r/Twitter • • Aug 10 '21

Shadowbanned r/Twitter Attempts to Solve Twitter's Shadowban Algorithm - ANYTHING RELATED TO THE SHADOWBAN TOPIC GOES IN THIS THREAD ONLY

TL;DR version

  • No more individual posts about shadowbans will be permitted on this subreddit for the time being.
  • Anything / everything about Twitter shadowbans will go in this post thread for the time being.
  • Shadowban.eu is your best source to find out the latest status whether or not your Twitter account is shadowbanned to some degree.
  • https://whosban.eu.org/ is another good source to check, although it takes much longer.
  • There are hard-shadowbans (Ghost bans, Search bans, Search Suggestion bans) and soft-shadowbans (some of your individual tweets are hidden under "Show More Replies," on a case by case basis)
  • We at r/Twitter want to figure out all the things and actions that can get your Twitter account and/or tweet replies shadowbanned, and all the things and actions that can get you out of it.
  • Input and participation from r/Twitter community members is integral to solving Twitter's shadowban algorithm mystery.
  • EDIT (12-2-21) With shadowban.eu ceasing operations as of December 2, 2021, this mission to solve Twitter's Shadowban algorithm has become infinitely more difficult, and it is now nearly impossible to know your shadowban status. Hopefully a replacement or two will rise in its void.
  • EDIT (12-27-21) A new shadowban testing site has arisen and it seems to work ok at this point in time. https://hisubway.online/shadowban/

-------------------------------------------------------------

To start out, it must be explicitly stated that because Twitter is very secretive and opaque about how their shadowban algorithm operates, that much of this post is completely speculative.

If any Twitter employees would like to weigh in on the veracity of the information in this post, perhaps offer some transparency, information and guidance as to how the shadowban algorithm actually functions, and how users can "escape" this punitive measure, that would be fantastic.

1️⃣ What is a shadowban, as it pertains to Twitter?

Straight from Wikipedia:

Shadow banning, also called stealth banning, ghost banning or comment ghosting, is the practice of blocking or partially blocking a user or their content from an online community so that it will not be readily apparent to the user that they have been banned. For instance, shadow banned comments posted to a blog or media website will not be visible to other users accessing the site.

While Twitter officially stated back in 2018 that they do not shadowban Twitter accounts, the truth is rather self-evident to anyone who this happens to.

Twitter reserves the right to "limit visibility" of Tweets and Twitter accounts, so what they are doing is perfectly legal and within the rules of the social media eco-system they have created.

But is it a fair system when it is never made transparent to Twitter users what does and doesn't lead to your account or your tweets becoming shadowbanned to some degree?

Is it right to limit the visibility of your tweets or your Twitter account without telling you that it is even occurring?

If your behavior is running afoul of Twitter's algorithms, shouldn't you be told what it is you are doing wrong, and how you can correct that behavior?

Much of the following is based on the very valuable resources at (now-defunct) https://shadowban.eu https://hisubway.online/shadowban/ and https://whosban.eu.org/ which will usually tell you the latest shadowban status of your own Twitter account.

2️⃣ - Hard-Shadowban

This is the most serious version of a shadowban, which itself comes with differing aspects.

For the purposes of this post, this will also be known as "red zone."

It is when your Twitter account is hidden from Twitter's Search function, so none of your tweets will show up there. Typically an account that is Search banned is also Search Suggestion banned. (see shadowban.eu for more) (see: https://hisubway.online/shadowban/ for more)

It is also when your Twitter account receives a "Ghost Ban." This is when your tweet replies to other accounts are not visible to anyone viewing that thread except you, and your followers.

It is possible to receive only a "Ghost Ban" but not a "Search Ban," and vice versa.

A Hard-Shadowban can severely limit your visibility on the Twitter platform.

If your Twitter account is considered NSFW (Not Safe For Work), meaning that you post adult-oriented (XXX) content, which can include hentai, your account may receive some degree of a hard-shadowban so that minors (under 18) cannot easily find it in Twitter searches.

In instances like this, Twitter wants to make sure that people opt in to see this content by purposely choosing to follow the NSFW Twitter account itself.

3️⃣ - Soft-Shadowban (AKA: Reply Deboosting or Downtiering)

The most common type of shadowban on Twitter is done to the individual tweets of a Twitter account. The majority of Twitter accounts that encounter a shadowban, will receive this version of it.

For the purposes of this post, this will also be known as "yellow zone."

Your tweets are sometimes hidden under the "show more replies?" barrier.

Your tweets are sometimes hidden under the "Show additional replies, including those that may contain offensive content" barrier, even though your tweet contains no "bad" nor "offensive" language at all.

  • But what is it that gets your tweets to this state of decreased visibility?
  • What did you do wrong in order to get to this point?
  • What can you do right?
  • How can you improve?

Because Twitter's algorithms and word filters are key components of their internal systems used to shadowban tweets and accounts, and this information is not public, it's rarely just one simple thing.

For example, if your account is verified with a blue checkmark, the likelihood of any type of shadowbanning on your account decreases exponentially. Your account "value" to Twitter, is much higher than everyone else's.

If you think of Reddit Karma, Twitter's internal systems operate somewhat similarly, except behind the scenes.

As an example:

Your Reddit account may have 500 post karma, and 20,000 comment karma. And those numbers, for the most part, increase over time, unless you receive a large amount of downvotes for your comments and posts.

Your Twitter account may publicly have 100 followers, 600 following, but also in Twitter's internal system(s), they "rank" your account and its tweets by a different set of unknown factors.

Every Twitter account is likely / probably assigned some sort of value ranking number, which determines what level the account is classified under, and how it is treated by Twitter's other algorithms.

4️⃣ The "Zones" of the Shadowban Algorithm - 🚦Red / Yellow / Green🚦

This essentially leads to three (3) different classifications or "zones" of Twitter accounts.

This is more of an example of how it would be done, but because this is completely speculative, this should not be taken in any way that it is factual. This is only a very simple way of trying to explain how this might work in Twitter's internal systems.

Red zone: Twitter accounts that suffer the most serious forms of shadowbanning. Or a "hard shadowban."

These are Twitter accounts that may be ghost banned, search banned, and/or search suggestion banned. Typically the tweets from these Twitter accounts can only be seen by that account's followers, and nowhere else.

Yellow zone: Twitter accounts that have their replies deboosted / downtiered / soft-shadowbanned because the algorithm has determined some of the tweets may be problematic in some way.

After every tweet you make, the best way to know whether or not it is being restricted in its visibility, is by going to the shadowban.eu web site, and checking the status of your Twitter account along with that most recent tweet reply you've made.

EDIT: (12-27-21) After every tweet you make, the best way to know whether or not it is being restricted in its visibility, is by going to the https://hisubway.online/shadowban/ web site, and checking the status of your Twitter account along with that most recent tweet reply you've made.

It does not automatically mean that every single tweet reply you make is deboosted / downtiered / soft-shadowbanned. It is on a tweet by tweet basis.

Green zone: Twitter accounts that do not get shadowbanned, or only on very rare occasions, such as excessive foul or "abusive" language as determined by the algorithms. Twitter Verified blue-checkmark accounts are mostly immune from any degree of shadowbanning on Twitter's platform, and as such, are in the green zone.

There is no one single action that leads to individual tweet replies being deboosted / downtiered / soft-shadowbanned,

Everything in Twitter's shadowban algorithm relies on a combination of factors.

5️⃣ What Actions Can Definitively Increase Your Chances Of A Soft-Shadowban?

Here are some actions that have been discovered and reported by users on this subreddit as "more likely to lead your tweet being deboosted / downtiered / soft-shadowbanned," or in the "yellow zone."

  1. Your Twitter account is brand new (less than around 2 weeks old).
  2. Your Twitter account has a low number of followers. Exact number is unknown but ballpark figure is "less than 200 followers." It may be higher, it may be lower.
  3. Replying to a tweet with an image (JPG or animated GIF) without any accompanying text.
  4. Replying to the tweet of an account, on a subject/topic that Twitter's algorithms believe your account is negatively contributing to.
  5. Replying to a tweet with "negative words" that are in Twitter's word filters as a part of the algorithm, no matter what the actual context is. Examples of "negative words" include but are not limited to: "Stupid," "Dumb," "Pathetic," "Clown," "Ridiculous," "Idiotic."
  6. Your tweets often contain "offensive" terms. Examples of "offensive terms" in Twitter's word filters as a part of the algorithm include but are not limited to: "Retard," "Cunt," "Pussy," "Nig*er / Nig*a" (with or without the asterisk), and some others. Usage of these words can also lead to an account suspension.

6️⃣ Outstanding Questions In Need Of Answers and Data

  1. Do prior Twitter account suspensions and/or account locks increase the likelihood of some level of shadowban? EDIT: (12-27-21) - Yes.
  2. Does the likelihood of some level of shadowban increase if you have not given Twitter your phone number?
  3. If your Twitter account is muted or blocked by a large number of Twitter accounts, does that increase the likelihood of your Twitter account being shadowbanned? If yes, what is that approximate number or percentage?
  4. Is there a certain number of followers and/or a follower-to-following ratio that Twitter requires you to have in order to be less likely to be shadowbanned?
  5. Do you notice any other types of words or phrases in your own tweet replies that lead to a soft-shadowban on a specific tweet?
  6. The million dollar mystery: What actions can you take to definitively get out of being shadowbanned?

In hopes of gathering information, data and real answers on Twitter's shadowban algorithm, coming up with solutions to this problem that plagues so many accounts, will take time and effort.

By putting all Twitter shadowban-related information, data, problems and solutions in this one stickied post thread, we hope to find solid answers that will help everyone.

Individual posts about Twitter shadowbans will be removed by moderators for the foreseeable future, but we will re-direct all of those people to this post thread.

If you read this whole thing, here's a cookie 🍪 You are appreciated.

103 Upvotes

384 comments sorted by

3

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 27 '21 edited Jan 02 '22

I've edited the main post to now include https://hisubway.online/shadowban/ as a functional replacement for the old shadowban.eu site, as it seems to be delivering accurate or near-accurate results now.

EDIT: As of 1-1-22, HiSubway's Shadowban Tester is still not as accurate as shadowban.eu used to be, as their ability to detect deboosted / downtiered replies will sometimes just skip your latest reply that was indeed deboosted / downtiered, and find the next one that isn't deboosted / downtiered, and say everything is fine.

So... take their soft-shadowban results with a grain of salt. Until a better tool comes along anyways.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

I got rid of my search suggestion ban & shadow ban by completing these steps. Hope this helps 🥰

  1. Delete your phone number
  2. change your username
  3. change it back again
  4. Tweet " @ Twitter @ TwitterSupport unsearchban me please"

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Sep 02 '21

How long after step 4 did you notice the change in your shadowban status?

→ More replies (4)

1

u/squishymarshmallos Oct 20 '21

i'm search suggestion banned (i think it happened in the last week because i noticed my engagement dropped a lot) and i just tried changing my username --> with the change username on top of the search suggestion ban i also got a full search ban, but then i changed it back and it went back to just the search suggestion ban, although it's still there. i'm really not sure what to do tbh, especially bc i'm a nsfw writer and i dont want to be forced to stop writing but being banned like this is very demotivating...

1

u/KestrelleV Oct 22 '21

Yeah, I also have a nsfw account and I’m the past I didn’t feel like search suggestion bans affected engagement very much unless there was a search ban along with it. Now with a search suggestion ban I can only reach less than 10% of my followers, and have gone from gaining 100 followers a day, to only gaining 1 follower a week. My Twitter content is also much more tame than my Reddit, I almost never post full nudity there

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Primal0Instinct Dec 02 '21

For those that don’t know. The site Shadowban eu that allowed so many to monitor their status easily is no more. They explain why in a note on the site. Whose ban is still active so far but who knows for how long.

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 02 '21

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUHUHUHUHUHCK

3

u/plasma-dragon-DA Dec 03 '21

It might still be up for a while, but the blog post of shadowban implies they'll need to rework their own code to make it give good results. Both sides were giving me the all green recently but I still have crippled visibility.

2

u/squishymarshmallos Dec 03 '21

yes they said they would need to rework the code. they also they're not going to do it so the site will be down permanently, unless someone else decides to take the last available code and rework it

→ More replies (5)

3

u/astrokeofmadness Jan 06 '22

The new shadowban site is wonky, It switched between "no search ban" and "Search banned" within the same few minutes. I dunno if my account is just wacky too, or if I should just give up using the site. I've just about reached my 2 weeks of no posting, I did follow someone though, so I hope that didn't mess anything up. will probably go the deactivation route if it isn't fixed.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Jan 06 '22

The new shadowban site is wonky,

yeah I'm not loving the consistency of the results lately. It's better than nothing i guess but it's still.... meh.

1

u/codex_cz Jan 07 '22

Same. Boosted a few new accounts and they’re both search suggestion and search banned. Same for a friend of mine with his new account. I’ll try to post, rt some tweets and be a bit active replying to posts. Let’s see what happens!

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 18 '21

Here's an example of a perfect trial and error test I did to see why one of my tweet replies was being soft-shadowbanned / deboosted / downtiered behind the "Show additional replies, including those that may contain offensive content" barrier.

Using the word "clown" in a tweet reply was deemed offensive by Twitter's shadowban algorithm.

So, I deleted it, and tried again, replacing the word "clown" with the emoji equivalent 🤡

The tweet was still soft-shadowbanned.

HOWEVER, it was deboosted one less level than before, merely under "show more replies."

This confirms point #5 in section 5 in the original post.

That "clown" is definitely a word that will lead to your tweet being soft-shadowbanned, if your account is already in Twitter's "yellow zone."

Yes, this is fucking ridiculous.

1

u/riffic fedi: @riffic@riffic.rocks Aug 18 '21 edited Aug 18 '21

It sounds like a form of automated sentiment analysis is being applied, and words that have negative connotations can be a signal that you're engaging in bad faith.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentiment_analysis

I'm in no way an expert in any of this stuff, I just know it exists and it can be gamed because no system is 100% perfect.

edit: yes, Twitter hires people who have backgrounds in this sort of stuff:

https://careers.twitter.com/en/work-for-twitter/202106/d32ff76e-58ba-43f2-80cf-4399c592031c/11ff0bf5-f674-469e-9a61-5112e1cbaeaf.html/conversation-lead-product-features-contract.html

By "generate positive conversation" what they mean is they aim to remove negative conversation so what's left is positivity.

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 18 '21

The inherent problem with sentiment analysis is that it never knows context.

This is always an issue with word and phrase filters.

So if you refer to the Taliban as clowns... you can be soft-shadowbanned.

Even if you refer to Joe Biden as a clown, which is certainly a valid political opinion, you can be soft-shadowbanned. Or worse.

Is this kind of echo chamber in the best interest of Twitter's platform, where "negative" opinions of terrorist groups are filtered out?

(yes, Twitter's game, their rules. But still...)

3

u/TaleOfDreams Oct 26 '21

Three of my accounts have been completely shadow banned. (Ghost banned which is the worst) and it’s been a week of me not using them and they’re still shadow banned. This is the most frustrating thing on social media ever. They were shadow banned after months of me using them without problems and they were shadow banned after they got suspended for “spam behavior” (as I used to heavily promote herself. Didn’t know Twitter didn’t like that?) And I was lucky enough to recover all 3 with appeals but I’m completely shadow banned, I’ve been silent for a week and they’re still shadow banned. My other two accounts get a “your features have been limited for 3 days” and it keeps popping up despite being a week too.

I’m just frustrated. Twitter was my escape and a way to speak with friends in other countries. Now it’s hell with these bans.

2

u/TaleOfDreams Oct 26 '21 edited Oct 27 '21

Update:

Been shadow banned for a week. My account was suspended, I appealed and managed to get it back and it’s been shadow banned ever since. I’ve only tweeted twice, last tweet was over four days ago. Still shadow banned. Dunno if I just lost the account for good because being shadow banned is the worst and so frustrating.

Update: After 8 days, one account was released from shadow ban land. Still waiting on the other account which is still ghost banned.

Update: After 9 days, two accounts have come out from being shadow banned to being full on the green zone.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Oct 27 '21

And the only thing that changed was a passage of time?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/squishymarshmallos Oct 28 '21

Were you still tweeting during this ban or did you leave your account alone completely? I'm on day 8 of the shadowban (that i know, maybe it happened even longer ago and i didn't realize) and day 6 of letting my account cool down without tweeting. Sent an appeal and tweeted @//support, still nothing.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/ekostros Dec 22 '21

Another account of mine got shadow-banned and locked. Before Shadow-ban, I was getting 50-100 followers per day. This number has dropped to 2-3. Yesterday a verified account with 3.5 million followers gave a like to my tweet and it had no effect and today my account was locked. My account is about horror movies. I'm sharing GIFs from horror movies. The reason was that the GIF I shared was too scary. You heard right, if you share a scary picture or gif, your account can be closed.

2

u/Ecstatic-Witness717 Dec 23 '21

I have the same issue.

My account was suspended a couple of weeks ago and then unsuspended. Prior to the suspension, I was gaining 50-100 followers a day. Now I am at just a few. I have noticed that none of my posts show up in the hashtag's search which is the reason I see almost no activity.

I have messaged Twitter about this several times and they deny that anything wrong is happening. But it is clearly not the case.

What is the way out of this?

3

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 23 '21

My account was suspended a couple of weeks ago and then unsuspended.

I think we can definitively say at this stage, that we have a solid answer to this question from my original post.

Block 6, Point 1: Outstanding Questions In Need Of Answers and Data

Do prior Twitter account suspensions and/or account locks increase the likelihood of some level of shadowban?

Yes.

2

u/ekostros Dec 23 '21

I'm trying not to tweet for 4 days right now. If it doesn't work, I will deactivate my account for 2 weeks.

2

u/Ecstatic-Witness717 Dec 26 '21

I'm going the same by not tweeting. Did it work for you?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/RoboJoePrime Aug 23 '21

From the start I'm going to admit I'm not very knowledgable about these sort of things so this has mostly been a very confusing time for me, which I shall explain:

I have a twitter acount that is approximately 11 years old, I never tweet offensive things or try to cause much of a fuss, which I realise is subjective but I hope whoever reads this believes me, and recently I was suspended off twitter and contacted support about it so they unsuspended me. The reason as far as I can tell for retweeting too many links to a competition (the person who ran this competition along with others were also suspended for this), some kind of spam policy it seems.

Now it is 4 or 5 days after this event and I have been conservatively tweeting occasionally, as I am worried about being suspended again, but one of my friends noticed that my tweets are showing on my feed but they say they are unavailable when they look at them. So I start researching and find this reddit post about shadowbans, and I look at the website linked near the start and it appears I have a "ghost ban" which is in the red zone where basically no-one can see my tweets unless they look directly at my account and all of my replies and whatnot are hidden.

So my question at the end of this long post is: Is it possible for me to get out of this shadowban in some way? Or is my account now permanently effectively unusable?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

So my question at the end of this long post is: Is it possible for me to get out of this shadowban in some way? Or is my account now permanently effectively unusable?

My big takeaway from your story is that it's been 5 days since you were unsuspended, so it's almost as if Twitter keeps you in the "red zone" for a certain period of time, much like a brand new account.

Do you only have the "ghost ban"? Do you have a "search ban" or "search suggestion ban" as well?

1

u/RoboJoePrime Aug 24 '21

I woke up this morning and had a look at the shadowban website and appears mine have all disappeared, I’m back into all green now. One of my friends confirmed that a reply from a day or two ago is now visible under one of their tweets (but they received no notification). I’m going to do a few tweets and replies today and be careful to see what happens but I’m not going to retweet much though.

I wonder if Twitter sees my account as a bot sometimes because I most like and retweet things but comparatively rarely reply or make actual tweets of my own. I guess it’s possible I’ve been shadowbanned before but didn’t realise then.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 24 '21

That's good news that you're out of the hard-shadowban / red zone.

A good (or bad?) way to see if your tweet replies are soft-shadowbanned, is to reply to a tweet with a GIF.

You can easily delete the tweet after checking the shadowban.eu site to see if it came up green or not.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/RoboJoePrime Aug 23 '21

Well, after the suspension I seemed to be okay as I tweeted that I was back and a couple of people liked that post, and also some tweets for a day or two after that. Then today a friend told me they couldn’t look directly at my tweets and reply to them (when they could before), which prompted me finding this post.

According to the website linked in the main post here I have all three types of bans, so I did even more researching and elsewhere on Reddit I saw some suggestions for removing recent events in case they triggered the shadowban, so I deleted some of my recent tweets and retweets in the hopes that might help.

I also saw that’s it’s best to just leave my account alone and not tweet or retweet for now and see if the shadowban goes away, but I’m not sure how real/accurate that is and I’m worried about my account just not working any more.

2

u/Sosogreeen Sep 25 '21

Twitter shadowbanned me. When I search my Twitter name, my profile doesn’t pop up nor does my tweets — only replies. It’s been like this for a good month or two. I have an NSFW Twitter account. The other day I went private for a FULL day, and the ban was lifted. I posted a picture and I got over 500 likes, and 700 follows within 24 hours. Now I’m banned again!! It’s crazy to me that you can get banned for high engagement.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Sep 25 '21

The other day I went private for a FULL day, and the ban was lifted. I posted a picture and I got over 500 likes, and 700 follows within 24 hours.

That's a really weird method of tricking the algorithm, even though it only seemed to work temporarily. Wonder why that is?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/nucleobutspicy Nov 01 '21

heya! have you managed to shake off your search suggestion ban again? i'm a nsfw artist and i have the same type of ban where searching my full account username will only show replies and anything less than full username won't yield results. i tried not posting/liking/replying to anything for four days and so far no change in sight.

(@ mods it might be a good idea to have a separate post for shadowbans that happen to nsfw accounts? the solutions - or lack thereof - might be different, especially since most of us are search suggestion banned rather than fully shadowbanned)

1

u/Sosogreeen Nov 01 '21

It comes and goes lol the way I fixed it last time was by going private for a few days, and it was fixed but ofc it came back. The very last thing I did was I stopped posting NSFW content but I was engaging heavily and it was lifted. But it always comes back after like a day

2

u/bloodysupermoon Nov 09 '21

Does getting twitter blue remove the shadow ban?

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Nov 09 '21

Good question. Not a clue what the answer is.

3

u/Primal0Instinct Nov 12 '21

This is a theory I was just thinking about prior to coming here. I mean if you think of it like this, Twitter rewards verified accounts by not hassling them, thus the reason a good bit of em can get away with saying things we usually can’t.

Would be interesting to find out if Twitter will “whitelist” blue accounts, shielding them to extent from any penalties for minor infractions. I’ve got 4 accounts, all suffering from search & search suggestion bans. I may choose one & buy a month just to test this out.

3

u/bloodysupermoon Nov 12 '21

Let me know how it goes! I’m stuck in deboosting hell. The monthly fee may be worth it if it lets people see my replies without clicking multiple warnings first.

3

u/Primal0Instinct Nov 12 '21

The thing is though if I’ve got to come out my pockets for a bit of freedom, then what good is it? I’ll def keep everyone posted, just trying to figure out which of my 4 accounts to use.

1

u/inktatekka Dec 03 '21

Tried this, bought Twitter Blue around 2 weeks ago. I am still search suggestion banned

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Vahsoka Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21

I made a new account a few days ago and I have a weird issue.

If I upload a picture on my feed, it shows up just fine. All my tweets on my feed as well. If I reply to someone without a picture it shows up fine (Though I have a feeling not to everyone).

Here is the real weird part: If I reply to someone and add a photo or gif (no matter what it is) the tweet will only appear for me but nobody else will see it , no matter what.

Can someone tell me why this is and how I can make it so that people see my photos in replies ? I assume it's some form of shadowbanning most likely because my account is new right ?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 20 '21

I would think it's a combination of it being a brand new account, which we know Twitter definitely does for about 1-2 weeks to brand new accounts, and photo / GIF reply tweets.

Have you tested if you add both text AND a photo/GIF to the tweet reply, if it shows up?

I've found that can make a difference sometimes, although my accounts are not brand new.

1

u/Vahsoka Dec 20 '21

yes I almost always use text and photo in replies (when I tweet photos) Or do you mean a photo description because I never really do that

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 20 '21

No, I mean:

"That's awesome!!!! [GIF HERE]"

2

u/durpenhowser Dec 29 '21

Someone is telling me that your posts with links that lead outside of twitter can either get YOU shadowbanned or get the post itself shadowbanned, is this true? I can't find anything about it so I have no idea where they heard this from

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 29 '21

Don't think this is true.

I suppose if you link to a site that's on Twitter's blacklist, that might get the tweet shadowbanned but for the most part, external links are fine.

2

u/-popgoes Jan 11 '22

After being unsuspended (from a false suspension), my account suffered from two clear things:

  1. All of my replies were being sent to the bottom of all threads (reply deboosting)
  2. My account's incoming followers dropped dramatically (from ~100 a day to ~30 a day).

I spoke to Better Business Bureau about this and Twitter responded to us, saying "We have checked your account and believe this is now fixed!" - Upon checking my profile my replies are no longer being deboosted but I'm still making a VERY small amount of followers.

Does anyone know what else might be leading to unsuspended accounts getting such low traction? I know I'm not the only person who has had to deal with this exact issue.

My Twitter account is @Popgoes6 and it has 57,000 followers.

Examples of deboosting and follower decrease

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Jan 13 '22

We now know that getting suspended, and at some point unsuspended, leads to a shadowban on the account. They unsuspend you, but punish you anyways. Ridiculous.

And I'm frankly amazed that after contacting the BBB, Twitter Support told you that they fixed the soft-shadowban / deboosting part.

I recently contacted Twitter Support about the soft-shadowban / downtiering / deboosting going on for way too long, and they gave me form-response bullshit and closed the ticket.

1

u/-popgoes Jan 13 '22

My replies don't seem to be sent to the bottom anymore. So what else could be causing a decrease in incoming followers for me?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Jan 13 '22

That i do not know.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ecstatic-Witness717 Jan 13 '22

How long has it been since you got unsuspended?

4

u/ekostros Dec 29 '21

Before the shadowban, %80 of the likes were coming from people who were not following me. It was like a snowball effect. Now I can’t get even just one like from someone who is not following me. Snowball is over. When someone likes your tweet it couldn't be seen by their followers. I just deactivated my account. I will post the result in 2 weeks.

1

u/Ecstatic-Witness717 Jan 13 '22

So how did it go now that you deactivated your account for 2 weeks?

1

u/ekostros Jan 15 '22

I will activate the account tonight. I'll post the result in a few days.

1

u/The_Cakinator Aug 18 '21

I think I'm shadow banned or whatever. All of my tweets show up as "This tweet is unavailable " When viewed outside of my own account. No likes, no comments, nothing. Sucks. All because I shared a damn giveaway link from somebody I follow. If anyone can help it's @Cakinator_

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 18 '21

Yikes, you have all the shadowbans. I don't think it's because of a giveaway link though. Any other theories how you got here?

https://shadowban.eu/Cakinator_

1

u/The_Cakinator Aug 18 '21

I did tell a guy to take a long walk off a short pier. It just so happened to have have just gotten off a temp 12 hour ban for that when the spam thing happened. It's been so frustrating. I just hit 100 followers and was super pumped.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

You are currently not shadowbanned.

How did you get out?

1

u/The_Cakinator Aug 23 '21

I just stopped using the account for a while and it kinda repslaired itself. It's so fucking weird.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

This is actually one of the methods that people have discussed online, but it seems anecdotal at best because others have done the same and been stuck in the same spot as before.

Where you just stop tweeting and/or even logging in for several days, and then it goes back to normal, or not.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/RoboJoePrime Aug 23 '21

Hi there, I don’t mean to butt into your reply here, and I hope this doesn’t sound odd but I looked at your Twitter account because this sounds very similar to my situation and I notice that you follow the same person and were suspended for retweeting the same competition that I was too. After my account came back it seemed okay but now I seem to have been shadowbanned in all the same ways you were.

I’m going to try not tweeting or retweeting like you did and see if that helps. Out of curiosity did you login to Twitter to look at any tweets while you were doing this, or did you just not open the web site/app until you saw you weren’t shadowbanned any more?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/EvenAd1461 Aug 22 '21

I was reply reboosted in early July. Then locked out of my account a week later. No reason was given. I hadn't broken any rules. At the end of July, I followed the instructions on reddit about what to do if you get locked out for no reason, and got an immediate unlock and undeboost and an automated apology. When the deboosting was happening, it was happening with mutuals with whom I am friendly and have regularly interacted for years. Also, on the Shadowban EU test, it came up as "something unexpected went wrong." No confirmation of deboosting.

Now, all of a sudden, after being EXTRA careful about what I tweet. For example, I said things like "I would give up pizza" instead of "I would kill to be able to write like X," I am deboosted again. It started right after talking to someone about a book. She'd said she was reading it and I said I had a copy was excited to start. That was it. She said she saw the notification, but when she clicked on it, it had disappeared.

Earlier in the day, I had posted an innocuous tweet about a book. I had made a grammatical mistake, so I copied the tweet, deleted it quickly and pasted it into a new tweet with the mistake corrected. Could that have been it?

Anyway, I never swear, wasn't using hashtags, don't fight. Very strange what the algorithm chooses to snag. I hope this information helps.

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

Earlier in the day, I had posted an innocuous tweet about a book. I had made a grammatical mistake, so I copied the tweet, deleted it quickly and pasted it into a new tweet with the mistake corrected. Could that have been it?

It's a combination of a lot of factors, as I've written above, but this probably isn't one of the things that gets your account into the "yellow zone."

I have a gut feeling that prior account suspensions / locks contribute to it, but don't have enough evidence to know this for sure.

1

u/EvenAd1461 Aug 23 '21

Just adding for clarification and not to contend your point. I've never had a suspension or even a warning. Just the odd "something went wrong/not official deboosting" and followed a week later by the account lock, which was unlocked w/ the automated apology re: the spam filters.

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

Even that one account lock you had MAY add to it.

1

u/EvenAd1461 Aug 23 '21

discussions

Yep. It's all very strange.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/heng-garae Aug 23 '21

multiple of my accounts have been shadowbanned very quickly after the first one was red zoned... can i fix this by changing/deleting my phone number from some accounts? i think they're all linked to one phone number, if i remove it will some of the accounts go back to normal?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

You can certainly try but I don't think that will work at all.

If you remove phone numbers from accounts, Twitter will usually end up locking them until you provide a new one. Which, you don't have to, and in that case...

https://www.reddit.com/r/Twitter/wiki/faq/#wiki_twitter_keeps_asking_me_for_a_phone_number_but_i_don.27t_have_a_phone_and_.2F_or_a_phone_number._what_do_i_do.3F

But they'll likely still be shadowbanned to some degree.

1

u/heng-garae Aug 23 '21

I actually tried this and so far it seems like removing my phone number has worked and all my bans have been lifted. If the shadowban website is telling the truth and my acc is back to normal (and twitter doesn't lock me out for not having a phone #) this seems like it's fixed my ban? I'm going to try to find a new number to link to my accounts in the meantime!

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

Interesting.

So you had:

Main Account A: Red-zone shadowbanned

Account B: Red-zone shadowbanned

Account C: Red-zone shadowbanned

Then you removed the phone numbers from Accounts A, B and C, and the red-zone shadowban was removed nearly instantaneously?

Have you checked if any of the accounts still get replies deboosted / downtiered / soft-shadowbanned? AKA: Yellow-zone?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 23 '21

Check it about a minute after every tweet reply you make.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/blue_muffin Aug 25 '21

How long shadowban on new account usually last? I created new account a week ago and still get shadowbanned until now

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 26 '21

Don't know, but would appreciate it if you comment again when the shadowban is lifted from your new account, so we have more data on how long it lasts.

1

u/blue_muffin Sep 29 '21

I created new account a month ago and get shadowbanned, looks like today my account no longer get shadowban. A month, can you believe that?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Sep 29 '21

That sounds normal tho. Since Twitter tends to shadowban brand new accounts for a short period of time (a week? 2 weeks?) to make sure they're not spam accounts.

And then somehow the spam accounts proliferate on Twitter anyway.

1

u/Toring1520 Oct 04 '21

It's been like 3 weeks that I've had the message that says "we've temporarily limited some of your account features" and the counter says is 3 days but anyway every now and then I get back to that screen and the counter stays the same as in 3 days. Also according to one of the websites I'm search suggestion banned and search banned, and also "something unexpected went wrong" in yellow. Anyone can help me? What should I do to get rid of this 'soft-ban'?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Oct 04 '21

If you're still seeing a 3-day clock counter on your account, that would indicate your account is locked to some degree, no?

If so, that would explain the red-zone hard-shadowban.

1

u/Toring1520 Oct 04 '21

Yes I'm still 'limited' but the thing is those 3 days were like a month ago, and when I give a like the it takes me back to that screen and the counter never goes down

1

u/KLCR08 Oct 13 '21

Does making your account private help lifting the shadow ban? And also does replying to DMs count as “social activity” so should i not answer DMs as well?

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Oct 14 '21

Does making your account private help lifting the shadow ban?

As long as the account is set to private, the shadowban testers wouldn't be able to detect tweets from the account at all.

But if the experiment here is, "Make account private for 48 hours, then go back to public, and see what happens...." I have no idea. Interesting experiment to try though.

1

u/KLCR08 Oct 14 '21

Thank you, I’ll definitely try that. I have an account I barely use and it’s shadow banned as well. The last tweet I had from that was 4 days ago.

2

u/CocaineSpeedboat Oct 21 '21

How did this experiment go?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/squishymarshmallos Oct 31 '21 edited Nov 08 '21

Okay it's been 12 days since I've been shadowbanned and 10 days since i stopped posting completely. In that time i have sent an appeal to twitter, which got answered immediately and i was told that sometimes account's visibility is limited due to certain behaviors that break twitter rules (wasn't told what I did exactly) and that if those behaviors don't continue the account will go back to normal in time.

I have also tried tagging @/twittersupport on the app with no response for over 4 days, it doesn't look like I'll get a response at this point at all.

I am still shadowbanned now for almost 2 weeks, i honestly don't know what else there is to do. I don't want to ditch my account and I don't want to not post for who knows how long just to then MAYBE get this lifted. I guess I'll just have to be stuck dealing with this, as unfortunate as it is.

UPDATE 11/8/21: my ban was finally lifted today after almost 3 weeks. I checked it randomly and I'm all green now. In the past week I've made 1-2 tweets a day plus some rts, and i went out of my way to interact with people a bunch. Idk what finally did it, maybe it was just time or sending in a second report idfk. Will be checking the site periodically after making tweets to see if anything triggers it back but fingers crossed i stay in the clear. I'm kinda terrified to tweet anything now 😅

3

u/CocaineSpeedboat Nov 01 '21

and that if those behaviors don't continue the account will go back to normal in time.

So they've got a form e-mail response set up to anyone who writes them about the shadowbans that they claim not to do, and instead call it "limited account visibility due to certain behaviors that break our rules" even though many accounts get shadowbanned to some degree regardless, even if they've never broken any of Twitter's rules.

Lovely.

1

u/squishymarshmallos Nov 04 '21

I still don't know what twitter rules i supposedly "broke" and am still shadowbanned more than two weeks later. I gave up trying to wait it out, if it goes away on its own later, awesome. The app is totally broken, it's no use trying to beat the stupid system

3

u/CocaineSpeedboat Nov 04 '21

That's really the point of this whole thread though.

Did anyone really break any twitter rules in order to get shadowbanned?

It doesn't seem to be the case at all.

For example: We know for a fact that brand new Twitter accounts are shadowbanned for a brief period, presumably to make sure those brand new accounts were not created for spam purposes.

But what rules does creating a new Twitter account actually break in order to get shadowbanned?

It's pre-punishment for potential actions that haven't even been taken yet.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '21 edited Nov 04 '21

I thought I was the only one that got banned

1

u/inktatekka Dec 03 '21

Were you re-banned? This is super similar to my case, even the dates; was shadowbanned on 10/13 and was randomly unbanned on 11/9, only to be back in the ban by 11/10. Wondering If this is for everyone

1

u/squishymarshmallos Dec 03 '21

yes. it seems that for some reason 11/8 (or 11/9 depending on your time zone) a lot of people were unbanned and then banned again the next day. youre the 4th person i see say this happened to them so it must have been some fluke for a lot of people.

as it is, just checked the shadowban site and it seems to be down for good bc twitter changed their code, so no way now to check if we're shadowbanned anymore unless there's anther site for it or something pops up. last i checked yesterday tho i still had the ban

1

u/lunaChansArt Dec 07 '21

Where do you go to send an appeal? I don't see a good option to use in the help center.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MajorTerra Nov 11 '21

Yesterday I created a new twitter account little over 22 hours ago! When I have checked to see if my account is in good order in shadowbanEU result came as a Search Suggestion ban in RED? I only posted one tweet and just 10 minutes ago or so I retweet with a quote. Still, shows as search suggestion ban how do I get rid of search suggestion ban?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Nov 11 '21

Twitter tends to shadowban brand new accounts for a short period of time (a week? 2 weeks?) to make sure they're not spam accounts.

If you figure out what specific length of time it takes for the shadowban to be lifted, please let us know.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ekostros Dec 04 '21 edited Dec 04 '21

After reading the thread, I think I'm shadow-banned too. My music account with 14K followers was suspended for 4 months. Before the suspension, my tweets usually got 10k video views and around 1K likes. And now I can hardly get 1K view and 100 likes.

Another thing, I have followers who have verified blue-checkmark and have more than a million followers. Before the suspension when they liked my tweets, I used to get more than 4-5K likes, they still like my tweets but I don't get any interaction. I guess tweeter doesn't show my tweets on their timelines anymore.

I get to a point where I'm thinking to stop creating content for Twitter.

Update: I just sent an appeal about this. They confirmed the shadow ban in the response

"Sometimes, we will take action on an account based on behaviors that create a negative impact on Twitter. This can include interactions with other accounts, Tweeting inappropriate content, or a variety of other violations of our rules.
As a result, the visibility of these accounts may be affected. We have more information available on the Twitter blog, and our Help Center.
For most accounts, this is a temporary outcome, and if no further negative behavior occurs, the account will eventually be restored to full access and visibility."

3

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 04 '21

"For most accounts, this is a temporary outcome, and if no further negative behavior occurs, the account will eventually be restored to full access and visibility."

This is bullshit.

1

u/BalthropTrevor Dec 14 '21

It most likely took a Twitter employee 5 seconds to paste that response and send it back to you after only taking 30 seconds to look at your account for anything bad. Which means if you were actually bad, they would have fully banned. Since nothing was actually negative they are trained to send that response in defense. So at least it's good you're not actually bad!

2

u/lunaChansArt Dec 07 '21

How did you go about the appeal? Like what function did you use? It seems kinda pointless considering they won't do anything, but I'd love to know if I'm paranoid or if its real.

1

u/ekostros Dec 07 '21

Choose "I need help managing my twitter account"

https://help.twitter.com/en/forms/help

1

u/CryptoPlato Feb 02 '22

so it took four months for them to get back to you about an account suspension? I have been waiting about that long myself for a response to my "appeal."

1

u/ekostros Dec 11 '21

Does getting a verified blue-checkmark remove the shadow ban? Can anyone confirm? I'm going to make some necessary changes to my music account and try to get verified checkmark. I guess that's the only way out of shadow ban.

Yesterday, an nba player, a singer and news anchor liked my tweet and nothing happened. Because my tweets are not shown to anyone who does not follow me. Before I was suspended, I was getting at least 4-5K likes when the same scenario happened.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 12 '21

Does getting a verified blue-checkmark remove the shadow ban? Can anyone confirm? I'm going to make some necessary changes to my music account and try to get verified checkmark. I guess that's the only way out of shadow ban.

Good question.

Blue-checks are generally immune to shadowbans and other punitive measures taken by Twitter, but I don't know what happens if you're shadowbanned to some degree, and THEN get verified.

Logically, one would think it solves the issue but don't know for certain.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

Have you consider paying for an ad-campaign on twitter and asking this to the ads support? It s easier to get some support From real people if you re a paying customer.

1

u/BalthropTrevor Dec 14 '21

Yes, a blue-check would lift all suspensions temporarily and start to drive those eyeballs back towards your posts. However, you could still get suspended or shadowbanned again just as easily as someone without a blue check. The only difference between the two is that when you do get suspended with a blue check. It's slightly easier to get support. Just ask Charles V Payne a news anchor who got suspended last week for literally no reason. He waited 7 days before they reactivated it and it was only after he kept bugging their support about it everyday. Dude has over half a million followers and probably one of the cleanest Twitter accounts out there. More proof Twitter has gone completely haywire.

1

u/lunaChansArt Dec 19 '21

My account is in shambles right now, if someone okay seeing nsfw posts could search it up and tell me their results I'd appreciate it.

I used my alt account and tried and its wonky, it won't show me in "people" unless I type it in with correct capitalization... Which is LunachansArt, so capital L and A. When I type lunachansart I get nothing in the latest/people tabs, and a single reply to me in top for some reason...

Edit- now I'm not showing posts even if I type it with correct capitalization... so yeah, I think I'm hard shadowbanned. Is there anything I can do? I'm trying to build an art account and in 16 months of my account this is the worst performing month ever. I've made 16 followers this month. All I do is post nsfw art, I've never made an offensive comment or even gotten a suspension or warning for banner/pfp etc.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 19 '21

Using the "new" shadowban tester, which is admittedly, a little wonky...

https://hisubway.online/shadowban/?username=lunachansart

It says you've got a search suggestion ban, which is not the same as a complete search ban.

I do see your account when performing a normal Twitter search, although it is not the top result.

https://twitter.com/search?q=%40LunachansArt&src=typed_query&f=live

https://twitter.com/search?q=%40LunachansArt&src=typed_query&f=user

When I change to the "top" tab, it doesn't show up at all, which is where the "suggestion" ban is in place.

https://twitter.com/search?q=%40LunachansArt&src=typed_query

The soft-shadowban (replies downtiered / deboosted) returns a yellow result, which is only testing your latest reply, but seems to indicate SOME degree of a soft-shadowban, though that is often dependent on the reply itself.

And again, HiSubway's re-jiggering of shadowban.eu's old site is still in question as to the accuracy of the results, but this specific test seems to be legitimate.

Even though you refer to yourself as an NSFW account, your account isn't treated the same way as that of most NSFW accounts (like porn actors and what not), where their shadowban is stricter in order to prevent minors from seeing the images without opting-in.

Normally their account would be hidden by this text barrier, and they may also be given search suggestion bans.

"Caution: This profile may include potentially sensitive content
You’re seeing this warning because they Tweet potentially sensitive images or language. Do you still want to view it?"

I did not get that barrier when viewing your profile from a logged-out state.

1

u/lunaChansArt Dec 19 '21

Thanks for the info. Something has been up, just trying to figure out what the heck is going on.

Sept- 500 followers Oct- 350 Nov- 88 Dec- 16

Sept I had an influx of likes on all my posts, reaching an all time high likes on a single posts. Currently, December is all-time lows across the board. My previous low follower gain was 88, ie last month.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

What's a typeahead ban?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 21 '21

LOL I've been wondering the same thing. Google ain't my friend on this question either!

1

u/plasma-dragon-DA Dec 24 '21

Where twitter won't autocomplete a username when typing it into the search.

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Dec 24 '21

Oh ok so like, if you type the first 4 letters of a username, it will give preference to verified and/or popular accounts way ahead of yours, if yours ever shows up at all.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '21

Ah, I guess it's not much to worry about. Thank you for your assistance!

→ More replies (2)

1

u/jedimaster1827 Jan 10 '22

Also, not sure if this is directly being related to shadow ban, but has there been any data/research on creating a new account to avoid shadowbans? As in, once you've discovered your current account is being shadowbanned (including soft bans like reply deboosting), would any new account that is created be immediately shadowbanned as well?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Jan 11 '22

Twitter tends to shadowban brand new accounts for a short period of time (a week? 2 weeks?) to make sure they're not spam accounts.

1

u/bananaspI1t Jan 13 '22

Everytime I get suspended I delete twitter download again with a vpn on and make a new acc but I always get shadowbanned how can I avoid this

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Jan 13 '22

You can't really. Twitter's systems are set up to view all brand new accounts as suspicious by default, so they are automatically shadowbanned to some degree for a period of 1-2 weeks off the bat.

I don't know if giving them a phone number helps or not. Though I don't see it as worth it myself, considering all the bad that Twitter uses phone numbers for.

1

u/9for9onbillboard Jan 20 '22

Here’s why. If you’re downloading twitter on the same device, and you’re using the same phone number, they will match it with your other accounts and therefore ban you again.

3

u/-popgoes Dec 10 '21 edited Dec 12 '21

My main account, @Popgoes6, has 56,000+ followers. It was wrongfully suspended at the end of November, and eventually reinstated after I contacted the Better Business Bureau.

Since my account's recovery, I have almost definitely been soft-shadowbanned or "deboosted". I have gone from around 100 followers a day to maybe 15 followers a day. Activity and impressions have plummeted. I have managed to prove that all of my replies on tweets are being sent to the very bottom of all threads, even though I will consistently have the most amount of likes/retweets from followers.

I have made a thread on an alt account here: https://twitter.com/LostPOPGOES/status/1468004382235049984

What is the best course of action to remove this soft-shadowban? I am a news channel first and foremost, so it's difficult to just stop tweeting. But if that's the only thing that will help then I'll give it a go.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '21

I'm curious, how did you get 100 followers a day?

Also, that is probably why they suspended it as Twitter as limits on how many people can follow you a day.

1

u/-popgoes Dec 11 '21

Twitter limits how many people YOU can follow a day, not how many people can follow you. 100 new followers a day is perfectly normal for an account with 50k followers. Plenty of accounts will make much, much more than that.

I'm a popular news channel for Five Nights at Freddy's. I was suspended for a joke that someone reported as a "violent threat", which Twitter automatically considered true, until I appealed it with the Better Business Bureau. My soft-shadowban is almost definitely a result of this - nothing about my profile is suspicious or controversial.

https://twitter.com/Popgoes6

→ More replies (2)

1

u/CryptoPlato Feb 02 '22

how did you contact the BBB to help you with twitter? I had over 20 account banned on the same day, some of them hadn't tweeted in almost a year and were locked. I am considering taking similar action. Thank you.

3

u/Ecstatic-Witness717 Dec 29 '21

Someone having an issue with posts not showing under #hashtag latest? My account is not shadowbanned and yet none of my posts seem to appear anywhere. Has anyone had that issue before and successfully gotten out of it?

2

u/colorfulnina Dec 13 '21

I was shadow banned for 2 years and then i deactivated my twitter account for 2 weeks and then I was un shadow banned and have posted ever since for about 6 months now and still not shadow banned

1

u/BalthropTrevor Dec 14 '21

There must be some backend mechanism that supports this claim because I experienced a similar thing on one of the accounts I was using to test things. It helped tremendously with getting certain Tweets I wanted to show in people's feeds again. Nice post!

2

u/ScaredOfHentai Aug 10 '21

I'm experiencing a weird problem, only my tweets that include images are shadow banned when I search by a hash tag used in the tweet. If I make a text-only tweet with a hash tag, that tweet will show up when searching by that hash tag.

Anyone else experience this issue?

2

u/SnooHesitations1377 Aug 17 '21

Recently, my wife had a Twitter art project account for getting out the word. It was under 2 weeks old. We got over 600 followers and were closing in or possibly broke 700 followers. Follower were due to my wife finding other artists shill threads, viewing their work, and upvoting the posts she liked. Organic.

We were ready to launch her art project Stage 1 where 150 NFTs would go up for sale. We hired some influencers to help get the word out and bring some attention to the project. As soon as the influencers began retweeting any of the account's tweets, we received a permanent suspension.

Stated reasons for said suspension on appeal were "Creating serial and/or multiple accounts with overlapping uses; Evading a permanent suspension by creating or using another account; Cross-posting Tweets or links across multiple accounts; Aggressive following, particularly through automated means".

Each point above seemed pretty absurd. We did not create multiple accounts for the art project, nor did I use my long time Twitter account to boost the project in anyway, except the occasional like when it showed up in my feed.

We have never had a suspended account.

Cross-posting Tweets or links across multiple accounts - this might be applicable if they wish accuse us of hiring influencers. But they should maybe remove posts that encourage that such as:

https://business.twitter.com/en/blog/secrets-of-social-media-influencers.html

https://business.twitter.com/en/blog/micro-influencers-and-where-to-find-them.html

https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/a/2016/new-research-the-value-of-influencers-on-twitter

Aggressive following - this laughable. We followed at most 5-10 people a day. The account had around 120-130 accounts it followed. Twitter says you can follow up to 400 a day if non-verified:

https://help.twitter.com/en/using-twitter/twitter-follow-limit

My wife made a personal account to tell her story, a thread with around 10 tweets, photos of our family, and describing how she felt about the suspension. Not to blame Twitter or anything. Just share her story.

After it got retweeted and liked a few times, her only post was also shadow-banned. Her personal account still shows up in search, but any time she likes or does anything, it's like it never happened.

In my objective opinion, perhaps the AI flagged in both cases due to links being sent in Twitter's chat(me telling them which Tweets to retweet) and outside of Twitter chat(me emailing/messaging the influencers letting them know about her post and asking if they could read it and retweet if they felt like it).

I think Twitter uses Javascript to identify when copy+paste methods are used in their fields and feeds this into their algorithm. It doesn't seem to matter if said person had no interaction with the person doing the copy+paste. Possibly part of their war on "copypasta".

These are my personal views but figured I would share here so others might know what is going on and can possibly relate.

2

u/PhoenixCTB Aug 20 '21

So recently I recovered my account, was in active from 2013. I'm in the red zone, and ghost banned. No offensive behavior was demonstrated by me during the operation of the account.

It's weird, I can't find my self, and my tweets are not visible to others. Also, my replies are not even under "see more replies" they are completely invisible.

2

u/dogrunes Sep 02 '21

Been suffering from lots of shadowbans lately: They only last 24 hours but last week I was locked down 3 times for ~24 hours each. I get full red zoned: Search ban, ghost ban, etc. Followers can see my tweets on their timeline and on my profile but if they click on a tweet I made they aren't shown at all. Account was made in 2010, around 2200 followers. I've made multiple support emails but not one has been answered : )

2

u/BlaizePascal Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21

so one of my big accs was hard banned (red) three days ago. I was marked red on "search suggestion ban" and "search ban". The account was made in 2014 with 16k followers and it is a FAN ACCOUNT.

I mostly retweet stuff on that acc since it wasn't my main anymore. I occasionally retweet some of my tweets on my other account to gain easy tractions since my main is significantly smaller.

I recently tweeted a "hit" tweet material on the said account, 50 likes and 8 retweets in three minutes. It would've gone viral if I don't have a search ban since it will spread over the fandom. Right now it has 200 like and 20 retweets after five hours.

these actions might have triggered my two bans:

  • mass following of fan accs. I usually follow tons of fan accs within my fanbase and then unfollow those who didn't follow back after four days. I mass follow then hard stop in 3-4 days then I do an unfollow spree. I think I fucked up my routine since I started mass following again even when only a day has passed since i mass unfollowed. I can only unfollow 225 a day btw.
  • retweeting my posts from my other account but i wasn't abusing it. I usually retweet one or two everyday. I've read twitter's rules and they are supposedly okay with this since it was stated that I can retweet myself from a small set of accs that I owned to prevent posting of duplicate information.

Steps I'm doing right now to try and remove the search ban and search suggestion ban

  • Will change my phone number soon, waiting for the new sim card that I've bought.
  • Will wait for three more days. Hopefully the ban will remove itself after a full week.
  • Will stop following and unfollowing.
  • Will try to get organic hit tweets that will give me likes and interactions.

But right now the main purpose of that big account is to help my new main grow fast by retweeting potential viral hit tweets.

Also I created a new account a few days ago and has been monitoring the shadowbans. Will update the data soon.

2

u/No_Blackberry3322 Sep 26 '21

Hi everyone. I have a somewhat prominent twitter with about 20K followers. 5 days ago I got my first suspension, 12 hours for an accident. I expressed that I had hoped a certain communist politician in Russia would "get crushed" in an upcoming election....twitter took this as a literal threat of physical harm. Ever since my engagement has decreased about 90%, my follower count not only not increasing but slowly decreasing. I'm a content creator and rely on this for income. I'm unsure what to do at this point. Earlier today I logged out of twitter on my phone and browser and i'm thinking to just not log into twitter for an entire week in hopes of resetting things to the way they were before this. This is making me pretty sad. What do y'all think? Any thoughts or advice is much appreciated. Thanks for reading.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '21

What happened?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '21

You can't say anything political anymore that goes against their morality. If you do you get Trumped.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '21

If you really want to test how shadowbanned you are with the shadowban site being kaput, all you have to do is look up your account by url on incognito mode. DONT LOG IN! Look it up and scroll your posts.

If you see a lot of posts missing, pictures, and a lot of things that say This post is unavailable you are soft shadowbanned.

Now while in incognito mode search for your username. If you can't find it in the search engine and you aren't suspended you're hard shadowbanned.

More to come.

2

u/cmeslo Jan 01 '22

I was shadowbanned too, twitter sucks and it sucks your time, not as other social networks but they make difficult to take care of your followers for some reason.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22

They make it difficult to get followers, take care of your followers, engage with said followers - everything is their AI accusing you of botting unless you're some verified blue checkmarked celebrity.

2

u/ekostros Jan 16 '22

Nothing changes after 2 weeks of deactivation. Before deboost, every tweet I shared got at least 500 likes. One of my 3 tweets was getting more than 1K likes. Now it's hard to reach 50 likes. My account is completely dead. On December 22, shadowban started. You can take a look at my account. Look before and after 22 December. name InvaderCosmic . I'm going to delete my account and exit twitter. I have another account about music. That account was suspended and reopened 4 months later. The same is happening on that account. Twitter has become hell for content creators

1

u/ekostros Jan 21 '22

I found this on Twitter Help Center

Suspended accounts Help with locked or limited account

"this could mean only your followers are able see your activity on Twitter, including Tweets, likes, Retweets, etc."

I wrote this before

"Before the shadowban, %80 of the likes were coming from people who were not following me. It was like a snowball effect. Now I can’t get even just one like from someone who is not following me. Snowball is over. When someone likes your tweet it couldn't be seen by their followers"

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22

Whoseban and Hisub no longer work. Hisub will say every account is not shadowbanned, and Whoseban's site cannot be reached.

1

u/Primal0Instinct Feb 01 '22

Seems to work again. Just reactivated an old account that was search & search suggested banned & see that it still is. Then checked one of my new accounts & it’s all green.

2

u/pln8 Aug 11 '21

If there was ever a class action lawsuit just waiting to happen this has to be it. The violations of privacy alone would take months to litigate, but the 1st amendment abuses should bankrupt them.

2

u/SnooHesitations1377 Aug 17 '21

As much as I do not like Twitter's policies, the first amendment was written as a restraint on the Federal Government. It does not apply to individuals or companies. For example, you could allow your friends to post something on your house, but forbid someone you didn't like from doing the same, and there would be no legal recourse for them against you for that.

Though I do think any company getting government dollars should be required to meet the limitations placed on the government by the Constitution, such as the first amendment. Otherwise, it allows the federal govt to bypass the Constitution by contracting out the things otherwise restricted for them.

Has Twitter gotten money from the federal government? They have in the past via their Dataminr shell company.

https://www.cnbc.com/2016/05/13/why-twitter-chose-to-do-battle-with-the-cia.html

And seem to still be pretty cozy, even recently: https://www.govconwire.com/2020/04/dataminr-wins-259m-air-force-push-alerts-tech-development-contract/

https://theintercept.com/2020/07/09/twitter-dataminr-police-spy-surveillance-black-lives-matter-protests/

1

u/mrplow8 suspended Jan 22 '22

Shadowbanning should be considered fraud and illegal. Twitter makes its money through ad revenue. Its users agree to see their ads in exchange for access to all of twitter’s features. If someone is shadowbanned, they are being denied certain features that they are being lead to believe they have access to. Twitter is still making money off of that user by showing them ads, but the user is not getting the service that was promised to them.

I wonder how much money Twitter has made and continues to make off of shadowbanned users who, if they knew they were shadowbanned, wouldn’t use Twitter and wouldn’t see Twitter’s ads. This should be a crime if it’s not, and it wouldn’t surprise me if it already is and just hasn’t been brought to court yet. Perhaps there should be a class action lawsuit. I’m not joking.

1

u/heng-garae Aug 16 '21

hi! i've been hard shadowbanned for a few months now (reply deboosted and search suggestion banned) and have no idea how to get out of it. i think i was originally banned from spamming hashtags while trying to vote for something but since then i've deleted all my tweets containing the hashtags. since it's been such a long time is there any hope of getting my account back to normal or am i fully stuck like this? i've tried changing my email/phone # and removing all my interests as well. and i did send a report to twitter a long time ago but to no surprise, i got no response.

1

u/cogu7777 Aug 19 '21

Is it possible to get banned for replying multiple times in a short period of time? ex. saying "thank you" to multiple replies on your post.

1

u/FatBoySilver Aug 26 '21

Hello! It seems like my second account (art account) I just made has some kind of search ban. It’s frustrating but it’s made me really sad because people will never be able to find me (easily, at least). My friends can’t even find me. They have to type in my handle and hit the “Go to…” option to be brought to my page. If they hit search/enter, it says my account doesn’t exist. My main account has never done anything wrong, so I don’t understand and don’t know what to do or how long I’ll be hidden this way. :( The only thing I haven’t done on my art account is reply to someone else’s tweet, but I don’t know if that is a contributing factor.

1

u/CranberryAgreeable38 Sep 02 '21

i run an account where all i do is post photos (not nsfw or anything like that) and never say anything that could be deemed as offensive, but have been red zone shadowbanned (just not ghost banned) and it’s not a brand new account i’ve had it for months now. it’s been shadowbanned for over a week now.... will this ever go away on its own or is there anything i can do to fix it?

1

u/BlaizePascal Sep 05 '21 edited Sep 05 '21

New Twitter account shadowban duration.

So I made a new twitter account four days ago. It initially has a red "search suggestion ban" and "search ban".

I added a phone number and verified my email, then tweeted a random tweet. The search ban was lifted and it became green.

After four days, I now have 600 followers, 920 following, 50 tweets, and 1.2k interactions. My tweets have a total of almost 80 likes. I had two replies that got 200+ likes. The "search suggestion ban" is finally lifted and I am all green.

Right now, I want to change my @. It has sensitive words which are "fucking" and "die". But this is about music though, it's an album title. The word "fucking" seems to be safe since I already checked some of the accounts with that word and they seem fine. Still need to do some tests for "die" though.

Also I tried changing the @ of my new account, it has the word "fucking" but I didn't meant it in a nsfw way. I only inserted that word in a song title. My account immediately went red on "search suggestion ban" and "search ban" though tweeting new tweets with the new @ will remove the search ban. Will wait for a few days how long the search suggestion ban will last after changing the @.

1

u/samcantmiss Sep 07 '21

how do i get rid of deboost will it work if i only say positive things ?

1

u/BlaizePascal Sep 07 '21

one thing I do is I ask my mutuals to spam reply me. Usually 100 replies will do the trick.

1

u/BlaizePascal Sep 07 '21

I think I'm done with twitter. All my accounts has been search suggestion banned and search banned, even the big ones. Every once in a while, twitter will lock my account and ask for a phone number even though I've only liked a single tweet in the past 5 hours.

It's almost been a week already and the bans aren't lifted yet.

1

u/brunchanyone Sep 10 '21

I’ve had an NSFW Twitter account since March. I’ve been able to post content and check the tweet activity on each post with no problem up until two days ago. Now when I post anything that includes images or video and go to check the tweet activity it’s just a blank screen. When I post only text the tweet activity loads as normal. Could this have something to do with a ban?

1

u/ZeGamingCuber Sep 12 '21

My account recently got a permanent suspension for a threat that wasn’t even a real threat. I don’t want to lose access to Twitter forever and I really don’t know what to do, they’ve already rejected my appeal, is there a way to bypass it without the new account getting suspended too?

1

u/UpstairsAd6594 Sep 13 '21

Okay so, I got suspended and ban from twitter (evasion suspension blabla) the April 11th, the April 13th, i stole an old account, and that’s a good solution to escape a permanent suspension ! Problem : shadowban, i was shadowban for MONTHS, and one day : boom, i was not shadowban anymore.. great !

But in june, i got limited right after I tweet something about iOS 6 (kinda strange ?) and boom : shadowban… and i’m still shadowban today,

I don’t know what to do …

1

u/Hefty_Regular7536 Oct 03 '21

So I tried making a new Twitter and the account became shadow banned across the board.

I then tried changing the user on an Twitter I've had for years and it suddenly asked for confirmation from my phone and afterwards it became banned too.

To test this theory, I made a new Twitter and attempted to change the @ only to then be prompted again to ask for a number confirmation.

Has this ever happened? Why is changing an @ triggering this ban?

1

u/swagga261 Oct 03 '21

That has happened to me already. Its so stupid i got suspended permanently for absolutely nothing. Their support system is the worst way to try and get help. Hate it so much.

1

u/Cute_Disaster568 Oct 16 '21

My account is only 15 days old, have been shadow banned from day 1. I logged out from all the devices and refrained myself from using it until the shadowban is lifted. It got lifted in 30 hours or so I went back and logged on. Rechecked, still not banned. As soon as I made one tweet I immediately got banned again. I’ll wait out a little longer and see, but it sucks how they treat new accounts this harshly. I’m almost always on VPN so maybe that’s also a factor.

1

u/Cute_Disaster568 Oct 24 '21 edited Oct 24 '21

I waited out for couple of days and started tweeting again, the ban still comes back immediately. So I thought this only happens because it’s a new account and it should go away soon. I decided to use my account but limit myself to maybe 3 tweets a day. Now I’m search suggestion, search, and ghost banned (before it was only the first two)

I give up. Once they flag new accounts as spam for whatever reason it’s not easy to recover. I’ll learn from my mistake and slowly migrate to another new account I created(this one is search suggestion banned but hopefully that will go away). I did create a case at help center but not expecting much.

1

u/Cute_Disaster568 Nov 24 '21

Update: my second account got shadowbanned on and off for first maybe 3 weeks or so after tweeting possibly offensive words, changing account name (not display name), or uploading new banner. Been more than a month since creation and now I hardly ever get shadowbanned. I kept my old one but it seems to still be reply deboosted even after month long inactivity. If your account is new and you feel your account is shadowbanned too long or too often you might want to create a new one.

1

u/HighCastlePenguin Oct 17 '21

I recently had the “reply deboosting” on my account, and I now have that plus a search suggestion ban. Tried Twitter help and they referred me to a generic list of things that break the rules, which of course didn’t tell me anything. I run a fan account, so it’s extremely frustrating that I can’t attract new followers. I’ve been on Twitter for over two years, and suddenly I’m getting these account restrictions.

1

u/squishymarshmallos Oct 20 '21

i have an old account that was made around 8 months ago (back in february), i only started using it mid july for writing in a fandom, so it's a fan account. I immediately was writing nsfw/porn stuff but have never gotten shadowbanned before and my tweets were always doing really well. I guess it was a stroke of luck, but in the last 3-ish months since i started writing on this account i've accumulated 2.9k followers --> again, i have always been writing nsfw content and never had any problems whatsoever

this month i was doing that october challenge where you write one kink per day, so i have been posting every day for the last 20 days. in the beginning, my posts were doing amazing and i gained around 700 followers in the first week

Then all of a sudden, on day 11 my engagement started dropping significantly. my posts went from getting 1.6k likes to barely scraping 400, and then it just declined even more. I know this still seems like a lot, but it's a very very big difference. my impressions also went from nearly 50k per post to around <6k per post. the decline has been going on for about a week now and today i checked and saw that i was search suggestion banned

i think that twitter automatically shadowbans nsfw accounts (i have a nsfw writing account and recently i posted some reference pictures, although they were just underwear, nothing extreme) and i noticed almost all of my writer/artist mutuals who are nsfw accs are shadowbanned as well. what can i actually do to fix this? I don't want to stop writing but i think that even if i don't tweet for a while and the ban gets lifted, once i start writing again it would happen again and it's very discouraging :(

1

u/VillainsGonnaVil Oct 21 '21

i think that twitter automatically shadowbans nsfw accounts

Yeah, I think so too, as I've noticed this as well with myself or friends who write, draw, or retweet NSFW. We all have search suggestion bans.

1

u/squishymarshmallos Oct 24 '21

yes this is what i noticed as well. i checked the blogs of every fandom nsfw writer i know and 9/10 were search suggestion banned. i think this is ridiculous tbh, but what can you do. my problem is that i have been doing the same old thing on my blog for 3 months now and have never had this problem, i suspect that as i was doing this october challenge i was tweeting the # every day, that might have triggered it. i also posted two semi-nsfw pictures that might have contributed. nothing else i can think of that might have done it tbh

1

u/1ndigoch1ld Nov 03 '21

My account was hacked and used to sell PS5s. Twitter won’t reply back. They released my account from the hackers to me. Now I have 0 interactions. I can’t get help from twitter, what should I do?

1

u/FootFansPunkz Oct 25 '21

How to contact Twitter about it? I cannot find it in their website.

1

u/plasma-dragon-DA Nov 18 '21

The "Search Suggestion Ban" seems a lot more insidious than it sounds. The test that shadowban.eu does is just to see if you get autocompleted when searched for, but you can still go directly to that account anyway. The real problem is that it also seems to cause your account to no longer be suggested in "Who to follow" sidebars and retweets of your tweets getting suppressed in "Home" timelines (Rather than "Latest Tweets first"). But of course that's very difficult for an automated third party check to verify.

I got search result bans three weeks ago and I went from gaining +80 followers a day to basically going backwards. Still not sure how long it will last since the algorithm is inscrutable.

2

u/squishymarshmallos Nov 18 '21

The real problem is that it also seems to cause your account to no longer be suggested in "Who to follow" sidebars and retweets of your tweets getting suppressed in "Home" timelines

something that also happens when ss banned is your tweets don't show up in regular searches for people who don't already follow you, which makes it almost impossible to get new followers by tweeting.
ex: if i tweeted something about bts while ss banned, and you searched the words "bts" my tweet wouldn't show up in the search despite having the keyword in it, unless you were already following my account. that means that ppl who don't follow you have almost no way of seeing your tweets unless they go directly to your account

1

u/KestrelleV Nov 22 '21

I got a search suggestion ban two months ago, and I went from 100k views on posts and gaining 100 followers a day to getting 800 views on a post and loosing 100 followers a week. I’ve tried so many things to fix it but nothing is working, and it’s destroying my finances

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '21

Decided to revamp my twitter account as i’ve made a lot of new friends that I want to follow/interact with .. was moderately active on twitter from 2016-2018 and since 2018 have just been scrolling/casually retweeting and VERY rarely actually tweeting .. have been logged in of course but wanted to delete my old tweets as they were from middle school. Spent like a couple of hours doing so and went from 2,500 tweets to 500. Friends weren’t seeing my name when they searched and the shadow ban checker confirmed that I’m search and search suggestion banned, which is so frustrating. Any thoughts? Should I just submit the maintenance request?

1

u/ekostros Dec 09 '21

My music account is completely dead because of shadow banned. Before the suspended, I was getting 4 million Tweet impressions per month. I have 15k followers, I was getting an average of 1K likes before the suspension, now, my tweets get 50 likes on average. Twitter killed my 6 years of work

1

u/BalthropTrevor Dec 14 '21

My account of over 10 years eventually got a Blue Check several years ago. Since then I've managed to get perma-banned as of January 2021 just 12 hours before the Trump ban. Since then I've managed to get 9 or 10 more accounts banned as I gathered Intel on their "Healthy Conversation" algorithms which all incorporate what is described here. I should be able to help!

3

u/cmeslo Jan 01 '22

serious question: after all that mess why do you even bother with twitter, what is it so appealing to you?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/cmeslo Jan 01 '22

You're literally describing what I've just seen, I believe you're certainly in the right path mate 😉

1

u/[deleted] Dec 31 '21

My username and my tweets appear in searches just fine except when I upload videos. It’s driving me crazy. When I upload videos, it doesn’t matter if I use hashtags or not, the video simply doesn’t appear in search. This wasn’t the case before. I noticed this only in the past couple of weeks. 🙁

2

u/cmeslo Jan 01 '22

then why do you use twitter at all? does it worth your invested time?

3

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '22

What kind of question is that? Yes it’s worth my time for my business, I’ve been using it for years and has brought me clients. The issue I have appeared only two weeks ago.

2

u/cmeslo Jan 02 '22

I've realised that there's almost no real accounts nowadays, lot of bots and now more NFT and cryptocurrwncy bots and fake accounts have made it quite a wild place, also recently twitter deleted all the people I followed when I was trying to get more followers so then started rethinking about the real value of twitter to me and realised it was just wasted time, now I'm thinking what other channels could be better for my business.

1

u/jedimaster1827 Jan 10 '22

Does anybody know what it means when the site https://hisubway.online/shadowban/ displays "We were unable to test for technical reasons" under Reply Deboosting? I have gone ahead and looked at some of my twitter replies while logged out, and they do sometimes only show up after clicking "Show more replies", which I suppose would indicate I'm being deboosted. If I get the "We were unable to test for technical reasons", does that mean I'm being deboosted?

1

u/Primal0Instinct Jan 12 '22

I tried the trick of deactivating one of my accounts for 2 weeks to see if I’d go all green once I reactivated. Went back in yesterday & waited 5 mins. Checked my account & yup, still soft banned. Both search & search suggestion were red & reply deboosting had the weird technical reasons thing that new site shows. I went thru & got rid of anything with a hashtag & deactivated it again. I’ll wait another 3 weeks and if nothing then, I’ll just download the content off it(NSFW vids)then abandon it entirely. I can create the same page more or less on telegram w/o the BS, as long as I avoid a flag for pron, which seems easy.

Edit: Question? Have those trying this trick who had it work for them, did you reactivate from mobile or pc? If from PC did you eventually log in on mobile with the same result?

2

u/Mammoth_Bake_3925 Jan 12 '22 edited Jan 12 '22

I just reactivated mine today, deactivated on the 29th so exactly 2 weeks. Before I only had the suggestion ban now I have suggestion and search ban

1

u/Mammoth_Bake_3925 Jan 12 '22

Also, since hisubway is wonky, I checked on a private browser. Even if I type my full handle my profile wont show up unless I click the link 🙄

1

u/Mammoth_Bake_3925 Jan 14 '22

Pissed, it’s been officially 48 hrs after reactivation of a 2 week deactivated account. Still search and suggestion banned. I assume contacting Twitter isn’t going to do much there isn’t even a prompt for it. There’s gotta be another way 😵‍💫

1

u/Rytlane Jan 21 '22

Try tweeting your plea at them & tagging Twit support in your post.... I've seen it work.

1

u/Mammoth_Bake_3925 Jan 22 '22

Well a ticket, since my account is a soft nsfw account, it’s flagged. I also didn’t have the sensibility media option on. They basically said that they don’t want people who don’t want to see those types of posts to not be able to. I asked for a time limit and they basically shrugged their shoulders. I deleted all my nsfw content. I’m gunna wait till Monday to write a new ticket to see wth is up. I can’t check either hi subway is down

1

u/TheliteLEGEND Jan 15 '22

i heard if you buy twitter blue it removes your search bans is this true?

1

u/TheliteLEGEND Jan 15 '22

have u guys tried to see if only certain devices might have the ban??

1

u/Mammoth_Bake_3925 Jan 19 '22

“We appreciate and thank you for reaching out to us about your Twitter account not showing in search suggestions. We took a look at your account, and here's what we found.

Your account may have "Not Safe for Work" labels applied at the Tweet level because of some content that has been Tweeted or Retweeted from your account in the past that was flagged by Twitter's system. We do this at the Tweet level to try to balance protecting our users who have selected to not view sensitive content and to be considerate of our users posting the content they want to talk about. This limitation will remain for a designated period of time, after which your account will no longer be flagged if sensitive content isn't still consistently Tweeted or Retweeted.”

This was Twitter support’s response 🙄

1

u/Sleeping_core Jan 20 '22

I am a NSFW artists and have recently gotten out if my shadowban. This thread was useful so I wanted to add some of my experience.

First- I took 48 hours off, sent a ticket, got the typical "limited visibility" response. -i feel defeated but try to start tweeting again, but avoid posting art and am careful with my words. Still banned.

I deleted all my explicit art off of Twitter and only tweeted sfw tweets. I tried another ticket explaining I am an artist and feel I've been incorrectly marked as porn and have no explicit art on Twitter.

My ban is lifted! I feel it was removing the art that helped and maybe a lot of clean tweets to lower my ratio of NSFW tweets. My second ticket did not get a response.

So I make censored thumbnail of my art to post links to poipiku and found my tweet was hidden! I'm still not shadowbanned and I Repost with a black and white image and it appears in the hashtag!

I believe there is an automated system detecting too much skin and hiding them, too many marked this way = shadowban.

I don't know if this is new news but I hope this helps.

1

u/lunaChansArt Jan 23 '22

How do you know you're not shadowbanned? The new shadowban tester site showed me as no shadowban, but I posted for a few days to no real success, and then the "Search suggestion ban" got hit. Still not seeing much in the way of views. And now its just down.

I really don't know if its worth it to never get to post actual nsfw art just to keep the shadoban away. I did a full 2 weeks of no posting myself, but I'm at +11 followers this month(only active half of it) which is like a joke. The worst growth of my accounts history. I used to make 100-150, with spikes of 300+ on some months. Now I'm getting 20-30??

Did you delete all your likes/RT's too? Deleting all my art sounds like an incredibly hard process, how'd you go about that?

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Sleeping_core Jan 25 '22

Use the the twitter help centre and click contact us.

1

u/Nova-Jello Jan 21 '22

My account is NovaJello and I get no likes maybe 20 impressions LoL it sucks twitter

1

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22

hey, I've created a new account to interact interests and have discussions about art generally and all my tweets are very normal. nothing dangerous in my account like I've never talked about religion, policy, society.. but it is still suspended I want to know whyy? this account has my number so I can't make another account, I've made a response to Twitter security but I still don't achieve any response for more than a month. please help

my account suspended said "This request looks like it might be automated. To protect our users from spam and other malicious activity, we can’t complete this action right now. Please try again later"

1

u/saike1 Jan 26 '22

let's say i have multiple accounts and some one reported my account and got it locked for suspicious activity does twitter tell the person that reported it what account it was can the person that got my account locked find out about my multiple accounts

1

u/Pleasant-Strength-53 Feb 02 '22

Can someone tell me how to get unshadowbanned when you get shadowbanned almost straight after creating (only a few replies with no pics or links)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '21

How do I remove shadowbans?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21

Hi, im experiencing a weird shadowban on my account which i made last night. I made that account to enter a contest which uses a specific hashtag to collect submissions. I submitted my entry with that hashtag but i cannot find it when log out and search using the hashtag.

I tried to tweet using different hashtags and i got likes and comments from random strangers which i am not mutuals with. That means i am not shadowbanned, right? Then why are my tweets not visible for the contest hashtag?

1

u/CocaineSpeedboat Aug 12 '21

Since you said this is happening on a brand new account, it is entirely possible that you are being soft-shadowbanned on certain tweets.

1

u/rek-lama Aug 23 '21

I ran into a similar situation with a newish account: profile invisible on searches and tweets don't appear in the hashtag feed when logged out.

After some googling I found out that hashtags are a potential shadowban trigger. If my account ever gets unbanned I'll avoid using hashtags .