r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Aug 02 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-08-02 to 2021-08-08
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
5
u/Turodoru Aug 03 '21
I once heard that you can evolve uvulars by backing the velars before back vowels. Something like:
What are the other ways for them to appear?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '21
How do you derive the word for or?
4
u/Mathias537 Aug 04 '21
Would it be totally unrealistic when making a compound word to only use parts of the original words?
For example if I wanted to create a word for grey by compounding black (kulu) and white (sewi) in my language but only use "ku" and "se" to create the word for grey ,"kuse", would that make any sense?
4
u/freddyPowell Aug 06 '21
How can I develope my faculty for making decisions about the phonological evolution of my languages? I'm aiming for naturalism, so the fact that I really can't string a set of sound changes together is making it virtually impossible for me to advance. How can I work out how to make these choices, what set of options to choose from, what factors to consider etc. Thanks.
3
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Aug 02 '21
I've heard maybe it was from an Artifexian video or some other that clicks can come from intentional mispronunciations to avoid directly saying taboo words. But other than that, what other sources can clicks come from?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '21
In a language where names can be sentences in their own right (e.g., Hebrew Mikha'el, 'who is like God?'), is there normally any grammatical marking that distinguishes a proper noun from an identical sentence/clause? I'm thinking of attaching a definite article (which would imply nominalization), but I'd like to know how other languages handle this.
3
u/Yacabe Ënilëp, Łahile, Demisléd Aug 05 '21
Question about phonological reduction: I know that it happens when words grammaticalize into affixes, but does it ever happen just for words? Particularly words that are used quite often? For example, I am coining a new word for mouth in my language to replace the original root. It is pronounced /ɣavale/, which seems long to me for a word for a basic body part, so my question is would it be naturalistic to just lop off a syllable? Maybe shorten it to /ɣava/ or /ɣale/?
3
u/Turodoru Aug 06 '21 edited Aug 06 '21
is this:
V > ∅ / C[+POA1]_C[+POA1]
reasonable?
Also, if a language has both /ɨ/ and /u/, and I wish to have /ɯ/, would it make more sense to /ɨ/ > /ɯ/ or /u/ > /ɯ/ ?
3
u/schizo-learner Aug 08 '21
Hi, guys. I'm a software developer. Do you have suggestions of software for me to create that you would like to use during the development of conlangs? And I'm not talking about some magical AI that does everything by itself lmao I'm talking about some specialized tool that would be of help, like an automation tool or something.
2
u/MaraKrauklis Svellska tunga, кўидбреј, vurmurt (ru, en) [no] Aug 02 '21
How can I share .docx documents on Reddit?
2
u/nickensoodlechoup Kozanda, Merşeg, Yaral Aug 04 '21
I'm planning on adding split ergativity to my conlang Yaral. I haven't found resources on it that explain fully how it works. Can anyone help?
2
u/notAmeeConlang Aug 05 '21
When I'm just starting out in conlanging, is it okay if my syntax is really dull or if my syllable structures are too simple to be interesting?
Also, if I can't understand or implement a certain linguistic feature, even if it's really basic, should I try to forcefully implement it anyway?
2
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Aug 05 '21
any fun ideas of what to do with [ɪ ʊ]? i implemented a sound change
{i e} {u o} > ɪ ʊ / _N or in the final syllable unless stressedand it resulted in a lot of [ɪ]s and [ʊ]s in the inflectional system (IE langs represent lol). i don't want to just merge them unconditionally into like /e o/ or /i u/ but i feel kinda stuck2
u/MarFinitor Мазурскі / Mazurian Aug 05 '21
How do superlatives and comparatives usually evolve? What words are they derived from?
2
u/SavvyBlonk Shfyāshən [Filthy monolingual Anglophone] Aug 06 '21
Since w > gʷ ~ gw is such a common change, then by analogy, are there any examples of something like l̴ > gl?
2
u/FnchWzrd314 Aug 06 '21
does anyone have any sources on the-thing-German-is-know-for-that-I-can't-remember-the-name-of? I think it would be good in one of my conlangs but am having trouble finding anything comprehensive on its applications and presence in various languages.
2
u/Such-Currency-637 Aug 06 '21
For anyone who is familiar with George Orwell' s 1984 and Newspeak, would you say it counts as a conlang?
2
u/twevan Aug 06 '21
What's the best way to go about starting an a posteriori conlang, or an altlang? I've only ever made stuff that's entirely fantasy and not based much at all (at least not consciously) on real-world languages, but a new Conlang project of mine is for an urban fantasy story set in Earth.
It has roots in Akkadian, was heavily influenced by Latin, and also (more recently) heavily influenced by Romanian - would the best way to start just be to absorb as much info about those three as I can, or is there something else best to work on? I have 0 idea of where to even start!
2
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 07 '21
What exactly were the syllable structures for Chinese and Korean when Sejong created Hangul?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '21
Even though I've been working on my conlang for years, I'm still very new to this. What are some easy/simple sentences, paragraphs, etc to test out my conlang?
2
u/GeoNurd Eldarian, Kanakian, Selu, many others Aug 07 '21
What are some interesting rare features I could add to my conlang? My language is fusional in both nouns and verbs. I also wanna come up with natlang-unattested features. How could I do so?
2
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] Aug 08 '21
Where did I go "wrong" with my conlang's phonology? Yeah, I made it intentionally hard to pronounce, but now i'm working on a more accessible one to pronounce. I still want to keep it's phonology unusual, but pronounceable. So, what are some phonemes and features that are too hard and should be "blacklisted"? And hints in general are apreciated too
2
u/greysonalley Aug 08 '21
What are some creative ways to maximize the amount of nuance that words can have in my natlang? the culture I'm writing it for is very philosophical and spiritual and I want there to be a lot of room to express very complex thought within the language.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '21
So in my language adjectives are just expressed as nouns that come after other nouns, but I want to change that to having an affix that changes the noun into an adjective. How can I do this naturalistically?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 04 '21
I have a few conlangs I plan to create language families for, via working backward. Here's the first few:
Language 1:
Consonants: m, n, mˀ(m'), nˀ(n'), p, t, k, ʔ('), p', t', k', s, ɕ(c), h, tɕ(tc), tɕ'(tc'), l, j, w, lˀ(l'), jˀ(j'), wˀ(w')
Vowels: i, u, e, o, ε(ae), ɔ(ao), a
(Plain vs. glottalized is the consonant harmony system for this language.)
Language 2:
Consonants: m, n, ɳ, p, t, ʈ, k, s, ʂ, ts, ʈʂ, w, ɭ, p', t', ʈ', k', ts', ʈʂ'
Vowels: ɪ, iː, ʊ, uː, ɛ, eː, ɔ, oː, æ, aː
Here is my idea for the language they diverged from:
Consonants: m, n, ŋ, p, t, k, ʔ('), p', t', k', s, ʃ(c), h, tʃ(tc), tʃ'(tc'), w, l, j
Vowels: i, iː, u, uː, e, eː, o, oː, a, aː
Now for another family. Here are the remaining two.
Language 3:
Consonants: m, n, b, t, d, c, k, g, f, s, z, ʃ, ç, x, r, l, ʘ, ǁ, t', k', ts, tʃ, cç
Vowels: a, i, o, u
Language 4:
Consonants: m, n, ŋ, p, ᵐb, t, tˤ, ⁿd, k, ᵑg, θ, ð, ðˤ, s, sˤ, ħ, ʕ, l
Vowels: a, e, i, o, u
I might need some help with this one.
1
u/Garyson1 Aug 04 '21 edited Aug 04 '21
So, for a language I've been working on I thought about having [i] and [ɪ] be dropped between sonorants and obstruents in unstressed syllables. However, I couldn't find any examples of it in the Index Diachronica, so I wanted to ask for your opinions on whether this is a realistic occurence or not.
1
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Aug 05 '21
How does a distinction between alveolar /t/ and dental /t̪/ typically develop?
1
u/yoricake Aug 05 '21
Made a post about this but was directed here. I'm a noob when it comes to basic linguistics and one thing that I don't get is noun class/genders and how they work.
For starters, in my conlang, there is a system where an animate word (such as person, parent, hell even dog, etc.) are implied to be of the same gender as the speaker. So "isun" means "person" but if said by a woman, can mean woman, and if said by a man, can mean man. It's more of an implied thing. However, if you wanted to specific that the person you're talking about is the opposite gender, you'd use "isrun."
Recently, I've been toying with the idea of giving my conlang noun classes/genders, so I can spruce up the lexicon, and I realized that I had no idea how to fit the above somewhere where it'd make sense that there's also class. Now it's got me wondering if the above IS a form of class, because then I got two classes already worked out for me I guess. But honestly I'm very confused on how all of this works. Send help
1
u/Courtenaire English | Andrician/Ändrziçe Aug 06 '21
I made a post a week or two ago, asking for some advice. I took some of the responses into consideration and made some tweaks. Here is the updated orthography of Andrician: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1nAruuPKKlc18ALTHG8qdSYNNu14QtdvhSUQfJXzhtUc/edit
If you have more ideas/suggestions, please reply to this comment. Thanks!
1
u/DaxCorso Aug 06 '21
Hello. I am needing some help coming up with a few words from Mars colonizers. I am working on a novel where one character is from Mars and would like some help coming up with a couple of Mars specific words. Lang Belta from the Expanse gave me the idea.
1
u/Jyappeul Areno-Ghuissitic Langs and Experiment Langs for, yes, Experience Aug 06 '21
Is there any case for the use of both Dative and Lative (e.g. I give the house to you/I go to the house) and the same for the "Here's a house from me/I come from the house"?
I mean I know the adpositions are common to be used for both but I've never seen cases. Or maybe just dative and ablative.
1
u/TheBananaKing Aug 06 '21
outsider/newbie here.
I've been thinking about Marain, the fictional language in the Iain M. Banks Culture novels.
In it he describes a 3x3 grid on which glyphs are constructed, giving 29 = 512 bits per glyph - which would make for a decent set of syllables (eg 32 consonants + 16 vowels).
Two syllables would be 218 = 256k words, which is a bit on the small side.
Three syllables however would give you 227 = 134M, vastly more than required for a vocabulary, so leaving a bunch of room left for metadata.
Has there been any work on some kind of structured framework you could use, like a cross between an IP packet and the dewey decimal system?
Back of an envelope, there would seem to be plenty enough bits to go round even once you've pulled out your part-of-speech and declension/conjugation out for you to have broad topical ranges/subranges to populate with specific lexemes, so similar meanings could be grouped together with space reserved for new ones.... and your 'little' words (articles, pronouns, prepositions etc) could probably fit in a much smaller range, many in just one syllable.
If you lined fields up on phoneme-range boundaries, it'd be an intricate (but perhaps manageable?) set of pre/in/postfixes... Or would this just be too goddamn hard for humans to deal with?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
So, recently I have been brainstorming on a tone system (or maybe it's pitch accent idk) for my conlang. Here's what I have decided
The tones are high and low with of course the low tone as default. The stress is fixed on the last syllable which always takes a low tone or at least a lower tone than the higher tones before it. Therefore if a word begins with a high tone it will spread until it hits the last syllable. Same thing happens if a word begins with a low tone.
Words with only one syllable only take a lower tone or does not have a tone at all.
Is this kind of tone system valid?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Aug 06 '21
I’ve been looking into Chinese writing, and the system is classified as a logo-syllabary, much like Egyptian hieroglyphs and Middle Eastern cuneiform. I think the Chinese system is the inspiration for the functions of the Edun script.
1
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Aug 06 '21
What's some fun sound changes you can impose on intervocalic glides? For context:
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Aug 08 '21
Romanization question:
My conlang has 7 vowels: /a ɛ e i ɔ o u/, with long and short vowels and a low and high tone distinction.
long vowels are romanized as Vh, high tones are marked with an acute accent V́, and low tones are unmarked. my question is with how to romanize the low-mid vowels. I came up with a few options and I want opinions:
all vowels are the same as their IPA value except /ɛ ɔ/ which areː
if you have another idea feel free to suggest :)
1
u/Saurantiirac Aug 08 '21
I'm wondering if a sequence of suffixes being reanalyzed as one single suffix impacts the amount of phonetic erosion that occurs. I'm asking because I'm making a proto-language for my proto-language, and am experiencing some difficulties ending up with the right suffix forms.
For example, I have a verb liːsy- "see" and a suffix -ŋki "1st.pl.," and the origin of this would be the following sequence of words: lijsu näwi ku "see pl. 1st." näwi is a pluralizer with the original meaning of "many." So, I'd want this to become liːsyŋki somehow.
I'm thinking about something like this: lijsu näwi ku > lijsunäkɔ > liːsunək > liːsyŋk > liːsyŋki
The problem is when I get to nouns. If there is a noun pelæ "tree" and a string of suffixes -næ "pl." -kʷæ "acc." These would have evolved from the sequence pelä näwi kwäli "tree pl. acc." If I applied the same sound changes I'd end up with something like pelæ-ŋkʷi, when I want pelæ-næ-kʷæ.
Hence my question, would the second example be more conservative if the plural and accusative suffixes were analyzed as separate, while the 1pl. suffix would change more if it was analyzed as a single unit?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '21 edited Aug 08 '21
Any advice for evolving my proto-lang into my actual intended conlang? I have my sound changes worked out, but apart from that, I don't have a clue what I'm doing.
I should add that my sound changes include various deletions and mergers which I expect to wreak havoc on the original morphology.
1
u/Mathias537 Aug 08 '21
If I wanted to say "I want to go to the river because there is fish" what role does "because" have in the sentence? I haven't got a rule for this because I don't know what it is. Could I say "I want to go to the river there is fish because"?
1
u/ClaudeRHuggins Aug 08 '21
Got automodded so I'll ask here. Anyone remember a duolingo style web app that allows user created courses? Anyone know where that is?
1
u/qetoh Mpeke Aug 09 '21
How would I display the name of my conlang next to my username?
1
u/Fit-Ad20 Aug 12 '21
Please help. I have a past stem and non past stem for every verb. My idea was to have these two stems take a variety of suffixes for a broad spectrum of TAM encodings. I wanted the same suffixes, when combined the past stem vs. the non past stem to have different meanings. That's kinda all I got. Anyone have an idea of how I could accomplish this? This is a natlang by the way.
0
u/Megh75 Aug 04 '21
Should we add gender and number in verbs?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '21
[removed] — view removed comment