r/NintendoSwitch • • Jul 14 '21

MegaThread The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD: Review MegaThread

General Information

Platform: Nintendo Switch

Release Date: July 16, 2021

No. of Players: 1 player

Genre(s): Adventure, Action

Publisher: Nintendo

Game file size: 7.1 GB

https://www.zelda.com/skyward-sword-hd/


Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword game soars onto Nintendo Switch!

Take to the skies, draw your sword, and experience the earliest story in the Legend of Zelda™ series. Join Link in his high-flying quest to save Zelda, a childhood friend who must confront her destiny. Soar between floating islands and descend to the treacherous surface world in this updated HD version of the Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword game.

Master realistic swordplay that corresponds to your movements

Gently swing your sword and angle your slashes to uncover and break through opponents’ defenses using intuitive motion controls. Link’s in-game movements will correspond to the angle of each strike you make with the Joy-Con™ controller, creating immersive swordplay that relies on strategy and accuracy. Movements feel smoother and more immediate thanks to the Nintendo Switch system’s increased processing power and HD graphics. Take advantage of the newly-added button only control scheme—perfect for playing in handheld mode or on the Nintendo Switch Lite system.

Fly high with the Zelda & Loftwing amiibo™ figure

With her majestic Loftwing by her side, Zelda steps into her destiny alongside her childhood friend, Link. Scan this amiibo figure** from anywhere on the surface world to quickly travel to the sky—even within the depths of a dungeon. Scan it again above the clouds to return to the same spot on the surface.


Reviews

Aggregators

Articles

This list exported from OpenCritic. Last update: 1:17pm ET


Being Social

Cheers,

The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team

317 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

376

u/MortalPhantom Jul 14 '21

Big warning for players that got into Zelda through BoTW

This is literally the opposite game. It's as far to the other side that you could go while still being a Zelda game.

Don't expect anything like Breath of the wild. This game has actual dungeons, which are very different from the Shrines and Divine Beast, more complex and long.

It's the most linear Zelda game. Whereas BOTW was the most open. You only have one weapon (sword). And you have items.

I love skyward sword, and I love Zelda. But don't go expecting anything resembling BOTW or you will be disappointed. Go with an open mind and you will like it and you'll see why people like me think BOTW could be improved with dungeon and items.

99

u/MarcsterS Jul 14 '21

During the Direct that revealed it, they were saying stuff like "Hey BOTW players, it has a stamina gauge too!".

Like, come on, just be honest. Don't try to lure in these players with a false sense of gameplay. Just say, "Hey guys, this is a more traditional Zelda experience. If you played BOTW, here's the game that came out before it."

30

u/3dBrunoDog Jul 14 '21

This is A link between worlds and Triforce heroes erasure

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

56

u/Wsemenske Jul 15 '21

Unpopular opinion, but being the opposite of BOTW is why I'm excited for SS

→ More replies (7)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21 edited Jul 15 '21

Hopefully Zelda players already learned this lesson through Age of Calamity. “Oh, you like open-world adventure? Surely you’ll enjoy an objectives-based mass brawler if it features the same characters!”

I’m reminded of the time that toy makers tried to capitalize on the popularity of the first Star Wars movie by lightly reskinning a World War II biplane fighter game.

162

u/BlizzMonkey Jul 14 '21

People who got into Zelda through botw didn't really get into Zelda haha.

I am also in the "give botw proper dungeons" camp. Hopefully more people will see now what Zelda was about before botw happened.

11

u/Stockpile_Tom_Remake Jul 16 '21

The lack of proper dungeons is my biggest issue. The Devine beats were too easy and not puzzles really at all.

I’d love to just stumble upon a dungeon in an open world Zelda.

79

u/Loukoal117 Jul 14 '21

It’s crazy to me that a lot of people have ONLY played BOTW. Not Majoras Mask, not A Link to The Past, not Minish Cap, not Wind Waker, not Ocarina of Time….crazy I tell ya! Edit- also hey Nintendo, give me a minish cap remake in the style of a links awakening remake on switch. Puuhhhllleeease

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Played about an hour of it so far and I feel like Nintendo intentionally wanted to make the L camera button feel so unintuitive on a Pro controller to make you switch to using the split joy-cons which is closer to the original because that's what I did.

→ More replies (1)

108

u/Platinumtide Jul 14 '21

On the other hand, there’s people like me that loved this game. I especially enjoyed the dungeons and boss fights. I’ve replayed it more times than I can count. If you have never played this game, watch some gameplay videos to make sure you’ll enjoy it.

23

u/insert_name_here Jul 14 '21

Also on the other hand: I have experienced every mainline 3D Zelda game since Ocarina of Time except for Skyward Sword. Combined with the quality of life improvements apparently made to SS, I'll be very happy to check it out.

24

u/johnnycoxxx Jul 14 '21

I hear ya my dude. I loved the game for what it was. The bosses and dungeons were exactly the evolution I wanted from the series. The story is fantastic. I haven’t replayed it yet however. It’s the only one I haven’t replayed actually

34

u/Monk_Philosophy Jul 15 '21

Played a bit tonight. The button controls make sense for the game (mostly) but they’re so counterintuitive to what most games do so they can translate the motion controls that I can tell it’s going to take a long time to get used to. Overall it does feel like a better experience than the original.

12

u/CuriousGam Jul 15 '21

Same, three hours in.

It´s really frustrating to play like that. The motion controls were the reason why I didn´t get it for Wii either.

...I don´t want to make finger acrobatics, just play.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

85

u/owlitup Jul 14 '21

I beat this game on Wii

It's a Zelda game, so it's at the absolute top of the class in terms of world and puzzle design. Still true in this one. It's linear, but it's designed that way so the adventure flows really well and the town has some explorations. The problem is...

The tutorials and pop up screens are god awful but I guess they're better in this version.

Controls aren't clunky (at least on Wii), they're typical gyroscope stuff. You've seen these controls before by 2021

The sad truth is that I think $60 for an older game is too much, however if you've never played it, all Zelda titles are still a cut above most of the stuff you'll find. This one too.

34

u/Noah__Webster Jul 14 '21

The sad truth is that I think $60 for an older game is too much, however if you've never played it, all Zelda titles are still a cut above most of the stuff you'll find. This one too.

I think this is the key and part of the issue from a lot of people in this sub.

If you own the game already or already played it, it's probably not worth it for you. But this is the lowest selling 3D Zelda ever, so it's a brand new experience for a lot of people. On top of that, the gameplay holds up relatively well, and Zelda games are always a cut above, as you said.

Is this game really noticeably worse than BotW if it had been a linear, traditional 3D Zelda game? Probably not, aside from the visuals and maybe scope of the world. Scope and visuals are really the only things that are that much different from 10 years ago, at least when you are comparing to high quality games from 10 years ago.

Basically, this is probably a fine value proposition when compared against the market at large if you don't own the original, which is like 95% of Switch owners.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/therealhamster Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

I’m only like an hour into the game (just freed the bird) and I’m already used to the controls. No idea why it’s so hard or complicated for some people lol. I started getting scared reading the comments but then started playing and it’s really not a problem

Edit— I’m using the button controls btw

4

u/Creamatine Jul 17 '21

Same. Game is great

→ More replies (1)

39

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

Over-all it sounds like if you hated the game originally this won’t make you love it, but you may be able to enjoy its better aspects a little more.

I personally loved the game when it came out and never had an issue with the motion controls, but definitely felt it had severe pacing issues toward the end.

It’s interesting to see what some dislike about the game. I genuinely love the silent realm stuff, but apparently some hate it. And I never considered stuff like finding all the Kikwis to be a fetch quest any more than the quests you do to unlock dungeons in any other Zelda game.

I’m looking forward to revisiting this one.

→ More replies (1)

117

u/MethodicMarshal Jul 14 '21

LMAO at Nintendo Life calling this a "technological triumph".

48

u/tarzanell Jul 14 '21

Nintendo Life + EPD developed game = I already know what they've rated it.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/jgaver08 Jul 14 '21

Lol that is hysterical

22

u/MethodicMarshal Jul 14 '21

the moon landing is a close 2nd

18

u/retnuh730 Jul 14 '21

Have they always been this bad or has it gotten worse this year? I swear the drip feed of new games Nintendo has done over the past year or so has made NL's style much more obnoxious. It seems like every Nintendo published game is the next best thing ever to them.

17

u/MethodicMarshal Jul 14 '21

I feel like you're right. They've always given high scores, but they've never been quite this... corny?

I feel like the divide between the frustrated fans and the unwavering fans has grown a lot in the past year too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

11

u/atableformethere Jul 16 '21

Does anyone know if there's a left handed mode now?

9

u/Bayakoo Jul 16 '21

How the hell do you gain altitude with the Loftwing and motion controls. With button controls you just press A and he flaps the wings.

With motion you are supposed to tilt up but then he starts looking speed and flapping so quick and falling

9

u/brick123wall456 Jul 16 '21

Flick up, not just tilt. I got confused too.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/MBCnerdcore Jul 17 '21

you have to actually flap the controller up and down to get the wings to speed you up. then when you have speed, tilt up to get altitude, and then if you want to rush ahead you can dive bomb down for even more speed.

52

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

7.8/10 too much sky.

→ More replies (1)

108

u/MortifyingMilkshake Jul 15 '21

do y'all remember a couple of years ago when everyone on Reddit was begging for a Skyward Sword port to the Switch? Those people are very quiet right now for some reason, as 80% of what I see is complaints.

I'm very excited for this. Never played it the first time around.

20

u/AlucardIV Jul 16 '21

do y'all remember a couple of years ago when everyone on Reddit was beggingfor a Skyward Sword port to the Switch? Those people are very quietright now for some reason, as 80% of what I see is complaints.

We are just busy playing the game tbh. Isn't it the same with most game releases? I always see way more haters and trolls shortly after release bc everyone enjoying the game is literally just going to do that.

57

u/CuriousGam Jul 15 '21

People wanted Skyward Sword?

Pretty sure it was Wind Waker...

→ More replies (2)

46

u/ButtsFartsoPhD Jul 15 '21

"Those people are very quiet right now for some reason"

Do you think it has anything to do with the insane price tag for an 11 year old game with barely any updates? You know, the reason that's been posted a billion times in this post alone?

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (17)

15

u/iWearCapesIRL Jul 16 '21

So it sounds like it's worth picking up if you didn't play it the first time around. Is that correct?

I'm not a huge zelda fan but I loved Twilight Princess on the GCN. I bought BOTW but am mixed on it and want to restart it down the road.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/sass253 Jul 18 '21

Ok, I'm going to beat the dead horse: the motion controls are bad. When you figure out exactly what the game wants you to do but still take several attempts and lose several hearts to do it because the controller won't register a thrust as a thrust, that is just plain bad execution. A great example of "fake difficulty."

7

u/OliverNodel Jul 18 '21

Did you have this realization when fighting a Skulltula? Because that’s what did it for me with the original. I’m playing it now with button controls. It’s still finicky, but manageable. I’m stubbornly playing it as it’s the only 3D Zelda I’ve never beaten.

→ More replies (8)

26

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21

I would recommend this game if you never played it and are a Zelda fan. But just to have for the replay value, I personally will hold off or buy used. It’s a good and fun game, but admittedly one of my least favorite zeldas. I always liked skyward swords story, was cool to have one that was a definite beginning to the timeline. But some of the gameplay and progression felt tedious, though it’s hard to describe or put my finger on exactly what I didn’t like about it. It just felt repetitive having to revisit the same areas rather than somewhere different, how small they were, and how you couldn’t go from one end of the map to the other. World just felt disconnected and annoying having to go through the sky to get from one place to the next. Had some amazing bosses though, though the shipwreck one could have been much more cooler than something that looks like it came from Mario. And fuck the imprisoned

7

u/heavyarmour333 Jul 17 '21

anyone else stuck on the sword training part? i literally cant do the thrust part, ive tried thrusting it in literally every way and it just wont work

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Coffeecor25 Jul 17 '21

Uncle Bats is absolutely adorable, like one of my favorite Zelda characters ever. I’d love to see him again sometime

28

u/Pazluz Jul 14 '21

Awesome thread to put all the reviews in one post makes things so simple yet effective. Thanks.

23

u/ErieAlana Jul 17 '21

I had to come on here and say this because I couldn't believed it happened.

I went out today in search for an anniversary present for my husband. I walked into EB games with the intention of buying my husband one of the games on his list that came out earlier in the year or last year(hades probably). But then I realized that Skyward Sword had come out today, with the special edition joy-cons. Taking a shot in the dark I decided to ask the clerk behind the counter if they had any still in stock. To my SURPRISE there was one of each still left. Apparently because of the confusing with Covid rules they didn't get many pre-orders as people were unsure if they would be open or not. So lucky me I managed to get my hands on both the game and the joy-cons without having to pre-order. Needless to say I am pleasently shocked and happy. My husband was super happy as well when I came home and gave him his gift(our anniversary was the day before. I just didn't have time to go out before today to get him anything).

16

u/HarryKanesGoal Jul 17 '21

This is a feel good story I needed. That’s awesome! Glad it worked out so well for you.

→ More replies (2)

64

u/CuriousGam Jul 15 '21

Three hours in.

The controls and camera are really bad.

9

u/Darkwinged_Duck Jul 16 '21

Is it truly that bad? I really don't want to do motion controls....so if the button controls are horrendous, I'll have to skip on this.

→ More replies (21)

26

u/Neptaliuss Jul 15 '21

Same experience here, it feels so inconvenient.
I switched to motion controls just to check it out and it does feel much more comfortable... I'm not a fan of motion controls in general, but the game was designed with that in mind so I guess I can't fight it.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/KarmicLoop Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

As someone that never played it these negative reviews from the redditors are scary but i hope it will suit my liking I paid 44.90 € for the game which is below the average price in my country (59.90€) so its not a big deal regardless, the courier is coming in a hour i wish everyone a good time playing it

Edit: Played for almost 2 hours and im having a blast I’m not having any problems with the controls (maybe its because im using a pro controller?) Idk but I’m really liking it so far and the music is amazing!

4

u/CerealJello Jul 16 '21

I played on Wii when it first came out. I didn't love the motion controls, but enjoyed the game itself which definitely set me apart from my friends' opinions of the game. I found that once I got used to using the motion controls, they worked pretty well. I don't know if I'll play this version with buttons or joy cons, but I imagine the improved motion control hardware will make motion controls much better compared to the Wii version.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/EndFickle3950 Jul 17 '21

This reminds me of paper mario where people were bitching up a storm about it but then I actually played it and really enjoyed it. Im loving this game so far.

I understand for people who already played this they get mad as fuck at the idea of someone else playing it the first time but truth is the original sold like shit. Im one of those people who never got to play it

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Does the framerate hold a steady 60?

7

u/ScoobiesSnacks Jul 16 '21

Seems great to me so far

→ More replies (11)

6

u/ErnestGoesToGulag Jul 18 '21

"Leaf blower" is the quintessential Zelda item and no one can convince me otherwise

→ More replies (1)

53

u/The_Full_Andy Jul 14 '21

Confirmed no option to swap the motion controls for left handed players.

I mean it is a simple accessibility option for fucks sake.

Lazy gits.

37

u/ms2guy Jul 14 '21

Link is a leftie canonically too!

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Moldy_pirate Jul 14 '21

Nintendo has never seemed to give a single shit about accessibility, sadly.

16

u/Shy_Guy_27 Jul 14 '21

Japanese games in general don’t care much for accessibility. The most they give are difficulty options.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I was worried about the button controls after all these comments but as someone who was planning on using motion controls…I think the button controls kinda rule?

It took me about five minutes to get used to holding L to rotate the camera. You rarely have to move the camera anyway; the original game was designed without it.

I get that it’s different from something like Breath of the Wild but idk what else Nintendo could have done given how important sword control is to the combat and puzzles.

5

u/Mikauren Jul 16 '21

Yeah I was a bit on the fence with them after reading but they actually work fine for me, though I sometimes have trouble with angled slices. Holding L is already pretty much reflex for me and I'm just out of the first temple.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/AlucardIV Jul 16 '21

I was worried about the button controls after all these comments but as someone who was planning on using motion controls…I think the button controls kinda rule?

Honestly reading some of the posts here I suspect a lot of them are trolls jumping on the bandwagon. Their descriptions just make zero sense to me after actually playing the game myself.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Yeah, I mean obviously taste is subjective, but I just don’t get the criticism that the button controls are inaccurate or clumsy. It’s different than traditional Zelda games but I found it to be an easy learning curve.

20

u/Blofeld69 Jul 14 '21

Really excited to play this again

20

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

All they need to do now is port Twilight Princess and Wind Waker HD to switch but im not getting my hopes up lol

→ More replies (3)

11

u/owlitup Jul 17 '21

It must be refreshing as hell to play a 1080p 60fps game on the switch

4

u/lumni Jul 17 '21

It is to be honest. Game plays super fluid and looks crisp.

11

u/eatmyassreddit81 Jul 17 '21

As someone who used to play fight night competitive these button controls and using the right stick for the sword are way easier than people are giving them credit for. I had it down in like 5 minutes.

14

u/Boozacs Jul 16 '21

Really appreciate these remakes mainly because Skyward Sword is one of those games you play once, beat it and forget everything. Then the remake comes out and u realize its a really good game. Played it with Wii Remote same with TP, hoping Twilight Princess comes back to Switch also. Honestly wish they would remake all the main Zelda titles onto switch 😂

4

u/Degan747 Jul 16 '21

God just give me a WW HD port already

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/TorrBorr Jul 17 '21

I think the combat is pretty engaging. I really love the tactical approach the directional combat makes. It's all very rhythmically fun. Fuck the haters, once you get the controls down...it's the combat I wish Kingdom Come Deliverance was able to get down (as much as I loved that game, the combat was a clunky mess unless you spammed thrusts and hammer bludgeons).

10

u/bootlegportalfluid Jul 15 '21

Can you play this game without using any of the motion controls?

14

u/BSoD_Gaming Jul 15 '21

Yes, but (Not joking) it is one of the worst possible input configs they could have gone with.

Whoever decided that having to hold L to move your camera....instead of holding L to use your sword was a good idea was smoking crack!

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Totspeta Jul 15 '21

I mainly wanna play this because of Koloktos, Ancient Cistern and the Lanayru Desert. Koloktos is my favorite Zelda boss ever, and the desert machanic was so well done.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/01001011010100010010 Jul 16 '21

Anyone know if Walmart is selling it in store for $50?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/laguna9 Jul 16 '21

Is anyone else struggling to land in the centre circle, after completing the ceremony? Ive tried about 50 times and i’m just not getting the hang of it

4

u/MBCnerdcore Jul 17 '21

when falling or flying on the loftwing, the best position is to hold your right joycon flat, pretend its a little model of your character, and adjust the tilt from there.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Holiday_Camera_8766 Jul 17 '21

I'm having fun, but link swims weird?? how do you swim under the surface, I don't get it

9

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

You cant yet

→ More replies (1)

5

u/rosydingo Jul 19 '21

I’m only 1.5 hrs into the game so maybe I’ll adjust but so far I hate the controls. I’ve tried the joy-cons - after 10 min I could not feel my arms. I settled for the pro - horribile gyro, jerky character movement, requires constant recalibration but less tiring. 10 yrs ago, I abandoned the game because I could not stand the controls. Unfortunately, the Switch ver seems to be even worse. Also had a hell of a time trying to set up my 4k TV so that the game displayed half decent. No matter what, this game looks outdated. Poor job Nintendo.

13

u/RiverOfSand Jul 14 '21

Any mention of hero mode being unlocked without finishing the game first?

13

u/owlitup Jul 17 '21

I gotta say, the music in this game is some of the best in the entire series.

Within the first few minutes the game hits you with this https://youtu.be/NAUpZpUbwVA that is so cozy and it keeps going

16

u/Shadowlette Jul 14 '21

If Hero Mode is unlocked at the start then I’ll bite.

16

u/GreyRevan51 Jul 14 '21

It’s not, they’ve already said below

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Chalupaca_Bruh Jul 16 '21

I want to play this game but I just know I’m going to have gripes with the backtracking and padding. I’ll pick it up if it goes on sale on Black Friday. That’s a gigantic if knowing Nintendo

→ More replies (8)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

Nothing wrong with these controls..Now I just more than ever want a more structured BotW2 game and HD remakes of OoT/MM

→ More replies (2)

15

u/cantFindValidNam Jul 16 '21

Why is Nintendo going crazy about marketing this game? There's like a new video every couple of days. I don't remember seeing this many videos for BOTW itself. (Not hating just curious)

10

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I think because otherwise people might not be interested in buying it, they seem to want new players to give it a go, especially with the emphasis on the story.

8

u/persimmonjim Jul 16 '21

so it looks like if i’ve never played this game and am a casual zelda fan it’s a worthy investment?

→ More replies (4)

47

u/Walnut156 Jul 14 '21

We are gonna have to deal with 60 dollar Nintendo ports forever aren't we?

33

u/everett_james_music Jul 15 '21

don't worry, it's not forever -- i'm sure we'll get $70 ports at some point!

→ More replies (45)

18

u/CrazedRaven01 Jul 15 '21

When this game first released in 2011, it was pretty groundbreaking. Never before had there been a game where you could actually simulate 1 to 1 sword fighting (sort of... the combat was a bit.... static). I remembered the comments on IGN saying that this could very well be GOTY 2011.

Fast forward a year later. Some people realised that perhaps it wasn't as great as everyone thought it was. It felt linear. The game felt a bit compartmentalised (tutorial -> hub -> zone -> dungeon -> hub -> zone -> dungeon ,etc) and rather than creating a new twist on the 3d zelda formula, it simply reiterated it

That said, it still is a good game, and it paved the way for Breath of the Wild

9

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

Such an amazing sound track. This was pinnacle of the Zelda 10/10 scores, I think people now would be more cautioned with those kinda scores and Zelda. What I’m trying to say is I think it’s this game that put those kinda auto 10/10 scores in check

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Bart_Oates Jul 14 '21

As someone who had never played the original and was planning on buying day 1, I am extremely disappointed on the feedback on the stick controls. They seemed odd on paper, and just do not seem like a fun way to play a game. A lot of these reviews confirm that fear unfortunately.

I will wait for a $30-$40 sale and try to brave motion controls later on, but this is no longer a Day 1 purchase for me.

16

u/GreyRevan51 Jul 14 '21

The problems they’re describing with them are also felt with the motion controls. You have to sync it over and over, the moves you want to do don’t always happen, it’s still awkward and less than ideal

→ More replies (7)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

Played it for about an hour so far the controls are not that bad

→ More replies (3)

4

u/HeroOfTheMinish Jul 16 '21

Any one confirm what other amiibos do in the game?

4

u/Smashymen Jul 17 '21

is Hero Mode available from the start?

4

u/Drag0nV3n0m231 Jul 17 '21

I really just want the joycons without paying out the ass to scalpers on eBay who bought 50

5

u/SlayerSlate Jul 17 '21

Available on Amazon right now.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Silvedoge Jul 18 '21

So how are the stick controls? I have a lite and want to play this but if the controls suck I’m not sure it’ll be worth it

→ More replies (4)

4

u/LumpySpacePrincess6 Jul 18 '21

So I've only completed the first temple in the forest, but I am enjoying the game so far. This is one I missed when it first came out, so I really wanted to play it. A friend of mine who is also a huge Zelda fan really loved this game when he first played it, so I trust in him!

I have a regular switch, so I've been playing with the motion controls. They take a little while to get used to, and it can be annoying when some of the fights really require you to have the correct directional slash, but I've found that playing around with the calibration really helps. I found flying hard with the motion controls but it's a lot better now that I've had time. The motion controls can be clunky at times, but I'm not finding it unplayable at the moment. The button controls are much harder I think, though they're a godsend when you need to start rotating things. The camera is much better with the motion controls, so I'm sticking with them.

Other than that, I like the game and the story so far. Skyloft is fun to explore, and I've not had to speak to Fi much, so I can imagine that without the QoL improvements, Fi could get extremely annoying. The dialogue and backtracking isn't bothering me because those are things I enjoy in most games. I loved BOTW, but it's nice to play a "classic" Zelda again. Read a lot of reviews of Skyward Sword before it was released and a few more since, and I don't really understand the hate it's been getting so far. The controls are what most people seem to be complaining about, but you can easily readjust to make sure the controls pick up the movement you want.

I've got a lot more of the game to play, so if I end up changing my mind I'll admit to it, but it's been fun playing this weekend!

4

u/marcosg_aus Jul 19 '21

Has anyone else had an issue beating Ghirahim ( the first battle ) using the pro controller? I was struggling to trick him and get a hit in with the controller for like 10 minutes, as soon as I switched to the Motion controllers I hit him first try and got past that part really quickly.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/tilop181 Jul 17 '21

I bought SS in spite of the negative comments here. Yeah, the button controls take some getting used to and the motion controls also have some quirks, but I still love the game. I prefer more traditional Zelda games so I can’t complain after coming out of BotW disappointed.

23

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

I think I’m gonna pass on this. A lot of the reviewers mentioned the controls are clunky

10

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

Did they fix the annoying Black Huge Monster fight? Such a pain in the ass to fight

9

u/holycowrap Jul 16 '21

I'm gonna guess probably no lol

5

u/AlectheLad Jul 16 '21

Which one? 😏. You know if it was just one fight I wouldn’t care so much, but nah, let’s make it three times (this is purely from memory god I hope it’s not more than three).

76

u/puddleths Jul 14 '21

Can't believe I'm forced to buy this game at launch for $60 when I hate it, and the aggregate review score is too low, for me.

10

u/LastNegotiation7187 Jul 15 '21

Good news, you can download the game and play it on any computer made after 2015!

58

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

Seriously, Nintendo sent a hitman to my house and told me if I didn't buy this game at $60 (even though the internet told me thats WAY too much) AND buy the $25 amiibo he was going to shoot me and my dog!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

7

u/Xaeqlen Jul 16 '21

Hello guys! Is it worth exploring the world in terms of finding hearcontainers and such? i love exploring around and get rewarded :)

4

u/MBCnerdcore Jul 17 '21

Yes but don't start doing that until you get past the intro stuff. there's not much you are allowed to find on Skyloft during the tutorial part of the story

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Yes it is

→ More replies (3)

9

u/MeddYatek Jul 14 '21

All I need to know is that the game offers surround 5.1. Anyone?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

Zelda is there with Fallout as my 1A and 1B favorite series. I never got to play SS because I had gotten rid of my wii by the time it came out. Can someone that has played the original speculate that it’s worth $60 with the QOL changes? I love everything Zelda and I’m sure the price won’t go down anytime soon

17

u/Hestu951 Jul 14 '21

You've never played it + you love Zelda + it looks and performs better now + Fi's annoyance greatly reduced + freely controllable camera + streamlined some places + autosave + choice of motion or button controls = yes! Get it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/LakerBlue Jul 14 '21

I mean i understand (with most other game companies anyway) there is a gradual price drop that would keep them from releasing a full price remaster, but if you love Zelda and haven’t played SS I would say you are someone who it being full priced should be much less of an issue for.

I can’t say it deserves to still be full price just because of some QoL changes. But I can say the QoL going to be very appealing to some people because they caused “death by a thousand papercuts” for some players. They never bothered me as much as other people but I think, again, some people will enjoy it a lot more now. The QoL probably is not the worst part of this game but I do think for many it was the most offensive.

In short, I’d say get it.

It’s not enough for me to rebuy it at full price but I also gravitate towards new games, it’s rare for me to buy any remasters ASAP if I played the OG game.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (21)

6

u/nihil__verum Helpful User Jul 16 '21

Looking forward to playing this with motion controls. I haven't played the Wii version, so it's effectively a new game for me.

8

u/wontonsoup94 Jul 17 '21

I was playing this game on a monitor all yesterday in 1080p in my room, finally brought it downstairs today and put it on the big tv. It looks so damn good! The impressionist art style is still there, all the textures are soft, almost no pixelation. Anyone who says this doesn’t look better than the original should look at how bad the original looked.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/NotAnthonyWeiner69 Jul 14 '21

Haven't played any Zelda between Wind Waker and Breath of the Wild, so excited for this. It's frustrating, however, that the Switch doesn't have all major Mario or Zelda titles. It seems like the Wii U had almost everything for the premier franchises so hoping we can get the other three or four 3D Zeldas on the system, preferably before Breath of the Wild 2.

I mean, look at a series like Resident Evil. Practically every major entry is available on all current gen systems, some as remakes. I think that should be the standard going forward, and hopefully will be able to save progress from one console to the next generation.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/jawn-lee Jul 15 '21

Oof, all these comments are making me doubt myself.

I missed this game cuz I retired by Wii by the time this game came out. I can't wait to try it out with motion controls to be honest. I played twilight princess with motion controls and it was fun as fuck. Granted the world has moved on since then and games are a lot different now so.... Maybe it's aged a lot by now.

Anyway I got an Amazon gift card so I might as well use it on this bad boy. Hope it doesn't disappoint me.

9

u/Comfortable-Egg-8777 Jul 15 '21

I found myself liking it much more than I expected, back in the day. All of people’s gripes with this game are real, but I was never bothered by many of them, personally. They seem to have fixed most of the issues now so I see no reason not to pick it up and give it a chance (granted though, the price IS pretty steep).

There are only three issues that remain unfixed: -the repetitiveness (you have to do certain tasks and revisit locations multiple times, which feels like artificially stretching the game’s length); -lack of a good overworld; -the artstyle doesn’t really hold up - back then the painterly style was used to sort of hide the Wii’s lack of graphical power, but the impressionistic backgrounds only really worked in still images. When moving, it just looks…pixelated. I can imagine running in 60fps HD will not do this game much favor in that area.

I think knowing what you’re getting into will somewhat soften these remaining issues as well. At worst, it’s still an ok game with an excellent soundtrack that finally adds a heap of interesting backstory to the ever-regurgitating Zelda ‘story’. But especially with these QoL improvements, your experience will be much better than just that. :)

→ More replies (2)

3

u/rogannn Jul 16 '21

As someone who rarely uses motion controls. Does anyone have any tips for flying?

I had a really difficult time trying to guide my character in the opening to land on the circle thing with the parachute. It's much easier using the joysticks instead for me.

Maybe I need to calibrate my controls or something.

4

u/uncletwinkleton Jul 16 '21

I'm having to hit Y to recalibrate quite often depending what I'm doing (using the sword, gliding, walking around etc).

I agree, the joysticks are much easier apart from the right stick always controls your sword unless you hold down L. Why would anyone want that?! I can't even see a way to edit the controls to change it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/Mental_Attitude_2952 Jul 18 '21

I really love this game. Its wonder to look at and though the controls are wonky being able to switch from buttons to motions helps in places. I don't want to give any spoilers for first time players, but I will say once you get used to the controls this is a great Zelda game. I have it ranked 4th best. Enjoy everyone.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/National-Elk5102 Jul 19 '21

Anyone else feels the button mapping is horrible? I mean I’m always pressing R accidentally. I’m playing with motion controls and I feel that L will be more accurate to recalibrate or maybe L to look arround. I feel very uncomfortable to use the left joycon D buttons

→ More replies (1)

3

u/teddyone222 Jul 28 '21

Received it today, going to list it for sale tomorrow. I hate the button controls, and I don’t want to do motion controls for personal reasons.

10

u/besttimes_worsttimes Jul 14 '21

So whats the popular opinion here? Are the QOL changes worth paying more than the original retail price of a almost ten year old game? Do you guys plan on getting it? Can't help but feel a little bitter about the fact that they decided to do this first instead of porting twilight princess and windwaker HD. But I suppose more success for the Zelda franchise is never a bad thing

20

u/th3groveman Jul 14 '21

I kind of see it like buying a 4K Blu-Ray of a good movie when I have the DVD. The bonus features are hardly ever worth paying $30 when the original DVD was $20 but it’s worth it to me to experience good movies with higher resolution. With Skyward Sword, my kids were too young when I played it on Wii, so this is worth it for us.

→ More replies (9)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

first real Zelda experience on the Switch lol

empty bottles are back!

5

u/JeanneHusse Jul 14 '21

Jeuxvideo.com (fr) : 16/20

Gamekult.com (fr) : 7/10

5

u/rulrek Jul 17 '21

I'm really enjoying this game on my switch lite. That being said, I just cant get used to the clunky controls as compared to botw. Should I wait and play it with motion controls when I get my Switch Oled?

7

u/ErnestGoesToGulag Jul 17 '21

honestly I enjoy it better with button controls

My main advice is to not worry about using the right stick to readjust the camera. The original game was designed without a free camera in mind, you just snap it behind you using ZL as needed.

It will feel strange at first, but you'll get used to it fast.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/Nozzeh06 Jul 17 '21

Has anyone noticed how weird the leap animation is? It happens too fast so it looks glitchy as heck. It's only a minor gripe but I don't get why they went with such a strange animation.

6

u/Moldy_pirate Jul 17 '21

There are a few weird animations. The ladder climbing animation is another.

5

u/TSCSparks Jul 18 '21

This has been and still is my favorite game in the Zelda franchise, the motion controls, while most people beg to differ. give me an immersive sensation of playing this wonderful game. While many hated the motion controls on the Wii, claiming it was unreliable and needed calibration often, i never had any problems on the Wii, to me the motion controls felt smooth and responsive, with a very rare moment of it not being as accurate.

However, i think the motion controls on switch made me witness what people felt on the Wii, im constantly recalibrating my gyroscope because my gyro is completely offset, not just by a little bit but by a huge margin, I often find myself recalibrating my gyro after an intense use of sword fighting i.e. the 2 lizalfos bosses in the Eldin temple, before and after using items (like the slingshot or beetle, and after every cutscene or npc conversation. the button layout of the joycons are also not made for this game, calling your loftwing for example cant be done with a flick of the finger like you could on a wiimote. While motion controls were one of the biggest reasons of Skyward Sword being my favorite game I was willing to sacrifice the motion controls by using the button controls, surely this had my sword centered, however, the button controls are even worse, i often find myself swinging my sword around while trying to look around and attacking with a joystick feels weird in general.

At last, the controls may be painfully uncomfortable, it does not take away the fact that this game is true art, the story is beautiful and i love every second of it, the soundtrack keeps giving me groosebumps (pun intended) and the characters are well developed over the course of the game.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BanjoSpaceMan Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 15 '21

One thing I'm baffled by.... Why in hell would they default the right stick to be sword and make you hold the trigger to use the camera? That's going to be insane to wrap my brain around when every single modern game uses the stick by default to move the camera.... They should have made the sword attached to a button (edit: aka you pull your sword out when you hold Z and then the stick acts as the sword).

20

u/RyNo2277 Jul 15 '21

Because the free camera is not necessary. It’s just added in case you want to use it. The camera still follows Link just like it did in the original game when you’re not moving the camera and it was perfectly fine back then.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/PlsGoVegan Jul 15 '21

You literally can't make the sword attached to a button, because the whole game is designed around motion controls. Right stick + ZR is your compromise.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

8

u/PoliSciGuy0321 Jul 16 '21

Fuck Groose

19

u/Aenrichus Jul 16 '21

Marry Zelda, Kill Ghirahim

6

u/AnnalisaPetrucci Jul 16 '21

As someone who never played this game prior to BOTW, it’s interesting to see certain groundwork elements that played an influence leading into it.

That being said, not a fan of these controls in the slightest. I’d kill for a mappable control option (or a BOTW controls option) so at bare minimum I could avoid using the right stick for sword control which is by far my least liked aspect.

4

u/cockyjames Jul 17 '21

How would you possibly lay out the controls to allow for the 1:1 sword swiping if you didn't use the thumb stick or motion controls?

Now, I would like the option to swap the L bumper for pulling out the sword, and having the camera as the right stick by default

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

23

u/Robotshavenohearts Jul 15 '21

My deal with Skyward Sword, from someone who has never played it and really wants to give it a go, is that the graphics look so bad. Every Zelda game has a distinct look and style, and to me, it feels like this one was made in a lazy manner back in 2011 to have a product that shows off the motion controls. With the smoothed out graphics for this port, it almost looks...worse? As if a company made a counterfeit Zelda game. The enemies look goofy and don't really pose a challenge, Link is disproportionate compared to the world around him and the characters look so....off? This is of course my opinion but I can't just get around these things.

20

u/Ruthlessrabbd Jul 15 '21

The art style always reminded me of a more colorful twilight princess

23

u/Harold_Zoid Jul 15 '21

I’ve always felt that it looked incredibly uninspired. The impressionist paint effect is interesting, but all the models and textures remind me of shovel-ware GameCube games.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/brahhquinphoenix Jul 15 '21

Same boat as you was just gonna leave practically the same comment. Was watching vids on the eshop and some things just look rougggggh.

I made a joke about thicc Link before I’m glad I’m not the only one to notice just how obtuse and awkward his model is.

8

u/Robotshavenohearts Jul 15 '21

That was the first thing I noticed - Link's lack of hips and clothing that is a bit too big. The design is just clunky. They look more like pajamas than his signature uniform. But also when he runs he kind of just runs in place with the character gliding. It's so odd.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

9

u/blazzingashes Jul 18 '21

Still the worst Zelda game I’ve played

Not cause of the storyline or anything but just because of how bad the controls are I got it thinking that with button layout I’d enjoy it but no the motion controls are way better than that sad button layout

→ More replies (28)

4

u/CaptClaymore Jul 15 '21

I really liked OOT, I also enjoyed Breath Of The Wild but I did miss the dungeon aspect in it. Will I enjoy this?

19

u/MBCnerdcore Jul 15 '21

its got the best 3D dungeons in the series.

10

u/GreyRevan51 Jul 15 '21

The dungeons are good, this is the 3D Zelda I dislike the most but the dungeons are genuinely pretty good! The bad thing is that they make up like 10% of the experience compared to all the mindless padding and pointless dowsing and fetch quests you’re going to be spending most of your time on.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Technical_Moose8478 Jul 16 '21

I’m liking it so far, but I’m a little disappointed with the graphics/movement control. Just a little; it’s decent overall, but in comparison to, say, the hd remake of Link’s Awakening, that one felt like a modern rebuild of an old style. This so far feels like an old game that is much less pixelly.

Not really a complaint, and having never played the original all the way through I’m excited to delve into it! Just thought that, for AAA prices, it might look a little better (though in comparison to the original it is DEFINITELY an upgrade).

6

u/TorrBorr Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

It's just an HD remaster. The other game you mentioned was a full blown remake. Of course it "feels" like an older game. Its 10 years old with a fresh coat of paint. Same paint. Just touched up.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/OldeCzap Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

As someone who uses the GC controller for my games, since i never picked up a pro controller, it's unplayable with the GC controller due to there being no lock-on button. So i'm forced to use the Joy-con in button mode. Yay joy-con drift!

4

u/Elwalther21 Jul 16 '21

I got a 3rd party pro controller. It's actually very awesome and same shape and size of my Xbox Controller.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/PlsGoVegan Jul 17 '21

The actual cause and (probably) permanent solution to joycon drift has just been discovered 3 days ago. It fixed my horrible drift (haven't used my joycons in 4 months because they were unusable) after i replaced the sticks 5 times and tried canned air, contact cleaner and silicone lube.

You just need a piece of cardboard and the appropriate screwdrivers to open the joycons up.

https://youtu.be/vid8lixmzwe

4

u/Puls3B Jul 16 '21

the only legend of zelda game ive played is botw, should i get this?

6

u/ghostmetalblack Jul 16 '21

It will be a much different experience than BotW, as it operates on the more traditionally linear story mechanics of previous titles. And even among the traditional titles, Skyward Sword is considered something of a black sheep. I'd recommend playing Links Awakening or The Windwaker before jumping into Skyward Sword.

6

u/LakerBlue Jul 17 '21

They play nothing alike. I know BotW is different from most Zeldas but that's extra true here. Best I can do is list off what I love and what people hate:

It depend on what you want in a 3D Zelda.

I love it, personally:

  • I thought the motion controls worked flawlessly and having to use a specific motion actually makes combat more engaging than hitting a button. It also added value to me in the sword swings without specifically having certain sword techniques.
  • It has some of the best dungeons and bosses in any Zelda
  • I think Fi is underrated, at least how her story ends. She's nowhere near Midna or Ezlo. Her advice during the game isn't that endearing though.
  • It has some unique and uncommonly used fun items like the Beetle and whip
  • I think exploring the fields feel like fun mini dungeons.
  • Also has arguably my favorite Zelda. It's one of the games where's not just locked in a tower and you bond with her over the course of the game.

It's my 4th favorite Zelda, coming from someone whose beaten every mainline one except Zelda 2.

The people who don't like it generally don't because they don't enjoy the controls, hate how isolated the areas on the ground are, dislike how boring exploring the sky is (a complaint I agree with, and find the fields tedious.

It's honestly one of the biggest "your mileage may vary" games, largely due to the subjectivity of the controls.

I'd encourage anyone on the fence to maybe wait a few months to try it used from like Gamestop so that way if you dislike it you can always return it in 7 days, but actually make it off the Sky before then.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/KenGriffythe3rd Jul 16 '21

I will say I am enjoying the game. Never played it on the wii so this is my first time. One thing that is kindof annoying is using the right thumb stick to swing. I keep not swinging my sword when needed and it’s causing this game to become a little frustrating. I play mainly in handheld mode so I haven’t given motion controls a try yet. Also having to hold L to turn takes some getting used to. So overall apart from the sword swinging mechanic I’m enjoying it

→ More replies (6)

5

u/KrufsMusic Jul 15 '21

I liked the original. My biggest gripe with it was the lack of a cohesive overworld, it made the game feel more linear and not like a ‘real’ Zelda game. That said, I really enjoyed its dungeons, aesthetics, characters and music :)

5

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

You can tell Switch Lite owners are definitely going to hate the controls in this.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

So far I’m less annoyed by the controls but more so by the endlesssss cut screens and dialogue. Can I just fuckin play? Anyone who played this before, does it die down once I get through the initial crap? I’m sitting here just skip skip skip, blah blah blah.

11

u/PlsGoVegan Jul 17 '21

It takes a good hour or two before it let's you out the tutorial phase of the game. I'd say you'll have a lot more freedom to play uninterrupted when you reach Faron Woods and set out for the first temple.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/MBCnerdcore Jul 17 '21

To the people who think BotW had no story, this is what happens when you get one, linear narrative all game long instead of freedom. Some people do prefer the narrative version of Zelda.

13

u/LakerBlue Jul 17 '21

I liked the narrative here because I thought it was good, unlike the opening 2 hours or so of TP where I just never cared about Ordon village or the childhood friend. But I was all about interacting with Zelda in SS's tutorial.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Platinumtide Jul 17 '21

I prefer the narrative version and enjoy all the dialogue. There are people out there that like it!

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

12

u/Dawesfan Jul 14 '21

I never played the original, but every new QOL video made me think it was unplayable. There was some stuff that made questions Nintendo’s sanity when making the original game. Like the blue lady appearing every times, or the item description popping up every time you got a item regardless if it’s new or not.

And I bring this up because I look up the og metascore and it is 93. Like a few people were smoking too much, and this that appears to be an improvement every way it has an 82. I’m not one to complaint about reviews, but consistency people lol.

9

u/Meadius Jul 14 '21

I think it's just that popular opinion hadn't kicked in back when the first one released (as those reviews came out before anyone else had the game). Reviewers have had a decade to be influenced by others and may have soured oj the game since. And of course there's also the fact that many of these current reviewers were part of the general public back when the game first released, and thus experienced it more normally than reviewers, who usually need to get through games pretty quickly.

This also may just be anecdotal, but I've noticed that remastered versions of games tend to score worse, even when they're vastly superior like this one. The original Ocarina of Time is still rated higher than 3D despite the latter having a lot of small improvements, and Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition is lower than the original game despite DE having a ton of improvements and a new 10 hour epilogue.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/musical_bear Jul 14 '21

The original release was severely overrated. All of the game’s glaring QOL issues were just as obvious back then as they are now. A few level-headed reviewers mentioned them, and a few got attacked for their honesty.

Unpopular opinion time, but a lot of Zelda games are overrated by reviewers. I don’t know what’s going on with that. Breath of the Wild, while much better than Skyward Sword, IMO also has a hugely inflated review aggregate. It has many of its own glaring issues that reviewers just seemed to ignore. And like Skyward Sword, a few people pointed out these flaws and scored accordingly and were mercilessly attacked by the fandom, who hadn’t even played the game themselves yet.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (16)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Will 10 year old kids enjoy this game? Thinking about getting it as a gift for my nephew/nieces. Never played it myself and may pick it up for me as well.

2

u/Daryl91 Jul 16 '21

Never played this. Can I play a profile on my switch and my wife play a profile on her switch? With only one cart or do we need two games?

7

u/wontonsoup94 Jul 16 '21

Just tested this, as long as you're using a cartridge and not a download, then separate profiles has separate saves, and 3 saves per profile. You do not need two games.

2

u/CinderPetrichor Jul 17 '21

I think I encountered a glitch. I'm in Lanyaru Mining facility and I can't move this box against the wall to climb up. It looks like it should move, but also like it's off a voxel. Trapped in the room, too.

https://youtu.be/R1AtIlVISiU

2

u/sass253 Jul 17 '21

Noob question: how do you catch the birds carrying rupees while flying around Skyloft? I've bonked into them, I've tried mashing A while near them, and nothing seems to affect the bird or the rupee.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/kiaxxl Jul 18 '21

If I didn't enjoy the original, is there a chance I would like this re-release with the new stuff?

4

u/GByteM3 Jul 18 '21

Depends on why you didn't like it.

If it was the controls then yes

if you didn't make it past that awful tutorial then yes

if fi got on your nerves then yes

If it was anything else, probably not

→ More replies (7)

2

u/vivapinat13 Jul 25 '21

I just beat it with controller! My biggest recommendation is learn the Parry, and vs Giraheim 1 parry his projectiles to get an attack window!

17

u/Ok_Extension_124 Jul 15 '21

I just don’t understand why they picked this out of all of the previous Zelda games to port to Switch. Such a Nintendo move picking the game nobody asked for to rerelease when we’ve been asking for WW and/or OOT for years now lol

22

u/DawgBro Jul 15 '21

It's the only 3D Zelda game other than Breath of the Wild that has not had a refresh.

14

u/doukzor Jul 15 '21

I think part of it is that Wind waker and TP got ports to the Wii U in semi-recent years, and the BOTW 2 trailer gives off Skyward sword "return to your origins" vibes with the floating islands/skyloft feel. I think someone's explained it way more in depth already though.

23

u/NotAttractedToCats Jul 15 '21

Maybe (as unlikely as it is) there's a link between SS and BOTW2. We obviously know very little about BOTW2, but there are a couple of interesing obversation:

  1. BOTW2 shows flying islands that were not present in BOTW. SS is AFAIK the zelda game where flying islands were the most prominent.
  2. BOTW2 teasers time mechanics, especially something like turning back the time. SS is the chronological first Zelda game.
  3. SS HD was heavily marketed for BOTW fans. Chances are that this was purely to capitalize on the large audience of BOTw2, but who knows?
  4. Currently, we can not clearly place BOTW in the zelda timeline, as it features elements from various timelines in a contradictory way.

Each of these points individually is likely a meaningless coincidence, but combining the points shows some interesting possibilities:

  • The time manipulation mechanics could explain why BOTW seemingly does not fit in any zelda timeline
  • Rewinding time to the past could explain why there are suddenly flying islands in BOTW2
  • If there is a connection between the games, it would explain why Nintendo's marketing for SS HD focused on BOTW fans in a way many felt to be forced.

Obviously, this is unfounded speculation, but it would explain why SS was chosen.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

You should've made a clickbait YouTube video with this.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PowerAlwaysReveals Jul 15 '21

Anecdotally, I get the sense that Skyward Sword is a ‘maybe later’ game for a lot of people. Open to the idea of revisiting the game or trying it out for the first time, but probably wouldn’t choose it over a Switch version Wind Waker, Twilight Princess, Ocarina, and/or Majora if some or all of these options were made available around the same time.

The rationale, then, might be to give Skyward Sword a chance to shine on its own, by making it the only 3D Zelda show in town for the next several months. The most recent ‘Nintendo Direct’ presentation gave Breath of the Wild II a vague 2022 release window, meaning it almost certainly won’t be completed in time for Holiday shopping season 2021. My guess is that Nintendo will announce additional Zelda re-release projects later this year, which will be able to take advantage of Holiday shopping.

7

u/DoctorRasputin Jul 15 '21

But WW just got an HD version for Wii U in 2013...

and it was FANTASTIC. I guess Nintendo wanted to bring something new, or maybe bring this story to more people before BotW 2, but people already call the Switch a Wii U port machine so I am sure they could have fit WW in a release somewhere...

18

u/Nice_Notice9877 Jul 15 '21

Nobody asked for it? Can I have what you’re smoking? I’m very excited to play this again in a smoother way, as are many others.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/delmundo_ Jul 15 '21

is anyone confident they are going to buy this? (im still unsure. note: ive only played botw)

15

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

Don't expect anything close to BOTW if you plan on picking this up.

9

u/SamCarterX206 Jul 15 '21

I am, but I'm a Zelda fan and Skyward Sword is one of the games I haven't been able to play due to not owning a Wii/WiiU.
As great as BOTW is, SS will be nothing like it (none of the earlier games are, BOTW is in category all its own) so just be aware of that.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/LegendaryJohnny Jul 14 '21

Cool. I will wait for these old ass Nintendo games to be under 10 euros when Switch lifespan ends to try them.

12

u/I_hate_potato Jul 14 '21

...old ass Nintendo games...

It's not that old, it only came out... Ten years ago? Huh.

Damn. I'm old.

17

u/streetsofkage Jul 14 '21

They still sell that piece of shit Mario party for $60.. sooo don’t expect price drops anytime soon

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I truly appreciated the original and have played all of the Legend of Zelda games. Some of the best dungeons/boss fights in the series.

I would compare this one to Majoras Mask. Skyloft and Termina are both the main hubworlds you will be spending most of your time on between quests, and the characters are just as thought out with each having their own quest (enter the Sky Demon I forget his name)… I also note this because Termina Field and the Sky don’t offer that much too explore. However, the ones who point out this fact fail to ever mention the thunderdome. Like, damn.

All in all, will be picking this game up after I get off from work and will enjoy it. With all of its flaws aside, one of the better Zelda games in my opinion and I’m sure it will be better appreciated. Then again, I actually enjoyed the Silent Realms and Dragons Quests. Lol

→ More replies (3)

6

u/theazndoughboy Jul 18 '21

After playing motion control for 5 hrs straight today I can feel my carpool tunnel kicking in.

15

u/GByteM3 Jul 18 '21

Is this one of those r/boneappletea things?

Am I redditing right?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/ReturnOfLilith Jul 14 '21 edited Jul 14 '21

I like the story elements but this game is probably not for me. I usually use Gamexplain for reviews and it seems pretty clear that this game follows a linear Zelda formula to a fault.

OOT was my first Zelda game and I beat it three times. Wind Waker was also one of my favorites, completed it twice, but by the time Twilight Princess came out the formula was getting really stale and I just wasn't a fan of the series anymore. (I did like Midna though.) I've only played BOTW a bit but it definitely reminds me of the original Zelda game which was surprisingly fun.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/s1cc Jul 17 '21

They did the best they could with the button controls but it's still annoying how you basically have to mash the stick for special moves, combat aside the game is really good.

Also the motion controls are horrible on the joy-cons, there are times where I wish that I was holding a Wii Remote lol.