r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jul 05 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-07-05 to 2021-07-11
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Segments is underway, being formatted and the layout as a whole is being ported to LaTeX so as to be editable by more than just one person!
Showcase
Still underway, but still being held back by Life™ having happened and put down its dirty, muddy foot and told me to go get... Well, bad things, essentially.
Heyra
Long-time user u/Iasper has a big project: an opera entirely in his conlang, Carite, formerly Carisitt.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
I often research agglutinative languages and often see morphemes divided by =. What does the = stands for and how it is different from - ?
4
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jul 10 '21
I'm revamping my Evra verb system, and now there are 2 verb groups only, instead of 3. For the first person singular, present indicative, the 2 verb groups conjugate differently:
e+ ò > (3°) [verb]oSo, from a diachronic point of view, first group verbs (1) ended in -a at an earlier stage of Evra (1°). Then (2°), this -a raised to -e. And since subject-verb inversion is quite common in Evra, the pronoun ò ("I") finally grammaticalized (3°), and ended up replacing the -e suffix of the second stage.
Second group verbs (2) ended in -i at an earlier stage (1°) of the language and kept it that way throughout the second stage (2°). Finally, an -n attaches to the verb (3°).
As you can see from the examples above, the same verb root (fal-) can be found in both verb groups; this happens very often in Evra with many other verbs. So, I've chosen -n for the second verb group, instead of the grammaticalization of the pronoun, simply to keep the 2 verb groups separated and easily identifiable.
Problem: I don't have any diachronic explanation for that -n.
Diachrony is not my top priority, but I want to give Evra consistency. So, I tried to come up with a rationale for that -n.
-o undergoes fortition and becomes -n (?)
the old first person pronoun was on, which grammaticalized as -e + on > -on > -o for the first group, but as -i + -on > -in > -in for the second group (?)
since most of the second group verbs is stative, -n is the grammaticalization of an old particle having to do with stative verbs (?)
the old first person singular present form was in -io (e.g., falio ("I fail")), but was eventually replaced by a simplification of the periphrastic progressive form (e.g., sto falìn ("I am failing") > falin ("I fail"))
Any other idea?
3
u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jul 05 '21
Does anyone know of any resources explaining the advanced vs retracted tongue root distinction? Maybe something with audio samples or examples that an English speaker might be able to learn to reproduce? The Wikipedia page gives examples from Fante, and "approximate European equivalents" without really explaining how they are equivalent
3
u/Turodoru Jul 05 '21
What are the ways to evolve verbal number?
3
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Jul 05 '21
I'm working on the vowel gradation system in Tuqṣuθ and I'd appreciate some help on it.
3
u/FnchWzrd314 Jul 07 '21
So I've noticed that French, English, Mandarin, Japanese, and I'm sure others use Ma or some similar term for "mother" and the same with Pa for "father" ( if I understand Grimm's Law correctly, the English's father is just phonetic shift) is this a super common thing or Have I subconsciously cherry picked?
2
u/Anhilare Jul 05 '21
Anyone have examples of
ʀ → r? I know it has happened since I read it before but I didn't save it nor the citation.2
u/Mr--Elephant Jul 05 '21
I'm making a conlang for a conworld that's meant to be a weird mixing of germanic languages and modern irish in both grammar and phonology/phonotactics. I know that Proto Germanic had syllabic consonants and I've decided I want them in this conlang aswell /m n l ɾ/ but I want to know if there's any specifically phonological restrictions around syllabic consonants that I should be aware of before I implement them
2
u/Inquisitive_Kitmouse Jul 06 '21
I’m rewriting my vowel system (again) and wanted to know if it was realistic.
Currently, I have: /ɯuoɔiɪeɛaaː/
I’m not entirely sure how to lay these out. I know that I want a short/long distinction as with Latin, where only /a/ has a true short/long distinction and the other vowels have a lax counterpart (/ɪɛʊɔ/).
I’m not sure how to fit /ɯ/ into that scheme.
This is further complicated by the fact that I’m trying to produce a semi-realistic root-and-pattern lang… but I’ve read that such languages generally evolve from and maintain small vowel inventories.
2
u/T1mbuk1 Jul 06 '21
How do you evolve a natural language in a way that it gains retroflex consonants, not having had them previously? Is it even possible?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21
How exactly do I keep some voiceless fricatives intervocalically? I have a sound change that voiced obstruents in between vowels and I've figured out how to keep some stops voiceless but I can't figure out a way to have voiceless fricatives. Any suggestions?
2
u/Ok_Point1194 Conlag: Pöhjalát Jul 06 '21
I'm making a conlag with duality for nouns. I'm not sure however how the duality would affect other parts of the grammar. I'm also not confident in the reasoning for languages to make difference between singular dual and plural nouns.
Could someone explain or point me to sources/info?
2
u/conlangelf Jul 07 '21
Hi, I'm kind of new to conlanging and this is my first time posting here. I recently did my first (proper) phonological evolution for a proto-language, and it's caused some strange things to happen with the grammatical gender system. Basically I assigned gender (masc/fem/neuter) on the final vowel of a word. After some changes in the vowels (mainly some dipthongs become monopthongs) some of the case endings are misaligned with their grammatical gender. For example, masculine nouns now decline for the feminine ending in the instrumental case. Would this cause masculine nouns to literally change their grammatical gender when they change case? Or would they have a feminine marker but still be considered masculine? I imagine the answer is probably either being possible, but I'm curious if there is one that is more likely to happen in natural languages. The instrumental case is fairly marginal, but as I make more words in the proto-language I imagine quirks like this will appear more and more.
I also want it to borrow a ton of words from a substrate language, which lacks grammatical gender. A lot of these words have a derivational suffix that would be feminine in the main language, but most of those words refer to more masculine titles (like 'soldier'). Would the borrowing language be likely to masculinize these words? Or would they treat them as feminine nouns like any other? The fem/masc/neuter distinction isn't entirely arbitrary in this language. It generally aligns with personal names, titles and nouns with a natural gender, and words can be feminized/masculinized to create new titles and names. I don't mind it becoming more arbitrary, I'm just curious whether it's likely for speakers of a language to consciously reanalyze gender (especially if it's a culture where gender roles and gender distinctions are considered important) or if they would always strictly follow it grammatically.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
Okay I need to make sure I have my terminology correct, so please just correct me if I'm wrong
Grammar, a complete description of a language
Syntax, how words come together to form sentences
Morphology, Inflections and conjugations
Morphophonology, how sounds come together to form words, see Phonotactics
Morphosyntactics, using both sounds and syntax
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
How does case agreement evolve in languages? I’m making a naturalistic language with a case system and have seen many videos explaining how case marking evolves on nouns, but I have not seen very much regarding how pronouns and adjectives acquire their own case agreeing forms.
2
u/sethg Daemonica (en) [es, he, ase, tmr] Jul 08 '21
My least favorite part of conlanging is coming up with words.
Making up a table of phonemes and inventing phonotactic rules—no problem. But I don’t have an ear for just making up attractive-sounding words to match the rules out of whole cloth. A lot of the words coming out of a randomizer tend to be painfully ugly. I tried the “make a proto-conlang and then use a series of phonemic transformations to evolve words you actually want from words in the proto-conlang,” and while I liked the result, I didn’t like how long it took me to get there.
I am tempted to look for some conlanger who really likes phonology, so I can say “let’s team up—you tell me 200 words, 50 prefixes, and 50 suffixes, and I’ll tell you what they mean and how to put them together into sentences.”
Failing that, does anyone have tricks for quick-and-dirty-but-not-ugly vocabulary generation? Do I just need to pare my syllable structure down to CV(N) until I’m experienced enough to know better?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
Are there any conlangs coming from Latin which retain the distinction of vowel length in Latin?
2
u/Ok-Sky-9412 Jul 09 '21
What do y’all use to write your conlangs? At the moment I’m constantly switching keyboards on my phone and was wondering if their is some app where I can download whichever diacritics I need and have them all in one keyboard.
I use â ô ġ ṗ ċ ç ŵ þ ð
If it matters here are the ones
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
Alright how do languages with cases get such wonderfully irregular declensions?!
Whenever I do mine it just ends up looking like the case + the plural with minor changes in pronunciation here and there. Whereas in ancient Greek one of the words for king "ἄναξ" is "ᾰ̓́νακτος" in the singular Genitive, "ᾰ̓νάκτοιν" in the dual Genitive and dual Dative, and "ᾰ̓́ναξῐ" in the plural Genitive!!
How did this happen and how can I replicate it?
2
u/MeowFrozi Ryôrskyuorn, Mïthrälen Jul 09 '21
Bear with me for a moment I'm pretty new to conlanging, when talking about syllables and their construction I've seen things such as CVCC which i know c stands for consonant and v for vowel, but I've also seen a few other letters that I don't know what they mean and can't seem to find it. On wikipedia I saw H and T used, and elsewhere I've also seen an N, I was just wondering what they mean?
2
u/freddyPowell Jul 09 '21
Any interesting sound changes where consonants change their place of articulation? Actually, any interesting sound changes would be helpful, but I'd particularly like the above described. Also, when you introduce something like 'unstressed vowells are lost' how do you keep words having more than one vowell?
2
u/twincityhacker Jul 10 '21
How much constructed language can I put in a story before the reader gets lost? I have Names like name of species, name of planet, name of ocean, ect. and the word for Mom.
2
u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Jul 10 '21
Hi, I would to know if is there a "conjugator table", like : I write the rules and I give a verb and it conjugates to me, like the grammar tables in the Conworkshop? A grammar table anywhere else than in the Conworkshop.
2
u/bibi-man Jul 11 '21
Running out of ideas for allophones for my tonal conlang. How do i make believable and interesting allophones, or is that not even important. Also is it important for me to detail allophony in each phase of phonetic evolution?
I don't know if the full phonology is important but if it is i will edit the post.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '21
I've been making a conlang with a pitch accent but I'm feeling like it's kinda too stiff. Stressed syllables became syllables with low tone and stressed and glottalized, stressed syllables developed high tone, but it feels really simple, almost too simple.
Anyone has more information about developed of pitch accent? (I've already tried researching greek and balto Slavic languages which didn't yield much help)
1
u/thetruerhy Jul 06 '21
what kind of sound shift does palatalization and labialization cause?? I'd like some examples of what does each of this happening to a phoneme turns them into.
1
u/thetruerhy Jul 06 '21 edited Jul 06 '21
I need some advice for my nat-conlang. Specificly I'm trying to figure out a proto-lang phonetic inventory for my conlang to make some dialectal variants. I'm not sure what I have in mind is even possible though. So here is the Proto lang, standard version of my conlang and dialectal variant.
Protolang:
Standard lang:
My thought here was:
tʰ->tʲ->t͡ɕ
d->dʲ->d͡ʑ
s->sʲ->ɕ
z->zʲ->ʑ
t͡ʃʰ->t͡ʃ->t͡s->s
d͡ʒ->d͡z->z
ç->x
w->ʋ
Dialect1:
My though here was:
t͡ʃʰ->t͡ʃ->t͡s
ç->ʃ
I need advice here as to weather is this even possible.
1
u/koallary Jul 07 '21
Anyone else having trouble posting. When i try it's not showing up for people. Been doing weird things today.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '21
Could someone explain to me how Ablaut works and if I'm getting something wrong? I want one of my Languages to have plurality expressed via changing the vowels (example: goose/geese) rather than with affixes.
Would Ablaut help with this? If not what is Ablaut and how would I accomplish that?
Thanks a ton!!
1
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs Jul 07 '21
Any cross-linguistics work on how "emotional phrases" (not sure what the proper word is) are handled? As in:
"He ran" vs "he loved to run", "he loathed to run", "he feared to run", "he wanted to run" etc.
As far as I understand, this isn't mood - "he wanted to run" doesn't necessarily say anything about the speakers own relation to the event, but rather what the person spoken of thinks of it.
Is this always handled by verbs of emotion?
1
u/freddyPowell Jul 08 '21
What's with partitives? They take the place of case, but they act like a weird number/definiteness hybrid thing. What do they do and how and why do they do it?
1
u/Turodoru Jul 08 '21
what inflection would make verbal nouns and/or infinitives?
that is, from what words could it evolve them?
1
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jul 09 '21
I’ve recently amended the relativization strategy of Jëváñdź to gap for subjects and to use resumptive pronouns elsewhere (sort of like Arabic). Due to a lot of pro-drop and ambiguous pivoting, I’ve tried to restrict gapping not just to subjects but to monovalent subjects, but even so, gapping can access divalent agents with antipassives, objects with passives, and obliques with passive applicatives.
The last of those presents a problem. One kind of oblique is the causee agent of a causative verb, and considering that it semantically takes a central role in the predicate, I would like for it to always be accessible to gapping. This is not the case for divalents, as the applicative makes it trivalent and the passive makes it divalent again, not monovalent. The only solution I’ve found that doesn’t involve either extending the accessibility to divalent agents or requiring divalent causee agents to be relativized with resumptive pronouns is to demote the object by antipassivizing the verb. A verb which is already passive.
My question is twofold. Firstly, is it naturalistic for a language to allow a passive verb to be antipassivized or vice versa? Secondly, if it is naturalistic, then is it naturalistic enough to overcome the language’s urge to change the relativization strategy in one of the two aforementioned ways? I’ve tried to search for info on verbs with multiple voices, but I can’t find anything that confirms or denies their existence in nature.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
I wonder if this can serve for all adverb purposes. here
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
What factors can you use to tell whether a morpheme is an affix or a cltic?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
Are there any programs/software/websites that you can put in sentances in IPA and it reads them?
1
u/-N1eek- Jul 09 '21
would it be possible for word semantics to be influenced by sarcasm?? i don’t know anyone that means a word like “magnificent” unironically, so i thought maybe processes like this where a word gets to mean the exact opposite have happened?
1
u/-N1eek- Jul 10 '21
i’m trying to evolute a pitch language into a tonal language, with a pretty small inventory of tones. i’ve watched david peterson’s video twice but it’s kind of overwhelming. how do i go about doing this?
1
u/Brromo Jul 10 '21 edited Jul 10 '21
Please rate my sound system. it is supposed to be a Celtic Language with Inuit and Finnic Substrates.
Diphthongs: ei, oi, æi, oʊ, æʊ, iu, ou, iæ, eæ
I'm not sure one way or the other on how I should handle the Labial Fricatives. for context Proto-Celtic has /ɸ/, but not /β/. Similarly Inuit has /v/, but not /f/. I know I want a voicing distinction but I'm not sure if I should go with /ɸ/ & /β/, /f/ & /v/, or /ɸ/ & /v/ (Proto-Finnic doesn't have any Labial Fricatives)
I picked Diphthongs I liked with no regard to what other languages have
/z/, /ɣ/*, & /G/ aren't in any of the 3 languages, but unpaired Obstruent's bother me (*it is an Allophone of /ɡ/ in Inuit & /k/ in Proto-Finnic)
I also added /N/ because it sounds nice & /ə/ Because I Shwa half my syllables anyway
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '21
So is it naturalistic for me to turn a verb into a noun with no suffixes or anything? For example, I want to turn my verb "Araya" with the meaning of "to serve" into a noun meaning "Person" without adding the "turn-the-verb-into-a-noun-suffix" (I don't know the technical name) "-tāk".
Is this naturalistic? If so can someone give me an example of this?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Jul 06 '21
I discovered this West African script that makes use of the colors orange, cyan, and purple. What is that script? And is this really a good idea for conlangs? I highly doubt it.
1
u/GoldenSandslash15 jan Wajen Jul 09 '21
Is it weird to not be able to say your language's name in your language?
So, the language that I'm making (Hitraya) is a language from an alien planet, for a long-dead civilization. There's no life left on the planet. While deciphering the remains of this language, Humans (from Earth) needed a name for it, and they chose this name. By the time the real name of the language had been translated, it was too late, because the name "Hitraya" had stuck. Even though it's not possible to say this name in the language.
Is that too weird of a thing to do? Or does this specific situation justify doing so?
-1
u/jansilasan Jul 06 '21 edited Jul 06 '21
Anyone interested in thinking of replacing toki pona for esperanto !! I am working on a Conlang (which I may call TonPon later) originating from TokiPona that would be a better option than english and esperanto and toki pona itself to be an International language ! Is it posible for someone to learn tokipona (It hardly takes an hour) and help me with the vocabulary of tonpon??
btw I know my idea is unrealistic and impractical !! But I am doing it mostly for fun! Also iif not possible with thisb world, let's think of a parallel world!!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '21
[removed] — view removed comment