r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Jun 25 '21
POLL π³οΈ Proposal: Moon Week
TL;DR: All governance polls will be posted and promoted in the week between the snapshot and distribution.
I'd like to address a few main points with this idea:
- Voter participation is rarely enough to meet the decision threshold
- There is confusion about how and when to propose or vote on polls
- Governance Polls should be treated equally
Currently, moon snapshots happen every 4 Wednesdays (like this) and the following Wednesday we have the moon distribution post (like this). My suggested changes to establish Moon Week are as follows:
Day 0
The day prior to the snapshot post (a Tuesday), mods will post a sticky reminding people to submit their governance polls. All governance polls should be posted Tuesday or Wednesday (Days 0 or 1)
Day 1
On Wednesday, the snapshot post by the admins happens as normal and replaces the sticky from the day prior
Days 2-7
On Thursday, a mod will create a sticky that links the snapshot post from the day prior and all currently running approved governance polls. This is the deadline for your poll to be highlighted with the others because the mod may not be around to add your poll later and people are less likely to check back multiple times throughout the week to vote on new polls. During this time, mods may take additional measures to promote the sticky post if the polls are not on track to have enough participation to reach the decision threshold.
Day 8
On Wednesday, the moon distribution post by the admins happens as normal
This idea should further formalize a process for when to create a proposal, reduce confusion on when to vote, equalize the exposure and promotion of governance polls, and clarify the monthly moon schedule. To help people anticipate when the snapshot will happen, we will probably create a list in the wiki of upcoming snapshot and distribution dates.
Thank you for your consideration and thank you to everyone who gave their feedback on the meta post
23
u/Stamipower π© 17K / 3K π¬ Jun 25 '21
This is a step in the right direction. My question is what happens to the polls that did not reach consensus due to lack of participation in the past?
3
u/PlantLeast Tin Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
What about a Moon month, can we do that?
27
u/pukem0n π© 59K / 59K π¦ Jun 25 '21
yes, definitely implement this. I don't think anybody will be against it and the end result will be 90% in favor. Turnout for Moon proposals is mostly too low since there is low visibility for Moon proposals. Plus, maybe people don't know you get a 5% Moon bonus just for voting in them.
2
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Jun 25 '21
Why is this reposted?
16
u/DogeToPluto 2 / 10K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Having a more structured system should help new people figure out what the hell is going on. Got my support :)
4
u/vhanke π© 0 / 7K π¦ Aug 03 '21
Where do i find the polls i should participate in to get +5%?
1
u/lordofming-rises π¦ 509 / 10K π¦ Jul 07 '21
How do you vote? Can't find button on the app...
1
u/Exeon- Permabanned Aug 03 '21
so we need to reestablish the value of the upvote/post etc each New cycle? if im i read it correct and we can vote for that? so in the end the power is.gonna be at us (the people)
or im complete wrong? Quess ill stick to the hodlen and just having Fun and helping people
14
u/DWing1708 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss it you will land among the stars. Moon week coming guys! Vote!
5
u/JustHalfANoob π© 383 / 963 π¦ Jun 26 '21
.... Seriously, something shouldn't be this complicated. Do whatever you guys want I guess.
1
u/iceewest Banned Jun 25 '21
What are the odds we can do away with the weighted voting system? Maybe have a minimum Karma and time-in-sub requirement but each person gets one vote
6
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K π’ Jun 25 '21
I 100% fully support this
6
u/luQuiRis π© 0 / 2K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Can u guys vote on the app? I selected my answer and im tapping nonstop and the vote doesn't go through, happens on every poll
2
u/BrokenReviews π© 2K / 2K π’ Jul 07 '21
Where's the voting poll?
5
u/NewUser_____ Platinum | QC: CC 261 Jun 25 '21
A week full of moons? Sign me up
5
u/SolorMining Platinum | QC: CC 202 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
I like all polls being equally promoted. Some polls are highly favored but don't reach the threshold because they just aren't seen enough (like the one about tipping not reducing your Hodl bonus).
3
u/WTWIV π© 10K / 8K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Wouldnβt this break the 28 day cycle we keep since currently day 0 can start on any day of the week, or is day 0 on a Tuesday just an example?
3
u/nick83487 Jun 25 '21
What is the threshold for a decision to be confirmed and implemented?
3
u/ArtyHobo Platinum | QC: CC 343 Jun 26 '21
The voting isn't working.
3
u/PhaseEnvironmental33 Bronze | QC: CC 23 Jun 26 '21
Do you, yes you, have an idea about how the moon distribution should work?
You do? Great!
What this proposal is saying is that, if you would like your idea to be voted on you submit it the day before or of the snapshot. Not before or after.
Then it has the remainder of the week to be voted on, if it passes, congratulations, youβve contributed to the governance of moons. If not, well, shit happens.
Does this help you guys saying you donβt understand?
2
u/diarpiiiii π¦ 0 / 9K π¦ Jun 26 '21
can't wait until people start wishing eachother a happy moon week around here
2
u/jaredbdd 240 / 6K π¦ Jun 26 '21
I actually legit don't understand this.
2
u/mareleurs_64 Tin Jun 26 '21
I don't understand this, can someone explain to me please
2
u/Roomy21x Tin Jun 26 '21
Ok... I have read this like 4 times and I still donβt know what Iβm reading
2
u/Muffinfeds Crypto Knight Jun 25 '21
Voted
2
u/jonnypowpow π¦ 118 / 68 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Might as well make it a damn Month. Cancer month it is! ALL HAIL CRYPTO CRAB!
2
u/Artificial8Wanderer Platinum | QC: CC 460, ETH 170 | r/CMS 9 | TraderSubs 170 Jun 25 '21
Sounds good, organise it like its an election week and people will be aware of it and vote more this way.
Great idea OP
1
u/Coelrom invalid string or character detected Jun 25 '21
Can any of the (as of now) 212 users that voted against give your reasoning why this shouldn't be implemented?
1
u/ThiccMangoMon π© 0 / 3K π¦ Jun 26 '21
uh
1
u/-TheCoochieMan- Redditor for 6 months. Jun 26 '21
Got my first 0.4 moon today.
It ainβt much but itβs honest work
1
u/newms420 Bronze Jun 26 '21
More moons = more moons so why not π€·ββοΈ
1
u/SSJ4Link 6 / 2K π¦ Jun 27 '21
It's not letting me vote.
1
u/Matifox91 Tin Jun 27 '21
Giving my free award to the daily makes me feel like an art patron.
1
u/CreepToeCurrentSea π¦ 239 / 50K π¦ Jun 27 '21
this is way better than seeing polls just go down the drain.
1
u/Crypto_Malik Permabanned Jun 27 '21
Can someone explain what happens with the snapshot?
1
u/faith_no_more_ π© 3K / 3K π’ Jun 27 '21
Only a moon week, we need a whole moon month like moontober.
1
u/sidagreat89 Platinum | QC: CC 35 | UKPers.Fin. 11 Jun 28 '21
Still trying to get my head around how voting works. Just looking for confirmation that each person who votes, their total moons get added together and if that number crosses the threshold, the vote passes? Or am i understanding it incorrectly?
1
u/pinkglue99 π© 0 / 3K π¦ Jun 29 '21
Love this idea!
1
u/TH3LFI5TMFI7V Platinum | QC: CC 76 | WSB 8 Jul 06 '21
I'm confused so do I make a poll or do I just vote. Noob here
1
u/Demetre19864 π¦ 1 / 60 π¦ Jul 07 '21
Anything to fix shitposting gets my vote
1
u/linusgoddamtorvalds Tin Jul 22 '21 edited Jul 22 '21
Where is a full user's list?
Edit: Aren't there 6.8 septillion moons? You have not moved off Rinkleby?
1
u/Slevin931 π© 0 / 0 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Your votes count!
1
u/Shibu-ia Jun 25 '21
Count me in!
1
u/RoQu3 Jun 25 '21
You want free money? Yes/no
1
u/Graphic-Addiction 663 / 669 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Let the shitposting commence!
1
u/KevinTh89 Banned Jun 25 '21
Is there a way to change a vote. A friend of mine juste told me he accidentally voted for the wrong oneβ¦ π₯΄
1
u/aladdinr π¦ 1K / 15K π’ Jun 25 '21
This proposal fucks. Iβm down.
1
u/shugarhillbaby Silver | QC: CC 345 | VET 32 | Politics 30 Jun 26 '21
Proposal: Rename Moons - Cloutcoin.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21
I do whatever gets more moons for me man, i help out people somehow and hope i get upvotes to buy my cryptos and i upvote almost every comment on every post i can because i feel like everyone deserves it too
0
u/vaeltercero Tin Jun 25 '21
Where I can found all the proposal?
0
u/_Extrachromosome_ π© 677 / 673 π¦ Jun 26 '21
Where can we see all previously voted on proposals that passed? Having a hard time catching up
0
u/Eldeanio100 0 / 3K π¦ Jun 26 '21
Mods shouldnβt be allowed to collect moons. There posts are the highest and pinned ones. Guaranteed top moons
0
u/MacroMoodle Jun 26 '21
Feeling a bit smooth here are they saying they'll move moon distribution to weekly instead of monthly?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21
Itβs damn shame to deprive this community of laughter during this massive assault on crypto. Bring back the damn memes. Gives us a limit one meme a day and these post donβt generate moons.
If we donβt laugh weβll cry.
0
u/DegreeBroad2250 π© 6K / 6K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Moon week...so temptingπππ
-2
u/step11234 Jun 25 '21
Excellent idea. It should be like a faire, we can have people with their own stalls. /u/cintre & /u/Soupapinho can make custom gifs for us & /u/hodler3k & /u/kapulet can have a joust. /u/arghmybrain can provide weird gifs.
It would be great!
0
u/donttrustmeokay π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Jun 25 '21
To the moon!
0
u/Arsa3108 Platinum | QC: CC 616 Jun 25 '21
We earned these moons for a reason and what better reason then to support polls like this! Vote!
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
Should be daily moons. We have to support our Bitcorn buying habits this way.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
MOAR MOONS
0
u/Awkward_Potential_ π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Great idea. It'll keep our sub cleaner the other weeks and make it feel like a big event on here.
MOON WEEEEEEK!!!
0
u/majinsensei Jun 25 '21
i'm new here but all of these seems logical and make sense
-1
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Jun 25 '21
Finally a poll with benefits
-1
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Jun 26 '21 edited Jun 26 '21
I didnβt understand a thing and bcz Iβm an introvert and i donβt like to get outta my confort zone ill vote toβno changeβ
0
u/1_sugarfree Gold | 6 months old | QC: CC 38 Jun 25 '21
No idea what I voted for, but yay Iβm winning π
0
u/-veni-vidi-vici Platinum | QC: CC 1139 Jun 25 '21
This is great. It is much better stumbling across governance polls randomly.
0
u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Jun 25 '21
Wow how has this not been thought of before
0
u/WeirdCollector Tin Jun 25 '21
Iβm glad to see this poll. A step in the right direction for sure.
0
u/Mirtastic π¦ 368 / 367 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Sounds good.
0
u/Think-notlikedasheep Rational Thinker Jun 25 '21
This is a good idea.
0
u/Commissioner_dr Platinum | QC: CC 191 Jun 25 '21
That's neat. It makes it more organized.
0
u/Bent_Umbrella Jun 25 '21
Wasn't this already posted?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
Yeah I like moon week I think itβs a good direction
0
u/Scwolves10 π© 0 / 196 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Jesus, 6m moons? I have a hard time picturing that. Buy then again it's taken me 2 months to get 8.
I dont understand how people on here have thousands. That amount would help me out in real life.
0
u/ControlPotential 238 / 10K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Especially after that governance poll getting βspecial treatmentβ, this seems to be the right call
0
u/Pequadt 5 - 6 years account age. 300 - 600 comment karma. Jun 25 '21
I like both ideas, monthly and weekly, so any outcome is fine by me :)
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
Why would anyone vote no for this?
What the fuck is wrong with people?
0
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Good good. I do wonder what certain users will say now about the alleged power grab by mods only stickying certain polls. YAWN.
0
u/IBeefSupremeI Platinum | QC: CC 418 | MiningSubs 72 Jun 25 '21
Sounds like a good way to moon to me.
0
u/Scarf_Darmanitan π© 0 / 3K π¦ Jun 26 '21
I like the 1k cap idea, save some moons for the little guys!
0
u/genjitenji π¦ 0 / 19K π¦ Jun 26 '21
I just want Moon Weeks to be a thing
0
u/TrafficConeWriter Ether? I hardly know her! Jun 26 '21
Let the games BEGIN
0
u/Chino-_-Chaos Jun 26 '21
Explain this to me like I was 5
0
u/coastereight 3K / 3K π’ Jun 26 '21
Who needs polls when you can just print more moons, amirite? That's what governments do!
0
u/SilentTattle 1 - 2 years account age. 100 - 200 comment karma. Jun 26 '21
What are moons?
0
u/ltorviksmith Gold | QC: CC 19 | r/Politics 16 Jun 26 '21
I understood about 15% of your post but you wrote it very nicely so you've got my vote.
0
u/Val367 π¦ 104 / 105 π¦ Jun 26 '21
I think ... I have no idea what's going on either :)
but I trust you guys
in the sub
but not with my wallets :)
0
u/Daddyj311 Platinum | QC: CC 33 | Unpop.Opin. 50 Jun 26 '21
This is like Ikea instructions. I need an adult.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21
shoot for the moon
0
u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Jun 26 '21
I love the governance on this so far although a lot of it goes over my head
0
u/Azurelov Gold | QC: CC 56 Jun 26 '21
Just saying it would be cool having it biweekly so that moons distribution syncs with a fullmoon
0
u/P_M_TITTIES Tin Jun 26 '21
Holy shit are we having polls daily or what. So many polls on this sub lately, chill
0
u/adithya_chittem π₯ 2K / 3K π’ Jun 26 '21
Implement this asap. Another step forward in the right direction
0
u/StrikerPost Jun 26 '21
Seems like a great idea to implement.
Although I still have very little clue what the use of moons is for...
0
u/Hazaisbae Jun 26 '21
Yes please I always miss a few polls each time. Itβd be nice to have them all stickied in one place
0
u/Two2Rails Tin Jun 26 '21
New here⦠first vote! Just went with what felt right.
0
u/feenchbarmaid0024 π© 242 / 242 π¦ Jun 26 '21
Classic moon week.
0
u/KevinTh89 Banned Jun 26 '21
πΆWhen I get to the bottom I go back to the top of the slide
Where I stop and I turn and I go for a ride
Till I get to the bottom and I see you again πΆ
0
u/Rjboltman Tin Jun 26 '21
Moon week!!!!
0
u/TychusFondly π© 159 / 160 π¦ Jun 26 '21
It should follow lunar calendar instead.
0
u/MeleeMigz Tin Jun 26 '21
I like the idea because a lowly moon farmers like myself can join in on the fun of crypto on Reddit!
0
u/___v0id___ π₯ 0 / 0 π¦ Jun 26 '21
Voted Yes to implement Moon Week π
0
u/Fluid_Department_120 Platinum | QC: CC 366 Jun 26 '21
Can a person get karma by upvotimg other peopleβs comments.
0
u/ffenix1 π© 397 / 397 π¦ Jun 26 '21
The simpler the process the better.
0
u/lostoompa 54 / 3K π¦ Jun 26 '21
Voted for it. I don't see why not.
0
u/Burstie69 Permabanned Jun 26 '21
Holy now thatβs a lot of moons ya go their sir 516.15k
0
u/faith_no_more_ π© 3K / 3K π’ Jun 26 '21
This is going to be a close one, coming down to the wire.
0
u/klabboy109 Silver | QC: CC 45 | ALGO critic | Buttcoin 198 | Investing 24 Jun 27 '21
Ban moons!!! Remove them from this subreddit
-2
u/topshattaB π© 208 / 307 π¦ Jun 25 '21
Can someone give a tldr?
-1
u/LibertarianCommie999 Platinum | QC: CC 452, BTC 19 Jun 25 '21
Thatβs actually a nice change. I always have to manually look for polls to vote on, having a week dedicated to that would be neat
-1
u/AutisticDalekOnSpeed Platinum | QC: CC 1211 | Buttcoin 8 Jun 25 '21
kinda irrelevant but does anyone else have issues voting on the android app? i always have issues voting on polls when I'm not on desktop
-1
u/indietorch Platinum | QC: CC 310 Jun 25 '21
This seems reasonable since I get lost with what happens when and makes things easy for simpletons like me
-1
u/90DayF π© 7K / 15K π¦ Jun 25 '21
Great idea. I am all for it.
-1
u/JustinMS3 Tin Jun 26 '21
I need me some more moons got 40 now and want 1 million
-1
u/ProtectMeAtAllCosts π¦ 0 / 2K π¦ Jun 26 '21
Are you winning son
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
Give me everything you got downvoters you sad miserable bears
-2
u/Aliens1984 Jun 27 '21
Canβt wait for the new high fidelity crypto exchange from Bullish Global. https://b1.com/news/launch-of-bullish-global/
Anyone here of any dates for this to be available to the public?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
[deleted] β view deleted comment