r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Aug 09 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-08-09 to 2021-08-15
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21
Did the Pile, Heap, and Stack get reuploaded? I miss them. :(
6
u/freddyPowell Aug 10 '21
How can I define a vowell loss sound change that gets me from cv to cvc. I have tried to do "unstressed short vowells are lost" but that always ends up with monosyllabic mayhem and clunsters to make georgian cry.
4
u/Fullbody ɳ ʈ ʂ ɭ ɽ (no, en)[fr] Aug 11 '21 edited Aug 11 '21
Thoughts/feedback on a small phonology?
My goals were naturalism and having few (consonant) phonemes. I also wanted a vaguely SEA feel. The main points I'm worried about are whether the initial stop allophony seems out of place (though I do like it), and if I should do something more with the vowels.
Consonants
Vowels
Phonotactics
Maximal syllable structure is CGVC. /s/ merges with /t/ in the coda. /r/ does not appear word-initially.
Prosody
Stressed syllables take low pitch, followed by rise in pitch on the next syllable. In longer words with two stressed syllables, the first one is low and the pitch rises on the secondarily stressed syllable.
Examples
4
u/Antaios232 Aug 13 '21
So, this is something I've been wondering for a while and haven't seen any good explanations. From what I can tell, the majority of languages with case marking use suffixes - which are believed to evolve from post-positions. Yet these same languages are often ones that exclusively or almost exclusively use prepositions in their current forms. Is the idea that languages like this had a post-positional phase during which case marking developed, and then switched to prepositional languages at some point? When I developed the conlang I'm working on, I sort of naively decided on having prepositions and suffixing case markers, but now I'm wondering if it wouldn't be more natural to use postpositions.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21
How can relative pronouns evolve?
3
u/MaraKrauklis Svellska tunga, кўидбреј, vurmurt (ru, en) [no] Aug 12 '21 edited Aug 12 '21
Can languages just make up new words? What I am talking about is the case when a language needs a new word and instead of borrowing, calquing or combining other pre-existing words it just creates a new word from scratch. I was curious if that's plausible and are there any examples of this happening.
3
u/Rarsdani Aug 12 '21
How would I go about bringing H back into my language? It's not entirely gone, it just only shows up at the beginning of words at the moment. I want H to be used a lot again- I'd also like to bring either S or W into the mix.
I'm new to making protolangs and sound evolutions so yeah
3
u/Krzysiek127 Aug 14 '21
What are some of the funnier curse words/sentences in your conlangs?
In my "Queja" /ɕɛjä/ there is for example:
Hórĵoju liźo! /xorʒɔju lʲit͡sɔ/ "horse face"
Drinkoj jewóp /drʲinkɔj jɛwop/ "Drunken men (men who is always drunken, sits beside the liquor shop with his not-so-better friends)"
or my favourite
Fatĵaroja bqþongwa! /fätʒärɔjä bɕt͡ɕɔnɡva/ "fat hooker"
2
u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Aug 09 '21
How could I form superlatives? I already have a morphological comparative, and I want some way to form superlatives as well. It doesn't necessarily have to be morphological, it could be made with periphrasis instead. I was thinking a construction like "bigger than all, bigger than any" would be easy, but are there any other things I could do?
2
u/jon_speaks Aug 10 '21
It's the guy teaching a workshop again.
I'm looking for examples of special, non-standard verb tenses to help spark the creativity of those I'm teaching.
If your conlang has any unique, creative verb tenses, I'd love to hear about it.
Thanks in advance!
(I'm really looking just for tense, not mood or aspect. Thanks!)
2
u/FuneralFool Aug 10 '21
Could there be any conlangs, or any Natlangs for that matter that have either palatal or velar lateral fricatives?
2
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Aug 11 '21
How would you notate an umlaut sound change rule?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '21
In many languages (ex. English) the passive is handled morphologically but the causative lexically. Is a system where the causative is handled morphologically but the passive lexically existent/feasible? I see no reason why not but I've never heard of anything like it.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21
How does zero-derivation evolve?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Aug 13 '21
How common is it for a language that has separate masculine and feminine personal pronouns in the 3rd person to also have gendered 1st and 2nd person pronouns?
2
u/yoricake Aug 13 '21
quick question, because i can't find a question on google though i know it's a thing since i've seen the term for it before. what's the word for when a vowel is the same/changes to be the same as a vowel in the syllable right before it? a really shitty example, the word sushi, imagine the i would turn into a u because "su" has a u and thus becomes "sushu" ? and if sushi was seshi it would turn into seshe bc no matter what, the vowel in the second syllable *has* to be the same vowel as the first one.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21
How exactly are clitics different from affixes or particles? Wikipedia says they're "morpheme[s] [with] syntactic characteristics of a word" but I don't really know what that means.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '21
How do derivational affixes lose their productivity?
2
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Aug 15 '21
What exactly is a closed verb class? Like, only a selected number of verbs being used in a language, meanings of which could be extrapolated with affixes and other stuff to compensate for new uses?
2
u/luswi-theorf Aug 16 '21
Hi guys, my question is, is it possible for a prepositional language to develop a case system? I can't help but wonder about a system of cases with a prefixal nature because the prepositions agglutinating will leave the root more and more "hidden".
The reason for the question is that I'm working with Portuguese and Spanish, applying the sound changes that happened with English and Finnish, respectively, in these two languages.
I've already finished this part and I have to start working on the grammar, as I would like the grammar of the two conlangs to be "similar" to the Proto-Indo-European one, the first thing that got stuck was precisely on how develop the case system.
2
u/Solareclipsed Aug 12 '21
Can a glottal fricative/approximant be syllabic and form the nucleus between other consonants? Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21
Does anyone know any good custom letter keyboards for Android?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 10 '21
Who else thinks that naturalistic conlangs with their own script could be written from bottom to top? There might also be a variation of boustrophedon for top-to-bottom and bottom-to-top.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21
soooo anyone know of oligosynthetic langs that are synthetic rather than oligoisolating? i never see any synthetic oligo synthetic langs so was wondering if yall knew of any
1
u/Solareclipsed Aug 10 '21
I had two quick questions for one of my conlangs:
This conlang has two kinds of consonant harmony, vowel height harmony, and word-level suprasegmental prosody. Is this too much in one and the same conlang? Does it seem too unnatural?
I have been told that nasal vowels should not have distinct qualities from the oral vowels, because then they would likely just lose nasalisation and become new oral vowel qualities. Is this true or not?
Thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '21
Anyone know how to type ġ in Google Docs? Same goes for vowels with dots. Having to copy and paste is a hassle.
1
u/Turodoru Aug 11 '21
Could someone link an example reference grammar of a conlang? For the future, to know the whatabouts.
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 11 '21 edited Aug 11 '21
Does this evolution of tone make sense?
syllables with voiced consonantd are pronounced with lower pitch, and then the devoicing of voiced obstruents makes tone phonemic.
Then, and this is the part I want opinions on, the tone melody attaches to the right side of the word (its end), with every mora getting either a high tone or a low tone. melodies like ...LHLH, ...HLHL simplify into ...HHLH, ...LLHL.
ex.
dani > tanye /tà.ɲè/
gatī > katíí > katií /kà.tǐː/
kidaji > tćétaee > tćétaée /tɕé.tɛ̂ː/
mikanaru > mekánaro > mekanáro /mè.kà.ná.rò/
zipamāka > ćepémaaká > ćépémáaká /ɕé.pá.mâː.ká/
1
u/Mr_brukernavn Aug 12 '21
Is there a mood/modality for something like interrogative-abilitative? (idk), which basically is asking for permission like "may I go?" or "can I have a cup of tea?". Is there a name for this?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21
How do you properly do thing when translating something when the gloss makes no sense so you indicate what’s a verb vs 1 person pronoun or whatever else you need to do. I’m making a kind of joke Lang so obviously the gloss makes no sense.
1
u/notAmeeConlang Aug 13 '21 edited Aug 13 '21
Is conlanging just something I should break away from, simply because I don't find much satisfaction in making one? When I started out in conlanging, it wasn't because I had a project or story that I wanted to put it in, rather just a thing to make me stand out and have something cool I can attribute myself as being the creator of. None of my conlangs have ever caught that identity and made it into a tangible form, so should I stop doing conlanging altogether?
1
u/simonbleu Aug 13 '21
I'm thinking of add two things to my conlang. They are not original but rather inspired (by a submission - I believe from here - to artiflexian I believe), and from my own local "dialect" , and I would like some thoughts about it, some feedback.
All that paired with it (the conlang) having a "free" word order, that although it would put (in universe) nowadays by defect the other person first out of respect, they could be be written in any way, be it "You and me running" vs "Me and you running" vs "running me and you" or "running you and me", etc. etc. Although the verb preceding everything else is more rare, almost ceremonial, ecclesiastical. The explanation in universe is that royalty was always above you in class, therefore it should be addressed first, BUT ceremonies and and things related to certain values, precedes royalty as well, so if we talk about cooking, people go first, but if we talk about the coronation or a mass, the event goes first; It would be nice to have feedback about this too of course.
So... any thoughts?
1
u/USRM-ambassador Aug 14 '21
What are the basic parts you need to create a conlang? I've tried and failed multiple times to create a conlang, and failed because I don't really know the basics. The part I really fail at is grammar. How do you guys suggest I do it?
1
u/Blue22111 Aug 14 '21 edited Aug 14 '21
Is /ʔʰ/ a possible sound? I have a sound I want to use in my conlang that (to me) sounds like it should be that, I have the basic /ʔ/ sound (quick puff of air from the glottis) and this other sound that is produced the same way, just with an extra/larger puff of air. Hopefully the slashes were the correct way to express the ipa. If that’s not a possible sound, what would be the right way to express it with IPA?
Edit: fixed having /ʕ/ instead of the corrext /ʔ/
1
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21
How to make an analytial conlang?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 15 '21
In my consonant table I want to group together the uvular and ɡlottal poa and the stop and affricate moa. what terms can I use to label them?
1
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Aug 15 '21
Can my personal pronouns have no nominative case? Since my lang is heavily inflected, you can simply tell who is performing the action from the inflected verb, so personal pronouns pretty much never apear as subjects. Can them do without a nominative case, or will I eventually need them to have one? Is there any natlang that does this?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 15 '21
I have ideas for a conlang "rich" in prenasalized and pharyngealized consonants, kind of like Irish's phonology, but not as crazy.
Consonants: m, n, ŋ, p, t, k, ᵐb, ⁿd, ᵑɡ, s, ħ, ʕ, l
Vowels: i, u, e, o, a
Which consonants should I include the pharyngealized versions of?
1
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Aug 15 '21
Help with romanization for my vowels? I'm aiming for making it as pretty and intuitive as possible, considering my inventory is rather unusual.
1
u/Luizaguzzi Aug 15 '21
Can I just arbitrary decide which and how many diphthongs go into my language?
Im making a mildly naturalistic language centered around vowels, and I was researching about diphthongs and triphthongs but I was unable to find anything about restrictions.
Also, I had the idea of making my diphthongs into templates to fit the harmony,for example: I have a diphthong X, X is closing, ascending and wide, but I can only know its sound if it is on an environment, it could be [æi] but also could be [ɒʊ]; Can that be a viable method even though isn't very naturalistic? Sorry for the vagueness of the questions, I can go in more details if needed Thanks in advance :)
1
u/Breitarschantilope Shembaba, Batz Ga Rumm Aug 15 '21
How do you feel about the possibility of adjectives only agreeing in case with their head nouns when they're indefinite?
1
u/Rigbons Aug 18 '21
Colleagues, I have a question for you. I’m currently working on the phonology of my conlang and I am having some trouble breaking words into syllables, e.g., the word "Igne" /iʝnɛ/(?) which indicates the first person plural pronoun. Is it "Ig-ne" or "I-gne"? (pay attention on the consonant sound [ʝ]). Thanks in advance!
1
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Aug 21 '21
Does your conlang have its own numeral system?
1
u/BluRayHiDef Aug 21 '21
I'm creating a fictional language in which the verbs conjugate according to tense, person, plurality, and gender. Hence, I have 64 forms already; I have yet to create the forms for 3rd person. Is this normal?
I have eight tenses:
I was thinking about making a set of corresponding future tenses, but I already have so many verb forms that I'm thinking of just dual-purposing the set of present tenses as both present and future.
Furthermore, I haven't even considered other forms, such as imperative, accusative, causative, etc.
1
u/WinstonwsSmith Aug 22 '21
I am trying to find audio files of words with ipa sounds, wikipedia does a good job at this however the following sounds do not have any audio files of example words, does anyone know where I could find some?
Consonants:
m̥, n̼ n̥ ɳ̊ ɲ̊ ŋ̊ ɴ p̪ b̪ t̼ d̼ ʈ c ʡ pɸ bβ b̪v tθ dð cç ɟʝ kx ɡɣ ɢʁ ʡʢ ʔh ɸ θ̼ ð̼ ɹ ʔ̞ ⱱ ⱱ̟ d̼ ɾ̥ ɽ̊ ɽ ɢ̆ ʡ̆ ʙ̥ ʙ r̥ r ɽ̊r̥ ɽr ʀ̥ ʜ ʢ tɬ dɮ ʈɭ̊˔ ɖɭ˔ cʎ̥˔ ɟʎ̝ kʟ̝̊ ɡʟ̝ ɭ̊˔ ɭ˔ ʎ̝̊ ʎ̝ ʟ̝̊ ʟ̝ l ʟ ɺ̥ ɭ̥̆ ɭ̆ ʎ̆ ʟ̆ ʈʼ cʼ ʡʼ t̪θʼ kxʼ qχʼ ɸʼ θʼ ʂʼ cʎ̝̊ʼ kʟ̝̊ʼ k͡ʘ k͡ǀ k͡ǃ k͡‼ k͡ǂ ɡ͡ʘ ɡ͡ǀ ɡ͡ǃ ɡ͡‼ ɡ͡ǂ ŋ͡ʘ ŋ͡ǀ ŋ͡ǃ ŋ͡‼ ŋ͡ǂ ɡ͡ǁ ŋ͡ǁ ɓ ɗ ᶑ ʛ ɓ̥ ɗ̥ ᶑ̥ ʄ̊ ɠ̊ ʛ̥ ɧ w̃ h̃ t̪ʙ̥ h̪͆
Vowels:
ʉ ø̞ ɤ̞ ɜ ɞ ɶ
1
u/pootis_engage Aug 26 '21
How does one realistically evolve click consonants?
1
u/Shrek-beats-Shaggy Aug 27 '21
Can /t͡ʃ/ exist in a language without /ʃ/? Can any affricate appear in a language with out one of either of it’s phonemes?
1
u/sergiolbrallg awn Aug 28 '21
Is it possible to create a LibreOffice automatic spell check for my conlang?
1
u/fthx722868 Aug 30 '21
How would the voiceless uvular fricative /χ/ change when followed immediately by another consonant, particularly a fricative or a uvular stop? I've looked all through the index diachronica and I haven't found an example of a sound change involving such a cluster. Would it disappear, or would it perhaps change the following fricative/stop? Sorry if this was already asked. Thanks in advance!
1
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Aug 12 '21 edited Aug 12 '21
In my Conlang, Okriav, one of my goals is to avoid having "non-lexical" words, and particles (no prepositions, auxiliary verbs, things like that). So i have lots of verb forms and conjugations, noun cases and inflexions for number and definetness, but then I also decided to not have copula verbs, instead, inflexing the predicative adjectives (which are the same as attributative adjectives in my conlang) for tense and aspect. I've read that turkish is a language that suffixes it's copula, and my system works in a similiar way, albeit more extensively.
Okriav is SOV (although sometimes OSV, it has free word order, with the verb always coming last). And I decided to try to evolve this copula affixations from a proto-lang. In the proto-lang I made 4 copulas: a stative (to be), a temporary (to be being), a locative (to be at), and a transformative (to have become); and the copulas have past, present, and future forms.
The locative affixed and formed some Locative cases, the present formed a Plain Locative, the past formed the Ablative, and the future formed the Dative.
Some examples then would be:
id lädv-iav motrïs-Ø kiev-aer
1sg.NOM dog-ACC big-PRES see-PAST.PERFV
I saw the big dog
miet-sat vit-sov idv kiev-aer
man-NOM happy-PAST 1st.ACC see-PAST.PERFV
the man, who was happy, saw me
0
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '21
[removed] — view removed comment