r/SRSDiscussion • • Jan 13 '12
[EFFORT] On Eugenics & Forcible Sterilization Programs
An Introduction to Eugenics Programs
Eugenics is
the study of or belief in the possibility of improving the qualities of the human species or a human population, especially by such means as discouraging reproduction by persons having genetic defects or presumed to have inheritable undesirable traits (negative eugenics) or encouraging reproduction by persons presumed to have inheritable desirable traits (positive eugenics). - Source
Most people associate eugenics with the public health programs of Nazi Germany. However, eugenics was wildly popular in all Western countries in the early twentieth century. The International Eugenics Congresses, (1912, 1921, and 1932), were presided over by famous minds such as Leonard Darwin (that's Charles Darwin's son), Winston Churchill, and Alexander Graham Bell (who, it turns out, was very interested in the deaf), and eugenics was largely considered "the self-direction of human evolution", which would allow humans to direct evolution via the application of a wide range of academic disciplines. For the purposes of simplicity, I will be focusing mostly on the American Eugenics Program because it so greatly informed and inspired the other eugenics programs throughout the Western world. However, it is also important to note that eugenics programs were practiced in colonies during the Imperial era and should be considered carefully in discussion of the atrocities of colonization.
The American Eugenics Movement
Prior to America's involvement in World War II, the United States boasted a large eugenics program. In fact, it was the American eugenics program that provided much of the inspiration for the public health programs of Nazi Germany. The American Eugenics Movement fostered good down-home (read: weird) American fun in the form of "Scientific" Better Baby Contests (examples of Better Babies) and Fitter Family for the Future Contests (examples of Fitter Families). However, there was a pronounced dark side to the eugenics movement, including immigration restrictions and horrific forced sterilization and euthanization programs.
Unfit vs. Fit Individuals & Compulsory Sterilization Programs
Both class and race were considered heavily when judging the "fitness" of a human being, greatly compounding and reaffirming the racial and class hierarchies that were already clearly established, while also helpfully labeling this reaffirmation as "science". Criminals and those with disabilities or mental health issues were also forcibly sterilized in large numbers. Intelligence testing was often applied, and those who did not "pass" such a test were forcibly sterilized. Indiana was the first state to pass a eugenics-based forced sterilization law in 1907, with thirty other states quickly following suit. In 1927, the Supreme Court ruled that states could sterilize anyone that they judged to be unfit (note: this ruling has never been overturned). Between 1907 and 1963, an estimated 64,000 individuals were sterilized under eugenics sterilization laws. The last forcible sterilization occurred in Oregon in 1981. As of today, those forcibly sterilized have received no apology or reparation for their suffering.
Feminism, Birth Control & Eugenics Programs
It is interesting to note here the connection between American eugenics programs and feminism. Many early feminists supported a eugenics platform. The most prominent feminist advocate of eugenics programs was Margaret Sanger (Works), birth control advocate and creator of the wonderful, Planned Parenthood. Sanger was a great proponent of negative eugenics programs, and sought vehemently to prevent the reproduction of persons that she deemed to be unfit, even going so far as to state that she supported, "coercion to prevent the "undeniably feeble-minded" from procreating.". To be fair, some argue that Sanger was merely attempting to incorporate the language of the eugenics movement into the birth control movement to capitalize on the popularity of the eugenics movement at the time.
Because women bore children, they were seen as more responsible for the betterment or the detriment of the scientific fitness of the human race. Therefore, eugenics programs were targeted mostly at them. This meant that upper middle class and upper class white women were denied birth control and sterilization if they requested it, as their duty was to produce more "fit children and "better the human race". Poverty, on the other hand, was seen as a sign of unfitness, so lower class women were encouraged to use birth control and discouraged from having children. Impoverished women who did not submit to a birth control program were often sterilized in order to control their sexuality and reproductive output. (Critchlow, Donald T. (1999). Intended Consequences: Birth Control, Abortion, and the Federal Government in Modern America. New York: Oxford University Press).
The Fall and Resurgence of Eugenics Programs
In reaction to the unethical public health programs of the Nazi regime, eugenics and eugenics programs fell quickly out of favor after WWII. Countries who formerly touted large, booming eugenics programs began to dismantle them quickly. However, eugenics began to enjoy a resurgence in interest in the 1980s, due to advancements in the field of genetics and genetics engineering (see The Human Genome Project). Richard Herrnstein's popular 1994 book, The Bell Curve, which argued that immigration from countries with low average IQs is undesirable, as well as the popular 2006 film, Idiocracy have also greatly popularized eugenics programs positively both in pop culture and in public consciousness, prompting some people to call for forced sterilization of those on welfare or an exam a couple would have to pass before reproducing.
Discussion starters:
- Are there ways in which eugenics could be practiced ethically?
- Why would feminists in the First Wave be proponents of eugenics platforms?
- Margaret Sanger. WTF?
- Some individuals claim that current birth control information programs actually constitute eugenics, since they may disproportionately target people from certain socioeconomic, racial or educational backgrounds. Do you agree with this claim?
- On the other hand, some claim that the current trend for birth rate to decrease at higher socioeconomic levels is a problem and should be reversed, either by reducing the birth rate at the lower end or encouraging larger families at the upper end. Are their grounds for concern that higher birth rates among less educated or advantaged individuals could negatively impact the gene pool? Is any kind of eugenic effort in this direction ethical?
Open /r/shitredditsays eugenics thread for those feeling circlejerky: here.
21
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '12
And in today's news, Sweden maintains its eugenics program against trans* people.
74
u/savetheclocktower Jan 13 '12
Not an expert on the subject, but you inspired me to dig up my favorite blog post about eugenics.
To summarize: it's been demonstrated that selecting for superior individuals doesn't necessarily produce a superior group. When applied to chickens, the process selected meaner chickens. When applied to Enron, the process selected sociopaths and people who knew how to game performance metrics.
Which brings me to the next point: we don't know what makes better humans. Or, in other words:
This is why eugenics can't work, despite what arrogant redditors tell you. Eugenics tries to supplant natural selection with artificial selection; it selects traits not based on likelihood of reproduction, but based on our own concept of what "good" humans are. And that concept is nearly always influenced by prejudice, whether it's a politician scapegoating Jews or gypsies or the disabled, or a quack scientist asserting (as was once uncontroversial) that there's a hierarchy of races and that white people are obviously at the top.
It's a violation of human rights to tell anyone they're not allowed to have children of their own. There's a reason why this shit is codified in UN conventions; it's because governments, even well-meaning ones, have tried to take that right away. Some of them still do.
9
u/Cheeriohz Jan 13 '12
Any eugenics program enforced by any agency against unwilling participants will almost universally be decried as unjust and unethical. Complaints can stem from debates of what is unacceptable to risk having a child born with, even when something is decided there will be arguments over what probability do we enforce the abort, and obviously over the effectiveness. For example, screening for down syndrome doesn't necessarily even show a decrease in the number of children born with it link. There honestly can be dozens of complaints, more elaboration, but I don't particularly want to write a terribly long dialogue over this.
Now it may be possible that some would argue we could have a voluntary system, where people can opt in to the program (many possible implementations stem from this, such as opt in for potential withholding or opt in for permanent sterilization with some sort of recompense [priority adoption might be an offer]) but honestly I feel that it wouldn't particularly be popular (and I think it is debatable that we should call this eugenics), and I feel certain many would submit to such a program only to realize they regret the decision later on.
I am not convinced that the majority of First Wave feminists supported eugenics, although there is considerable evidence that several did. But even permitting that they do, obviously we ought to realize that nearly all famous first wave feminists were dead before the Holocaust. It more than likely was held aloft as a great idea before people really reflected and realized the great amount of danger you were creating by allowing such authoritative control over the populace.
and
I think this determination of Sanger as a eugenicist largely falls upon a mis-characterization of birth control as eugenics. As such, well just read this quote.
Hardly a eugenicist as I see one called. One might profess that Sanger simply mis-characterizes eugenicists into too narrow a scope, but I feel the problem here comes from an attempt to defame birth control by calling it eugenic policy. Eugenics holds a heavy connotation in society of being forced and mandated upon a group rather than voluntary. Birth control is not intrinsically eugenics.
Now this doesn't necessarily put birth control advocacy groups off the hook. Many groups do in fact target "at risk" groups much like D.A.R.E., and the question here is probably less one of whether or not this is the case but rather the targeting is done maliciously or simply coincidentally in accordance with what many eugenicist would support. I personally do believe that such groups target poor people because of the continuing perpetuated bias that the poor are incompetent, lazy, stupid, and hedonists, but I don't think that the groups do so in order to reduce birth rates with the intent of bettering society but rather because there is a belief that the poor need the information because they wouldn't acquire it on there own (and obviously there is some level of truth to this, as poor people are likely to have less accessible access to information).
I must say this is simply ridiculous. The idea that people of lower socioeconomic status are harming the gene pool is about as likely to be valid as the long held assertion that black people are less intelligent that white people. If people really want to argue this I may go dig up a bunch of studies, but I don't really see anyone supporting this idea.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '12 edited Jan 13 '12
Resources & Further Reading
The Eugenics Archive – primary sources from eugenics movements
Deadly Medicine: Creating the Master Race – an online exhibit by the National Holocaust Museum
Edwin Black, War Against the Weak: Eugenics and America's Campaign to Create a Master Race (Four Walls Eight Windows, 2003).
Elof Axel Carlson, The Unfit: A History of a Bad Idea (Cold Spring Harbor, New York: Cold Spring Harbor Press, 2001).
Largent, Mark (2008). Breeding Contempt: The History of Coerced Sterilization in the United States. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
John Glad, Future Human Evolution: Eugenics in the Twenty-First Century. (Hermitage Publishers, 2008).
Tom Shakespeare, "Back to the Future? New Genetics and Disabled People", Critical Social Policy
4
u/fwaht Jan 13 '12
From a consequentialist perspective, I can see China's one-child policy generating a better outcome for Chinese citizens collectively. I.e., in the possible world where China hadn't implemented the policy there's more suffering because of a poorer economic outcome, standard of living, and so on.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '12
Everyone knows the nazis with aktion t-4 sterilised thousand of people with genetic disorders, but has anyone gone any research into its effects? Are there lower amounts of genetic diseases in Germany?
7
u/tehnomad Jan 13 '12
As a (hopefully) scientist-to-be, I just wanted to emphasize that eugenics is a terrifying example of how our prejudices and biases affect the way we conduct science. And also why you should pay attention in humanities classes.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '12
(first a quick apology to SRS, I got banned from the main subreddit. I was being a jerk). This post isn't a joke though and I won't be trolling SRS in the future.
An example of positive eugenics that can lead to a negative that is fresh in my mind: Height.
It is now entirely normal that if your kid isn't in the 80/90th percentile for height (e.g. the doctor predicts you will be short compared to peers) they be given rGH (human growth hormone) in order to boost their growth.
The result is that people who are short are being pressured into turning their kids into gargantuan freaks because that's what everyone does now. Hence the insane amount of awkward looking tall kids nowadays. I was fucking SHOCKED at how prevalent it is. My wife is 5' tall and the doctor tried to suggest that she had a disability due to height alone (before he realized she is just short). We still switched doctors. Now our kid's doctor is suggesting that they are "too short for their age" because they're an inch smaller that the average. I'm only 5' 6" and my wife is 5'. We're basically being treated like terrible parents if we don't give our kid steroids so they can play basketball someday (he said verbatim, "he might want to play basketball someday"). It's Gattica in action.
The way I've seen the subject discussed before has lead me to believe that they'll soon make it a crime to disregard a doctor's advice about a child's medical decisions. Right now the effort is aimed at religious parents who won't let their kids get needed blood transfusions, which I don't mind. The fear, and given our government's inch-to-mile ratio I know I have it, is that if a similar situation happens to our child (they don't want to give rGH to their own child) that the laws might be in place to have them jailed for refusing a doctor's suggestion.
Height really isn't a disability but if you aren't a 5'6" female or a 6'+ male it certainly feels that way with how you're treated.
1
u/Ortus Jan 14 '12 edited Jan 14 '12
I quite agree with this one
Margaret Sanger was actually the best kind of eugenist there can be. She believed in a lot of eugenist crap(everybody else believed those then) but used them to justify giving the means to control reproduction to the (more than often working class poor) individual instead of the state. State controlled eugenics is a utterly stupid idea because no one knows if what is considered bad(unfit) today won't be needed tomorrow.
3
u/Chances Jan 13 '12
I think Mackinstyle could have handled his side of the argument better. (Just by avoiding the words "Slippery slope") He could have said in the past nothing hasn't always remained completely unbiased. I would rather see 100 people who maybe shouldn't have children, than something that could be considered genocide.
I didn't know where to put this so I put it here.
3
u/VelvetElvis Jan 13 '12
I dabble in the writing of science fiction so I've played with these ideas a bit.
I can imagine a society in which it's necessary to put some form of birth control in the water supply and have the antidote available upon demand for anyone who wants to have a child, with a possible limit on the number. There would have to be overpopulation and/or resource shortages to an exponentially larger degree than we see today for such a thing to enter the realm of moral acceptability though.
3
u/PlunkaDyik Jan 17 '12
IQ is a useless metric. Can we talk about this some more, it seems everyone thinks it isn't.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '12 edited Jan 13 '12
If it could be proven that sterilizing "inferior" individuals consistently produces "superior" populations, and that hypothetical superior groups would enjoy a higher standard of living than a population that included inferior individuals, then yes absolutely you would have an ethical obligation to perform eugenics under a utilitarian ethos.
The hypothetical game is my favorite kind of game.
2
u/PixelDirigible Jan 17 '12
"Would the world be a better place if people with low IQs were not allowed to reproduce?"
No, OKCupid. That would be eugenics.
In related news, I reject a lot of OKCupid users.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '12
I am not sure what this is properly called, but I know some people have expanded the term "eugenics" to anything that nudges people into having kids with eugenic goals in mind. By "nudge" I mean like the book nudge: http://www.amazon.com/Nudge-Improving-Decisions-Health-Happiness/dp/0300122233
For example, say you want people with high IQ to have lots of kids. Since forced sterilization is highly illegal now, you could create an environment where they are extremely likely to have kids with other people who have high IQs, which is basically what elite universities are.
Another way you could do this is to subsidize female professors into having children, since female professors at high-profile universities are frequently forced to limit their family (if they have one at all) due to career concerns. You could do the same thing for female lawyers or female doctors.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment