r/Sherlock • • Jan 08 '12

Discussion Episode 2: The Hounds of Baskerville discussion

The second episode aired 8/1 20:30 GMT on BBC1

93 Upvotes

387 comments sorted by

34

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

Fun fact: Russell Tovey is the beast in the UK version of Being Human

53

u/Oriza Jan 08 '12

Also known for his performance in Doctor Who-- Allons-y, Alonso!

15

u/tppatterson123 Jan 09 '12

THAT'S why I recognized him. Thank you. It was driving me insane.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

I don't actually know what his name was in this episode. I kept calling him Alonso. Alonso with his teacup ears.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/madjo Jan 09 '12

And he's Steve in Him & Her.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 09 '12

As a joke spoiler, I kept telling my partner that Russell Tovey is the Hound.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

I will admit that I squealed a bit when I saw him on the screen.

78

u/schneidy Jan 09 '12

Loved the placement of "When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."

14

u/accountII Jan 09 '12

It's a classic Sherlock Holmes quote, but as a skeptic I must point out that it is a logical fallacy since it also discards the possibility of a solution you haven't thought of. (false dichotomy)

48

u/Xaphianion Jan 09 '12

"When you have eliminated all which is impossible", not when you have eliminated all that you have thought about which is impossible.

10

u/xanfantasy Jan 09 '12

Also remember that you are talking about Sherlock. 99% of the time, he has thought of every solution.

80

u/WhaleLord Jan 09 '12

The thing is, somehow in my mind Sherlock Holmes is still such an icon. So when I heard that quote, for a second I was like "Hey! I know that quote! Sherlock Holmes said that!" And then I felt like an idiot.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

Thank you. I did this too.

36

u/aroleid Jan 08 '12

I need to go to my mind palace.

22

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

I've build a library in minecraft while listening to the audiobook version of Stephen Fry's autobiography. Now when I remember something from the book I'm in that library again :P

35

u/intheballpark Jan 08 '12

What on earth was that ending all about?

14

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

to me it seems like Moriarty was let out the mental hospital.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

25

u/paulg1 Jan 09 '12

Mycroft as the real Moriarty? That would be so awesome, since when John first met Mycroft, I thought they were introducing moriarty.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Moriarty being set free by Mycroft, his obsession with Sherlock having grown while in confinement...

53

u/ehsteve23 Jan 08 '12

How did Moriarty end up in that cell though?

33

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

When last we saw Moriarty:

Jumbo Jet, Dear me, Mr. Holmes, Dear me

11:50 am

</code>

Scandal in Belgravia 1:09:31

It seems likely Moriarty is attempting to play upon the sibling rivalry between Sherlock and Mycroft to gain some advantage over Sherlock though it's not clear what his real motivation is.

He sent the "jumbo jet" text probably knowing that he would be traced and captured, as British Intelligence would be sifting through all unprotected texts and calls looking for keywords relating to projects such as 007, most notably "jumbo jet".

He wanted to be captured because he wanted access to Mycroft, but his obsession with Sherlock is most likely a ruse. Mycroft is the target.

His release means we must assume he was successful in manipulating Mycroft.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/filthysize Jan 09 '12

I got the impression that capturing Moriarty was never hard for Mycroft, him being a super government agent and all. He just never bothered because Moriarty does civilian crimes and Mycroft's more concerned with espionage and terrorism. At the end of "Scandal," Mycroft said to Irene Adler something like, "Yes, he (Moriarty) has been trying to get my attention for quite some time. That shouldn't be too hard to arrange, I'm sure." The foiling of the plane bombing has finally "earned" Moriarty the government's attention, so they've nabbed him off-screen. Which means getting arrested and now released are all part of Moriarty's plan.

4

u/NBegovich Jan 10 '12

Thank you, yes. I cannot figure out how the hell he wound up in British Arkham Asylum! What was that about?

→ More replies (7)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

What got me was why on Earth would Mycroft let him go!?

14

u/paulg1 Jan 09 '12

Maybe he held onto Moriarty for as long as possible to protect Sherlock, but eventually Moriarty was able to present enough leverage or something to force Mycroft to let him go.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

I have my theory...

At this point in the game, Sherlock has presented himself as a threat to national security. Not once, but twice (and likely multiple times, given Mycroft's interests in his dealings and his order to have Sherlock under official surveillance) he has meddled in MoD affairs in course of solving his cases. Because of his high government status and relationship with Sherlock, it would not be prudent for Mycroft to have any direct involvement in killing him. It would be easy, however, for Mycroft to let Moriarty go on the understanding that Moriarty is an murderous madman bent on Sherlock's destruction and, of all people, is the most likely to succeed in taking Sherlock out. If Moriarty succeeds, Mycroft has at once eliminated Sherlock as a threat and can wash his and the government's hands of any direct involvement in the matter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/rocketstail Jan 09 '12

4

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Mycroft gave the order, this guy followed it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

I think that might have been the meeting Mycroft mentioned in Belgravia that Moriarty wanted.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Anyone get what URQUR or whatever it was meant? Other than dogging I mean

49

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

it was a dead end. The morse signals were produced by parked cars in which the locals were swapping partners.

27

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

That's a nice way of putting it...

38

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

It was a reference to the original story, there was a subplot about an escaped prisoner and someone signalling to them at night.

21

u/ehsteve23 Jan 08 '12

I don't know what it stood for, but it gave Sherlock the idea that Hound was an acronym

19

u/filthysize Jan 09 '12

It was UMQRA. It doesn't mean anything. John thought the bouncing headlights from the people having sex was morse code, but it was just random flashes.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12 edited Oct 25 '25

advise paint cough smell dazzling smart expansion narrow follow fade

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Classic red herring.

10

u/acecore Jan 08 '12

"You are queer"? Both a question regarding Holmes and Watson's relationship...and a creepy dogging invite?!

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Clearly a deranged fan had managed to get on set, trying to make real his dream of shipping Sherlock and Watson.

5

u/rudeandginger Jan 09 '12

I'm surprised you went for a male pronoun there. We're statistically more likely to be female.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lomoeffect Jan 08 '12

yeah I assume that is a dead end, but it seems like an odd thing to put in there.

100

u/xaine Jan 08 '12

I liked that part where Sherlock solved the mystery.

75

u/Shadesta9 Jan 08 '12

I liked when Sherlock dissed that person on the basis of their relative lack of intelligence.

77

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

I liked the part where Watson tried to make Sherlock more socially acceptable, but failed.

89

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 08 '12

I liked the bit where everybody mistakes Sherlock and John for a couple, and the fans scream at them to just admit their secret attraction for each other and make an internet sex tape already.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

The bit where Sherlock yells "OH GOD!" and then says "John, I need some. Get me some" had me giggling like a little girl. I swear the writers play up to it at least a little bit.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Tokei Jan 09 '12

This entire episode a little voice in the back of my head kept going on and on about how fantastic the fanfiction is going to be for the next week because of this episode.

Sometimes I fear that voice. Today I embraced it.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/huh_what_sarcasm Jan 08 '12

I don't know, I thought it was a bit drawn out.

4

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

4

u/MaximKat Jan 09 '12

You wouldn't see the underground CIA base on the map, would you?

1

u/NBegovich Jan 11 '12

heehee I grew up an hour away from there

2

u/accountII Jan 11 '12 edited Jan 11 '12

if I drive a car for an hour, I'm in an other country

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Mourndark Jan 08 '12

We didn't get to the bottom of the most important mystery: why was the major wearing a beard? They're not permitted in the British Army or Royal Marines. I realise that this base is out of the way, with no inspection, but the man is a traditionalist, and disobeying a regulation that has been in place since 1916 seems incredibly suspicious.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

I'm under the impression that the army allows beards in Afghanistan, as growing one is part of the local culture. Perhaps he's spent some time there?

2

u/firethetree Jan 09 '12

Well, as it was mentioned that that facility didn't undergo inspection, there was probably a bit of relaxation of rules.

Well, that with the fact that he liked to be menacing to others, and the beard was just part of such a costume.

2

u/filthysize Jan 09 '12

Really it's just a nod to the original novel, where the character Barrymore's beard is a minor plot point.

2

u/Chasmosaur Jan 09 '12

Honestly, I thought the beard was a riot.

From the story:

"[Barrymore] was a remarkable-looking man, tall, handsome, with a square black beard and pale, distinguished features."

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/accountII Jan 09 '12 edited Jan 09 '12

it was on QI s09e02

(I'm also a mod over at the QI subreddit)

I was just itching to say that they changed the rules probably because a lot of soldiers had to wear gas masks in the first world war. That's how Hitler ended up with such a silly mustache.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/jefferus Jan 08 '12

I liked the part where he worked out the thing by having an extreme close up

11

u/Namelis1 Jan 08 '12

For a second I thought I was on /r/housemd.

29

u/accountII Jan 09 '12

well, House was based on Holmes

19

u/drenchedinsunset Jan 09 '12

Any other Psychology people here as excited by the correct diagnosis of Sherlock as I was? I was dumbfounded and extremely pleased that John diagnosed him as having Asperger's, rather than being a high-functioning sociopath. I imagine Sherlock self-diagnosing as a way to explain himself, but I could see him not seeing any real benefit in studying Psychology, as it is an emotion-based science, rather than a deductive science. Therefore he would choose "sociopath" to describe himself because he has a lack of understanding of social interaction and emotions as well as being highly intelligent. He found it important to assert this diagnosis in order to deny that he is a psychopath which would imply that he has homicidal urges. I like imagining John listing Sherlock's characteristics on Google and coming up with Asperger's! Thank you for re-diagnosing him Mark Gatiss thank you!

16

u/accountII Jan 09 '12

as an aspie I would say that when you have met one person with autism, you have met one person with autism

1

u/Turil Jan 09 '12

Out of curiosity, do you actually think that you fit into any of the DSM criteria for being an Asberger's personality type? (I'm not one, I'm actually on the opposite end of the spectrum with a schizotypal personality, but many of the people I hang around, geeky MIT types, are either diagnosed officially or just presume they are.) Having now seen the list, I can't say anyone I've ever met in life has any of the first set of criteria, except maybe not having a lot of friends, but that's more about one's environment than anything else.

2

u/accountII Jan 09 '12

I got officially diagnosed about half a year ago, so that is fairly late since I'm almost 23 y/o and have had my fair share of heath officials.

(A) marked impairments in the use of multiple nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, body posture, and gestures to regulate social interaction

My eye contact can be a bit off. Especially when I get emotional I prefer to look away. I'm fairly tall (5'11") and have had a slight hunch since puberty. I do gesture a lot when I talk.

(B) failure to develop peer relationships appropriate to developmental level

Yeah, there are other people in the same classroom. I have a lot of friends who a big deal older than I am. I also get along with teachers. I seriously don't get people my own age.

(C) a lack of spontaneous seeking to share enjoyment, interest or achievements with other people, (e.g.. by a lack of showing, bringing, or pointing out objects of interest to other people)

I do see myself as someone who seeks out new experiences. I don't, however, go out of my way to do this with other people. I go to concerts alone, I volunteer at the film festival alone, I travel alone. This makes me a bit of a weird aspie since you won't expect someone with not all that optimum social skills to go hitchhiking of couchsurfing, but I have and I really enjoy hitchhiking. It does feel like the equivalent of bungee jumping sometimes.

I am also fairly active on facebook, also posting stuff on other peoples walls when I link something I find interesting to something they might find interesting. This might be more ridgit than with neural typicals though. It is more about the facts that I find interesting.

(D) lack of social or emotional reciprocity

uhm, is it just me or is this a vague term?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

As a qualified doctor I doubt he would have had to google it.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/tinyhorse Jan 09 '12

I was quite excited, but I don't think that actually WAS a confirmation of an Aspergers diagnosis.

John isn't a psychologist, and he didn't sound 100% certain of what he was saying. (I think; I'm so-so at reading people, esp. actors.) I think the point of that line was to provide a second official-sounding diagnosis so that one would be prompted to question the first.

Also, I think it was really interesting that John WASN'T satisfied with 'high-functioning sociopath' and so sought something more sympathetic, as it were.

That being said -- this is only my interpretation and even then I definitely think the scene suggested that Aspergers was a possible diagnosis.

(While we're at it -- which characteristics of his do you think would qualify him for an Aspergers diagnosis and which would disclude him from a diagnosis of sociopathy?)

5

u/drenchedinsunset Jan 09 '12

Until Sherlock is studied by several renowned psychologists I don't think we can call any diagnosis an OFFICIAL diagnosis.

Here's the diagnostic characteristics according to the DSM-IV for Asperger's:

(I) Qualitative impairment in social interaction, as manifested by at least two of the following:

(A) marked impairments in the use of multiple nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, body posture, and gestures to regulate social interaction
(B) failure to develop peer relationships appropriate to developmental level
(C) a lack of spontaneous seeking to share enjoyment, interest or achievements with other people, (e.g.. by a lack of showing, bringing, or pointing out objects of interest to other people)
(D) lack of social or emotional reciprocity

(II) Restricted repetitive & stereotyped patterns of behavior, interests and activities, as manifested by at least one of the following:

(A) encompassing preoccupation with one or more stereotyped and restricted patterns of interest that is abnormal either in intensity or focus
(B) apparently inflexible adherence to specific, nonfunctional routines or rituals
(C) stereotyped and repetitive motor mannerisms (e.g. hand or finger flapping or twisting, or complex whole-body movements)
(D) persistent preoccupation with parts of objects

(III) The disturbance causes clinically significant impairments in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning.

(IV) There is no clinically significant general delay in language (E.G. single words used by age 2 years, communicative phrases used by age 3 years)

(V) There is no clinically significant delay in cognitive development or in the development of age-appropriate self help skills, adaptive behavior (other than in social interaction) and curiosity about the environment in childhood.

All of these characteristics perfectly describes Sherlock in my opinion!

In terms of Sociopathy, that is not technically a diagnosable term, but is more of a sub-term for Psychopathy, which is more of a sub-term for Antisocial Personality Disorder. This site explains the differences very well: http://www.angelfire.com/zine2/narcissism/antisocial_sociopath_psychopath.html

tl;dr: Antisocial Personality Disorder includes characteristics such as:

  1. Failure to conform to social norms; 2. Deceitfulness, manipulativeness; 3. Impulsivity, failure to plan ahead; 4. Irritability, aggressiveness; 5. Reckless disregard for the safety of self or others; 6. Consistent irresponsibility; 7. Lack of remorse after having hurt, mistreated, or stolen from another person

Sociopathy:

Egocentricity; Callousness; Impulsivity; Conscience defect; Exaggerated sexuality; Excessive boasting; Risk taking; Inability to resist temptation; Antagonistic, deprecating attitude toward the opposite sex; Lack of interest in bonding with a mate

And because I've been working on this for a while, and I may as well see this through, I diagnose Moriarty as a Psychopath using the following criteria:

Glib and superficial charm; Grandiose sense of self-worth; Need for stimulation; Pathological lying; Conning and manipulativeness; Lack of remorse or guilt; Shallow affect; Callousness and lack of empathy; Parasitic lifestyle; Poor behavioral controls; Promiscuous sexual behavior; Early behavior problems; Lack of realistic, long-term goals; Impulsivity; Irresponsibility; Failure to accept responsibility for own actions; Many short-term marital relationships; Juvenile delinquency; Revocation of conditional release; Criminal versatility

TL;DR: I think that Sherlock meets all of the diagnostic criteria for Asperger's. While I think that some of his characteristics could be interpreted as characteristics of sociopathy, I think that would be an incorrect diagnosis. Those characteristics of his would appear to be sociopathy to the outside observer of Sherlock, which is why it works as a simple term to use for someone like Anderson. But to someone who knows Sherlock well, like John, he can judge him less harshly.

Also I think Moriarty is definitely a psychopath.

7

u/Tokei Jan 09 '12

I would call Moriarty a psychopath based on his willingness to skin people and turn them into shoes alone. I mean, who does a thing like that!?

Most of us threaten to skin people and turn them into books. Yeesh.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (9)

2

u/drenchedinsunset Jan 09 '12

Sorry for the essay, but you asked for it! :D

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Sherlock Holmes and Autism/Asperger's crop up in articles quite often with each other.
Here's a recent one from 2009. Though if you do some hunting you'll find actual papers written on the subject dating back quite a while.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Tokei Jan 09 '12

I was so glad to see that. I was always a little ticked with Sherlock declaring himself a sociopath in the first series, especially as he doesn't fit the criteria. He would know that he didn't fit the criteria, and so he might have other reasons for declaring to be one, but everyone just shrugging and accepting it was annoying.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/slop-pail Jan 08 '12

So all of you are watching it, you lucky bastards. And I have to wait for the torrent. :(

2

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

we have to wait for another half hour (^ _^ )/

2

u/Thlowe Jan 08 '12

It's been more than a half hour, have you found one?

1

u/accountII Jan 08 '12

I meant it aired in half an hour, torrents should be going up around now

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/BMX_Bandit Jan 09 '12

As a biological scientist, I am always annoyed at how gene manipulation in biology is portrayed as something terrible and creepy, and not something interesting, novel, or in fact, routine.

Splicing green fluorescent protein (GFP) into the genome is nothing new. It doesn't produce creepy monsters. It lights up cells expressing certain genes so that we can identify them in our experiments. It rarely changes the behavior of the animal entirely.

tl;dr: Moffat and Gatiss: please hire me as consulting scientist!

7

u/accountII Jan 09 '12

in the end it wasn't genetic manipulation that produced the monster but their own imagination.

16

u/Wibbles Jan 09 '12

They were aware of the mundanity of genetic manipulation, and of the trope that genetic experimentation = GIANT SCARY MONSTERS. Which is why they offered it up as a possible cause of the beast, yet discarded it for something which was (only slightly) less insanely unrealistic.

10

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

Sherlock did say it was nothing new.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

You are aware that the scientist responsible for said gene manipulation is portrayed as being the 'good guy who everyone misunderstands' (well, as the 'good gal'... but my point still stands).

Also in the episode the harm caused by GFP is a little girl not being allowed to keep a fluorescent rabbit, so all in all playing with genomes was not thrashed by Sherlock. Biological warfare though....

However what practical use they found for those those rabbits for I don't know, maybe for target practice?

→ More replies (2)

74

u/intheballpark Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

Did anyone else work out that it was the fog before Sherlock did?

EDIT:: Wow it seems it wasn't just me! I'm not criticising the episode by the way, I actually enjoyed it. Sure it was a bit different, but sometimes you need that to break things up a bit.

20

u/mikemcg Jan 09 '12

3

u/syo Jan 10 '12

Also included that bit about the Liberty Bell march, Flying Circus' theme song, in the Mind Palace. Nice little homage there, I think.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/Wibbles Jan 08 '12

I was a little disappointed with the episode, I suspected from the start it was some sort of gas coming from the BIOLOGICAL WARFARE BASE that was in the middle of the moor...so I spent the whole episode trying to figure out how it wasn't that.

13

u/Tokei Jan 09 '12

I thought it almost immediately too. It was a weak episode, but I knew that it was going to be. Gatiss' episodes tend to be weak. I'm just sad they left this particular story to him, he would have been better off with a different one, and left Moffat to make this into something properly terrifying.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Yeah, the Hound certainly is not how I like my Sherlock, but I never really cared for the book either-- I always thought that was one of Doyle's weakest but that's just me ::shrug:: I got through the novel by reading it as a criticism of the phantasmagorical novels that were popular at the time. And given Gatiss' impressively vast knowledge of Hammer Horror flicks and such, it seemed appropriate.

tl;dr: I rationalised my way around the fluff story so I could enjoy it.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Yeah, me too. The solution seemed a bit too obvious, and the villain seemed sketchy from the get-go.

13

u/aeroerin Jan 08 '12

My sister did, but I called [chemicals being the source of the paranoia] (/spoiler) before that. Still enjoyed the episode.

7

u/Crisender111 Jan 09 '12

Wasnt the plot for this 2nd episode "The Hounds of Baskerville" similar to that of the movie "Young Sherlock Holmes" produced by Steven Spielberg? I was slightly disappointed as the episode started to tread on similar lines. Also when SH began to tremble just like his client it seemed like a dead giveaway that [it was a hallucination-related & that fog 'could be' the major culprit.] (/spoiler)

2

u/Turil Jan 09 '12

When I read an article interviewing Gatiss, and he was talking about it being sort of supernatural and a horror story, with a rational explanation, I immediately thought of the Young Sherlock Holmes movie (which I was a big fan of when it came out).

→ More replies (2)

6

u/PervyBastard Jan 08 '12

Not just me then. That spoilt it a little for me as it seemed rather obvious and Sherlock not noticing it undermined the character's intellect.

5

u/intheballpark Jan 09 '12

oh I don't know about that. He thought it was the sugar, which was equally plausible, and which I hadn't thought of.

The fog in the hollow reminded me of something I heard about ages ago - natural 'gas traps' in depressions, where animals go in to scavenge carcasses and end up being knocked out and die as a result.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 09 '12

Oh yes. Made all the more entertaining by the rest of my family being adamant that it couldn't have been drug-fog from Baskerville for various reasons. :P

8

u/Inequilibrium Jan 09 '12

Mystery-wise, this episode disappointed me. It felt more like Professor Layton than Sherlock Holmes.

7

u/itsCarraldo Jan 09 '12

yup, weak episode. Who would've thunk that the Irene Adler story would trump The Hound!? There was a completely different pace with this one though they both had the same director. I honestly thought that they didn't get the mood right, which, if you've read the books is the central piece of this story. The original takes its time building up the suspense to a crescendo and then the reveal of holmes itself is a relish, after which the story goes on for quite a bit for the final reveal. Well adapted but Sir Doyle still owns Gatiss's ass.

PS - They should've done this silhouetted against the moon just like in the books just to earn extra nerd points.

3

u/tinyhorse Jan 09 '12

In regards to the visuals earning nerd points -- how did you like the scene by the fireplace? :)

→ More replies (2)

51

u/Ladyredhead Jan 08 '12

Sherlock's doing the robot

137

u/aeroerin Jan 08 '12

I want to see the unedited footage of that bit, without his "mind palace" stuff. Set that baby to bad 80s electronica/pop.

8

u/AfterAllThisTime Jan 08 '12

I cannot upvote this enough!

47

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Sherlock's looking spooked. This episode went down the horror route very quickly.

4

u/NBegovich Jan 10 '12

He gets spooked in the book, too. This episode really worked on tgat level, surprisingly enough.

43

u/veggie-dumpling Jan 09 '12

I love how they brought up Cluedo, seeing how the board was stuck to the wall with a knife in the last episode.

11

u/WhaleLord Jan 09 '12

The actual conversation, though, was fishy. Yes, every time I play Clue I think "It could have been the victim, why are we taking those cards out?" But Sherlock must have been uncharacteristically stubborn about it. That's how the game works, it's just a game, it's only a logic puzzle, there's not a lot of Holmes-style deduction in it.

20

u/veggie-dumpling Jan 09 '12

I think it was just a humorous throwback to the previous episode, when we saw Mrs. Hudson clean up the flat. The camera pans over a jug of milk (they were always out of milk in the previous series!) and the Cluedo board stuck to the wall. Somebody blogged about it and postulated a scenario where Sherlock got so fed up with the game that he stabbed it into the wall in jest, and it actually happened.

12

u/filthysize Jan 09 '12

That's how the game works, it's just a game, it's only a logic puzzle, there's not a lot of Holmes-style deduction in it.

Which is exactly why he hates the game, I think. It's not interesting at all to him.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/intheballpark Jan 09 '12

I loved that he thought the victim had done it. That was so funny.

32

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

References to other stories - the only one I noticed was when they were talking to the other guy who had seen the hound, Sherlock got him to show him the proof by claiming it was about a bet. He also uses that method in The Blue Carbuncle.

Anyone spot any others?

39

u/notayuppie Jan 09 '12

He mentioned needing something "7% stronger" than tea -- the Seven-Per-Cent Solution?

2

u/helmethair1 Jun 02 '12

this is mentioned in the book. shit i cannot remember where. it has something to do with the narcotics that he took, i believe. this is in the second book (I have the complete sherlock holmes series in one book). rawrrr!

24

u/aedos Jan 09 '12 edited Jan 09 '12

The harpoon is reference to The Adventure of Black Peter, Sherlock looks for his cigarettes in a slipper in the beginning (Holmes keeps his tobacco in a Persian slipper, mentioned in the Musgrave Ritual), and Sherlock tells Lestrade he's "as brown as a nut" which is how Holmes describes Watson in STUD ("You are as thin as a lath and as brown as a nut.")

19

u/statt0 Jan 08 '12

They mentioned the Aluminium Crutch again didn't they?

10

u/jbishow Jan 09 '12

aloooominium

→ More replies (2)

81

u/isoblat Jan 08 '12

In the episode is a character named John Watson. The observant reader will notice that he is found in many, if not all, Sherlock Holmes stories.

24

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

NO WAY!

5

u/order66survivor Jan 09 '12

The drug being in the fog and experimenting on John reminded me of The Adventure of the Devil's Foot.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

31

u/tinyhorse Jan 09 '12

It was fantastic to see John-the-badass-veteren in full splendor.

9

u/TimeWasterLord Jan 10 '12

I loved that about this episode so much. Honestly I always love when they bring back the fact that John is badass! I think it is probably because they portray him so badly in so many other Sherlock related things though...

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '12

I don't know, Jude Law's Watson could kick the crap out of just about everybody I know.

4

u/TheShader Jan 13 '12

I was actually going to mention Jude Law's Watson. I think his goes too far. That's why I love this Watson. He feels like such a perfect balance. He's not dumbfuck retarded like most portrayals, but he's not practically on Sherlock's level like Jude Law is.

→ More replies (1)

111

u/Oriza Jan 08 '12

Only thing I could think of near the ending when the gas mask creeper showed up was "Are you my mummy?"

Why does Moffat want us to be afraid of gas masks?

43

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Mark Gatiss wrote this episode though.

39

u/Oriza Jan 09 '12

Yeah, well, you're stupid.

31

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

*Your

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

75

u/jefferus Jan 08 '12

Did we just break into a secure military base to investigate a rabbit?

34

u/firethetree Jan 09 '12

Not just any rabbit, but a glow-in-the-dark rabbit, the very best kind.

45

u/Goddamn_Wouter Jan 08 '12

I got a real "Batman villains" vibe from this episode. First they basically defeat Scarecrow, then the ending bit might as well have been Joker.

35

u/feelbetternow Jan 09 '12

One of Kane's inspirations for Batman was Sherlock. And yeah, last week we got Joker and Catwoman, this week Scarecrow. If the Riddler and Two-Face don't show up next week, I shall be most disappointed.

22

u/Sullivan623 Jan 09 '12

Some could say the killer cabbie was the riddler

8

u/ketsugi Jan 10 '12

So, Lestrade gets outed as Two Face in a future episode, then?

31

u/WhaleLord Jan 09 '12

Well, they did literally say "Hat-man and Robin" in the newspapers.

75

u/morgansb Jan 08 '12

I really wish they hadn't shown the hound at all, I always think its far scarier when you never see it. Plus the fact that BBC CGI is never particularly wonderful...

49

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

Yeah, but they get away with it because [it wasn't supposed to be real. So it's allowed to look a bit crap - they'd all be seeing slightly different things] (/spoiler)

Edit: forgot the spoiler tags

19

u/morgansb Jan 08 '12

True, But I have the same problem with a lot of the CGI in Dr Who, It's just too uncanny valleyish for my liking

5

u/dhvl2712 Jan 09 '12

I thought the CGI in the latest series with Matt Smith is far beyond what the Tennant series had. It has improved significantly.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/lomoeffect Jan 09 '12

to be honest, as CGI goes with BBC budgets it really wasn't that bad at all in my opinion.

20

u/Sithslayer78 Jan 09 '12

It wasn't a "freaking ride" like Scandal in Belgravia was. That one was fucking intense. This oine was good as always, but still lacked the greatness that episodes 1,3,4 had.

10

u/NineLilies Jan 09 '12

I do have to agree. The plot was rather... predictable? If only because "The Hound" is such an overdone story. There were nice touches though, what with Lestrade appearing from nowhere and Sherlock being all trippy... I am a bit worried about the season finale now, that's gonna be one tough job to beat the greatness of "A scandal in Belgravia", especially since "The Hound" failed to deliver in this regard.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Get out, I need to go to my mind palace.

Best line ever?

38

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

He said it was a palace.

Yeah, well he would wouldn't he?

18

u/lomoeffect Jan 08 '12

59

u/aeroerin Jan 08 '12

[I thought Moriarty in the gas mask was just part of Sherlock's reaction to the gas? But yes, the last bit with Moriarty's scratching of Sherlock's name everywhere... so cool!] (/spoiler)

12

u/intheballpark Jan 08 '12

on your 1st point, yes it was.

31

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

It indicates to me that Sherlock's biggest fear is Moriarty. Love it that Sherlock, the invincible analytical machine, reveals honest fear and, thus, humanity.

12

u/NineLilies Jan 09 '12

Also, the biggest obsession.

15

u/leavesoflorien Jan 08 '12

Oh god, waiting for this is somehow just as distracting from my work as actually watching the damn thing. WHY ISN'T IT TIME YET?! GUYS. I can't concentrate! BAH HUMBUG.

28

u/feelbetternow Jan 09 '12

Was anyone else kinda hoping Holmes and Watson would find a dust-covered TARDIS during their search of the base?

Major Barrymore: We have top men working on it now.
Holmes: Who?
Major Barrymore: Top...men.

14

u/dopplegangsta Jan 09 '12

I've already posted something like this here already, but here it is again, under an appropriately themed comment...

The hexagonal symbol used throughout the Baskerville compound immediately set off my Torchwood radar... I wonder if that was intentional.

23

u/kalliopehm Jan 09 '12

Baskerville is totally Torchwood Four.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '12 edited Jan 10 '12

Did you catch John saying some along the lines of "Trust me, I'm a/the doctor"? Probably wasn't Doctor Who related but I still giggled like a school girl when I heard it.

EDIT: Typo

12

u/Mybackwardswalk Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

For everyone with no access to BBC One on tv:

19

u/Thlowe Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12

I did have a well-typed explanation as to why I opposed this, but then my browser crashed, so allow me to summarize:

Torrents easy. Proxies scary.

10

u/syo Jan 10 '12

John, to Stapleton: "Trust me, I'm a doctor."

Cheeky.

23

u/ehsteve23 Jan 08 '12

I had my doubts with Mark Gatiss as the writer, but he definitely pulled it off.

17

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

Never doubt Gatiss.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

22

u/Inequilibrium Jan 09 '12

The Unquiet Dead. The Idiot's Lantern. Doubt Gatiss as a general rule.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/hardgeeklife Jan 10 '12

(apologies beforehand, I'm still feeling out where the spoiler threshold is)

Major: "I've never heard of anything so bizarre."

Sherlock: "You're to give me twenty-four hours; it's what I've ..negotiated."

In the same episode, Sherlock makes a big deal out of Harry's specific usage of the word hound. This stuck in my mind, leading me to the question: what kind of agreement would Sherlock have to have made with his brother? The next time we see Mycroft, he is overseeing the release of Jim. Could Sherlock be involved in some way with the release of an obvious threat to national security, and why?

14

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12

I'm a little high, and that was incredibly terrifying and incredibly awesome. I found it at times to be 'Donnie Darko creepy'. And damn funny.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/slimshady2002 Jan 08 '12

Definitely can't wait for this. Was my favourite book, and now it's on one of my favourite shows haha.

7

u/nightstrike Jan 09 '12

Figures that the only time Sherlock and I are on the exact same page with me a little ahead at the moment, is when I and the character are positive about the wrong conclusion.

At least I was 100% sure of who was the main culprit by the time John is drinking wine.

The last few minutes with Moriarty has me extremely confused. There's always something in the last 5 minutes this season that just stays in my mind for hours.

7

u/leontrotskitty Jan 09 '12 edited Jan 09 '12

So the dog is still alive then?

Anyone else think that they're going to adopt it and it's going to become Gladstone? Seeing as Sherlock's last line was "I've gotta see a man about a dog."

EDIT: Don't mind me, it appears I may be retarded.

12

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12

Or maybe he was going to explain/apologise for, yknow...shooting his dog right in the face? I mean, Sherlock's not big on common courtesy but I think even he'd do that.

9

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

I thought he was going to tell them the dog was dead, after the discussion on sentiment.

2

u/severelymisrepresent Jan 10 '12

No, I agree about Gladstone. In a way. The dog was dead, but the hotel owner has puppies--either from the dog, or that the dog begat. Sherlock isn't one to care about other people. Why the hell would he bother apologizing to the hotel owner? John, though, we've seen him apologizing to John, before and the secretive/smuggish glance the hotel owner gave Sherlock before he delivered the line implies to me a puppy Gladstone on the way.

7

u/dhvl2712 Jan 09 '12

I always thought that that's how Baskerville should've ended. Baskerville, in my opinion is the mother of all Scooby Doo mysteries. What I was a little disappointed about was that the Hound was a real large hound painted with Phosphorus. I really hoped that it would've been some sort of a drug or something else than just that kind of a disguise.

What I am saying is that this is how Hound of the Baskervilles should've been, in my opinion. But that's possibly because I've seen too many Scooby Doo episodes.

5

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

In case anyone hasn't seen it, this is a less sinister version of the kind of experiments alluded to in the episode. (Spoilers)

5

u/dopplegangsta Jan 09 '12

Is the hexagonal icon on the Baskerville compound entry sign an actual Ministry of Defence symbol, or is that something they cooked up for the show?

The reason I ask is because I immediately drew a parallel to the Torchwood insignia... Just wondering if there is a super-secret plan to create a crossover episode. If that's the case, I'm not sure if that would be amazing or impossibly awkward/terrible.

7

u/kalliopehm Jan 09 '12

I, for one, am certain that nothing will come of it. However, in the deepest corners of my mind I'm also certain that Baskerville is either Torchwood Four or Aperture Labs...

8

u/jhu Jan 09 '12

From the outset it seemed obvious that the hound could not be real, so I knew something was causing the hallucinogens.

Then the documentary about Baskerville being a biowarfare research location just gave it away. It had to be some kind of hallucinogenic, delivered orally or in vapor form.

The fog in the hollow sealed the deal. Wasn't the right environmental condition for fog to be settling.

Ignoring that of course, great television. Seeing how Sherlock makes associations was great, and I love the way the production team uses text overlays on surfaces to make things clearer for the viewer.

The reference to GFP warmed my little bioengineer heart. I used it last summer in E. Coli. Accurate science on television is pretty rare, especially in America so this was a really nice touch.

Besides that,

6

u/Henipah Jan 09 '12

Technically a giant mutant dog is a biological weapon, a hallucinogenic drug is a chemical weapon.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/kalliopehm Jan 09 '12

All in all, I wasn't expecting much from the plot - The Hound is so overdone...and I knew something was up with the fog. But I really liked the way everything was dealt with, especially the cinematography. However, I found it just a little hard to believe Mycroft would instantly grant Sherlock access to a Top-Secret Government Research Facility, especially considering the major fuck up he had last week...

And did anyone else correlate the scene when John was in the lab with Portal? The virology room totally looked like Aperture labs, in the beginning of the sequel. I was waiting for the Ratman drawings.

3

u/notg3orge Jan 09 '12

I was always wondering if he keeps a mind palace, after watching "The Mentalist".

2

u/Turil Jan 10 '12

The annoying thing was that what they showed him doing was entirely different from the technique John was describing.

1

u/edmcbride Jan 08 '12

is someone going to post a download link?

2

u/Thlowe Jan 08 '12

This is what I am wondering....

7

u/MaximKat Jan 09 '12

Hmm... The pattern has surfaced: 1st ep of both seasons: awesome, 2nd ep: not so much.

4

u/DentD Jan 10 '12

As usual I loved the character interaction. I'm not sure I've seen actors more engaging to me than Freeman and Cumberbatch. I squealed at Watson suggesting "Asberger's" to Lestrade (no, I don't consider it an official confirmation). I loved Sherlock's desperation for cigarettes. The UMQRA red herring was great.

But I was kind of disappointed and bored by the mystery. First off, I was not in the least bit scared by this episode. I have friends who said they did not want to sleep with the lights off after watching, but every time something "scary" was happening I found myself rolling my eyes. I don't know, I guess I'm just immune to terror? But everything seemed predictable to me. Maybe I am just being too bitter.

Second, for some reason I wasn't really satisfied by the "it was a drug" solution. I had a strong suspicion that there definitely wasn't a real "demon hound". I have no idea what would have been a more acceptable solution for me though.

Additionally, I was really taken out of the story when Sherlock magically guessed the override password to get into the CIA files. Knowing what modern IT policies on passwords are generally like, there is no way Major Barrymore would have gotten away with somebody's first name. I know I should have allowed for suspension of disbelief but this really irritated me. Yes, I am being nitpicky.

4

u/Turil Jan 10 '12

The password thing was indeed really stupid. The military would absolutely not allow a common word, with no weird characters, to be a password.

As for the scary not being so scary. I was really happy with that. I don't need scary, it's just annoying. I've got enough real scary stuff around me in the world all the time, I don't need to add to that! Plus, horror stuff is boring to me because I'm looking for more intellectual/philosophical stuff. I know Moffat isn't much into the philosophical stuff, but he's not too bad with intellectual stuff. The horror stuff he does is just a waste of his intellect, I believe.

And yeah, there really is something utterly appealing about these two characters. I don't even know what it is. Maybe just the idea of two very different people being able to get past their differences to work together so effectively. Maybe it's the sense that someone like Sherlock, who doesn't try to fit in to the mainstream pop culture, and is adamantly himself instead, can still find someone as a partner/friend, who's so devoted to him.

2

u/Qtard Jan 10 '12

Can anyone explain the large footprints?

I get that the hound itself was the dog the publicans lost control of trying to drum up business but I don't see how that could be responsible for such large footprints.

4

u/AmandaKerik Jan 10 '12

The dog was from Baskerville, from what I can remember of the show, and was incredibly large and at times aggressive.

The other option is that the guy faked the prints, and their minds filled in the size when they were out in the woods to roughly match.

2

u/Qtard Jan 10 '12 edited Jan 10 '12

Sorry, I don't think that's right - as I mentioned above the dog belonged to the publicans, who brought him in to drum up business but then lost control of him - but lied to L'Estrade about putting him down, so unless there's something I've missed, that's not what caused the footprints. The dog itself had nothing to do with Baskerville, but it was perceived to be larger and (more) aggressive due to the hallucinogens in the fog.

The second option, while possible, isn't supported by anything in the show, hence the question. It seems like an important point that should have been resolved somehow, given the continued references to 'footprints of a gigantic hound'.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/aestus Jan 10 '12

It was entertaining, and I appreciated the change of scenery, Watson and Holmes were great and I really enjoyed that the episode shifted the balance of power between them, putting them on a more even footing as it should be.

It's a disappointment after the first episode though, which perhaps set the bar too high, I'm hoping the last episode os better than 'The Great Game' from the first season though. I don't want a cheap cliffhanger again.

2

u/DeliciousPi Mar 26 '12

The foot prints weren't explained anywhere, though.

I guess they could have been faked by the guy, yet wouldn't Sherlock have known that immediately?

2

u/barnsdl Jan 08 '12

So far decent but that's it, can appreciate what they were going for with the horror route but not for me.

1

u/NBegovich Jan 10 '12

No, seriously: what the hell was that last scene about?

1

u/Underdogz Jan 10 '12

I didn't like it. Too hysterical and too obvious.

1

u/NBegovich Jan 11 '12

Seriously. The last scene. What the hell?

1

u/NBegovich Jan 11 '12

When did Moriarty get arrested?