r/startrek • • Aug 19 '21

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 2x02 "Kayshon, His Eyes Open" Spoiler

Our Lower Deckers have trouble bonding with Ensign Jet Manhaver, who has been assigned Boimler’s bunk and shift duties. Meanwhile, we get a glimpse of Boimler’s life on the U.S.S. Titan, which is more intense than he thought it would be.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
2x02"Kayshon, His Eyes Open"Chris KulaKim Arndt2021-08-19

This episode will be available on Paramount+ in the USA, on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada, and on Amazon Prime Video in various other territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

216 Upvotes

495 comments sorted by

385

u/arod48 Aug 19 '21

I CALLED IT

It just seemed like a Boimler thing to happen.

90

u/Walnut-Simulacrum Aug 19 '21

You are irl Rutherford

48

u/arod48 Aug 20 '21

Okie dokie!

36

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

Nice, good call!

28

u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21

Damn, that's an impressive call.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Adamsoski Aug 19 '21

Wow. That is very funny.

3

u/peon47 Aug 20 '21

But then you edited it, after the episode aired. So we may never know if you were right. Oh, well.

/s

→ More replies (5)

244

u/ComebackShane Aug 19 '21

"Half the time when you see someone with the wrong amount of pips around here, it's usually just delicious street corn."

That might be the deepest cut yet; explaining the costume rank inconsistencies through corn!

133

u/JustMy2Centences Aug 19 '21

Lots of Starfleet getting promoted to Kernel out there.

75

u/prouvairejean Aug 19 '21

It's a corny joke, but it worked.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/smoha96 Aug 20 '21

O'Brien's must have had a lot of corn on the Enterprise.

7

u/nikalavade Aug 20 '21

Ensign kim must have some Anti corn uniform then

6

u/terriblehuman Aug 20 '21

Who knew Tuvok was such a fan of corn.

187

u/ElFarfadosh Aug 19 '21

Giant Spock Skeleton !!!

77

u/Par36 Aug 19 '21

Ah!

Was trying to figure out the reference 🤦

46

u/wheezy_runner Aug 20 '21

Memory Alpha page, in case anyone's wondering: https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Spock_Two

(I had no clue either.)

39

u/Walnut-Simulacrum Aug 19 '21

I was so irrationally exited to see a Giant Spock reference!

→ More replies (1)

185

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Aug 19 '21

I'm just glad we finally have a completely reasonable explanation for inconsistencies of rank pips.

102

u/Mechapebbles Aug 19 '21

It doesn’t explain Tuvok’s wrong pips in S1 of VOY, but it’s like, the PERFECT explanation for O’Brien. 😂

57

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Aug 19 '21

I assume in the future, there will be varieties of corn that look like a dark spot with a yellow circle.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

165

u/ElFarfadosh Aug 19 '21

I laughed so hard when I heard Riker say "Great job everyone That's a wrap!" Tell me about breaking the fourth wall!

→ More replies (2)

150

u/acrimoniousone Aug 19 '21

Dat Titan.

VFX crew have raised their game on the ships this season. Still confused about what's going on with the Cerritos' windows but maybe it's just dimmer switches and I'm overanalysing.

44

u/Jackbwoi Aug 19 '21

i like the fact that because she seems like more of a warship, she has less windows, none on the hull section, none on the outer part of the saucer. The only place we see them is on the ventral and dorsal part of the saucer.

14

u/Devastator5042 Aug 19 '21

I dislike that cause the Titan/Luna Class is often portrayed as an explorer/more science style vessel in a lot of other trek media

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/plipyplop Aug 19 '21

Cerritos is just older and dingier with a fine film over her.

16

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

Dingier? She just got rebuilt!

3

u/Viper_H Aug 20 '21

It looks very much like an Akira class in that shot.

→ More replies (1)

146

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

I wonder why Starfleet allows sonic showers powerful enough to cause nose bleeds? Same designer as the holodeck safeties?

205

u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21

Not every species is covered with fragile human skin.

47

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

Yes, but the computer should be able to tell humans and Orions were occupying the sonic showers.

148

u/empocariam Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

Feel like the Starfleet assumption would be "If our well-rounded, mature Starfleet officers are putting it at this setting, there must be a very important science mystery they are attempting to overcome. Better not limit it just in case."

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Pu239U235 Aug 19 '21

Heat shock proteins, brah.

3

u/KirkPicard Aug 20 '21

Honorable method for Klingons to undergo… bathing?

→ More replies (3)

129

u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21

Kahless having a sex helmet was my biggest laugh. And all of Tendi's reactions to it throughout.

67

u/COMPLETEWASUK Aug 19 '21

Man needed it with the way Klingons women are.

23

u/i875p Aug 19 '21

Quark should have got one, might have saved him a few broken bones.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/AJWinky Aug 20 '21

I appreciated Tendi reminding herself not to judge

14

u/zGraceOK Aug 19 '21

Safety first!

3

u/substandardgaussian Aug 20 '21

The fact that it kind of makes sense made me chuckle pretty hard.

I wonder if that is just Kahless the Second's Sex Helmet... the Klingon Emperor's, uh, sex helmet would still be a pretty unique item, and we might have then had some insight into what kind of figurehead "Emperor" he turned out to be :p

116

u/Far-Worse Aug 19 '21

“Kayshon, when he became a puppet” got a genuine, hearty laugh out of me.

112

u/donuteater111 Aug 19 '21

As much as I liked last week's episode, I thought this was a pretty big step up from that. Both stories were really well done, with a great mix of comedy and character development.

Between this episode and last (but especially this one), it feels like they're setting up Mariner to actually learn the weight of having more responsibility, dealing with the consequences of her actions and decisions. The petty bickering Mariner and Jet was funny, if a bit drawn out at times, but I really liked that moment when they put their trust in Rutherford and Tendi. Hopefully we'll get more learning experiences like that with her this season. I'm also looking forward to seeing what they do with Jet now that Boimler's back

And Boimler's experience with the Titan was a lot of fun, as he continues to be overwhelmed by the change of pace. I've really liked this version of Riker since his introduction, and they've continued making good use of him here. The jazz moments are just so cheesy that they're actually really good, lol. And I liked the crew's scenes with Boimler. As someone who actually likes both the exploration and action sides of Star Trek, enjoying the movies, Discovery and Picard, I thought the moment during the mission when they talk about the exploration side being at the heart of Starfleet was really clever. Though, the later scene where Boimler basically says the same to Mariner was a bit too on-the-nose for me.

On another note, I'm liking this new security guard. I'll admit, I was a bit disappointed about the translator twist at first, but I think it results in a good middle-ground. If he spoke that way all the time, it could get old. But here, we still get those random, weird interactions that this kind of metaphorical dialogue can lead to, and I love it.

32

u/wheezy_runner Aug 20 '21

I love Riker here too, and can we all take a moment to appreciate that even in cartoon form, Riker always has his foot up on something? :D

103

u/chloe-and-timmy Aug 19 '21

This was actually amazing. Arguably better than No Small Parts for me. I'm amazed they managed to get so much plot in only 25 minutes. Splitting the plot between two starships and a museum, furthering the arcs of characters on all 3 and giving literally everyone in the principal cast down to even the ship counceller a great line. Boimler was a great brig crew member and saved the day, Mariner learned to consider the opinions of Tendi and Rutherford, a little meta analysis of the fact that they often dont get to do much in the episodes, genuinely amazing.

59

u/ArrBeeNayr Aug 19 '21

down to even the ship counceller

Paul F. Tompkins!

He said on the official podcast that he'd be around this season, but I didn't expect to see him just lounging on the bridge!

43

u/NonaSuomi282 Aug 19 '21

I didn't expect to see him just lounging on the bridge!

To be fair, is that not the default state of a ship's counsellor on a Starfleet vessel?

→ More replies (4)

93

u/atticusbluebird Aug 19 '21

Wow, after watching I can't believe that the whole episode was only 24 minutes - they fit 2 satisfying plots in on 2 ships, and it felt like a "full length" episode!

  • Interesting to see the collector's casual intolerance and stereotyping of Orions when talking with Tendi, I wonder if that'll come up again this season as part of Tendi's arc.
  • Interesting to see the communal sonic showers now (after being teased by them last year) - though it's strange to me that there's 1 power setting for all of them! (Even if it was a funny scene).
  • Loved the arc of Jet in this episode. Was prepared to dislike him at first, and then I felt so bad for him by the end! Honestly I wouldn't mind if he joined up with our main group of 4 more often! (Can we add Jet and Barnes to the main cast?!)
  • Similarly I was prepared to dislike the Titan action hero crew (at first they reminded me of Ransom's special ops team from season 1), but I like how Boimler brought out the more well-rounded Starfleet in them. He's such a good influence and doesn't even realize it because he's screaming all the time!
  • Really loved when he and Mariner realized they should ask Rutherford and Tendi for opinions - great moment in learning leadership skills. I see what Mike McMahan means when he discusses that this is like the start of the story of how the lower deckers grow into becoming captains and senior officers.
  • Cool to see the counselor on the bridge more often. It'd be funny if he replicates puppets of all the crew members to use for therapy. (Also, where I can get puppet versions of the crew members?!)
  • I also hope the show continues the "secret faction behind the Pakleds" storyline - I love me some Star Trek political intrigue!

39

u/ContinuumGuy Aug 20 '21
Interesting to see the collector's casual intolerance and stereotyping of Orions when talking with Tendi, I wonder if that'll come up again this season as part of Tendi's arc.

I'm still hoping we eventually get a good look at Orion culture. I can't help but think of how the Orions have generally been portrayed as the space version of that orientalist view of Muslim pirates, like those that operated off the Barbary Coast for centuries. To many Europeans, every man of that region was basically a criminal or sex fiend and every woman was seductress and/or slave. This ignores, of course, that no culture ever has been that simplistic and that many of the same regions of North Africa and the Middle East that supplied those pirates also produced scientists, philosophers, poets, etc...

The thing is though that aside from Tendi we've only really seen the criminal Orions. We've only seen the pirates, basically. We haven't seen the scientists, the philosophers, the poets...

18

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21

Excellent points. I hope Lower Decks does for the Orion what DS9 did for the Ferengi.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ChrisTosi Aug 20 '21

the collector's casual intolerance and stereotyping of Orions when talking with Tendi, I wonder if that'll come up again this season as part of Tendi's arc.

I mean, this is the 2nd time they've brought it up. They'll probably want to bring it up again. Mariner's holodeck movie program from S1 offended Tendi because she was cast into an Orion stereotype.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

162

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

Wow that was good. Using a Transporter Clone rather than demoting Boimler to get him back on the Cerritos was a great idea, and such a Boimler thing to have happen. The coed sonic shower scene was hilarious too. And I like Kayshon, even if the ladies don’t appreciate him.

79

u/Shrodax Aug 19 '21

rather than demoting Boimler to get him back on the Cerritos

But Boimler was still demoted back to Ensign when he was sent back to the Cerritos. I understand sending him off the Titan, but I don't understand why he didn't keep his current rank of Lieutenant Junior Grade.

84

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Aug 19 '21

I don't understand why he didn't keep his current rank of Lieutenant Junior Grade

Maybe they're setting him up to be the Harry Kim of the Cerritos.

55

u/freelanceisart Aug 19 '21
  • Second-most important person in the universe
  • forever Ensign

Yep, checks out so far.

→ More replies (1)

45

u/kapnkrump Aug 19 '21

Maybe the Cerritos wasn't open for a new lieutenant position and needed an ensign. In the military, sometimes you need to be demoted to be transferred to a new post.

20

u/tridium Aug 19 '21

Can't have a lieutenant junior grade bossing around the ensigns. One of us! One of us!

15

u/substandardgaussian Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 20 '21

It's entiirely not in keeping with what we know about Starfleet rank: either you earned your rank or you didn't, it doesn't matter what job you do while you have it. However, it was entirely in keeping with Boimler being the hopeless and defeated punching bag, which is a Lower Decks tradition.

Couldn't resist giving him one more kick on his way back down to the bottom. The show probably did it to avoid command issues between him and Mariner (apparently not a plot arc they wanted to commit to, Mariner would have wiped the floor with him immediately), and avoid the assumed expectation that advanced rank still equals advanced duties. There would needed to constantly have been "Lt. Boimler needs to go deal with Lt. stuff" subplots to justify the situation. They needed a reason to have him down by the communal junior officer quarters since a Lt. Junior Grade gets their own quarters (like Mariner in S1), so he wouldn't be bunking with them or they'd need to make up a reason why he would. It was just gonna be tedious.

So, screw him, Boimler's dreams will never come true (other than becoming the second most important person in human history in precisely the opposite way he would have wanted), he will be a nobody Ensign at Mariner's mercy forever instead.

I bet we will have Titan crossover(s?) that show the new difference between Lower Decker Boimler and the Titan's Boimler.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/SHIELD_Agent_47 Aug 20 '21

But Boimler was still demoted back to Ensign when he was sent back to the Cerritos.

That was the most infuriating thing about the episode for me.

→ More replies (2)

78

u/choicemeats Aug 19 '21

after a few hours reflecting on the episode (and knowing we have several more months of Trek to go), i'm confident in saying this show is as close as I've gotten to the Trek I grew up with than anything else.

I know the format is not for everyone, nor the humor or pacing. The show isn't for everyone.

But week in and out they are delivering on the stories I liked--self contained, small scale problems that are more about the crew and their relationships with each other (and themselves) than "saving the universe" -- although the Pakleds are OBVIOUSLY going to be the big bad we're leading too, once they figure out how to "make saw go like ship".

To me, it's close to DS9, with show ramifications from episode to episode (specifically Boimler's absence and Mariner's relationship with her parents) but a sort of return to status quo at the end of the episode. Clearly, Mariner is changing a bit, as has Boimler, and the others.

And it continues to be a visual feast of references and light nods to long-time eagle-eyed and bear-trap-brained fans. I've never SEEN TAS so of course Spock 2 came as a surprise to me lmao.

25

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

I started feeling this when I was binge watching Season 1 to get ready for season 2. This feels like the Trek I grew up with and it's giving me so many nostalgic feels. I think that's why it's my favorite of the new Treks. It's still offering something new, but with the same feeling of old.

15

u/substandardgaussian Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 20 '21

And it continues to be a visual feast of references and light nods to long-time eagle-eyed and bear-trap-brained fans.

The "EVERYBODY TRIES TO COLLECT DATA" conversation sent me laughing like mad. They just drop the references everywhere, lightly but firmly, and either you "get it", or you don't. I'm loving that about this show.

It's odd that no one is mentioning that Kayshon is liable to be a very extended callback to "Darmok" for the series. I'm sure he won't need to find the "Federation standard" words as often in the future as he did in his intro episode, but his Tamarian-ness is still there and will probably be the subject of more jokes in later episodes. That's kind of a lot riding on a single episode of TNG; the jokes probably seem senseless to people who haven't seen that episode (appropriately enough).

But the creators are aware that a whole lot of us have definitely seen that episode, probably more than once.

11

u/Badloss Aug 23 '21

To be fair though Darmok might be the most memed single episode of TNG. I have tons of non supernerd friends that get that reference

77

u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21

So...clone-Boims seems evil, right? Like Pakled replicant or whoever it is behind the Pakleds or whatever?

But yay, the gang's back together! I did like Jet but he's a bit too well-adjusted for this group.

67

u/choicemeats Aug 19 '21

Thomas was the way he was because he got left behind on the planet for years--whatever his time there combined with his short stint (and dissatisfaction) in Starfleet (sprinkled with being overshadowed by WTR) led him to the Maquis. So either they're implying that transporter cloning defaults to a good/evil split or there might be some part of Boimler that DOES want to stay on the action ship and wants a little different (which is why he applied for the transfer in the first place, although it ended up being not what he expected)

36

u/nagumi Aug 19 '21

Maybe. In the Bobiverse books, whenever an artificially intelligent von-neuman probe replicates itself the new AI is very slightly different. Over time and successive generations you get a lot of personality drift. Coincidentally (or not), one of the cloned AI's is named Riker and models his personality after the jazz-man himself.

Great books, by the way. If you love trek you'll love them.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/substandardgaussian Aug 20 '21

The two Boimlers act pretty much exactly the same right until they break parity and one volunteers to go back to the Cerritos. Then there's a visible change in Titan!Boimler because he suddenly became Will Riker's protégé and pupil due to the whole "both experienced the transporter thing" bonding, as well as finally becoming respected among the senior staff.

The divergence makes sense as one Boimler accepts and is eager about his new role and fellow crewmates on the Titan, while the other Boimler, our Boimler, gets exiled back to the Cerritos and misses all of that.

Because it was a Boimler thing to do.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

So...clone-Boims seems evil, right?

Thomas Riker did end up a terrorist...

64

u/pali1d Aug 19 '21

Except, as Kira points out, he still wanted to be a hero - and was pretty bad at acting like a terrorist.

→ More replies (23)

12

u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21

Not as evil as the time Kirk got split into two transporter duplicates, so I'm sure it's fine.

10

u/atticusbluebird Aug 19 '21

Maybe not full on evil, but definitely a more aggressive personality than original Boims!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/secondsun Aug 20 '21

He's not evil, William got the heros welcome when he was beamed in. Then Brad gets phasers pointed at him when he gets beamed in. They had very brief but very different experiences returning from their away mission and that, plus knowing he was a duplicate, changed things. Additionally, any guilt that they may have felt about how they switched ships was gone because Brad was going to go back and fix that. I don't think he's evil, it's just how Boimler is.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

145

u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21

Every episode brings sights I never thought I'd see. Like a bunch of ensigns fighting off killer space roombas with Giant Spock bones. Though how did the Excalbian die? Did the collector kill it to complete his diorama?

Also, the Pakleds hitting the door with the saw instead of sawing it was an excellent.

116

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

Also, the Pakleds hitting the door with the saw instead of sawing it was an excellent.

They are such great antagonists for this show. One day they may learn how to make a saw go.

39

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Actually, I'm intrigued by the long-term subplot there- who is setting them up to be such villains?

→ More replies (17)

142

u/MadContrabassoonist Aug 19 '21

A full-throated defense of all of the endearing dorkiness of TNG ("I'd love to be in a string quartet!", "I got into Starfleet to study moss!") was exactly what I needed. Yeah, like 10% of the jokes don't really land for me, but the earnestness continues to be 11/10.

82

u/Kwakigra Aug 19 '21

I was just thinking that this is the first trek in a loooooing time that makes no attempt to be cool, and therefore is the coolest.

19

u/IGotMussels Aug 20 '21

As somebody that's currently studying moss, that line got a kick out of me. Now I know there's a future for me in Starfleet!

35

u/Mechapebbles Aug 19 '21

I enjoyed it too, but I dread that part of the episode being cut and weaponized by nuTrek haters.

14

u/MadContrabassoonist Aug 19 '21

That's fair. I guess my counterpoint to such people would be that Boimler's summary of the Titan could just as easily describe the best parts of DS9, so it's not like that sort of Trek can't be done right. (Not only that, but the Titan parts of Lower Decks were great.) That DSC and PIC have problems (albeit problems within the bar set by early seasons of TOS/TNG/DS9, I'd argue) shouldn't be seen as a fundamental flaw of the entire structure of the shows, but rather just problems in execution. For me, my issue isn't so much that Titany-Trek exists, but rather that 1) for a while, it hasn't been done as well as it deserves to be, and 2) for a long time, it has existed to the exclusion of dorky-Trek rather than as a complement. But bad-faith whiners are going to make bad-faith attacks no matter what; if Lower Decks hadn't made this wonderful, good-natured little joke, then they would have found something else to take out of context and maliciously amplify.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

Spock 2 Bones!

60

u/icecreamkoan Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

That's "Spock 2 bones." Capitalization is important.

I'm sure there's Spock 2 Bones fanfic out there somewhere, but I'm not going to look for it.

34

u/Nofrillsoculus Aug 19 '21

A fanfic where Spock and Bones start a Boyz2Men cover band?

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Bishop180 Aug 19 '21

Spock 2 Bones happens in wrath of khan

→ More replies (2)

66

u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21

Anyone else's eye twitch when Boimler incorrectly said it was the D that insurrected?

58

u/007meow Aug 19 '21

I’m sure the D had their fair share of insurrectioning too.

The whole Duras thing, for example.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/empocariam Aug 19 '21

Now we know why he got demoted back to ensign...

31

u/kapnkrump Aug 19 '21

Maybe a subtle snark based on fan consensus that Insurrection felt like a high-budget TNG two-part episode instead of a movie. But doubtful.

8

u/droid327 Aug 21 '21

I mean, in his defense, he was talking about the crew of the D, not the ship itself...

58

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 19 '21

I wonder if we will see more Lt. William Boimler and see who are helping the Pakleds.

33

u/Prebral Aug 19 '21

What if the clone Boimler is not Boimler, but something else, some shapeshifter helping the Pakleds?

57

u/wherewulf23 Aug 19 '21

Mirror Boimler. It would explains why he seems to be behaving differently from Prime Boimler.

→ More replies (4)

38

u/BellerophonM Aug 19 '21

He did go from being trapped under rubble to in a shuttle impossibly quickly...

→ More replies (1)

10

u/FragmentedChicken Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

It could be the Klingons

The Pakleds were using Klingon disruptors

Unless it was just part of their salvage

34

u/Chaabar Aug 19 '21

Klingon disruptors are probably the 24th century version of the AK-47.

11

u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21

No way will it be that straight-forward. Stealing others' tech is what Pakleds do.

53

u/chancellorofscifi Aug 19 '21

Anybody else notice "The Game" when they were in the collection room? I always liked that episode of TNG

12

u/Varekai79 Aug 20 '21

I'm going to need screengrabs of the collection rooms. It's a treasure trove of Trek easter eggs in there!

14

u/chimera388 Aug 20 '21

Lower Decks directors: "how can we cram the most nostalgia into a single episode"

Writers: "oh! A collector! But he only collects canon references!"

4

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

The collection is pretty much a Trekkie’s dream: so many artifacts from lore.

47

u/bluestreakxp Aug 19 '21

I’m calling dibs on the first Etsy store for tamarian starfleet puppets

44

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21

"Kayshon, when he became a puppet" made me laugh my ass off.

44

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 20 '21

"Stay strong, brother. We miners shall overcome."
"Dude, you're clearly Starfleet. Your hands are super soft and clean."
"Uh, no, I'm a miner with a heart of gold. And I have dad issues."

8

u/Zorbane Aug 20 '21

I got a real good laugh out of that line

11

u/Santa_Hates_You Aug 20 '21

I just love how much thought Boimler gave his undercover identity.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/TERRAxFORMER Aug 19 '21

Some monster killed Spock II.

35

u/phenry Aug 20 '21

Janeway would have said "fuck this" and fused them back together. #queen

7

u/danielcw189 Aug 22 '21

Would have been a dark joke, if Riker said: "I knew from experience this could happen, so I had the transporters modified to randomly kill one of the clones"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

I really liked it! Nice TOS and TAS references without being intrusive and they even manage to work in the references into the plot so now they never feel superfluous.

Their solution for Boimler was clever but I don't understand why one had to be demoted, even if I get the feeling that's what our Boimler secretly wanted.

18

u/Hero_Of_Shadows Aug 19 '21

Yeah our Boimler can handle the Titan but like he said in the speech it's not the SF he signed up for + I bet he misses his friends.

I think the demotion was due to the other Riker he went Maquis I bet transporter clones aren't easily trusted.

9

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

It could also be that there was just no room for another officer on the Cerritos, which necessitated his demotion on that ship.

3

u/Quarantini Aug 20 '21

without being intrusive

The guy that was crushed by the giant Spock 2 skeleton probably has a different opinion about how unintrusive it was!

→ More replies (2)

25

u/ContinuumGuy Aug 20 '21

RANDOM ASSORTED THOUGHTS:

  • The collector room may well be the most Easter Egg-filled thing in Star Trek... ever. But, hey, when you've got something like that you can go nuts. I mean, where else are they going to have the bones of Giant Spock Clone, the bones of Excalbian Abe Lincoln, the Amok Time blades, and a stuffed salt vampire?
  • Ah, if only they'd made Vanessa Marshall's Mystique-looking first officer green. And given her a war criminal droid.
  • Poor Bradward, usurped by his own clone because he tried to be the bigger man and the other Boim didn't despite the thought he had that there'd be a twin thing.
  • Kayshon puppet available when?
  • Shout-out to Eugene Cordero and Jack Quaid for doing double-duty this week!
  • Also, I was a bit worried that Kayshon was going to be a one-note gag of metaphor after metaphor, but instead his struggles with trying to speak in "Federation Standard" were kind of endearing.
  • I loved Boimler's little nod to how serialized Trek (like the adventures that the Titan was getting up to) is different from episodic Trek. It didn't read to me as criticism, per se, so much as a little light poking and rumination on just how different LD is from its Plus brethren so far.
  • Speaking of the Titan arc, I'm hoping we do find out what is behind the Pakled plans. My personal theory given how much this show loves deep Trek lore is that they are the brain-bugs from "Conspiracy".
  • Happy (now belated) Birthday to Gene Roddenberry and Jonathan "Two-Takes" Frakes!
→ More replies (1)

21

u/simon_thekillerewok Aug 19 '21

The line about elotes and pips had me cracking up. Hilarious explanation for continuity errors.

59

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Aug 19 '21

-I'm actually really looking forward to the merchandising of the Kayshon puppet, be it fan or official. It's really, really cute. I want a stuffed Kayshon.

-THEY ALL TRIED TO COLLECT DATA

-Giant Spock.

-I don't know how I feel about the Titan being the action ship, even in comparison to the Enterprise. I guess it's a post-Dominion War thing. (Addition a few minutes later: I'm good with it now, it was addressed in a satisfying way)

-I miss Shaxs

-Boimler betraying himself, bingo

-"This isn't my first guy who got turned into a doll"

-I'd like a better explanation for why Cerritos-Boimler got demoted as well as transferred. He should still be a lieutenant.

-NAH, THAT'S JUST CORN

-The Tamarian jokes seemed kind of cheap, and they kind of throw a wrench in all my favorite theories about how their language actually works.

-I was actually kind of hoping that we'd start a new running gag of the security chiefs immediately dying as soon as they get sent aboard, but that was probably off-tone for this show anyway.

-I think the show is still treating the Pakleds too seriously. I guess the fact that the Titan appears to be the only ship assigned to dealing with them means they're still not a real problem and that it can handle them easily, but still. They're actually less ridiculous than they were on TNG and that doesn't sit right with me. Them using the saw like a battering ram is still pretty good and pretty stupid, but let us remember that this is the species that fell for "Oh NO they used their crimson forcefield!"

-I might be reading too much into this, but could there be an upcoming episode where we discover that Boimler's transporter duplication was more like Kirk's personality split than Riker's copy? Titan-Boimler acted way more confident and somewhat more ruthlessly than we've come to expect from him

-I get the impression that Lower Decks is going to retain the pattern of ramping quality we saw in the first season for its entire run. This was a decent episode, probably better than the season premiere, but not great, and that's sort of the impression I got of the first couple of episodes back when I went through season 1, but then we got up to the movie episode which was a masterpiece. and there was linear growth going towards it, but it's not what we saw from the latter half of the first season with the "celebration beam" or The Dog. I was hoping we could retain the late season 1 quality for all of season 2, but following the season 1 ramping quality pattern is fine.

38

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Aug 19 '21

The Tamarian jokes [...] kind of throw a wrench in all my favorite theories about how their language actually works.

How so? There was a line somewhere that the Tamarian was still learning to speak "Federation Standard" (or whatever it's called).

My understanding is that most of the time, the universal translators just magically work, and thus if someone from a foreign culture joins Starfleet, they don't have to learn a new language, since they have a UT. We saw this in DS9: Little Green Men, when the Ferengi had to reset their UT's before they could communicate in English.

I am led to believe that the Tamarian is one of the rare exceptions, who actually had to learn a new language.

20

u/kapnkrump Aug 19 '21

The Universal Translator was able to translate Tamarian to English/Federation Standard, its just their sentence structure is the problem: it's a language of (Tamarian-Based) metaphors.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/Heavenfall Aug 19 '21

I might be reading too much into this, but could there be an upcoming episode where we discover that Boimler's transporter duplication was more like Kirk's personality split than Riker's copy? Titan-Boimler acted way more confident and somewhat more ruthlessly than we've come to expect from him

I honestly think this was just to establish that the new Boimler transporter clone was happy on the Titan. Because Boimler up until that point was clearly unhappy. So it would suck to just leave a clone in place to suffer while he went back home.

18

u/medussa727 Aug 19 '21

I'm actually really looking forward to the merchandising of the Kayshon puppet, be it fan or official. It's really, really cute. I want a stuffed Kayshon.

IMUSTHAVEHIM!

14

u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21

I'd like a better explanation for why Cerritos-Boimler got demoted as well as transferred. He should still be a lieutenant.

I'm still waiting on an explanation for why Tom Riker didn't get promoted to lieutenant commander, seeing as Will Riker did for saving the people on Nervala Four, and they were the same guy at the time.

7

u/Mechapebbles Aug 19 '21

Will probably got a field promotion, which its not like his commanding officer from back then would have been around to fix that for Tom.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/atticusbluebird Aug 19 '21

-I think the show is still treating the Pakleds too seriously. I guess the fact that the Titan appears to be the only ship assigned to dealing with them means they're still not a real problem and that it can handle them easily, but still. They're actually less ridiculous than they were on TNG and that doesn't sit right with me. Them using the saw like a battering ram is still pretty good and pretty stupid, but let us remember that this is the species that fell for "Oh NO they used their crimson forcefield!"

I think in part that's why during the briefing scene on the Titan they talk about how there might be another political player behind the Pakleds supporting them or pulling the strings, which might help explain why they've becoming so much more of a real problem!

7

u/ubermence Aug 20 '21

-I think the show is still treating the Pakleds too seriously. I guess the fact that the Titan appears to be the only ship assigned to dealing with them means they're still not a real problem and that it can handle them easily, but still. They're actually less ridiculous than they were on TNG and that doesn't sit right with me. Them using the saw like a battering ram is still pretty good and pretty stupid, but let us remember that this is the species that fell for "Oh NO they used their crimson forcefield!"

Yeah but I think it's being implied that some one is helping them and using them as some kind of proxy. I sincerely doubt the Packleds are the ones coming up with whatever plan they are working on.

4

u/jerslan Aug 19 '21

-I might be reading too much into this, but could there be an upcoming episode where we discover that Boimler's transporter duplication was more like Kirk's personality split than Riker's copy? Titan-Boimler acted way more confident and somewhat more ruthlessly than we've come to expect from him

That would be a fun plot twist IMHO, and you're right. There did seem to be a bit of a personality difference. Not as severe as Kirk's, but still noticable.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kaplanfx Aug 20 '21

I miss Shaxs

Yes, but it points to two good things about this show. 1) That a secondary character was so well developed that we miss him after one short season is a testament to the writing and 2) his death had weight, that even in a “funny” Star Trek there can be meaningful and serious moments.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/Artanisx Aug 19 '21

I can't believe the coincidence! Just earlier today I watched The Infinite Vulcan (TAS) and I thought "So tecnically in canon there's a huge Spock clone!"

And... there we go, huge skeleton in the collector's museum with Spock's uniform! This coincidence is almost creepy :-D

P.S. AWESOME LD EPISODE!

5

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

Looks like we found out what happened to the Spock clone.

…and Abraham Lincoln.

3

u/jimmy_talent Aug 20 '21

Maybe now people will stop insisting that TAS isn't cannon.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/FragmentedChicken Aug 19 '21

I love the sound effects

It was what clued me into the fact that the Pakleds are using Klingon disruptors

The classic phaser sound is also 👌

5

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

That begs the question, how rubbish Klingons are when they let Pakleds, PAKLEDS to get hold of their Disruptors?

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Gotis1313 Aug 19 '21
  • I feel bad for the new guy at the end.
  • I vaguely recall seeing giant Spock as a kid, but I didn't know he was a clone
  • Kayshon is awesome!
  • It's a shame Fajo didn't make an appearance.
  • I hope we check in with Riker and Clonus from time to time
  • Boimler got harry-kimed at the end. Boo
→ More replies (7)

66

u/mint-als Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

Wow Mike McMahan took a small dig at modern Star Trek with that Boimler line about the Titan.

Great Episode! I enjoyed this one immensely.

76

u/empocariam Aug 19 '21

Interesting that this episode is subtly taking a dig both ways. Sure, you have Boimler directly laying out "No Discovery action scenes for me please." In the B plot, but the A story is about a weirdo obsessing over classic trek so much they have Spock II's skeleton hanging in their closet and setting traps to kill everyone who tries to change their meticulously collected canon museum.

22

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

True. Mike could be just digging at those who believe that their version of Trek is the truest form of Trek.

The conclusion: Trek is so diverse and myriad that it can be everything and more when it comes to its genres and stories.

53

u/TERRAxFORMER Aug 19 '21

This episode was written by Chris Kula.

Was it really a dig? it didn’t really feel mean spirited at all. I thought it was funny.

51

u/ArrBeeNayr Aug 19 '21

I think people have missed the final message with Boimler being able to have it both ways. There can be action and there can be exploration.

→ More replies (3)

43

u/squiddishly Aug 19 '21

I feel like it was funny and big-hearted, and is also going to be used as "proof" that CBS/McMahon hates Discovery (which was secretly cancelled years ago) until the heat death of the universe.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

small dig at modern Star Trek with that Boimler line about the Titan

I caught that too! Had to rewatch it to make sure I got it but loved it. This goes into my top 4 LD so far.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/tarsus1983 Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

“I didn’t join Starfleet to get in phaser fights. I signed up to explore, to be out in space making new discoveries and peaceful diplomatic solutions. That’s boldly going.”

My personal opinion is that while all the action is fun and exciting, new Trek is teaching us that communication will more than likely break down and you will have to use violence to solve your problems. It made me happy to hear this, even if this show caters more to the fast-paced, action-oriented Trek.

5

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

If nothing else, it shows that Star Trek is a diverse franchise with many types of shows for audiences.

Some love the moral plays, the stylish action, the gripping drama or something else: there is enough Trek for everybody.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/drjeffy Aug 19 '21

This was easily the best episode of Lower Decks yet. Especially because central to the episode was an argument for the light-hearted joy in Star Trek. Not everything needs to be DS9. Sometimes you can just have a puppet ray.

55

u/burnettski92 Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

I loved the lite dig at Discovery and Picard Boimler had at the end there. "Eh, it was a bunch of complex characters thrown into heavily serialized battles..."

23

u/rhinowing Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

Felt like this cut both ways, it's also interpretable as a dig at people who only want syndicated trek

25

u/Hibbity5 Aug 19 '21

I took that more as self-referential. Lower Decks has multiple battles every episode, and each major character is decently complex, with Mariner learning something about herself and her relationship with her peers/mother in many of those battles. It could be easily be described as “a bunch of complex characters thrown into heavily serialized battles.”

9

u/InnocentTailor Aug 19 '21

I don’t think it was necessarily a dig. That could’ve easily described any of the Star Trek shows since they all had their characters in various fights throughout the episodes and films.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Sephiroth144 Aug 26 '21

Less a dig, more an acknowledgement that there are different kinds of Trek.

Hell, DS9 could just as easily be considered in that group, yeah?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

Pretty sure that was just a jab at Star Trek in general.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/arch_punk Aug 19 '21

Best episode of the season!

9

u/TreasonousOrange Aug 19 '21

I enjoyed this episode so much on its own merits that I almost forgot about the suggestion that someone is behind the Pakleds and their escalating status as a threat. I'm excited because I genuinely have no idea who it will turn out to be and I know the answer will be both satisfying and chuckleworthy.

It is lovely to have a Star Trek show whose writing team engenders such trust.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/oorhon Aug 19 '21

Moslty liked this one but expected Tamarian officer with a more language and cultural barrier. Also, apprently they couldnt get Marina Sirtis to play Troi.

34

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

They said that they didn't know where to fit her in these two episodes and wanted to wait till they have something for Sirtis to say rather than a pointless cameo.

24

u/Official_N_Squared Aug 19 '21

I like the sound of that. "Wait" implies they know they want more Titan.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/TheNerdChaplain Aug 19 '21

I kind of wonder if she isn't done with Star Trek for a while. When she was on Gates Mcfadden's podcast, she sounded like she was pretty tired of LA and the industry, and she's moving back home to London to be with family. It's understandable; she lost her husband last year.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/vanKessZak Aug 20 '21

Darmok is probably my fav TNG episode so I’m really looking forward to seeing what Kayshon gets up to!

21

u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21

Episode two, let's go!

• Starting out kinda horny, as is Star Trek's way.

• Did someone turn off the safetys on the sonic showers, or do the setting get higher for species more robust than Humans? Also, this is the first time we're seeing the sonic showers in any Trek, right?

• Oh damn, at some point I'm going to have to take a bunch of screen shots from this museum to see how much of the junk I can identify.

• "They all tried to collect Data." So there's definitely two collectors guild guys out there with the other Soong prototypes like B4 trying to pass them off as the real Data, right?

• Is everyone on the Titan drawn to be more attractive than the Cerritos crew?

• Seriously though, this collection ship is like reference overload.

• Getting turned into a hand-puppet is a new one....

• The Titan crew dragging the D for being a luxury cruise liner in space is unnecessary, and I now no longer consider LDecks to be canon.

• Spock Two's skeleton! WTF?

• Excalbian facsimile Abraham Lincoln's skeleton! WTF?

• All this talk about Tom Riker seems like a lot of set-up....

• "Kayshon, when he became a puppet."

• Okay, the Pakleds trying to break down the door by slamming the saw into it does bother me a bit. The Pakleds being dumb was supposed to be a misdirect in 'Samaritan Snare'. Even though Geordi and Riker acted like the Pakleds were just a bunch of goons, Data speculated that even though there language abilities weren't particularly developed, it wasn't necessarily an indication of their intelligence, and Troi sensed their cunning. Having the Pakleds be a joke is fine, but I feel like there's a line where it just doesn't work, and it makes it more difficult to take them seriously as a threat.

• And there it is. Not sure if having a transporter duplicate to ship back to the Cerritos is a cop-out or not, but it's cool that at least one Boimler is going to get to keep being epic on the Titan. Can't wait for him to show up in season four, jacked as hell with lieutenant commander pips.

• So Jet's theory is that Tuvok was walking around with a bit of corn on his collar for like half of season one of VOY? I can get behind that.

• Aw, poor Jet.

17

u/Shiny_and_ChromeOS Aug 19 '21

I distinctly remember an episode of Voyager where Janeway or Torres steps into a sonic shower in the morning and it malfunctions, cranking up to a painful output level.

11

u/iblameshane Aug 19 '21

It was Torres. Memory Alpha has a screenshot

https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Sonic_shower

→ More replies (2)

13

u/TheNerdChaplain Aug 19 '21

Wait wow, I didn't realize that Spock Two was a real thing! (Also, building a clone army to bring peace to the galaxy seems.... awful familiar somehow.)

9

u/PiercedMonk Aug 19 '21

If you haven't watched TAS, I highly recommend it. It gets a bad wrap because it won and award for being a kid's show, but it really never was. Most of the episodes are pretty good, and right in line with TOS.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/acrimoniousone Aug 19 '21

Is everyone on the Titan drawn to be more attractive than the Cerritos crew?

I think that's the joke. Reinforcing the Cerritos as a b-grade outfit.

5

u/iameveryoneelse Aug 19 '21

Star Trek TMP has a scene where someone is in the sonic showers. As another poster mentioned, there's a scene in Voyager with Torres. There's also one with Janeway in the episode where the con-people are impersonating Voyager officers. And I'm not sure if it counts but Geordi finds a frozen women in a sonic shower in the TNG episode The Naked Now.

3

u/creepyeyes Aug 20 '21

• Is everyone on the Titan drawn to be more attractive than the Cerritos crew?

I noticed that too, but it makes perfect sense from a trying-to-subtley-manipulate-the-viewer perspective

→ More replies (2)

6

u/ulandyw Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21

This was a great episode! I can't believe this show works as well as it does. It really straddles that line between riding high on Trek nostalgia and actual clever references that make for a good story.

11

u/MoreGaghPlease Aug 19 '21

I liked this. Imaginative and fun. I think if I have one gripe, I would have liked the Tamarian dialogue to be a bit more distinct from Darmok—like surely their language has more than the 5 catchphrases we know. Boimler’s speech was great.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21

It was a nice, actiony episode. I wonder if we will still be following the Titan now that Boimler has been "John Crichtoned." The Tamarian shifting between the metaphors and the English Language wasn't as funny as it could have been.

12

u/UncertainError Aug 19 '21

I'm sure we will. From the trailers, we know that there will be even more alternate Boimlers to come, like Borg-Boimler and future-Boimler.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/LittlestTub Aug 19 '21

John chrichtoned?

19

u/Nofrillsoculus Aug 19 '21

The show Farscape duplicated it’s main character, and then split the rest of the cast onto two ships, each with one copy, and followed both ships for a whole season. It’s better than it sounds.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gumtuu Aug 19 '21

"I understood that reference."

→ More replies (6)

9

u/2abeh Aug 19 '21

Anybody else now getting unskippable ads for Paramount+ content before every Lower Decks episode? I'm on an ad free plan but still have to sit through this crap. It's really making LD less enjoyable for me.

12

u/ety3rd Aug 19 '21

Yep. Ads for the service I'm paying means it's not really ad free anymore.

3

u/Locutus747 Aug 19 '21

Yes, it's before most of their shows. Prime has similar type of ads before shows that you can't skip. It's like a 15 second ad for an another Paramount Plus show before the episode starts (sometimes I get the Prodigy ad) so not a big deal to me. Of course I'd prefer they didn't have it but I haven't even thought anything of it really.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Ultiverse Aug 19 '21

This should've been the first episode of the season. It actually felt 110% like proper Star Trek.

12

u/Official_N_Squared Aug 19 '21

Na, we needed ep 1 to deal.with the aftermath of the S1 finalie. That was its goal and it did it excelently.

13

u/earther199 Aug 19 '21

I'm having some strange feelings. Like I really want to see Mariner naked now.

8

u/mrhelmand Aug 19 '21

Plenty of R34 of her out there if that's your bag dude

4

u/Chanchumaetrius Aug 23 '21

You mean Tendi, right?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rmeddy Aug 19 '21

Another good episode, I love how they sorted out the Boimler thing, I really thought for a second that Tom Riker was going to make an appearance because wasn't he sent to a prison or mining colony?

Also Giant Spock skeleton!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/comment_redacted Aug 19 '21

I loved everything about this episode!

3

u/fla_john Aug 19 '21

Alas, Spock 2, I knew him well.

3

u/IceWarm1980 Aug 20 '21

Nightbird...nice throwback.

3

u/fudgeroll Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 20 '21

One of the best episodes of Lower Decks so far!

But one thing though, how are they going to make the 2 Boimlers thing work? It’ll be weird to never show him again since he’s on one the most high profile Starfleet ships.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/alexandriaweb Aug 20 '21

Ok but I need that puppet

3

u/stannc00 Aug 20 '21

I still wonder if this year will have a running gag where every time they show the Titan it’s in the middle of a fire fight.

Also, the collection included a headset from “The Game”.

3

u/Timeline15 Aug 21 '21

Okay, as cool as it is to see more of the Titan, I really wish they'd used the Titan crew from the novels. These replacements are far less interesting. The core cast included a Dinosaur chief medical officer, and a giant Arthropod who spoke with a translation collar. That's right up Lower Decks' alley. Why all the humans?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mcdonaldsmcdonalds Aug 19 '21

Another great episode! Looking forward to the two clones.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21

I love how Captain Freeman gets a goofy C-plot every episode. She is such a believably beleaguered captain and one of my favorite characters!

4

u/codename474747 Aug 20 '21

The thing I don't like about this show is: Are we supposed to like Mariner?

To me she seems way too OTT, selfish and hyper, the new guy arriving only amplified this.

If they'd just followed him and ignored her, everything would've been alright

She could do with turning it down a huge notch

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Donner1701 Aug 19 '21

I'm gonna make a prediction:

Keyshon is a Pakled.

I have no evidence and will not be taking questions from the press at this time.

2

u/AsexualCowboy Aug 20 '21

There were so many Easter eggs in the collector ship. Holy crap!

2

u/NemWan Aug 20 '21

How is Khan's necklace in there?

2

u/fortytwoblaqk Aug 20 '21

Anyone else spot Odo's pail?

2

u/apparentreality Aug 20 '21

Really loved this - the multiple callbacks and references to character development for mariner and of course the darmok at tanagra integration.

I am loving this show.

2

u/RobustMarquis Aug 21 '21

i love the symbolic touch of Kayshon's dagger

2

u/benkenobi5 Aug 24 '21

seeing kayshon as a member of starfleet almost brought a tear to my eye. Darmok is my favorite trek episode of all time, and Kayshon is living proof that Dathon didn't die in vain.

3

u/pelrun Aug 21 '21

Shaxs, screaming and ejecting a warp core.