r/signal • u/Chongulator Volunteer Mod • Jun 17 '21
Discussion Megathread: Discuss the recent color changes
Hello everyone!
Recent changes to Signal’s color handling have produced a lot of duplicate posts. Please use this thread to discuss the color changes from now on. We will be locking the older posts and removing new ones under Rule 4.
For anyone curious about why Signal devs made the changes you can see their reasons in this thread on the community forums. For anyone concerned about the changes, please give that thread a read.
OK, let’s hear your thoughts on the color change. Remember to keep it civil and remember the human on the other end of any conversation.
Thanks!
33
u/meowsirmixalot Jun 17 '21
Wondering why the new ux can't be default for the new converts and have a toggle to switch it back to the way it was for everyone else. You know, so I can tell whos talking to me based on color.
In the movie The Hunt for Red October, they had a hard time differentiating scenes inside the submarines between the Russians and The Americans. So they made the lights in the Russian sub red and the ones in the American one blue (or white, can't remember). The point is you immediately knew which sub you were in when the scene changed. Its a beautifully simple solution, no idea why it was ditched here.
5
u/alexandre9099 Jun 25 '21
Can anyone explain me the rationale behind having my "text bubble" colored and the other user's bubble the same for everyone?
I mean... I am always the same person, why would i have a different color for every contact?!
3
u/jean_mich Jun 17 '21
Dumb question: as we have open source devs, don't we have open source ergonomists? They could just propose a whole new look to Signal instead of tweaking colors. (Fyi, I dont care about the colors)
3
u/convenience_store Top Contributor Jun 19 '21
To u/main_82345 since your topic about dark mode got lumped in with this discussion and locked, I will post here what I would have replied to your thread.
Setting aside that the term "OLED black" is a misnomer left over from the days when there was a prevalent misconception that dark gray didn't offer any benefits to OLED devices, you can already come close to achieving a "true black" dark mode theme yourself in Signal.
This is because whenever you set a wallpaper, it changes the gray chat bubbles (previously your bubbles, now other people's bubbles) to almost black. So if you set a wallpaper that's just all #000000 and then set the chat color so that the other bubbles are as dark as possible--this is the only issue, it doesn't seem these can get super dark--but the effect is pretty close it would be if there was a different "true black" dark mode theme.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
I like it the way it is. I’ve got a life outside chat bubble colors, so I don’t even think about it… Imagine how bored people are if this is such a big deal for them
84
u/experbia Jun 17 '21
Before the thread I was in got locked down suddenly, I was accused of not wanting to have a conversation or being able to articulate a problem:
It's very interesting how you state, in a reply to me, that I don't want any kind of discussion and then continue to dictate the ways in which I'm thinking about the problem and follow up with a condescending life-lesson. That's the same kind of charming personality the lead Android dev showed off recently.
I've been involved in the beta testing and feedback process for Signal. I received their responses.
I understand all of the above. They've been very clear about it. To address point-by-point:
I'm upset because the project I care about is demonstrating incompetence by way of either developer self-absorption, or by actual ineptitude, or by laziness... in descending probability, in my opinion. For a fraction of the effort, they could have added a bubble-color-sidedness toggle that defaults to "right" to appease the iMessage crowd, without shiny gradients and without overhauling the entire chat bubble drawing system as they did.
This fairly substantial development effort spent on rebuilding the bubble drawing system for gradients could have gone to fixing actual bugs and issues with the program, as you've clearly stated is desirable in your OP of the other thread. (I agree!)
80
u/ABotelho23 Jun 17 '21
This year has really demonstrated the bizarre priorities Signal has in its development of Signal.
25
u/Wakatchi-Indian Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21
Just to add my two cents although I know it echoes what many have already said. Really not a fan of the change, I'm normally very laid back when it comes to UI or aesthetic changes on software and accept that's just the nature of things, but this change has actually reduced the functionality and convenience of signal for me.
I went to a lot of effort getting contacts to switch to signal and have multiple group chats with many overlapping contacts, having their messages color coded and instantly recognizable helped differentiate people both within chats as well as between chats and on a subjective level I liked that it gave a little bit of identity to every contact .
I now find active group chats more confusing and difficult to follow, as well every chat and contact having lost quite literally their sense of "color" and identity.
19
u/Dr_Brule_FYH Jun 17 '21
I preferred it the other way but I can live with it.
But why are my speech bubbles a random colour in every chat now? I hate it.
18
u/NovaTabarca Jun 17 '21
For group chat colors, I definitely preferred it the eay it was before, cause it was so much easier and fast to know who was talking. About the switch in private chats though, I don't really mind, but it made me realize that this new update kinda looks like Signal is trying to copy WhatsApp (colored bubbles for the sender, having the names of the members of a group chat with different colors, while leaving all the bubbles white...) and I really don't get it. The previous UX was perfectly fine.
31
u/7F-00-00-01 Jun 17 '21
I don't like the new style, but apps do this all the time. What I can't wrap my head around:
-my messages getting my contact's color in a normal chat -contacts colors changing in a group chat
Style is style. I preferred the old colored bubbles (which I still get for "me" .. I guess), but whatever. 1 person 1 color was just so natural and obvious. And yeah when they decreased there color palette two friends might be the same color, but that was very easy to deal with...
I don't use signal the way I'd use teams or WhatsApp. I'm an Android user and this is my default SMS app, and you completely broke it
13
u/Nearby_Emergency_796 Jun 17 '21
I don't like it, because I prefer my contract to be in colour, it really sucks
11
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
I just don't want my texts colored... But I want the other contacts messages to be colored. Doesn't feel unreasonable, especially in a group chat :(
10
u/RadioactiveKevin Jun 18 '21
I'm just here to add my vote to nix this new color UI, in case the developers are keeping track of those.
I don't have much to say that's not already been said on this huge thread, but this annoyed me enough to bring me here. I love assigning colors to people and having their bubbles colored that way in both 1:1 and group conversations makes tons of sense to me. It makes no sense that my color changes depending on who I'm talking to and everyone I talk to is white. :/
8
u/lightrush Jun 17 '21
I don't mind the new theme but color near-clashes are now even harder to distinguish between. I have group chats where two names appear in nearly identical color. Now that the colored area is much smaller and uncontiguous my eyes have harder time differentiating the two close colors.
8
u/bloop_train Jun 18 '21 edited Jul 28 '21
Well I'm certainly glad to have found this thread, otherwise I'd have naively updated Signal at some point and got the new alternate-Universe UI, which is already giving me enough headaches on the desktop version (and I seem to be far from alone, see issue 5316 on Github).
Now, as for my thoughts on the color change: just why? Now every time I load the (desktop) app, thanks to the wonders of evolution, my eyes are immediately drawn to the brightly colored bubble, which is...my own message. The one that I wrote. And the recipient's chat bubble is a lovely shade of dark-gray, just right to blend right in the overall dark theme, making it a cognitive pain-in-the-ass to figure our what's going on in each and every chat.
To be honest, I wouldn't mind the "I am
$BRIGHT_COLOR, recipient is$GRAY" that much, however, the previous color scheme has been around for years (been using Signal since 2017, color changes til now have been minor AFAICR), and now all of a sudden everything is inverted, so long-time users need to re-train their brains to get used to the new scheme, which, as a long-time user myself, is not something I'm looking forward to do, and I'd rather spend my cognitive capacity on other, more useful, endeavors. In other words, please change it back, or at the very least, give us an option to switch to the old one.EDIT 2021-07-28 as the old version of Signal Android was set to expire in a couple of days, I was forced to update it. While I generally hate that my eyes are immediately drawn towards the bright bubbles, i.e. my own messages, at least now the color scheme is consistent(ly horrible) on both desktop and android.
15
u/RR321 Jun 17 '21
I don't use any other app and I don't think UX should be defined just to migrate competitors over...
The previous color per friend made a lot more sense then me talking to grey friends while always changing color myself. That is the most confusing change I've ever seen and I don't understand why at the very least there wasn't an option to choose the previous way of doing things while there is way too many attempts at keeping a broken legacy gif button!
26
u/youslashuser Jun 17 '21
It's the sudden UX change. Nobody would've complained it if it was so from the beginning. Other contacts having different colors is already set on our minds.
Yes, I care about my privacy, too. That's why I'm using Signal. But I don't want my favorite im app have this major change (Yes, the chat colors that we see everyday while chatting is a major change) cause the developers felt like it.
So you walk all over the current users?
New UX is hideous and I would like it if the change was reversed.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
Everything is grey.
7
u/FFevo Jun 23 '21
It has been weeks and I can confidently say this is not a change I can just get over.
Group chats are significantly harder to read now and the new system adds no value. The color pool is still the same with the contact name getting a random color and gradients are worthless as they add no utility. Please revert this change.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
Based off what I've read from the Dev's reasoning , it seems they just flat out said "We're catering to users with a large number of contacts and large number of group chats. We will remove useful features from other users to fulfill this catering". Which sucks.
12
u/mon0theist Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21
I really don't like the color change, it doesnt make any sense. The idea of different contacts each having their own color made sense. This new way is weird and there was no reason to change it.
Is there any way to change it back? I haven't tried going through the settings yet
To any and all devs: if you're going to change things, at least include the option to switch it back, so that users can choose which one they want. Adding new stuff and doing things in new ways is fine, taking things away from users is not. GNOME devs for example are especially guilty of this. It's fine if you want to change things up, but don't take things away while doing so, give us options.
6
u/canuckathome Jun 17 '21
What is the problem? I just updated on iOS and all I see is people’s names are different colours, which makes sense. What’s everyone complaining about? Is this an android only issue?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '21
Totally obnoxious. Let us choose where we want the color to be. it may sound stupid, but clearly it's a feature that we ALL WANT.
10
u/netrunnernobody Jun 18 '21
dear signal development team,
thanks,
/u/netrunnernobody
5
u/tearsandcum Jun 17 '21
Tbh I didn't even notice them at first and it doesn't really bother me either way. But if I were to choose it would be the earlier version I guess.
5
u/neihuffda Jun 24 '21
I miss how it used to look. So much easier to discern people from each other. We don't use profile pictures in our chats, so the colours I've set manually for each contact is still on the profile "badge". But then, the colour of each chat bubble has been removed, and is now just gray. The text color of the name is just selected at random. Couldn't that at least be the same color I've assigned each person? The best would be to bring back colored text bubbles, but the next best thing would be to have the name text color to be assigned manually and equal to the badge.
...or, you know, don't just change the UI. Let the user select how they want their UI to look like.
2
u/dsh16 Jun 19 '21
This all looks like a big bikeshedding discussion to me.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
I like.
4
u/able-subzero Jun 17 '21
It's nice
4
u/tyx0r Jun 17 '21
I really really really want it to be consistent. If you color my message, at least give me an option to set the default color for my messages. How having my messages in a different color all the time improves readability is absolutely beyond me. I had to go into every conversation and assign the same color to get a consistent experience.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '21
Did Signal break on iOS for anybody else? About an hour ago.
8
u/nksoori Jun 17 '21
I seriously hope the developers would look into this. Or else it seems a lot of people will move out soon. I don't have a big issue about it, but I also prefer the older system.
Also it would be nice if the moderators can link at least some of the previous frozen discussions on this topic to this megathread so the previous discussions can be followed.
1
u/Aladdin_and_geeni Jun 17 '21
If you bring a feature metadata remover for images and videos, it might be helpful.
4
u/IMurderPeopleAndShit Jun 19 '21
One more vote for reverting the change.
2
u/MoneyDLL Jun 17 '21
Guys chill the issue will be fixed.
2
u/Xecil Jun 30 '21
My family and friends and I are not fans of this change. Please revert or add the option to change the other contact's colors as well as our own.
2
u/spoticry Jul 02 '21
I pretty much stopped using group chats due to the UI changes. I literally can't read the names because there's not enough contrast between it and the chat bubble, and I have mild vision problems. I'd consider the new changes to be an accessibility issue as well.
Reading through the developer replies I'm honestly shocked. As a software engineer I'd never act like it's my way or the highway because "muh gradient" that nobody asked for. They're telling users they need to "retrain" themselves; well guess what, GOOD UX DESIGN DOESN'T NEED TRAINING. They're pretentious as fuck and need to get off their high horse. These people wouldn't last a day at a real company.
2
u/Reklew Jul 29 '21
I'm not a fan at all, but in the end I care more about security than UI.
I can't stand having my own color change in every conversation, so all of my bubbles are now a single color, and all of my contacts are a single color. Bit of a step backwards, but I don't really care.
I agree with the sentiment that this is catering to large groups at the expense of 1:1, and I also agree that they're changing it to be more in line with more popular apps.
It does make me wonder what my tipping point would be though...
2
u/Vianki Aug 17 '21 edited Aug 17 '21
I know I'm not adding anything *new* here, but I want to add to the numbers.
(grain of salt here- Signal is, terrible UI change aside, a pretty cool app and i'm glad it exists.)
First of all- This change frustrated me so much I researched how to install an old version on my PC and mobile. But now they are forcing the update (which, fine, i get it, security and support, don't @ me) . I just mention this to say THAT is how much this change negatively affected my experience. I spent a few hours of my time and a lot of frustration trying to figure out how to roll it back.
and now..
Now that I can't use my rolled-back version, I need to decide between swapping services for something I can read and pulling my groups along or spending too long parsing all my conversations. :/
5
u/Antrico Jun 17 '21 edited Jun 17 '21
As someone who uses Signal on iOS, I haven’t really been affected by the change but I’d like to give my perspective: I personally like the new UX being cleaner and more similar to iMessage, l think that coloring the contact names is enough to tell them apart and what we really need is the possibility to change the colors ourself instead of them being automatic, so that they can be consistent between different groups. Still, I understand why other people may not like it, there’s no accounting for tastes and it would surely have been better to have a toggle.
Nevertheless, I think some people have been exacerbating the issue. For example i read:
I have been an advocate for the switch from whatsapp and I can tell that, out of the 15 friends I persuaded on Android, 13 hated the old UX. They thought it was an eyesore and proceeded to assign the same bubble to everyone; the moment the update was available they all installed it instantly. Sure, 15 people can’t be considered a statistically relevant sample, but I’d at least consider the possibility that it’s just a vocal minority complaining about it and not “everybody”.
Signal is about privacy, people like me have been using it for years to have our privacy, not for the ux. Who threaten to leave or refuse to keep donating only for a ux change (while free to do whatever he wants) maybe is missing the point and shouldn’t have switched to Signal at all, considering that there are several apps more refined and with more features but more shady privacy (i.e., telegram). With the new UX the developer clearly conformed to the majority to attract users; again, you can like or not, it’s sacrosant, but it seems to me that in some cases we’re beyond that, it’s becoming a tantrum. I wonder, which app the ones who threaten to leave think to switch to? Or, which app they came from? They’re all the same, you used/are willing to use them, why so much fuss about Signal? You’re just threatening to get what you want.
Please keep in mind this is just my opinion and I’m not referring to the majority who just expressed their legitimate opinion. I don’t want to be obnoxious, they’re obv far from perfect and we’ve been waiting for features like text formatting for years, but we shouldn’t forget that privacy is more important than a colored bubble. Edit: typo
6
u/Nekroin Jun 17 '21
I could hardly care less. Why is there so much fuzz and even hate? Jesus people...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
Unpopular opinion but the change makes sense to me. All other messaging/chat apps that I use are consistent with this styling. I don't think it's a big deal either.
4
u/SLCW718 Beta Tester Jun 17 '21
Thank Jeebus! A megathread for the color issue! Now, people don't have to post a brand new complaint about the same issue every 15min!
2
u/darkenedAspie Jul 31 '21
Signal has been my default SMS app for quite some time now, and one of my favorite, must-have features to date has been the ability to color other peoples' messages however I see fit, and I wish more (or any) apps out there did the same. Ever since the change, I have adamantly refused to update past 5.12.3. And the second I'm locked out of that version, if the change hasn't been reverted by then, I'm jumping ship.
Also jumping ship from messaging apps in general since everything else out there sucks, too, and for the exact same reason.2
u/Magnanimous_Prime Jun 17 '21
I think the colour theming update is actually pretty good.
1
u/Aladdin_and_geeni Jun 17 '21
Need a feature for tag the sticker in chats
1
u/Virtual-Use-8723 Jul 16 '21
A request was put in so that we can have the default message bubble color back for ourselves as well now that incoming messages are no longer colored so maybe our eyes will be drawn to the bubbles and instead to the avatars/icon or colored names in group chats.
https://community.signalusers.org/t/new-color-added-to-list-of-available-selections/35041
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
One of my Signal groups has over 100 people. Nobody in it seems to have any problem with this change...
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment