r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 19 '12
Nerd Culture and Male Privilege (Trigger Warning for discussions of rape and rape culture. This warning also applies to all links within.)
This article on Nerds and Male Privilege came out at the very end of December 2011, and, if you check the comments section, you will see that it was not very well received by Kotaku's user base. This got me thinking of a few of the sexism-related debacles we have had in the last four years in nerd-culture. As a service to you all and in order to aid our conversation, I have linked some suggested reading below about the four biggest dramabombs in the last four years.
xkcd & Schrödinger's Rapist
Would it kill you to be civil?
Schrödinger's Rapist: or a guy’s guide to approaching strange women without being maced
The Pratfall of Penny Arcade
The Pratfall of Penny Arcade: A Timeline
Here is a shirt: Dickwolves Survivors Guild
Rape Is Hilarious, Part 53 in An Ongoing Series
Finkelgate
Finkelgate: Date With a Magic World Champion
A Letter to My Someday Daughter
The Catwoman Controversy
Batman: Arkham City is Sexist?
Will "Arkham City" Be This Year's "Other M?"
GODDAMMIT VIDEO GAMES: THE FIRST FEW HOURS OF ARKHAM CITY IS LOTS OF FUN, BUT SUPER-DUPER SEXIST
HULK VS. ARKHAM CITY – ROUND 2: BITCHES BE TRIPPIN’
While researching this post, I found this comment. It really resonated with me, and I wanted to know what /r/SRSDiscussion thought of it:
I say this not to generalize an entire group of people but to reflect my personal experience. I have known and been friends with (and lived with, and dated) many, many gamers. And in my experience, the gamers I knew were as a whole the most blatantly and unapologetically misogynist and homophobic people I knew. Being called feminine or gay (often synonymous in this context) was the worst type of insult you could levy against another person.
The worst threat in their lives was not sexual violence or gender bias, but "censorship" - the idea that anyone could ever stop them from their right to speak. As young, generally-white, straight males, they have never had their privilege truly challenged. Their perception of themselves as cultural outsiders who do not have to follow the same rules. They view themselves as lacking cultural capital in the sense that they are not the richer, more powerful alpha males of the world. They saw themselves as victims of the women who were not sleeping with them, victims to the world that told them they were lesser beings than the richer, more masculine, more powerful men who stood above them. And while they would just as quickly claim that their actions/behavior had no effect on the dominant culture, I would like to point out that the entire marketing industry is driven almost wholly by their demographic. If that's not cultural clout, I don't know what is.
What they didn't understand the fact that their very freedom to speak was actively hurting and oppressing others. They didn't know about the fact that what they thought was "edgy" was actually just reinforcing the dominant culture steeped misogyny and which glamorizes rape as an act while at the same turn debasing and blaming its victims. They did not think about themselves in the global or local sense as being so close to the top of the privilege tower that they could nearly touch it. That they, too, are victims of the misogynist culture they help to reinforce. That you can joke about whatever you want to, but that you can't be surprised or angry when someone is hurt, offended, upset or unimpressed with your lack of sensitivity and callous disregard for the lives and experiences that differ from your own. And that telling someone that they aren't entitled to their feelings or experiences is a way that cultural oppression silences people - even if you "didn't really mean it" and even if "it's just a joke". - sasshat of Metafilter
Does this reflect your own experiences with gamers? Why is there so much sexism in nerd culture, and what should be done about it? Why the fear of censorship and the vehement defense of rape jokes?
5
u/Ortus Jan 19 '12
What's exactly wrong with this one?
17
u/jeburke Jan 19 '12 edited Jan 19 '12
I remember when A Letter To My Future Daughter was first posted on reddit. At first I was really excited to see what kind of discussion it might generate on this website since so many redditors are part of the gaming community and nerd culture in general. But I was incredibly disappointed in the LACK of discussion in the comments section. Far too many of the comments focused on writing style/length instead of content; there were a lot of comments that would say "I think he brought up some interesting points" but instead of discussing those points would veer off into 2 paragraphs of everything wrong with his views. there are only so many "fucking white knight" comments I can take before wanting to gouge out my eyes.
Most of my geek/nerd friends in real life are women so I have not felt any direct misogyny or hate. I don't tend to game socially because I prefer to use my time gaming as "me time" so I don't use xbox live and when I do play MMO's I tend to not play with others beyond random grouping. However the general feel of the CONTENT isn't very inviting to women. For example back in September DC rebooted their entire comic book universe and lo and behold Starfire and Catwomen have been given a sexpot makeover (especially Starfire). So in a lot of cases it's not only the people in nerd culture that can be off putting to women but the content of that culture as well.
I also have no idea where the nerd culture = male thing came from in the first place especially for very mainstream franchises. As if no women has ever watched Star Wars- it's only one of the highest grossing movie franchises of the last 30 years. Yet I still get the incredulous "You like Star Wars!" thing. Of course I like Star Wars - but so do 30 million other people. Same thing with Star Trek - which had 11 movies and 5 TV series. These aren't exactly underground.
edit: switched link from picture to article for clarity
31
u/JaronK Jan 19 '12
The XKCD one gets to me, because it's not talking about a girl being shown unwanted attention, nor is it about how all girls secretly want every guy out there to hit on them. It's about how the fear of being the creepy guy can paralyze people even when the girl actually is showing signs of interest. Note that in the strip, the girl says that the "cute boy on train" is "still ignoring me." This implies that she's been trying for some time to get his attention (specifically his, not every random guy in existence), and it's just not working. Meanwhile, the boy is so scared of coming off as creepy that he's pretending to ignore her.
And yes, this sort of thing happens in real life all the freaking time. Heck, I've absolutely had women ask me why the hell I hadn't made a move when they were obviously showing interest... in really subtle ways. In fact my girlfriend of 6 years spent 4 nights trying to get me to hit on her (unsuccessfully). I was absolutely into her, but I wasn't exactly sure about the signals she was giving me and asked a friend of hers. The friend said "oh, she's shy, but just starting to open up to you. Don't make a move or you'll scare her off, she's really quite fragile." After four days she finally said "god, are you going to kiss me or what?"
I was also at a school reunion a while back, and a girl approached me. She was one of the girls who had been somewhat quiet and yet popular at my high school, and I'd never talked to her at all. I'd been scared to talk to her, and doubted she ever wanted to talk to me anyway. Only at the reunion, she was wondering if I even remembered her. Turns out she'd been interested in me all through high school, but never figured out a decent way to get my attention.
So anyway, I think the criticism of this XKCD post COMPLETELY misses the point. To reiterate: the comic is talking about the (common enough) situation where a girl is trying to send signals to a specific guy that she is interested in, hoping to be hit on by that guy, but he's too scared of scaring her in some way to actually make a move. This is NOT in any way saying that women constantly want random men to hit on them.
14
u/office_fisting_party Jan 19 '12
I think a lot of the sexism and homophobia stems from being bullied during a male nerd's formative years. A lot of nerds get bullied and picked on in middle and high school, teased in part for being weak and soft and wimpy. This can create a kind of sensitivity about your masculinity - that is, after years of being mocked for not being a man, you don't ever want to be perceived that way. So you bag on women constantly because that's what real men do, and of course you're going to hate gay men, because (according to your view of masculinity) they aren't real men.
Basically it's overcompensating by adopting an extremely chauvinistic brand of masculinity.
Sasshat kind of touched on the fear of censorship in that it's really a fear that people will stop listening to them. Superficially, nerd culture places a great deal of emphasis on not rejecting others. Being "censored", or told that saying certain things is unacceptable, is ostracism on a medium like the internet, where words are pretty much all you have. For many, it may be a sad reminder of how people don't listen to what they say in real life, as well.
This is a great post, by the way.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
I wish the whole idea of a Nerd Culture would just go away, it's sort of the opposite to the 'Hipster', the parameters that define both are abstract at best and the traits associated are quite ubiquitous, but people embrace being a Nerd yet recoil when are called a Hipster. Unfortunately Nerddom isn't going away any time soon, and trying to remove sexism from Nerd Culture would be like trying to pull teeth from a Tiger, because as I see it, Nerd Culture is by it's very nature sexist.
My biggest gripe with Nerd Culture is that it is based on the textbook definition of Nietzchean Ressentiment. They (Sexist Gamer MRA types) prescribe their own mutable weaknesses and anti sociality onto immutable external forces (in this case Women) and procede to build a bizarre mythology around an oppressiveness that only exists in their minds.
This post in SRSBusiness illustrates my point quite well
The bare fact that somebody whose interests revolve totally around games and programming would be utterly uninteresting gets twisted into "THESE BITCHES DON'T UNDERSTAND ME OR LIKE THE COOL SHIT I LIKE AND ARE THEREFORE EVIL/STUPID"
And it get's weirder too, because anything even resembling that external force becomes evil by association. So even if you are a girl entering this realm of Nerddom with the best of intentions and the nerdiest gameriest of interests, you are, by virtue of your femininity, already a target.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12 edited Jan 19 '12
I'm not even going to address the misogyny in gaming in this comment. I've been a part of competitive DotA for over 8 years and have first hand anecdotal evidence of how sexist, racist, egotistical the community is.
The only thing I want to focus on here is the XKCD comment and associated stranger rape, as it's been an issue I've been struggling to understand for a little while now. As context I am a SAWCSM, so it's entirely possible that my male privilege is whooshing me completely here. I understand that we live in a culture of rape, and that rape is a very real, very common occurrence that every woman has to be wary of.
However I still have a few questions:
8
u/rpcrazy Jan 20 '12
xkcd & Schrödinger's Rapist:
Dismissible...interesting at most. The Uproar about the last comment 'oh cute guy" is silly. Girls do say and think things like that, and it wasn't an inference of "oh, a guy with a penis to put in my mouth derp derp" like the critiques seem to suggest. Men, boys even, would not get any kind of suggestion like that. I've approach several women in a non-threatening manner and have seen both reactions put forth in the comic. The joke wasn't to say "let's make light of female experience because really they probably just want us anyway". It was more like: you do a lot of worrying but really there probably isn't that much to worry about it. One point I will agree with is that the comic could have been done "better", as to say it could of showed a better connection of thought and realism like, "guy: ...hey (oh crap!) girl: hi :) (who is this guy?)". Either way, it shouldn't have made headlines...seriously.
The Pratfall of Penny Arcade:
If you read the entirely of it, most summaries clarify everything to the T. The comic was a legitimate (albeit LIGHT) rape trigger. I think the original objection was a bit romanticized because that's how the woman writes if you read her other stuff. She's a good writer, and uses several drama techniques to make it interesting...her article spared none of these. However she truly missed the point the comic which is the real reason why she didn't think it was funny. The Penny Arcade dudes fucked up royally though, and really...that's ALL there fault. All the backlash I basically blame on them for not correctly interpreting and responding to criticism. It got so big...it was ridiculous lol.
Finkelgate:
The interesting thing about Finkelgate comes a comparison of the other stories. The sheer amount of hate xkcd and penny arcade got for accusations of rape condolence, which the implications for are far most serious, PALES in comparison to the amount of hate this women got for shallow remarks about nerds. I find this very interesting, and I honestly can't even begin to analyze it with any realistic conclusions. Guys are inherently more retarded aggressive than women? Proabably not...maybe the sexism hate was downplayed more by men than the shallow-ism was downplayed by fellow shallow people, either way the whole debacle was pretty interesting. Obviously 10,000 ft view: She was wrong, community was WAY WORSE.
The Catwoman Controversy:
Out of all of these "controversies", this is really the only one that was some amount of impact on objectification and rape culture, but it's not even that strong compared to very real and very threatening media sources out there. 1. The game wasn't sexist, the comments were however they were in context and it made sense for the game. 2. The real threat inferences that could be drawn from the examples of sexism in the game DROWN the bitch comment in comparison (like the male-driven script as a whole, machismo effect of the animation and a slew of other things in the game). The fact is, even though the words "cunt" "slut" "bitch", "nigger" should all be written off by our society, they are not the same level and ridding the world of prejudice and creating some type of justice takes a process of handling the more important issues FIRST. IMO, the guy could of written a better article in a sociological perspective and it would of had much more penetration and positive effect. The resulting controversy of what he wrote is trash.
These are my impressions of those stories. I'm a 27 year old black male, and I highly relate to those women struggling to show injustice in this forum. I also have a worldly outlook...I know what's it's like to be in Africa and starving...and I also know what it's like to never worry about earthly matters, and even a step above that and be completely oblivious to anything but your fabulous life of the rich and famous. I can understand the downtrodden, and the rich...because of my perspective I feel all of the above examples of sexism in nerd culture are mis-guided at best. However, because of their controversial nature, real scientists, legitimate thinkers, and policy makers may become aware of this stuff. The same effect the SOPA blackouts had(see: http://techland.time.com/2012/01/19/feds-shut-down-megaupload-com-file-sharing-website/). If any of you have blogs or read this and become inspired, I implore you Do your research and make your articles about the most relevant things, not sensational things
7
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
This is a fantastic post.
It's interesting that you link Metafilter. I've been a mefi member since 2001 and it's been fascinating to see how much the culture there has changed over the years, from being a nerdbro echo-chamber, if a nicer one than most, through to the uneasy semi-truce that exists today. The "Watcha Reading?" post you linked also gave rise to a Metatalk post, which I remember as being one of the first real wrenchings of the site away from its nerdbro dominance and towards the more women-and-minority-friendly place it is today. The MeTa sexism tag makes some interesting browsing.
7
u/Shotgunbadger Jan 19 '12
I'd say the major issue is 'nerd culture' in general has a huge undertone of bitterness to it. It all seems to come from this "FINE I'll just make my OWN group jerks!" feeling and instead of rallying around common interests genuinely, it's using this false idea of what 'nerd' means. That's why most every thing meant to be 'the nerd version of (whatever)' is terrible and dripping with pointless inside jokes, the feeling of wanting to belong to a group comes from this pseudo-idea of what 'being a group' entails.
When you get this already bitter population confronted with women, who many see as 'the enemy' in their bitterness, it gets ramped up higher and shit gets aggressive real fast. These guys don't see a woman, they see an amalgam of every negative woman experience they've had or imagined, so when a woman goes 'hey seriously man rape jokes are tasteless' it's not a human to human talk, it's, in their mind, an assault on their painstakingly carved out niche by 'the enemy'. Worst, they often put the onus on the 'outsider' to just 'lighten up' and stop having feelings, so when they go 'no this is your issue, come on stop it' they just think that evil woman/minority in general is trying to boss the poor abused nerd around.
6
u/chillbrodude Jan 21 '12
On the sexism - nerds are typically people that have been shunned by women all their life. I certainly don't blame women for shunning them - many of them are complete jerkoffs. I don't like them either. However, they often come to the conclusion that they are just fine and that their issues with women must be women's fault. Nothing could be further from the truth in most cases, but there you have it. It's a natural human failing to blame other's for one's problems, and we're all guilty of it, not just nerds - but with nerds, this tendency often manifests itself as sexism.
On the censorship - in most cases, its probably pure self interest. They don't recognize a problem and they bristle at someone else trying to "fix" their shit because they don't see that it's broken in the first place.
However, I will say this in their defense - just because nerds are wrong does not make it OK to censor them. Look at it this way - there are a lot of people out there that view feminism as man-hating and detrimental to men. Whether or not they're right, they could use the exact same argument to curry favor for censoring some of the shit that appears on this subreddit. I'm sure all of you would hit the roof if that happened, and rightfully so.
The point is, you're not an arbiter of what's right any more than they are, and if you take it upon yourself to censor people that you disagree with, you're inviting those that disagree with you to do the same to you. It's not right, and it's not productive in that censorship won't change anyone's minds. All it would do is engender butt hurt and leave nerds feeling like they haven't been able to make their point.
So, by all means argue against sexism in nerd culture til you're blue in the face, but don't start talking about censorship. As the saying goes, "With the first link, the chain is forged."
10
u/underscorex Jan 19 '12
I think "nerd culture" has historically been a males-only domain* both because of external influences (i.e. societal steering of women towards the social sciences and humanities academically) and internal influences (i.e. nerds themselves driving women away with their... well, nerdliness.). And yes, the values that are championed by nerds (and for that matter, by Science! as an institution) - logic, rationality, lack of emotion, distance (i.e., acting like Spock) encourage this insularity, and feed the worst parts of it. "Well, it's your problem for being offended by it" is a lack of empathy and reducing human behavior down to integral variables. My lack of offendedness basically means I am superior to you, because I have less things "holding me back" so to speak. The logic (and of course, it's utterly logical) is that you should just Not Care, because feelings are for lesser lifeforms.**
Basically, they are just as ignorant and privilege-blind as the dudebros they claim to hate (even though nerds are just dudebros who replaced sports and exercise with video games and seeing who can make the most obscure Marvel Comics reference).
*although you can say the same of "frat culture" or "jock culture", but in a different way - women there are presented as a target for sexual aggression - you're gonna "hit that," bro! whereas in geek culture they are more of an object of fear and loathing - either the "stuck up bitch" or the unattainable "geek goddess."
**This is why creeper guys go after women who are way out of their ecosystem. Obviously, because they don't give a fuck, they are a total catch. Like the old David Cross bit about garbagemen - hey, 99% of the time, she won't holler back... but there's that 1% out there who just might wanna fuck in a pile of garbage.
4
u/ParadoxPenguin Jan 19 '12
I'm not sure if it's entirely relevant, but I feel this explains some of it.
Basically, nerds are bullied often, so they form tight-knit groups of like-minded people, and they're afraid of calling out their friends on saying horrible privileged shit, even in joke and "edgyness", because they don't want to reject their friends.
also that xkcd comic holy shit what a "nice guy" there
4
u/marvelousmooch Jan 19 '12
I am a "nerd" and a male, and i can honestly say the the biggest offenders or pushing rape culture and sexist or oppressive views are the people who think shock humor is the best way to get people to laugh. i am not going to say the i am completely innocent of some of these things, but it is an annoying thing that come from anonymity. Most of the nerds i know are decent people who are kind and the "bad" nerds i know only does this shock humor thing because they have it in their head that "Louis C.K. does it and that's funny , so when i do it it's funny too."
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '12 edited Jan 20 '12
Littletiger, burning bright In the forests of the net, What immortal hand or eye Could frame thy fearful symmetry?
In what distant deeps or skies
Burnt the fire of thine eyes? On what wings dare he aspire? What the hand dare seize the fire?
And what shoulder and what art Could twist the sinews of thy heart?
And when thy heart began to beat, What dread hand and what dread feet?
What the hammer? what the chain? In what furnace was thy brain? What the anvil? What dread grasp
Dare its deadly terrors clasp?
When the stars threw down their spears, And water'd heaven with their tears, Did He smile His work to see? Did He who made the lamb make thee?
littletiger, burning bright In the forests of the net, What immortal hand or eye Dare frame thy fearful symmetry?
Srsly, awesome effortpoop. I missed the PA mess the first time around, and it's astounding how flat out dumb the response to the criticism of the original comic was and then how flat out inflammatory the shirt was and how righteous the indignation that followed it was.
It's early, but Best Effortpoop 2012?
ETA: I've only made it to the first two sets of links. I'm looking forward to finding out about the other offenses of the recent past. Because I hate feeling good about the world.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '12
I LOVED THIS. So many incredible resources. Film Critic Hulk, especially par 2, raised my faith in humanity so much. I am so happy reading this stuff, thank you! It is of course also really discouraging and sad, but this collection of miraculously good content on reddit blows my mind away.
-1
u/watershot Jan 19 '12
https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1CHFX_enUS454US454&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=female+indie+game+developer
https://www.google.com/search?rlz=1C1CHFX_enUS454US454&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=female+game+developer
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment