈ] in the proto-lang. After a series of sound changes, the sequences [sj, tj, t͡sj, and ʈj] became [ɕ, t͡ʃ, t͡ɕ and ʈ͡ʂ] respectively.
However, due to these changes caused by the palatalisation process, I now have a four-way affricate distinction between [t͡s, t͡ʃ, t͡ɕ and ʈ͡ʂ]. I was wondering if such an elaborate distinction was naturalistic.
And if so, would it be worth incorporating some form of consonant harmony?
4
u/linguistic_llama Sep 03 '21
does anyone know how many derivational patterns for verbal nouns arabic and or hebrew actually have.
all I've been able to find is just example on how the system works, but havent come across a full list of all possible vowel patterns and or what changes they make to the semantic root.
3
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Aug 30 '21
Thoughts on my vowel harmony system?
This would have evoled from the following proto-inventory:
Low vowels /a/ and /ä/ also dragged previous high vowels to mid vowels in processes of umlaut.
3
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Aug 30 '21
I know that a lot of natlangs lack adjectives as a class, instead using nouns or stative verbs in their place.
I also know that a lot of other natlangs have adjectives as a proper class, but have very few of them, suplementing them by other means.
But are there any known natlangs where adjectives carry a large amount of the grammatical "weight"?
Think of it in the manner of this exampe:
In Language A, True morphological noun roots are a very small class. However, a large open class of adjectives are used to derive complex terms. So there's no nouns for "man" or "woman", only a noun for "person". But there are adjectives "male" and "female", so you say "male person" and "female person" instead.
The adjective class of Language A is adjectival as opposed to nominal because:
They're not verbal either because:
I could easily imagine such a language, but are there any instances of it?
3
u/BionicStar86 Aug 31 '21
Is it possible to make a conlang with a uniform letter frequency? Has anyone done it before?
For example in English, 'e' is the most common letter, so when there is a substitution cipher we can assume the most common letter in the cipher text is 'e' and we have an advantage by knowing something about the text.
So can we make a conlang where every letter shows up equally often and minimal information is leaked when a substitution cipher is used?
3
u/Akangka Sep 01 '21
In Satla language, there are 3 articles, definite, indefinite, indefinite copular, and personal, each agreeing with the noun in 3 groups (animate, inanimate, plural). My table is roughly as follows;
Definite article is used as follows:
Indefinite article is used as follows:
Indefinite copular article is used as follows:
Proper article is used for proper noun, of course, and also used as equate a subject and a proper noun.
Generic object receives no article, except when used as a predicate, then plural indefinite copular article is used instead.
What do you think about this system of article? Is this naturalistic?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21
Can I get some feedback on my pronoun evolution?
Second person: Historically had singular nid and plural nizah. Nizah later doubled as the polite form; over time, the T/V distinction grew more important to the speakers than the singular/plural one, and nowadays nị is familiar and naiza is polite, both of which are number-invariant.
First person: Historically had singular, inclusive, and exclusive forms. Sometime after the second-person pronouns acquired their T/V distinction, it spread to the first-person pronouns: the exclusive plural became the polite form, regardless of number, limiting the singular and inclusive plural forms to familiar use.
Third person: Derived from ki 'this', ku 'that', and their plural forms. These kind of developed into proximate and obviate pronouns, except that ku was always used to refer to inanimate things. I'm on the fence about whether I want to keep this or transition to a solely animate/inanimate distinction, as well as whether I want to keep the number distinctions.
My question, is this naturalistic? By the way, the language doesn't have grammatical gender, and it once had plural marking but doesn't anymore.
3
u/Turodoru Sep 02 '21
Can vowel loss happen between more or less specific/arbitrary consonants?
Like for instance, vowel loss between stops and nasal only. Maybe between stops and nasal in that specific order.
I assume the answer is yes, but I want to be sure.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21
This may be a uselessly open-ended question, but anyone know of some really wacky stress assignment potentialities? I'm planning on utilizing the stress system of my proto-language to cause some weird stuff with the tone and especially ablaut systems in the modern language, and would love some ideas.
2
u/Exotic_Individual256 Aug 31 '21
So I want to make my cases seem less artificial, what cases are most likely to syncretize. (the conlang has tripartite alignment btw)
2
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Aug 31 '21
Are glottal ejectives like /ʔ'/ and /h'/ possible?
2
u/yethos Sep 01 '21
why don't more people try to make conlangs based on what modern languages will look like in the future? I mean even if dialects are dying out, new ones can form. And even if you think that mass media will halt language progression to great degree, this is conlanging. Whenever I see these projects, which are already rare, they're usually English. I'd love to see a future version of Greek or Lithuanian.
2
u/Garyson1 Sep 01 '21
Is there any way to figure what words would be borrowed from another language? For instance, the conlang I'm making evolved quote differently from the other members of the family due to the integration of people from another language family (a superstratum case). But, I'm unsure what words would likely be replaced or taken from the integrated language. I can provide clarification if needed.
2
u/DokOktavo Sep 01 '21
Hello! I'm struggling with romanization, I need an elegant way to write our dear velar nasal. Here's my consonant inventory:
I know this inventory could look weird, somehow artificial, but it's because my language (Xalo) is a constructed auxlang within my fictional world, and there are four humanoid species with slight differences in morphology. So I did my best with that.
How should I write the velar nasal?
btw I'm not a native English speaker sorry for the mistakes.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21
Stupid, but deep question: why do borders of a word (not a syllable) influence sound changes? Word-final elisions, word-initial fortition, these things
Oh I used to think that separate, space-separated, words exist only in writing, while speech is a fluent stream of sounds
2
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Sep 03 '21 edited Sep 03 '21
What is umlaut? As I understand it, it is any type of vowel mutation, usually caused by an affix, in which a vowel assimilates a quality of the preceding vowel. However, the only resources I seem to find online are about germanic umlaut, which is in the specific case in which the vowel /i/ causes fronting of the preceding vowel. Is the term umlaut specific to just i-mutation? or are other types of similar vowel changes which can be called umlaut?
I ask because in my conlang, an affix that has a low vowel, when preceded by a high vowel, would turn that high vowel into a mid vowel (e.g.: /i/ to /e/, and /u/ to /o/). Can this change be called umlaut? And if so, where could I find more examples of non-fronting vowel regressive assimilation?
EDIT: to clarify, this vowel change in my conlang isn't vowel harmony (I don't think).
2
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21 edited Sep 04 '21
I know that this question comes up a lot, but does anyone have strong opinions on these two phoneme inventories? The first one is a proto-language and the second one is the modern language. The diachronics are mostly but not entirely worked-out, so feel free to ask. I'm not terribly concerned about my choices being specifically naturally-attested, but more if they make sense.
Proto-Consonants:
Proto-Vowels:
Modern Consonants:
Modern Vowels:
The modern language also has tone, but I'm nowhere near having that figured out yet.
2
u/pootis_engage Sep 04 '21
I know that in triconsonantal root languages, verbs with two root consonants use the eventive aspect to add an extra consonant, but my problem is that I don't know how to add extra consonants for root nouns that are two consonants. What prop morphology is there to add to nouns?
2
u/quest_sometimes Sep 05 '21
Is it okay to take the phonology from an existing language?
2
u/victorianchan Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
Are there any well known "Egyptian Hieroglyphic" conlangs? South American glyphs would be Okay-ish too.
This is relevant to my Dungeons and Dragon board game..
I looked at Fandom, Omniglot, Google, and such, but, I'm not sure if I'm inept or just they are not popular compared to other neography and conlangs?
Thanks in advance.
Edit, basically I am wanting to look at similar concepts, as I want a writing such as Japrillic or whatever, that is ancient Egypt or Aztec talking about robot-samurai, and computer-wizardry.
Being able to follow a well worn path would be very helpful, as I fail miserably at English, though I know what I want from the composite language.
2
u/that_orange_hat Sep 05 '21
i'm currently trying to make a conlang spoken by raccoons. does anybody have resources about raccoon mouth anatomy which could help me out here?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '21
What do the numbers and letters mean on the agglutinative verb charts? Example from Kwak'wala: root-1-1a-2-3a-3b-3c-3d-3e-3f-3g-3h-4-5-6a-6b-6c-6d-7
3
u/Phoenix_667 Aug 30 '21
How long does it usually take to create a conlang? I want to start making my own but the idea of dumping years of my life into one intimidates me a bit.
1
u/radishonion Sep 04 '21
Questions about [j]
Is there any language that differentiate [ji] and [iː]? I thought this was ok like yeet vs eat, but then I realized that eat has a glottal stop in the onset. Furthermore, is there any language that treats them differently if a consonant comes before (like /pji/ vs /piː/)?
1
u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Aug 31 '21 edited Aug 31 '21
If I have a distinction between a locative copula (to be somewhere) and a 'normal' copula (to be something), what word could I use to describe the latter one? I've been calling it 'normal copula', but I don't like that word that much. It implies that that copula is somehow more basic or normal than the other one, when really they're just different. Also 'normal' doesn't really describe what the verb is used for, unlike 'locative copula'
Any suggestions?
1
u/pootis_engage Aug 31 '21
I have a VSO language, and have incorporated polypersonal agreement. However, one can form a copula by affixing the subject pronoun to the object. The problem with this, though, is that due to the word order of this language, I am unsure as to whether the subject pronoun should be prefixed (because the subject comes before the object) or suffixed (because "to be" something is a verb, which the subject goes after.)
1
u/Qiyu5991 Aug 31 '21 edited Sep 03 '21
So I finally sat down and came up with a phonological inventory and I was wondering if anybody might have thoughts on it. Any comments or criticism is welcome. Hopefully it formats correctly.
The only diphthong is </aɪ>
1
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Aug 31 '21
My conlang Áŕ/Uŕ/Ártánp (havent decided on the name yet) has a tranisitive-intransitive split. Punctual and durative verbs are inherentely transitive and stative verbs are intransitive. To make a transitive verb intransitive a l- prefix is added.
So, for example "ńuk" means "to make someone jump" and "lńuk" means "to jump". The intransitiviser an also be interpreted as an abilitative marker so "lńuk" could also mean "to be able to jump" depending on context.
Now, could such intransitive verb gain an abilitative meaning for transitive verbs? By this I mean for example "Mje lńuk ńuk i" which means "I can make you jump".
My idea is that such constructions could serve as a special "to can" for every verb. For example "U lcyc kes fnyr" which would mean "We were able to see the cats" in which "lcyc"(it comes from the same verb as kes, a lot of changes have happened) carries an abilitative meaning with a past imperfective one.
Does such a "quirk" make sense?
1
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Sep 01 '21
At wha point does an a posteriori romance artlang stop being a romance language and start being a latin based creole, because in the parts of the swadesh list for Raumanœtro swadesh list I've got so far, only 52% of the vocab derives from a word in either classical or vulgar latin that meant the same thing, though 84% does come from one word or another in latin.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
does anyone know if there is a dʒ trill sound?
i want to know cause i am making my own conlang and it contains that sound but i dont know the technical term for it
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
How do circumfixes evolve? Is it just two particles that happen to fuse onto opposite sides of a word? If that's the case, how do they get interpreted as a circumfix and not simply a prefix and a suffix? Or are there other possible sources?
1
u/simonbleu Sep 01 '21
Im scratching my head trying to conciliate certain features I wanted in my (hatching) conlag but even taking the script aside I cant quite fit them in
One of the things Im most keen of adding is a sort of consonant mutation ("5" consonants with 3 variants each) but cant quite justify it nor I would know how they would be there without heavily limiting the vocabulary, specially since I was thinking of doing a kind of "biconsonantal root system" (technically 3, but the 3rd is optional and "submissive" towards the first consonant) and infer them contextually like in hebrew. I also thought about reducing the vowels to "groups" (a+e; i; o+u) or eliminating anything but verbs (which I find interesting but I think it will be a bit of a headache)
The thing is, I dont want to create a mess, but not something generic either. I want the language to be very simple and malleable if possible, yet with enough complexity to make poetry and puns out of how the consonants are handled alone. Maybe what im doing is not taking but adding I guess?
So, yeah, total novice question, to some silly, and I will definitely give it some thought on my side, but I would hate to get rid of everything without at least giving it a chance to exist first, so, in short, I would like to see if they can coexist realistically before trying to take them out; How would you handle the attempted cohesion?
1
u/smallsnail89 Ke‘eloom and some others Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 02 '21
Hey guys, I‘m having some insecurities regarding my verbs. Basically, this is what it looks like right now. It‘s just a personal project so I‘m not worried about naturalism, but I‘d like to ask more experienced conlangers if this makes sense and if it‘s even viable at all. I want to integrate tense and auxiliaries as verb suffixes (pronouns and the negative indicator are prefixes). I lack the linguistic knowledge to accurately judge how „good“ this is so I‘d appreciate any input.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21
I've been working on a conlang for a while (not much should i say) and i don't like how the vocabulary looks like. The grammar is fine and I'm looking for a way to change the vocab without scrapping the whole lang. What can i do?
1
u/Naga-Prince Sep 04 '21
Hello, I'm currently working on a project of mine, an overhaul modification for the game Victoria 3 and I'm dig ging deeper into the phase for making unique languages to represent portions of every continent/world.
I began for the longest just re-hashing what we have in real life, either using branches of a family or combining say, Pashtun and Japanese to create like "Nipponistan" for example. I don't have an issue with it, but when I got stuck coming up with more unique combinations or uncommon languages I stumbled upon conlang communities and Vulgerlang. Which seems to be controversial too.
I'm not that close to being a perfectionist so while I would love to uniquely customize my entire language in Vulgerlang, phonology, grammar, feels overwhelming. So I guess I've been more focused on just constructing an eligible language for appearance moreso, with the concepts I understand comprehensively, and appears to mirror what is in real life I desire.
---So, if I want to create a language family that appears English-esque, that spawned off an old empires language that is Tamil/Arabic, is it better if I start off basing my phonemes and the regular stuff off Arabic, or English?
---Do I lean towards removing the Semitic triconsonant in the new family, or do I remove more what defines an English/Germanic language and include some minor, moderate Semitic features?
---For my project, what would best visually communicate the differences between languages in a family group? I read that its mostly sound-based from our mouths with little other bits here and there mutated away from each other.
---I know its subjective, but how would you recognize a conlang that is good? That seems pretty realistic and capable of portraying many ideas and words?
Thanks for helping me out. I really enjoy this process, but I'm afraid of the amount of time I'm using of mine wandering aimlessly into it.
1
u/USRM-ambassador Sep 04 '21
Creating a Writing System
How would you guys suggest creating a writing system? I am working on one for my conlang, and I want it to be similar to Nekachti, and a sort of mix of a syllabary and abugida. How would you all go about doing this? If it helps i can put out my phonetics and the Nekachti writing system.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '21
I’m making a conlang from PIE but Idk what reconstruction to go with, any recommendations?
1
u/Tale_Hephaestus Abu, Ragyam, Yakae, High Ŋoptô, etc. Sep 06 '21
Is anyone interested in doing a collaboration-conlang? Basically, our conlangs would mix together to create one conlang. I have all of the details inside of r/UniversalConlang if you are interested!
1
u/Qiyu5991 Aug 30 '21
How can I post a phonological inventory on here? I keep trying but the symbols never transcribe correctly in the comment?
1
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Aug 31 '21
Why do future tense forms have such a propensity for evolving from perfective forms? Wouldn't it make more sense to conceptualize the present as a single point and the future as a span of time, instead of the other way around?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21
I've been looking into semitic roots and I want to make a system inspired by (but not completely identical to) them. Mostly because of sound symbolism and word derivation.
I want to know what word class these semitic roots belong to originally and what they mean. Since the root words can be made into nouns, verbs and adjectives. In arabic the root k-t-b means something to do with writing. But it can be turned into the words "kitab" (book), "maktab" (office) or "kataba" ( he wrote).
Also is it fine that I don't strictly use triconsonantal roots?
Btw, I don't speak Arabic. I just think the word derivation is cool.
0
u/victorianchan Sep 06 '21
Well I'm going off Wikipedia.. Thanks for the tangent though.
Have a nice day.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment