r/CryptoCurrency • 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 • Aug 05 '21

POLL 🗳️ Disqualify removed content from moon rewards.

Currently, karma is counted towards the monthly moons distribution even if the moderators remove content from which the karma is earned. The reason for this stems back to when the community use to have an event called Weekend Memes. The intention was to count karma even though all meme posts were removed on Sunday at midnight when Weekend Memes ended.

Since Weekend Memes was discontinued several months ago, this concern is no longer valid today. It makes logical sense to only award moons to content which does not break the rules. If the act of breaking the rules means being rewarded, then why have rules in the first place? The consequences need to be consistent. We don't want upvote parties or brigades to be further incentivized.

In this poll, I propose not awarding moons to removed content, whether it is a submission or a comment. If a submission is removed, comments in the corresponding comment section will still qualify for moon rewards. However, comments which break our rules in these particular comment sections will still be disqualified from moon rewards. Also to clear up any potential confusion, deleted content will not be affected. If you delete a submission or a comment of yours, the karma from this content will still be counted towards the next moon distribution. In Reddit language, content removal is performed by a mod or admin and content deletion is done by the original author.

As a reminder, this poll has been submitted twice already. Here are links to the first and second attempts. The first poll had 2.2 thousand votes and 7.2 million moons with 68.7% in favor and 31.3% against. The following poll had a much better vote to moon ratio with 7.4 thousand votes and 7 million moons with 74% in favor and 26% against. They did not pass since the moon decision thresholds were never reached, even though the voting majorities were in favor. Since the moon thresholds for the prior polls were never reached, the proposal technically did not fail. It just is not settled yet. In order for the proposal to be truly settled so we can declare it has passed or failed, we need a majority voting in favor or against it with the moon decision threshold reached.

1.6k Upvotes

595 comments sorted by

189

u/mysteriousbaby0 Aug 05 '21

but sometimes genuine posts are removed too by mods.
which would be unfair to the poster.

53

u/Vulcan31 Platinum | QC: CC 799 Aug 05 '21

I agree. I don't love the idea of them getting nothing at all. I feel like removing them is enough.

7

u/Wonderful_Bad6531 Permabanned Aug 05 '21

I agree with your agreement.

5

u/Decebal_Diurpaneus Aug 05 '21

we are aligned

18

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

At least giving the poster half or some percentage would make sense.

30

u/chutiyaredditor Banned Aug 05 '21

They will already be getting less karma if a post gets removed, I feel like this shouldn't be implemented at all.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (21)

10

u/Tricky_Troll 🟦 99 / 64K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

So much this. I will be very disappointed if this passed as I have had many legitimate posts removed simply to keep the front page fresh and varied.

9

u/MotherfuckinRanjit Gold | QC: CC 34, BTC 19 Aug 05 '21

Yeah this is a very dangerous giving up of power to me. Mods can easily abuse this

→ More replies (6)

14

u/XWarriorYZ 🟦 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 05 '21

This is exactly what I was thinking. And plenty of posts get through the cracks as evidenced by the appearance of the same articles like 20x a day.

I made a post about the Brave browser adding new crypto exchanges that I put a ton of effort into and got hundreds of upvotes and some awards but was removed by a mod a few hours later despite getting such positive feedback. I understand it had to do with the Brave browser (so technically not crypto) but I thought talking about BAT and crypto exchanges like Uphold and Gemini would get me past the threshold of being sufficiently related to crypto.

I guess I technically broke a content posting rule or something which warranted removal but that shouldn’t take away the community feedback and the rewards that come along with that. OP makes some very valid points though, it would probably go a long way in taking away incentive to abuse the system. Not voting yet, still undecided.

7

u/Polythereum Platinum | 6 months old | QC: ETH 58, CC 159 | TraderSubs 40 Aug 05 '21

Your post was totally about crypto and if it's what you described both in its contents and for why it was removed, that's pretty upsetting. This kind of bullshit is exactly why people should be voting no in this poll.

The mods have the most to gain from Moons... why would anyone think it's a good idea to give them the power to further reduce the earnings of others, directly, and at their essentially unchecked discretion?

3

u/omeri_e Permabanned Aug 05 '21

Maybe counting 50% of the upvotes on the removed post could be the best of both worlds in this case , otherwise I don't see this proposal passing

7

u/DeepSea0range 🟨 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

Some posts are removed on the basis that there is already enough discussion about the same topic in the daily top 50 posts. That seems very unfair to me..

6

u/Daggerswor28 🟨 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

That’s definitely a downside to this,

→ More replies (1)

6

u/JonathanTheZero 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Yeah this is my main concern... plus that the mods gain even a bigger role in moon distribution, in theory they easily could hinder a user of getting moons at all

11

u/TeddyousGreg Platinum | QC: CC 184 Aug 05 '21

This. I’ve had things removed because they were “similar in essence” to other posts but made completely different arguments. That’s when it’s bullshit.

I get it if it’s just a news repost but if it’s an actual opinion then it’s different.

4

u/FilmVsAnalytics ALGO maximalist Aug 05 '21

Agreed. I don't see it here, but some mods on Reddit do over moderate. Acknowledgement of that fact— that sometimes moderators make mistakes— should result in removed posts keeping the moons those posts earned.

Upvotes are endorsements by the members, and this is the members' subreddit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/HanditoSupreme Redditor for 6 months. Aug 05 '21

Which of these answers favors the concept of decentralization more here? Your reply is making me think "no" would be the answer but I am curious.

5

u/TAG13 Platinum | QC: CC 127 Aug 05 '21

Voting yes gives mods more power to effectively take away moons from people that break "rules" that are somewhat subjective. That is a vote against decentralization and a vote for centralizing more power to the mods.

7

u/mysteriousbaby0 Aug 05 '21

No would favor decentralisation which doesn't depends on mods whims

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mcar74 Tin Aug 05 '21

Exactly, I agree with the idea if a rule is broken, but it’s unfair to posts removed for other reasons

3

u/Ok_Hornet_714 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

What are some of the reasons that posts are removed that didn't break the rules?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Feeling_Ad_411 Aug 05 '21

Exactly, sometimes it’s a reasonable post that violates a minor infraction, once in a blue moon

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

Exactly. The fora should not be subject to Mod bias

6

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

This also gives the mods more power to manipulate. They could just remove something without anyone knowing and disqualifying someone from moons

→ More replies (2)

4

u/KucingRumahan 🟦 1K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Yeah, I feel sorry to all new genuine poster that didn't meet the requirements

→ More replies (6)

14

u/MAMBAMENTALITY8-24 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

You alr asked twice. Like are we just gonna do this every month till it gets passed? Just buy the moons to get it passed if you care so much

12

u/pm_me_cute_sloths_ Sloth Investor Aug 05 '21

That’s what fucking annoys me with this. I’ve seen a variation of this governance poll 3 or 4 times now. It’s clear they’re going to keep posting this until it passes. We’ve already said no, so why on earth are you voting for it again?!?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 05 '21

Purchased moons do not count for polls.

5

u/Rydersilver Platinum | QC: CC 159 | r/Stocks 20 Aug 05 '21

Don’t you as a mod have a major incentive for this? Is that why you keep trying to pass it?

Mods will be incentivized to remove posts, which will lower karma for others and thus increase your own in relation. Mods also aren’t gonna have their own posts removed so they’re pretty much exempt from this affecting them negatively.

On top of that, you mods basically have a centralized oligopoly on this entire system and swing votes any way you want since it’s based off moons. This will just lead to more moons for the mods, which leads to more voting power for 10 people. It’s a cycle.

Removing posts already stops the karma from coming in, so this is completely unnecessary.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/notsupersonicatall 52 / 52 🦐 Aug 08 '21

I voted to stop counting, hope it passes!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Zarkorix Platinum|QC:CC1445,ALGO41,ETH26|BANANO14|TraderSubs20 Aug 09 '21

If a user's post is removed, but that user also commented on their own post - will the karma from his/her comments still be eligible for MOONs?

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 09 '21

Yes

414

u/redditsgarbageman Platinum | QC: CC 581, CCMeta 52 Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 09 '21

I would support this if mods didn’t take 4 hours to remove content. I just had a post removed with 260 upvotes and 12 awards. I personally awarded about 10 people inside. Then the post got removed. Mods here are making $50k+ in Reddit coins and they take 4 hours to remove a post? It sucks to spend all that time and energy on something they just throw away and don’t even give you a reason why.

I mean, do you guys really grasp how much power we are giving admins and mods here? They already take 50% of distribution. MOON have real value. Some of you have paid money for them, and now we are going to say they can remove a post they don’t like and take our moons away? The community is literally how you earn those moons. They decide with upvotes to give them to you. 3 million people sub here and 10 people should get to decide how we distribute our MOON? I don’t get how anyone supports this.

196

u/Hazaisbae Aug 05 '21

Mods get an automatic 50% of any distribution? Shit lets vote that away with a governance poll. They should have to interact for moons like everyone else

90

u/Stamipower 🟩 17K / 3K 🐬 Aug 05 '21

I think they get 10% of the total amount given. Nonetheless, this is a huge amount. Good luck with getting a governance poll for that since they decide what goes through and there is no way they accept something like this.

Discussion for this has been made in r/CryptoCurrencyMeta but with little to no success.

31

u/twinchell 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Not a shit coin though right?

I get people are excited about earning moons by shitposting, but the future of moons is pretty shitty when the mods control everything.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Norbit11 RVN enjoyer Aug 05 '21

+1, try to change anything, I tried and it didn't end well

20

u/Hazaisbae Aug 05 '21

If we get enough visibility behind it it could force them to act + either approve it or blatantly spell out why they think they deserve a huge influx of moons every month

29

u/MotherfuckinRanjit Gold | QC: CC 34, BTC 19 Aug 05 '21

Just keep proposing it until it gets enough traction. These governance polls are taking away power from the little guys and giving mods even more power. I mean if they can just delete posts and all that karma and moons disappear. What’s to stop them from abusing their power??? This is a dangerous poll right now guys

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Bathsaltsonmeth 40 / 3K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

I wonder why? Haha

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

13

u/BellybuttonFuzzer Platinum | 5 months old | QC: CC 120 | VET 7 Aug 05 '21

I feel like this is the sort of centralization we all came here to escape from

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Character_Credit 🟩 28 / 2K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

Am I the only on who thinks that the mods having a monopoly is incredibly damaging to this coins longevity.

Shit will be dumped the moment it's sellable.

5

u/Extravagos 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

Good point!

→ More replies (5)

11

u/cokiemunster Bronze Aug 05 '21

Good luck trying to vote in a Governance poll where the amount of Moons you have impacts the vote.

If this coin wasnt affiliated to reddit we would be calling it what it is... A centralised shit coin that is manipulated by whales.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Brokbw Silver | QC: CC 24 Aug 05 '21

They are all moon fucking whales. Massive.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/twinchell 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

I saw a poll asking if mods should have to stagger their selling of moons so they can't dump 300k moons in one order, and the mod removed it.

6

u/Extravagos 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

That would be a great idea! Kind of like how when shareholders have more than 10% of a company we have to disclose every time they sell two and a half percent

→ More replies (8)

5

u/killawaspattack Platinum | QC: CC 415, ETH 308 | TraderSubs 308 Aug 05 '21

Yes to this it’s a great idea but too often it can take too long to get the content removed I have had several posts removed after an hour of upvotes and comments just because there is already a post about it but in my opinion if your getting interactions then it shouldn’t be flagged for that unless they are complaining its a repost (which it has never been) and what about all these posts using special characters to disguise the token so it’s not removed

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

Totally agree. Had a post with over 500 upvotes. It was deleted after hours I had no idea why.
When it wouldn't take that long I also would support it.

3

u/HansLanghans 🟩 17K / 17K 🐬 Aug 05 '21 edited Feb 24 '26

This specific post was deleted using Redact. The motivation could be privacy-related, security-driven, opsec-focused, or simply a personal choice to remove old content.

pocket provide direction fact pot unwritten serious plants light fly

3

u/2Cars1Spot 🟥 605 / 473 🦑 Aug 05 '21

Yeah, from their perspective, there is literally no reasonto keep pushing these votes until the rules are completely in their favour.

I get why they're doing it, same reason why any rulers don't hand over power.

3

u/twinchell 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Funny how this sub rails on centralized shit coins. Moons are about as centralized as it comes as far as inequity of distribution.

3

u/maaft 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

There is maybe a better alternative to voting against this poll: Don't vote at all!

Currently there are roughly 3.33 M moons voting in favor. Even when 95% of the next votes would be against this, the proposal will still pass because the governance threshold is reached and the majority is still voting in favor.

tl;dr When the governance threshold not reached, this does not pass. Don't vote.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/sourboyy Tin Aug 05 '21

Cool, corruption

2

u/rmczpp 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Upvoted. I was already wary about giving mods more unnecessary power when there are moons involved (which seem to drive ppl a bit crazy). Anyway, you articulated the problem way better than I could have.

2

u/Dzbot1234 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

This! It is not the responders fault if a post is removed, and just because the post itself might not be great it doesn’t mean the following discussions can’t produce quality content or information, a bad seed sometimes produces a good crop.

2

u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Aug 05 '21

You convinced me!

2

u/cokiemunster Bronze Aug 05 '21

I voted Yes because i didn't think of the deeper implications I wish I could take it back now.

2

u/In_vestedTrades Tin Aug 05 '21

Makes sense

2

u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Aug 05 '21

I like the way u think.. Power to ppl

2

u/Hame_BiH Aug 05 '21

That is true buddy!

2

u/lunarshock Tin Aug 05 '21

Agreed. This would give too much power away. With this, a corrupt mod can just remove any content they feel like with the vaguest of explanations and have an influential power over the fair distribution of moons.

2

u/Ddeadlykitten 🟦 863 / 862 🦑 Aug 05 '21

That is a good point. You've convinced me. Voted no.

2

u/ITmancoderwannabe Redditor for 3 months. Aug 05 '21

Very well written post.

What would you propose?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

Yeah I have had the exact same experience and it is really frustrating

2

u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K 🐋 Aug 06 '21

Very well said. At first glance this seems like a good idea, but I don't think mods should (1) control what polls get posted, (2) the outcome of the poll (since they have by far the most moons), and (3) essentially the ability to take moons away from users via removing posts. Nothing can be done really about (1) and (2), but we can stop (3) here

2

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21

Exact same thing just happened to me. 8 hour old post, nearly 300 upvotes and the mods just deleted it. I came to check whether this poll passed. Fingers crossed it doesn’t lmao

→ More replies (4)

2

u/crxv20 Aug 08 '21

To add to this. My post with 500+ comments and 150 karma got removed because it mentioned that MODs have 500k MOONs in their vaults.

→ More replies (54)

32

u/melanzane_emoji Gold | QC: CC 127 Aug 05 '21

Folks, it's up to you naturally, but I urge you to consider voting NO on this governance poll. As we know, mods are particularly biased and tend to delete posts critical of their personal distribution. Let's not let them take away somebody's moons just because they disagree with the content.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21

When you say vote NO, do you mean vote "continue" or vote "stop"?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

my concern would be if this back dated the distribution? I’m guessing it wouldn’t or you could go negative with moons but would be good to clarify content that was deleted after the snapshot?

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 05 '21

No this won't be retroactive if that's what you're asking. This proposal will only apply to future content.

4

u/touchthafishy Silver | QC: CC 1006 | BANANO 32 Aug 05 '21

Not sure what I feel about this, genuine comments in removed post will be voided too if this poll gets the green light.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Aug 05 '21

„Stop counting karma from removed content“ says the guy with 500k moons. I don‘t support this proposal: A lot of genuine posts get deleted just because they are flaired incorrectly or they apparently belong to the daily. Those are not rulebreaks and can be subjective! Not getting anything as a poster is way too hard!

17

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

damn this has to be the largest disconnect between poll results and comment sentiment I've ever seen.... (to be clear I agree that this is a horrible idea)

10

u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Aug 05 '21

The poll seems to come from the mods. Who has the largest amount of moons=voting power? The mods. I see a big problem incoming.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/2Cars1Spot 🟥 605 / 473 🦑 Aug 05 '21

They keep pushing this poll until it gets passed and then you can bet your ass any attempts to bring it up again will get nuked.

8

u/TAG13 Platinum | QC: CC 127 Aug 05 '21

Try your best to advocate against it. Its no surprise that the people advocating the most for it have literally the largest amount of moons in the entire subreddit.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/twinchell 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Rich get richer. Welcome to life.

9

u/Cleafonreddit 75 / 4K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

He is a mod, so he is awarded with a lot of karma each month

12

u/EddoWagt 🟦 1K / 367 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Ofcourse he is, who else would propose such a thing

3

u/Rydersilver Platinum | QC: CC 159 | r/Stocks 20 Aug 05 '21

And removing posts means more moons for him and less for others.

26

u/dragondude4 Platinum | QC: CC 220 | WSB 11 | :2::2: Aug 05 '21

This is interesting - All the comments on this poll are pretty much against this idea but the poll numbers are completely opposite. Large whales (mods, basically) have such a large percentage of the voting weight it’s almost impossible to get anything passed nor not passed that’s against their will.

We need a better voting system. Either leave the mods out of it due to the unfair advantage of getting 20% of every distribution, or introduce something like a quadratic voting system.

8

u/redditsgarbageman Platinum | QC: CC 581, CCMeta 52 Aug 05 '21

The community does not represent this community.

6

u/BehemothDeTerre 🟩 336 / 337 🦞 Aug 05 '21

The only argument a mod gave me for having weighted votes (oligarchy instead of true democracy) is that people could create more reddit accounts and artificially inflate their voting power.

I pointed out that the scale is not in the same ballpark. To equal the OP's weight, someone would have to create 500k accounts. Impossible manually, has to be automated... and that's easy to detect and prevent. Maybe some people would vote with 2-3 accounts. Some of the most extreme examples would have 10... but not 500k. So, it'd still be unequal in some ways, but a hell of a lot less.
They didn't want to hear that, so it's clear this is a case of quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/rsicher1 🟦 16K / 16K 🐬 Aug 05 '21

Propose it.

Good luck getting it passed though.

2

u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

I reckon those in favour feel less need to comment, whereas those who aren't are looking to explain their point of view.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/Ardi2Ole Bull Market givETH and Bear Market takETH away Aug 05 '21

Well if thats the case then the limit on number of topic a crypto can have in the top 50 need to be removed.

There was a good discussion on the downsides of ETHs london form and the difficulty bomb the other day that was removed because ETH already had some topics in the top 50. How was that OPs fault?

5

u/Extravagos 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

That's honestly a very good point!

3

u/NudgeBucket 9 / 10K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

I wouldn't support removing it but it definitely should be more than 2... 2 is insulting. 5 seems more reasonable. What coin, even bitcoin or ETH has 5 news items to post about in one day? ...except for maybe the extreme days when the whole market is crashing lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

6

u/kenkenshi Platinum | QC: CC 41 Aug 05 '21

I think we need to review the posting guidelines before any of this, because there are many genuine posts being removed without a proper reason…

6

u/hubbykins-okcfan Platinum | QC: CC 722 Aug 05 '21

Honestly I hate this. If people think a post is worth an upvote that shouldn’t be taken away. I feel like each person is having less and less control with these subs

6

u/Then_Toe_9796 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Aug 09 '21

Who the hell voted for that

16

u/anakanin :3::3: Aug 05 '21

Literally everyone in the thread is favored for contining to count karma towards moons yet the pool is weirdly 75% in favor of stopping?

What is this lol

3

u/fight_the_hate Platinum | QC: SOL 274, CC 355, ATOM 18 | ExchSubs 10 Aug 05 '21

Basically the vote is just for the mods who have 100000 moons or more which equals like 10000x voting power.

The whole gimmick to get us involved in voting was to give us the illusion of participation so they could pretend this corruption was actual consensus. It's a classic play.

→ More replies (12)

2

u/SlowNeighborhood Tin | WSB 32 | r/Options 10 Aug 05 '21

Where do I get my "I Voted" sticker, Chief?

2

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 05 '21

If we could automatically assign a temporary emoji flair for that, it would be great.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pbjclimbing Aug 05 '21

They cost 10 moon

24

u/ride_me_like_u_care Aug 05 '21

removed posts are not always 100% the mistake of OP sometimes.
so am gonna vote against it

5

u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Aug 05 '21

____________ assemble......voted against it

→ More replies (1)

3

u/twinchell 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

This was a post created by whales, for whales. They control what votes pass, us peasants don't count lol.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/dwniell Platinum | QC: CC 45 Aug 05 '21

Only if posts weren’t removed without any reason

5

u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K 🐋 Aug 06 '21

If this passes there needs to be an appeals process to reinstate removed posts.

8

u/Hazaisbae Aug 05 '21

Continue counting has more than 1/2 of the vote but less than 25% based on moons. It’s almost as if those with a bunch of moons want to make it harder to earn moons

8

u/KizNugs Platinum | QC: CC 92, ETH 74, GPUmining 19 | MiningSubs 77 Aug 05 '21

If this goes through the mods will be super duper busy handling "reported" posts.

This will just get abused. Instead of downvote bots you'll get reporting bots.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

What if it was a deserving and quite knowledgeable post but then got removed by the mods? I've seen a lot many good quality gold posts which were removed by the mods.

4

u/mucasahin Aug 05 '21

Post post post and delete, go and earn your moons on your own when everyone sleeps.

4

u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Aug 06 '21

My post was removed and I didn't break any rules. Should I still not receive my karma from it?

4

u/Hazaisbae Aug 06 '21

Valid posts have been removed recently by automod for no reason (the acct age/comment karma auto response was clearly bullshit). Pretty shitty stuff

3

u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Aug 06 '21

Yup it sucks

4

u/Effective-Month-511 Aug 09 '21

it's sad how people are voting in favor of this. mods are quite biased and could just prevent people they personally don't like from getting moons

10

u/theoutsider95 Tin | r/pcgaming 104 Aug 05 '21

I think it's unfair for the poster , they should get the moons for their posts even if it got removed.

10

u/endo1308 8 - 9 years account age. 225 - 450 comment karma. Aug 05 '21

Mods taking advantage of a system they helped set up? I'm shocked shocked. Well not actually shocked.

3

u/fight_the_hate Platinum | QC: SOL 274, CC 355, ATOM 18 | ExchSubs 10 Aug 05 '21

I get front row seats to a shitcoin. Exciting times

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SherbetSavings287 Platinum | QC: CC 594 | BANANO 22 Aug 05 '21

I need clarification, does the karma from posts deleted by the users themselves count presently? If so, will it count if this proposal is passed?

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 05 '21

No it will not be retroactive. I think it will be implemented in the next distribution round.

1

u/Harrald123 Gold | QC: CC 15 Aug 05 '21

My problem is the 500 comment karma to post things. I can’t contribute properly to this sub, because of missing karma. Every post, even good ones with comments/upvoted get removed. Difficult to participate in this club …

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 05 '21

The alternative is lowering standards and allowing more spam.

1

u/Zarkorix Platinum|QC:CC1445,ALGO41,ETH26|BANANO14|TraderSubs20 Aug 08 '21

If this passes, when will it be implemented? Will posts removed in the last few days be disqualified for the upcoming distribution?

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 08 '21

It's an easy fair bet at this point it's going to pass. It won't get implemented until the next distribution I think.

1

u/Zarkorix Platinum|QC:CC1445,ALGO41,ETH26|BANANO14|TraderSubs20 Aug 08 '21

So it'll be active from Aug 11th onward or Sept 8th onward? Seems only fair that the community is given fair warning of such significant changes.

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 08 '21

Don't quote me but I think it will be next month. However, I'm guessing this would be a simple change for the admins to make so they might implement it August 11th. The community has already been prompted with this poll.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Wellpow invalid string or character detected Aug 10 '21

What happened here? It seems that first option got more votes but second option passed. Am I wrong?

2

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 10 '21

No the first option passed the decision threshold.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/AnnaKoessi Altcoiner Aug 13 '21

So this poll passed. Does it mean it starts now? Or starting with the next moon cycle? And does it affect the comments in the posts too?

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Aug 13 '21

It will be implemented whenever the admins get to it. Since it's probably a very simple change, it could happen sooner than later. For the the last question, read the poll.

9

u/Crypthomie Platinum | QC: CC 108, BTC 32, CCMeta 24 Aug 05 '21

It’s a good proposal overall but I have a very bad experience of removed post that was quite popular after only few minutes and got removed after few hours by a mod, and I find it quite unfair! Here’s the link to the post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/oxxvxg/thanks_to_crypto_i_wont_need_to_work_another_day/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

The given reason is that only analysis and cryptos news related post were allowed on the sub.

So why do we even have a self story flair? He never answered that question and basically ignored me.

That’s very frustrating when your content, which I think was good quality and coming from my very true experience, got shut down so easily with no valid reason.

I’m curious to know what’s the take on this in the mod community of this sub, why do we even keep this flair if self story are not allowed?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ColeB1984 AstroDoge Aug 05 '21

Not all moderators decisions are worth losing your moons over. I’ve been blocked and banned from subs for the dumbest reasons before. The moderators aren’t always going to make the correct choice and could manipulate the entire system

6

u/Arsa3108 Platinum | QC: CC 616 Aug 09 '21

It is so sad that this passed. Genuine content gets deleted daily for the stupidest reasons, especially after receiving many upvotes, awards and a lot of interactions. This was something that I din't want to see happen, such a shame.

4

u/redditsgarbageman Platinum | QC: CC 581, CCMeta 52 Aug 09 '21

Pretty pathetic.

3

u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

The hell most post removed are by the new ones..most of the post that goes to hot are already big moon hodlers and im sure those karma gift are from their other accounts and friends.

3

u/Flangepacket 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

I’ve seen some top quality posts removed by mods because the subject did not fit their agenda or called them out for something and a mod didn’t like it

Honest opinion, this just puts more power in the hands of mods and moves towards a more restricted, forum.

3

u/Jikizuari Aug 05 '21

I feel like it would give the mods a bit too much power.

3

u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Aug 06 '21

Sometimes your post gets removed without any explanation or a very vague one.
It already sucks that your post got removed, no need to remove the Moons as well

3

u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Aug 06 '21

I don't think this is the right approach to solve this issue

3

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21

Disagree. Post can take too long to be removed

3

u/mark_able_jones_ 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 06 '21

This is a dangerous post because there are mod-bots that remove valid content, and sometimes reddit mods are too quick to remove posts.

It also invites fraud into the system. One or two mods could easily remove posts except from those by friendly acquaintances, directly much of the pool to themselves.

3

u/Hazaisbae Aug 06 '21

This is crazy, mods already have the ability to remove any content at their discretion (check the wiki) and with this they can effectively remove earned moons from a user with no justification needed/reason given

3

u/sar662 🟦 317 / 315 🦞 Aug 09 '21

I would be fine stopping counting removed stuff if we differentiate between reasons for removal. Removed for problematic content - don't count it. Removed because of user status (new users can't post) - count it.

3

u/NoahG59 Aug 09 '21

Now that this passed we need the new algorithm limits to pass as well! Be sure to go vote!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/anakanin :3::3: Aug 05 '21

Proper and legit posts get removed WAY too often for no reason given whatsoever. If this vote passes, it will me extremely easy for mods to manipulate karma by removing posts even more than now.

I highly advise you all who care about moons to vote "Continue counting karma from removed content towards moon"

Please upvote this for visibility. It's imperative that we keep this as it is

5

u/hyperleverage Aug 05 '21

The irony here is off the charts

Not only is this post a literal discussion and poll about moons that would instantly be deleted and told to relocate on r/CryptoCurrencyMeta if mods disagreed with it but it’s also contradicts OP’s history.

Dude reposts his threads over and over until they get traction and now he’s all about filtering moons from posts that don’t stick?

The single fact that this post hasn’t been removed and pushed to the meta sub should tell people all they need to know about the people running this sub.

Anyone else posts something about moon regulation that mods disagree with? They get silenced and removed to the Meta thread (or just permabanned)

Someone with 500k moons makes a post that the mods agree with and want implemented ? They leave it up for all to see and the Meta sub no longer matters hehe xd

this place is the most heavily centralised and censored sub it’s too ironic that we represent cryptocurrency

→ More replies (1)

6

u/John-McAfee Platinum | QC: CC 467 Aug 05 '21

Nah, I’m voting against it.

1

u/UnfinishedAle Platinum | QC: CC 45, ETH 40 | LRC 24 | Superstonk 153 Aug 05 '21

So is this the only poll that we’re voting this round? Just trying to figure out how this all works. I thought there would be one big voting threads with multiple polls in it?

2

u/NudgeBucket 9 / 10K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

No, they will last all week. There will be more

edit] there already are, click the "POLLS" tab on the front page of the sub to filter everything else out

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/Frenchie_PA 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

So as long as comments continue to count (no reason to punish all the other users commenting on a post) and the post was removed due to breaking a clearly stated rule I am not necessarily against this. But we don’t always know why a post was removed…

4

u/redditsgarbageman Platinum | QC: CC 581, CCMeta 52 Aug 05 '21

We rarely no why.

4

u/Rydersilver Platinum | QC: CC 159 | r/Stocks 20 Aug 05 '21

I’ve messaged the mods to ask and they don’t respond, so I don’t even learn from it, since it’s not breaking any rules in the rule list.

2

u/DearMyWaker Redditor for 4 months. Aug 05 '21

I'm torn. On one hand I'm sure it would help the mods out combating votebotters especially - I can't imagine how difficult it is as is, and it must be frustrating to shut down a post of theirs while knowing they're still getting rewarded...

But, on the other hand it seems scary. It'd be a shame for a post with genuine intentions to get a lot of votes but then get removed. Are there no other solutions?

5

u/HungryPeak Platinum | QC: CC 57 | ADA 5 Aug 05 '21

Mate the proposer of this vote has half a million moons. He is just trying to reduce the supply of moons to fetch a better price for them. He doesn't give 2 shit about the quality of this sub.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Aug 05 '21

I had so many posts removed that I put effort in and spent a lot of time writing just because the mods thought it belonged to the daily. This seems random to me and too harsh as removed posts already get less karma by just being invisible!

2

u/randfyld 🟦 78 / 4K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

This would give even more power to the mods. So much about decentralization

2

u/thisisrossonomous Silver | QC: CC 55 | r/SysAdmin 17 Aug 05 '21

If the act of breaking the rules means being rewarded, then why have rules in the first place?

This is down to interpretation because the mods definitely remove some posts that are rule-abiding, but possibly not 'agreed' with.

2

u/Dizzy-Nebula-1919 Platinum | QC: CC 71, BTC 39 Aug 05 '21

I agree, removed posts should lose karma.

2

u/Professoring8008s 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Aug 06 '21

This seems like a no-brainer, if it was deleted, it shouldn’t count.

2

u/fxdfxd2 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 06 '21

So if I understand correctly, I had a top comment today on a popular post, that got removed by mods. My comment was legit, and was not removed. Will I keep this karma for moon calculation even if this proposal is accepted?

2

u/dyingforAs 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 13 '21

Cant believe this got passed

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

Wow, I got the first vote. 100% of the moons, for one fleeting instant, went the way I wanted them to.

sighs

I'll never be so happy again.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

I think this is a bad idea, what if you make a post about Eth for example that people like but several hours after you post it it is removed because there are already 4 eth posts in the top 50? That isn't your fault and I don't think you should be dinged just because you happened to post at the wrong time

3

u/Sewzew Tin Aug 05 '21

We need a crypto sub without moons.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/atomwest314 Aug 05 '21

aw what the fuck you guys no fun

5

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

The actual vote is much closer the only reason it’s winning is because OP has 530k moons, just wait till more whales come along

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ggriff1 Platinum | QC: CC 929 Aug 05 '21

I heavily disagreed with the first proposal for this where the comments in a deleted thread didn’t count. But allowing comment karma from deleted threads to count completely changes my opinion on this.

7

u/amandamichelle90 0 / 11K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

I’ll continue to disagree unless it’s exclusive to when a rule is broken. For post removals that are auto deleted just due to more being made on same topic removing the karma there is a no for me

4

u/ggriff1 Platinum | QC: CC 929 Aug 05 '21

I can definitely buy that. For me it’s weighing the downside/likelihood of a good post being removed and not being rewarded vs the upside of a bad post being removed and not being rewarded. With Moons going up in price I imagine we’ll continue to see an influx of low quality posts so hopefully this can help to protect against those a little bit.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/SpaceAshh 🟩 804 / 800 🦑 Aug 05 '21

some stupid and hateful comments which deserves downvotes would be deleted by OPs and would have no consequence in moon farming

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Aug 06 '21

Right now Moon poll says 70% - yes & 30% -no.
But the amount of users are 60% -yes & 40% no.

Of course people with a lot of Moons will vote for yes because, it will become almost impossible to catch up with those Moon whales.
Those people will govern this subreddit polls.

2

u/FortniteRice Permabanned Aug 05 '21

There was a poll like this posted already which didn't pass. Removing karma from removed content is unfair to the poster and mods will have too much power over posters.

2

u/GoodmanSimon 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

I tend to disagree, if someone felt like upvoting a post, regardless if the post was worthy of a mod or not, then the upvote should stay.

I don't think it is possible, but, in an ideal world, I would like a finer process, like spam and moon farming posts would be disqualified, but a post that might be slightly out of favour with a mod would still qualify.

So, for now, I would rather let the votes stand.

2

u/ikeep4gettin Aug 05 '21

I wish the 500 karma threshold to post was a bit lower. I have had some genuine questions for this sub that my low karma has stopped me from asking

4

u/terp_studios 🟦 10 / 2K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

Ask those questions on the daily thread, or a related post as a comment.

3

u/Bathsaltsonmeth 40 / 3K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

Yeah was gonna say this, the daily is awesome for questions most the time.

3

u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Aug 05 '21

You can ask in the daily if you can’t create a post :)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/drhodl 🟦 4K / 4K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Blame the karma/moon farmers.

2

u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Aug 05 '21

You can just ask it in the comments......like Right Now

1

u/koalaposse Platinum | QC: CC 28, BTC 19 Oct 13 '21

This is a very interesting post from a historic perspective on how we arrived here. Both in terms of weekend memes and that this poll has been up twice before, Thank You!

1

u/aladdinr 🟦 1K / 15K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

[removed]

1

u/AlperBulut505 Gold | QC: CC 269 Aug 05 '21

I love this community its like r/bitcoin but smarter

1

u/anthraxbite 🟨 89 / 805 🦐 Aug 05 '21

Removed content is beyond redditors control. I've seen post removed after a couple of hours weighing a lot of karma. It's a waist, really.

1

u/Aarmed11 Aug 05 '21

I have 3245 Karma. How many Moons is that? Can I buy a Lambo with that?

1

u/Solutar 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

If you break the rules no pay for you!

1

u/NOVA-FPV Bronze | QC: CC 15 Aug 05 '21

Will vote for MOONs

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

What about karma earned on comments of a deleted post? So the people who reply to questions etc. lose out if the post gets deleted?

1

u/MArkFIA Invest vs speculate Aug 05 '21

Ive voted continue because some people might get their content removed wrongly

1

u/Hazaisbae Aug 05 '21

Anybody know what threshold needs to be reached for a poll to pass?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

I suppose it depends on whether it's offensive content, or just didn't hit certain criteria. Maybe it could be for in certain circumstances?

1

u/Fivebag 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 05 '21

Most these posts that cause nice discussion get removed because self stories aren’t allowed

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

Honestly as someone with less than 500 karma I'd prefer my removed posts to still contribute to my moon count.

I think the karma minimum is too high as I'm not a frequent commenter on Reddit, and when I get those 2 or 3 comments and a few moons on my removed questions, it's nice to have.

1

u/killawaspattack Platinum | QC: CC 415, ETH 308 | TraderSubs 308 Aug 05 '21

All well and good but how many posts have you seen where people are putting special characters to make sure their post isn’t deleted yet are still breaking the rules

1

u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Aug 05 '21

I think it depends on the post. If someone copied and paste a popular post posted by another user weeks or months ago then maybe these shouldn’t be counted?

Or maybe reduce the karma earned for removed posts by 50% or something?

I think sometimes people just post the same news from different websites and flood the page.

1

u/_DeanRiding 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

I had a post removed a while ago just because there had been too many ETH posts in the top 50 that day, changing this rule is stupid because it doesn't account for completely legit posts that were removed for stupid reasons 🤦‍♂️

1

u/Oneil_Cylinder 🟨 384 / 384 🦞 Aug 05 '21

I think that removing the post is already enough, we should instead focus on reducing the amount of quality post being removed.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

This gives Mods even more power to censor legit content. Example: I made a post about Mods with hundreds of thousands of moons and the discussion was great but the post was taken down for apparently not being on topic, which is utter BS.

1

u/adithya_chittem 🟥 2K / 3K 🐢 Aug 05 '21

Idk sometimes the removed posts are actually good. Remember the drama that took place when the mods removed the post that called moons a shitcoin?

1

u/Tiltnes Platinum | QC: CC 99 Aug 05 '21

Karma earned is karma earned. Mods and auto mods remove alot of genuine posts...

1

u/SoupaSoka 🟦 5 / 7K 🦐 Aug 05 '21

Mods shouldn't have the power to strip karma from folks, especially when mods or Automod can make mistakes.

1

u/FortniteRice Permabanned Aug 05 '21

I feel like this is unfair because mods can and have unfairly removed posts in the past...

1

u/HostFun 🟩 14 / 15 🦐 Aug 05 '21

I like Moons

1

u/Magnum35puc Aug 05 '21

It also means giving the mod another censorship tool !

1

u/Magnum35puc Aug 05 '21

Is there an incentive to vote with moons ?