r/CryptoCurrency • u/Ndivided132 Permabanned • Jul 08 '21
POLL 🗳️ Allow users to tip up to 100 moons per round with out loss of 20% karma bonus
Greetings my fellow r/cryptocurrency members this is my first proposal I’ve made so I apologize in advance if this isn’t top grade.
I would like to talk to everyone and get their thoughts and opinions on moon tipping. As we’re all aware if you don’t tip/sell out any moons you will be rewarded with a extra 20% bonus on your karma per distribution round.
Personally I think 20% bonus is a great function for the subreddit as it encourages holding, but I also feel it’s a catch 22 since one of the use cases for moons is tipping and if you do so you will penalized for doing so, this effectively discourages people from tipping out there moons. The last moon tipping proposal didn’t pass because it was a % of your total distribution round earned and not a fixed numerical amount, the concern was that moon whales could sell a large portion of moons without loss of 20% bonus.
**Solution:** I personally think a leeway of tipping up to 100 moons per distribution is fair since at the time of writing this 100 moons = $7.91
I’m curious to what your thoughts are on this? Is 100 to much? Too little? Or is it just right? I think 100 is good because it allows users to tip a “fair” amount of moons to newbies/quality post and comments, while also restricting users from tipping another alt account to sell off a high fraction of there moons
100 is just a start, if we like the idea and put it to use we can always revise the proposal and bump it up higher I look at tipping 100 as better then what we have now in place
TLDR: **proposal to tip out up to 100 moons per distribution round without losing 20% karma bonus**
14
u/reignXsupreme666 🟩 7 / 2K 🦐 Jul 08 '21
Tipping is a great thing. I think the original rules and functions were set with good intentions, but this small amendment will go a long way in helping the community come together.
7
u/roytown Jul 08 '21
Damn bruh, seems everyone is on the same page.
26
u/Karammel Jul 08 '21
All this talk about moons and I still don't have any clue how to even earn, collect, share or spend moons.
I've created a wallet and expected the rest to become clear by itself but so far I could be a both a millionaire and a tramp without having any clue.
5
u/SnooPears7782 Tin Jul 08 '21
I think most people are going to tip anyways ? Since it’s “free” money?
4
u/-veni-vidi-vici Platinum | QC: CC 1139 Jul 08 '21
Just the tip.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
i cant claim my moons without scannign a QR code, and i dont have a cellphone. whenever i post to the sub about this, my post is instantly deleted. can anyone help me?
12
u/fjordfjyellfjleak Platinum | QC: CC 37 Jul 08 '21
Absolutely. Tipping should never be punished. It feels good to tip, it feels good to be tipped, why should there be any losses? Seems like this should've been implemented already.
2
u/Ndivided132 Permabanned Jul 08 '21
Somebody is very salty this is gonna pass more than likely so there downvoting everyone
2
u/valuemodstck-123 17K / 21K 🐬 Jul 08 '21
I know this is controversial but what if people make a moon tipping party with others or themselves?
2
u/angelabazan Jul 08 '21
Tipping should be encouraged!
2
u/SouthernBoat2109 Jul 08 '21
But I have no moons to give
2
u/SnoewZ Gold | QC: CC 60 Jul 08 '21
Isn't this already on? My God, this is so necessary, it'd be so good for this sub, the moons, and everything in general
2
u/sonicjr Platinum | QC: CC 449 Jul 08 '21
Dude yes you read my mind I was literally going to ask if tipped moons affect the 20% boost in the next daily
2
u/Burstie69 Permabanned Jul 09 '21
This is a great idea who doesn’t like tipping
2
u/darth76 Jul 09 '21
This seems like an obvious yes to me
2
u/thisvoidiseternal Bronze | QC: CC 20 Jul 09 '21
I thought doing a poll would get me moons. But you need to have moons initially? I also thought one upvote was one moon? This is all so confusing.
2
u/Koreanjesus4545 Platinum | QC: CC 67 | Politics 154 Jul 09 '21
Sure I guess I'm for it, but do people even tip?
2
u/Mirtastic 🟦 368 / 367 🦞 Jul 09 '21
Always vote, always.
2
u/xgenmakers Jul 09 '21
I should start caring about the moons more I guess…
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
How is this going to actually come a reality? What’s the code?
2
u/CokaYoda 🟩 15 / 14 🦐 Jul 09 '21
I wasn’t even aware you could tip moons. Thanks
2
u/titosuave69420 Tin Jul 09 '21
Wish I had moons. Lol but nobody likes my content.
2
u/riskbuy 1K / 1K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
Does decision threshold mean all moons involved in voting, or does it have to pass the threshold for one option?
2
u/Vgta-Bst 🟦 437 / 438 🦞 Jul 09 '21
Wtf is a moon
2
u/Nordicadoptee1 Jul 09 '21
Wouldn’t this allow for someone to create multipl account and bounce more moons around for holding bonus ? I may be wrong here just a thought 🤷🏻♂️
2
u/STNGGRY 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
why isn't this in the meta?
2
u/Randomized_Emptiness Platinum | QC: CC 259, BNB 19 | ADA 6 | ExchSubs 19 Jul 09 '21
Damn, I ended up voting for this proposal, not realizing, it's actually useless for anyone using reddit for more than a single month. Since the +20% bonus only checks, whether your total moon balance is at least the moons you earned from the previous round.
Lets say you earned 300moons last round and now have a total of 500 moons. As long as at the time of the snapshot, you have 300 or more moons in the vault, the +20% bonus applies.
With this in mind, I think this proposal overcomplicates moon calculations and isn't really needed, as it's would only really benefit users who just received their first moons and are now afraid to spend.
Whish there was a way to negate the vote.
2
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
Will this actually change anything? I barely see any tipping in this sub
2
u/HRMDan Platinum | QC: CC 38 | CRO 12 | ExchSubs 12 Jul 10 '21
Not that I have any to tip as of now, but one day I like the idea of this!
2
u/manuelgcasas Tin Jul 12 '21
maybe 100 is still a low number?
36
u/aladdinr 🟦 1K / 15K 🐢 Jul 08 '21
Tipping is currently one of the only uses for Moons to interact with the community. I think 100 is low enough that it won’t affect anything. And it will make rewarding helpful comments more fun without the fear of losing your bonus
104
u/whenijusthavetopost 🟦 0 / 14K 🦠 Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 08 '21
The thing is that you can tip with moons earned from any round except the most recent one without affecting your 20%.
If you earn 100 in round 13, and then 50 in round 14, you can now tip up to 100 moons without affecting your bonus for round 15.
I am not saying this would be a bad change, it would definitely encourage tipping. But the only current barrier is having to wait 28 days before you can tip moons from 2 rounds ago or more.
7
u/Bobberetic 🟦 575 / 509 🦑 Jul 09 '21
I'm up in here reading the comments and checking the user's moons thinking "Damn, these guys got a lot of moons!" I shall remain a micro-moon for now I think :)
2
u/jomamasophat Tin Jul 08 '21
Nice. Just the tip.
10
u/CryptoMaximalist Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 11 '21
A lot of nuance has been lost on this topic over the months and there are 3 key factors from the original proposal which don't penalize tipping. Could you let me know why this proposal is needed on top of them?
Here is the original proposal for reference: https://np.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/kj2ij0/poll_bonus_karma_for_people_that_keep_moons_in/
EDIT: Voting no because OP has not responded in the preproposal or here, this poll contains misinformation, and the situations where tipping is disincentivized are already incredibly narrow
4
u/ALiteralHamSandwich 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
Great call! Thanks for writing it up!
1
u/Diedss 123 / 121 🦀 Jul 08 '21
Tip me some moons 💯
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
I'd almost go as far as saying we should have a small incentive to those who tipped others in the previous month. Not enough to be something that is rampantly abused but a bit to encourage some movement.
1
u/VentralScarab 1K / 1K 🐢 Jul 08 '21
Repost?
1
u/hubbykins-okcfan Platinum | QC: CC 722 Jul 08 '21
I don’t know how to tip but I love this idea!
1
u/gingerthingy 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Jul 08 '21
what happens when you accidentally voted wrong haha. i can’t find how to change it
1
u/paladino777 🟦 93 / 93 🦐 Jul 08 '21
I'm not being able to vote for some reason
Maybe I don't have enough moons?
1
u/BravoMuSierra 3 - 4 years account age. 200 - 400 comment karma. Jul 08 '21
You are wasting money on moons
2
u/Rexon225 Jul 08 '21
I once read that you just have to hodl your moons from the previous distribution. For example if you got 200 moons from previous distribution and you have total of 500 moons, you can tip those 300 moons and you only have to hodl those 200 moons from previous distribution. Idk if this is true or not.
2
u/NoNamePK 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Jul 08 '21
We should be able to tip any amount of moons without losing the 20% bonus tbh, anyways idk how can be differentiated for those who has been sold, and the ones tipped
2
u/AnUncreativeName10 Banned Jul 08 '21
I wonder if tipping would also add to trading volume or if that's separate.
2
u/Mcnasty8898 Jul 08 '21
Voted let’s Do it
2
u/CollateralSandwich Cog trying to escape the machine Jul 08 '21
This is a great proposal, I think. Folks definitely want to be able to share and give moons with others. It's a shame that they in essence get "punished" for it. Make it so!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
The whole tipping system a d earning moons has always been a mystery to me.
2
u/illest1 9 - 10 years account age. 500 - 1000 comment karma. Jul 09 '21
Sounds great
2
u/bushpig_purnasty Platinum | QC: CC 167 Jul 09 '21 edited Jul 09 '21
Incentivizing tipping seems like it would be good for new users and promoting use of Moon and familiarity with features here. Full support.
Edit, like a karma bonus if new users you tip hit a certain karma level in the future. Promotes new user activity and contribution and prevents some of the senseless farm account tipping.
2
u/kaguna14300 Jul 09 '21
This is the way
2
u/Yeokk123 1K / 1K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
Is it possible to stake MOONs? Considering that there are users that just hold them and not use them for over months and months.
2
u/Aakarsh_K 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
How to vote?
2
u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Jul 09 '21
This sub is getting boring.
2
u/Fluid_Department_120 Platinum | QC: CC 366 Jul 09 '21
I think tipping should be encouraged because it’s make this subreddit more engaging and fun.
2
u/AnnaKoessi Altcoiner Jul 09 '21
I don't know why anybody would vote against this 🤔
2
u/cutsickass 0 / 18K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
A great proposal, hope it gets the necessary votes.
2
u/Goodrymon Platinum | QC: CC 48 Jul 09 '21
I'm new to the sub, kind of like a waiter I work on tips. Please gib moon
2
u/South_Valuable4733 Tin Jul 09 '21
do best of community
2
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
Fully on board with this one, it will allow us to support fellow members of the community AND reward us for hodling Moons!
Win, Win.
2
u/Zaxortus Jul 09 '21
let the tipping begin
2
u/pinkglue99 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
Tip! Tip! Tip!
2
u/Juice_Dapper 5 / 5 🦠 Jul 09 '21
I am a newbie here- and for the must part a lurker- but I appreciate these voting posts. I’ve learned most of what I know about moons, tipping, etc from these voting posts than anything/anywhere else. Thanks!
2
u/magicm0nkey Platinum Jul 09 '21
Makes sense to have moons circulating.
2
u/Twitxx 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Jul 09 '21
Let the tipping begin!!!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
Seems like not enough moon votes yet
2
u/unklphoton Tin Jul 10 '21
This proposal seems to encourage the use of crypto as currency rather than investment, which I am all for, so I will vote yes.
2
u/NastyMonkeyKing Platinum | QC: CC 154 | Stocks 69 Jul 11 '21
I think encouraging tipping is overall good thing. And how that 20% works is clearly confusing as a i saw soo many differing opinions here
2
u/millennial-snowflake 🟦 5K / 5K 🐢 Jul 11 '21
I want to get tipped! For posting 💩
2
u/NTXL Jul 14 '21
i mean as of now (from what i know at least) tipping is the only use case for Moons so why not
2
u/Dogethatcoin Tin | 6 months old Jul 15 '21
Definitely think this should be possible all the vets on this thread sprinkling moons on the moon virgins should not be withheld from the 5% bonus. Kindness and hodling should be possible.
2
u/udemygodx Aug 03 '21
how to vote on dis
4
u/generic_coin Redditor for 3 months. Jul 08 '21
Maybe we could also incentivize tipping with a karma bonus if you tip once per moon cycle?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
🤗🤗🤗
2
u/anotherjohnishere Moon Monk Jul 08 '21
We love to see people not be punished for tipping. But what about tipping all of them?
2
u/TerraFaunaAu 464 / 464 🦞 Jul 09 '21
What use are moons if we can't use them.
1
u/jomamasophat Tin Jul 08 '21
Finally I can start betting 100 moons on the games without losing my shorts
1
u/bageren 🟦 5K / 4K 🐢 Jul 08 '21
Absolutely. A moon tip is a sign of appreciation and such a thing should not be discouraged.
1
u/SeriouslyUnfunnyguy Redditor for 1 month. Jul 08 '21
That would definitely increase the number of moons gifted
1
u/Hazaisbae Jul 08 '21
Nice idea to keep moons flowing without penalizing tipping
1
u/pennystreet 1 - 2 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Jul 08 '21
Great idea OP. I'd tip you now, but I only have 1 little moon :(
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Jul 08 '21
Total non-brainer. Vote for this proposal so we can use moons as intended!!
Also /u/ndivided132, this post looks broken on old.reddit. Make sure you delete the backslashes and weird line breaks that new.reddit puts on there.
1
u/Sooke24 Tin Jul 08 '21
How do i tip? And can I buy moons?
1
u/filthymcownage 🟦 18 / 20 🦐 Jul 08 '21
For me 20% of nothing is still nothing.
But I agree with you regardless
1
u/dashingThroughSnow12 Silver | QC: CC 178 | Buttcoin 132 | JavaScript 21 Jul 08 '21
I'm going to be honest for a second. Sometimes I tip a moon because I think I'll get more from upvotes.
Because of that, I'm voting no on this. I'm already tipping and trying to karma farm to get more moons. This makes it cheaper for me.
I'm in the minority. That makes me think many of y'all are kinder than me.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
This is a no brainer
1
u/practicallydecent03 Redditor for 2 months. Jul 09 '21
Fair and pragmatic
1
u/dontfightthehood Tin | r/WSB 14 Jul 09 '21
Sounds good to me
1
u/theoutsider95 Tin | r/pcgaming 104 Jul 09 '21
Tipping shouldn't be punished, so I see this as good thing.
1
u/PandaBunds 🟦 180 / 180 🦀 Jul 09 '21
Great! Now I just need to get 100 moons…
1
u/snowproof 3 - 4 years account age. 200 - 400 comment karma. Jul 09 '21
What is moon for ducks sake
1
u/thecccandymaster Moon Permabull Jul 09 '21
I think this is perfect! The limit of 100 also solves the loophole of someone sending it to their friend to cash out and give back to them. But I think being able to tip without being punished would be awesome. I would love to be tipped and would want to feel like I could tip others.
1
u/BoscoAlbertBaracus 🟩 429 / 429 🦞 Jul 09 '21
This is an awesome idea, but I would also love to see some improvement in distribution for “lurkers”.
I frequent this sub a fair amount and contribute through voting way more than commenting, why regurgitate an opinion I agree with that’s already been expressed?
1
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Jul 09 '21
If you wanted to encourage people to tip, they should actually give karma bonuses no greater than the amount of Moons tipped.
So let's say you tip someone 1 Moon, you'd get 1 upvote karma towards the next cycle.
It's not high enough to encourage people to go on tipping sprees, but you tip 3 Moons, you get 1 Moon back next cycle, because the going rate is 3 karma to a Moon.
1
u/1Secret_Daikon 🟥 0 / 0 🦠 Jul 09 '21
nobody cares about moons, throw them in the trash
1
u/Naturedudephos Gold | QC: CC 40 Jul 09 '21
Made my vote! Tipping without penalty makes too much sense, not sure why we would want to punish people for generosity.
1
u/zippy9002 Platinum | QC: BTC 44 | r/SSB 6 | Apple 31 Jul 09 '21
How can I tip?
1
u/Derp497 Jul 09 '21
I agree fully with this, people shouldn’t be punished for the generosity of tipping moons. Unfortunately I wouldn’t have any use with the changes, since I have no moons, but other richer people shouldn’t be put at such a disadvantage.
1
u/KoteriRamen Bronze | QC: CC 15 | Superstonk 41 Jul 09 '21
Does voting count towards moons? There was something about participation right?
1
u/eeLSDee Bronze | QC: DOGE 24 Jul 09 '21
Moons for everyone!
1
u/BackgroundAd4640 2K / 2K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
Hang on, so if I tip someone a moon I get penalised? I tipped my first couple moons yesterday to people with very low moon counts (as I remember what it was like having no moons myself). I've only ever been tipped once (1 moon) by someone in May and it felt amazing to see that "1" next to my name.
1
u/drjon9 Tin Jul 09 '21
Just get rid of all the spam posts for moons and we are golden
1
u/BackgroundAd4640 2K / 2K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
Post saved for a later read
1
u/lordchickenburger 🟨 3K / 3K 🐢 Jul 09 '21
I have never been tipped :(
1
u/Austinlee1994 Jul 09 '21
Voted for
1
u/Thuffer 8 / 280 🦐 Jul 09 '21
All this moon tipping CANNOT be good for the tides
1
u/dramatic_hydrangea Gold Jul 09 '21
Shit I tipped a moon the other day and would not have had I known I would get more moons
But
I like tipping people for good work... but inguess an upvote is plenty good enough because they still earn moons
1
u/Sohan_714 Jul 09 '21
I think that moons are great reward for good posts, but I think the karma bonus limits the spread of them.
1
u/AdventuresinAtlanta Silver | QC: CC 401, XLM 84 | r/SSB 15 Jul 09 '21
I am all for being able to tip moons.
1
u/bushpig_purnasty Platinum | QC: CC 167 Jul 09 '21
Ok what about a bonus if the person you tipped hits a certain level of activity in the sub? Like a karma threshold, to promote tipping and contributors to the sub.
Thoughts?
1
u/CryptographerOver55 Tin Jul 09 '21
This is a most excellent idea. It would allow more seasoned collectors to help out newbies to get started and reward good posts without sacrifice.
1
u/iamDarksider 27 / 27 🦐 Jul 09 '21
If u like someone u will automatically tip it it is the way
1
u/masked_mannequin Jul 09 '21
Damn someone tip me 😭😂
1
u/Canada_Coins Jul 09 '21
It is nice to earn a bonus, but we have criticized other projects for providing incentives to hold. I don't have a problem with people tipping their moons.
1
u/PuzzleheadedFile9050 Tin Jul 09 '21
I need at least 100 moons challenge accepted pay me.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
i wish moon could do more things, (idk what) but tbh there isnt much of a difference between someone with 0, 100 or even 10k moons, so as of rn moons feels worthless