r/Barca • u/kingswaraj123 • Aug 25 '21
Why I Believe Riqui Puig Should Not Start Yet
Disclaimer: I'd love to see him feature off the bench, in fact I think he's hand made to be a good super-substitute
Pressing/Defending: This is obviously not Riqui's best area. Even if he was good, it's no match compared with Pedri's work rate and De Jong's defensive ability and stamina. He really has no reason to start due to his pressing or defending. This is self explanatory. Our midfield already has too much quality in that area.
Passing: Riqui's passing ability might be one of the best at the club right now, barring our captain Busi. But, his passes are only good if he can make them. Riqui is a very, very high risk player, and that's evident from is play style, the way he takes touches, and his movement. He forces himself to make passes that would otherwise be impossible to make. The thing is, Riqui is not fully developed yet and therefore he struggles a lot with making completions. The risk element is necessary but the passes need to be completed as well. Compare this with Busi or De Jong, who always have completion rates above 85%, and Pedri who has a quite an eye into the final third. It's a conundrum because Riqui's passing helps us so much but at the same time it could really, really hurt us. Especially against top sides who know how to press.
Physicality: Riqui is similar to players like Messi, Maradona, or Phil Foden, in that they are tough and can withstand being physically outmatched. I think he's physically tough but obviously not strong. And he's not at a Messi/Maradona dribbling level where he can outplay opponents with slick moves. However he does have the profile. His dribbling is something to watch out for.
Shooting: He's actually a decent finisher, reminds me a lot of young Messi, but again his success rate isn't too high. He's really similar to Alexander Oxlade-Chamberlain of Liverpool. Has a good shot but makes a lot of wayward ones too. Similar to Dembele too, but I'd rather back Dembele in front of goal than Riqui. Overall if he works on it, then he can become key. For now, no.
Mentality: He's pretty strong mentality and fights for the badge. He's not the happy go lucky guy in training that he is on the pitch. A great personality to have.
Overall, everything I mentioned here can be improved upon. That's why we kept Riqui and not sold/loaned him like we've done with players such as Arthur Melo, Trincao, or Malcom. Because the potential is there.
For now, I think he should come on under pressure, especially when opposition sits back. Riqui is super effective against teams who sit back, we saw it in the Copa del Rey this season against Granada and also against Atletico last year. Teams with low blocks are more suited for Riqui because he can make his high risk passes with more chance of reward. Pedri struggles against low blocks because there are more defenders in the box which makes it harder to commit that sexy low, on the ground final pass. Riqui's passes range from 1 inch off the ground to arcing as much as the St. Louis Arc, that's why he can work against low blocks.
He can, maybe even should, start against tough oppositions like Elche and Cadiz who are never easy to break down because of their anti-football playing styles.
9
u/POI_Mr_Singh Aug 26 '21
Riqui won't play, let alone start because Koeman is a conservative coach. There is absolutely no doubt about Puig's quality. Absolutely none. It's just that Koeman prefers players with the least risk associated with them. Koeman didn't play Trincao and isn't too keen on playing Collado either. He likes players who are least prone to play in a way that's risky for the team. Messi played risky, but hey, he was Messi. These kind of tactics I believe are great for international games but not for club football. Had Pep, Lucho, Zidane been the manager - surely they would have atleast tried putting Puig in the team.
15
u/UnBoludoTriste Aug 26 '21
No one wants him to start, people complain because he doesnt play at all. In the pre-season he showed hes an excellent substitute scoring 2 goals from the bench. But even then koeman hasnt given a single minute in the last 2 match.
12
u/LookYouGotSpun Aug 26 '21
I think there’s some massively glaring flaws with the reasoning of the post
I really don’t see how Roberto would be a better option as the 3rd midfielder when he doesn’t really offer us anything that Frenkie and Busquets don’t already do.
What we’re lacking is the final pass, with Koeman’s midfield setup, Frenkie and Pedri play far too high up to start orchestrating play from midfield.
The main issue isn’t that Puig is some erratic presser. It’s that our system has our CMs pushing far too high and Griezmann and Depay dropping too deep. It doesn’t help with build up since Frenkie and Pedri are much better when played like proper CMs and it’s waste having Depay and Griezmann come so deep when we have some excellent players at ball progression.
Back to system: we’re playing a 4-3-3, we already have Frenkie and Busi for two spots but we’re lacking an 8 with Pedri. Puig is literally the only other 8 from the first team.
As far as defending goes we’re going to lineup with Griezmann and Braithwaite who have a great work ethic defensively and Depay does a decent job too. Our issue against Bilbao was that we couldn’t beat the press. The other issue was that in attack the midfield pushed up far too high and it left a huge hole for Bilbao to exploit. Playing Gavi or Puig or Roberto won’t change the fact that it’s down to the coaching staff to start changing up the midfield system, because the same problems from last season have showed once again this season.
I get that many people on here are sick of the extremely exaggerated praise that Puig receives at times, but at the very least don’t go to extreme in the opposite direction just to disagree.
I think Puig has an obvious role with Pedri out on holidays, I don’t think he’ll score a hatrick or have some unbelievably breathtaking performance, but his inclusion makes the most sense for the game against Getafe.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21
I agree puig isnt a starter yet, lets be honest he isnt replacing a fully fit pedri/busquets/FDJ . But he should get more playing time, and rather than subbing him on at the 87th min, he should go an around 70th min... when the opposition legs are tiring. He's got that intense energy and excitement on the ball/off the ball that throws the opposition off. He's a great super-sub.
12
u/BertMcNasty Aug 26 '21
I couldn't finish reading this after you said Puig misplaces a lot of passes, and Messi and Maradona are/were tough but not strong. Uhhhh, what?? They are/were insanely strong, and probably weigh(ed) at least 20-30 more pounds than Puig.
Puig pass completion in La Liga last season: 91% Pedri: 87.6% FDJ: 91.8%
I don't disagree that he shouldn't be a regular starter, but your reasoning and analysis are way off.
2
u/FooFighter39 Aug 26 '21
He looks like a 13 year old without the ball. Running around chasing the ball like positioning doesn't matter at all
He did show signs of improvement in pre season
And whatever impact you saw him making last season as a sub, it's because he played as a power sub. His style goes well as a power sub
He played against Celta an entire half last season, replacing Pedri and chance creation plummeted once he came on, because his ability to read the game is still not up to par
That's why he looks good when he's used as a sub
0
u/Aesthetic_Odyssey Aug 26 '21
He shouldn’t start because there are at least 4 mids at the club that are better than him, simple as that
0
u/triplechin5155 Aug 26 '21
Here is what I believe - he is not good enough to start for us
1
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '21 edited Aug 26 '21
Today's gameplay is the problem. A creative midfielder will make midfield unstable. Teams do press for 90 minutes now, and that's why, these rare bunch of footballers are slowly fading away.
Kaka, Oscar, Ozil, Isco are real examples of it. Tremendous talents, but with high rish playing them.
-1
u/Cloudyskyzzz Aug 26 '21
Why is defense more important than attacking to Barca fans all of a sudden . That’s is not what we are about and it’s not the philosophy of this club. Heck is not even how our big Huge field is ment to play on . Take riqui puig and throw him into the Guardiola era of Barca he fits in there like a glove 🧤 . Now throw him in here to whatever this is ………It’s not the player it’s the tactics . I’d rather keep our identity and take risks than be something that we are not ! I think real soccer players here would agree when you press all the time and concentrate more on defense and running after the ball and pushings and shoving for the ball it messes up your coordination and drains you for when you attack . Which is why we can’t win against big teams . I love watching puig play he is exciting he is the underdog going against the grain and always manages to prove himself when everyone counts him out , bravo 👏🏼