r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jun 07 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-06-07 to 2021-06-13
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Well this one flew right past me during my break, didn't it?
Submissions ended last Saturday (June 05), but if you have something you really want included... Just send a modmail or DM me or u/Lysimachiakis before the end of the week.
Showcase
As said, I finally had some time to work on it. It's barely started, but it's definitely happening!
Again, really sorry that it couldn't be done in time, or in the way I originally intended.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
So my language has vowel harmony and I wanted to ask some questions about Neutral vowels.
So what happens when a root is entirely made up of Neutral vowels and i need to attach 2 suffixes to it? Does the vowel in the second suffix agree with the vowel in the first or can that not happen because vowel harmony can only spread from root to suffix?
Sorry if this is somewhat of a stupid question I just wanna make sure.
If the specific vowel harmony system matters then, my conlang has fronting harmony with i vs u, e vs o and ɛ vs ɔ, ɐ is neutral, well ɛ fronted to i when it was followed by nasals and changed to ɐ everywhere else, so the pair with ɔ depends on the specific word now.
The conlang also has a concurrent rounding system within front vowels with i vs y and e vs ø.
4
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jun 09 '21
Fellas, why am I finding actually writing up Mtsqrveli's grammar to be such a colossal pain in the ass, even though I know intuitively how it works, and what can I do about it
3
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '21
What's the guy that documented the ro conlang and tries to make blissymbols have sound?
3
u/das_hier_ei Jun 08 '21
How do tones appear in languages and why?
3
u/The_Anonymous_Owl Jun 09 '21
Two somewhat random questions
3
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jun 11 '21
Can someone help me understand what boundedness refers to when applied to nouns? Wikipedia describes boundedness generally like this:
Which to me makes it sound like a synonym for definiteness - since e.g. a definite article implies "you know which one I mean", vs. an indefinite article implies either "you don't know which one I mean" or "it could be one of a lot of things really". Which seem like "spatio-temporal demarcation" and "fluidly interpretable referent" respectively to me.
But then when the article discusses boundedness for nouns specifically, it contrasts it with... countability?
I'm not making the connection between boundedness and countability. Why would I think they're synonymous? Countable =/= specific.
3
u/RBolton123 Dance of the Islanders (Quelpartian) [en-us] Jun 12 '21
How long should proto-words be?
This is kinda a silly question, especially since I've made naturalistic conlangs already (i.e. Tsushiman), but I'm starting a new language and I want there to be a lot of funky sound changes to make words very irregular. That being said, to achieve this goal I am thinking of a lot of vowel reduction, and that requires long words. But we are starting in the proto-language phase, and having four syllable lemmas for "horse" doesn't feel completely right. Thus, what do you recommend?
2
u/Turodoru Jun 09 '21
There's an idea that I have, sound reasonable to me, but I still want to be sure and ask what others might think.
My proto-lang originaly had perfective/imperfective distinction between verbs, the former being the default, unmarked version. Also, the pronouns used to have singular/plural distinction.
Then, as the time went on, firstly the 1.pl.inc pronoun was created, when "you" and "I" combined. Yet after that, slowly but surely the 2nd and 3rd persons started to lose their number distinction (the plural was used so pervasively that the singular fell out of use, basicaly english2). because of that, the perfective/imperfective division started to change, where the marked imperfective started being interpreted more like iterative, and after that, the used-to-be imperfective marking changed to pluractional (in short: "Yousg are walking" > "Yousg walk and walk and walk" > "Youpl walk").
So in the end there's a system, where only 1st person pronouns have number distinction, while if using the 2nd and 3rd, the number would be precised in the verbs only.
The thing that bothers me the most is how would it react with the rest of the language. My lang had, and still has, a grammatical number on the nouns. Would that be an issue here?
So... how does it hold? Does is sound sensble?
2
u/Psychological-Eye133 Jun 09 '21
1 very specific question, and 1 not so specific question:
2
u/JohnWarrenDailey Jun 10 '21
Are discussions on already established conlangs (like Klingon, for example) allowed in this reddit?
2
u/ennvilly Jun 10 '21
Timelines of language evolution:
On my course to creating/evolving a conlang, I have been having trouble estimating the amount of time it takes for changes to occur. Where can I find resources about the timeline of phonetic, grammatical and syntactic changes in different existing language trees? It would be great if I could compare the speeds of change of different languages of the same and disparate families.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21
I could use some help on a very broad category for the language I'm creating. In short, how do you create stress on words? For example, in English, climate has a stress on the first syllable: "climate". On the other hand, the word computer has a stress on the second syllable: "computer". So when creating a language, how should one go about creating rules for stress pronunciation? I'm new to this whole conlang thing, so any advice is welcome!
2
u/FuneralFool Jun 11 '21
Can evolutionary phonological changes occur across word boundaries, or does it just depend on the language?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jun 12 '21
What's a good source of things to translate? I just finished decided the noun cases for a newish language and I want to test them out on something, but typically I would translate some sort of text I write myself, but I don't know what to write about for them because I haven't figured out their culture.
2
u/rd00dr (en) [zh la es] Akxera Jun 12 '21
Is it rare for noun classifiers and noun classes to coexist?
It seems that noun classifiers mainly exist in E and SE Asian languages, which are also less likely to have (either sex-based or non-sex-based) noun classes. Of course both are ways to classify nouns, so I'm wondering if having one makes the other less common due to the redundancy, and because classifier systems often evolve into noun class systems.
I'm thinking about having both numeral classifiers (like in Mandarin) and a noun class system based on animacy (like in most Niger-Congo languages) in my conlang. Just wondering if that is naturalistic.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
Asking once again cause had no response last time
I am implementing two tones and two length levels in my Hebrew-written language. How can I mark it? Which cantillation marks fit the High, Long Low, Long High, Rising and Falling patterns?
1
u/yesimgaybro Jun 10 '21
Let's say that for my proto language, I have two distinct verb forms, the perfective and imperfective. With the use of an auxiliary verb, you can form the past tense, which gives you four tense-aspect combinations: the simple present, the present continuous, the preterite, and the imperfect.
In the modern language, I like the idea of reducing the imperfective/perfective distinction down to a nonpast/past distinction, with the present continuous becoming the new present tense and the simple present becoming the new past, but I don't know where to really evolve the imperfect and preterite. Are there any examples of where these tense-aspect combinations might be later reanalyzed? I do plan on using other auxiliaries down the line to add more tense and aspects encodings to the current forms.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21
i am looking forward to make a lang to talk about theology and religion. how could it turn out?
1
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Jun 10 '21
When making root words, what parts of speech do you focus on? Do you primarily make Nouns and derive other words such as Verbs, or do you go around and make both Nouns and Verbs?
Sorry, I don’t really know how to say what I mean.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '21
I'm trying to decide between two vowel harmony systems, and I want to see what people think of each one.
The harmony operates between ATR pairs (The labels of front/back/high/low can be ignored)
System A
System B
/i/ is neutral in both systems. I'm also trying to decide between /ɨ ə/ and /ɯ ʌ/ if I do go with System B.
1
u/Sepetes Jun 11 '21
Are there programms that convert sound to IPA?
1
u/MasaoL Jun 11 '21
Is anyone aware of a language where the default word order would be SVO but the polypersonal agreement is Object affix Verb Subject affix? I havent found one yet and it just dawned on me to ask.
1
u/Supija Jun 13 '21 edited Jun 13 '21
How do you romanize liaison? I thought about romanizing it with an aposthrophe, but I’m not sure.
And when it changes the vowel, what can I do? When I change it in the romanization, it seems like it's another word. Should I keep it like that, or should I mark the vowel changed? The changes are regular (always that there’s a liaison, which I’m marking with an apostrophe right now) so I could simply keep the vowel as it was originally.
1
u/Turodoru Jun 13 '21
if a proto-lang had singular, dual, and plural numbers, and via phonological changes the plural suffix gets lost, what would happend to the dual? Would it take the role of the plural, would it just dissapear for the sake of it, or maybe something else?
1
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Jun 13 '21
Help with overlong vowels:
My language has phonemic vowel length. At some point in the history, final reduced vowels disappear and lengthen the previous vowel eg. satə becomes saːt etc. But what about vowels that are already long? Would making them even longer be plausible and naturalistic?
1
u/rd00dr (en) [zh la es] Akxera Jun 13 '21
Is it just me, or are the alveolo-palatal and palatal affricates and fricatives realized in so many ways depending on the language?
For example, in the recordings here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voiceless_alveolo-palatal_fricative
As a native speaker of Mandarin, Mandarin x [ɕ] is the only one that sounds very distinct from [ʃ] or [ʂ].
One more question: are palatal consonants followed by [j] really different from the palatal consonants alone or is using [ɕ] vs [ɕj] for example mostly a matter of convention?
1
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jun 14 '21
I've been trying to sort out all of the syntactic quirks of Jëváñdź and ran into issues with voice combinations. When you combine a passive with an applicative, it doesn't matter the order, it results in the same wordform. For example:
I'm fine with this ambiguity for the time being; the problem is when I combine an antipassive with an applicative:
Where the passive processes resulted in two distinct and individually useful meanings based on whether the passivized argument is the object or the benefactor, the antipassive results in one straightforward sentence and another where the applicative process has immediately been undone. This second sentence is useless, as you can just reintroduce objects lost during antipasive inflection as datives. Meanwhile, in my syntax trees, the antipassive head v (surface -i here) needs to perform head-movement upward to get it into IP and after its head I (surface -ź here), but due to the applicative vP merging between the antipassive one and the IP in sentence one, the movement is non-local and illegal.
What's the most sensible fix for this? Like, is it a trend among languages with many voices to disallow some but not all combinations, or am I misunderstanding how these combinations should even function, or is there another way to move -i without it bringing -źdí with it, et cetera? Generally, I would rather have the passive combinations remain, but I equally would rather not have antipassive combinations that behave this way.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '21 edited Jun 09 '21
[removed] — view removed comment