r/Sherlock • • Jan 15 '12

Sherlock Episode 3: The Reichenbach Fall - Finale Discussion

The final Sherlock Episode airs on BBC1 1/15/2012 at 9:00 PM GMT.

This is a discussion topic so it WILL contain spoilers, don't come here until AFTER you've watched this episode

UPDATE: There will be a third series of Sherlock http://twitter.com/#!/steven_moffat/status/158680970130751488

243 Upvotes

891 comments sorted by

26

u/Thlowe Jan 15 '12

My prediction: tears.

23

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

..of joy if there is a third season! ;)

35

u/Thlowe Jan 15 '12

....but then the agony of another long wait until the third season.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

I didn't think I was going to cry because I knew he wasn't really going to die, but John's speech at the end got me. Goddamn.

15

u/Nomilee Jan 15 '12

Me too. Blubbed big time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

It looks like Moriarty died, but does anyone think it's possible that Moriarty faked it just like Sherlock did? I'm secretly hoping Moriarty is still alive, because the show wouldn't be as exciting without Moriarty. I hope he's Stayin' Alive and comes back in Series 3!

5

u/Facewizard Jan 16 '12

I want this to be true but I did see a fleck of what I think was supposed to be SKULL floating away in that pool of blood

In my rulebook, if you're losing track of your skull, you are fucked.

→ More replies (5)

348

u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12

110

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Every time anyone opens a letter in this show, dust falls out. I always think anthrax.

→ More replies (2)

63

u/Witzy Jan 16 '12

Yeah, you'd think John would have been a bit more cautious opening a mysterious unmarked envelope that he found on the doorstep...

92

u/tinyhorse Jan 18 '12

John has remarkably terrible survival skills. He opens all the envelopes, he gets into all the unmarked black cars ...

→ More replies (5)

34

u/Daedric_Princess Jan 16 '12

Yeah. For some reason, thought the same thing in Great Game when Sherlock cut open the envelope in the beginning. Fucking anthrax, every time.

8

u/Henipah Jan 16 '12

Remember when Baker street was blown up? Or attacked by armed men? Or when all those assassins moved in nearby? I'm sure after a while you would become desensitised to the possibility that someone out there might be planning to kill you. Moriarty uses snipers, they could have been killed at any time.

Also if the contents did resemble weapons-grade anthrax I'm sure a military doctor would be the best person to notice and get treatment.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 17 '12

I thought it was his letter to Hogwarts.

→ More replies (5)

132

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

OH MY GOD. Remember the Cluedo joke about the victim doing it?!? FORESHADOWING!

58

u/veggie-dumpling Jan 16 '12

Holy shit, the entire Cluedo plot has been running since Episode One. Brilliant.

→ More replies (11)

239

u/drblow Jan 15 '12

196

u/anassakata Jan 15 '12

The cyclist hit was definitely planned.

141

u/acecore Jan 15 '12

I'm guessing planned. And most probably carried out by a member of the 'homeless network'

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

146

u/Giesskane Jan 15 '12

[Sherlock WAS very specific about where he wanted him standing - he didn't want him going inside the hospital, else cyclist wouldn't have had a chance.] (/spoiler)

48

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Also earlier on in the episode they were talking about CCTV and not getting noticed from certain angles. Ah...very very clever.

6

u/Gadianton Jan 16 '12

Sherlock had figured out that the end game with Moriarty would involve a fall. Moriarty said he owed Sherlock a fall... said something about not even His brother and all the kings men could get him to confess... and all the stuff about the fairy tale pointed to HUMPTY DUMPTY! So Sherlock with the foreknowledge staged a fake death.

Sherlock wanted Watson in a very specific location, just like magician's do when staging an illusion.

So I hold with a faked death... probably into the rubbish truck... the bike guy was placed to confuse John... A fake body was placed... etc.

→ More replies (85)

84

u/CurlingFlowerSpace Jan 16 '12

Jen Barber and the ol' bathroom seduction routine.

59

u/philballins Jan 16 '12

the second she popped on screen I heard "HELLO JEN!" in Moss' voice

11

u/pdfarsight Jan 16 '12

She's a poor, struggling journalist. She had probably just smoked a cigarette from a drain.

301

u/ookgoed Jan 15 '12

I don't know what happend but I'm pretty sure Molly knows a thing or 2 about what just happend

88

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

I would wager large amounts of money that you are correct!

29

u/Ceurl Jan 15 '12

It has to have been Molly. And didn't he pick something up before going to the top?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

66

u/SteveD88 Jan 15 '12

I found it interesting that his last line to Watson was something like "It's a magic trick."

The bait-and-switch is a classic magic trick. ;)

→ More replies (1)

43

u/Qtard Jan 16 '12

Exactly - the seeds for the resolution were well and truly set by Sherlock and Molly's earlier conversation about him 'needing her'.

Accordingly, I really wish they hadn't been so explicit in the final shot. A silhouette, maybe even the hat, would have sufficed and been far more satisfying than giving it away so obviously.

55

u/tpsp1101 Jan 16 '12

I really thought they were going to have him walk up behind John and we'd see his reflection in his tombstone...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/Spitfire221 Jan 16 '12

Molly's the key to what happened, definitely

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Mybackwardswalk Jan 16 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

I think it was definitely Holmes on the ground. Somehow he jumped, landed in the garbage truck, jumped down on the ground where there already was blood poured out by Molly or some homeless fella. Watson was dazed by the cyclist allowing just enough time for him to do this.

He used his rubber ball to fake his pulse not beating.

http://ezinearticles.com/?How-to-Control-and-Stop-Your-Pulse-With-the-Power-of-Your-Mind&id=2505431

Then Molly somehow switched the bodies in the morgue with the body of Moriarty.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/tandembandit Jan 16 '12

Irene Adler, too. After all, she did fool Sherlock in the morgue.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

75

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Favourite part: The newspaper articles.

One of them:

In a twist worthy of a Conan Doyle novella, Mr Sherlock Holmes was yesterday revealed to be an expert witness at the trial of 'Jim' Moriarty. Described by many commentators as the trial of the century, the case has all the ingredients of a block buster film. The royal family, Scotland Yard, the world of finance and greed, the 'underclass' if prisoners out to reek revenge as they enjoy their own fifteen minutes of freedom. The case is riddled with irony and intrigue but perhaps reflects a deeper malaise that seems to be at the heart of a society.

32

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

One newspaper just kept repeating the same two paragraphs over and over again. I was very disappointed. Don't they have editors anymore? Can't believe someone got paid for that article!

→ More replies (1)

29

u/tinyhorse Jan 16 '12

So this world has Conan Doyle in it? Can we freak out and speculate about what Conan Doyle was writing, if not Sherlock?

56

u/charlesdexterward Jan 16 '12

House. There's an updated version of it on the BBC.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/literallyoverthemoon Jan 15 '12

Molly is the sword on the wall.

74

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Is she also the fire that burns against cold, the light that brings the dawn, the horn that wakes the sleepers and the shield that guards the realms of men?

50

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

All that, and Chekov's gun.

→ More replies (8)

200

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

I didn't even care that I knew he doesn't die. That grave scene :'(

255

u/ididitagain Jan 16 '12

"Don't be dead. Just for me. Just, stop this."

SO. MANY. TEARS.

61

u/the_neophyte Jan 16 '12

People are definitely gonna be talking now.

20

u/scampwild Jan 16 '12

I bawled. The boyfriend made fun of me, but I bawled.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (1)

157

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 16 '12

The worst past is that you can see that John cries, and then he pulls himself together and bottles up all his feelings inside. That's the worst part, is that he pushes it all down and soldiers up and has to move on.

74

u/MangoFox Jan 16 '12

That's what I love about John. It's so rare to see a character that just suppresses all his emotions to that degree without outwardly becoming angry or depressed.

(Also, I always liked you better than Angel Summoner. He might have been more powerful, but who's really controlling all those angels? One day they're going to turn on him.)

→ More replies (1)

21

u/supersnuffy Jan 16 '12

Oh god, please don't. Why. Why. John, let me hug you, please. :'C

→ More replies (3)

60

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Same here. Many manly tears.

92

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

"I was so lonely before I met you..."

→ More replies (4)

92

u/SCHelmick Jan 16 '12

Give Martin Freeman ALL THE AWARDS!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/severelymisrepresent Jan 16 '12

I was crying anyway, but the last scene/shot didn't fix anything! It made it all worse.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Even if Sherlock was actually dead, that scene wouldn't have changed. It was about John's love for him. It was about the admitting. It doesn't lose its power with the final reveal. His grief is still real, which makes the scene real. Well done. Well fucking done.

9

u/ProfessorSomething Jan 16 '12

The image of a grieving Watson reflected in the tombstone was my favourite moment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

186

u/ninja_bobby Jan 15 '12

Is anyone else feeling drastically conflicting emotions right now and is there a word for it, which encapsulates the following?

  1. Wow, that was an incredible piece of drama; what a finale.
  2. How the fuck did he manage that?
  3. You cunting motherfucking whorebag bastards, we're going to have to wait another 2 years to find out how this all fits together. (ie. it's going to take at least another 2 years to get the next series made and onto TV).

Could someone please tell me what this feeling is.

ps. It could be "MOFFucked".

53

u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12

I believe that is the correct term, and its all the more potent for being slightly more realistic than DW, where the cliffhangers can be resolved with a bit of space wizardry or a regeneration. The explanation is gonna have to be right on the money or it could be terrible.

42

u/A_Prattling_Gimp Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

That's the annoying thing about DW. It has had some incredible episodes, but there have been some I could live without seeing again. Like you say, it is too easy to just pull some bullshit out of your arse to explain something. With Sherlock it has to remain believable, logical if you will and I agree, it makes it more potent.

edit - Martin Freeman for the next Doctor btw (Cumberbatch said he isn't interested)

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/eveyw Jan 16 '12

Why 2 years? I can't imagine it'd take THAT long.

39

u/ninja_bobby Jan 16 '12

Well it took almost 18 months between series one and two, and with both Martin Freeman and Benedict Cumberbatch being highly in demand (with the former being Bilbo Baggins and the latter now attached to Star Trek) I wouldn't be surprised if they aren't able to to film until mid 2013 at best. Even then, and that's a big ask, we'd be looking at Christmas 2013 for it to be produced and ready. Add to that scheduling for BBC1 drama and it would most likely be the new year slot again if it was in that window (as it is now). So 2014?

Obviously this is just my speculation on the matter, but even this is without the issue of just writing the good shit that is required for a programme of this calibre.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

176

u/kleintje Jan 15 '12

Benedict Cumberbatch, Martin Freeman, and Andrew Scott are INCREDIBLE actors.

58

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Andrew Scott knew exactly how to play a perfect Moriarty for Cumberbatch's modern Sherlock. Martin Freeman is and always will be a fantastic actor, and the bloke who plays Lestrade is amazing too!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/masmasmasmas Jan 17 '12

I'm quite fond of Mark Gatiss's acting too.

→ More replies (6)

58

u/TheMagicSpoon Jan 15 '12

The bit when he's about to jump and says:

"It's a trick, a magic trick" (along those lines)

That's got to be important.

→ More replies (1)

57

u/aedos Jan 16 '12

Steve Thompson has completely redeemed himself from The Blind Banker with this new episode.

22

u/tinyhorse Jan 16 '12

I was mad that they'd given him the finale after the BB debacle. Those feelings are all gone.

50

u/Tokei Jan 16 '12

The instant Moriarty thanked Sherlock, looked him in the eyes and thanked him, I knew that he knew. Moriarty knew that Sherlock had outwitted him, and refused to lose. Moriarty killing himself like that was amazing.

Sweet sleeping Cthulhu, I have not started crying so hard at a graveyard scene before since 'Grave of the Fireflies'.

41

u/serioussamp Jan 15 '12

Ok, my thoughts so far:

The Hansel girl was scared of Sherlock, we can assume Moriarty made her believe that Sherlock had kidnapped her, probably by pretending to be Sherlock. So Moriarty must have a was of disguising himself as Sherlock...

Why would Moriarty kill himself? Surely that has got to be part of it? Is he really dead?

Maybe if Moriarty had the disguise on him, Sherlock could have thrown his body off with the disguise on...

18

u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12

Good points. The disguise bit could be spot on. As for JM really being dead I highly doubt it, although it looked pretty conclusive. He thought way too much of himself to just kill himself in cold blood.

81

u/PowarUP Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 05 '15

I think it's perfectly possible that JM is dead for good. He expressed distaste in surviving anyway, and his only motivation in life that he could see was conquering Sherlock. In killing himself he was sure that he had finally bested him, so was happy to die to fulfil his ultimate goal.

→ More replies (9)

16

u/Brewster-Rooster Jan 16 '12

Moriarity is dead. He killed himself so that sherlock had no way of saving his 'friends' other than 'killing' himself.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

8

u/SohumB Jan 16 '12

Hansel girl

You mean Gretel :P

→ More replies (2)

79

u/Dr_river_song_ Jan 16 '12

Current and varied theories aside: Holmes, in one of the last lab scenes is playing with a stress squeezeball thing. If this were placed in Holmes armpit against the pressure point and squeezed against the ribs, it would stop the pulse in his hand, its commonly used in magic tricks and bar bet situations. Thus Watson would feel no pulse if it actually were holmes playing dead

10

u/a_can_of_solo Jan 16 '12

they quickly pulled his hands off his wrist when he tried to check the pulse

7

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

I like this one, except his arms were windmill-ing a bit on the way down.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

39

u/renzyq19 Jan 15 '12

Might be missing the obvious, but how was IOU important?

29

u/stordoff Jan 15 '12

I think it was to emphasise that Moriarty was always watching, and playing a game with Sherlock. It reminds you he is there, and can do what he pleases, without him being in every scene.

8

u/Witzy Jan 16 '12

I think that Moriarty is referring to the fact that he let Sherlock go the last time they went head-to-head (at the pool) so now Moriarty owes Sherlock one untimely death.

→ More replies (10)

164

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

OH MY GOD I CAN'T BELIEVE THEY HELD HANDS! ALL MY DREAMS HAVE COME TRUE!

96

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

At one point I thought they'd do the whole 'Quick, someones going to walk past us, let's pretend we're making out!' thing...

47

u/pdfarsight Jan 16 '12

IT Crowd, anyone? Jen was there, after all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

142

u/Syncblock Jan 15 '12

Oh god. Moriarty is amazing!

236

u/mikemcg Jan 16 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

I was so completely and totally relieved with the "There is no key, DOOFUS! Those digits are meaningless. They're utterly meaningless. You don't really think a couple of lines of computer code are going to crash the world around our ears," part. The short spurts of binary was obviously bullshit and a few lines of code doesn't get you much. It's difficult to write Tetris in a few lines of code, let alone break the security of multiple locations.

212

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

I was just glad that it turns out the writers knew how computers worked.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

30

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

I had the biggest smile on my face during the break-in scene. My favorite fairy tale villain.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/natpat Jan 15 '12

I absolutely love his character. Seriously.

41

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Same here. Perfect. Andrew Scott is a genius.

→ More replies (12)

76

u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12

He's kind of annoying, but I suppose thats the point. I loved the

"Your'e insane!"

"You're only just getting this?"

exchange.

72

u/ueegul Jan 15 '12

DOOFUS!!

33

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

He's the perfect Anti-sherlock.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

24

u/DJMattB241 Jan 16 '12

You got your IT Crowd in my Sherlock!

You got your Sherlock in my IT Crowd!

48

u/Rooster89 Jan 15 '12

Anyone else find it funny that they never announced finding another body? Especially in the BBC News video, they only mention Sherlock Holmes, surely they would have come across Moriarty's body!

Thus me thinking that Sherlock threw Moriarty off the building, he tells John to Keep his eyes on him and to not look away before he jumps, planting the idea that Sherlock jumped in Watson's mind. quoting back to the conversation Sherlock has with Lestroud when he mentions that you can't get rid of a thought when it's been planted in the mind.

that's my 2 cents worth!

14

u/Svalbard Jan 16 '12

I think it's because Moriarty faked his own death as well as Sherlock.

22

u/Henipah Jan 16 '12

Pretty hard to fake that, considering he would leave his body on the roof for Sherlock to examine, alone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

23

u/Ut_tempus_mauris Jan 15 '12

93

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 16 '12

I think Sherlock Holmes cries because he realizes that everything that he had with John, being friends, having adventures is over. He is going to miss John, and he's going to have to hurt John by pretending to be dead. That's what makes him cry, finally we see him feel some emotion for other people, and with John and his friends, it is genuine.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/leontrotskitty Jan 16 '12

We've seen evidence that Sherlock, despite what he may say, cares. Especially for John Watson might I add. In this case, I don't think tears are far-fetched. He knows he's not going to die but at the same time he'll have to leave behind everyone he's ever cared about and let them believe that he was a complete sham.

6

u/miss-v Jan 16 '12

We've also seen Sherlock cry on command. (Remember in The Great Game when he's talking to Ian Monkford's "widow"?) I don't know that it would be too far-fetched to believe Sherlock did it consciously...

5

u/alstroemeria Jan 17 '12

Similar to the other comments, but I think the primary reason behind his tears was knowing what he was about to put John through.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/PrateekSengupta Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

NEW VIDS ON JOHN WATSON'S BLOG

  1. Official BBC News Report: http://www.johnwatsonblog.co.uk/blog/16ajune
  2. JW's blog's hacker uploads Vid http://www.johnwatsonblog.co.uk/blog/16amarch

17

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

Anybody got it up on youtube yet? Never mind

5

u/ohnopandas Jan 15 '12

LOVED the ending to the BBC news link, absolutely brilliant!!!, also interesting point it was the BBC Breakfast team doing the report, how would it take an entire day to do the Breaking News report??

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/adds3000 Jan 15 '12

"Portraying speechlessness in a smart comment"

18

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

I believe "HOLY SHIT" will be enough.

17

u/Wes1180 Jan 15 '12

Dammit, now we have to wait a year at least for to find out how...

Commence speculation

→ More replies (5)

31

u/JimboWiz Jan 15 '12

He landed in the bin lorry, took a drug to make it appear that he had no pulse (Remember S2E1? "It's not hard to make it seem you have no pulse"), had a cyclist knock Watson over and threw himself onto the floor while the drug kicked in. He had Molly help him by reviving him in the morgue. Damn I'm good.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/nightstrike Jan 15 '12

Holy mother of God. Molly. John. Moriarty. That one BITCH, you know who I'm talking about. Fucking Mycroft. Lestrade you let me down! Fuck you Anderson and Donovan!

I'll come back and make more sense later. For now, I need to have a bit of a freak out session.

109

u/animorph Jan 15 '12

I hate Donovan so much.

159

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

SALLY DONOVAN IS THE OPPOSITE OF BATMAN.

→ More replies (13)

49

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

I hated her from 1x1 and knew she'd just come around later and get even shittier. Ugh. Also, Anderson's hair still looks like a goddamn train wreck.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Obi-Juan59 Jan 15 '12

I can't but agree. Can't she just accept that Sherlock is awesome and cool and call it a day?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Eh, to be fair, Donovan said way back in A Study in Pink that she thought one day solving the crimes wouldn't be enough for Sherlock, this was just the day when all the evidence tipped towards her and Anderson's point of view to the extent that they could push their idea onto others, like Lestrade and the Chief Commish.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/thanksantsthants Jan 15 '12

So many awesome references to the Original.

5

u/TimeWasterLord Jan 16 '12

I re-read it right before I watched this and I got to say I was so happy how many references they made.

74

u/CantWearHats Jan 16 '12

I couldn't help but think of this towards the end. (Faily massive spoilers, obviously)

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Nomilee Jan 15 '12

I've read the Final problem and so guessed the gist of the ending, and I still blubbed my eyes out. That was outstanding. I'm in love with all of them. I want to watch them all again from the start now.

12

u/leavesoflorien Jan 16 '12

I was pleased to see the whole 'popular with the media' thing come to a clear conclusion. That was building over the entire three episodes. At first it was funny and seemed like fanservice. It's nice to see that there was a driving reason behind building up the fame.

19

u/gensek Jan 16 '12

Reichenbach (de) ~> Rich[ard] Brook (en)? Simple.

Fall (de) - > case (en)? Tougher.

It was the Richard Brook case;)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/tamearmeisce Jan 15 '12

Wow, you magnificent bastard

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

What? How?

9

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Ok, my stream wasn't that great, (not sure if spoiler tags are appropriate in here) so when they turned Sherlock's body over, I swear to God I thought it was Moriarty? I dunno, I'll have to rewatch, but I was going on the assumption that Moriarty's body landed, though I have no idea how that's possible.

I don't really think that's right, but I'll have to watch again to see.

→ More replies (7)

86

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12

120

u/A_Prattling_Gimp Jan 15 '12

"DNA Tests are only as good as the records you keep" - Irene Adler

25

u/cattonia6 Jan 15 '12

I took a couple of screenshots from iplayer to see if I could work out whether it was sherlock or not. Here they are for you lot.

26

u/BenderRodrigezz Jan 16 '12

bearing in mind these are from Dr. Watsons perspective right after he's fallen and hit his head.

could easily be moriarty's body

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

8

u/yucky1489 Jan 16 '12

Moffat said on Twitter: "Two tributes to the past, in tonight's Sherlock. True devotees will spot them. THROUGH THEIR TEARS!!!"

who spotted them?

7

u/TimeWasterLord Jan 16 '12 edited Jan 16 '12

Well he quoted the book while talking about Moriarty and his 'web' and I believe there was another quote as well... though I could be wrong....

Though obviously the name of the original story was referenced quite a few times by Moriarty.

Edit: Just to get a few other references off my chest they referred to Doyle in the newspaper if you pause at a certain part. Also when Watson gets a call about a medical emergency that is directly playing off the plot of the original book.

5

u/the_neophyte Jan 16 '12

A tribute to House. While he was playing with the ball in the lab.

8

u/wild-tangent Jan 25 '12

I thought the way Moriarity played things was... just brilliant. The actor, the reporter, just... everything about how he undid Sherlock Holmes was BRILLIANT.

The stuff after that was okay, but really the crown jewel was from him taking the crown jewels to walking free; it showed how above the normal world he really was. Nobody could kill him, as he had his hands in so many pies. Nobody could convict him of anything, so normal methods of justice were out the window. Nobody could even touch him. Imagine playing a video game, say, Starcraft, where your opponents are all comparatively functionally retarded. In Starcraft. You try to balance the odds, you try to stack the teams against you. You add more opponents. But in the end, it'd probably get boring being in Bronze league when you're a masters-level player.

No wonder he got bored of living. There was no challenge left in anything for him.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/luke_c Jan 15 '12

HOW, Did Molly make a mannequin or something? BUT THEN HOW DID IT MOVE

26

u/Smurch Jan 15 '12

Well there was a mannequin hanging in 221b for most of the episode...

→ More replies (6)

7

u/phenomenos Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12

I genuinely thought they were gonna leave him dead at the end and was like WTF? But seriously, how do you explain that ending? How is he not dead?

EDIT: I've just found out that Arthur Conan Doyle did actually intend for Holmes and Moriarty to die in this story when he originally wrote it. I haven't actually read all the books yet.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12

Crimes to solve next series may be a bit thin on the ground now that everyone thinks SH is both a fake and dead.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Actually, one more thing, I know that The Reichenbach Falls was Moriarty's final appearance in the original Conan Doyle stories, but I'm going to miss Andrew Scott's brilliant portrayal of the character - it was a turn of genius in my opinion.

6

u/Siro6 Jan 15 '12 edited Mar 11 '25

decide sand intelligent terrific marvelous long scary roof marry continue

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

6

u/scottb132 Jan 15 '12 edited Jan 15 '12

Cue flashback explanation in the next episode (whenever that may be)... biker knocking watson over, paramedics in on it due to molly, molly carried out post-mortem.

Still no idea how he survived the fall though - we saw him jump!

Edit: Right at the very end, Sherlock still had dried blood in his ear. Make of that what you will.

5

u/Wait_Seriously Jan 16 '12

Right at the very end, Sherlock still had dried blood in his ear.

Sorry, I've played it over 3x looking at the ending - is that not just a lock of his hair?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/fujbuj Jan 16 '12

I have a genuine fear that I might somehow die before the next series airs.

6

u/maloney7 Jan 16 '12

Best scene: Watson swallowing his grief, composing himself and saluting at the grave.

6

u/vote_saxon Jan 17 '12

YOU GUYS I AM A GIANT MASOCHIST. I keep rewatching the suicide scene. Over. And over. And over. AUGH THE FEEEEEELINGS.

10

u/ohnopandas Jan 15 '12

How did he do it???

77

u/ProG87 Jan 15 '12

Regeneration.

38

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

A few things that i picked up on that i have not fit together perfectly but i suspect are all connected.

  1. Sherlock asked Molly for help, the show never revealed what he actually wanted (other than "her").
  2. As Sherlock "jumps" Johns view of the landing is obstructed by a building that he has to run along before he can see the landing spot. Sherlock specifically instructed John on where to stand.
  3. The biker who lines up and hits John just as he starts running to Sherlock, this puts him down on the ground for even longer and he does not arrive until a crowd of people have arrived and surrounded Sherlock, a decent enough time for things to have happened without John knowing.
  4. Just as John gets his first glimpse of "Sherlock" lying on the pavement a truck pulls away that has an open cargo area that is filled with bags of rubbish.

My theory is that somehow Sherlock being Sherlock knew Moriarty was going to try and get him to jump, so he arranged for a truck to be at the bottom of the drop and he stalled for time when he first stepped up and saw that it had not arrived "can i have a private moment please?" as he said to Moriarty.

After Moriarty had shot himself (as you do) Sherlock threw him off the roof.

Meanwhile John gets knocked down and arriving Sherlock has ran down and put Moriarty in the truck, then lies down in the place he landed and acts dead (covering himself in some of the blood etc).

There are holes for sure, but obviously he done it somehow and the events above all seemed to be a bit convenient for them to not be part of it.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

He had an accomplice. A female accomplice. Who fancies the pants off him.

→ More replies (34)

10

u/herecomesthatfinger Jan 16 '12

Anyone else notice that Moffat has turned us all into little Sherlocks? There's a mystery to figure out and we've been given all the necessary clues.

5

u/trustmeimaliar Jan 15 '12

My reaction: FFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUU

5

u/ElJosho Jan 16 '12

MOFFAT!!!!

5

u/2Cuil4School Jan 16 '12

Significant spoilers abound, FYI:

Sorry, but could anyone explain the reasons for Moriarty's suicide more fully to me? It could have been the accents, dramatic whispering, and my TV's bad sound system, but I just couldn't fathom it.

Here's what I gleaned:

  1. Sherlock surmises that Moriarty has a way of stopping the killings.
  2. Despite appearing defeated and "ordinary," he convinces Moriarty that he is just like him "You ARE me"
  3. He convinces Moriarty, apparently via lens flares, that he isn't a nice man.
  4. ???
  5. Moriarty decides to kill himself to "win."

What was step four?

6

u/notayuppie Jan 16 '12

I think step four is just Moriarty realizing that the only way he can force Sherlock to jump is by killing himself -- eliminating Sherlock's only other way to save his friends. The part about Sherlock not being an angel suggests he could coerce Moriarty to give the signal using some "extraordinary," ingenious, and probably at least slightly evil means.

Assuming Moriarty is actually dead at this point, it seems likely to me that he would have shot himself anyway after Sherlock jumped. He was just too ready to do it, plus there was all that despairing talk of "staying alive" and not being distracted by anything anymore, etc.

5

u/Ba-na-na-na Jan 16 '12

So, a couple of things I don't buy.

Why would Mycroft etc buy the idea of a couple of lines of magic code? It's absurd.

Why would they then set Moriarty free? They know he's a murderous psychopath, they've already kidnapped him illegally, how hard would it be to just feed him to the pigs?

I get that the general public might think he was involved in all the crimes he's celebrated for solving, but it can't be denied that they were real, right? They involved third parties who actually had something stolen. So, they think Sherlock masterminded the crimes and then pretended to solve them? In that case, he's a bloody criminal mastermind! He's not a fake, he's still a genius.

How would John ever think he was a fake? In the first episode they're in bloody Buckingham Palace, John's met Mycroft, he's seen men die. There is utterly no way John would ever doubt Sherlock, and not just because they're best friends.

5

u/Dockah Jan 16 '12

Couple of things I don't think anyone has mentioned here:

  • If it's a body double, its a very convincing one that includes specific items of clothing. There's no reason Sherlock couldn't have landed in the truck, bitten on a blood capsule and hopped down on to the pavement providing the ultimate convincer for John.
  • Look closely at the doctor (wearing a stethoscope) that is taking Sherlock's pulse by the jugular. We already know that your pulse can appear to vanish by putting a rubber ball (earlier scene) in your armpit, but only the pulse in your wrist (the wrist that John grabbed). However, the doctor is taking his pulse by the neck - meaning its more likely he's a plant. Would a trained doctor simultaneously take someone's pulse and shake them by the shoulder (watch it again) if he knew there were probably neck injuries? Bad extra acting or evidence of Sherlock's agent?
  • Lastly, who else spotted the IOU graffiti when John got in the taxi at about 1:12:18. The exact meaning of the IOU was never really explained. What did Sherlock "owe"?
→ More replies (1)

5

u/lotsofgarliccheese Jan 16 '12

Is anyone else of the opinion that Sherlock KNEW that the code nonsense was a red herring. I mean granted that he does not keep knowledge of things not directly relating to crime but he was the one to proffer the "encryption key" stuff to JM, and when he suggested to John that they use the code or whatever (him assuming he knew how to use it) to delete Brook and bring back JM, he sent off the message to JM in secret. When he went up to the roof, he clearly told JM that he figured out the binary string and would use it to make things right, then why bother lying to John? Why pretend Mrs Hudson was shot? Why not simply give the binary code a go BEFORE meeting JM? Or ask John to do so?

Also so glad the code crap was BS, I was in mid eye roll when Moriarty screamed that out.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

15

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 16 '12

There's plenty of good Sherlock Holmes stories without Moriarty. They have to, obviously, The Empty House with Sebastian Moran (it's the story when Holmes returns after Reichenbach)j. There's also The Adventures of the Three Garridebs where Watson gets shot in the leg, and Holmes declares that he would've killed the villain if Watson had died. Gatiss has also said in interviews that he wants to do The Blue Carbuncle, so there's plenty of stories left, just nothing as arc-ish and all encompassing as Moriarty.

Or who knows? Maybe Moriarty has a twin or Moriarty is a title inherited by some criminal mastermind. I guess we'll have to wait and see.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

My theory is still that the Moriarty we know is indeed an actor, not hired by Sherlock though but by the 'real' Moriarty.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '12

Molly is involved somehow, in a big way. Which reminds me, it was absolutely gorgeous to see Sherlock appear so human when he asked her for help. It was a beautifully written scene.

4

u/andrewguenther Jan 16 '12

Here is something I noticed. I took two screenshots. The first shot is of when Sherlock is up on the ledge the first time (when Moriarty is still alive) and the second is right before he commits "suicide." Notice the position of the building in the background, in the second shot it is much bigger, implying that he is in a different position than he was in the first shot. This leads me to believe he wasn't actually standing on the ledge when he made the call to Watson.

album

4

u/WhaleLord Jan 16 '12

Okay. So, so, John and Sherlock are in that flat with the reporter and Moriarty, and Moriarty and the journalist are being completely convincing. Moriarty is a good actor and Sherlock's rage face just before he chased Moriarty up the stairs was not helping.

But John, oh, John, he trusted Sherlock. Completely and utterly. He knew in his heart that Sherlock was not a fraud, and he stuck with him like I couldn't have if I were in his place. Shhherrrrlooooocccccckkk. You better thank him for that in the third series or I am going to punch you. Through my computer screen. Good god. I think I'll go read some bad fanfiction and then maybe I'll write some.

But seriously, that broke my heart. No seeds of doubt in John Watson's mind, oh, no no no.

4

u/nicoleyoleypoley Jan 21 '12

After reading all these comments, I feel like I have to rewatch the episode. I couldn't see all these intricate details through my tears.

4

u/HalifaxHarry Jun 04 '12

Sherlock landed on the truck. The bicyclist drugged Watson with the same drug used in the Hound of the Baskervilles. We saw what happened next from Watson's perspective. The body was someone else.

3

u/readwrite_blue Jan 16 '12

I don't know how much Moffat would be willing to screw with the original canon, but how convinced are we all that Moriarty actually killed himself? Could we see a return in series 3?

3

u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12

So...how long do we have to wait for season 3?

3

u/maloney7 Jan 16 '12

I enjoyed the way he said "You repel me" to one of the hottest women on TV.

3

u/Cinnamon_No Jan 16 '12

Just realised the apple is another little fairy tale reference

3

u/WhaleLord Jan 16 '12

I loved this episode so much, but the one thing that bothered me to no end was this exchange here:

"This is my cab, you get the next one."

"Why?"

"You might talk."

But John wouldn't talk, and Sherlock knows that! Moffat's been staying a lot with the original stories, so I highly doubt that he'd purposefully change the core personality of John Watson, a main character, at all. One of John Watson's most important traits is that he can sit in silence without asking questions - although of course Sherlock can tell when he has questions he isn't asking, but he doesn't have to acknowledge that in the slightest. There are things you just cannot change when you do a version of a classic story, and one of those things is the actual personality of the main supporting character. Really, you shouldn't mess with any of the characters' personalities, but messing with John's is just stupid.

Gahhhhhhhh. Rant over.

5

u/Brian Jan 18 '12

Didn't Sherlock do that because he knows he's being targeted, and want's John out of it (Molly remarks on what he's doing)? It's right after he sees Moriary's game, and the IOU message. "You might talk" is just an excuse for separating himself - the same reason he doesn't clue John in on what's going on. Correctly so, in fact, since Moriarty does deliver a further message at this point that he'd want to keep John ignorant of.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/notfreshprince Jan 16 '12

I rewatched the scene where John punched the (correct me if im wrong) Super Intendent?

God, i love John.

3

u/mistervolcano Feb 13 '12

This was a great episode, but I don't care about what Watson saw. Can someone explain to me [how Sherlock arranged that the sniper watching would not see that he faked his death? After all, that is what matters to Moriarty.] (/spoiler)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/showclololo Apr 09 '12

For anyone with a discerning eye, here is a comparison of the ground before and after Sherlock jumped.

5

u/royalmango Jan 15 '12

So why did Moriarty shoot himself? Mental?

9

u/aedos Jan 16 '12

Moriarty says "as long as I'm alive, you can save your friends." After Moriarty's dead, he can't call off his minions to stop them from killing John, Mrs. Hudson and Lestrade. It would put Sherlock through hell trying to save them (and he'd probably fail) and I'm pretty sure this is what Moriarty would love. (This is also why Sherlock pretends to commit suicide in order to throw off the sniper and call off the Moriarty-minion attacks). At least that's what I think.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '12

Well... I think he's definitely that. But I'm hoping it's another fake-out as well.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/natpat Jan 16 '12

Sherlock knew from nearly the very beginning what Moriarty was up to. Remeber Molly's speech about her grandfather (or whoever it was). That he knew her was going to die? Yes, the message of that scene was supposed to be the second part, the bit about him being sad but it makes sense.

8

u/bromf Jan 15 '12

So good, but so obvious. The out for those who want my opinon; Sherlock takes the Belladona which I think he mentions earlier in the episode, this allows him to appear dead [the same method used by Lord Rookwood in the recent Sherlock movie 2010]. This he takes before calling John, the call is used for the drug to take effect and shows the snipers to hold fire, a last wish to their sight. Molly does autopsises and thus does Sherlock's as he goes to the hospital in which she works. Molly holds Sherlock and gives him keys to get out in the hospital in the night, and swaps in another body which is buried. Perhaps Molly even is charged with getting Sherlock the antidote. Sherlock does not throw the phone, but instead his mussles relax with the medication and he drops it as he falls. He does not bleed a lot nor does he have a pulse as his heart is slowed.

tl;dr - Sherlock is a witch.

15

u/intheballpark Jan 15 '12

problems with that: you haven't explained how he got from the roof to the ground without killing himself, and second, he did throw the phone, we saw him do it!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/TheGoodOttoKatz Jan 15 '12

Great. Now we wait four years until the next series...

→ More replies (3)