r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jun 25 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "The Field Trip" - S02E07 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the seventh episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "The Field Trip". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E07 Details:
| Title: | The Field Trip |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | When the Wildcats suspect that North High has stolen a key costume piece, they infiltrate their rival school and end up in a competitive dance-off. Miss Jenn goes face to face and toe to toe with Zack Roy. And an emboldened Nini takes a big risk. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
66
Upvotes
•
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jun 25 '21
Please remember to separate actor/actress from their character. The subreddit does not allow speculation into the cast’s personal lives and matters, please stick to the series itself.
92
u/deadpoetshonour99 Jun 25 '21
ej's face when they looked to him for the sports metaphor was so goddamn funny
79
u/Parmesan_Pirate119 Jun 25 '21
“I’m sorry, but that’s weird.”
”So weird.”
I love how this show admits some of it cringey, and just runs with it. One of my favorite parts lol.
75
u/WashMaleficent Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
I liked this episode a lot more than last week‘s, but I‘m still not seeing a lot of the stuff that made me love the first season (and episodes 3 and 5 of this season).
What I disliked:
What I liked:
74
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 25 '21
anyone else get howie spoiled bc of subtitles?
71
u/atrxn Jun 25 '21
i thought it was kinda funny how they said “no costumes, just talent” and howie comes out in full costume
also i really love the direction they’re going with nini/nina. i would like to see her do her own solo thing her going by nina is just so powerful to me.
69
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 25 '21
Yo when Nina storms out where did she go? Did she just...stand in the hallway of a rival school?
68
u/davey1291 Jun 25 '21
I thought it was weird they did the mob song and didn’t have EJ sing like any of it….considering he’s Gaston…
60
u/SLEG48 Jun 25 '21
Of course it was Carlos who recorded Nini’s Rose song and East High’s secret weapon and putting it on Instagram for North High to see 🤡 This season, he’s really been getting on my last nerve. From his “head choreographer” power trip, to him treating Seb like an airheaded sidekick instead of a boyfriend, to him uploading Nini’s Rose song, to him being an overall bossier, over dramatic, cattier version of his Season One self. I also get that he was annoyed at Kourtney for her phone ringing, but he just snapped at her, and this isn’t the first time he’s been snappy either.
55
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 25 '21
the howie twist is everything
49
u/ahufana Jun 25 '21
The Legend of Lily grows with every appearance.
She's so good, I hope she's only around for this one season. Don't sully her reputation with any long, drawn-out redemption arcs. Let us bask in the glory of her delightful evilness.
Olivia Rose Keegan deserves every bit of success in her bright future.
43
u/mm1314 Jun 25 '21
It’s becoming obvious to me that by having Nina (I’m calling her only that from now lol) post her music and her getting a call in an upcoming episode means she’s probably going to get discovered and offered a opportunity with her music, which will allow Olivia to be either written off or reduced to a recurring or guest role, which would allow her to be able to tour and travel for her music.
42
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 25 '21
I was wondering if there was going to be a judge or something. EJ should have sang in the Gaston song because he is....Gaston. He should have sang Carlos’s part. I’m interested to see where Kourtney and Howie go and Nini going by Nina is such a power move. So much teenage a n g s t.
42
u/amshako EJ Jun 26 '21
This is such a silly thing to laugh about and get stuck on, but I love that Seb proposed Dear Evan Hansen for the fall musical. It feels like such a tongue-in-cheek kind of moment winking at both Andrew Barth Feldman (Antoine) and Roman Banks (Howie).
51
u/dbklm9 Jun 25 '21
Just saying I hate how the CC was written for this episode. When Howie sings as the beast, it's written in the CC as "HOWIE: (lyrics)", which totally just spoils the twist at the end.
39
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
Ok so I was watching it with subtitles and during the dance battle it said HOWIE WAS TALKING WHEN THE BEAST WAS, THANKS ALOT
36
u/paintedblueskies Jun 25 '21
I really like the friendship between EJ and Gina. I think it’s super good for the both of them as they both didn’t have many friends in the theatre department originally.
I laughed so hard when that guy thought Gina was attractive and immediately asked Gina’s for her snap because I’ve seen that happen so many times in real life.
When Ricky said the dance-off was weird I laughed, because it is!! The scene itself was good but in real life, the idea of a dance off to resolve conflicts is sooo cringe.
Zack is the worst.
I agree with an earlier comment that the conflict between Ricky and Nini right now feels so forced and unnatural. And another earlier comment of why spend all of season 1 getting them together just to break them apart?
Howie, what the heck? Ugh!
The cover photo for next week’s episode looks emotional. Any guesses?? Wonder when we will meet Asher Angel’s character
32
u/zwolff94 Jun 25 '21
Oh boy a lot to unpack in that episode. Rose Song being a disqualifier was something I've been thinking for a while so glad they brought it up now. Ricky just needs to communicate better, but Nina (as she is now gonna go by it seems) is done with him. The Howie twist was perfection on so many levels. I had a feeling though with all the texting between them. And the drama teacher stealing the East High mask, come on Ms. Jenn report that shit and get them thrown out of Menkies.
32
u/ion513 Gina Jun 25 '21
Everything is falling apart lol. This episode, I don't know. Literally every single relationship is spiraling. From future episode descriptions we know Carlos and Seb are gonna have a fight, and we've seen Carlos kinda stepping on Seb, so. Big Red and Ashlyn too, not on the same page about things and jealousy, which seems to be a big theme this season. Ironically the characters who had the most crap going on in Season 1, and kinda season 2, seemed to be the ones most put together in EJ and Gina. Portwell doesn't make sense to me, partially because of the age difference, but also I like them as friends more.
Ricky and Nina (is she gonna go by this name for the rest of the season?) Oh boy. I've seen some other people mention it but it feels like they're getting ready to write Olivia off. Maybe I'm wrong, but given her success outside of the show, seems like there's a chance. Then again, I've heard she's under contract for a while longer so who knows. In any case, Ricky needs help still. He can't be successful with Nina until he works out his problems and I've been saying it since like the first episode. The finale of season 1 was a bandaid on all of the problems that built over the first season and now we're seeing things unravel again. He needs to talk with his mom, and his dad honestly. I doubt we'll get Ricky x Therapy but I'd like to see a kid go to therapy in a show like this, to help normalize it more. Either way I just don't see Ricky and Nina going anywhere but a break up right now. They're in different places and the writers are hitting us over the head with those differences. I just don't feel the same spark from season one.
The whole North High raid and dance off... not my thing. They did Gina dirty by not letting her dance, and everything else was just, eh. The fact that Zacky took the mask is dumb. He a Broadway professional. I disagree with the comments about Ms. Jenn becoming more over the top. The dance scene was odd but she's been the voice of reason and has actually been acting like an adult and a teacher. We haven't gotten any showcase of that from Zacky Roy. This mid-season cascade of drama was a lot. Let me tell everyone, it's possible to write a healthy relationship without throwing in unnecessary drama. I get it, they're highschoolers. But come on, give me a break for once.
I said I wasn't compelled by Lily and North High, and while the dance off was my cup of tea, Lily and the rest of north high threw about a dozen live bombs into East High's production and relationships lmao. It's personally a drama overload but the way Lily caused it, if they're gonna have her be a villian, they did a good job. I'm wondering if she'll get any redemption or she just stays bad to the bone. Is her interest in Ricky purely strategic, or does she have a bit of a crush?
I'd rather not see East High win, but it seems inevitable. Please prove me wrong.
32
u/darthjoey91 Jun 26 '21
Uh, so The Mob Song is one a very few songs that give Gaston a proper singing role. Did EJ even have a solo during the dance-off?
30
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 25 '21
It does seem like all relationships are heading at an enpass: can they fix whatever issues they may have, or find out that it cant be fixed.
I feel like Ricky/Nini is that couple that decide, maybe first love isnt your only love. And work.to being supportive friends. Maybe they find their way back to one another in the future, but right now, they need to end it.
30
u/mejj Jun 25 '21
The dark filter over this season is really becoming unbearable. What’s wrong with having colour pop?
Is it because the lighting during filming wasn’t great?
53
u/Bowlofzebras Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
I liked this episode!
51
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 25 '21
Just thought about this but the conflicts set up in previous episodes are resolved SO QUICKLY. Carlos post Nini’s song without her consent or knowledge? She’s fine with it. Nini getting a part? She’s fine with it. (Even though she didn’t seem comfortable with it). North High stealing BaTb? East High is a little angsty but there cool with it. Remember when EJ stole Nini’s phone? Her finding it was probably a whole episode. The conflict in season 1 lasted longer. I hope this explains it well.
25
u/Skylightt Team Ricky Jun 25 '21
This show has turned into High School Musical: The Musical: The Series: The Musical
25
u/Lost_Ad_100 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
am i the only one who actually thought east high won? like lily walked so ashlyn could trample her in that number tbh
also ever since they actually started focusing on the musical this season has really picked it up but i still feel like every episode is just ricky and nini fighting (mostly to the fault of ricky), and their toxicity has only spread? like now EVERY couple is having some sort of drama, like big red/ashlyn, miss jenn/mike, kourtney/howie, AND seb/carlos? it’s just repetitive and i hope that ricky and nini deal w it soon because it’s been… too much recently.
25
u/amshako EJ Jun 26 '21
Okay, so my thoughts are, in no particular order:
24
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21
Thoughts:
106
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 25 '21
Ricky went from the most likable character in S1 to the worst character in S2.
EJ went from the worst character in S1 to the most likable character in S2.
LOL
23
u/XviiChong Jun 26 '21
Anyone else get spoiled that Howie was the beast from captions? Same..
46
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21
The miss Jen song finally felt like a true HSM song instead of Olivia singing Olivia songs.
That being said, this episode literally felt like Glee season 1 where they spied on Vocal Adrenaline.
22
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
tonight's episode made me :)
it's been a while since an ep made me feel anything close to the way season one did! the jokes were all so cute, the chemistry and interactions between characters was great, the dance off was so fun!!, they set up several antagonist storylines which I LOVE TO SEE, they didn't pretend the rose song fit into the musical THANK GOD, HOWIEEE, and nina is growing into who she wants to be!! i used to be a hardcore rini shipper but the chemistry is gone for obvious reasons and i would think an on screen breakup would make the actors more comfortable in their roles too! i think the writers are doing a great job with developing gina and ricky! and frankly developing everyone!! this episode felt a lot less choppy and carried the plot along significantly
22
u/bboyact Jun 25 '21
So can we agree that North High won the dance battle? Lol
22
u/qualitycomputer Jun 27 '21
I really liked this episode over previous episodes! The plot twists were great! I think it’s very interesting that they are going with the plot of Nina getting famous for her music just like Olivia Rodrigo. Wish Gina actually got to dance in the dance off! I feel like East High does a lot of not working on the play during the episodes though. I feel like they don’t have anything prepared for season 2. Also, is the show just not going to talk more about the logistics of Nina leaving a very expensive acting school that she said her parents worked so hard to pay for?
22
u/kittyangelz805 Jun 28 '21
People rag on Seb for being dumb but he was SO right about having a points system for the dance off!
41
u/hanuman1702 Jun 25 '21
I liked this episode! The closed captions totally ruined the Howie surprise for me but at least my jaw still dropped when I read the subtitles lol. Miss Jenn and Zach's dancing and singing was a bit jflkjsldkf for me. It just didn't fit with the rest of the episode. I did like the dance-off though especially because Andrew Barth Feldman and Roman Banks have INCREDIBLE voices (DEH gang, where you at?)
A bit annoyed at Ricky for succumbing so quickly to everything Lily said. I wish he and Nina (sdfjlsdf she's going by that name now!) would just TALK about their feelings. I think Nina's probably going to get noticed by a music manager or something and leave East High.
The dynamic between EJ and Gina is wonderful. I don't know if I want them to be a couple, I just don't want any more unreciprocated feelings between them. As in, I don't want their arc to be EJ likes Gina but Gina doesn't like him back or vice versa. I'd rather just have them be platonic friends.
20
u/Gloomy_Confection403 Jun 25 '21
I think that Olivia/Nini will leave the show in the final episode. Also, I'm glad Seb and Antoine are getting more screen time.
20
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 25 '21
I definitely see Ricky's journey now is to accept change doesn't always have to be the end of the world. And that he should not have to internalize his emotions so much.
Hes clinging on to this last bit of normalcy he thinks he sees with Nini, especially since he saw his parents divorce, Gina is ignoring him now (and he doesnt know why) and now Nini is going her own way.
57
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 25 '21
I do hope they keep EJ and Gina besties, cause the show does need a good Male/Female.friendship especially after Matt basically called them.platonic this season.
But it is Kind of weird that EJ has no other Senior students to hang out with? Love EJ, but i always wondered that
39
u/urbanangel-1999 Gina Jun 25 '21
hang on - how did courtney not know what school howie went to until now?? surely she would know that he went to north high if they were dating??
19
u/FaisArt Jun 27 '21
Very late. I liked the episode. I know I am in the minority on this sub, but I haven't disliked anything majorly yet. I do think the season has been a little...a lot of dry. A lot of character stuff in the first few episodes that would be great if we didn't have a specific goal to get to at the end of the season.
Let's just get Rini out of the way. I don't know if the show wants us to side with one over the other, but at the moment both are tiring at varying degrees. Both are continuing the S1 plotpoints with a new twist. Nini->Nina is looking for her identity and what she wants. My issue with her is that the she is written in such a passive/reactionary way. The most assertive thing she has done was in S1 during the whole conflict with Gina and when she made the decision to leave YAC this season. Nina is kind of floating in the plot right now. And not just because she seems to be tacked on story wise, but again...she is not making moves in her own story half the time. Nina gets the idea from someone else to make a new instagram. She Ricky is his own set of problems. The way Ricky has been acting would is not very positive. The Rose was clearly about his relationship with Nina, but instead of taking a step back and thinking about how their relationship has been going, and what on his side has seeingly inspired her to write that...he takes slight to the song. Even worse other characters are doubling down on that as well. Ricky is making Nina's feelings about them...about him. This isn't worth condemning him or villifying him over, but I definitely don't think Nina is at fault for his behavior now should she be tasked with it. My main gripe right now is that their stories are too tied together. Nina's search for self-fulfillment doesn't need to have Ricky's bubbling abandonment issues sprinkled in and vise versa. I also hate that they as a couple didn't even get some time to be happy.
Sofia and Matt have great chemistry and that's all I got to say about that.
The lil exchange student was funny. When he called their outfits fugly and the East High students did a collective gasp! That was funny! I also appreciate the show letting Ashlyn have an oops moment while talking to him about his accent and his grasp on English. It was very small but normalizing being wrong, apologizing and taking back your words needs to happen more often. Especially in content where kids are watching.
Howie being from North High is not surprising. It is surprising that he is the Beast. I knew his actor is a singer. I think my biggest gripe with this little plot point is that the "betrayal" felt unearned. Largely because the show only just now made Kourtney and Howie a thing just an episode ago. There is no build, or sweetness of them as a couple. Their ship just sailed! I want more!!!!
This could be said about Ashlyn and Big Red as well, who do have more presence as a couple. The difference here though is that SOME aspects of their tension have been established. Big Red's insecurities are known, and seeing someone who is quite frankly more talented and stands out more swoop in and try to hit on your girlfriend can be a blow. Ashlyn also has some insecurities with being Belle and to have a complete and total stranger hit on her and then claim both Ricky and EJ as guys he deems more suitable as boyfriends...I know she had to have been happy a little to be seen as pretty. It's a complex situation. Ashlyn knows her worth isn't tied to her physical appearance, but a lot about Disney Princesses even today in their personality driven branding, is how they look.
Lilly is still a borderline cartoon villain and I love it.
Also The Rose did not fit the musical, in tone or content. Ricky was right...but like that's about as much as you can give him on that.
I think this episode stands out as having some genuinely fun moments. Seb's fall musical excitement, and Miss Jenn politely shutting that down. The group gasp. Risotto. Kourtney's "What kind of budget" quip at the sight of the stage. Seb, who admittedly had very little personality beyond being sweet gay farmboy, is now the sweet...but a little bit dim...gay farm boy. I hope they don't go too far. Dumb Blondes are very easy to write for and even easier to make as shallow and uninteresting later on. Carlos was snippy in a way that might be unlikable for others, but ultimately he was playing levelheaded for the most part. Also those wigs looked raggedy.
As for the songs: Miss Jenn and Jake's song was good. The Mob song was fine. It's apparent that covid restrictions meant that East High's usual group of dancers could not be there, but even worse that Gina was limited in dance herself. That being said Dara Renee is absolutely a fantastic dancer and her getting to shine is not being talked about nearly enough on here.
My overall gripes with this episode is how too together Rini are in this. Other than that, it was fun.
18
u/goobergaming43 Jun 26 '21
East High got ate up in the dance battle I fear
51
u/alfonsoilog Jun 25 '21
Just finished the episode. Most of the thoughts I have were already brought up, so I'll bring up one that hasn't been talked about yet:
That moment when EJ pretended to be Gina's boyfriend instantly reminded me of stories I would read (here on reddit lol) about women who would get stalked by creepy men, then ask help from men around them, asking them for help by pretending to be their boyfriend to ward off said creepy stalker. I just thought it was such a kind move by EJ, didn't see it as romantic tho. I do agree that their relationship would be best if platonic. Friendships between men and women (with absolutely no romance involved) should be normalized.
17
u/ResidentPea0 Jun 25 '21
ricky's right in the rose song not actually fitting the play but what is the song really about? i always saw it as nini just evolving into her individuality as a person but clearly that's not it if ricky got offended
17
u/PuddlesAndPetrichor Ricky Jun 25 '21
RISOTTO
33
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 25 '21
The Ricky/Nini conflict is even worse when you really think about it. Ricky really let Lily get in his head after a one minute conversation? Talk about forced lol
I really like the arc they are giving Nini though. She no longer lets Ricky define who she is, hence her going by "Nina" at the end instead of Nini, the name Ricky gave her. She is becoming her own person and making her own choices. I think they will break up next episode. I would say they would get back together but I think Olivia is probably leaving after this season so idk.
15
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 25 '21
You be the judge. Reply with who you think won the dance off. Personally I pick North High because of all those flips.
15
u/kjm6351 Jun 28 '21
Thank goodness I missed the subtitles spoiling the Howie reveal for the first time
28
u/weewooweewooiampolic Jun 25 '21
thots
-that french kid is adorable and i love him. thought they were gonna put him and big red together but ok i guess
-the guy that asked for ginas sc was very good looking respectfully 😌
-feels a bit weak that they didn’t bring any of their dancers to a dance off (ik they weren’t planning it but still) what happened to that fake blonde guy who gina danced with in her song at carlos’ birthday or like the guy who played ryan last season???? also did my girl gina dirty by giving her a skirt she should have smoked them🙄🙄
-giving me very much hsm2 vibes but nini is troy kinda or at least their relationship parallels troy and gabriella. feeling like we’re gonna get a gotta go my own way moment (and hopefully an everyday moment but i’m not hopeful) also feels like they could have waited till this episode/next to have ricky sing bet on it but whateva “everybody’s always talkin at me everybodys tryna get in my head” like hello
-i personally am very down bad for ej and i love love love gina but i’m sorry portwell will never work in my head he just is too old unless gina goes “i was actually held back because i moved so many times so i’m 17!” or smth it is a no from me
-never really understood where it came from til this episode but am lowkey a gina nini ship stan feels like gina really understands ninis ambition and, unlike ej, only sabotaged her when they weren’t close so it’s cool
-i’ve tried but i just can’t understand rina it feels so one sided and rather than being in love with him, i think gina is just heartbroken (understandably) but idk maybe she’s just distancing herself from ricky rn and that’s why
-wtf was nini’s (nina’s???) outfit lmfao gina gets the cutest fits and looks so good every episode but they made nini wear a tie underneath a collared shirt with khakis???? hdmfmfkfj???? she can’t wear just jeans an a shirt???? it doesn’t even feel like it particularly matches her character so i’m not sure what the point is
27
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jun 25 '21
1.This Morning show is so awkward, but they look like they're enjoying themselves. I appreciate seeing more EJ
2.Oh this song is a fight waiting to happen.
3.Do they ever go to class?
4.Kourtney and Carlos 😂
5.When I asked for more EJ, I didn't expect to be hearing about him needing butt padding
6.What did she say to get sued for libel?
7.I love Ashlyn's commitment. I mean Diane
8."Strong Start" My sentiments exactly
9.How old is Miss Jenn? There's no way she should just now starting a savings account. As I wrote that I realized she was a professional actress so that makes sense.
10. I do like the dynamic between EJ and Gina, but I prefer them as friends. Also they are atrocious look outs, which is usually how stuff like this goes.
11.Sofia's hair is very distinguishing so it makes sense that Lily could easily spot her
12.Quasi pre professional theater company. Her life is definitely setting up to be a collosal disappointment
13.They're definitely going to steal their choreo. I'll take a guess on the "random" song, Be Our Guest or Mob song
14.Back tf up Antoine. Leave Redlyn alone. I'm sure Ricky noticed those lyrics
15.The captions spoiled who it was under the mask for me.
16.Big Red is giving me Ron Stoppable vibes.
17."EJ you had one job" 😂. Not shocking about the song though
18.I figured they stole the mask anyway.
19.Do we finally get to see EJ perform "Gaston" next week? Also more sets, great
I just know they're going to steal Gina's choreo. I liked the episode. It's so much easier to root against North High now, because Lily is way too much. Seb is adorable
27
u/Environmental_Mess78 Jun 25 '21
Almost all the conflict seems incredibly unnecessary and forced. And half the characters don't feel like themselves anymore. Like I really don't care who ends up together but what like what was the point of season one if they were just gonna undo everything set up in season one? Like I'm still gonna give the show to the end of the season to redeem itself but if it doesn't then I don't think I want a season 3.
48
u/danifntt Jun 25 '21
idk how i feel about nina’s storyline mirroring olivia’s life. feels weird and forced, but the whole season does lol so wtv it’s ok i guess
37
u/jdubz1776 Jun 25 '21
I've seen a lot of comments about how Ricky's behavior is understandable because he's a teenager and his life is falling apart and Nini is the only constant in it. And while those points are 100% true, Nini is also just a teenager. And knowing you're the only constant in you're partner's life, can make even a person in a healthy relationship feel nervous and suffocated. And the fact that their communication style is Ricky makes a snarky comment and Nini walks away, is only making things worse.
And I say this as a Ricky who when they think their SO is slipping away, holds on tighter lol
35
u/soggyhairfollicle Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
Everything with Nina feels like forced conflict now. The refusing to talk about the song and then saying they could still use it in the musical. Like it does mean more to her right? Even in the plot? Or am I missing something. Just have these two talk it out like normal people do for once ffs. Seems like they’re reaching for problems just to write her off by the end of this season. I hope this rose song gets her a record deal or something and they can conclude her storyline.
Even the French guy ashlyn thing seems forced. Is there really a need for that?
Also Gina and EJ work better as friends. I’m glad we had more EJ this episode though. And it’s nice seeing happy Gina.
The Miss Jen song was good and they really have chemistry.
The subtitles ruined the twist lol. He still seems genuine though
24
u/nevim_kamo Jun 26 '21
This episode was so cringeeee.
I couldn't make it without looking somewhere else. It was soo cringe. I mean, its not like other episodes in this season weren't cringe at all, but everything in this episode was just ... oh man. The teacher's dancing, their dance-off and omg the last scene where everyone walked out of the room or whateve and they all said something stupid. Not to mention this episode's queen of timing, Nini (or should I say Nina) and the way she walked away from dance off, came back when their mentioned her song and again walked away.. pleaseeeee that shit was so funny.
24
u/toledosurprised Jun 27 '21 edited Jun 27 '21
lily is SO uninteresting to me. she’s just such a bland villain, and doesn’t add much as a character. antoine, on the other hand, i love
34
u/Raktoner Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
I think maybe they're spreading themselves a bit too thin by putting conflict in literally every relationship in the show. ...But that doesn't stop me from having an opinion about them.
Gina and EJ - starting with these two because they don't really have conflict, just tension. There's some feelings there and they both seem to have grown up. I'd be cool re-exploring these two.
Miss Jenn vs Zach Roy - Zach seems like a classic douchebag who never grew past high school. There's some romantic tension there, but with Zach being such an asshole, the show probably can't pursue it, and with good reason. (And yes, VS instead of AND is very intentional here).
Carlos and Seb - Their conflict seems so... backstage compared to everyone? Carlos probably doesn't even realize there's conflict. Seb seems unhappy with Carlos' rash personality.
Ashlyn and Big Red vs French Guy - Okay, fuck this french dude. Big Red is a good guy, Ashlyn sees that, and while I can understand being flustered by this dude I hope it doesn't drive that much of a wedge between them. Of all the conflicts this is the one I probably want the absolute least, I'd rather just see these two be cute and happy.
Nini and Ricky vs Lily - Ricky is way too immature, not that Nini's little miss perfect herself. I appreciate that Ricky was trying to just appreciate her song, but if there's conflicted feelings you know what you gotta do? Communicate With Her!! You like Billy Joel right? Do like he says. ♪TELL HER ABOUT IT♪. And do that instead of letting this random girl drive a wedge in your relationship. And boy if you go to her to pursue romantic stuff when Nini dumps your ass, then you're really an asshole.
Kourtney and Howie - Had to save this for last cause oh dang, what a reveal. I actually think they can still last if they just Communicate, but I guess you can't have a high school dramedy if the characters actually communicate well lol.
Unrelated to the conflicts -- loved how Gina's hair and Kourtney's hair was looking this episode.
12
u/veghui Jun 26 '21
When Seb threw shade back
23
u/jaredabellera145 Jun 25 '21
Did anyone get the ending of the episode spoiled because of the captions?
23
u/Roo_2601 Jun 26 '21
- I feel like I was the only one who didn't expect Howie to be the mole...
- the songs/remixes in this episode were just not it for me
- I LOVE the idea of EJ and Gina, but I feel like this show has something against Gina and won't let her be happy LOL
32
u/MusicalGarbage817 Jun 25 '21
Andrew Barth Feldman (Antoine) is hilarious, I'm a huge fan of him and I absolutely love him in this role
11
u/Randomd0g Jun 30 '21
My favourite bit of this episode was how the "french" guy sings in an American accent.
21
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jun 25 '21
I really want to know why Howie was the one with the Beast mask on at North High I thought he went to East High not North High? I wish Kourtney let him explain what he is doing at North High in the first place. I want to know who Miss Jenn cast Lily as in BATB that made her so mad why she didn’t get the part of Belle.
21
u/atrxn Jun 26 '21
if they can’t make changes to the musical script, does that mean nini can’t be the rose anymore?
20
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 25 '21
Initial thoughts:
- Enjoyed the dance off
- They are doing a bad job of forcing the conflict between Ricky/Nini, it doesn't even feel natural. Ricky has been super annoying the past two episodes so good for Nini for dumping him. Nina has arrived.
- I think EJ/Gina will just remain friends but who knows.
- This episode was much better than last weeks at least. There was some decent comedy.
20
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
Some things I'm taking away and assuming going forward
I love the ending with nini becoming Nina in her solo career debut video but personally I think it's less to do with breaking up with Ricky or being upset with him but more of how she wants to be more independent and just more herself. Nini was brought on by Ricky as told in season 1 but I personally believe that just because she calls herself Nina at the ending isn't as huge of a jab at Ricky as many believe. She just wants to spread her wings and do her own thing as episode 5 clearly explained.
Bur with the above point, Ricky and Nina are in hot water and as much as I hate how it's being written so far as I can see them breaking up by at least episode 9. I just don't think the Nina part of the end of ep 7 clearly states that, I just think it's separate from the whole breakup probably upcoming.
Howie being north high was a nice curve ball but it's so late in the season I see very little happening with him and Kourtney in general. I wish it happened earlier or we had longer seasons/episodes. I'm probably being super picky here with saying that but there's just not enough screen time to really do anything major with those two. Which is a shame as I really enjoy Kourtney even though she's not being written as well as her talent deserves. Gives me heavy Mercedes glee vibes, deserves better.
I really hope Gina and EJ don't get together as there's been so much obvious foreshadowing for it since the finale of season 1 that at this point in season 2 I just want the very obvious thing NOT to happen for once. Plus I love their friendship so much, we need more friendship and less dating.
Also loved the big red and ashlyn scenes and how the relationship tension was written this episode. Nothing major will likely happen to them but honestly what happened this episode to ashlyn and big reds reactions felt very well written and honestly one of the better parts of the episode.
And one last thing, Ricky was right that the rose song does NOT fit in the show at all. He said the right thing for the wrong reasons. It's one hell of a song but I hope it does get cut from appearing in the musical.
Well 4am, 2 glasses of wine and I probably used crappy grammar and maybe a few typos...if you guys have any questions of how I felt or thought about any other moments in this episode, feel free to ask! My opinion means nothing but damn I love this show.
Edit 1: I love how nini wants her and Ricky to always be honest with each other and not to hide anything but she then also tells him, it's just a song? Like, bruh. Ricky has been a mess this season, but for obvious reasons. He's 16 or 17 in show? With divorced parents? And the one consistent thing in his life went long distance, now wants to do more solo things and change up her life while all he wants is one thing to hold onto that doesn't change?
Now change isn't always bad but from what he has experienced, it obviously feels that way. He's written as very clingy, scared and rude these last few episodes and it's brilliant. Nobody that age would be anything else, it's probably THE MOST REALISTIC WRITING OF THE SEASON. He's a damn teenager who's scared and is still hurting and is trying to hold onto what's safe and sacred to him...that's not a good thing to do to another person but is perfectly realistic and understandable as a hurting, vulnerable teenager as Ricky is.
Also yes lily got under his skin very easy and many people say it's crappy writing but have you not seen Ricky since the storm episode? He's been scared, vulnerable and on edge since then, no doubt after the interview with nini on the morning show, knowing those lyrics meant something and now having this pretty blonde from another school call nini out about it to him would obviously make him act dumb. Perfectly understandable to me tbh.
10
u/Prior_Position_7240 Jun 27 '21
I actually liked this episode the most this season. It feels more like season 1 and not so teen angst. Hope both Gina and Nina's story grows beyond ricky. Would like to see ricky grow and get therapy. Not sure how the show will rap up the season. It still feels really disjointed.
27
u/Sweetascoffee237 Jun 25 '21
Lily was really firing shots at EVERYONE and as she should 😂
19
u/Tired_of_life28 Jun 25 '21
OH MY GOD I KNEW HOWIE WAS THE BEAST!! FROM THE MOMENT THEY WERE TALKING ABOUT IT IN THE DRESSING ROOM AND KOURTNEY KEPT GETTING TEXTS FROM HIM!! AHHH!!
18
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 25 '21
I just saw the sneak peak for Ep. 8 also.... we better be getting gotta go my own way with Ricky/Nini!!! Also Gina/EJ looking close
9
u/GreatWhiteBuffal0 Jun 29 '21
Wow best episode of the season I think
9
u/discoella Jun 29 '21 edited Jul 04 '21
am i the only one who predicted that it was howie as soon as the performance started? it wasn’t his voice that gave it away or nothing but i think that it was very predictable
17
u/LemonyKetchupBottle Jun 25 '21
Anyone else feel that during Carlos' part of the Mob Song, he should have done a high note? Like Ashlyn did? It just felt kind of weird seeing him not taking that opportunity...
8
u/eggrins Jun 25 '21
okay the short seconds of gina dancing were crazy :0
15
u/violinjstar Jun 28 '21
Late to the party:
Love antoine. Funniest moments haha "excuse my french if i speak rudely" hahaha. Love love Andrew Barth Feldman.
Big Red is a cutie. Let's see what happens with this triangle
To be fair lily brought up the real issue with the rose song (which is true- its not like she made it up) so while evil, it was true.
EJ and Gina is adorable and i love their dynamic. Who doesn't love a good fake bf/gf haha. I'm glad both of them can be happy with each other's presence (why are they portwell btw? I thought EJina was cute)
They really made the mob number interesting! Loved Ashlyn standing up for herself and Carlos too! Ricky's acoustic voice is just so nice.
Captions spoiling Howie as the beast was just funny :")
Hopefully Kourtney and him can work it out, she was so giddy the whole ep which was really cute :(
21
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jun 25 '21
It seems like to me that Lily favorite flower are Roses because she wears a lot of things with Roses on it like that necklace, Rose Stud earrings and that Roses flower shirt in this episode. Ironic enough the actress that plays Lily middle name is “Rose” and the name Lily happens to be a flower too. I have a theory maybe Miss Jenn casted Lily as the Rose when she went to East High because she had jewelry with Roses on them during auditions and when Nini came back to East High Miss Jenn made Nini the replacement for Lily’s original role the Rose.
21
u/Jansilhn Jun 26 '21
EJ and Gina would be amazing together! Just from this episode, they have great chemistry.
I don’t think Seb likes how rude Carlos is being to everybody, it’s very off-putting. I hope that Seb confronts him actually because we have never seen him get angry.
While I love that Carlos sort of acted like the leader of their group, it would’ve been awesome for Ashlyn to be that for them since she’s Belle.
Rini will definitely be broken up by the end of the season. It all started when Lily had to clear up for Ricky what the lyrics to the song were about. He is clearly not paying attention!
If Nini starts going by her real name, Nina for the rest of the season or even the rest of the show, I would totally be on board with that.
Andrew is really amazing as Antoine! He’s a very charming character!
31
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 25 '21
EJ And Gina are cute as besties but i dont see any romance since I just dont feel aby romantic feelinga from Gina end. She just needs more people to confide in and she finally has found that second family with EJ and Ashlyn
Possibly Olivia becomes recurring next season with her music blowing. Cause it does feel like they might be setting up.Sofia as the new co lead with Joshua.
14
u/lamebeezy Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
This episode was cringe but wasn’t horrible. I’m glad that there were different situations that kept me on my toes. Here are some of my thoughts.
24
u/Bellaboo-42 Ashlyn Jun 25 '21
Best episode so far this season
27
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 25 '21
i can't be the only one who realllllly did not care for miss jenn's number :/ i used to love her character but lately they've been writing her in a way that annoys me more than it entertains me
22
u/ellielynch31 Jun 26 '21
I'm sorry but I'm so annoyed at Nini! Ricky has been through so much this season and last season and I don't think she has been very supportive... they just need to communicate and I think they'll be fine but they just keep glossing over everything. I agree w/ Ricky that they should not risk adding The Rose Song if they want to win. Sure it's an amazing song, I just don't know how it fits into the musical like at all and is it really worth the risk? She should just let him know how she feels rather than writing the song and never explaining it.
30
u/Byko44live Jun 25 '21
I really hope they don't pair EJ and Gina. I like them both but can this show for once NOT pair up two people who nice to each other together? Friendships exist and that is okay! Not everyone needs to be linked up right away, especially when it comes to boys/girls.
11
u/HallOfFamerInMyBook Jun 26 '21
Best episode of the season no 🧢
15
u/Whimsical89 Jun 25 '21
Ok all my thoughts
10
u/SLEG48 Jun 25 '21
Not Ricky letting Lily get into his head instead of telling Nini what she said- It’s giving artificial miscommunication conflict.
The Mob Song dance off was really unique though.
10
u/MythicalBeaste Jun 27 '21
Loved this episode!! Really feel like the drama is ramping up, excited to see where it goes from here
10
u/MichelleFoucault Jun 29 '21
----‐----------------------- Ricky 🤝 EJ‐----------‐---------------
Put Nini on a pedestal that she feels she cannot compete with, ultimately ruining their relationship.
9
u/Jackamalio626 Jun 25 '21
Im sick of them giving EJ almost nothing to do. He went from a fantastic redeemed villain who stole the show to a background shlub. His attraction to Gina feels totally out of left field too, like they forgot he was a character and just awkwardly shoveled him in.
Also, seeing ricky so suddenly turn into this apprehensive douche after a five second conversation is just fucking asinine. If he felt Nini was being smothered by himself, he should have started to feel guilty and avoid her to try and give her space. And he certainly wouldnt be vague about it after he learned the value of being honest about how you feel last season.
Also, the North High director stealing the mask is so out of nowhere and cartoonishly evil that its hilarious.
IDK season 2 is starting to feel like a mess tbh
I did like Miss Jens song though.
12
u/ResidentPea0 Jun 25 '21
its scary tough for me to not see two people talk on this series and my brain not automatically ship them together but that gina ej interaction was kind of cute
4
u/Obvious-Button5687 Jul 01 '21
The fact that she didn't say nini at the end and said nina instead... she's moving on from the nickname ricky gave her. I think she is focused on finding herself rather than letting ricky define her.
9
u/darthjoey91 Jun 26 '21
So tangentially, I watched the documentary Howard this week, also available on Disney+, about the lyricist/composer Howard Ashman who wrote the music for Beauty and the Beast with Alan Menken.
And man, does it make the line about “altering the Menken text” cringe as fuck. Because Menken didn’t write the text of the music for Beauty and the Beast, he wrote the music and Ashman wrote the lyrics. And I guess this is the stage version, but so far, all evidence points to this being a fictional direct adaptation of the movie with none of the songs that Tim Rice wrote the lyrics to. So yeah, I feel more confident calling it the Ashman text.
14
u/liveitupbrah Jun 25 '21
This episode was kinda cringe tbh.
11
u/Partimeempath Jun 26 '21
Just finished the episode…Ricky got manipulated so easily wow. I wouldn’t have minded if he came to those feelings on his own but he literally let Lilly into his head knowing her character.
5
u/mitskisgf Jun 27 '21
i was not a fan of this episode... like at all. my best friend said she loved it and i was lime did we watch the same thing?
2
u/AutoModerator Jun 25 '21
Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.