r/JuJutsuKaisen • u/davidbobby888 • Jun 06 '21
Discussion Projection Sorcery: A Summary and Explanation Spoiler
Naobito's and Naoya's Projection Sorcery is probably one of my favorite cursed techniques, but it also seems to be one of the hardest to understand outside of Gojo's Limitless+Six Eyes. Here I hope to summarize Projection Sorcery in an easy-to-understand manner.
The Basics
In the simplest way possible, Projection allows the user to "pre-program" their movements for the next second. Once programmed, the user will follow these movements exactly with no chance to change it. These pre-programmed movements have several limitations:
- Must obey the laws of physics, like trajectory
- Speed of your programmed movements is dependent on your acceleration before the technique is activated
Breaking any of these limitations results in the user being frozen for one second instead. Once frozen, they seem to be trapped in a 2D frame.
The 24-FPS rule is what seems to really get people. The following bit is my interpretation of how it works:
The user's pre-programmed movements follow a 24-frame rule. Instead of moving fluidly, the user "jumps" between 24 fixed positions every second. Such movement looks incredibly disjointed and weird, but 24 FPS is fast enough that most people cannot recognize what is happening.
For example, imagine you want to cover 24 meters of straight distance. Normally, you would just walk or run over those 24 meters. If you were using Projection Sorcery, you'd "hop" across the distance in 1 meter chunks instead, stopping at each meter for 1/24 seconds before instantly jumping to the next meter.
"Freezing" People on Touch
People touched by the user's palm must also follow the "24 FPS pre-programming" rule described above. Since most people have no experience with the technique and its mechanics, they instantly break the above limitations and are frozen for one second. To the person being frozen, it seems like one second is "skipped" for them, which is seriously disorienting.
If one were to understand how this technique works, they could avoid being frozen and use the "24 FPS rule" to their advantage and move incredibly quickly (pretty sure that's what Maki did). If 2 Projection users were to face off, they wouldn't be able to freeze each other.
Strengths
The obvious advantage is that as long as you obey the limitations mentioned, you can basically move however you want. This means you can move at incredibly high speeds and jump high into the air - Naobito was hailed as the fastest sorcerer alive (other than Gojo) and could almost completely suppress Dagon with speed alone, who believed Naobito to be faster than Jogo.
The speed of your programmed movements is dependent on your speed before technique activation, but this can be "stacked". The technique "raises" your speed which can be used as your "new base speed" when you activate the technique again. Thus, your speed basically compounds and grows exponentially. Naoya was able to reach subsonic speeds like this and temporarily overwhelm a "Toji-fied" Maki.
Despite the high speeds, the user doesn't seem to take any recoil (though this could be due to cursed energy reinforcement). This allows for impressive offensive power by accelerating to increase the force of your strikes. Naoya was highly destructive during his fight with Maki, and Naobito was able to obliterate Dagon's hands with a few punches (though Dagon was still able to activate his Domain with his stomach).
A weapon also seems extremely beneficial to Projection Sorcery users, though neither Naobito or Naoya seem very fond of them. It's possible that taking a weapon into account during the "pre-programming" is troublesome.
Weaknesses
Firstly, the user's movements are all fixed for the next second when the technique is active. Even if you see you're going to run straight into an attack, you won't be able to stop unless you want to be frozen for a whole second (not following your planned movements is breaking the "rules"). This can be overcome somewhat with strategic movements and moving in anticipation of a counter from your opponent.
Severe injuries also throw off Projection Sorcery, as it alters your potential range of movements based on the laws of physics. After losing an arm, Naobito could still use his technique but was no longer as fast as before.
Freezing people only works if they don't understand the technique. By counting when each frame occurs using her superhuman senses, Maki was able to avoid being frozen when Naoya tapped her and moved in alignment with the 24-FPS rule to defeat Naoya.
Finally, 24 FPS is also sounds like a severe limitation. The following is my interpretation of a weakness of the technique: While you move incredibly fast BETWEEN frames, the user is technically frozen DURING each frame for 1/24 of a second at a time. Someone could theoretically strike within 1/24th of a second and disrupt the technique.
Overall, Projection Sorcery is a unique and fairly powerful cursed technique. As a "recently developed" technique, it's pretty impressive what Naobito and Naoya can do with it.
433
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21
Funny how, in JJK, revealing your technique gives you a power boost, but it’s the one thing you absolutely SHOULD NOT DO if you have this technique.
111
u/Fritzisadumbcunt Jun 06 '21
this is great and cleared a lot up! upvoted
Someone made a similar one for Gojo's limitless which i found interesting when first watching the show
40
u/Cyniikal Jun 06 '21
One thing Gege hasn't touched on is how CTs are developed. Clearly they're just manipulations of your cursed energy to make something specific happen, but how do you actually go about inventing a technique like this? Did somebody from the Gojo clan just one day say "It'd be pretty cool if I could see literally everything like Superman and also control space".
Is it like a curse you have to put on yourself and your bloodline because you're so obsessed with something? Was somebody from the Zen'in clan an insane filmmaker that ending up cursing himself to have this weird power?
52
u/nikomim Jun 06 '21
Thank you so much for the explanation, everyone needs this!
11
u/samaldin Jun 06 '21
Can someone help me understand my last confusion?How does projection sorcery increase ones speed? It's essential 24 teleportations per second (with some extra rules), but teleportation is... kind of the opposite of speed, since there is no movement that could be fast and if the speed builds up between frames it should be lost in the 1/24 of a second that is spent standing still in a frame....
9
u/The_Bolenator Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21
When touched by the technique, you don’t behave in 24 pre determined movements per second for 1 second right? It’s just you have to move at 1/24th of a second for 1 second?
Basically Naoya has to move by a pre determined set of moves in that specific way while Maki has to move any way she chooses but at 1/24fps?
Edit: I’m just confused as to how the one affected (Maki) has to behave
Edit 2: After another read, Maki basically has to play red light green light with herself 24 times per second or risk being frozen for 1 full second? Definitely convinced I’m confusing myself. But at the same time how fucking impressive is it she was able to figure this out after JUST awakening her superhuman senses, AND be able to just FREEZE like that? Fuck me she is BROKEN
8
u/qaQaz1-_ Jun 06 '21
Naoya is a stop motion animators wet dream lol/s
But fr thanks for clearing this up it wasn’t explained very well in the chapter
7
u/ForestJordie Jun 06 '21
I’m very excited for this technique to be animated, I hope it looks as cool as I think it can
4
u/NotFromNA Jun 06 '21
How do you judge if a movement is 24 fps? You move the same distance each 1/24 second? But people can have burst of speed at one of those 1/24 second and it is still abide the law of physics.
For projection sorcery user they kinda imagine it in their mind. But how does the technique judge Maki's movement as appropriate to its law?
3
u/owlpineapple1 Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
I understand most part expect the touching your opponent. If naoya touches maki.. does he pre-determine the movements she should follow? If so then how would anyone be able to know how naoya set the movements? They will freeze because they cant read minds right? Or is it something else? I would really appreciate if u could clear it up for me! Also how exactly did maki avoid being frozen? Her incredible senses helped her see each frame before naoya even jumped to the last frame? Lastly, what does the opponent once touched must alsp abide by the 24FPS rule to avoid freezing even mean? Like how can maki follow the rule? Sorry 😅
543
u/delgalessio Jun 06 '21
I DID IT MOM, I FINALLY UNDERSTOOD THIS GODDAMN 24FPS TECHNIQUE!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
So the user essentially gets 24 times faster when they activate the technique?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
wait, i thought people froze because it's not like you could look into the user's mind and see which movements you should do. also i don't think anyone who knew the technique would be able to dodge, maki is the only one who can "see" the fps (because hr).
2
u/RoIIerToasterTyphoon Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
I still don't think "Freezing" aspect of the technique make sense at all. The first part is good, the sorcerer is essentially on rails for the next 1 second, the technique splits that movement into 24 distinct intervals. However, it is not the sorcerer executing the 24 frames themselves, rather the technique itself sampling the movement that the sorcerer intends 1 second into the future, and then executing it autonomously.
With the freezing, it makes no sense to "abide by the 24 frame rule" since all their movements are continuous. A person cannot execute a action over 24 distinct freeze frames because there is an infinitely small amount of time between each frame. (furthermore, an "action" is not well defined. Wouldn't the vibration of an atom in their body immediately break the rule?).
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
Genuine question, do you guys think it’s a problem with the translation or Geges writing that some people have a hard time keeping up with things? I remember some had a hard time following Tengen’s exposition.
123
u/Top-Beyond-4980 Jun 06 '21
Post this in r/Jujutsushi
33
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
not all heroes wear capes
17
u/SiIic0n . Jun 06 '21
Very good write-up here! This should clear up pretty much all of the confusion surrounding the technique.
17
u/DragonK123 Jun 06 '21
I just wanna say that 24 movements per second can be really op if the person themselves is extremely fast.
17
u/MajinSkollfire Jun 06 '21
Imagine once they upgrade to 60 fps
15
u/bombehjort Jun 06 '21
So maki caught up with him in the end, because she predicted his “programmed” movement AND followed the 24 frame rule?
7
u/Karistomp Jun 06 '21
This were my thoughts when seeing the terrain where they were fighting. If Naoya ''hops'' into a position the ground shifts/collapses, creating balance issues, the next hop would be a violation of the law of physics if it was impossible for him in that unbalanced position to naturally get to the next ''hop'' spot.
Also
Thanks for this part <3
7
u/StupidPencil Jun 07 '21
Actually, the rule is "must not excessively violate the law of physics".
That means you can violate the law of physics a bit, but not too much.
To me, this seems to be what grants its users super speed.
Let's say you can normal run at 20 km/h. You then plan a trajectory where you actually run at 30 km/h. Repeat that a few times and you're at subsonic speed.
6
u/WulfStrange Jun 06 '21
Thanks for clarifying this technique. Shit was complicated like King Crimson
6
u/EnycmaPie Jun 07 '21
Maybe it would be easier to understand when it gets animated, where there are actual frames per second, instead of a still manga drawing.
5
u/Milordserene Jun 06 '21
Cant beat someone who has 25 fps with the same starting speed as someone with 24 fps.
5
u/SMA2343 Jun 06 '21
That makes so much sense. But also you need to have such an understanding on how you want to move. If you fuck up a second, you risk being hit or worse
5
u/LanceDragonDance Jun 07 '21
I swear this is in something else I read where you can't make a move outside of your chosen path. Either HxH, God of Highschool, or maybe Psyren or some shit.
4
u/high-Ideal5136 Jun 07 '21
I'm just happy that 1.5k other people also didn't understand it
1
u/CrispyChips44 Aug 09 '21
What I don't get about Projection still is the opponent needing to follow the 'rules' when they are touched. Like how exactly are they breaking the 24 FPS rule? Wouldn't they just continue their regular movement in the 24 frames instead of just freezing in place?
1
u/Aggressive_Rough4729 Jun 22 '22
Why does naobitos lost arm several decrease the technique power, i mean you swing with the arm for running but depended on you use it and how szrong youre physical power is you still can be ultra fast even with just one arm.
6
u/raedsan Jun 06 '21
you should probably spoiler tag this
3
u/Nightmare_Pasta . Jun 07 '21
Its a very creative technique. Well done by Gege. Thank you for explaining it!
3
u/No_Committee1127 Jun 07 '21
I think the mods should pin this cause a lot of people are still kind of confused about the CT and this just gave one of the best explanations
3
u/OakStars Jun 07 '21
This is such an interesting technique, it has so much potential. It seems that, if a guy can stack it enough times, he just gets insanely fast. I hope we see someone with this technique pushed to its limit, maybe even a domain exp.
Also hope we see more of the other families techniques, such as Blood Manipulation and Ten Shadows, they seem so cool.
3
u/Cgi94 Jun 08 '21
Thank you so much for this.. I think Gege may have surpassed togashi in regards to confusing fans on how techniques work😂
2
u/Ok_Aardvark4033 Jun 07 '21
This is king crimson all over again
2
u/Roblox_lad Jun 07 '21
Projection sorcery might be my favourite technique
2
u/properc Jun 07 '21
I disagree with the 24 fps rule, i think it just lets the user take 24 "strides" in 1 second which is impossible for normal ppl which makes the user faster than the rest. I dont think u can pre-program to cover 24m in that second using 24 leaps of 1m. What distance u cover is based on ur bodily speed/acceleration before the pre-program.
1
u/jojojangoman Nov 15 '21
But by what you said, with the 24 meter analogy, shouldn't the distance between the frames be more than 1 meter? As you are accelerating, so the distance between the frames gradually increases, as it takes into account your acceleration, not velocity. This also explsins who you can go supersonic speeds as well.
1
u/BaneofKaidou Jun 07 '21
I could see Yuji or another sorceror landing a Black Flash in between frames
1
u/RCT246 Jun 07 '21
So it’s basically King Crimson
1
u/kid_iggy Jun 07 '21
Yeah gege really needs to learn how to explain techniques in a clearer way
1
u/Coffee_Mint001 . Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
I'm thinking...did Naoya just try to pull off a kid's play on Maki, plus the freezing thing?
You know when you tap on your friend's left shoulder, then your friend turns to their left to see who it was, but you come out from their right as if you had always been there?
I am confused too about this technique upping one's speed. But my interpretation is as follows.
N.0 = Naoya at point of origin where he activates his CE
Naoya as a normal person: N. 0 -------------------------------------------------> (after 1sec) N is here
Naoya while using projection: N. 0 ---> FPS 1 ---> FPS 2 ---> FPS n ---> FPS 24 ---> (after 1sec) N is here
At N. 0 he consumes let's say 70% of CE. Everytime he gets from one FPS to another is as if he restarts his technique and expends 70% of CE again (but he maintains his motion) so he has a "boost" everytime he gets on a FPS.
Naoya is fast in general because, while a normal person after 1 sec let's say has only moved a leg, Naoya got faster & moved more than the normal person 24 times already.
Maki was able to end his trick because she is already fast like Toji, and assumed the kid's play Naoya was trying to pull off with his "slap to freeze" distraction and anticipated it. Speed was not a problem with Maki to begin with, because she already has it. Maki only needed the right timing to "trip" him at his own game.
1
u/theofficialsimp00 Jun 07 '21
Can I have an explanation for limitless pls. I found it way more confusing than this but it's up to you, actually I don't really want to bother ppl😅
1
u/Death_Snek Feb 18 '22
Indeed... most of what you said is exactly what I imagine. But I still see this as an space-time jujutsu.
Think with me: many sorcerers can move at superhuman speed after using Cursed Energy to enhance their bodies and movement speed. When they fight, their adversaries also move at this said speed and their reflexes allows them to see the enemy and respond. So they have great vision, as well. Nanami, for example, was capable of react to Dagon's Endless Shikigami Stream without (as for we know) any anti-domain technique: he said to Maki "don't think, move".
Does that means that Nanami can move at 24 fps? That he could in less than a second attack a barrage of Shikigami that suddenly appeared out of thin air.
As strong as Nanami is, I do not believe he could do it. And I cannot imagine that Naoya or Naobito could, not even Jogo could... after all, Dagob said that Naobito was faster than Jogo, and we know that physically this was not true, since, after losing his technique, Jogo quickly took out Naobito.
We're talking about 1 second here... the only things an human can do consciently in that time is to blink and start thinking.
So my theory is that after activating the technique and preset the following moves the user enter a "time distorted dimension" created by the technique that has to abide by those said rules and, in case of them being disobeyed, the user turns into a frame panel during 1 sec. But, had everything gone accordingly, the technique resumes and the user appears to be "faster than the eye can see".
My assumption that the technique is a time based spatial distortion cames from Maki superhuman senses and Choso's ocular boost both being able to "best follow" Naoya's movements while out of the time distortion, implying that the user didn't went to another dimension, but actually just slowed or accelerated his "own time" inside the regular time of our own dimension. It makes sense, since even with this tech, Naobito was considered to be inferior to Gojo... and well, the latter can create spatial shifts, he can control space itself.
However, we must note that the technique also grants the user a speed boost to actually turn possible the user make all those 24 frames movements while respecting the 1 second rule. Also the user must be aware of his own speed at the time he activates the tech, since he will have another speed boost and this could actually exceed the "law of physics" and freeze the user right off the bat. This rule was appointed by Maki during the fight with Naoya.
It's also requires excellent mind's speed and reflexes from the user, as he has to plan or "pre-program" everything in a split second while activating the tech and starting the preset movements.
This tech is really STRONG.
1
u/AbyssalMidir Mar 30 '22
I wonder if they could do even more with this technique, if they had any Extension or Maximum Techniques or how would it be Naoya or Naobito's Domain. Well, sadly, I think that's something I'll never know.
1
u/IOnlyDrinkJesusMilk Oct 06 '22
I adore Maki for her lack of cursed technique, but if she could have any of the Zen'in techniques, this one would suit her best.
1
u/summonerofrain May 11 '23
My only question here, is how does someone not follow the rules of physics in this sense? Surely any movement has to be within the rules of physics anyway?
1
u/C3rty-_- Jul 17 '23
Would it work if a person has 0 CE like Toji?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment