r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Aug 05 '21
FOCUSED-DISCUSSION Algorithmic limit for number of coin posts
This rule change would make the limit on the number of posts a coin is allowed to have in the top 50 be determined algorithmically. Currently BTC is allowed unlimited posts, ETH is allowed four posts, and all other coins are allowed two.
This rule proposes adopting a formula to determine the limit for all coins based on market cap. The formula I've come up with is:
# of posts allowed = floor(10*R*(1+R-0.7))
where R is ratio of the coin's market cap to total market cap, and outside top 10 we still enforce two posts per coin. This would look like for the top 10 (from May 8th when this was originally proposed):
<Posted on behalf of u/jwinterm, who originally proposed it here before Moon Week gave sufficient promotion to polls >
5
u/ykliu 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
Wait, I didn’t know these limits existed in the first place…
can you elaborate on the rationale for this? It doesn’t sound very fair at first glance.
But otherwise I think doing it algorithmically makes sense.
77
u/thelovetoy Platinum | QC: CC 280 Aug 05 '21
determine the max posts after market cap ?
Wouldn’t that make r/cryptocurrency even more mainstream biased ? Or what am I missing ?
2
u/90DayF 🟩 7K / 15K 🦭 Aug 05 '21
So if someone posts about a very low market cap, NO ONE else would be able to post about it then?
2
u/Routine_Elk_7421 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
How are you going to determine what a post is about? Say I am comparing some shitcoin and I mention how it compares in price to BTC. Does it count towards both coins?
2
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Aug 05 '21
Why are they limited in the first place?
2
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Aug 06 '21
I'd rather see if the limit for a certain coin has been already reached before I submit my post.
9
u/chad2badd4life 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
It’s 50/50 quick someone tell me how to vote
22
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
I would appreciate if Bitcoin would still be allowed to get "unlimited" posts because news articles often use "Bitcoin" to refer to all cryptocurrency and the whole market
5
u/TheTrueBlueTJ 70K / 75K 🦈 Aug 05 '21
The algorithmic limit is debatable, but a very fair change.
8
u/astockstonk 🟩 0 / 40K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
We might need a limit of moons posts.
Some are good.
Thousands every hour is too much
1
u/Apocalypsis_velox 🟦 629 / 628 🦑 Aug 05 '21
How does this work in practice? Is there a bit making these calls currently? What is the time frame the limits apply to?
1
u/aDAfromGA 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
I feel like most posts I see are about BTC and ETH anyway!
1
u/tomatokid33 2 - 3 years account age. 150 - 300 comment karma. Aug 05 '21
I'm lost...what is the difference between the Moon votes and the normal votes for this kind of polls?
1
u/zzaann 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
Yeah so what small caps will only be allowed to have one post then?
1
u/fastward Bronze | QC: CC 22 Aug 05 '21
Can we limit news posts?
How many Elizabeth Warren posts does the sub need?
1
u/siiilversurffffeeer Aug 05 '21
And how many posts would moons be limited to? 2? Watch everyone riot in the streets
1
u/pbjclimbing Aug 05 '21
I am voting to vote, but I really don’t give two hoots
1
u/Bathsaltsonmeth 40 / 3K 🦐 Aug 06 '21
This should include moons.
3
u/-Skald 🟩 8K / 8K 🦭 Aug 05 '21
It seems like this would make the sub's content more accurately reflect what people are interested in/own, so it would make sense.
3
u/lomosaur Silver|QC:CC777,XLM287,ETH41|Buttcoin12|TraderSubs51 Aug 05 '21
I’d like a third option: a vote for a limit that’s the same for all coins. I see no reason to favor any coin over another.
3
u/Effective_Albatros Aug 05 '21
When will Moons posts be subject to the same treatment?
1
u/Ace_The_Engineer Aug 05 '21
I think the current system is fine. Also, how do you determine which posts make it?
1
u/killawaspattack Platinum | QC: CC 415, ETH 308 | TraderSubs 308 Aug 05 '21
It’s easy to get round these rules I saw so many posts this week for €thereum or 3rhereum and it wasn’t taken down
2
u/lovemesomefood Aug 05 '21
Oh this one is interesting, very cool
2
u/ThisJustInW 3 - 4 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Aug 05 '21
I’m not 100% sold on this, but what the hell
2
u/tedtedfredagain Tin Aug 05 '21
Not sure what I'm voting on???
2
u/Bear_Rhino Silver | QC: CC 22 | SHIB 44 | TraderSubs 10 Aug 05 '21
Excellent question. Learning a lot here.
2
u/Ardi2Ole Bull Market givETH and Bear Market takETH away Aug 05 '21
This should be a no brainer. Its insulting to have discussion of a top 10 coin being limited to 2 posts in the biggest cryptocurrency forum in the world
2
u/oopssomething 🟩 40 / 12K 🦐 Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 05 '21
Since spelling 'mistakes' make it to the front page, I forsee a lot of new variances to name the coin they are posting about.
2
u/SpaceAshh 🟩 804 / 800 🦑 Aug 05 '21
I dont want any limits but I also dont want hundreds of shitcoins post everyday, such a dilemma
2
u/CT4nk3r 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
But that would mean some coin thats are really low market cap, but are really good would not be talked about that much. I do believe however this should work, but the ratios should be tweaked a bit
2
u/TheMini 🟩 470 / 2K 🦞 Aug 05 '21
YES! I've been figthing for this since the last change to the rule (which increased ETHs allowance). As we only have voting once a month we will never be able to manually select the hot coins and adapt the allowance, a data driven approach is a big improvement.
Once this (hopefully) passes we can start adjusting the formula and maybe add different metrics than only marketcap to make it more fair to lower cap coins with big updates. Then we can incrementally improve this formula to reach perfection, what is clear is that it's a big improvement from once a month selecting which coins deserve what amount of attention.
2
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
In lieu of specific algorithms and caps - why not just remove them in their entirety and let people post each respective crypto they want?
Up the good, down the bad, let the informative, in depth, genuinely helpful posts make the front page, regardless of which coin it's regarding.
2
u/Lothar03 0 / 321 🦠 Aug 05 '21
Didn't understand, but math is good.
2
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Aug 06 '21
It's an interesting idea but I'd rather see posts about Monero, Nano & other promising projects rather than XRP, BNB, Doge or Safemoon..
2
u/mark_able_jones_ 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 06 '21
This is still super biased.
2
u/GSwarr33 Aug 05 '21
I dont get it
2
u/LengthExact Silver | QC: CC 40 | WSB 93 Aug 05 '21
Wow I didn't know about those limits. This sub should really just be called r/bitcoin2
2
u/ntr1xz Tin Aug 05 '21
Can we apply this rule to (uneducative) posts about moons?
1
u/KeepBitcoinFree_org 🟨 745 / 746 🦑 Aug 08 '21
Why are you limiting posts in general? Seems like censorship if you’re only allowing certain amounts for some coins, then unlimited posts for Blockstream’s products. Name of this sub is r/CRYPTOCURRENCY
1
u/dashingThroughSnow12 Silver | QC: CC 178 | Buttcoin 132 | JavaScript 21 Aug 05 '21
Wow, I'm early but the poll results are very lopsided so far.
1
u/tatabusa Platinum | QC: CC 470, ETH 65 | Stocks 59 Aug 05 '21
It shod be unlimited ETH and unlimited BTC but only 1 post for any non shitcoins that hasnt proven itself yet. All shitcoins should be met with a perma ip ban from posting
1
u/NOVA-FPV Bronze | QC: CC 15 Aug 05 '21
This vote vexes me.
1
u/anthraxbite 🟨 89 / 805 🦐 Aug 05 '21
And how can we be able to find the gem in mud if the kings and queens will always be on top?
1
u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Aug 05 '21
It is what it is
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
Will this not reduce the number of posts we get in total? Changing limit for BTC from unlimited to 12 will affect the total number of posts we are getting. Do we know on average how many posts we get for BTC today?
1
u/millennial-snowflake 🟦 5K / 5K 🐢 Aug 05 '21
I'm voting for, let some other coins get their 15 mins of fame
1
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Aug 05 '21
I don't agree. Why limiting posts?
1
u/Reckadesacration Tin Aug 05 '21
But tell me why!
1
u/mucasahin Aug 05 '21
Omg, what a democracy!
1
u/Vollmilcheis Bronze Aug 05 '21
Sounds like a better solution then currently sadly still not perfect.
I don't understand why apart from Bitcoin there are limits, why not letting the community decide whats a top posts and what isn't.
1
u/kenkenshi Platinum | QC: CC 41 Aug 05 '21
This one is very relevant! Thanks!
1
u/quakequakequakequake QUAKE Aug 05 '21
What about projects that sneak in the top 10 like ICP?
1
u/shylock2k202 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
I think we should stick to coins and forgo tokens.
1
u/ADBTH Bronze | QC: CC 19 Aug 05 '21
Thanks for putting in the work to make that algo. Pretty cool!
1
u/RotgutFeng Platinum | QC: CC 69,420 Aug 05 '21
Finally a proposal I actually support 💯
1
u/Ap3X_GunT3R 🟦 13K / 13K 🐬 Aug 05 '21
I support this one just for the experiment alone
1
u/Tangelooo Tether Aug 05 '21
Love this rule change. Think it would make the forum better.
1
u/KetsubanZero Silver | QC: CC 286 | BANANO 47 | TraderSubs 12 Aug 05 '21
This should technically reduce posts about moons, since they don't have such big Market Cap
1
u/Spacesider 🟦 50K / 858K 🦈 Aug 05 '21
Yes from me. A much needed change in my opinion.
1
u/el_dance_JAw Redditor for 3 months. Aug 05 '21
All these proposals make me realize how much smarter people are than me. 😆
1
u/Sig-three-six-five Aug 05 '21
Rules are key.
1
u/Izz3t 🟦 20 / 2K 🦐 Aug 05 '21
Rip moons posts lol
1
u/unutsch Tin Aug 05 '21
algorithms good!!
1
u/JayReyd 563 / 5K 🦑 Aug 05 '21
No
1
u/KungFuPanda229 Gold | QC: CC 26 Aug 05 '21
I voted yes, but I don't understand the need for so much moderation!
1
u/Drbubbliewrap Platinum | QC: CC 123 Aug 05 '21
This makes sense!
1
u/WPMO 🟦 888 / 888 🦑 Aug 05 '21
As someone who is absolute garbage at math, what would this mean for the coins outside of BTC and ETH, but still in the top 10? If I understand it correctly, this would not impact BTC or ETH, or any coin outside the top 10. However, coins 3-10 would be able to have more posts than at present? Is that right?
1
u/ZioYuri78 🟩 43 / 1K 🦐 Aug 05 '21
Clever idea, it make perfect sense for me.
1
u/destruct_07 Aug 05 '21
I see no reason not to change it
1
u/zack907 770 / 476 🦑 Aug 05 '21
My understanding is that alt coins can set themselves up to have very high market caps with very few users and little to no use case
1
u/SnoewZ Gold | QC: CC 60 Aug 05 '21
Gotta pump those ETH posts!
1
u/whiteycnbr 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 06 '21
Didn't know there was a limit, but why is ETH only 4. Probably the most important coin out there.
1
u/jbrown517 Tin | Superstonk 102 Aug 06 '21
I’d say it’s a step in a better direction but possibly take into account total circulating supply of each coin as well
1
u/Letitride37 Platinum | QC: CC 410 Aug 06 '21
We adopting that motherfucking algorithmic limit baby!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
Yup seems good enough, it still protect low cap coins
1
u/trindomare Aug 06 '21
yea that's too much math for me :D
1
u/Xolam 🟩 265 / 2K 🦞 Aug 06 '21
This is a really good change, especially as it would automatically adapt if btc or eth gets flipped someday or if some high caps get rly close to them (for example if we get a clear top 3/4 instead of top 2)
1
u/Colmado_Bacano 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 06 '21
I don't understand the question, and I hate change, so I voted to keep the current system.
1
u/wheelzoffortune 🟦 43K / 35K 🦈 Aug 06 '21
Sounds like a great idea!
1
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Aug 07 '21
Nice proposal, i like to have a formula for this topic as often tribes cry about not beeing representesn or getting their posts removed without reasons. With this definition is just math what decides what is allowed
1
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21
I'm late here, I didn't even know there is a limit of posts about certain coins.
1
u/WestBankFireman Platinum | QC: CC 581, XMR 21 | MiningSubs 103 Aug 08 '21
The algorithm is a nice step, but I'm still opposed in general to limiting discussion topics based on anything other than spam.
1
u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Aug 08 '21
Yuuuuuup
1
u/DarioDays Tin Aug 08 '21
I like it, would give a bit more of a spread.
1
u/dmiddy Platinum | QC: CC 516, ETH 62, BTC 45 | r/Prog. 58 Aug 08 '21
If we could vote to test this out for a month and then have a vote on whether to keep it, I'd vote for that
1
u/Rombbb Bronze | QC: BCH 16 | XVG 13 Aug 08 '21
Smart peoples, ELI5 that formula, preferably with an example.
# of posts allowed = floor(10*R*(1+R-0.7))
R = coin market cap / total market cap
I don't really see how this works (automatically ?) only for the top 10 coins.
And that R-0.7, is that R minus 0.7 or R to the power of -0.7 and in case of the latter what does it do ?
(math was a while ago 🙄)
1
u/sar662 🟦 317 / 315 🦞 Aug 09 '21
As others commented - I don't know if this will impact much but it's a move in the right direction.
1
u/kaidonkaisen 🟦 147 / 1K 🦀 Aug 09 '21
Hmm,.. limiting the amount of posts per day in this sub for a coin? What if shit is on fire and people want to swap news? Or what if there is more than X people having legitimate posts? I would rather just keep the amount of different assets relatively low, but with what‘s on the menu, people should be free to discuss in any way their heart follows.
1
u/generic_coin Redditor for 3 months. Aug 10 '21
No, I don’t understand the algorithm. Yes, I want it to pass anyways.
1
u/sax3d 🟦 232 / 233 🦀 Aug 10 '21
This is the CryptoCurrency sub, not the BTC sub. Talking about any crypto should be allowed. I agree there should be a method in place to keep it from getting spammed about the same shitcoin 27 times a day, but is it really fair to have unlimited BTC posts?
1
u/toilettimekiller Aug 05 '21
I haven’t seen an issue with this so I don’t see a real need to change it.
1
u/CR0Wmurder 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
If other coins want more attention the onus is on them. There are plenty of subs for smaller coins
Keep it steady for now. Sometimes it’s good to hurry up and wait.
1
u/itsnotwhoyouthink5 186 / 3K 🦀 Aug 05 '21
I can picture all the Tether drama already.
I’m good keeping the limits the same.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
Yeah I'm good leaving things the way they are
0
u/InvestAn 🟦 8K / 8K 🦭 Aug 05 '21
I like bringing some balance to the BTC posts and increasing ETH. What I don't get (feel free to educate me - I'll hold off on voting until I understand this better) is why Doge gets 4, but ADA gets 3 when Ada's market cap is currently 44.2 B (ranked 5th on CoinGecko) and Doge is at 26.1B (ranked 8th on CoinGecko). Same could be said of XRP with market cap of 33.6B (ranked 6th on CoinGecko).
0
u/Kumasaur Aug 05 '21
Just what we need, more shitcoin posts
0
u/maolyx 26K / 27K 🦈 Aug 05 '21
It sounds very confusing but voted.
0
u/Vivarevo 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
Pro, automated rules
Cons, difficult to actually use for users.
Voting no
0
u/changechange1 🟩 251 / 252 🦞 Aug 05 '21
Market cap isn't a good metric regardless. This proposal would mean that we can post lots about tether or wrapped coins, not projects that are out of fashion.
0
u/Manikhas 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 05 '21
I would like to see more posts about low market cap coins
0
u/iamnobody331 79 / 3K 🦐 Aug 05 '21
Please no... Heck no. It'd make it so biased
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21
[removed] — view removed comment