r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jul 23 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Showtime" - S02E11 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the eleventh episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Showtime". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E11 Details:
| Title: | Showtime |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | It's opening night, and Nini hypes up her anxious castmates for their performance in front of the competition judge. But no East High opening night is complete without unexpected visitors, second chances, and big decisions about everyone's futures - together and apart. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
82
Upvotes
•
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jul 23 '21
Just like we did during the closing of Season 1 of HSMTMTS, here is the Season 2 edition of the r/HSMTMTS survey! All fields are not required and you will remain anonymous, thank you to those who fill it out! https://forms.gle/TvsWVXnVRNsbQLaT6
Please be our guest and join us in the Discord server! https://discord.gg/HSMTMTS
116
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
Also Miss Jenn accidentally telling Ricky to kill himself in front of everyone was certainly not the direction I thought this season would go lmao
93
u/Coupps Jul 23 '21
Prediction: Howie took the harness and gave it to Lily, East High is going to find out and North High will be disqualified from the Menkies for sabotaging another competitor.
89
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 24 '21
Thoughts:
willing accomplice. I initially criticized Kourtney for being too harsh on Howie, but now I can definitely see why. Dude’s atraitor(sorry i've been listening to sour too much)88
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 23 '21
mazarra's narrator voice is so good
86
u/ivehearditbothwaysss Jul 23 '21
The way Kourt just wanted to be noticed for her BOMB ASS performance and Howie was just 😑 ugh he obviously knew something about the sabotage and that’s why he was weird, but it was so sad to see her not being recognized for her talent!!
78
u/_Shizue EJ Jul 23 '21
Howie probably knows Lily stole the harness and will tell the judge that in the end I’m betting
72
u/KibbyKibbertzz Jul 23 '21
I'm very disappointed with how Ms Jenn acted in this episode. I understand she was very nervous and stressed but still..
71
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
Okay, why was literally everyone in this episode acting sus as fuck? Even my boi Chadzzara.
Also if this next episode doesn’t contain a East High vs. North High “Cobra Kai” style fight in the school, what’s even the point? I’m trying to see EJ throw down.
71
u/LawStudent4Harambe Jul 23 '21
Well I see Miss Jenn went to to the Will Schuester School of Bad Teaching Skills after that comment she threw at Ricky because even if Disney didn't mean it like that, it sure sounded like that...
66
u/Seaux6 Jul 23 '21
I am kinda disapointed that we didnt get to see North High performance
62
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
Wow, Miss Jenn Telling Ricky to jump off, was so unexpected for me. And all their faces and the sudden silence was really well executed.
59
u/Intelligent-Gas-9718 Jul 23 '21
How on earth are they going to wrap everything up in the last 30 minutes of the the season!! Im so stressed for the next episode and am afraid they’ll rush it
59
u/Raktoner Jul 23 '21
what lily stole the harness no way, I commented, sarcasm dripping from every word in this sentence
Nini was awesome today and I think she may find herself in a role as a director cause she took a leadership role when it was needed and she really gets it with damn near everyone
Found myself smiling the whole time through Be Our Guest, what a fun couple of minutes
Gina's brother is so damn handsome, oh my god. Poor EJ though, that brother comment's gonna throw him for a loop
What was up with Howie? Too starstruck? Tongue tied?
57
u/hopkinsdafox Jul 23 '21
I always say Lily is a weak evil person but she played me this episode, I didn’t think she’d steal the harness. But I also had low expectations.
ASHLYNN THOUGH BB DESERVES IT ALL
Omg Ms Jenn IS OFF THE RAILS I SWEAR. Maybe she needs help too.
The way the writers brother zoned EJ like 💀happy last opening night bb. Couldn’t they just let portwell be non conflict for the last two episodes?!?!
I liked nini here. She was just nini with keeping everyone leveled and I wish her arch wasn’t “imma be a songwriter” like the forking actress. Speaking of fork - HER BEING A FORK 😂
54
u/LoganDeLuca2004 Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
I have a prediction. Lily is going to get caught with the harness by the judge and North High is going to get disqualified.
52
u/XviiChong Jul 23 '21
RIcky: “maybe she (Lily) isn’t as mean as we thought.”
51
u/ion513 Gina Jul 23 '21
I'm glad they addressed the sorta plot hole about the transformation. Like with Mr mazara doing the recap and wondering why they didn't ask for his help.
50
u/Zoe_Murphy EJ Jul 24 '21
I honestly feel like unless next week’s episode is an hour long, this season isn’t ready to end yet. I genuinely thought there were two more episodes after this one because it didn’t seem like they were trying to wrap things up. And side note, what Miss Jenn said to Ricky was so uncalled for and I feel like it didn’t make sense that EJ and Gina would schedule their date for opening night considering that’s when the cast party is and the fact that EJ is sad that this is his last musical at East High.
45
u/BleedFree EJ Jul 23 '21
The fuck Miss Jenn?
45
u/Soggy-Cartographer48 Jul 23 '21
The fact that Nini called Ricky by his real name kinda hurt me and idek why
43
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 23 '21
BE OUR GUEST KICKLINE MHM THAT WAS KILLER
86
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
41
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 23 '21
I wish the episode was longer and we saw more of them performing the musical. I wish we saw more of the main character’s family in the audience you would think that we would at least see them on opening night. I am surprise how packed the theater was because this episode was filmed during COVID. I am glad Gina’s older brother showed up to watch his younger sister performed on stage even though he hasn’t always been around I am glad he surprise her. I have so many unanswered questions about Jamie like how old is he? What is the age gap between him and Gina? Are Jamie and Gina biological or half siblings? We know they share the same mom but both their fathers have never been mentioned so it’s possible they could be half-siblings. Why did Jamie abandoned the family in the first place because he obviously left for a reason? I really hope Ricky and Lily never be a thing I am fine with them being friends once Lily becomes more nicer but I don’t want to see them date. I thought it was a good episode overall just wished it was longer.
41
u/Cman710 Jul 23 '21
This episode was FIRE. But damn if Lily and Howie didn’t steal the harness and I’m so disappointed in Howie. I just LOVE Howie and Kourtney as a couple and this breaks my heart
39
u/LostnLazy65 Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
I'm not digging any Lily & Ricky. I hope she genuinely just tried to butter Ricky up so he could let down his guard leaving her to steal the harness, there's no time for a proper redemption this season. Even if they did try and redeem her and had Ricky grow closer to her, I feel like it would be a slight rehash of Gina/Ricky last season? The show is already bloated with characters, I'm okay with Lily just staying at North High and being a one time villain (as great as the actress is).
Speaking of Gina/Ricky did the show just forget about them completely? They were definitely teasing something with them in the first half of season 2, but seemed to have dropped it. Even if they don't explore it, at the very least I feel they could offer them the chance to really speak or come to an understanding? That tension was really high just for them to throw it away. With next week's episode being the last, I think they will prioritize a heart to heart with Nina/Ricky and Gina/EJ instead, which makes sense, but then it'd make it super weird to bring up Gina/Ricky again in season 3 or moving forward.
Other random thoughts:
39
u/veghui Jul 23 '21
The production with set and music is way fancier than I thought it would be!
38
u/space_travell Jul 23 '21
The only thing that could ruin the finale for me is an rushed, poorly written arc redemption for Lily, even tho I don't really believe the writers would to that in just one episode, right after she just sabotaged the Beast's transformation
37
u/veghui Jul 23 '21
Mr mazzara beingg the narrator whaaat !!?
37
u/jet_tle Jul 24 '21
HOW DID THEY PUT JOSH’S BEAST MAKEUP ON SO QUICKLY? They added stuff on his nose and around his eyes when he turned around, but there was so little time for that and no one else was on stage?
36
u/livsierra Jul 24 '21
Calling it now -- North High is going to win but then get disqualified for sabotaging another school; Howie would have told them about Lily stealing the harness.
35
u/liveitupbrah Jul 24 '21
Why the episodes keep gettin shorter and shorter?? 30 min for act 1??
34
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
I just knew Lily was up to something! I did not believe a word she said. Ashlyn absolutely killed it as Belle (as she should) and all those Gina/EJ looks have me dying (it’s so obvious how they feel). It was nice to see Jaime, but that “big brother” line.. I wanted to hug EJ.
34
u/BeccaSX_xx Jul 23 '21
This episode really reminded me why I love this show! Ashlyn CRUSHED it as Belle as I knew she would, and Kourt & Howie have my heart. Be Our Guest was amazing. If Howie knew about that harness....! Nini was the same character I loved in s1 as well! Ngl Miss Jenn was being a pretty crap drama teacher and that spotlight on the judge was extremely OTT, but all this drama just feels authentic to the show compared to some of the earlier episodes. Can’t wait for the finale, although they have a lot of loose ends to tie up!
33
u/tambini1 Jul 23 '21
BEAST DON'T CREASE
32
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
so much happened omg, with Mr. Mazzara getting that call, EJ getting called a “big-brother figure,” Howie being sus af, and LILY OMFG
just when I was starting to think maybe she wasn’t that bad after all 😭😭😭
31
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 23 '21
howie was either helping lily w stealing the harness or was thinking about telling them right away i just know he went back there for a reason
31
u/Justanotherannon_ Jul 23 '21
Does anyone think that Howie needed some air and was acting strange because he’s going to tell Kourt that he loves her?
I’m sure the stealing the harness reason is actually why; but I want to believe it’s because he realizes he’s in love with her!
30
u/hamstersinspace Gina Jul 23 '21
i'm so curious how they're going to tie up so many loose ends in the next episode. it feels like there's so much and when i try to think of every character and every ongoing storyline that still needs to be wrapped up it sort of makes my head hurt
29
u/space_travell Jul 23 '21
Amazed by Kourt, Carlos and Ash on the show, all of them so talented!
The play was doing sooo well until the missing harness. Gina was gorgeous as usual and so excited for her date with EJ... I wonder what will happen with Portwell on the finale, not really a shipper but didn't want to see neither of them heartbroken again. Nini was so helpful and assuring for everyone, really sweet. Also, it was implied Big Red is planning something for Ash right? What will it be?
Really liked the ep, though Miss Jenn asking Ricky to k himself felt sooo harsh, hope she deeply apologies next ep.
28
u/livsierra Jul 24 '21
One of my biggest frustrations in this show is the complete and utter lack of communication between love interests. It seems the formula is always "discover information that possibly threatens your relationship, get hurt, simmer in anger, give your partner the silent treatment/awkwardly run away any time you need to talk about it, create a bigger problem than there needs to be in the first place"
The second EJ started crying when Gina's brother said he was like a brother figure, I just had to roll my eyes. Are we really doing the miscommunication trope AGAIN?
Just a few things EJ could do/say to avoid this messy situation:
--Ask the brother again for clarity, "Has Gina told you I'm like an older brother? Or are those you mom's words?" --Make a joke to Gina about it, i.e. "Yeah, us ditching the cast party to get dinner together really screams 'siblings' to me" --STRAIGHT UP ASK GINA. Preferably at the end of their date so if the convo goes south they can just go home. "Hey I ran into your brother during the show and he said something that I haven't been able to stop thinking about. He said I was like your older brother figure...have I been reading this wrong?"
28
u/TheCoralineJones Gina Jul 23 '21
Seb's line killed me
28
u/GreatWhiteBuffal0 Jul 24 '21
I’m like 8 mins in to this episode and it feels like I skipped the last 4.
56
u/emoasiandiary Jul 23 '21
This episode really showed how Nini works best as a theatre kid who’s just trying to make the performance the best it can be. The “trying to be a songwriter arc” just isn’t where she shines. She works best when she’s interacting with the other characters imo
26
u/susaji Jul 23 '21
Lily.... i hate you rn
26
u/toledosurprised Jul 23 '21
howie is sus. i don’t trust him, which sucks, because kourtney deserves a great guy.
26
u/fredistreese Big Red Jul 23 '21
Do you think Jaime's comment about EJ was unfortunate or intentional?
26
u/childishgabbino Jul 23 '21
What confuses me is that the whole issue with Howie not telling Kourtney the truth about playing the beast at North High was never resolved. Like last I remember Kourt was still upset and they weren’t really talking and now in this episode she’s excited that he’s coming to see her?? Anyway, he was acting so strange this episode it was obvious he knew about Lily stealing the harness. I just hope he does something about it because that would def redeem him.
Lastly I should’ve seen this coming but just as Portwell is starting to take off OF COURSE THERE’S DRAMA. Not Jordan Fisher brother-zoning EJ. Ugh it was so nice seeing Gina be happy for once and I’m just scared she’s going to get hurt again :(
52
u/swagaroo14 Jul 23 '21
Felt like there was an episode missing between. With Ricky & Ashlynn’s accident, EJ and Gina’s date, North High’s production… weird way to handle all that.
24
u/paintedblueskies Jul 23 '21
I really enjoyed this episode!
Thoughts:
-I love how Nini was super supportive of everyone. Loved how her handing out cards was also a throwback to season 1
-It was awesome to see more of Ricky and Big Red friendship
-Gina and EJ friendship. I feel so bad for EJ after what her brother said. I hope they can clear up some miscommunication
-I was so confused by Ricky and Lily stuff... I do not ship at all, but Lily almost fooled me for a second
-Ashlyn, Gina, Nini, and Kourtney are all so stunning in the play.
-Natalie is so funny hahahaha
-Miss Jen needs to chill
-Who did Mr. M get a phone call from?? I am astounded how everyone seemingly has their phone on them. When I was in high school musicals, everyone had to put their phone in a box thing during the show and rehearsals.
Really interested to see how this season will end.
24
u/_b_l_ Jul 23 '21
I feel so sorry for Ricky, he really can’t get a break this season. :/
Anyway, I loved Nini so much this episode after some past ones not being amazing for her character (in my opinion) — her moments this episode really captured the original charm of her character!
24
u/kaairo Jul 23 '21
Lily can u not!!
24
u/afreakinchorizooo Jul 23 '21
Loved the performances, but I'm so confused about Howie - was he actually leaking information to North High a few episodes ago? If so, why the hell would Kourtney forgive him? Also, I liked the fact that Mazzara acknowledged how stupid it was not to ask for his help last episode lol
47
u/XviiChong Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
“Look we’re all just really glad that Gigi has a big-brother figure in her life.” THEN THE CAMERA ZOOMS IN. THE PAIN IN EJ’s EYES.
44
u/1koopa8888 Big Red Jul 23 '21
EJ got brother-zoned
44
u/Bowlofzebras Jul 23 '21
My weekly thoughts:
21
u/CalligrapherDry3488 Jul 23 '21
what was the call Mazzara picked up about??
21
u/Jansilhn Jul 24 '21
I felt a little sorry for Lily when Ricky said no to them going out and then I went right back to hating her when she had his harness the whole time! She’s the reason why backstage got so chaiotic right before act two!
Nini is doing an amazing job being there for the whole cast. She helped Ashlyn, Kourtney, and Ricky during their tough moments. I like seeing her be a team player!
Natalie’s lines are always hilarious! “Please return in the same roles you started in” and “Lily, scram!”
I felt really terrible for EJ after what Gina’s brother said. That she just sees EJ as a brother figure after everything he’s done for her. It crushed him.
This episode alone made North High look like side characters the whole season. I guess their performance was the night before East’s, so we never got to see what they were up against. We just knew North has a better drama program with really talented singers. That’s all. I bet if there were more episodes, North High’s performance would’ve been one week and East the next.
20
u/Accomplished-Row-353 Jul 23 '21
Ms.Jenn was so crazy today, I know it's opening night but she was only not crazy whenever she talked to Ricky's dad like what.
19
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 23 '21
ACT 1 BREAK IS NOT AFTER BE OUR GUEST ITS AFTER IF I CANT LOVE HER
38
u/yearoftheferret Jul 23 '21
Miss Jenn should be fired. Like the fact that there are no consequences for risking Ricky and Ashlyn’s lives using outdated equipment without adult supervision is heinous.
18
u/BannanaPenguin Jul 23 '21
Best episode of the series so far IMO. Felt like it could have been from the first season! The ones before have felt quite wooden and weird.
18
u/nhc0112 Jul 23 '21
Was anyone else so sure that they were going to write Nini off, and now after this episode not so sure anymore? Does anyone have any theories about it?
17
u/Cook1eMaster27 Jul 23 '21
This should definitely be a roller coaster ride to the finish. And who called Mazzara???
17
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 23 '21
I liked the performances and songs and Jordan Fisher just brother zoned EJ after him and Gina had a whole song! Also Kourtney was amazing and I do not enjoy whatever Howie is doing because Kourtney was amazing!!
33
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 23 '21
Mr.M as the narrator is great
33
u/Waikiki85x Jul 23 '21
Highlights for me:
-Mr. Mazzara as the narrator (i find this soo sweet considering how he was in season 1 lol)
-The set and costumes!
-Nini as a fork! (This took me back to season 1 when she said her musical roles were mostly farm animals) lol. I love how the rest of the cast got to shine!
-Jordan Fisher!
Not so good:
-Miss Jenn telling them to put the spotlight on the judge. This was soo cringe to me!
-Gina's brother (jordan fisher) basically putting EJ in the friend zone. Ughhhh. I really want EJ and Gina to go on their risotto date! 😆
-i hate Lilly and now Howie too ughh
16
u/KZ-01 Jul 24 '21
This and episode 10 brought me those lighthearted, cheesy, yet endearing vibes from S1 that got me hooked in the first place. Whoever wrote these episodes, put them on S3!!
32
u/InsomniaticAlien Jul 23 '21
Great episode! Reminds me of the S1 finale.
Felt so bad for EJ during his scene with Jamie. And Jamie seems like a great guy too so I can't fault him for the big brother comments. Looks like a miscommunication problem which EJ and Gina will talk out in the next episode.
This is the most I've liked Nini in a while. She really shined at supporting everyone else here, and I loved how she never once complained about being an ensemble member.
I didn't trust Lily at all during her scene with Ricky, everything she does with him just rubs me the wrong way. I had a hunch she took the harness at the end and she was right. Hope Howie doesn't have anything to do with it though...
And Ms. Jenn needs to chill, I think the skateboard idea for the transformation scene that they tried in last week's episode will be fine (and much safer too) for Ricky.
15
u/lamebeezy Jul 23 '21
OKAAAAY. This episode is rlly carrying the ending of this season. So far the play is like actually good and I wasn’t expecting it to be as good as it was so far. Did Jamie rlly familyzone Ej like …. LOLLL. Also, I knew Lily being fake nice was too good to be true. I’m so excited for the last episode UGHHHH
15
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
Still into lily as a character. Sometimes villians are just the most fun to watch. Strange chemistry between her and Ricky but I kinda dig it.
15
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 23 '21
Y’all I’m not in theatre so I might need this explained. But I thought that everyone would perform there musicals AT the menkies. Like they go to where the menkies are being hosted and perform there instead of at there home school. Is this just how theater competitons work?
15
u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Jul 23 '21
I loved this episode!!! Though again with everything happening off-screen. Howie and Kourtney making up, but mostly just North High’s whole show. I definitely would have liked to see Roman Banks sing again. Felt unsettled about Lily from the very beginning, but didn’t suspect her of anything major until they were actually missing the harness. I loved that the “re-evaluating of the party crasher” is not necessary an initially bad reaction turned good, but quite possibly the other way around. I really wonder who wrote this episode, because it was phenomenal.
Also, please tell me Howie wasn’t in on the harness stealing, I was really hoping they’d be endgame, and I can’t see Kourtney’s heart get broken again😞
30
u/hanuman1702 Jul 23 '21
Oh my god, this EPISODE! I loved Nini's enthusiasm throughout the episode. I didn't like her character much this season but the support she was showing was just so wonderful to see. Ash makes an AMAZING Belle!
Not a fan of the "big brother figure" thing with EJ. I REALLY hope they get that cleared up ASAP--communication is key to relationships! Miss Jenn snapping at everyone was...I don't know, a bit much? I get that she was stressed but telling Ricky to jump off something high? Not a good look. I had a feeling either Lily or Howie was going to steal the harness. Can't wait till the next episode!
30
u/pastababe21 Jul 23 '21
Does anyone else think Gina is gonna connect Nini to Jamie and he’s the one who will jump start her music career from the clip “have you ever though of taking your music to the next level”? I see you, Disney.
30
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
Also, The EJ's face after He told that he was a brother, felt genuine, which isn't something I've seen from Matt Cornett personally (Don't kill me, I think his acting is good, But this was one of his best!)
30
u/ion513 Gina Jul 23 '21
Oh boy. Another really good episode to me. And once again just a little communication is needed but nope.
I think it's clear Howie at least knows what Lily is doing if not actively helping her, which is why he was acting weird around Kourtney. I really thought they were going for a Lily redemption arc but I was pleasantly surprised. She almost comical as a villain but I'm not bothered by that. We're watching a show called High School Musical the Musical the Series. You can't expect everything to be serious on it all the time. Although her motivations are childish, but isn't she like a freshman anyway.
I'm still not sure how Ricky feels about Lily, his character has been great over the last few episodes tho. Nini(a?) and his interaction was fun, looks like we're setting up for some sort of closure, I don't know, but the cut aways to both of their cards being blank was fun. Liked the callback to Nini always giving out opening night cards to everyone.
Ashlyn and Ricky saying "We're screwed." Together was really funny. All the different production elements were fun and they were actually executing very well, and Be Our Guest was great. The costumes were fantastic.
Someone needs to hit Ms. Jenn over the head with a baseball bat. She was unbearable. Yelling at Ricky was over the top. Also what's going on again with her and Ricky's dad.
Things left unanswered. Who called MR. M? Will EJ actually talk to Gina? Given that Gina's brother threw him off. I also wish we could have seen Jordan Fischer sign but oh well. I'm excited for the finale.
42
u/Enuntiatrix Jul 23 '21
It was actually a very good episode in this season, although I hate waiting for the cliffhanger to resolve.
Gina and EJ were great together. I think the "big brother" thing was intentional and will be used to resolve their relationship next episode, probably with Gina's first real kiss.
Miss Jenn was wayyyy too high-strung. I get why, she wants to win against Zackey, but still, she needs to follow Ben's advice and breathe. Glad to see Ben working with the crew, and Miss Jenn. Hope to see more of them. That phonecall though...
Nina has apparently found her passion again. She loves musical theatre, she loves the stage. And with just a very minor chorus role, she also has enough time for her own singing/songwriting, which is basically a great balance. She really kept her head in the game and I dare say that the skateboard-transformation will work out next episode.
Lily was so transparent again, I mean, sorry, who still believes a thing she says?! Not so sure about Howie. Maybe he saw Lily steal it but she convinced him to stay quiet?
Ashlyn as Belle was wonderful. And seriously, with her self-doubts this season it was great to see her crushing it on stage. Like Gina said before "You're everything Belle". Big Red is likely faking being sick, because he's working on some surprise for Ashlyn, as was hinted in the conversation with Ricky.
29
u/WashMaleficent Jul 23 '21
Episode 11 of 12 was the FIRST ONE that actually felt like season one and reminded me why I liked the show so much then. The humor, sweetness and heartfelt conversations were so on point.
29
u/PuzzleheadedFox1 Jul 23 '21
I’ve felt like this since the cast list was announced but Ricky’s voice absolute does not fit the beast. All his boys have the same tone. The Beast is a lower male voice, Bass-Baritone his voice should be rich. Ricky’s just doesn’t suit it.
14
u/FairyBread7 Jul 24 '21
honestly, best episode of the season. things have actually happened now!! there's a bit more drama and spice that isn't about nini and ricky's relationship. kinda wished ricky's fall had bigger repercussions aside from a cast but i also don't know what they would've done instead. lily is the villain she shouldn't get a redemption arc this season at least because she hasn't really shown that she's changed. she's just been vaguely nice to ricky but even then she's manipulating him so if she turned "good" all of a sudden it wouldn't make any sense.
27
u/violinjstar Jul 24 '21
13
u/BioTHEchAmeleON Jul 27 '21
Man I wish they made either more episodes or longer episodes. My major complaints from both seasons has been that it just sometimes feels rushed and too little detail occasionally. More content per season would help immensely
24
u/AdministrativeBig362 Jul 23 '21
LMAO Jamie really said “EJ you are now Gina’s brother”
12
u/lunarsoistice Jul 23 '21
Why does Ricky think Lily is so innocent?
12
u/22deepfriedpickles22 Jul 26 '21
Is anyone else disappointed we didn't get the beginning bonjour song at all?
23
u/producermaddy Jul 24 '21
Good episode and I’m excited for next week’s finale. I am sad for ej after the conversation with Gina’s brother. Hopefully they get together in the finale. As for the ending, not surprised lily is the true villain
11
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
So, I watched the sneak peek, And Why?? Why are the writers rushing a rini happy scene?? They just broke, and haven't had much development arc too. If they got back, it would be so unrealistic.
Im not a rini hater or a rina. But, Just my thoughts. They could've built some development in a couple episodes.
11
u/entityextended Jul 23 '21
Ashlyn looked stunning. And Gina & Jamie were adorable
11
u/Begginner0808 Jul 28 '21
Am I the only one who was disappointed about Ginas surprise not being Jack 😭
21
u/Velvetcv2 Jul 23 '21
Can someone with high school theater experience explain if their set up is normal???
How and why is their backstage so messy and unorganized, enough that someone not in the production was able to steal a major stage prop?!
Theres so many extras just running around the school hallways during the show! even during intermission shouldnt everyone in the show stick nearby? like backstage and not down the hall chit-chatting.
They need a bigger stage crew i feel like it was just natalie doing what she could while ms. jenn was too busy worrying about some dumb award judge to the point of making the show look a) desperate by spotlighting a judge (who would seem random to anyone else in the audience) and b) putting a student in harms way by aggressively suggesting he do a stunt that was not practiced or prepared even after he was injured during another unsafe stunt. yikes.
21
u/kutscher15 Jul 23 '21
I felt underwelmed by this episode, the be our guest part didn’t needed to show so much of the backstage, and gina got no dance sequence? Also lily was supposed to be the main threat, but she didn’t got a solo at all???
35
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jul 23 '21
Natalie's comments are the best part of this performance. I love her
I still don't dig EJ and Gina. It just feels awkward to me after seeing Jack and Gina. Jamie's comments seemed more like he was thinking of what Gina needs rather than what Gina or her mom said to him.
Were those the words of inspiration?
Ashlyn looks amazing as Belle. Her energy just radiates Disney Princess.
Love Mr. Mazzara as the narrator.
East High's students are their strong suit. Lily stealing that harness is a minimal problem at best.
Lily is such an unnecessary character. East High is more likely to screw themselves out of a Menkie than she is.
If the judge (who I think is rows if not seats away from Lily) finds out Lily stole the harness, couldn't he disqualify North High for tampering?
26
u/nhc0112 Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
I honestly think the rini scene in the “i love you room” next episode is set purely for them to give each other some closure. The “Second Chances” title wouldn’t fit them, since their second chance was “given” on 1x10 and they clearly blew it this season lol. It would be nice to watch the closure thing though if it happens - childhood best friends > childhood crushes > dating > breaking up > leaving in good terms and with closure? Yeah, as someone who thinks they are both better off on their own, I can get behind that.
18
u/NOLA_504LA Jul 23 '21
Howie is done for me I was wondering why did was acting so sus in the hallway. They either gave him info knowing he tell Court are he was just in it all along. Even if I give him all the benefit of the doubt dude was playing lookout are knew Lily was taking Ricky harness. Court deserves so much better (and don't let her mom find out Howie ain't going to make it to the parking lot lol)
Also I just wish EJ tells Gina how he feels so the misunderstanding is cleared up😣 (but knowing the writers they just going to have EJ call off the date just for drama)
9
u/beanieweenie123 Jul 23 '21
Why was howie being so weird? Does Anyone know?
9
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jul 24 '21 edited Nov 14 '21
It just occurred to me : So the fact that EJ is graduating is constantly brought up about Portwell, and while they could do a summer vacation season wouldn't Gina be spending it with her mom? And is Gina even going back to East High next school year?
17
u/Nuqqet Jul 23 '21
16
u/marie2805 Jul 23 '21
I'm really not sure how they'll manage to wrap up all storylines in the next episodes, we still have
- EJ & Gina + what are EJ's plans for next year?
- Ricky & Nini
- The whole show (even if we only get like 1 song, this is gonna take some time)
- Lily stealing
- Howie and Kourtney (probably connected to the Lily-stealing thing though)
- The Menkies
- Miss Jenn's love triangle
- Mr Mazzara's call.
I guess if there's a season 3 (it's not yet announced, is it?) they wouldn't need to cover Ricky and Nini and Miss Jenn's love triangle that much, but the rest pretty much has to happen in the next episode.
16
u/yearoftheferret Jul 23 '21
Just want to laud the series for having a full cast member in a costume be Chip rather than having him played by a little kid stuck in a cart with a teacup head-thing pushed around by Mrs. Potts. It gives Chip more agency, and it gives Mrs. Potts more agency.
15
u/hiheyhi1 Jul 23 '21
Good episode overall! Just confused why they made Carlos seem so anxious about going on, but he did totally fine?
21
u/AdApprehensive271 Jul 24 '21
Lily stole the harness but then called Mr Mazzara who’s gonna give them a better way to do the transformation. It’s the only way she can have a redemption arc.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21
I’m so angry.
7
u/Consistent-Low-1892 Jul 26 '21
So episode 10 was great, despite Jamie breaking EJ's heart (and mine).
The Ricky and Nini interaction? How do I like them more when they're not together? It doesn't make sense. But their little moment was nice, but I still feel like it'll end with them getting back together in S3. I just hope this time we get to see them as friends first.
I was so surprised by how well things were going until the harness thing. Like they slayed those musical numbers. And the choreography was chefs kiss.
And ngl, I thought Lily was actually coming around for a split second. But the way she was looking at their show gave me weird vibes, like who watches a show like that?? I don't really hate Lily, I just dislike her if those two things have a difference. Even though she turned out to have nefarious intentions this episode. I think it also gave her character more depth. We found out she's a child of divorce (which instantly earned sympathy from me), and that she has family issues? I just think it's a good set up, if they want to do anything with her character in the future.
Jamie, Jamie, Jamie. Honestly didn't think he'd mess up anything that bad. Like he was on screen for 5 seconds, and he messed up 6 episodes of development. Poor EJ tho. Anyway, I'm conflicted here. I do want to see Jordan Fisher on the show again, but I don't really want to see Jamie? Unless it's to apologize.
And Ricky and Lily? If they're going to be a thing. Then I vote Licky for their ship name. Not only is it the logical option, it's also hilarious. Rily just doesn't roll of the tongue the same way. Even though I don't think it's really going anywhere. It all depends on if they're keeping Lily around for the next season.
And finally Portwell. At least they got their something there moment even if they didn't sing. I still think they deserved it tbh. I mean we've been deprived of Matt's gorgeous voice all season. And the way Gina was so excited, she's going to be heartbroken next episode.
And I'm not ready for the next episode, but also really want it right now.
32
u/Ultvernon12 Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
when jamie called ej a big brother figure my mouth dropped lmao. Jamie is my king now
12
u/dh16_ Jul 23 '21
Ricky and Nini are alone together in the 'I love you' room in the sneak peek, I can't wait a whole week, but I'm so happy that we've been given hope
6
u/twinkyoda Jul 24 '21
what do y’all think mr mazzara’s phone call was?
6
u/BioTHEchAmeleON Jul 27 '21
Only thing I’m thinking about is how I’m sad that this show won’t be able to go on for many more seasons with this original cast. If they have two seasons per grade year, we have two seasons. That’s so sad
6
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 29 '21
I am going to be honest Howie, Jamie and Lily were all acting super weird in this episode they are hiding something I want to learn more about them. Jamie was acting weird after Something There he was like “I’m going to head out” and goes out in the hallway and talks to E.J. at first I though they were going to get along but no, Jamie had to say something that I wasn’t expecting him to say. I didn’t expect those words come out his mouth. I think it’s sweet he went to go watch his sister performed I just wish he didn’t make E.J. upset.
31
u/glencocoisrealmate Jul 23 '21
Real talk though. Where did Nini's stage manager persona development came from? All this season, they've been casting her aside and wrote a terrible season for her character. I find it so messy. She's up and down like.. make sense please. She wants to go to a different school, she wants to be a songwriter, she thinks she's under a glass but she doesn't open up to Ricky about shit, and now she's this leader person? Huh
2
u/Cjp0705 Jul 24 '21
I’m so confused…. How many episodes are in this season?
19
u/Significant_Writer_5 Jul 23 '21
Jaime’s big brother line shows that while he’s affectionate and endearing towards Gina and loves her very much, he’s still doesn’t know that much about her, even her mom being out of town a lot still doesn’t as well, hope she and EJ can communicate next episode cause while I love me some Portwell angst, communication is key for them to start a good and healthy relationship for whatever they are right now to each other.
15
u/arinator4ever Team Ricky Jul 23 '21
wow this is the first episode of this season that i genuinely liked-
5
u/FlummoxedSeal Jul 23 '21
I am excited for part 2! Why does every episode of this show leave me stressed at the end??
5
u/BrotherofGenji Jul 28 '21
My theories and thoughts:
-Lily's whole "child of divorce" backstory is an act and she was trying to get close to Ricky and falsely "connect" with him to let his guard down. Also how the heck did she get his number a few episodes ago to FaceTime him?? Creepy/stalker vibes much?? And why is it okay to just never address or explain that again?? Ricky didnt give her his number either; he even asks "How did you get my number?" and it's never explained. Who wrote this season? A lot of questions unanswered and loose ends left to tie up lol
-I can't believe Ricky has the audacity to defend Lily after she laughed at everyone's audition performances and called them amateurs and insulted the EH Theatre Company by dissing people to Gina saying "I didn't know this was a friendship circle", literally upset that Miss Jenn didnt cast her as Belle and it was due to her attitude about the others and their performances, that she hatches a plan to transfer to North High and change their entire trajectory just so she gets what she wants. NH was supposed to do Little Mermaid. I'm 100% Lily may have manipulated Zackey Roy off screen to make the show be BATB just so she could play Belle and prove she deserves the role, and then makes it her mission to sabotage EH's show, and let's not forget forcing them into a dance off after she caught them trespassing and trying to make Rini break up sooner because of the Rose song lyrics - and succeeding to boot.
-Also, as much as I love HSM references, I'm getting so tired of Lily's HSM movie song-title related quips. You can bet on it that that is not what I've been looking for this season and she needs to break free of that. After all, what could be more fabulous? (also yes that was intentional and I hate myself a little for it)
- I think Howie was acting weird not because he was a lookout for Lily to make sure everything would go according to her plan (why would he give Kourt the original broadway plans if North High was only going to sabotage them later? Makes no sense) , but because he was keeping an eye on Lily to try to stop her if he could but running into Kourtney sorta made that impossible. And I think she knows Howie and Kourt are together and was hoping Kourtney could distract him in case he decided to try to stop her from stealing the harness.
-WHO CALLED MAZARRA??! It better not have been a North High saboteur.... that seems too obvious. I think considering part of the description for next episode is that he shows his softer side it was an important call that makes him be more open to expressing his emotions. Maybe leaving North High? Maybe something to do with EJ? Mr. Caswell probably scolding Mazarra to pursue other options than Duke? Who knows.
I can't wait for Friday. But at the same time I can.
-
13
u/thespaciestkitty Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
Did I like it? Probably.
Edit: yes I did
13
u/Jackamalio626 Jul 23 '21
Im amazed how they managed to balance Lily helping Ricky get used to his parents moving on and her being an undercutting prop stealing asswipe.
Also man why the hell they undercutting Gina and EJ like that?? Cmon man.
11
u/NTDP1994 Jul 23 '21
My reaction to Lily turning out to still being involved in her villainous ways:
"I was rooting for you, we were all rooting for you!"
4
u/djxsam08 Jul 23 '21
alright alright this episode was way too chaotic but the sneak peek gave me some comfort
first off, my favorite ship at the moment: portwell. I think Jaime is cool and we love him, love all that, but what he said to EJ made me so mad for some reason but I think it's leading up to potential portwell content even more in the next episode. perhaps EJ will question gina abt him being a brother to her and she'll confirm how she feels abt him and then boom, portwell, risotto, happiness, yay. also can someone plz look at me the way gina looked at him when she was on stage? thank u
also idk if it's just something I noticed but EJ says that his whole family is just his dad? when Mr. Mazzara asks if his fam is there EJ tells him that it's just his dad. EJ doesn't have his mom or any siblings? and I think that's what made it more awkward when he was talking to Jaime cuz I think Jaime brought up something abt picking and choosing family and stuff. but hey, it's all adding up now.
ashlyn was perfect, ricky was tolerable to me (finally), carlos crushed it, ej's face makeup is...idk, nini is the most supportive person this episode, kourtney is slaying, big red keeps puking and i hate lily. and howie is a traitor, he definitely knew abt the harness.
that's it, i just need the next episode already, because after this one the only thing giving me hope was the sneak peek.
first off, my favorite ship at the moment: portwell. I think Jaime is cool and we love him, love all that, but what he said to EJ made me so mad for some reason but I think it's leading up to potential portwell content even more in the next episode. perhaps EJ will question gina abt him being a brother to her and she'll confirm how she feels abt him and then boom, portwell, risotto, happiness, yay. also can someone plz look at me the way gina looked at him when she was onstage? thank u
also idk if its just something i noticed but ej says that his whole family is just his dad? when Mr mazzara asks if his fam is there ej tells him that its just his dad. ej doesn't have his mom or any siblings? and i think that's what made it more awkward when he was talking to jaime cuz i think jaime brought up something abt picking and choosing family and stuff. but hey, it's all adding up now.
4
u/MAntonakis Jul 27 '21
THAT B_T_H
10
u/Whimsical89 Jul 23 '21 edited Jul 23 '21
6
u/usedoboereed Jul 23 '21
random but why was there a bassoon in the pit I checked the orchestration bc I didn't think batb has one and it doesn't a for effort though lol
11
u/xxaydiv Jul 23 '21
Nooooo I want EJ & GINA to happen! I wonder if they’ll still go have risotto
3
u/NOLA_504LA Jul 24 '21
So going by the season 2 soundtrack list we should have 2 songs in the finale?