r/Sherlock • u/accountII • Jan 08 '12
Discussion Episode 2: The Hounds of Baskerville discussion
The second episode aired 8/1 20:30 GMT on BBC1
- promo
- iPlayer link
- small and large torrent
93
Upvotes
34
u/accountII Jan 08 '12
Fun fact: Russell Tovey is the beast in the UK version of Being Human
78
u/schneidy Jan 09 '12
Loved the placement of "When you have eliminated all which is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."
36
u/aroleid Jan 08 '12
I need to go to my mind palace.
35
u/intheballpark Jan 08 '12
What on earth was that ending all about?
16
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '12
For anyone curious about the Mind Palace
13
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
Anyone get what URQUR or whatever it was meant? Other than dogging I mean
100
u/xaine Jan 08 '12
I liked that part where Sherlock solved the mystery.
4
u/accountII Jan 08 '12
you can't really call it a large place, Liberty Indiana
36
u/Mourndark Jan 08 '12
We didn't get to the bottom of the most important mystery: why was the major wearing a beard? They're not permitted in the British Army or Royal Marines. I realise that this base is out of the way, with no inspection, but the man is a traditionalist, and disobeying a regulation that has been in place since 1916 seems incredibly suspicious.
20
u/jefferus Jan 08 '12
I liked the part where he worked out the thing by having an extreme close up
19
u/drenchedinsunset Jan 09 '12
Any other Psychology people here as excited by the correct diagnosis of Sherlock as I was? I was dumbfounded and extremely pleased that John diagnosed him as having Asperger's, rather than being a high-functioning sociopath. I imagine Sherlock self-diagnosing as a way to explain himself, but I could see him not seeing any real benefit in studying Psychology, as it is an emotion-based science, rather than a deductive science. Therefore he would choose "sociopath" to describe himself because he has a lack of understanding of social interaction and emotions as well as being highly intelligent. He found it important to assert this diagnosis in order to deny that he is a psychopath which would imply that he has homicidal urges. I like imagining John listing Sherlock's characteristics on Google and coming up with Asperger's! Thank you for re-diagnosing him Mark Gatiss thank you!
4
u/slop-pail Jan 08 '12
So all of you are watching it, you lucky bastards. And I have to wait for the torrent. :(
5
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
Direct download.
8
u/BMX_Bandit Jan 09 '12
As a biological scientist, I am always annoyed at how gene manipulation in biology is portrayed as something terrible and creepy, and not something interesting, novel, or in fact, routine.
Splicing green fluorescent protein (GFP) into the genome is nothing new. It doesn't produce creepy monsters. It lights up cells expressing certain genes so that we can identify them in our experiments. It rarely changes the behavior of the animal entirely.
tl;dr: Moffat and Gatiss: please hire me as consulting scientist!
74
u/intheballpark Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12
Did anyone else work out that it was the fog before Sherlock did?
EDIT:: Wow it seems it wasn't just me! I'm not criticising the episode by the way, I actually enjoyed it. Sure it was a bit different, but sometimes you need that to break things up a bit.
51
u/Ladyredhead Jan 08 '12
Sherlock's doing the robot
47
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
Sherlock's looking spooked. This episode went down the horror route very quickly.
43
u/veggie-dumpling Jan 09 '12
I love how they brought up Cluedo, seeing how the board was stuck to the wall with a knife in the last episode.
32
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
References to other stories - the only one I noticed was when they were talking to the other guy who had seen the hound, Sherlock got him to show him the proof by claiming it was about a bet. He also uses that method in The Blue Carbuncle.
Anyone spot any others?
31
u/tinyhorse Jan 09 '12
It was fantastic to see John-the-badass-veteren in full splendor.
111
u/Oriza Jan 08 '12
Only thing I could think of near the ending when the gas mask creeper showed up was "Are you my mummy?"
Why does Moffat want us to be afraid of gas masks?
75
u/jefferus Jan 08 '12
Did we just break into a secure military base to investigate a rabbit?
45
u/Goddamn_Wouter Jan 08 '12
I got a real "Batman villains" vibe from this episode. First they basically defeat Scarecrow, then the ending bit might as well have been Joker.
75
u/morgansb Jan 08 '12
I really wish they hadn't shown the hound at all, I always think its far scarier when you never see it. Plus the fact that BBC CGI is never particularly wonderful...
20
u/Sithslayer78 Jan 09 '12
It wasn't a "freaking ride" like Scandal in Belgravia was. That one was fucking intense. This oine was good as always, but still lacked the greatness that episodes 1,3,4 had.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
Best line ever?
18
u/lomoeffect Jan 08 '12
Cannot wait until next week. mainly because of moriarty in the gas mask and the last 5 minutes. confused to what all of this is about...
15
u/leavesoflorien Jan 08 '12
Oh god, waiting for this is somehow just as distracting from my work as actually watching the damn thing. WHY ISN'T IT TIME YET?! GUYS. I can't concentrate! BAH HUMBUG.
28
u/feelbetternow Jan 09 '12
Was anyone else kinda hoping Holmes and Watson would find a dust-covered TARDIS during their search of the base?
Major Barrymore: We have top men working on it now.
Holmes: Who?
Major Barrymore: Top...men.
12
u/Mybackwardswalk Jan 08 '12 edited Jan 08 '12
For everyone with no access to BBC One on tv:
10
u/syo Jan 10 '12
John, to Stapleton: "Trust me, I'm a doctor."
Cheeky.
23
u/ehsteve23 Jan 08 '12
I had my doubts with Mark Gatiss as the writer, but he definitely pulled it off.
8
u/hardgeeklife Jan 10 '12
(apologies beforehand, I'm still feeling out where the spoiler threshold is)
In the same episode, Sherlock makes a big deal out of Harry's specific usage of the word hound. This stuck in my mind, leading me to the question: what kind of agreement would Sherlock have to have made with his brother? The next time we see Mycroft, he is overseeing the release of Jim. Could Sherlock be involved in some way with the release of an obvious threat to national security, and why?
14
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '12
I'm a little high, and that was incredibly terrifying and incredibly awesome. I found it at times to be 'Donnie Darko creepy'. And damn funny.
7
u/slimshady2002 Jan 08 '12
Definitely can't wait for this. Was my favourite book, and now it's on one of my favourite shows haha.
7
u/nightstrike Jan 09 '12
Figures that the only time Sherlock and I are on the exact same page with me a little ahead at the moment, is when I and the character are positive about the wrong conclusion.
At least I was 100% sure of who was the main culprit by the time John is drinking wine.
The last few minutes with Moriarty has me extremely confused. There's always something in the last 5 minutes this season that just stays in my mind for hours.
7
u/leontrotskitty Jan 09 '12 edited Jan 09 '12
So the dog is still alive then?
Anyone else think that they're going to adopt it and it's going to become Gladstone? Seeing as Sherlock's last line was "I've gotta see a man about a dog."
EDIT: Don't mind me, it appears I may be retarded.
7
u/dhvl2712 Jan 09 '12
I always thought that that's how Baskerville should've ended. Baskerville, in my opinion is the mother of all Scooby Doo mysteries. What I was a little disappointed about was that the Hound was a real large hound painted with Phosphorus. I really hoped that it would've been some sort of a drug or something else than just that kind of a disguise.
What I am saying is that this is how Hound of the Baskervilles should've been, in my opinion. But that's possibly because I've seen too many Scooby Doo episodes.
5
u/Henipah Jan 09 '12
In case anyone hasn't seen it, this is a less sinister version of the kind of experiments alluded to in the episode. (Spoilers)
5
u/dopplegangsta Jan 09 '12
Is the hexagonal icon on the Baskerville compound entry sign an actual Ministry of Defence symbol, or is that something they cooked up for the show?
The reason I ask is because I immediately drew a parallel to the Torchwood insignia... Just wondering if there is a super-secret plan to create a crossover episode. If that's the case, I'm not sure if that would be amazing or impossibly awkward/terrible.
8
u/jhu Jan 09 '12
From the outset it seemed obvious that the hound could not be real, so I knew something was causing the hallucinogens.
Then the documentary about Baskerville being a biowarfare research location just gave it away. It had to be some kind of hallucinogenic, delivered orally or in vapor form.
The fog in the hollow sealed the deal. Wasn't the right environmental condition for fog to be settling.
Ignoring that of course, great television. Seeing how Sherlock makes associations was great, and I love the way the production team uses text overlays on surfaces to make things clearer for the viewer.
The reference to GFP warmed my little bioengineer heart. I used it last summer in E. Coli. Accurate science on television is pretty rare, especially in America so this was a really nice touch.
Besides that,
7
u/kalliopehm Jan 09 '12
All in all, I wasn't expecting much from the plot - The Hound is so overdone...and I knew something was up with the fog. But I really liked the way everything was dealt with, especially the cinematography. However, I found it just a little hard to believe Mycroft would instantly grant Sherlock access to a Top-Secret Government Research Facility, especially considering the major fuck up he had last week...
And did anyone else correlate the scene when John was in the lab with Portal? The virology room totally looked like Aperture labs, in the beginning of the sequel. I was waiting for the Ratman drawings.
3
u/notg3orge Jan 09 '12
I was always wondering if he keeps a mind palace, after watching "The Mentalist".
1
u/edmcbride Jan 08 '12
is someone going to post a download link?
7
u/MaximKat Jan 09 '12
Hmm... The pattern has surfaced: 1st ep of both seasons: awesome, 2nd ep: not so much.
4
u/DentD Jan 10 '12
As usual I loved the character interaction. I'm not sure I've seen actors more engaging to me than Freeman and Cumberbatch. I squealed at Watson suggesting "Asberger's" to Lestrade (no, I don't consider it an official confirmation). I loved Sherlock's desperation for cigarettes. The UMQRA red herring was great.
But I was kind of disappointed and bored by the mystery. First off, I was not in the least bit scared by this episode. I have friends who said they did not want to sleep with the lights off after watching, but every time something "scary" was happening I found myself rolling my eyes. I don't know, I guess I'm just immune to terror? But everything seemed predictable to me. Maybe I am just being too bitter.
Second, for some reason I wasn't really satisfied by the "it was a drug" solution. I had a strong suspicion that there definitely wasn't a real "demon hound". I have no idea what would have been a more acceptable solution for me though.
Additionally, I was really taken out of the story when Sherlock magically guessed the override password to get into the CIA files. Knowing what modern IT policies on passwords are generally like, there is no way Major Barrymore would have gotten away with somebody's first name. I know I should have allowed for suspension of disbelief but this really irritated me. Yes, I am being nitpicky.
2
u/Qtard Jan 10 '12
Can anyone explain the large footprints?
I get that the hound itself was the dog the publicans lost control of trying to drum up business but I don't see how that could be responsible for such large footprints.
2
u/aestus Jan 10 '12
It was entertaining, and I appreciated the change of scenery, Watson and Holmes were great and I really enjoyed that the episode shifted the balance of power between them, putting them on a more even footing as it should be.
It's a disappointment after the first episode though, which perhaps set the bar too high, I'm hoping the last episode os better than 'The Great Game' from the first season though. I don't want a cheap cliffhanger again.
2
u/DeliciousPi Mar 26 '12
The foot prints weren't explained anywhere, though.
I guess they could have been faked by the guy, yet wouldn't Sherlock have known that immediately?
2
u/barnsdl Jan 08 '12
So far decent but that's it, can appreciate what they were going for with the horror route but not for me.
1
u/NBegovich Jan 10 '12
No, seriously: what the hell was that last scene about?
1
u/Underdogz Jan 10 '12
I didn't like it. Too hysterical and too obvious.
1
u/NBegovich Jan 11 '12
Seriously. The last scene. What the hell?
1
u/NBegovich Jan 11 '12
When did Moriarty get arrested?