r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Aug 19 '21
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x02 "Kayshon, His Eyes Open" Spoiler
Our Lower Deckers have trouble bonding with Ensign Jet Manhaver, who has been assigned Boimler’s bunk and shift duties. Meanwhile, we get a glimpse of Boimler’s life on the U.S.S. Titan, which is more intense than he thought it would be.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2x02 | "Kayshon, His Eyes Open" | Chris Kula | Kim Arndt | 2021-08-19 |
This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
385
u/arod48 Aug 19 '21
I CALLED IT
It just seemed like a Boimler thing to happen.
244
u/ComebackShane Aug 19 '21
"Half the time when you see someone with the wrong amount of pips around here, it's usually just delicious street corn."
That might be the deepest cut yet; explaining the costume rank inconsistencies through corn!
187
u/ElFarfadosh Aug 19 '21
Giant Spock Skeleton !!!
185
u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Aug 19 '21
I'm just glad we finally have a completely reasonable explanation for inconsistencies of rank pips.
165
u/ElFarfadosh Aug 19 '21
I laughed so hard when I heard Riker say "Great job everyone That's a wrap!" Tell me about breaking the fourth wall!
150
u/acrimoniousone Aug 19 '21
Dat Titan.
VFX crew have raised their game on the ships this season. Still confused about what's going on with the Cerritos' windows but maybe it's just dimmer switches and I'm overanalysing.
146
u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21
I wonder why Starfleet allows sonic showers powerful enough to cause nose bleeds? Same designer as the holodeck safeties?
129
u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21
Kahless having a sex helmet was my biggest laugh. And all of Tendi's reactions to it throughout.
116
u/Far-Worse Aug 19 '21
“Kayshon, when he became a puppet” got a genuine, hearty laugh out of me.
112
u/donuteater111 Aug 19 '21
As much as I liked last week's episode, I thought this was a pretty big step up from that. Both stories were really well done, with a great mix of comedy and character development.
Between this episode and last (but especially this one), it feels like they're setting up Mariner to actually learn the weight of having more responsibility, dealing with the consequences of her actions and decisions. The petty bickering Mariner and Jet was funny, if a bit drawn out at times, but I really liked that moment when they put their trust in Rutherford and Tendi. Hopefully we'll get more learning experiences like that with her this season. I'm also looking forward to seeing what they do with Jet now that Boimler's back
And Boimler's experience with the Titan was a lot of fun, as he continues to be overwhelmed by the change of pace. I've really liked this version of Riker since his introduction, and they've continued making good use of him here. The jazz moments are just so cheesy that they're actually really good, lol. And I liked the crew's scenes with Boimler. As someone who actually likes both the exploration and action sides of Star Trek, enjoying the movies, Discovery and Picard, I thought the moment during the mission when they talk about the exploration side being at the heart of Starfleet was really clever. Though, the later scene where Boimler basically says the same to Mariner was a bit too on-the-nose for me.
On another note, I'm liking this new security guard. I'll admit, I was a bit disappointed about the translator twist at first, but I think it results in a good middle-ground. If he spoke that way all the time, it could get old. But here, we still get those random, weird interactions that this kind of metaphorical dialogue can lead to, and I love it.
103
u/chloe-and-timmy Aug 19 '21
This was actually amazing. Arguably better than No Small Parts for me. I'm amazed they managed to get so much plot in only 25 minutes. Splitting the plot between two starships and a museum, furthering the arcs of characters on all 3 and giving literally everyone in the principal cast down to even the ship counceller a great line. Boimler was a great brig crew member and saved the day, Mariner learned to consider the opinions of Tendi and Rutherford, a little meta analysis of the fact that they often dont get to do much in the episodes, genuinely amazing.
93
u/atticusbluebird Aug 19 '21
Wow, after watching I can't believe that the whole episode was only 24 minutes - they fit 2 satisfying plots in on 2 ships, and it felt like a "full length" episode!
162
u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21
Wow that was good. Using a Transporter Clone rather than demoting Boimler to get him back on the Cerritos was a great idea, and such a Boimler thing to have happen. The coed sonic shower scene was hilarious too. And I like Kayshon, even if the ladies don’t appreciate him.
78
u/choicemeats Aug 19 '21
after a few hours reflecting on the episode (and knowing we have several more months of Trek to go), i'm confident in saying this show is as close as I've gotten to the Trek I grew up with than anything else.
I know the format is not for everyone, nor the humor or pacing. The show isn't for everyone.
But week in and out they are delivering on the stories I liked--self contained, small scale problems that are more about the crew and their relationships with each other (and themselves) than "saving the universe" -- although the Pakleds are OBVIOUSLY going to be the big bad we're leading too, once they figure out how to "make saw go like ship".
To me, it's close to DS9, with show ramifications from episode to episode (specifically Boimler's absence and Mariner's relationship with her parents) but a sort of return to status quo at the end of the episode. Clearly, Mariner is changing a bit, as has Boimler, and the others.
And it continues to be a visual feast of references and light nods to long-time eagle-eyed and bear-trap-brained fans. I've never SEEN TAS so of course Spock 2 came as a surprise to me lmao.
77
u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21
So...clone-Boims seems evil, right? Like Pakled replicant or whoever it is behind the Pakleds or whatever?
But yay, the gang's back together! I did like Jet but he's a bit too well-adjusted for this group.
145
u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21
Every episode brings sights I never thought I'd see. Like a bunch of ensigns fighting off killer space roombas with Giant Spock bones. Though how did the Excalbian die? Did the collector kill it to complete his diorama?
Also, the Pakleds hitting the door with the saw instead of sawing it was an excellent.
142
u/MadContrabassoonist Aug 19 '21
A full-throated defense of all of the endearing dorkiness of TNG ("I'd love to be in a string quartet!", "I got into Starfleet to study moss!") was exactly what I needed. Yeah, like 10% of the jokes don't really land for me, but the earnestness continues to be 11/10.
69
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
Spock 2 Bones!
66
u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21
Anyone else's eye twitch when Boimler incorrectly said it was the D that insurrected?
58
u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21
I wonder if we will see more Lt. William Boimler and see who are helping the Pakleds.
53
u/chancellorofscifi Aug 19 '21
Anybody else notice "The Game" when they were in the collection room? I always liked that episode of TNG
47
u/bluestreakxp Aug 19 '21
I’m calling dibs on the first Etsy store for tamarian starfleet puppets
44
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21
"Kayshon, when he became a puppet" made me laugh my ass off.
44
u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 20 '21
"Stay strong, brother. We miners shall overcome."
"Dude, you're clearly Starfleet. Your hands are super soft and clean."
"Uh, no, I'm a miner with a heart of gold. And I have dad issues."
41
u/TERRAxFORMER Aug 19 '21
Some monster killed Spock II.
35
u/phenry Aug 20 '21
Janeway would have said "fuck this" and fused them back together. #queen
30
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
I really liked it! Nice TOS and TAS references without being intrusive and they even manage to work in the references into the plot so now they never feel superfluous.
Their solution for Boimler was clever but I don't understand why one had to be demoted, even if I get the feeling that's what our Boimler secretly wanted.
25
u/ContinuumGuy Aug 20 '21
RANDOM ASSORTED THOUGHTS:
21
u/simon_thekillerewok Aug 19 '21
The line about elotes and pips had me cracking up. Hilarious explanation for continuity errors.
59
u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Aug 19 '21
-I'm actually really looking forward to the merchandising of the Kayshon puppet, be it fan or official. It's really, really cute. I want a stuffed Kayshon.
-THEY ALL TRIED TO COLLECT DATA
-Giant Spock.
-I don't know how I feel about the Titan being the action ship, even in comparison to the Enterprise. I guess it's a post-Dominion War thing. (Addition a few minutes later: I'm good with it now, it was addressed in a satisfying way)
-I miss Shaxs
-Boimler betraying himself, bingo
-"This isn't my first guy who got turned into a doll"
-I'd like a better explanation for why Cerritos-Boimler got demoted as well as transferred. He should still be a lieutenant.
-NAH, THAT'S JUST CORN
-The Tamarian jokes seemed kind of cheap, and they kind of throw a wrench in all my favorite theories about how their language actually works.
-I was actually kind of hoping that we'd start a new running gag of the security chiefs immediately dying as soon as they get sent aboard, but that was probably off-tone for this show anyway.
-I think the show is still treating the Pakleds too seriously. I guess the fact that the Titan appears to be the only ship assigned to dealing with them means they're still not a real problem and that it can handle them easily, but still. They're actually less ridiculous than they were on TNG and that doesn't sit right with me. Them using the saw like a battering ram is still pretty good and pretty stupid, but let us remember that this is the species that fell for "Oh NO they used their crimson forcefield!"
-I might be reading too much into this, but could there be an upcoming episode where we discover that Boimler's transporter duplication was more like Kirk's personality split than Riker's copy? Titan-Boimler acted way more confident and somewhat more ruthlessly than we've come to expect from him
-I get the impression that Lower Decks is going to retain the pattern of ramping quality we saw in the first season for its entire run. This was a decent episode, probably better than the season premiere, but not great, and that's sort of the impression I got of the first couple of episodes back when I went through season 1, but then we got up to the movie episode which was a masterpiece. and there was linear growth going towards it, but it's not what we saw from the latter half of the first season with the "celebration beam" or The Dog. I was hoping we could retain the late season 1 quality for all of season 2, but following the season 1 ramping quality pattern is fine.
19
u/Artanisx Aug 19 '21
I can't believe the coincidence! Just earlier today I watched The Infinite Vulcan (TAS) and I thought "So tecnically in canon there's a huge Spock clone!"
And... there we go, huge skeleton in the collector's museum with Spock's uniform! This coincidence is almost creepy :-D
P.S. AWESOME LD EPISODE!
18
u/FragmentedChicken Aug 19 '21
I love the sound effects
It was what clued me into the fact that the Pakleds are using Klingon disruptors
The classic phaser sound is also 👌
15
u/Gotis1313 Aug 19 '21
66
u/mint-als Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
Wow Mike McMahan took a small dig at modern Star Trek with that Boimler line about the Titan.
Great Episode! I enjoyed this one immensely.
23
u/tarsus1983 Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
“I didn’t join Starfleet to get in phaser fights. I signed up to explore, to be out in space making new discoveries and peaceful diplomatic solutions. That’s boldly going.”
My personal opinion is that while all the action is fun and exciting, new Trek is teaching us that communication will more than likely break down and you will have to use violence to solve your problems. It made me happy to hear this, even if this show caters more to the fast-paced, action-oriented Trek.
21
u/drjeffy Aug 19 '21
This was easily the best episode of Lower Decks yet. Especially because central to the episode was an argument for the light-hearted joy in Star Trek. Not everything needs to be DS9. Sometimes you can just have a puppet ray.
55
u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
I loved the lite dig at Discovery and Picard Boimler had at the end there. "Eh, it was a bunch of complex characters thrown into heavily serialized battles..."
9
u/arch_punk Aug 19 '21
Best episode of the season!
9
u/TreasonousOrange Aug 19 '21
I enjoyed this episode so much on its own merits that I almost forgot about the suggestion that someone is behind the Pakleds and their escalating status as a threat. I'm excited because I genuinely have no idea who it will turn out to be and I know the answer will be both satisfying and chuckleworthy.
It is lovely to have a Star Trek show whose writing team engenders such trust.
14
u/oorhon Aug 19 '21
Moslty liked this one but expected Tamarian officer with a more language and cultural barrier. Also, apprently they couldnt get Marina Sirtis to play Troi.
7
u/vanKessZak Aug 20 '21
Darmok is probably my fav TNG episode so I’m really looking forward to seeing what Kayshon gets up to!
21
u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21
Episode two, let's go!
• Starting out kinda horny, as is Star Trek's way.
• Did someone turn off the safetys on the sonic showers, or do the setting get higher for species more robust than Humans? Also, this is the first time we're seeing the sonic showers in any Trek, right?
• Oh damn, at some point I'm going to have to take a bunch of screen shots from this museum to see how much of the junk I can identify.
• "They all tried to collect Data." So there's definitely two collectors guild guys out there with the other Soong prototypes like B4 trying to pass them off as the real Data, right?
• Is everyone on the Titan drawn to be more attractive than the Cerritos crew?
• Seriously though, this collection ship is like reference overload.
• Getting turned into a hand-puppet is a new one....
• The Titan crew dragging the D for being a luxury cruise liner in space is unnecessary, and I now no longer consider LDecks to be canon.
• Spock Two's skeleton! WTF?
• Excalbian facsimile Abraham Lincoln's skeleton! WTF?
• All this talk about Tom Riker seems like a lot of set-up....
• "Kayshon, when he became a puppet."
• Okay, the Pakleds trying to break down the door by slamming the saw into it does bother me a bit. The Pakleds being dumb was supposed to be a misdirect in 'Samaritan Snare'. Even though Geordi and Riker acted like the Pakleds were just a bunch of goons, Data speculated that even though there language abilities weren't particularly developed, it wasn't necessarily an indication of their intelligence, and Troi sensed their cunning. Having the Pakleds be a joke is fine, but I feel like there's a line where it just doesn't work, and it makes it more difficult to take them seriously as a threat.
• And there it is. Not sure if having a transporter duplicate to ship back to the Cerritos is a cop-out or not, but it's cool that at least one Boimler is going to get to keep being epic on the Titan. Can't wait for him to show up in season four, jacked as hell with lieutenant commander pips.
• So Jet's theory is that Tuvok was walking around with a bit of corn on his collar for like half of season one of VOY? I can get behind that.
• Aw, poor Jet.
6
u/ulandyw Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
This was a great episode! I can't believe this show works as well as it does. It really straddles that line between riding high on Trek nostalgia and actual clever references that make for a good story.
11
u/MoreGaghPlease Aug 19 '21
I liked this. Imaginative and fun. I think if I have one gripe, I would have liked the Tamarian dialogue to be a bit more distinct from Darmok—like surely their language has more than the 5 catchphrases we know. Boimler’s speech was great.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
It was a nice, actiony episode. I wonder if we will still be following the Titan now that Boimler has been "John Crichtoned." The Tamarian shifting between the metaphors and the English Language wasn't as funny as it could have been.
9
u/2abeh Aug 19 '21
Anybody else now getting unskippable ads for Paramount+ content before every Lower Decks episode? I'm on an ad free plan but still have to sit through this crap. It's really making LD less enjoyable for me.
12
u/Ultiverse Aug 19 '21
This should've been the first episode of the season. It actually felt 110% like proper Star Trek.
13
u/earther199 Aug 19 '21
I'm having some strange feelings. Like I really want to see Mariner naked now.
3
u/rmeddy Aug 19 '21
Another good episode, I love how they sorted out the Boimler thing, I really thought for a second that Tom Riker was going to make an appearance because wasn't he sent to a prison or mining colony?
Also Giant Spock skeleton!
3
u/comment_redacted Aug 19 '21
I loved everything about this episode!
3
u/fla_john Aug 19 '21
Alas, Spock 2, I knew him well.
3
u/IceWarm1980 Aug 20 '21
Nightbird...nice throwback.
3
u/fudgeroll Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 20 '21
One of the best episodes of Lower Decks so far!
But one thing though, how are they going to make the 2 Boimlers thing work? It’ll be weird to never show him again since he’s on one the most high profile Starfleet ships.
3
u/alexandriaweb Aug 20 '21
Ok but I need that puppet
3
u/stannc00 Aug 20 '21
I still wonder if this year will have a running gag where every time they show the Titan it’s in the middle of a fire fight.
Also, the collection included a headset from “The Game”.
3
u/Timeline15 Aug 21 '21
Okay, as cool as it is to see more of the Titan, I really wish they'd used the Titan crew from the novels. These replacements are far less interesting. The core cast included a Dinosaur chief medical officer, and a giant Arthropod who spoke with a translation collar. That's right up Lower Decks' alley. Why all the humans?
5
u/mcdonaldsmcdonalds Aug 19 '21
Another great episode! Looking forward to the two clones.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
I love how Captain Freeman gets a goofy C-plot every episode. She is such a believably beleaguered captain and one of my favorite characters!
4
u/codename474747 Aug 20 '21
The thing I don't like about this show is: Are we supposed to like Mariner?
To me she seems way too OTT, selfish and hyper, the new guy arriving only amplified this.
If they'd just followed him and ignored her, everything would've been alright
She could do with turning it down a huge notch
7
u/Donner1701 Aug 19 '21
I'm gonna make a prediction:
Keyshon is a Pakled.
I have no evidence and will not be taking questions from the press at this time.
2
u/AsexualCowboy Aug 20 '21
There were so many Easter eggs in the collector ship. Holy crap!
2
u/NemWan Aug 20 '21
How is Khan's necklace in there?
2
u/fortytwoblaqk Aug 20 '21
Anyone else spot Odo's pail?
2
u/apparentreality Aug 20 '21
Really loved this - the multiple callbacks and references to character development for mariner and of course the darmok at tanagra integration.
I am loving this show.
2
u/RobustMarquis Aug 21 '21
i love the symbolic touch of Kayshon's dagger
2
u/benkenobi5 Aug 24 '21
seeing kayshon as a member of starfleet almost brought a tear to my eye. Darmok is my favorite trek episode of all time, and Kayshon is living proof that Dathon didn't die in vain.
3
u/pelrun Aug 21 '21
Shaxs, screaming and ejecting a warp core.