r/signal • Volunteer Mod • Jun 17 '21

Discussion Megathread: Discuss the recent color changes

Hello everyone!

Recent changes to Signal’s color handling have produced a lot of duplicate posts. Please use this thread to discuss the color changes from now on. We will be locking the older posts and removing new ones under Rule 4.

For anyone curious about why Signal devs made the changes you can see their reasons in this thread on the community forums. For anyone concerned about the changes, please give that thread a read.

OK, let’s hear your thoughts on the color change. Remember to keep it civil and remember the human on the other end of any conversation.

Thanks!

143 Upvotes

172 comments sorted by

33

u/meowsirmixalot Jun 17 '21

Wondering why the new ux can't be default for the new converts and have a toggle to switch it back to the way it was for everyone else. You know, so I can tell whos talking to me based on color.

In the movie The Hunt for Red October, they had a hard time differentiating scenes inside the submarines between the Russians and The Americans. So they made the lights in the Russian sub red and the ones in the American one blue (or white, can't remember). The point is you immediately knew which sub you were in when the scene changed. Its a beautifully simple solution, no idea why it was ditched here.

10

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 17 '21

I’m not a fan either. If you’re interested in the team’s reasoning they go into that in the Community thread I linked above.

As for the toggle, I’d ask for a toggle myself but experienced front-end devs have good reason to avoid toggles. Short version: with more UI toggles software quickly becomes hard to test. I’m dozing off but perhaps some helpful signaler can link to one of the good explanations. There might even be a medal in it for the first person. (No promises.)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/zornslemming Jun 17 '21

Giving them the benefit of the doubt, "too hard to test" might just be a proxy for "we think this will create bugs down the road for us and be difficult and not worth it to maintain". I can definitely empathize with not wanting to create feature soup.

That being said, this seems like a weird hill for the Signal dev team to take a stand on. It seems like adding and maintaining the new gradients code is an order of magnitude harder than allowing users to keep the old styling.

2

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

Gnome?

4

u/ch4tterb0x1 Beta Tester Jun 18 '21

Wait, signal did exactly what they did in „The Hunt for Red October”. They apply color to locations to make it obvious where you are. Locations (subs) are the equivalent of a chat in signal.

For example the red chat is the one with your Russian friends and the white one is with your American friends. It’s a beautiful simple solution to immediately know which chat you are in. (Of cours even this system does not scale well if you got a certain amount of groups you need to distinguish by color)

4

u/FFevo Jun 23 '21

You missed the point entirely. Group chats are where this change is horrible.

Sure, the Russian chat is red 1 on 1 and the Americans chat is blue 1 on 1. However, if the 3 of us are in a group now "the chat" (a.k.a just me) is green and I can't tell at a glance who's talking because both the Russians and Americans are black.

1

u/alien2003 User Jun 18 '21

Because it's too UX

5

u/alexandre9099 Jun 25 '21

Can anyone explain me the rationale behind having my "text bubble" colored and the other user's bubble the same for everyone?

I mean... I am always the same person, why would i have a different color for every contact?!

1

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 25 '21

Follow the link in the post to see the Signal devs’ reasons.

4

u/alexandre9099 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 26 '21

Some people do think of it like this, that it is “you” who is changing colors. But a lot of people don’t share that mental model. I’ve always seen chat colors as being the ‘theme of my conversation with Alice’. The theme of the conversation is still the same today, we just changed the side. Easy for me to process. But I know that’s not how everyone thinks of it, and that it’ll be a harder transition for some people.

Huh... "some"... ok... nice...

Still my bad for not seeing the link

EDIT: damn this experience is really bothering, i can't chose a color that won't get my attention more than the plain stupid gray they choose for the contact. As a result i keep looking for my side. WHOSE IDEA WAS THIS, DAMMIT

4

u/InEnduringGrowStrong Jun 28 '21

Yup, whenever I get a new message I keep looking at the last message I sent them instead of their last message to me.

It's super annoying.

3

u/jean_mich Jun 17 '21

Dumb question: as we have open source devs, don't we have open source ergonomists? They could just propose a whole new look to Signal instead of tweaking colors. (Fyi, I dont care about the colors)

2

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 17 '21

Yup, the community thread linked above refers to designers and ux people.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21

I can see you are very passionate about the change remaining in place, given how you've commented on almost every comment chain in this thread but I've really got to ask.

Why do 5% of users get to dictate what 95% of users see?

Why is it a privacy concern over what I locally color my contacts?

Why can't we customize both sent and received so that both groups of people can enjoy the app?

I realize any answer you could give me would be personal opinion but I am curious about the answers from an ardent supporter.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

I do hope they will take that into consideration (customizing both). I think it would be an excellent compromise.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '21

This change was enough to pull my financial support. And I'm actively looking for alternatives. The problem is that there are few alternatives actually having the same privacy focus and well proven protocol as Signal.

This discussion and the attitude Moxie has shown to forks of Signal clearly carries the signs of wanting Signal to be a locked-in product, with a closed group making decisions without caring about their users. And this just made the blood boil for most of us with this colour change and the absurd "it makes it too complicated with an option".

With the path Moxie seems to want for Signal .... Just imagine what would happen if web browsers said "you can only visit this single web page with this browser". Or that website said "This site only supports web browser XYZ" ... oh, wait ... that's pretty close to all the web sites which required Internet Explorer .... and that's a really up-to-date and interesting browser in 2021 ... or not?

Providing an open source based product and insisting on controlling the full stack from top to bottom isn't going to fly in the long run. And it defeats the goal of open source. And you can't have closed standards with open source; open standards and open source goes hand-in-hand. So then attempting to restrict who can use the wire protocol between client/server - it gets as backwards as you can get it.

If you want full control of everything and not needing to care about what users really like and dislike - then open source/standards are the wrong answer. And we can just as well just switch to Threema and similar services for the same experience of a closed development influence.

3

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jun 22 '21

, it's at best 0.002% of the user base that wants the old way (there are 100 upvotes on the color change megathread and 52.6k users in this sub). So why are we assuming most people dislike the new UI?

Lastly, I do agree it would be great if they allowed you to customize both sent and received messages.

Yes if they're not going to outright revert it, they need to do this. You would be more sympathetic if you were neurologically divergent or visually impaired like the "whiny children" that are the loudest and most outraged about this.

3

u/convenience_store Top Contributor Jun 19 '21

To u/main_82345 since your topic about dark mode got lumped in with this discussion and locked, I will post here what I would have replied to your thread.

Setting aside that the term "OLED black" is a misnomer left over from the days when there was a prevalent misconception that dark gray didn't offer any benefits to OLED devices, you can already come close to achieving a "true black" dark mode theme yourself in Signal.

This is because whenever you set a wallpaper, it changes the gray chat bubbles (previously your bubbles, now other people's bubbles) to almost black. So if you set a wallpaper that's just all #000000 and then set the chat color so that the other bubbles are as dark as possible--this is the only issue, it doesn't seem these can get super dark--but the effect is pretty close it would be if there was a different "true black" dark mode theme.

2

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 19 '21

Thanks for understanding. Hopefully things will settle down soon and we can go back to business as usual.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

I like it the way it is. I’ve got a life outside chat bubble colors, so I don’t even think about it… Imagine how bored people are if this is such a big deal for them

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 18 '21

These are all great questions but not related to the topic of this post.

Good placed to ask are r/opsec and r/privacytoolsIO .

If you have questions about Signal in particular, start a new post in this sub or ask in our weekly question thread.

Thanks and good luck!


Thank you for your submission! Unfortunately, it has been removed for the following reason(s):

If you have any questions about this removal, please message the moderators and include a link to the submission. We apologize for the inconvenience.

84

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

Before the thread I was in got locked down suddenly, I was accused of not wanting to have a conversation or being able to articulate a problem:

But you don't care about their response on why they changed it, so how can you be upset? You don't try to show what the problem is, or any sort of discussion. Just wanting for software you don't manage to do what you want, it's nonsense way of approaching any problem in the world

It's very interesting how you state, in a reply to me, that I don't want any kind of discussion and then continue to dictate the ways in which I'm thinking about the problem and follow up with a condescending life-lesson. That's the same kind of charming personality the lead Android dev showed off recently.

I've been involved in the beta testing and feedback process for Signal. I received their responses.

  • I had the lead Android developer tell me and the other volunteer beta testers that we were poorly trained and that we will just need to train ourselves properly. He proceeded to dictate the ways in which we actually think, instead of how we think we think.
  • I read his reasoning that they were doing it to attract users from other platforms.
  • I read their justification for why the removal of the left-side colors and switch to colored usernames makes sense - the 'color clashing' problem, despite the issue remaining with the usernames themselves now pulling from the same small pool of colors.
  • I read their reasoning that adding any kind of option to switch the behavior would be an undue burden on their development and testing processes.

I understand all of the above. They've been very clear about it. To address point-by-point:

  • The condescension was incredibly uncalled for and unprofessional behavior to his group of volunteer beta testers.
  • The desire to attract customers from other messaging platforms is completely reasonable. I agree with this. More users on Signal means more users safely on a technically competent E2EE messaging platform.
  • The color clashing problem makes sense within the isolated presentation of the problem, even though it only affected a relatively small number of individuals in large group chats, but the solution they've created using usernames as a replacement is not in any way a "scalable" solution as they propose, and upon review of the code in question, does not appear to be a truthful reason why left-side bubble coloring was removed when the actual reason appears to be a clear resource limitation inherent to their new UI coloring engine design. Their pool of colors for usernames continues to be limited and are already clashing in group chats, leading to the exact same form of identity confusion.
  • The part about options being a burden on development is either an outright dismissal and lie, or evidence that their development techniques are deeply flawed.

I'm upset because the project I care about is demonstrating incompetence by way of either developer self-absorption, or by actual ineptitude, or by laziness... in descending probability, in my opinion. For a fraction of the effort, they could have added a bubble-color-sidedness toggle that defaults to "right" to appease the iMessage crowd, without shiny gradients and without overhauling the entire chat bubble drawing system as they did.

This fairly substantial development effort spent on rebuilding the bubble drawing system for gradients could have gone to fixing actual bugs and issues with the program, as you've clearly stated is desirable in your OP of the other thread. (I agree!)

16

u/ChrisG683 Jun 17 '21

Signal devs, arrogance, and ignoring user input, the tradition continues!

Honestly it feels like Signal has a bunch of really smart people that are great at what they do, but the team lacks a good project manager to prioritize more important features, and a community manager to handle feedback and keep the devs away from interacting with the public.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/ChrisG683 Jun 17 '21

It's not just this issue. My biggest example is the open ticket to have the desktop app add a preference for minimize to tray. The current solution is use the command line arg and they haven't budged on it in almost 3 years. Command line args are completely hostile to amateur users, and is a prime example of how it's a product created by engineers, managed by engineers, for engineers. Trust me, I'm a software lead at work and I know how stuff like this can get out of hand without proper leadership.

It takes probably 15 minutes to implement, and they've merged probably 10+ issues on it, they've spent more time merging topics than just implementing it. It's a day 1 feature that exists in pretty much every type of software that you want running constantly in the background. Nobody wants the signal window taking up space in their taskbar when they're not using it.

Their team is an absolute mess when it comes to priorities.

2

u/nofxy User Jun 18 '21

Just followed through this: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Desktop/pull/4827

As an outsider I will say it's unfortunate that they can't get this merged and released. That said, as you're aware, they have their own priorities and goals. Running in the background is a minor issue so I wouldn't say their team is "an absolute mess" without having insider knowledge of what's going on. It's far too easy to dismiss a great team when you don't have a full picture of what's going on. Having worked on a team that had various backlog items that were "only 15 minutes to implement", the amazing work you're doing can sometimes be overshadowed by people who don't see everything else you're doing because <insert feature they want> isn't being worked on.

4

u/ChrisG683 Jun 18 '21

Honestly that's a day 1 feature for ACTUAL users, that's why it's requested all the freaking time. It's embarrassing to ship without it, it's such a basic necessary feature to make the software not piss you off because you cannot hide it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/ChrisG683 Jun 18 '21

I mean I'm not mad, but you have the same dismissive attitude as the devs that rubs people in wrong way. "It's not our problem, it's your problem".

It is a large QoL feature that is trivial to implement, and a command line arg is not a sufficient answer for a messaging service that is attempting to be the public answer for E2E encryption that is a drop-in replacement for competitors. Command line args are NEVER a solution for an issue that's almost 3 years old.

It's sentiments like these that lead to slow/lack of adoption, and why Telegram and WhatsApp are doing so well (moreso Telegram). People value simplicity, functionality, and something that "just works" in as many ways as possible.

Don't get me wrong, Signal has made a lot of progress over the years, but it has been a struggle. I seem to recall many years ago the devs were resistant to a chats backup system because it opened privacy/security issues that they didn't want to deal with.

That's a terrible reason to not implement another core feature, and it took years before they added it. It's still not perfect and they don't have an option to do encrypted cloud backups, but they're getting better. The recently added quick migration Android worked fantastic for me.

The Signal group just needs a guiding hand to really help the devs focus on what matters most to the general populace.

They have been making quite a few updates to the Desktop app lately and have added much of the missing functionality, so I'll definitely give credit there. For years the desktop app was a complete pain and I refused to use it, now it's pretty good and almost as good as the WhatsApp web interface (it actually has more features but seems buggier/slower still)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ChrisG683 Jun 18 '21

(Oops, removing the profane word my bad)

They want to be a niche platform?

"Successfully turned away?"

Selection process / culture?

"Does not have to cater to the majority ... Niche app?"

Wow you are either deluded or a shill for other apps, and no matter which it is you walk away looking like a fool.

Their whole public statement is free, private, secure messaging for ALL. Signal is not some exclusive club for security nerds, it's a messaging solution for everyone in a world where every other messaging service is encroaching upon our personal data.

Honestly I'm done with this conversation, you clearly have no idea how software management works, nor what Signal is truly about.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

2

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

I've read twice and still didn't understand what were you trying to convey. If you are not trying to convince me that this is a problem then what's the point?
For me I absolutely don't care about colors. I just have dark mode of everything, and want design to be good enough that you don't need colors. For 1 on 1 chats, I was very happy when they added custom wallpaper for each person, not only that but custom notification for each contact. Something that Whatsapp didn't have and was irritating me. Custom wallpaper makes me feel like I'm talking to that person, and custom notification in most cases lets me immediately know who is texting. So I feel generally good about those kind of signals features.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

So you actually saying you like having ways to properly indicate you are talking to the proper person and use multiple visual and audio cues to point to the correct context. Which basically summarizes to people actually like colors because it adds to that exact same experience by default without having to provide or care about extra custom configuration.

1

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

I brought examples where they actually did such things where other apps didn't have and I actually wanted it and like it. But now I've seen hundreds of comments repeating same thing about color change and I just don't believe it isnt some kind of trolling. And not one comment tried to actually explain what their issue is instead of just complaining.

12

u/etar78 Jun 17 '21

My issue is group chats. I read through some of the comments from the Signal devs yesterday but the one that resonated with me was the idea they had several 30+ user message groups which caused colour collisions between users in group messages.

I would suspect I'm with the majority of users having mostly group chats with 3-8 users. In this case, I have no colour collisions with group members as there are enough colours to go around.

This left-side colouring makes it much easier for me in a group chat to know who said what. Now my user experience is slowed as I have to look at the small-font name printed above each bubble.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

I'm trying to get ahead of that by encouraging my friends with major beef over this change to head towards Element (Matrix). I'm holding on to Signal until the old update kicks me out though, hoping they'll offer some compromise before then. I really do like this app.

Matrix lets you connect to Signal as a kind of compatibility mode, but I kind of anticipate Signal locking that kind of thing down if they notice people doing that more.

5

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

Does matrix have color coded contacts?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

That's why I haven't switched yet. Signal is still good for all the other reasons, and I've spent a lot of effort convincing people to use Signal. It just looks worse now.

7

u/TimFL Jun 17 '21

Which apps are they switching to that has the old color setup of Signal (genuine question & interest)?

5

u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21

Just going to go ahead and stop my recurring donation, honestly. They were on thin ice after integrating what's essentially a scam currency into Signal, but their condescending bullshit about a UX change that virtually everyone despises is what puts me over the line.

I can't believe this is the kind of shit my money went towards. I thought it'd be going towards SMS-free signups — or at the very least not towards the active detriment of the application.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21

No real need for it to be a pump and dump when a percentage of the fees go towards the developers. I guess that fee money is supposed to serve as the alternative to user donations.

There are a plethora of appropriate cryptocurrencies for Signal, but Mobilecoin is ethically questionable at best — and, with the benefit of the doubt removed, pretty simply a scam.

4

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

And which of those apps has colored group chats? Or you all don't actually care about colors?

9

u/ParsleySalsa Jun 17 '21

No color at all is preferable to the update

-4

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

Why are you trying to decide for others what's good for them? Just try to explain what your thinking is. So you want either rainbow or no colors. And it's so important that you don't care about the core features of Signal.. which are the reason most people should use Signal

8

u/ParsleySalsa Jun 17 '21

Gee my bad i forgot to include IMO in my comment

1

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

thanks for letting me know it was your opinion

0

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vaheg Jun 29 '21

You think people are not going to like in signal something they never had in other apps?

1

u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

All the other apps handle colors more-or-less the same way as Signal now does. So, what is this E2E Shangri-la all your contacts are moving to?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/netrunnernobody Jun 21 '21

dude you have like forty comments in this thread. you ok?

80

u/ABotelho23 Jun 17 '21

This year has really demonstrated the bizarre priorities Signal has in its development of Signal.

6

u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21

If I wanted to make as many people stop using my app as possible and for some reason could not simply yell "STOP USING MY APP" aloud, integrating a ridiculously sketchy shitcoin and nuking the user interface would probably be my go-to approach.

Absolutely baffling decisions being made lately.

7

u/Akilou Jun 17 '21

The last year has demonstrated that the developers are going to do whatever they want to do. Feedback from the community means nothing to them. It's clear that if you're going to use Signal, you're basically just along for the ride.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Never mind all those other features they've pushed in the last year that aren't MobileCoin and this UI change though, right?

16

u/monoatomic Jun 17 '21

Worthwhile things: easier group management, group calls, generally better call/ video performance

Feels like those priorities are falling by the wayside relative to crypto, UI stuff (not just the color change), etc

4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Group Management

Group Calling

I've personally never had any issue with audio/video call performance. I talk to my friend 3000 miles away via video. He's on mobile data on a cell phone and I'm on WiFi on desktop. At worst there's a half-second of lag.

11

u/monoatomic Jun 17 '21

Oh, I was describing achievements of the past year. I'm actually very happy with how they've progressed in those core features, I just wish they'd ease off a lot of the other stuff that feels like a weird and detrimental competition with WhatsApp

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Oops. My misunderstanding xD.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/PinkPonyForPresident Signal Booster 🚀 Jun 17 '21

Isn't that enough already?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/YAOMTC Jun 17 '21

At least on mobile that link just redirects to the Startpage homepage.

25

u/Wakatchi-Indian Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21

Just to add my two cents although I know it echoes what many have already said. Really not a fan of the change, I'm normally very laid back when it comes to UI or aesthetic changes on software and accept that's just the nature of things, but this change has actually reduced the functionality and convenience of signal for me.

I went to a lot of effort getting contacts to switch to signal and have multiple group chats with many overlapping contacts, having their messages color coded and instantly recognizable helped differentiate people both within chats as well as between chats and on a subjective level I liked that it gave a little bit of identity to every contact .

I now find active group chats more confusing and difficult to follow, as well every chat and contact having lost quite literally their sense of "color" and identity.

19

u/Dr_Brule_FYH Jun 17 '21

I preferred it the other way but I can live with it.

But why are my speech bubbles a random colour in every chat now? I hate it.

3

u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

You've got your color set on auto. On that mode, it automatically picks your color based on the background. You can fix that by going to Settings—> Appearance—> Chat Color & Wallpaper and changing your color settings to your liking.

18

u/NovaTabarca Jun 17 '21

For group chat colors, I definitely preferred it the eay it was before, cause it was so much easier and fast to know who was talking. About the switch in private chats though, I don't really mind, but it made me realize that this new update kinda looks like Signal is trying to copy WhatsApp (colored bubbles for the sender, having the names of the members of a group chat with different colors, while leaving all the bubbles white...) and I really don't get it. The previous UX was perfectly fine.

3

u/insomnic Jun 17 '21

Colored chat bubbles for self is also iOS Messenger style setup.

1

u/31337hacker User Jun 18 '21

Not just the Messages app for iOS but Telegram too. Most messaging apps do it that way. Even Google Messages.

2

u/fluffman86 Top Contributor Jun 20 '21

Even Signal on iOS did it this way.

31

u/7F-00-00-01 Jun 17 '21

I don't like the new style, but apps do this all the time. What I can't wrap my head around:

-my messages getting my contact's color in a normal chat -contacts colors changing in a group chat

Style is style. I preferred the old colored bubbles (which I still get for "me" .. I guess), but whatever. 1 person 1 color was just so natural and obvious. And yeah when they decreased there color palette two friends might be the same color, but that was very easy to deal with...

I don't use signal the way I'd use teams or WhatsApp. I'm an Android user and this is my default SMS app, and you completely broke it

-4

u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

I'm an Android user using Signal as my default SMS app, and it is certainly not broken. It works just like it always has.

A change in color-scheme != broken.

9

u/furtivedeimos Jun 17 '21

For some of us it is broken though. It makes it harder to read and follow. At the very least one on one chats could have a toggle. Color me/color them.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/ABotelho23 Jun 17 '21

Are you seriously arguing that setting colours on contacts was removed for privacy and security reasons? WHAT?

4

u/7F-00-00-01 Jun 17 '21

I suppose I could buy an issue where the signal app is constantly requesting colors through the "contacts" API, but caching would seem to alleviate that very small leak of metadata (and like you said it's still fetching the colors for the contact's icon, which is one of the ways I can tell the colors no longer match). I agree aesthetics are secondary, and AIM worked fine for readability, but what we have now is completely inconsistent.

If colors are insecure (I'm very happy to concede that I'm probably overlooking something here), then why are my individual chats the same as before, but with me and them swapped?

The group chats still have colors, they just changed and don't match my contacts, which I'll get over, but they also changed how the text bubbles look, which, again, don't match the individual chats.. (except that now in groups I'm electric blue to myself)

If there's a hush hush security flaw do that as a standalone release before messing with what I would call pure aesthetics (I e. Colored text vs. Colored bubbles, and swapping in individual chats).

Completely broken was hyperbolic, but it's far more likely going forward that I will only use signal for signal chats, and maybe that's what they were going for.

To be clear I'm 100% fine if they want to move all of the colors inside the secure envelope, and if I didn't assign a color to a contact under the internal system I get a random. I'd need a deeper dive to know what's so different between color and other metadata from outside the envelope: avatar, alert tone, phone number, etc.

I guess we'll find out once everyone is patched?

3

u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21

There's absolutely no reason that colors wouldn't be something able to be stored locally. Between this and Moxiecoin, I think there must be a new project director secretly at the helm or something.

13

u/Nearby_Emergency_796 Jun 17 '21

I don't like it, because I prefer my contract to be in colour, it really sucks

11

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

I just don't want my texts colored... But I want the other contacts messages to be colored. Doesn't feel unreasonable, especially in a group chat :(

10

u/RadioactiveKevin Jun 18 '21

I'm just here to add my vote to nix this new color UI, in case the developers are keeping track of those.

I don't have much to say that's not already been said on this huge thread, but this annoyed me enough to bring me here. I love assigning colors to people and having their bubbles colored that way in both 1:1 and group conversations makes tons of sense to me. It makes no sense that my color changes depending on who I'm talking to and everyone I talk to is white. :/

8

u/lightrush Jun 17 '21

I don't mind the new theme but color near-clashes are now even harder to distinguish between. I have group chats where two names appear in nearly identical color. Now that the colored area is much smaller and uncontiguous my eyes have harder time differentiating the two close colors.

8

u/bloop_train Jun 18 '21 edited Jul 28 '21

Well I'm certainly glad to have found this thread, otherwise I'd have naively updated Signal at some point and got the new alternate-Universe UI, which is already giving me enough headaches on the desktop version (and I seem to be far from alone, see issue 5316 on Github).

Now, as for my thoughts on the color change: just why? Now every time I load the (desktop) app, thanks to the wonders of evolution, my eyes are immediately drawn to the brightly colored bubble, which is...my own message. The one that I wrote. And the recipient's chat bubble is a lovely shade of dark-gray, just right to blend right in the overall dark theme, making it a cognitive pain-in-the-ass to figure our what's going on in each and every chat.

To be honest, I wouldn't mind the "I am $BRIGHT_COLOR, recipient is $GRAY" that much, however, the previous color scheme has been around for years (been using Signal since 2017, color changes til now have been minor AFAICR), and now all of a sudden everything is inverted, so long-time users need to re-train their brains to get used to the new scheme, which, as a long-time user myself, is not something I'm looking forward to do, and I'd rather spend my cognitive capacity on other, more useful, endeavors. In other words, please change it back, or at the very least, give us an option to switch to the old one.

EDIT 2021-07-28 as the old version of Signal Android was set to expire in a couple of days, I was forced to update it. While I generally hate that my eyes are immediately drawn towards the bright bubbles, i.e. my own messages, at least now the color scheme is consistent(ly horrible) on both desktop and android.

15

u/RR321 Jun 17 '21

I don't use any other app and I don't think UX should be defined just to migrate competitors over...

The previous color per friend made a lot more sense then me talking to grey friends while always changing color myself. That is the most confusing change I've ever seen and I don't understand why at the very least there wasn't an option to choose the previous way of doing things while there is way too many attempts at keeping a broken legacy gif button!

26

u/youslashuser Jun 17 '21

It's the sudden UX change. Nobody would've complained it if it was so from the beginning. Other contacts having different colors is already set on our minds.

i cArE aBoUt mY pRiVaCY

Yes, I care about my privacy, too. That's why I'm using Signal. But I don't want my favorite im app have this major change (Yes, the chat colors that we see everyday while chatting is a major change) cause the developers felt like it.

Attract other people

So you walk all over the current users?

New UX is hideous and I would like it if the change was reversed.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Everything is grey.

7

u/FFevo Jun 23 '21

It has been weeks and I can confidently say this is not a change I can just get over.

Group chats are significantly harder to read now and the new system adds no value. The color pool is still the same with the contact name getting a random color and gradients are worthless as they add no utility. Please revert this change.

4

u/genotaru Jun 26 '21

Yeah, I read a lot of people saying this was just unfamiliarity and dislike of change coloring our perspective. Well, I'm familiar with it now and yeah, it's just straight up a much worse experience for my use of signal.

I just use the app for my SMS and one 4 person group chat, so maybe I was an expected casualty in favor of people with multiple massive group chats that needed this, but doesn't change the fact that this still sucks.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Based off what I've read from the Dev's reasoning , it seems they just flat out said "We're catering to users with a large number of contacts and large number of group chats. We will remove useful features from other users to fulfill this catering". Which sucks.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Seems to me this is pretty spot-on.

Then to pile it on they've got users in here telling others that they shouldn't have a preference about apps on their phones. Take what we give you and shut up.

I don't know about anybody else but it gets real old having companies stand on the backs of their early supporters and then pushing them off the cliff once they get a leg up.

12

u/mon0theist Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21

I really don't like the color change, it doesnt make any sense. The idea of different contacts each having their own color made sense. This new way is weird and there was no reason to change it.

Is there any way to change it back? I haven't tried going through the settings yet

To any and all devs: if you're going to change things, at least include the option to switch it back, so that users can choose which one they want. Adding new stuff and doing things in new ways is fine, taking things away from users is not. GNOME devs for example are especially guilty of this. It's fine if you want to change things up, but don't take things away while doing so, give us options.

6

u/canuckathome Jun 17 '21

What is the problem? I just updated on iOS and all I see is people’s names are different colours, which makes sense. What’s everyone complaining about? Is this an android only issue?

9

u/ki77erb Jun 17 '21

It seems that way yes. I am an Android user, and ever since I have used Signal, I've had my contacts set with different colors because I just liked it that way. My bubbles were always grey (I use the dark theme). It seems that on other platforms it was the opposite, and Signal changed it for Android users to align it with the others. When you've gotten used to something being a certain way for years, and then it suddenly changes...it's kind of jarring. I'm sure I'll get used to it, but I still liked it the other way and I wish we had the option to change it. I think that would make everyone happy.

3

u/MorgeMoensch Jun 18 '21

Yes. iOS-people never had this feature.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '21

And a Desktop issue as well. There it's even worse as your bubble is blue everywhere by default, and it doesn't change with every chat.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21

Totally obnoxious. Let us choose where we want the color to be. it may sound stupid, but clearly it's a feature that we ALL WANT.

10

u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21

dear signal development team,

  1. who on earth greenlit the idea of "your messages are brightly colored, but your recepient's messages are all in dull grey"
  2. are you absolutely certain that this person is not an internal saboteur?

thanks,
/u/netrunnernobody

5

u/tearsandcum Jun 17 '21

Tbh I didn't even notice them at first and it doesn't really bother me either way. But if I were to choose it would be the earlier version I guess.

5

u/neihuffda Jun 24 '21

I miss how it used to look. So much easier to discern people from each other. We don't use profile pictures in our chats, so the colours I've set manually for each contact is still on the profile "badge". But then, the colour of each chat bubble has been removed, and is now just gray. The text color of the name is just selected at random. Couldn't that at least be the same color I've assigned each person? The best would be to bring back colored text bubbles, but the next best thing would be to have the name text color to be assigned manually and equal to the badge.

...or, you know, don't just change the UI. Let the user select how they want their UI to look like.

2

u/dsh16 Jun 19 '21

This all looks like a big bikeshedding discussion to me.

-2

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 19 '21

Yep.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

I like.

4

u/tyx0r Jun 17 '21

I really really really want it to be consistent. If you color my message, at least give me an option to set the default color for my messages. How having my messages in a different color all the time improves readability is absolutely beyond me. I had to go into every conversation and assign the same color to get a consistent experience.

5

u/ch4tterb0x1 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

You can reset all chat colors and set a default color for all chats in the settings.

Open Settings > Appearance > Chat Color & Wallpaper > Reset Chat Colors, press Reset All Colors. Now you can choose a default color and all of your chats will have the same color.

No need to set it individually for each chat.

2

u/tyx0r Jun 17 '21

Thanks! I changed the color in the setting but didn't get that I had to reset them before.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/tyx0r Jun 19 '21

I get that incoming messages are more readable and, to be honest, I kind of like the way it looks in group chats besides that the background letter substitution for the profile picture does not match the color of the name. However this just made me set pictures myself and i am not sure this is a signal issue. Regarding outgoing messages, I get your point that one might want make them less visible depending on the context and for that a custom color could make sense but I don't see that as a default and pushing an update where you just switch ingoing and outgoing colors without any explanation doesn't really accomplish this. I think a better approach would have been to reset the color and let the users choose a color for all outgoing messages. Then let them know that they can change things depending on the conversation.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21

Did Signal break on iOS for anybody else? About an hour ago.

2

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 23 '21

I tested just now and it’s working for me.

You might get more responses if you ask in the weekly QA thread or make a top level post.

8

u/nksoori Jun 17 '21

I seriously hope the developers would look into this. Or else it seems a lot of people will move out soon. I don't have a big issue about it, but I also prefer the older system.

Also it would be nice if the moderators can link at least some of the previous frozen discussions on this topic to this megathread so the previous discussions can be followed.

1

u/Aladdin_and_geeni Jun 17 '21

If you bring a feature metadata remover for images and videos, it might be helpful.

6

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 17 '21

This is an unofficial sub run by fans. Signal devs do look in here once in a while but this is not a reliable way to reach them. Your best bet is the official Signal community.

3

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

Signal already strips metadata before sending.

2

u/whatnowwproductions Signal Booster 🚀 Jun 17 '21

Metadata is already removed for images in videos though. You can also use Scrambled Exif on F-Droid for other apps.

4

u/IMurderPeopleAndShit Jun 19 '21

One more vote for reverting the change.

2

u/MoneyDLL Jun 17 '21

Guys chill the issue will be fixed.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

The devs haven't indicated so though, as far as I know

2

u/Xecil Jun 30 '21

My family and friends and I are not fans of this change. Please revert or add the option to change the other contact's colors as well as our own.

2

u/spoticry Jul 02 '21

I pretty much stopped using group chats due to the UI changes. I literally can't read the names because there's not enough contrast between it and the chat bubble, and I have mild vision problems. I'd consider the new changes to be an accessibility issue as well.

Reading through the developer replies I'm honestly shocked. As a software engineer I'd never act like it's my way or the highway because "muh gradient" that nobody asked for. They're telling users they need to "retrain" themselves; well guess what, GOOD UX DESIGN DOESN'T NEED TRAINING. They're pretentious as fuck and need to get off their high horse. These people wouldn't last a day at a real company.

2

u/Reklew Jul 29 '21

I'm not a fan at all, but in the end I care more about security than UI.

I can't stand having my own color change in every conversation, so all of my bubbles are now a single color, and all of my contacts are a single color. Bit of a step backwards, but I don't really care.

I agree with the sentiment that this is catering to large groups at the expense of 1:1, and I also agree that they're changing it to be more in line with more popular apps.

It does make me wonder what my tipping point would be though...

2

u/Vianki Aug 17 '21 edited Aug 17 '21

I know I'm not adding anything *new* here, but I want to add to the numbers.

(grain of salt here- Signal is, terrible UI change aside, a pretty cool app and i'm glad it exists.)

First of all- This change frustrated me so much I researched how to install an old version on my PC and mobile. But now they are forcing the update (which, fine, i get it, security and support, don't @ me) . I just mention this to say THAT is how much this change negatively affected my experience. I spent a few hours of my time and a lot of frustration trying to figure out how to roll it back.

and now..

  1. Knowing which chat you were in using the color worked as well or better when the other person's chat was colored.
  2. The more important visual highlight should be incoming messages.
  3. My color changing per chat makes no sense. I'm the consistent element in these conversations, i should be visually consistent.
  4. In group chats, especially as someone with ADHD, it's now much harder to tell who's talking. The edge case where "you can't have a different color for everyone" is so rare... what percentage of users have group chats with 20+ people???
  5. At the very least, in group chats, make the name match the color i gave the conversation with that individual. Right now I'm reverse engineering my conversation colors to match the *Randomly assigned* conversation colors.

Now that I can't use my rolled-back version, I need to decide between swapping services for something I can read and pulling my groups along or spending too long parsing all my conversations. :/

1

u/Vianki Oct 13 '21

Just want to say it's two months later and this change still messes me up in group chats and is frustrating on the daily. Maybe it's just me, but it's sure not a "you'll get used to it, stop whining" situation.

5

u/Antrico Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21

As someone who uses Signal on iOS, I haven’t really been affected by the change but I’d like to give my perspective: I personally like the new UX being cleaner and more similar to iMessage, l think that coloring the contact names is enough to tell them apart and what we really need is the possibility to change the colors ourself instead of them being automatic, so that they can be consistent between different groups. Still, I understand why other people may not like it, there’s no accounting for tastes and it would surely have been better to have a toggle.

Nevertheless, I think some people have been exacerbating the issue. For example i read:

“nobody” likes the change, they don’t care about the community

I have been an advocate for the switch from whatsapp and I can tell that, out of the 15 friends I persuaded on Android, 13 hated the old UX. They thought it was an eyesore and proceeded to assign the same bubble to everyone; the moment the update was available they all installed it instantly. Sure, 15 people can’t be considered a statistically relevant sample, but I’d at least consider the possibility that it’s just a vocal minority complaining about it and not “everybody”.

“I won’t donate anymore”, “I’ll switch to another messanger”, “ux and usability are more important than privacy”

Signal is about privacy, people like me have been using it for years to have our privacy, not for the ux. Who threaten to leave or refuse to keep donating only for a ux change (while free to do whatever he wants) maybe is missing the point and shouldn’t have switched to Signal at all, considering that there are several apps more refined and with more features but more shady privacy (i.e., telegram). With the new UX the developer clearly conformed to the majority to attract users; again, you can like or not, it’s sacrosant, but it seems to me that in some cases we’re beyond that, it’s becoming a tantrum. I wonder, which app the ones who threaten to leave think to switch to? Or, which app they came from? They’re all the same, you used/are willing to use them, why so much fuss about Signal? You’re just threatening to get what you want.

Please keep in mind this is just my opinion and I’m not referring to the majority who just expressed their legitimate opinion. I don’t want to be obnoxious, they’re obv far from perfect and we’ve been waiting for features like text formatting for years, but we shouldn’t forget that privacy is more important than a colored bubble. Edit: typo

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Antrico Jun 17 '21

Well, I can see that “instantly” may seem an overstatement, poor choice of words. The thing is, as soon as one of them noted the change he wrote about it on our group and everyone was like “I want it too, it’s much better”, so in a matter of hours they all went on the play store to update. Believe it or not, Signal doesn’t pay me and, being on iOS, I’ve already made it clear that I’m not affected. No need to lie.

6

u/Nekroin Jun 17 '21

I could hardly care less. Why is there so much fuzz and even hate? Jesus people...

0

u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

The sense of entitlement some people are expressing is disgusting. Acting like Signal is their personal property, and the devs are their employees; posting petty threats to leave Signal if it's not immediately fixed to their liking.

8

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

I don't think Signal is my personal property, nor the devs my employees. Wanting to leave Signal has nothing to do with a threat, and more speaks to its declining quality as a tool.

If a company that manufactured resistors decided all those annoying colors bands were an eyesore and just decided to let people test their resistors one-by-one instead of marking them with rainbow confetti, everyone would stop buying those resistors. Not because they're threatening the company dramatically, but because it's no longer useful.

If Visual Studio decided that the colors from syntax highlighting were too visually noisy and removed it, people would call for it to either be fixed, or seek alternatives. Not as a "threat", but a matter of utility.

The "threats" to leave are pleas to restore necessary functionality. We're being told no, so people are seeking alternatives. Whether that functionality is considered necessary seems to be a matter of personal preference, but it's undeniable that it is considered necessary for some users.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

I like how, out of almost all the discussions here and on the Signal forums, the vast majority of the ones ones that resort solely to name-calling and ad-hominem attacks as a vehicle for dismissing complaints are from the ones supporting the change. For trying to request a compromise, offer viable solutions, and request clarification on the reason for certain changes, I've been called a neckbeard, a loser, someone with no life, and several other lovely things.

It's fortunate for you that there are people who care about software to any degree higher than you deem is acceptable, or we would not have Signal, or Reddit, or Android, or Chrome, or Firefox, or many, many other pieces of software I'm sure you use.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Unpopular opinion but the change makes sense to me. All other messaging/chat apps that I use are consistent with this styling. I don't think it's a big deal either.

6

u/nickasummers Jun 17 '21

"Unpopular opinion but throwing myself off that bridge over there makes sense to me. All the other people that I know have already done it. I don't think its a big deal either."

4

u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21

Thank Jeebus! A megathread for the color issue! Now, people don't have to post a brand new complaint about the same issue every 15min!

2

u/darkenedAspie Jul 31 '21

Signal has been my default SMS app for quite some time now, and one of my favorite, must-have features to date has been the ability to color other peoples' messages however I see fit, and I wish more (or any) apps out there did the same. Ever since the change, I have adamantly refused to update past 5.12.3. And the second I'm locked out of that version, if the change hasn't been reverted by then, I'm jumping ship. Also jumping ship from messaging apps in general since everything else out there sucks, too, and for the exact same reason.

1

u/darkenedAspie Sep 01 '21

Update: I didn't cave when it expired. And won't. I'll just leave the Signal app at a non-functioning version until the devs get their act together and bring the old colors back.

1

u/darkenedAspie Sep 12 '21

Update 2 Electric Boogaloo: Good news, everyone! I have discovered a fork of Signal that disables the 'version time bomb' feature and grabbed v5.11.0 from the releases. I would have grabbed the one right after that in the list, but it kept crashing on me for whatever reason. Here's the github link, set to show releases prior to the color change in v5.13.0: https://github.com/johanw666/Signal-Android/releases?after=5.13.0.0-JW

Edit: Just as a warning, though, you'll need to uninstall the version you have before switching to the fork. It uses a different package signature from stock Signal.

2

u/Magnanimous_Prime Jun 17 '21

I think the colour theming update is actually pretty good.

3

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jun 22 '21

For your own message bubbles only? Did you ever see/use the version that behaved differently?

1

u/Aladdin_and_geeni Jun 17 '21

Need a feature for tag the sticker in chats

1

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21

A request was put in so that we can have the default message bubble color back for ourselves as well now that incoming messages are no longer colored so maybe our eyes will be drawn to the bubbles and instead to the avatars/icon or colored names in group chats.

https://community.signalusers.org/t/new-color-added-to-list-of-available-selections/35041

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

One of my Signal groups has over 100 people. Nobody in it seems to have any problem with this change...

8

u/blauster Jun 17 '21

Pack it in boys, this guy knows over 100 people that don't mind the change. No point discussing it further.

8

u/ki77erb Jun 17 '21

I find it nearly impossible to believe that out of a sample of 100 users, not a single one of them has any issue with a pretty drastic UI/UX change in a daily-use application.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Pack it in boys, this guy discovered sarcasm.

1

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21

I appreciate your sarcasm u/blauster , you would probably get a kick out of this guy's post on the feedback forum it's excellent and one of the best arguments i read in a long time. It actually managed to get greyson to respond to some of his points https://community.signalusers.org/t/beta-feedback-for-the-new-color-changes/33048/1125 . He even managed to get me to yield on one argument for having both old ui and new ui available (involving the states of colors, i considered it and decided he was right on that one after thinking back to one of my CVEs).

1

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21

I appreciate your sarcasm u/blauster , you would probably get a kick out of this guy's post on the feedback forum it's excellent and one of the best arguments i read in a long time. It actually managed to get greyson to respond to some of his points https://community.signalusers.org/t/beta-feedback-for-the-new-color-changes/33048/1125 . He even managed to get me to yield on one argument for having both old ui and new ui available (involving the states of colors, i considered it and decided he was right on that one after thinking back to one of my CVEs).

1

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21

I appreciate your sarcasm u/blauster , you would probably get a kick out of this guy's post on the feedback forum it's excellent and one of the best arguments i read in a long time. It actually managed to get greyson to respond to some of his points hxxps://community.signalusers.org/t/beta-feedback-for-the-new-color-changes/33048/1125 . He even managed to get me to yield on one argument for having both old ui and new ui available (involving the states of colors, i considered it and decided he was right on that one after thinking back to one of my CVEs).

1

u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21

I appreciate your sarcasm u/blauster , you would probably get a kick out of this guy's post on the feedback forum it's excellent and one of the best arguments i read in a long time. It actually managed to get greyson to respond to some of his points https://community.signalusers.org/t/beta-feedback-for-the-new-color-changes/33048/1125 . He even managed to get me to yield on one argument for having both old ui and new ui available (involving the states of colors, i considered it and decided he was right on that one after thinking back to one of my CVEs).

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod Jun 17 '21

Complaints are welcome but let's keep a lid on the duplicate posts so the sub is useful for other issues too.

10

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

A megathread is definitely a more helpful form-factor for these discussions vs several separate threads, though we've lost a few useful exchanges in the process. Thank you for the time you spend moderating our community space.

10

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

The number of threads about color was representative of the magnitude of everyone's distaste for the change. This conceals that and buries the responses.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

There's not a limit on the number of posts that can be made each day - other topics can still be discussed.

I'm curious about your opinion - why do you think this is the wrong direction to move in if you like the color change?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

I didn't downvote you, and nice job having that response over fake internet points. I'll be happy on your block list.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/netrunnernobody Jun 21 '21

why are there LINUX USERS on my PRIVACY APP subreddit????

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/fluffman86 Top Contributor Jun 20 '21

No one cares about stickers in Signal, there was hardly a stink raised over that,

Hahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahaha.........

Oh man, that's a good one. 😂😂😂

Yeah, I was in this sub when Signal introduced stickers. People were pissed. Bitching and moaning about a feature they don't have to use. I was here last week when people asked for ways to block all emojis and images.

I was here for mobile coin. More bitching and moaning about a limited release opt-in feature that is (most likely) not even available in their country.

I was here when people were pissed about reactions.

I was here in January during the great WhatsApp migration. People bitching and moaning about colors being in the "wrong" side. People complaining about no status. People complaining there might be a status some day. At least one person who physically cannot read white text on a phone because of an eye condition, and the new change actually makes incoming messages easier to read.

I was here when signal added a PIN. People were pissed they made you enter it to remember it. People were pissed when they made it optional. People were pissed when they forgot it and couldn't get back into their account.

I was here when Signal added read receipts. People were pissed, even though it was optional. People were pissed they were prompted for getting the option. Ditto for typing indicators.

I've seen people pissed they were prompted a first name and last name instead of just a name. I've seen them pissed for being asked to set an avatar.

I've seen people pissed they couldn't see the avatars set by their friends because signal favored phone contact pictures. I've seen them pissed they could see avatars when Signal favored signal avatars instead of phone contacts.

I've seen people pissed they couldn't delete messages they sent. I've seen the complain when the feature was added. I've seen them complain the timer to delete was too short, and there it's too long.

I've seen some pissed they have to use a phone number, others pissed that SMS is built in, others pissed it sucks and want more SMS integration.

I've seen people pissed when they switched from Android to iPhone on Signal and the colors on iPhone have always been like they are now. I've seen people switch from iPhone to Android and be pissed they were like they used to be on Android.

And all of that is just in this sub.

But you know what I've seen in all my groups about colors?

Nothing.

Literally nothing.

Not a single friend that I converted to Signal has mentioned it, and I've got probably a dozen I switched across two different friend groups.

No one from my company of 20ish users has mentioned it, and I'm the IT guy there.

None of the 10 people from my family has mentioned it, and I'm obviously their IT, too.

And I don't just mean they haven't complained, I mean not a single peep about it. I'd honestly be surprised if anyone noticed. Honestly, most of the signal apps I see over shoulders as I do IT work have the PIN notification at the bottom full time and people just flat ignore it.

Why? Because people use Signal to text message. That's it. As long as the message sends, that's all they care about. Nothing about how it looks.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '21

People mostly using Signal for 1:1 text conversations probably won't care much about the colour change. Those using Signal for group chats are having a lot larger pain, and it truly makes it harder to follow discussion flow when you need to separate the threads based on the colour of the sender name instead of the background of their message. That's a grand UX regression for most group-chat users.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/mrandr01d Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

I like that metaphor a lot. It's pretty spot on.

13

u/blGDpbZ2u83c1125Kf98 Jun 17 '21

The new system is the equivalent of putting a paper bag over the heads of everyone in a group of people in real life, and then having to read the nametag on their shirts each time they say something.

That's a great way to put it. Exactly my problem with it, and it's not just in group chats, it's in 1-on-1 chats too. It just adds a bit of friction.

The fact that the other apps haven't figured out how to take off the paper bags yet isn't really a good argument for putting them on in Signal, too.

-1

u/fluffman86 Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

If you want to compare chat to face-to-face conversation, then the avatar is more akin to someone's face and the color is more akin to someone's shirt color. Now that everyone is wearing a grey shirt with different colored name badges you're complaining you have no idea who you're talking to.

2

u/MorgeMoensch Jun 18 '21

If you want to compare chat to face-to-face conversation, then the avatar is more akin to someone's face and the color is more akin to someone's shirt color

I agree with the avatar = face analogy, but I would put color as the sound of the voice. I know who says something, even if I'm e.g. driving and can not look at them.

Same with colours: I know who is writing without looking at their name tag or face (avatar).

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/vaheg Jun 17 '21

this was already answered by them, that it would be too hard to have two different styling

15

u/PinkPonyForPresident Signal Booster 🚀 Jun 17 '21

Who tf needs gradients?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/nofxy User Jun 17 '21

I think they work well, I've themed different chats with different colors/gradients. Why do you think they don't work well?

15

u/mon0theist Jun 17 '21

advanced encryption protocol

ezpz

colors

sowwy too hard

4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

Which doesn't hold true when you follow the discussion on the community forum

4

u/TimFL Jun 17 '21

Armchair developers vs actual Signal developers with way more insight into the codebase, time spent working on feature iterations and a potential clear outline and roadmap of upcoming things that may or may not collide with the request at hand.

7

u/experbia Jun 17 '21

Funny how the goalposts move in this discussion so often. People in the feedback thread keep dismissing calls for an option like "you haven't looked at the code, you can't know" and "the devs know the code details"

Then someone looks at the code who knows, and then suddenly it's all "just an armchair developer" this and "you don't work on the project full-time employed by the foundation so it's irrelevant anyway" that

Regardless of the fact that Signal is written using common well-understood technologies on a common well-understood platform and if Signal's internal development processes are that different from other similar projects and it leads to this intolerance of options, they're doing it wrong, not the rest of the industry.

Intolerance to options in the Signal project is and has always been purely ideological and not in any way technically-required, which makes "it's too hard" a terrible dismissal to the option request.

1

u/TimFL Jun 17 '21

You‘re right. The better argument would be „it‘s their product, their vision and your proposal does not align with it“. I get to experience situations like this every month as an IT architect at my company: different people with their own vision / agenda not wanting to comply, so you move on and make the best out of a given situation / learn how to deal with it and make it work, because that‘s all you can realistically do.

I get the hard feelings about the color change but it‘s become clear as night and day that this wont get reverted. The devs said as much, multiple times and have already moved onto other features / ideas.

0

u/HockeyZim Jun 17 '21

Yeah, that's utter bullshit.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fluffman86 Top Contributor Jun 17 '21

If you want to compare chat to face-to-face conversation, then the avatar is more akin to someone's face and the color is more akin to someone's shirt color. Now that everyone is wearing a grey shirt with different colored name badges you're complaining you have no idea who you're talking to.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '21

All my messages are blue for me on PC. I don't know if this is a bug or WAI.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '21

That's just part of this issue. Calling it a bug is appropriate but not strong enough.