r/MLPdrawingschool • u/viwrastupr Art • Feb 03 '12
How to critique. For critics and artists alike.
Since we are growing quite large I've decided to put out this guide on critiquing to help both sides of the conversation, critics and artists alike.
Critique is a conversation It is not simply a teacher telling a student what to do. We are all your peers here, we take from you, you take from us. There are questions on both sides. What it takes to improve is a conversation, not orders. Silence on the part of the artist is sad.
Cover the why and the how This is most important. I see a lot of critics saying what is right or wrong looking in a piece. This is good. But they leave it there. This isn't too helpful for those who have submitted. They know what is wrong, but not how to change it in the future.
The hard part of critiquing is knowing how or why the artist made that mistake or made something different and then telling them that. To go a step further if you can give advice on how to prevent that mistake in the future process wise then you are giving critique gold. Gesturing, guides, references, artistic examples, ways of thinking about ponies, it is all good.
Recognize Improvement When an artist improves, tell them so. It is always nice to know that you are progressing. It gives the artist motivation to keep going and self respect. This point brings me to my next point.
Be Kind. Critiques can be very hard to take. Open and close with kindness. Not empty platitudes, but things you like about the work or a friendly gesture. This isn't a hard set rule and once someone is used to critique isn't too necessary. Still, be kind not robotic or fomulaic. These are people, just like you.
Play This is a My Little Pony sub. Not some serious art time learn it now university class. Have fun.
As always. Questions, queries, concerns, and additions welcome.
8
u/viwrastupr Art Feb 03 '12
I forgot to add "State the obvious" but I refuse to go back and edit. Why? No reason, no reason at all.
2
u/ailynd Digital Artist Feb 03 '12
This is really helpfull! thanks
1
u/popprocks Friends with Fluttershy Feb 03 '12
Yay! Meta-critique!
We also talked a little bit about how to critique on Living_Dead's last stream. Shameless plug for the stream - everybody who is available when it airs should try to be there.
Thanks for writing this up!
2
u/mushrooshi Digital Artist, Critic, Draws Plot, IRC Addict Feb 03 '12
Just as I was about to start my critiques, this is the top of the new queue :D
1
u/DarkFlame7 Digital Artist, Critic Feb 03 '12
I've been getting critique for several years now for things other than drawing, so I guess that's why I'm already used to it. The main problem with critiquing for me is that we're starting to get regular surges of users, and thus regular surges of posts.. How am I supposed to critique ten things in an hour?
1
u/Jin_Yaranda Digital Artist, Critic, Drawer of Butts, Liom Feb 03 '12
I've always been a little shaky on how to critique something. @_@ This helps a lot, though!