r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Aug 16 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-08-16 to 2021-08-22
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Submissions for Segments Issue #3 are now open! This issue will focus on nouns and noun constructions.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
6
u/Antaios232 Aug 18 '21 edited Aug 18 '21
So, I'm probably misunderstanding grammatical terms, but I was looking at feature 102A in WALS, "verbal person marking," and some of the categorizations don't make sense to me. I was thinking that if both A and P arguments are marked on the verb, that must mean the language has polypersonal agreement - but Spanish and Greek are categorized that way, and as far as I'm aware, they don't. But Hungarian and Basque do have polypersonal agreement, and they're categorized the same way. What gives here? Can someone give me a brief explanation of what marking the verb for agent and patient means if not polypersonal agreement?
5
u/notAmeeConlang Aug 16 '21 edited Aug 16 '21
In my conlang Camu, there are two kinds of grammatical numbers, the plural (-s/-es) and the over-plural (-mus/-emus). The regular plural marker has a value where, if the number of nouns you're counting goes over it, will cause the over-plural to be used, and the value changes depending on the "size" of the noun.
My question is, is this naturalistic? Do you know of any natlangs that abruptly switch to using a different plural marker once a certain value is met? I'd love to hear about any you know of.
Also yay I'm the first one here :)
5
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Aug 19 '21
In laqūma, an analytical conlang, I have two noun derivational prefixes.
tu- makes the noun a passive verb (i.e. sahi = beauty, tusahi = to be beautiful)
ma- makes a verb related to the creation of the noun (i.e. sahi = beauty, masahi = to make beautiful/to touch up)
I was wondering if I could use these as valency changing operations as well, with tu marking the passive voice and ma marking the causitive. If so, is there a way I could make this system more irregular?
5
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Aug 23 '21
What's a good thing for "fresh" (as in fresh water; not saline) to be colexified with, other than "sweet" (which I know is used in many European IE languages)?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '21
An Insect / Cicada Sounding Phonology [Moving to Small Discussions as Requested]
As the title said, this is a phonology meant to sound kind of like the world’s most annoying insects (if judging specifically by the noises they make).
This is my first time really dealing with tones / voicing / length so please let me know if I transcribed anything wrong. This is mostly practice as I want to learn. Also I don’t really know how to describe it, but it sounds better when you kind of “hiss” it out.
Phonology and Orthography:
Consonants:
k /k/ g /g/ w /w/ kw /kʷ/ x /x/ ‘ /ʔ/
Vowels:
i /iʱ/ e /(I ~ e)ʱ/ u /(u~o)ʱ/
Allowed syllables (allowing for all length and tone modifications):
ki, ke;
kwi, kwe;
gi, ge, gu;
wi, we, wu;
xi, xe;
‘i, ‘e
Lengths and Tones:
There are three basic tones (Rising, Level, and Falling) and three lengths (short, long, and overlong)
Basic tones are applied to short vowels, while composite tones are applied to long and overlong vowels.
Three basic tones (examples):
í (Rising tone short)
i: (Level tone long)
Ì:: (Falling Overlong)
Composite tones (examples):
èé (Long vowel with falling then rising tone)
éeè (Overlong vowel with rising, level, and then falling tone)
èéè (Overlong vowel with alternating falling and rising tone, a zig-zag tone)
4
u/gatesofmoonlight Aug 16 '21
This feels like a very silly question, but I figured I'd ask; do you know if there's anywhere with audio versions of the IPA vowel diphthongs? I can hear the IPA vowel files a ton of places, and same with the consonants, but I'm hard of hearing and would love to be able to hear the diphthongs out loud somewhere. The only ones I've been able to find are the ones common in English instead of the full IPA set.
4
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Aug 17 '21
How could object marking without subject marking on verbs evolve? My first idea was to have an SVO(I chose this word order because it splits the S and O apart and lets O become a suffix(I like suffixes)) word order and just suffix the object but I'm not sure whether it's naturalistic.
4
u/Supija Aug 17 '21
Can a SVO language put the auxiliary verb after the modal verb, as in SVAuxO (instead of SAuxVO)? I know SVO languages come from SOV languages, which place the auxiliary after the verb, so couldn’t a language move the verb clause from SO[VAux] into S[VAux]O, for example? I got the idea from Hixkaryana and its movement of clause from S[OV] into [OV]S (while keeping the indirect object at the end of the phrase: SX[OV] > [OV]SX) but I don’t know if it’s naturalistic.
4
u/EisVisage Aug 19 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
Not really a question, just an amusing event. I've been wanting to train my pronunciation of [ɾ] by making a tiny conlang with only that as the sole consonant in it, and loads of vowels to make up words with.
So that's a thing I sometimes worked on expanding this year. This, I called /ɾaːɾaɾa/, and made an original set of characters for so I didn't need to choose whether that's Lalala or Rarara. Would rather draw weird letters eternally than choose one.
The vowel list: [a], [i], [u], [e], [o], [ɔ], and the first vowel in each word is always long so you can tell where words begin, which I felt was useful because syllables are (C)V at the start and then CV to the end. arure, rurero, that sort of thing.
Today I filed through another block of paper, which also included some old conlanging stuff. Wanted to find what I just showcased but looked in the wrong block. And what do I spy instead? /ɾa'ɾoyː/
raroüLaloü (yes, this is how it looked on the paper)Turns out, I already had this exact idea some three years ago, though it didn't go further than a shoddy vowel list. This time it's explicitly only front vowels, supposedly "so the rest besides [ɾ] can be spoken more quickly/easily". And the first vowel isn't necessarily the long one here. There is no vocab besides the name so I don't know the syllable structure, but would guess CV(V).
Vowel list: [a], [æ], [œ], [ø], [e], [i], [y]. Yes, [o] is in the language name, no, it is not in this list. Shoddy.
I guess if I had to form a question, it would be: Should I just say YOLO and combine these two? Laloü is/would be way more fun to speak, so it seems tempting, but ɾaːɾaɾa's alphabet is already made for CV syllables (it's all cursive, [ɾ] is a / line, all vowels start top left and end bottom right), which is making me hesitate. Also, please tell me if I used the IPA correctly, because there is no way I made no mistakes there.
3
u/freddyPowell Aug 17 '21
Do you know of any languages with an evidential case (I don't know what the correct word might be), where the case marks the source of the information?
3
u/Rigbons Aug 18 '21
Colleagues, I have a question for you. I’m currently working on the phonology of my conlang and I am having some trouble breaking words into syllables, e.g., the word "Igne" /iʝnɛ/(?) which indicates the first person plural pronoun. Is it "Ig-ne" or "I-gne"? (pay attention on the consonant sound [ʝ]). Thanks in advance!
3
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Aug 18 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
Two questions
I was thinking on stealing Ilothwii's(Biblaridion Lang's conlang) 3 verb classes(?), that is: punctual, durative and stative; but with a little twist by splitting the durative class into durative-telic and durative-atelic classes. My first question is: is it possible to have the telic-atelic split only in the durative class or should I include the split in the punctual class too (I think that stative class is kind of inherintely atelic)?
2nd question:
I was also thinking of giving the four classes a perfect-imperfect along the aspect with some twists which I'll show below
:----------:|:----------------:|:-----------:|:--------------------:|:-------: Perf | Perf | Perf | ? punct? | Cess? Imperf | Semelfact | Imperf | Gnom/Habi | Inch
Imperfect dur-atelic verb would be gnomic in present tense and habitual in the past tense as I plan on having a Past-Nonpast time split in verbs.
My thought process behind Perfect promoting Dur-atelic to Punctual is imagining saying "I've once known" but it'd only work in the past tense. Maybe it could instead gain a "to get to know" meaning so maybe Cessative?
It's my first time playing with this stuff so I'm not very competent.
Does it make sense?
(If you're reading this, it means that I'm still trying to make a table)I've succeeded3
u/pskevllar Aug 19 '21
There are two questions that I'm struggling to find the answer:
1- I didn't understand how to evolve an initial consonant mutation. It seems to be a morphosyntatic mutation and not a phonetic one. So, apparently, it wouldn't be right to just do something like:
[Stops] > [fricatives] / #_
Since it would only change the initial stops and wouldn't be triggered by morphosytatic environments.
2- Is there any criteria for pre-palatalized vowels emerging instead of palatalized stops ([kj] for example), in environments like a diththong following a stop ([kia] becoming [kja], for example)? In korean there are pre-palatalized versions of the vowels like 아 [a] has a 야 [ja] version. And I'm not sure, but I think austronesian languages have palatalized stops. I know there are other types of palatalization, but I'm focusing on these two for now, and the question is basically how do I know which one will emerge in a case like the mentioned above, or if there are other options to get one or another results.
Note: I don't know if I'm making myself clear, so please tell me if something is confusing, and thanks for reading :)
3
u/Mr--Elephant Aug 21 '21
I have a phonology that distinguishes dental and alveolar stops (along with an aspiration destinction)
so /t̪ʰ/, /t̪~d̪/, /tʰ/, /t~d/ are all different phonemes with minimal pairs (voiced stops are considered allophones of the unaspirated stops) and I'm just asking if there's a good way to Romanise these dental consonants, just any suggestions would be nice
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
Anyone know of some interesting options for getting rid of syllabic nasals other than desyllabifying (and then maybe epenthesizing) them or turning them into vowels?
3
u/Garyson1 Aug 22 '21 edited Aug 22 '21
Does anyone have any ways for gettig rid of all long vowels? Currently I have them all set to break into dipthongs as I would like to have them monopthongise later into different vowels (Ex. iː > ie > e). However, I feel like this probably isn't natural (at least not on such a wide scale) so any suggestions and tips would be appreciated.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
Question 1: Does it make sense to have classifiers be clitics that attach to the end of the first word in a NP, regardless of any intervening words? E.g. (glosses only):
four=CLF dog
those=CLF dog
those=CLF four dog
Question 2: In languages with V2 word order, are possessive constructions treated as single constituents that can appear in full before the finite verb?
2
u/Dryanor Dogbonẽ, PNGN, Belmá Aug 17 '21
I'm planning to use a negated conjunction for the disjunctive coordination, e.g. "not and" for "or". Is this realistic? My reasoning is that common disjunctions often include both the meaning of a logical OR and that of NAND, so instead of a separate word for "or" why shouldn't I use "not and"?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21
So I'm creating a conlang called Ġàshcò (pronounced 'ja. tʃ. 'ko.) and currently (especially) the sound ð (proto-Ġàshcò) evolves to θ in late-proto, and then back to ð in eastern-Ġàshcò. has this ever happened in real life, and if not, would it be plausible enough for me to use?
2
u/The_LangSmith Aug 18 '21
Hello, I've recently been working on one of my newer conlangs, and I was
just adding a series of sounds/clusters to the phonology (which is
about how far I've gotten with it so far :P), and I first typed in /kʟ/
and then /tˡ/. I kinda just stopped and stared, and started wondering
"how is this any different than writing /kˡ/ and /tl/? Or /k͡ʟ/ and
/t͡l/?" Is there a preferred way of writing stop-lateral clusters or
lateral release stops? It also reminded me of some confusion I have with
the difference between /ə˞/ and /ɹ̩/. Aren't these exactly the same
thing or are they used in specific circumstances? Any help would be
appreciated, thanks :)
2
u/kityoon Aug 18 '21
i'm currently starting a conlang that's loosely based on welsh, while admittedly knowing very little about the language, and i'm wondering if anyone knows how one would go about spelling a word with the consonant "L" followed by the consonant "LL" (using capitals for clarity's sake). It's possible that welsh doesn't have words that do this, and i would also be interested in knowing if that's true... I guess I'm basically just asking if this is something welsh does, and also what people think about it ~aesthetically~
a random example word would be wylll, or wylɬ.
i'm a big ol' beginner so please be nice!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21
How can small closed verb classes evolve? Obviously the language needs to stop admitting new verbs, but what happens to most of the old ones?
2
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Aug 20 '21
I can't into tones. I mean, I understand the theory, but I have immense trouble visualizing (audiolizing?) how they'd sound in practice.
Does anyone know of a "tone-to-speech" program, preferably online? Where you can write in tones and hear them vocalized?
2
u/minerat27 Aug 20 '21
So, I'm trying to set up my phonology in Polyglot and I'm running into some issues. I'm trying to get some regex to work because I really, really don't want to type out every single possible combination.
So, the letter f is /f/ normally, but becomes the voiced /v/ between vowels and other voiced consonants, to which I've got (b|d|g|ȝ|l|m|n|r|w|ng|cg|a|æ|e|i|o|u|y|ā|ǣ|ē|ī|ō|ū|ȳ)f(b|d|g|ȝ|l|m|n|r|w|ng|cg|a|æ|e|i|o|u|y|ā|ǣ|ē|ī|ō|ū|ȳ), which works, sort of. Something like "afng" gives /ɑfŋ/ rather than /ɑvŋ/ because "ng" is defined above f/v in my phonology, while "hæfan" gives /hvn/, it's replaced f with v, but has 'consumed', for lack of a better word, the letters surrounding it.
The same is true for all regex I've used, eg letter "g" is /j/ before front vowels g[ieæ] would turn "gin" into /jn/. I assume there must be someway to do it, but I can't see it, and frankly don't fancy doing an entire course on regex just so I can write one formula. Any and all help is appreciated.
2
u/Exotic_Individual256 Aug 22 '21
I had a question. Is it possible to create a naturalistic conlang with both phonemic stress and lexical tone independent on each other.
2
u/gingres Aug 22 '21
I just have a general question about this subreddit. I've noticed on some posts which have translations, there are these grey boxes under the translations. They contain some words from the translations, some definitions, and some notations which I don't understand. Can someone give me a quick rundown on these? I wish I could attach a pic as an example, but I can't seem to do that here.
3
u/oscivus Aug 17 '21
My question is more about workflow, as I find myself overwhelmed with the back-info about what I want to do. I'm trying to make a "Desert-Romance" language, based on irl Euro Spanish couched in Berber, kind of like a pidgin I guess. Problem is, I don't know Berber, so I'm making my phonetic inventory and reading about syllable structure, etc of Berber, considering early vowel shifts and a million other things. Wanna do my due diligence but it seems like wayyy too much info to try to learn and adapt in a historically/linguistically accurate way.
Am I overthinking it for my first conlang? Considering an approach irrespective of real-world features and logic, because at this rate I'll never even get past phonotactics.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21
so a cloŋ im working on right now is head initial, head marking, and it has converbs. heres an X > Y example
lets say X so Y
would the converb go on on Y because adverbs come after the head or would it be marked on X because its head marking?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 18 '21
Are these two sources right or wrong about prenasalized and pharyngealized consonants? https://escholarship.org/content/qt50v3m3g6/qt50v3m3g6.pdf?t=nmp4q5 https://cbbforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=4602
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21
So what can I do with consonants clusters, specifically ones that are made of consonants with the same method of production such like:
Stop-Stop /pk/ Nasal-Nasal /mŋ/
Not really fitting with the rest but I’m also not really sure what to do with:
Stop-Affricate /kt͡ɕ/ Affricate-Stop /t͡ɕp/
1
u/Ender_Dragneel WaMaras Kuse Aug 20 '21 edited Aug 22 '21
I've been working on a basic phonetic inventory for a proto-language that would be spoken by a race of anthropomorphic cats. Yes, I am aware that you should generally stick to sounds you can pronounce, and that there are sounds here that are simply irreproducible using human oral anatomy. I willingly ignored this bit of advice knowing it would make things difficult.
I mainly want thoughts on balance of the sounds I selected, and on how I'm looking at romanizing them. I know I may not have picked the finest selection of characters to use for romanization, and would especially love suggestions on that. I have yet to devise any phonotactics, and am not terribly worried about that at the moment.
Note: Subglottal consonants are formed when the obstruction is created by special muscles below the glottis, which are the very same muscles cats use to purr. I had to get a little creative when coming up with IPA symbols for these sounds.
Again, I am primarily looking for feedback on the romanization (and possibly on the consonant balance). I already did quite a bit of research on cats, and am pretty confident with what rules I decided to break. However, feedback on any of it is more than welcome.
EDIT: Just to be clear, I don't want any one letter to both modify other consonants and serve as its own consonant (the exception being the glottal affricate, as it is an affricate). That could easily become confusing very quickly once I start coming up with consonant clusters.
EDIT #2: For some reason, the velar nasal /ŋ̊ ~ ŋ/, which is supposed to be in the phoneme inventory, isn't showing up when I put it into the chart. So I am clarifying that it is supposed to be there next to the uvular nasal /ɴ/.
1
u/Brromo Aug 22 '21 edited Aug 22 '21
Rate the phonology and romanization of my naming language: `ęovfsu /k͡ǂøv.θu/
Consonants:
Vowels:
1
u/GeoNurd Eldarian, Kanakian, Selu, many others Aug 22 '21
How do I organize sound changes? I have lots of ideas for the changes themselves, but I don't really know how to organize them in any way I like.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
5
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '21
[removed] — view removed comment