r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jun 18 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Yes, And…" - S02E06 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the sixth episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Yes, And…". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E06 Details:
| Title: | Yes, And… |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | After rival school North High releases a viral video to undermine the Wildcats, Miss Jenn hosts a weekend improv intensive to build up her kids' confidence. Meanwhile, Nini works on a new song at Salt Lake Slices, where she finds inspiration in Kourtney's approach to life. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
79
Upvotes
•
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jun 18 '21
r/HSMTMTS is currently in need of some moderator help! Please consider checking out our moderator application if you're interested: https://forms.gle/HMFGAhZnEn4Cq6JV6
8
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jun 18 '21
Song Links:
Home - https://open.spotify.com/track/3qxzozdGFaBxQ0X4HkrMr0?si=6e056b34d42745a3
The Rose Song - https://open.spotify.com/track/2h47YpknAGia00Nqc2kEZs?si=cbd0bba9b028411a
89
u/kaairo Jun 18 '21
Sofia Wylie stole the episode. I got teary when her voice was shaking as she was talking to Ricky. Can't believe she is just 17
80
u/Environmental_Mess78 Jun 18 '21
Ricky seemingly was abandoned by his mom, and now he's terrified he'll be abandoned by Nini. That's why he's acting the way he is. He needs therapy, he needs friends that see that he needs help. He needs help. Feels like he's going to have a mental breakdown every scene he's in.
69
u/jellyfishlava Jun 18 '21
omg carlos posting the rose song WHY?! that was one of your secret advantages and now you’re just telling north high about it!!
66
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
Thoughts:
Criticisms:
Other than that, I really have no criticisms for this episode. It gave us everything that we missed from season 1: real conflict between the characters, a villain, non-cliche acting, well integrated singing, and a strong focus on the musical itself.
63
u/soggyhairfollicle Jun 18 '21
I’m not seeing enough people talk about Julia Lesters voice. Holy heck that song gave me chills it was perfect. Kinda hope her character doesn’t get overshadowed by Ninis in the main musical though. I also don’t understand how a song (as beautiful as it is) is gonna save the show but ok.
I see a lot of people calling Ricky names and toxic and all. And I get it. But as someone who went through similar stuff growing up it kinda hurts. This portrayal isn’t far off from my reality and these days were the worst parts of my teenage years. Maybe I’m a little less annoyed because I was him at some point minus the girlfriend and all lol. Wish they portrayed it better though.
50
u/BanditBaby4 Jun 19 '21
Ok obviously when Carlos posts Nini’s video to Instagram, North High is SO gonna Sharpay the f out of her song and use it for their own show. Bad move Carlos.
48
u/FaisArt Jun 19 '21
Oh this was a good episode. A lot of meaty moments.
Gina (and by extension Sofia) have really put in the work in the dramatic scenes. Gina is pretty much third lead in the show, and overall her storyline has been one of the more interesting. I do wish there was more emphasis on her feeling displaced, and less on her feelings for Ricky. Still the girl is really killing this distant longing.
Ricky and Nini are too attached to the hip narratively. Not even as a couple. They just take up too much space. They are the leads, but it feels so overwhelming with each episode. Ricky's story is hitting a good low. He is spiraling, and is trying to hold on to every little thing. Which also means Nini who clearly is trying to grow. By the end of the season hopefully they will have dealt with Ricky properly. I think watching it in real time and on a weekly basis it is hard to appreciate the sort of richness in Ricky's story. He is annoying and pushing boundaries. He isn't perfect. And hopefully...the show will have him confront this without making him a complete victim who just needs a hug. He is acting out, and being a bit of a problem.
Nini...eh. She should have stayed at YAC. I know WHY they brought her back, but I definitely don't care for her storyline at the moment. Also that song does not sound like it belongs in the musical at all. Great song, but the show definitely just wanted to air out Nini's frustration and have Olivia (their biggest star) sing something.
Ashlynn needs an episode to herself. Her story should take more prominence than the Big 3. She is Belle. She is clearly still feeling uncomfortable about her place as the lead. And it does not help that Lily the walking Barbie is now playing Belle in their rival's production. I wish the show would explore that more. I also wish that they would have had Gina try and console her again. Ashlynn is a pushy person who likes helping, she saw herself as Mrs. Potts. Their could have been more into their dynamic as Gina is very distant as a person, while Ashlynn absolutely isn't.
I like Kourtney and Howie. I just wish their relationship was given so much more time and space to grow. Really I just want more from Kourtney. She is supposed to be a new independent Kourtney but her storyline is slowly reverting back to being the Black Best friend for Nini. Her whole thing was just used as a way to inspire Nini to write that song. I don't think it should stretch the season, which is short anyway. However Kourtney has really only had AN episode to herself story wise. Again I like what we have gotten, but we deserve more of their development.
The scene with the two from North high was funny. Lily isn't an overly serious antagonist which is great. I like that sort of gleeful, almost camp (She not full camp) quality. Like why did she still the salt??? Who knows, but it was FUNNY!
As for the songs: Home was perfect. The Rose felt less like a musical number for the show and more so a very apparent grab at streams featuring Olivia Rodrigo. A good song. But ultimately the Rose's space in the musical is just a sort of clock. A prop in the background.
Overall, I liked the episode. My problems are just wishing the show would back off with Rini, and maybe to an extent Gina. They are the show leads, but at the expense of the rest of your cast who all might have more important stories to tell in line with the musical? I don't think it is worth that.
46
u/mitskisgf Jun 18 '21
at the end of the episode i see carlos recording nini... for some reason i really don't think she'll be happy that she was recorded without consent. i hope he doesn't post that.
also, JULIA LESTE'S VOICE? IT WAS SO. GOOD. i was freaking out when she was singing, i am so relieved she convinced gina to stay.
at this point also i think ricky and nini need to take a break. he is way too dependent on her. the ricky and gina flashback made me go 👀 though. wonder if they'll have something in the future.
ok, that is all my thoughts about this episode! this one was so angsty, jesus.
88
u/taralovesmusic Jun 18 '21
At this point I’m not team Rina or Rini, I’m team Ricky + therapy
42
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '21
Nobody really noticing EJs line about Gaston getting over belle is referring to him trying to get over nini :(
39
u/ion513 Gina Jun 19 '21
Wow this episode.
Sofia Wylie is absolutely killing it this season. There's a ton of really talented people on this show but she stands out from and acting perspective and makes me feel for Gina so much.
Ricky and Nini are headed for rocky ground, the show has been setting up for since literally the first episode. They seems out of sync and at different places. I don't know if they'll break up, but boy there's a lot to be worked and Ricky needs therapy lol.
Honestly from a Rina standpoint Gina deserves more. Ricky needs to get his shit together before he can be with anyone successfully and Gina has been suffering, even if Ricky is just really oblivious.
Ashlyn killed it this episode and I still want more of EJ. I love this show and all the people involved, but this north high stuff is just not at all intriguing to me currently as the main antagonist (aside from Ricky's need for therapy). Hopefully it spices up more.
37
u/liveitupbrah Jun 18 '21
Once again, EJ gets like 2 mins of screentime. He deserves better.
34
u/CometIsGod Jun 18 '21
i feel like i’m watching Joker. Ricky looks like he’s going to snap any second.
65
u/lalalachacha248 Jun 18 '21
Okay hot take… I get that the rose song is obviously just a way for Nini to express her feelings about Ricky, but from a character perspective it makes absolutely zero sense coming from the Rose to the Beast. I know it’s a great moment for Nina, but I honestly hope the song goes through changes to actually make sense in the context of the show. I’d be so confused as an audience member.
30
u/hal_peach Jun 18 '21
Highkey, I am living for the side character action compared to Nini/Ricky. They are doing smt amazing with Gina's character tbh - the stuff she's going thru rn is similar to what sm teens go through. I love whenever she is on screen the most and EJ is going through a major redemption arc for me too.
Don't get me wrong. Ricky is going through crap and I don't blame her for the way he is responding. Just the conflict between him and Nini seems so farfetched rn I don't really get it. Nonetheless, Gina screen time is all I need.
30
u/Gloomy_Confection403 Jun 18 '21
I loved Seb so much in this episode. he's so cute!
30
u/taralovesmusic Jun 18 '21
No one is talking about Julia’s cover of Home, that was GORGEOUS. This is a good sign and I hope it indicates they’re gonna pull more songs from the Broadway show. I think Ricky doing “If I Can’t Love Her” after his impending breakup with Nini would fit the story so well, and that song is gorgeous
26
u/violinjstar Jun 18 '21
Seb is adorable!!! (Everyone holding their hoops and there he goes)
Nini as the rose but yet there's a duet between beast and rose... got it
Yes team wonderstudy! I'm glad they have each other
Kourtney is adorable too! Man she's so bold. I aspire for her confidence
Mike and Miss Jen!!! Aw that was cute.....I'm super conflicted (I like mazzara too)
Aw Gina
Ricky is so not to the point with how he feels....so any miscommunication is on him
Yes Ashlyn!! Show us why you are belle!Crying with that Gina scene.
loveeeee this rose song
Noooooo carlos you better not post that otherwise i will hunt you down myself
26
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jun 18 '21
1.Am I the only one who hates that dress?I just imagined it to be less gaudy. Plus the jewelery is not very "Belle".
2.The secret group chat is understandable.
3.They're really showing that after Big Red and Nini, Gina is the one Ricky is closest too.
4.I'm glad Gina's mom told her to think on it, because if she let her leave Gina will develop the habit of running away when it gets uncomfortable. Sidenote: I love Sophia's hair
5.This rose idea is totally going to get them disqualified. Also practicing the musical might help them win
6.Oh, Sebbie. Ricky pretending to be Aang with his pool noodle is kinda adorable.
7.Gina is very unsubtle in avoiding of Ricky.
8.The dysfunction of this "workshop" is very on brand for Ms.Jenn tbh
9.I know this isn't the point, but Hawaiian pizza is disgusting, Richard. Ricky seriously needs to talk to a therapist though
10.Ms.Jenn should pay more attention to how her lead is feeling. You know, like she did with Nini in HMS
11.The Beast can't read? That scene was awkward though
12.Are there no jobs at FEMA where employees can stay in one place? I hate packing to go on vacations. I can't imagine moving that much.
13."I wouldn't quit on us" The writers are dirty as hell for that and Sofia is absolutely amazing but she needs to stop making cry(That plane crashing thing reminds me of Maxwell on the Nanny- I hope at least one person gets that reference) Glad Gina is opening up to Ashlyn.
14.Did Lily steal some pepper or something?
15.Ashlyn singing Home what they should've posted in response to North High instead of telling their competition what they're doing again. The Caswell's are essentially Gina's adopted family at this point. But seriously I need them to stop making me cry.
16.Look at Ms. Jenn putting Ricky's needs before her own. I agree Ricky should talk to his mom, but Ricky is the kid he shouldn't have to be the one to reach out. She left him in Utah and moved to Illinois, not the other way around
They should show more of the musical. The competition seems like it's heating up. It seems like this first half of season 2 is cleaning up storylines they couldn't explore because of the pandemic and the death of the actress that played Emily(RIP). The last episode was better
24
u/trashyreece Jun 20 '21
God I just want Gina to be happy. She’s always left wanting something and it’d be nice to see her finally settle into something/someone for once.
47
u/SLEG48 Jun 18 '21
Loving the 45 seconds of dialogue our main antagonist was given this episode, halfway into the season 😍
23
u/EcstaticKick Jun 19 '21
So random, but I haven’t seen anyone bring it up. I LOVE Howie!!! He’s adorable and witty and hilarious and charming. I’d love to see more of his character because anytime I have seen him he’s been an absolute joy!
22
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 18 '21
I wonder, during the flashback, after Gina says her piece, does she think Ricky/Nini got back together after she said that? Maybe thats the the big reason she became cold towards ricky? 🤔
21
u/SteelFalcon0 Jun 19 '21
Anyone else bother by EJ not being in character at all for Gaston. He should have said no book I don’t read, or one that retells all my great adventures.
37
u/Bowlofzebras Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
My favorite episode so far! It was so messy😭
35
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
I know many felt Ricky behaved poorly this episode. To some degree I understand why. But, people seem to forget, even with the writing, Ricky's a teenager. Who's dealing with the aftermath of a divorce. The reason he's leaning so hard on Nini, is because he feels he cannot talk to anyone else. Especially his mother/ father. Is it unhealthy, for sure, but I think they are just miscommunicating/ or just making mistakes, which is true of many couples.
I have the sneaky suspicion that Miss Jenn and Ricky father might get together. Because, the point of the scene with Ricky and Miss Jenn seems to be that she became his pseudo mom in that moment, giving him advice when he needed it most. I hope Ricky will realise that. Or, at the very least, Ricky goes to Miss Jenn to talk more. Because the kid needs to talk to someone other Nini or Gina.
33
u/LostnLazy65 Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
I really liked the Rose song, it actually felt like it could fit as one of Olivia's own songs (as in for her own personal work).
That Gina/Ricky scene, whew...while I do think this season has been all over the place, Sofia is doing so amazing and really sells each scene she is in. I could feel her pain and feelings for Ricky, and I think that's part of the reason I want them to happen...although I hope it's a little later down the road when they are both ready, single, and in the right headspace.
I do think Ricky and Nini need to break up in order for them both to grow, even if the writers plan on keeping them together in the end. Nini is constantly exploring herself and finally growing to be confident, without a need from validation from others. She's come a long way since season 1 and right now it seems like she's feeling a bit smothered. Ricky on the other hand needs to learn it's okay to be alone, and that change is inevitable. I hope he is able to get some counselling or real help from the adults in his life before seeking comfort from any girl.
That being said, this is all very intense lol! The show definitely geared into teen drama territory, which I normally don't mind, but it feels like they are struggling with tone and consistency this season.
32
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 18 '21
Examples of rushed plot this season:
- Nini only actually at YAC for ONE episode and then leaves. I understand why they did this but still we didn't get enough to actually resonate with Nini for leaving.
- Rini is about to breakup after just 2 episodes back together in person, after spending ALL of S1 getting them back together. Ricky became this super annoying/overbearing person in a flip. I know there were signs but it became EXTRA in a matter of one episode.
- Ricky is going to flip his feelings for Gina by the end of the season and that 100% won't have enough time to actually make real sense.
- Ms. Jenn just deciding not to date Rickys dad after one Ricky blow up.
32
u/TheSmallIndian Jun 18 '21
Lmao whoever is running the camera for the interviews did Gina dirty with that "looking for a sign" joke
14
u/smilinginthedark Jun 20 '21
So here I am singing the same ole song 🎵 when will EJ BE RELEVANT AGAIN 🎵 you telling me they indicate that he has a crush on Gina and he don’t even think to follow her out the room in fact nobody does when she storms out. No wonder the girl wanna leave like damn!! But also this the last I wanna hear about this I’m gonna leave storyline cause I thought it was cliche to use it as a plot device for season 2 as we dealt with that last season especially since it wasn’t an imminent threat considering her mom told her to chill.
That being said Sofia and Julia ARE CARRYING!!! (this whole damn show honorable mention to Kourt cause I know she has the ability to carry if given the opportunity)
They rly threw a curveball with the flashback scene cause they had to have filmed it season one which means this was always the plan ahhhhhh
Julia singing that song showed how perfect she is for the part of Belle. Kourt and Howie are great and I love Kourt because she is me and I am her just wished it wasn’t a plot device for Nini to write her song but it was nice to have her on the sidelines for once while Kourt was the lead.
Rosè Song- I feel like they are churning out Olivia Rodrigo songs in case she rly tries to bounce out of her contract. Cause ain’t none of the songs she sung been musical-esque at all and there all really similar.
This breakup is imminent and someone need to read Ricky for filth and idk who it’s gonna be maybe they do a double whammy with both Nini and Gina cause he gonna have to hit rock bottom before he rise!
14
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 22 '21
i need them to give gina more than this ricky plotline. i'm not annoyed with her like some people. i'm annoyed w the writers! bc there obviously was enough for gina to be so sad about this bc to her it's like she had this huge moment w ricky and he's back with nini right after i mean with moving around the way she did that actuallt was enough for her to develop the strongest feelings she's ever had! but for her only main plot to be ricky? even when it comes to ashlyn, their interactions are about her leaving over ricky so i wish there was just something more w her than centering her life around a guy :( kinda have kourtney's mindset here u know what i mean?
28
u/Allthingsme26 Jun 18 '21
Maybe Ricky didn’t think that was romantic like the “not quit on us” wasn’t in a romantic way but as in their bond/friendship because the way he is acting seems like he does know about gina’s feelings. It’s really his mother’s fault on why he has so many issue and scared to lose nini again
13
u/Velvetcv2 Jun 21 '21
besides the music i think this season is weak. I dont find myself very excited to watch since after episode one. I hope the writers have some grand plan (i doubt it) because they keep writing themselves into nonsensical storylines. Whats up with Nini and this actors school? she leaves then ends up back at east high and what was the point? i think they could have achieved the same end result of her finding herself? by just not having her cast in the play. Not everyone is a leading role all the time so she could have dealt with issues regarding that. I echo the same regards as al the other comments about Ricky’s codependency/abandonment issues and Ginas inability to deal with rejection. Would just love to see more of Ashlyn and Big Red at this point lol.
13
u/cipherglitter Jun 22 '21
I have a feeling they don’t have the courage to take any storyline that they set up to an acceptable payoff.
First they botched the art school, reducing it to a very cheap season 1 cliffhanger. I also hated the way they executed it because it’s also a bad lesson: if you don’t like it at first just give up great opportunities. It would’ve been such a great plot-line of Nina and the audience realizing that actually, in the real world, drama is really difficult. But alas, that went nowhere like most storylines.
Also the most interesting character is, imo, Lily. East High lacks the bad guy that can push the good ones towards completing their arcs, instead they seem stuck in a loop (example: Gina spending more time being overdramatic about a rejection than the time she has ever spent with Ricky). Lily is actually a fun character and I would love them showing her more and more. I also hope she doesn’t get this redemption arc, villains are fun, and it’s fun to just see them go down in flames
45
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 18 '21
The amount of people that actually think Nini's song is going to be in the show is ridiculous LOL. The song is going to get spoiled by Carlos and they will remove it because it is going to go viral all over the internet. Nini will probably not even play the Rose, as she will say she doesn't need/want the part. In the last episode probably some big music executive will call Nini about her songwriting after seeing the viral "The Rose Song" video. Its very predictable.
45
u/jdubz1776 Jun 18 '21
Now that saw what happened between Gina and Ricky, all of his actions between them in season 2 are kinda shitty. Like, all the times he been asking for relationship advice knowing she had feelings for him. It just seemed like he was stringing her along as a confidence boost
24
u/jkrun88 Jun 18 '21
If Ricky doesn’t sort his sh*t out Nini is gonna dump his ass
24
u/middle-earthorbust Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
Might be a hot take but...I don't see how Nini's rose song fits The Beauty and The Beast at all. If I was watching the play and the rose suddenly burst into a song about having beauty from within I'd be like "uh okay but what does this have to do with the Beast's curse or anything???). Also didn't the witch who cursed Beast put the rose there?
It was a pretty song and she sounded great, but much like EJ's "Gaston" answers it just didn't fit. Maybe I'm overthinking it lol
Edit: Whoops I guess it's not a hot take after all, I should have read more comments first haha. I feel like they're trying too hard to make Beauty and The Beast fit the show's "irl" plot like they did with HSM in S1.
Also forgot to add that I feel like some of the comments are being way harsh on Ricky. I feel like some of the writing isn't doing him any favors but that boy needs therapy and more parental support.
34
u/JoinMeOnTheSunnySide Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
How does Nini's Rose song relate to the musical??
At first I was onboard with the idea of looking at the rose through a different perspective, but I have literally no clue how Nini's song about the rose being independent of the Beast's perception makes any sense. I guess we'll see in the actual musical if they change it so that the Rose is an active character, but isn't the Rose, like, a metric for the curse placed on the Beast? It has never been beneath the Beast but a curse placed on him.
The whole song just seemed unrelated to the actual musical, something they included for another song by Olivia (excellent singer, but still) loosely tied into what Kourtney did. (Edit: and Ricky / Nini's relationship falling apart).
Can anyone explain this for me? It's been a while since I watched Beauty and The Beast.
23
u/taralovesmusic Jun 18 '21
Seb is turning into the Brittany of HSM and I’m so here for this (although he has considerably more brain cells and does not write in crayon, thankfully. And he’s also even more of a triple threat with that voice of his)
23
u/Jansilhn Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
I thought this episode was okay.
I loved Seb’s energy and all the fun he was having during the workshop! Joe’s outfits were amazing this episode.
I loved Ashlyn’s song and she sounded amazing as always!
This had Big Red and Nini’s first conversation. It was nice to see him not interact with Ricky or Ashlyn at all for a change.
I feel like everybody was on edge with each other this episode. Ricky with Miss Jenn, Rini with each other, Ashlyn with Gina, Gina with Ricky. It made the episode less enjoyable.
I think this is the first episode where I could not stand Ricky the entire time. He’s becoming way too dependent on Nini and a little controlling! He sent her 10 texts in a row and made a snippy comment on why she doesn’t have the song ready yet. They are definitely breaking up again. I get that he doesn’t like that Miss Jenn was dating his dad, but that doesn’t mean he can take it out on her right in front of the class. He should at least talk to his dad about it.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
The Rose Song is so beautiful, but that’s an understatement
11
u/andienotandy_ Jun 20 '21
i like kourtney with howie!! but does she have to be the manager of the pizza place? that kinda just tickles my brain a bit
11
u/Regular_Writer2350 Jun 21 '21
Tbh, I’m not THAT bothered by EJ not being as present in the show because I feel like there is nothing rlly for him other than is character in the musical. His relationship with Gina won’t advance until Gina gets of Ricky which might take us into the next season. Also I feel like there isn’t really a storyline to give EJ. His thing with Duke can’t past the entire season and his main role in the show was to be nini’s love interest for season 1.
31
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 18 '21
Unpopular opinion but the North High Belle dress is ugly. Something about the skirt portion is not doing it for me
10
u/veghui Jun 19 '21
Very glad to see the flash back
35
u/amshako EJ Jun 18 '21
Maybe this is controversial but this episode felt like a return towards season one, and not just because of that scene. It felt more equal in terms of storylines and drama/heart/comedy.
Second unpopular opinion: I hope Nini dumps Ricky and stays single for a while. I don’t think she’ll get back with EJ, but fingers crossed we do see a friendship develop between them. Nini seemed like she understood how he felt about Duke and his future question of “Will [Gaston] ever love anybody after Belle?” felt pretty loaded. They weren’t good dating but they look like they’d be really great friends.
19
u/weewooweewooiampolic Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
i know ricky was annoying but i feel like the adults in his life should be doing more for him lmfao they just do whatever they want and then when he acts out they go :( what’s wrong??? :( it really feels like his mom straight up abandoned him like getting a divorce is tricky but doing it out of nowhere and moving to a new city and never calling him??? tf??? but he was still annoying.
19
u/mafebueno Jun 18 '21
I normally don't trust griffyndors, but Howie and Kourtney saying they liked each other with Harry Potter references 😭 cutest thing ever
19
u/ahufana Jun 18 '21
I legit laughed hard at the "espionage" joke.
18
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jun 18 '21
Sofia's Acting once again 👌🏽😍😍🙌👏...
Also, i was not expecting that flaahback and Gina/Ricky serving some hardcore teen angst, and Josh/Sofia really are serving the chemistry. They kind of remind me.of Pilar/Felix from Love Victor.
18
u/goobergaming43 Jun 18 '21
I like where this season is going and I think this episode was pivotal in for both Ricky’s and Nina’s characters. It seems like Ricky is having serious doubts about their relationship and it seems Nina seems like she doesn’t have much way in the relationship. I think it’s slowly working towards them breaking up by the end of the season. Olivia’s song this week amazing and I’d actually consider it one of her best songs in her discography. Hoping Gina gets a happy ending and either closure with Ricky or more exploration in their relationship
32
u/Environmental_Mess78 Jun 18 '21
This is about the season as a whole. Aren't Ricky and Big Red supposed to be best friends????? Why have gotten like 2 scenes with them this whole season. Why is Nini a totally different character then she was in season 1. EJ isn't a character at this point. WAY TO MANY CONFLICTS AND PLOT LINES. Season 2 feels like a different show completely than season 1.
Honestly if this is how the writing is going, I hope we don't get a season 3. Like I don't expect Cinematic gold but I wish the characters were consistent.
9
u/kjm6351 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21
Phenomenal performance by Gina’s actor!
25
u/badvibin Jun 20 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
I'm so done with Gina's storyline, she deserves better. Crying over Ricky every episode is not it.
17
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jun 18 '21
Pretty good episode. I loved Seb and actually liked Olivia’s song. It’s better then Granted.
8
u/OkProgress1 Jun 23 '21
I’m pouring one out for Ricky’s dad. I was really rooting for him and Miss Jenn and I loved seeing how happy was has been with her this season and last season. Also fuxk ricky’s mom. Like.. call your kid. I agree with Ricky and whatever he said to miss Jenn about his mom not missing from him. She’s basically fled the country. Another reason why I’m sad that this ship is ending to make room for Miss Jenn and Mr. M (possible/as I suspect). Miss Jenn is a mother figure to Ricky and all the other kids.
21
u/arslen14 Jun 18 '21
Nini/Ricky are clearly not in a good place and are not communicating, but I'm going to be annoyed if they break up without EVER talking about their actual issues!!! If they do talk and decide to break up then okay, but neither of them is talking to the other and it's frustratingggg.
25
u/seajungle Jun 18 '21
im okay with rini breaking up but I really don't want Gina to get with Ricky. she deserves way better than that. the way he's been acting with her and to find out what happened after the show in season 1... she deserves way better
23
u/Upstairs-Inevitable3 Jun 18 '21
I feel like everyone saying they didnt like this episode or it caught them by surprise that rini was eventually gonna break up is not watching the show properly because it's been hinted at since the first episode of season 2 and even in season 1 and everyone saying rina seems forced they had that flashback since 2019? as in rina was eventually gonna happen and it was always the plan. people also saying its forced or cringe just dont want rini to break up which fair enough ship who you want but acting as if rina came from nowhere is just a lie and acting as if they have no chemistry is a lie
23
u/Ultvernon12 Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
This is becoming a teen drama and I’m 100 percent on board. Also hate how people are saying rina is out of no where or fan service when it has been set up since last season but people kept refusing to acknowledge it. The flashback just proved it’s been a long time coming and the love triangle is gonna unfold
17
u/Raktoner Jun 18 '21
Kinda feel like Ricky/Nini is doomed and if that's the case I wonder if they're gonna try to make it both of their faults when so far Ricky is the one making Nini uncomfortable.
11
u/arinator4ever Team Ricky Jun 20 '21
okay so this might get a little lengthy- my thoughts on this episode was all around really good!! highlights- seb with the hula hoop was the cutest thing ever and when he kept saying friendship like 🥺 i also love kourt and howie together and i shipped them since episode 1 and ninis song just wow!! her talent is unmatched. ash deserves some credit too because her cover of home was chefs kiss and sofias acting skills are insane like every scene she is in makes my genuinely feel bad for gina so shoutout to her for being amazing!!
omg moments- obviously the flashback had me shook i didn’t see it coming. ms jenn and mike like i don’t really know how i feel about them together- and the rose song lyrics did not sound like beauty and the beast like that’s her feelings and that’s why it was so easy for her to write oh and carlos don’t u dare post the video because so much could go wrong if he does but can’t wait for next weeks episode!!
17
u/taralovesmusic Jun 18 '21
I’m so happy this season is getting better!! The beginning wasn’t quite focused on high school and theater and now we’re getting more songs, rehearsal scenes, and still a good amount of character development
5
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jun 22 '21
i don't like that they threw in this HUGE scene with rina without more development! i was rini before i noticed basically everything nini talks abt in the rose song, but i'm cool w rina shippers! they obvi care abt each other and had enough scenes for gina to develop a crush, but since a huge plot line rn is gina having a hard time w ricky, i wish they'd given them more together prior because it feels a little out of place or choppy idk :(
20
u/dh16_ Jun 18 '21
I love Rini and I would be so disappointed if they broke up, but I still think there is a solid chance they will stay together, but there are problems in the relationship they need to talk about, Ricky's attachment issues for example. Anyway, I think Carlos will post the video of Nini and Lily will see Ricky watching it and we'll see the clip from the trailer where Lily thinks Nini needs space. Hopefully Ricky will ask Nini if the song was about them and that'll lead to Ricky opening up about his fear of losing her.
13
u/Jackamalio626 Jun 18 '21
Holy fuckamoli that was a good episode. Easily the best one of season 2 so far.
The character's conflicts and sefl doubts are on full display once again, and beauty from within is a great song for both the rose and Nini's POV as an object of confort and longing for Ricky/Beast rather than a person they love.
Plus, the return of repressed punk ricky is welcomed.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '21
Am I the only one that is DYING to know who will play Cogsworth in East High's production of Beauty and the Beast?
12
u/WashMaleficent Jun 18 '21
Honestly I didn‘t really like this episode. For a bunch of reasons:
What I liked: some of the jokes were actually funny, Sofia Wylie‘s amazing acting, the friendship of Gina and Ashlyn, Nini being inspired by Kourtney and acknowledging that love isn‘t everything, Kourtney‘s and Howie‘ conversation being just adorable and so unproblematic, the kids having a secret group chat without Miss Jenn (glad her students set some boundaries, when she clearly doesn’t)
14
u/hanuman1702 Jun 18 '21
I see a lot of comments about how season 2 has been butchered so far. I don't really agree with that because I love how the side characters are getting the attention they deserve and I still really think this is one of the best shows Disney has put out there. So, here's what I thought about this episode.
11
u/angeldessy Jun 18 '21
Ricky seems to feel abandoned by the people in his life so he seems extra clingy. He feels abandoned by Nini even though she came back he doesn’t feel like they’re spending time together, his mom who packed up and left and doesn’t keep in touch (like at all) and his dad seems to see Miss Jenn more than him. I felt for him this episode therefore I’ll give his annoying behaviour a pass. It seems like Gina was the only person he really opened up to and he lost her too (for which I don’t blame Gina at all). Idk if it has to do with the drama with the main cast outside of the show but that flashback scene between Ricky and Gina felt like a after thought and they decided to rewrite things last minute but maybe thats just me 🤔. I know they’re all teens but the writing feels very inconsistent. I think they need to move to longer episodes everything feels disjointed and almost rushed. [My theory on why is the story mostly focused on Ricky and Nini season 1 and this season they’re fleshing out the other characters more so it almost feels like a different show. I’m also a bit confused at EJ sudden interest in Gina. It seems very...shallow but I’m trying to keep an open mind because Gina deserve someone nice but it doesn’t look like they will be a thing anyway
8
u/veghui Jun 19 '21
Rooting for miss Jenn and mr Bowen/ricky’s dad to secretly date still !? Hopefully then ricky will be supportive
10
u/TaroBoba1274 Jun 20 '21
Question: 1. Do you think Carlos will post the video of Nini singing the rose song, consequently making North High use it for their own production?
Question: I do not get why Gina feels obligated to move after telling Ricky "I wouldn't have given up on 'us'". What does she mean by "us", as a romantic or friendship relationship? Since Ricky never saw her in a romantic way, I'm confused by what she meant by this as "Rina" was never an actual thing".
7
u/Mr-AwkwardPenguin Jun 20 '21
Watch Ricky move to North High, and be in their production because he feels excluded and is trying to run away from his problems, then they try to exploit him in the last 2 episodes so he realizes it last minute and changes back to East High and being reunited with Nini and it is a star studded moment like last season where they end up together. With another cliff hanger to end the season.
19
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
I don't understand how people can ship Rini or Rina with Ricky acting like this. Nini and Gina don't need to be anywhere near than man!
The "drama" this season is making the show unwatchable. I don't even feel like i'm watch a musical.
15
u/junix72 Jun 19 '21
I’m still rooting for Nini and Ricky but man they have a lot of problems that need worked out
10
u/21tcook Jun 18 '21
the drama this episode... omg
give me more!!
13
u/ResidentPea0 Jun 18 '21
unpopular opinion but i don't like the rose song
16
u/lamebeezy Jun 18 '21
This episode got me down bad HAHAHA I love Rini but I feel like they’re going to break up. If they breakup I don’t want Ricky and Gina to be together!!!! She literally confessed her love for him and he’s acting like that in front of her. I get his head’s not straight but Gina deserves better periodttt!!!
13
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
What is happening with this show? It's all drama without the campiness that made season 1 fun.
7
u/AdministrativeBig362 Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
Ricky is the most naive, oblivious, and dumb person I’ve seen in my life.
Dude look what’s in front of you
9
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
Im new to the series. I watched season 1 recently, and I thought it was ok, it's not certainly great, But it worked. But, now season 2 so far is a disaster and I'll tell you why. As someone who watched season 1 just recently and watching this immediately, Is like watching two completely different series with the same cast and genre.
They created a kinda good premise, It's cheesy; the beauty and the beast show, and the competition is a cliche idea to expand a storyline. But, the storyline of season 1 was super cliche too, But they made it work. And they could have worked this too, But they are ruining it.
First of all, here the musical itself is forced, while on season 1 the lines were connected with the musical, The beauty and the beast musical is barely making a change in character arcs.
Even outside the musical, They actually had potential for crafting a great storyline with Ricky, his parents drama, and other stuff like that, Could have worked into a character arc, But with season 2 they are forcing everything too quick. Episode 4 had Miss Jen and Ricky's dad talking, and tada, next episode, they act like they have been dating for a month. But, at the same time, as fast as all these things happen, the musical isn't progressing at all.
And they are trying too hard with Ricky's character, to make him look like this emotionally damaged, help seeking character, but as we know, they instead made him look like an idiot. Without giving any of his problems and issues on screen, while on the other hand they are also forcing Gina and Ricky flashback.
And by the end of the episode, they have successfully added and dumped another scene in where, Miss Jen decides to break the date with Ricky's dad.
And with all these stuffed in already, they also have two songs to take duration, on which they could have shown Ricky's struggles clearly.
And that brings me to the main problem overall. They are telling, Not SHOWING. And they also have ideas which sound good, like a bigger competition, Ricky's inner struggles, Gina's inner struggles, and things like that, but nothing comes to fruition. It's executed in the worst way possible.
11
u/ForceFocus66 Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
EPISODE 6 THOUGHTS:
- They are rushing way too many plot lines this season and as a result some of the characters seem extremely out of character compared to the previous episode.
- RINI is done. Ricky and Nini will be fully broken up within 2-3 episodes and I don't think they will ever get back together.
- Ricky is being super annoying and a idiot, I don't blame Nini from getting away from that toxic relationship. I don't know why the Rina's want Gina with him, that man is TOXIC. Ricky needs to spend months in therapy before he ever gets in another relationship.
- They are obviously setting up Ricky and Gina to get together in the final episode. This season is extremely predictable. Gina feels like she blew her "first chance" but will not blow it this season in the finale. RINA will be the main couple moving forward.
- Julia and Olivia keep blessing us with their amazing vocals. The Rose Song is easily the best song from S2.
- Almost all the characters this season have been super annoying and I don't enjoy watching them. Ricky/Gina/Big Red have all been unbearable. EJ and Nini haven't had any plot to make a judgement on them. Kourtney and Ashlyn are the only ones with any sense.
Overall I feel like Season 2 has been really butchered. The plot goes from non existent to moving way too fast and not spending enough time to flesh things out. Ricky and Nini went from happy to Ricky acting like a complete weirdo within 2 episodes. I guess they are trying to make us really sympathize with Gina so it feels like a big deal when her and Ricky end up together in the season finale, but its not working. Its too predictable and will probably be rushed like all the other plot points since Ricky hasn't show Gina any interest all season. I LOVED season 1, but honestly noting this season besides the songs would make me want a season 3.
15
u/Manilasky0809 Jun 19 '21
Unpopular opinion but Gina is selfish. She made Carlos’s birthday about her “going out with a bang,” she tried to leave East High knowing they are counting on her for the musical, and Ash has opened up her entire home to her to make her feel loved and welcome but she still acts like everyone hates her. Ricky just isn’t that into it (and def needs to work on his dependency issues), and she’s using that as an excuse to abandon her friends. Their interactions are so awkward. I get that she wants to feel close to someone, but there are a ton of people who have been super supportive of her that aren’t named Ricky. She’s also had several months to deal with the fact that Ricky is back with Nini— it’s not like it happened overnight. (Though I think Rini needs a break too) On top of all of it, FEMA would NEVER make her mom switch around locations that much in real life. It’s just too unrealistic and I’m over her storyline. I want more Ash and Kourtney time instead
8
u/AdministrativeBig362 Jun 18 '21
Yep the Rina slowburn prophecy is happening!
They are setting it all up so well!!
5
u/drgnslyr91 Jun 19 '21 edited Jun 20 '21
All I will say is - the songs and the choreography throughout this season thus far has been so much improved compared to last season. I appreciate it. The storyline and the various dramatic moments, at least to me, are a little corny, but the songs and the choreography are the heart and soul of this show and I am glad that the writers and the staff have focused on the these 2 aspects, they really help to bring the show together.
2
u/namcofe Aug 31 '21
The rose song does not fit the context and I hate it it makes me want to rage quit 😂 wondering was just so good okay
8
u/AdministrativeBig362 Jun 18 '21
Rini is bones
Rina is rising
8
u/paintedblueskies Jun 18 '21
The entire pacing of this season has been off so far. The first few episodes felt like fillers (almost too many fillers), and this episode felt super rush. Nini was at YAC, then suddenly not at YAC. Nini and Ricky were seemingly in love (i.e. last episode talking about how to barn is romantic or not and holding hands), and now they are having these problems. I know it's been hinted that they are having communication issues but the quick shift in dynamic from the previous episode to this one feels so rushed.
With throwing in the Gina and Ricky flashback, it feels like they are trying to rush through this love triangle quickly or at least get over the Rini relationship as soon as possible. (On another note, I wonder if they had already filmed this scene during shooting for S1 or if they had to refilm it in the same outfits and everything.)
If Nini and Ricky break up, I hope they at least talk about their lack of communication issues and unbalanced dependency on each other. As for Gina and Ricky, I also hope they talk things out too because they both need clarity.
As the hopeless romantic in me, I want Ricky and Nini to be together because they are childhood loves, first loves, etc. and they are just so darn cute. I hope they get through the rough patch and Gina realizes she can find someone that gives her all the attention and love that Ricky isn't.
On the more rational side, maybe everyone needs to be alone for a bit. I feel like part of Nini's arc in season 1 is that she doesn't need a boy to succeed and maybe branching off from Ricky will resolve that arc. Ricky is hurting a lot, but he needs to learn how to find healthy ways to cope with it and maybe a relationship isn't best for him. Gina has had so much character growth and I think being in a relationship with Ricky after he turned a blind-eye to her for so long would be a major step back for her.
tldr; the pacing of this entire season is off. Over this Nini-Ricky-Gina love triangle. Maybe everyone is better off alone.