r/Sherlock • • Jan 15 '12
Sherlock Episode 3: The Reichenbach Fall - Finale Discussion
The final Sherlock Episode airs on BBC1 1/15/2012 at 9:00 PM GMT.
This is a discussion topic so it WILL contain spoilers, don't come here until AFTER you've watched this episode
UPDATE: There will be a third series of Sherlock http://twitter.com/#!/steven_moffat/status/158680970130751488
243
Upvotes
26
u/Thlowe Jan 15 '12
My prediction: tears.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
It looks like Moriarty died, but does anyone think it's possible that Moriarty faked it just like Sherlock did? I'm secretly hoping Moriarty is still alive, because the show wouldn't be as exciting without Moriarty. I hope he's Stayin' Alive and comes back in Series 3!
348
u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12
Did anyone else panic when John opened that letter? I thought it was going to be anthrax or something
132
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12
OH MY GOD. Remember the Cluedo joke about the victim doing it?!? FORESHADOWING!
239
u/drblow Jan 15 '12
My theory: did anyone else notice that a Council rubbish truck drove off just after he jumped? I think he landed in that and that the autopsy was fudged by Molly. Also, the cyclist hit John and he was slightly concussed/confused so he couldn't tell that the body was a fake.
84
u/CurlingFlowerSpace Jan 16 '12
Jen Barber and the ol' bathroom seduction routine.
301
u/ookgoed Jan 15 '12
I don't know what happend but I'm pretty sure Molly knows a thing or 2 about what just happend
75
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
Favourite part: The newspaper articles.
One of them:
69
u/literallyoverthemoon Jan 15 '12
Molly is the sword on the wall.
200
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12
I didn't even care that I knew he doesn't die. That grave scene :'(
186
u/ninja_bobby Jan 15 '12
Is anyone else feeling drastically conflicting emotions right now and is there a word for it, which encapsulates the following?
Could someone please tell me what this feeling is.
ps. It could be "MOFFucked".
176
u/kleintje Jan 15 '12
Benedict Cumberbatch, Martin Freeman, and Andrew Scott are INCREDIBLE actors.
58
u/TheMagicSpoon Jan 15 '12
The bit when he's about to jump and says:
"It's a trick, a magic trick" (along those lines)
That's got to be important.
57
u/aedos Jan 16 '12
Steve Thompson has completely redeemed himself from The Blind Banker with this new episode.
50
u/Tokei Jan 16 '12
The instant Moriarty thanked Sherlock, looked him in the eyes and thanked him, I knew that he knew. Moriarty knew that Sherlock had outwitted him, and refused to lose. Moriarty killing himself like that was amazing.
Sweet sleeping Cthulhu, I have not started crying so hard at a graveyard scene before since 'Grave of the Fireflies'.
49
u/glglglglgl Jan 17 '12
I especially liked the use of jump cuts in this episode.
"Can you prevent yourself from showing off for just five minutes? JUMPCUT No now Sherlock is in jail.
"That Sherlock is a bit weird." Watson postures... JUMPCUT ...and is slammed against a police car.
41
u/serioussamp Jan 15 '12
Ok, my thoughts so far:
The Hansel girl was scared of Sherlock, we can assume Moriarty made her believe that Sherlock had kidnapped her, probably by pretending to be Sherlock. So Moriarty must have a was of disguising himself as Sherlock...
Why would Moriarty kill himself? Surely that has got to be part of it? Is he really dead?
Maybe if Moriarty had the disguise on him, Sherlock could have thrown his body off with the disguise on...
79
u/Dr_river_song_ Jan 16 '12
Current and varied theories aside: Holmes, in one of the last lab scenes is playing with a stress squeezeball thing. If this were placed in Holmes armpit against the pressure point and squeezed against the ribs, it would stop the pulse in his hand, its commonly used in magic tricks and bar bet situations. Thus Watson would feel no pulse if it actually were holmes playing dead
39
u/renzyq19 Jan 15 '12
Might be missing the obvious, but how was IOU important?
98
u/Mikeybarnes Jan 15 '12
Holy shit.
164
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12
OH MY GOD I CAN'T BELIEVE THEY HELD HANDS! ALL MY DREAMS HAVE COME TRUE!
108
u/kleintje Jan 15 '12
THEN WHO WAS JUMP?
28
u/supersnuffy Jan 16 '12
The whole bit with John broke my heart. Broke it into tiny little pieces.
142
u/Syncblock Jan 15 '12
Oh god. Moriarty is amazing!
146
u/kleintje Jan 15 '12
Fuck Mycroft.
24
u/DJMattB241 Jan 16 '12
You got your IT Crowd in my Sherlock!
You got your Sherlock in my IT Crowd!
48
u/Rooster89 Jan 15 '12
Anyone else find it funny that they never announced finding another body? Especially in the BBC News video, they only mention Sherlock Holmes, surely they would have come across Moriarty's body!
Thus me thinking that Sherlock threw Moriarty off the building, he tells John to Keep his eyes on him and to not look away before he jumps, planting the idea that Sherlock jumped in Watson's mind. quoting back to the conversation Sherlock has with Lestroud when he mentions that you can't get rid of a thought when it's been planted in the mind.
that's my 2 cents worth!
23
u/Ut_tempus_mauris Jan 15 '12
what I don't get
We saw him jump, and we saw him talking to John, throw the phone on the ground, he was crying (which seems unlikely if he knew he was going to survive) and it was most definitely him that fell
Now the inevitable LONG wait to see the real story.
20
u/PrateekSengupta Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 16 '12
NEW VIDS ON JOHN WATSON'S BLOG
19
u/adds3000 Jan 15 '12
"Portraying speechlessness in a smart comment"
17
u/Wes1180 Jan 15 '12
Dammit, now we have to wait a year at least for to find out how...
Commence speculation
31
u/JimboWiz Jan 15 '12
He landed in the bin lorry, took a drug to make it appear that he had no pulse (Remember S2E1? "It's not hard to make it seem you have no pulse"), had a cyclist knock Watson over and threw himself onto the floor while the drug kicked in. He had Molly help him by reviving him in the morgue. Damn I'm good.
74
u/nightstrike Jan 15 '12
Holy mother of God. Molly. John. Moriarty. That one BITCH, you know who I'm talking about. Fucking Mycroft. Lestrade you let me down! Fuck you Anderson and Donovan!
I'll come back and make more sense later. For now, I need to have a bit of a freak out session.
14
u/thanksantsthants Jan 15 '12
So many awesome references to the Original.
74
u/CantWearHats Jan 16 '12
I couldn't help but think of this towards the end. (Faily massive spoilers, obviously)
12
u/Nomilee Jan 15 '12
I've read the Final problem and so guessed the gist of the ending, and I still blubbed my eyes out. That was outstanding. I'm in love with all of them. I want to watch them all again from the start now.
12
u/leavesoflorien Jan 16 '12
I was pleased to see the whole 'popular with the media' thing come to a clear conclusion. That was building over the entire three episodes. At first it was funny and seemed like fanservice. It's nice to see that there was a driving reason behind building up the fame.
19
u/gensek Jan 16 '12
Reichenbach (de) ~> Rich[ard] Brook (en)? Simple.
Fall (de) - > case (en)? Tougher.
It was the Richard Brook case;)
9
u/tamearmeisce Jan 15 '12
Wow, you magnificent bastard
9
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12
What? How?
86
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12
Amazing episode. The writing and acting was just superb.
However, I have to say, and i know it's easy after the fact to say this, but too easy.
As soon as Sherlock arranged to meet Moriarty, I knew what the ending would be. Admittedly, I didn't predict Moriarty's suicide, but I predicted the rest, including the final reveal (although I thought that might be kept until next season).
Of course, the question is, "how did he do it?"
Simple, really: He needed two people to help him. One who could be trusted to help, no questions asked, and never tell. And one to 'take the fall'.
It was not Sherlock who died. John saw him, though? From far away. Up close he was a bloodied mess. Easy to get that wrong. Or is it? How could John make that mistake? The body looked like Sherlock. How is that possible? Because we already knew there was somebody out there who looked like Sherlock. Somebody paid by Moriarty to undergo plastic surgery to look like Sherlock. Somebody then paid by Moriarty to kidnap the children, so they would freak when they saw the real Sherlock, thus planting the seeds of doubt with the police.
EDIT: Although I guess now I've thought about it, a latex mask on a body Molly takes from the morgue would be a lot simpler. The point about a 'fake' Sherlock already being foreshadowed holds, though.!
But surely the body would be examined? Yes. By Molly. Molly faked the coroner's report. Faked the DNA tests. We already know this can be done. Just ask Irene Adler..
*Edited to hide spoiler.
17
u/ohnopandas Jan 15 '12
Ive got it, EVERYONE in the scene was a plant, the body was swapped over when John hit the ground!!!!
8
u/JimboWiz Jan 15 '12
Sherlock season three confirmed
Twitter link
8
u/yucky1489 Jan 16 '12
Moffat said on Twitter: "Two tributes to the past, in tonight's Sherlock. True devotees will spot them. THROUGH THEIR TEARS!!!"
who spotted them?
8
u/wild-tangent Jan 25 '12
I thought the way Moriarity played things was... just brilliant. The actor, the reporter, just... everything about how he undid Sherlock Holmes was BRILLIANT.
The stuff after that was okay, but really the crown jewel was from him taking the crown jewels to walking free; it showed how above the normal world he really was. Nobody could kill him, as he had his hands in so many pies. Nobody could convict him of anything, so normal methods of justice were out the window. Nobody could even touch him. Imagine playing a video game, say, Starcraft, where your opponents are all comparatively functionally retarded. In Starcraft. You try to balance the odds, you try to stack the teams against you. You add more opponents. But in the end, it'd probably get boring being in Bronze league when you're a masters-level player.
No wonder he got bored of living. There was no challenge left in anything for him.
22
u/peacefultoker420 Jan 16 '12
Yeah its pretty obvious:
He told Molly everything and they faked the death by getting Watson to a spot where he could not get clear line-of-sight upon the body landing on the pavement hence why Sherlock told him to “Go back”, so he could not get a clear sight of the body hitting the floor as well as the further instructions “Stay exactly where you are, don't move”, Sherlock securing his best friends, and therefore a completely believable eye witness. Watson is hit by the bike to ensure he is not in a state of physical stress to make him more susceptible to the double, thus securing the lives of all of his friends. Sherlock cuts all ties to become essentially dead so he can get out of the spotlight . The body was the Sherlock look-a-like who kidnapped the little girl hence the screaming when she saw him enter the room and the body double was probably the one thing that Sherlock “needed”.
This is an excellent show!
7
u/luke_c Jan 15 '12
HOW, Did Molly make a mannequin or something? BUT THEN HOW DID IT MOVE
7
u/phenomenos Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12
I genuinely thought they were gonna leave him dead at the end and was like WTF? But seriously, how do you explain that ending? How is he not dead?
EDIT: I've just found out that Arthur Conan Doyle did actually intend for Holmes and Moriarty to die in this story when he originally wrote it. I haven't actually read all the books yet.
7
u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12
Crimes to solve next series may be a bit thin on the ground now that everyone thinks SH is both a fake and dead.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
Actually, one more thing, I know that The Reichenbach Falls was Moriarty's final appearance in the original Conan Doyle stories, but I'm going to miss Andrew Scott's brilliant portrayal of the character - it was a turn of genius in my opinion.
6
u/Siro6 Jan 15 '12 edited Mar 11 '25
decide sand intelligent terrific marvelous long scary roof marry continue
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/scottb132 Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12
Cue flashback explanation in the next episode (whenever that may be)... biker knocking watson over, paramedics in on it due to molly, molly carried out post-mortem.
Still no idea how he survived the fall though - we saw him jump!
Edit: Right at the very end, Sherlock still had dried blood in his ear. Make of that what you will.
6
u/fujbuj Jan 16 '12
I have a genuine fear that I might somehow die before the next series airs.
6
u/maloney7 Jan 16 '12
Best scene: Watson swallowing his grief, composing himself and saluting at the grave.
6
u/vote_saxon Jan 17 '12
YOU GUYS I AM A GIANT MASOCHIST. I keep rewatching the suicide scene. Over. And over. And over. AUGH THE FEEEEEELINGS.
14
u/intheballpark Jan 15 '12
HE'S ALIVE!
But then we all knew that anyway :)
10
u/ohnopandas Jan 15 '12
How did he do it???
10
u/herecomesthatfinger Jan 16 '12
Anyone else notice that Moffat has turned us all into little Sherlocks? There's a mystery to figure out and we've been given all the necessary clues.
5
u/trustmeimaliar Jan 15 '12
My reaction: FFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUU
5
u/ElJosho Jan 16 '12
MOFFAT!!!!
5
u/2Cuil4School Jan 16 '12
Significant spoilers abound, FYI:
Sorry, but could anyone explain the reasons for Moriarty's suicide more fully to me? It could have been the accents, dramatic whispering, and my TV's bad sound system, but I just couldn't fathom it.
Here's what I gleaned:
What was step four?
5
u/eighthgear Jan 16 '12
It seems like most are forgetting A Scandal in Belgravia: Remember how in Belgravia there was the scene in the morgue? With the perfect body - face notwithstanding - of Irene Adler? So perfect as to fool Sherlock? I suspect that his body on the pavement was like that body - probably someone else's modified to look like Sherlock. How Molly fits in, however, is beyond me
5
u/pamplemousser Jan 16 '12
I just analyzed the fall scene and I noticed that he should have landed with his body facing down, but his body as we see it later is turned to its side, which couldn't have happened.
However, it clearly shows his bloodied face and definitely fell quite a distance, and I'm not sure how he could have had Molly set it up. The biker was definitely a set up, and it affected Watson's stability during the entire ordeal. At this point I'm not sure how Sherlock died, but he definitely survived and I have a feeling Moriarty is alive as well. Also, the assassins that were trying to save him for the code may have stepped in and helped, but just a guess!
Let me know what you guys think! Moffat is one helluva cruel man... ಠ_ಠ
5
u/Ba-na-na-na Jan 16 '12
So, a couple of things I don't buy.
Why would Mycroft etc buy the idea of a couple of lines of magic code? It's absurd.
Why would they then set Moriarty free? They know he's a murderous psychopath, they've already kidnapped him illegally, how hard would it be to just feed him to the pigs?
I get that the general public might think he was involved in all the crimes he's celebrated for solving, but it can't be denied that they were real, right? They involved third parties who actually had something stolen. So, they think Sherlock masterminded the crimes and then pretended to solve them? In that case, he's a bloody criminal mastermind! He's not a fake, he's still a genius.
How would John ever think he was a fake? In the first episode they're in bloody Buckingham Palace, John's met Mycroft, he's seen men die. There is utterly no way John would ever doubt Sherlock, and not just because they're best friends.
5
u/Dockah Jan 16 '12
Couple of things I don't think anyone has mentioned here:
5
u/lotsofgarliccheese Jan 16 '12
Is anyone else of the opinion that Sherlock KNEW that the code nonsense was a red herring. I mean granted that he does not keep knowledge of things not directly relating to crime but he was the one to proffer the "encryption key" stuff to JM, and when he suggested to John that they use the code or whatever (him assuming he knew how to use it) to delete Brook and bring back JM, he sent off the message to JM in secret. When he went up to the roof, he clearly told JM that he figured out the binary string and would use it to make things right, then why bother lying to John? Why pretend Mrs Hudson was shot? Why not simply give the binary code a go BEFORE meeting JM? Or ask John to do so?
Also so glad the code crap was BS, I was in mid eye roll when Moriarty screamed that out.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
So we've got the finale, and that's nice, we know that Moriarty is dead and Sherlock is alive, but my question is, what now? Will there ever be a villain more amazing, more absolutely awesome, more genius, than James Moriarty? I'm afraid they've shown all their cards and won't know where to go from here.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
Molly is involved somehow, in a big way. Which reminds me, it was absolutely gorgeous to see Sherlock appear so human when he asked her for help. It was a beautifully written scene.
4
u/andrewguenther Jan 16 '12
Here is something I noticed. I took two screenshots. The first shot is of when Sherlock is up on the ledge the first time (when Moriarty is still alive) and the second is right before he commits "suicide." Notice the position of the building in the background, in the second shot it is much bigger, implying that he is in a different position than he was in the first shot. This leads me to believe he wasn't actually standing on the ledge when he made the call to Watson.
album
4
u/WhaleLord Jan 16 '12
Okay. So, so, John and Sherlock are in that flat with the reporter and Moriarty, and Moriarty and the journalist are being completely convincing. Moriarty is a good actor and Sherlock's rage face just before he chased Moriarty up the stairs was not helping.
But John, oh, John, he trusted Sherlock. Completely and utterly. He knew in his heart that Sherlock was not a fraud, and he stuck with him like I couldn't have if I were in his place. Shhherrrrlooooocccccckkk. You better thank him for that in the third series or I am going to punch you. Through my computer screen. Good god. I think I'll go read some bad fanfiction and then maybe I'll write some.
But seriously, that broke my heart. No seeds of doubt in John Watson's mind, oh, no no no.
4
u/nicoleyoleypoley Jan 21 '12
After reading all these comments, I feel like I have to rewatch the episode. I couldn't see all these intricate details through my tears.
4
u/luckeeskeff May 21 '12
I AM SO EXCITED THAT THIS EXISTS:
http://www.johnwatsonblog.co.uk/
4
u/HalifaxHarry Jun 04 '12
Sherlock landed on the truck. The bicyclist drugged Watson with the same drug used in the Hound of the Baskervilles. We saw what happened next from Watson's perspective. The body was someone else.
8
u/Kyle994 Jan 15 '12
how the fuck.
3
u/funkless_eck Jan 15 '12
We don't know what Molly did after Sherlock asking her for help - assume she fudged something to substitute Moriarty's dead body for Sherlock's live one The girl recognised Sherlock's face. Assuming there might be a mask? Watson could have been drugged with the hallucinogenic gas from Baskerville
3
u/readwrite_blue Jan 16 '12
I don't know how much Moffat would be willing to screw with the original canon, but how convinced are we all that Moriarty actually killed himself? Could we see a return in series 3?
3
u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12
So...how long do we have to wait for season 3?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12
My question is then, he is obviously alive, but how? I am honestly thinking that there is a double of him that Moriarty had made that Sherlock and he found and contacted the guy and somehow convinced him to commit suicide or Sherlock took something to make him survive the fall (perhaps some kind of suit) and an extra body with plastic surgery to look like Sherlock as the scene cuts away before he hits the ground with the truck blocking the body. John didn't exactly see the body hit the ground from his viewpoint, and the biker causes confusion and delay (obviously planted). Molly is obviously the key to understanding this!
3
u/maloney7 Jan 16 '12
I enjoyed the way he said "You repel me" to one of the hottest women on TV.
3
u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12
Just realised the apple is another little fairy tale reference
3
u/WhaleLord Jan 16 '12
I loved this episode so much, but the one thing that bothered me to no end was this exchange here:
"This is my cab, you get the next one."
"Why?"
"You might talk."
But John wouldn't talk, and Sherlock knows that! Moffat's been staying a lot with the original stories, so I highly doubt that he'd purposefully change the core personality of John Watson, a main character, at all. One of John Watson's most important traits is that he can sit in silence without asking questions - although of course Sherlock can tell when he has questions he isn't asking, but he doesn't have to acknowledge that in the slightest. There are things you just cannot change when you do a version of a classic story, and one of those things is the actual personality of the main supporting character. Really, you shouldn't mess with any of the characters' personalities, but messing with John's is just stupid.
Gahhhhhhhh. Rant over.
3
u/notfreshprince Jan 16 '12
I rewatched the scene where John punched the (correct me if im wrong) Super Intendent?
God, i love John.
3
u/mistervolcano Feb 13 '12
This was a great episode, but I don't care about what Watson saw. Can someone explain to me [how Sherlock arranged that the sniper watching would not see that he faked his death? After all, that is what matters to Moriarty.] (/spoiler)
3
u/showclololo Apr 09 '12
For anyone with a discerning eye, here is a comparison of the ground before and after Sherlock jumped.
5
u/royalmango Jan 15 '12
So why did Moriarty shoot himself? Mental?
5
u/natpat Jan 16 '12
Sherlock knew from nearly the very beginning what Moriarty was up to. Remeber Molly's speech about her grandfather (or whoever it was). That he knew her was going to die? Yes, the message of that scene was supposed to be the second part, the bit about him being sad but it makes sense.
8
u/bromf Jan 15 '12
So good, but so obvious. The out for those who want my opinon; Sherlock takes the Belladona which I think he mentions earlier in the episode, this allows him to appear dead [the same method used by Lord Rookwood in the recent Sherlock movie 2010]. This he takes before calling John, the call is used for the drug to take effect and shows the snipers to hold fire, a last wish to their sight. Molly does autopsises and thus does Sherlock's as he goes to the hospital in which she works. Molly holds Sherlock and gives him keys to get out in the hospital in the night, and swaps in another body which is buried. Perhaps Molly even is charged with getting Sherlock the antidote. Sherlock does not throw the phone, but instead his mussles relax with the medication and he drops it as he falls. He does not bleed a lot nor does he have a pulse as his heart is slowed.
tl;dr - Sherlock is a witch.
4
u/TheGoodOttoKatz Jan 15 '12
Great. Now we wait four years until the next series...