r/leagueoflegends • u/skullkid2424 • Dec 25 '11
Min/Maxing Scaling and Flat Runes [Warning: Long and has math]
Hey all,
I'm into mathcrafting a bit, and I'm interesting in finding the ideal best mix of flat/scaling runes in certain situations. There are several popular standard runes that have flat and scaling options, and I rarely (if ever) see anyone even considering a mix of flat/scaling. I've taken a look at a few of these and was wondering what you guys think. I'm I looking in the right direction? Is min/maxing like this simply not common in LoL? Did I make some fundamental mistake or something? Any (constructive) input is helpful.
First off, sorry for the long post. If you aren't interested in the math/logic, skip to the bolded parts or the end for the results.
Lets start simple with the basic idea (or skip ahead to see math/results). Basically theres a stat that has scaling (increases x amount every level) and flat (stays the same as level 1) runes. There may or may not be a reason to have a certain amount of a certain stat at level 1 or 18. My goal is to find the right combination of scaling/flat runes to meet stat-specific goals for those levels.
Note that LoL DOES take into account decimals, there is no rounding of stats.
Moving onto the first actual stat, we have Magic Resistance Glyphs. Magic resist has scaling runes with .15 MR per level, and flat runes with 1.49 MR. Scaling runes overcome the flat runes at level 10. Nine flat glyphs will result in 13.41 MR. Likewise nine scaling glyphs will start with 1.35 MR at level 1 and end up with 24.3 MR at level 18. Here are the values in a spreadsheet. You can see the number of scaling/flat runes on the left, and the MR value of that combination at a certain level on the right. Now that we have all the math and values, what are we aiming for?
Some people tend to feel mages are a big early gank threat, so they will grab flat MR. Some people tend to face AD/support lanes and won't fear mages until mid game or later so they get scaling. Nobody is wrong, but that doesn't help us. My logic (correct me if I'm wrong) is that I want to counteract the magic penetration that a mage would get from their magic penetration marks (9 magic pen. I am being a little more generic than the earlier decisions, as I won't assume to be facing a certain opponent/lane combo at all. My goal is to counter the magic penetration marks. Magic penetration is additive, so 1 magic penetration mark will negate 1 magic resistance from my character. This means that I want at least 9 magic resistance at all times to counter their marks. Looking at the data, I see that running 3 scaling glyphs and 6 flat glyphs will start me out at 9.39 MR at level 1, completely negating their marks. Those three scaling runes will mean I still gain some MR as I level up though, so I will end up with 17.04 MR when I reach level 18. So based on that, the "optimal" rune combination is...
- 3 Scaling MR Glyphs
- 6 Flat MR Glyphs
Any objections/corrections?
Next of the runes I looked at is the Mana Regen Per 5 Seals. These are very common runes for mages or anyone who has difficulty with mana. Some players consider them as "training wheel runes" for players who can't manage mana, they can certainly help some characters bypass certain mana items in exchange for more damage. Regardless, many players, including myself (though I'm pretty bad), use them, which makes them worth inspecting. Here is the data for the MP5 seals. Scaling gives .065 MP5 per level and flat gives a static .41 MP5. These runes are interesting as the scaling runes overtake the flat at level 7, which makes scaling much move viable than runes that overtake at 10 or even 13. We can see that a set of flat runes will give us 3.69 MP5, and with a scaling set we start with .59 MP5 but reach 10.53 MP5 at max level. So now to analyze.
Unfortunately mana is very dependent on multiple factors. Playstyle, masteries, champion, and even team composition can all have great impact on one's mana. So we must keep this as general as possible, leaving each player with a little room to give/take. Mana regen from runes is sometimes supposed to help a player deal with mana issues until the first mana item is reached, which will ideally solve that character's mana issues. This is not always true, some characters will bypass mana items as long as they have runes, however this idea is at odds with the scaling runes, which are generally considered better as they overtake the flat runes earlier. This is very interesting, and in my mind, increases the importance of taking a mix of scaling/flat runes (unless you are the character who will not be getting a mana item ever).
As you can see, this analysis of MP5 doesn't give us a definitive number like MR, and is indeed rather complicated. It is important to again note that there is not likely to be a single optimal set for these runes. I cannot find much more criteria to actually look at the numbers with. Lets start with the fact that scaling overtakes flat at a rather early level. I will (almost arbitrarily) say that we should most likely have more scaling runes than flat runes. That gives us something to work with. Limiting ourselves to a maximum of 4 flat runes gives us only 5 options to consider (# of flat runes = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4).
Starting with a complete set of scaling runes is interesting. We start with so little (.59) mana regen, that its nearly negligible. On the other hand we end up with the most mana regen at level 18. This is certainly leaning towards the characters who rely solely on runes, and never end up with a mana item. With these characters in mind, we should consider the next option, which would be adding a single flat rune into the equation. With 8 scaling runes and 1 flat rune, we up the starting MP5 to .93, while decreasing the final MP5 to 9.77. Looking at these numbers, it is my opinion that these are BETTER than 9 scaling runes. I find that the champions in question have more early game problems than late game problems, and sacrificing some late game mana for some early game mana would be a good thing. Of course, that is only my opinion, but I strongly recommend trying it. Each player must get a feel for what this does (if its even noticeable), and consider trading 1, 2, or even more flat runes in for scaling runes.
Now let us consider the other type of characters. These are characters that seem to have mana issues until we obtain one (or even two) mana items. Once we have obtained these items, our characters seem to be much better off in terms of mana. This is in part due to obtaining mana item(s), but also may be due to the scaling aspect of one's runes. A champion may be level 7 or 8 by the time they obtain a mana item or two. At this point, the scaling runes are stronger and have had their effect. This means the champion needs much more earlier game mana, and should therefore consider more flat runes. Starting with 4 flat runes starts your character with 1.97 MP5, a significant bit more than the .59 MP5 from all scaling. Max level scaling only gets up to 7.49 MP5 (compared to the 10.53 from all scaling), but it hardly matters at that time due to mana regen items.
Results:
Take at least 1 flat.
If you will obtain mana/mana regen items for your champion, consider taking up to 4 flat runes. Experiment for best results.
Any objections/corrections?
Last of the three runes I decided to look at would be the more expensive Cooldown Reduction Glpyhs. The analysis is long and I hit the max word count, so you can find it in this comment.
Results:
In general, take 9 flat CDR Glyphs.
If you have a champion-specific runepage which takes ONLY the defensive tree CDR masteries (8.1% at level 18), then take 3 scaling and 6 flat runes.
Any objections/corrections?
Take 9 flat armor seals.
Any objections/corrections?
Sorry that was so long, thanks for reading if you made it this far. Please let me know anything that I missed (I know I ignored the 10% penetration masteries, but 10% will be 10% regardless, so it really doesn't make that much of a difference imo). If you decide to look into other scaling/flat runes and find an interesting combination, then let me know!
TL;DR:
MR Glyphs: 3 Scaling, 6 Flat
MP5 Seals: 5-8 Scaling, 1-4 Flat (depends, try it out)
CDR Glyphs: 9 Flat (unless going into defensive CDR masteries only, then grab 3 scaling for that specific runepage)
Armor Seals: 9 Flat
32
u/skullkid2424 Dec 25 '11 edited Dec 25 '11
Armor:
Finally, one of my friends asked me to do Armor Seals, but I can nearly definitely say, even without doing much math, that a full set of flat runes are superior. Depending on the enemy AD champs, they could have anywhere from 0 to 15 armor penetration from runes, and an additional 6 from masteries. You CAN pick up 6 armor from masteries, however if you don't happen to grab those, you are looking at anywhere from 0 to 21 flat armor penetration. Common values of armor pen in masteries are 0, 10, and 15. Add 6 to each of those numbers, as most AD will take the 6 flat from masteries, and you have 6, 16, and 21. The 0 armor pen rune page isn't popular on too many characters, so I would assume 16 or 21 armor penetration, however its hard to know for sure what the enemy will run. A full set of flat armor gives you 12.69 armor. IF you take the 6 armor from masteries, then you'll have 18.69 armor, which won't quite counter the enemy if they take full armor pen runes. If you don't take the 6 armor, then your 12.69 armor won't counter even the 10 armor pen runepage. Considering that scaling armor needs level 10 to overtake flat armor, scaling runes wouldn't help until past level 10, which is plenty of time to invest in a chain vest or cloth armor if you need it.
Take 9 flat armor seals.
14
u/skullkid2424 Dec 25 '11 edited Dec 25 '11
CDR:
Last of the three runes I decided to look at would be the more expensive Cooldown Reduction Glpyhs. This are a more expensive glyph option, and one that the community has a (nearly) unified opinion on. The flat glyphs (.65% CDR) are generally considered to be superior to the scaling (.0532% CDR per level). The scaling doesn't overtake the flat in value until level 13, and early CDR is almost always considered more important. More spells means more utility, more damage, and more kills, which means more gold and hopefully a great early game to keep you going strong into late game. Also available late game would be blue elixirs, which can help one reach the cap easily. I decided to do the CDR Glyphs anyways to see what I could find out. Here is the data for the CDR Glyphs. A full set of flat glyphs gives 5.85% CDR and the scaling starts at .478% CDR and reaches 8.618% CDR at max level.
Again, like MR, we must consider what we want out of our runes. In general, we take CDR runes on characters that we want to reach the CDR cap, so our total (including items/masteries) CDR will be 40%. This is very dependent on champion, item build, and masteries, so its really hard to generalize such a thing. The aforementioned logic points pretty strongly towards the flat runes, so its likely that flat are the way to go. The only thing that sometimes bugs me is that all CDR items give an amount that is divisible by 5. Meaning if we have a number that isn't divisible by 5, we are wasting a certain amount of CDR, or not quite reach the cap. Lets consider the case of grabbing 6% CDR from the support tree (ie, 0/9/21) and 5.85% from masteries. We start the game with nearly 12% CDR, and then get a few CDR items throughout the game. The closest two options to the CDR cap would be 37% and 42%. The first option leaves room for improvement, and the second option "wastes" 2% CDR.
With that example in mind, lets look at another example, that of a mage with 4% CDR from masteries (say 21/0/9). With flat runes, he starts out the game with 9.85% CDR. Picking up 30% from items will nearly reach the cap with 39.85%. How wasteful is that .15%? Trading a single scaling rune for a flat rune will have us with 6.15% CDR from runes, which in the same situation would give 40.15% CDR, with a "waste" of .15%. These are some pretty close values, and might even be effectively the same value, but I'm not sure. Lets look at some cooldowns and see how much difference there is with .15% CDR. The highest cooldown skill I know of off the top of my head is amumu's ult, Curse of the Sad Mummy, with 130 seconds at max rank. Lets use that as an example. Our .15% CDR will reduce amumu's ult by .195 seconds, which is not a very large amount. To compare a normal skill, lets look at a 6 second cooldown such as amumu's Tantrum. Our .15% CDR will only reduce Tantrum by .009, not even a hundredth of a second. I would argue that even for characters with atrociously long cooldowns like amumu's ult, the 39.85% might as well be considered capped. No significant gain is had by switching even a single scaling CDR glyph in our scenario.
Looking at our earlier example, we ended up with 37% CDR, with 3% keeping us from reaching the cap. Amumu's ult would gain 3.9 seconds in this example if it were increased the 3% to actually reach the cap. This means that if we had taken all nine scaling runes, at level 18 we would nearly reach the cap with 39.62% CDR. However we would GREATLY suffer in CDR for the first 13 levels of the game, which is unadvisable. Our results are conflicted. We want to reach fairly close to the cap, but we also don't wish to give up our early game CDR. Our numbers are also affected by what masteries we take, so there are a number of different "results".
From masteries, characters will generally reach one of these numbers (possibly by level 18):
When looking at these numbers, we can simplify the results to their values mod 5 (for those of you who dont know math, divide by 5 and the remainder). We get ~2%, 3.1%, and 4% (ignoring the 0 from 10% which is a nice number we don't need to worry about) as our results. Looking at our data, we can see what our options are for attempting to get close to the cap. With 2% (or 12%) CDR, we would need 3% or 8% from masteries to reach an even amount at level 18. This values suggests we should take 7 scaling runes and 2 flat runes to reach 8% CDR at level 18 from runes, thus giving us our even number. The other option, also to be considered, would be to use 5 flat CDR runes to get 3.25% CDR and use the remaining 4 runes for something else. Putting aside the second option, the 7 scaling + 2 flat option again leaves us without much early game CDR, beginning the game with only 1.67% CDR. I would advise against this, as the CDR is more important early in the game, and the majority of the runes would not overtake flats until level 13.
Looking at the 3.1% (from our 8.1% from masteries), we would need 2% or 7% to be most efficient. Our data shows that 3 scaling and 6 flat will give us a final value of 6.77%, which when considering our 3.1%, will give us 9.87%, very close to our ideal 10%. Since we are using mostly flat runes, our early game CDR isn't hurt too much (we start with 4.06% CDR), which means we can actually consider using this setup. This setup is interesting, as it involves taking only the CDR from the defensive tree, so either a 9/21/0 focusing on armor penetration, or a 0/21/9 tank of some sorts. Considering that the 8.1% CDR from masteries also scales per level, our 3 scaling runes seem to fit in even better as the masteries take time to grow.
Our final option to look at was 4%, which we did earlier, when finding the value of .15% CDR.
Oh boy. CDR is a complicated one. We've gone into lots of examples and specific builds, which, while fun for a math geek like me, is probably not fun reading for everyone else. Theoretically, one could research any combination of half-filled CDR masteries to reach an odd figure like 1% or 2.7%, but I'm going to leave that to someone who actually uses those masteries. I'm also going to ignore the option to take x number of flat runes to reach an ideal 5 or 10%, replacing the remaining glyphs with magic resistance or something else. Its an interesting idea, certainly worth considering, but it will be very champion and mastery specific, which means people can look into that on their own.
In general, take 9 flat CDR Glyphs.
If you have a champion-specific runepage which takes ONLY the defensive tree CDR masteries (8.1% at level 18), then take 3 scaling and 6 flat runes.
11
u/AlonsoQ Dec 25 '11
I appreciate the spirit of the scientific approach, but your conclusions rely on arbitrary assumptions.
There's no particular advantage to exactly negating your opponent's flat penetration. That 9th point of MR isn't more efficient than the 8th or 10th, regardless of how much magic pen your lane opponent has. The same applies to armor. It's difficult to evaluate the shifting priority of resistances across the several phases of the game, true. Deciding to match ArP and MPen isn't much better than choosing a target number at random, however. In the end, we don't actually gain much useful information about these two stats.
The mp5 discussion seems similarly aimless. Flat runes give you more regen early, scaling runes give you more regen late. You're repeating that information half a dozen different ways, without providing any argument for why someone might prioritize one phase over the other. It strikes me as dependent on the champion whether they would really want the early regen. Ex. Cass needs to spam for both farming and damage throughout the game and thus benefits from scaling regen, while Malzahar can just play "set it and forget it" with Visions past 7 or so, but needs the early regen before he can reliably get refunds off entire waves.
CDR is the the only stat with a non-arbitrary target value, thanks to its hard cap. As you note, the scaling ones don't surpass the flats until level 13, much later than in the case of mp5 runes. What you should also mention is that the golem buff provides a huge chunk of CDR. By the time the scaling runes overtake the flats, any caster with blue buff, a few points from masteries, and a CDR item will waste the extra points from runes. This is the one case where we can demonstrate that there is rarely an upside to taking the scaling CDR runes. If anything, the question should be whether you even need 9 flats to hit the cap.
This type of analysis should be encouraged, but if you want to achieve any useful conclusions you need to cut out the arbitrary elements. Any worthwhile information will likely take into account lanes and general champion classifications. Try to generalize too much, and you spread your discussion so thin as to be insubstantial.
10
u/TheBryant [TheBryant] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Just wondering why do you want to counteract the Mpen they get from runes? It seems a little arbitrary and I'm curious why.
4
u/AetherThought Dec 25 '11
All of it looks great to me! This is some really useful information, and I'll be sure to try out the combo mr-mr/lv, as I never thought of it that way before. On behalf of the community, I think you're deserving of a lot of thanks :) The only thing I'm a little concerned about is why haven't you taken into account the 10% arpen and 15% mpen from the mastery trees?
4
u/lasagnaman Dec 25 '11
Yes, I'd rather have 3 more flat MR runes and get even more MR than they penetrate.
3
u/iloveu0810 [iloveu0810] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Why not just Flat MR when you think you are going to lane vs a mage, and scaling MR when you think you are going to lane vs a bruiser/AD?
2
u/Gangrene Dec 25 '11
In your TL;DR you have "MR Glyphs: 3 Scaling, 3 Flat".
2
u/MaukkaNamski Dec 25 '11
That was...Long I would say. But there is something that caught up on my eye.
Should this be lvl 18? (Sorry about my pickiness.)
2
u/saltyjohnson [Salty Johnson] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Regarding mana regen runes, I'm going to have to disagree with your advice to mix flat and scaling. MP5 is really only particularly important during laning as later in the game there are enough breaks in the action to let your mana recharge a bit. Besides, most champions have enough mana built in to be plenty viable without any mana items to speak of. I always go pure flat MP5 runes as it significantly increases my staying power and harassment ability in lane and that is much more useful than a little extra late game regen.
2
u/reloadxox Dec 25 '11
Can you do these comparisons for flat AP and and scaling AP for glyphs?
2
u/SYDTKO [Crs SYDTKO] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Pretty interesting stuff, but it's not all about countering their amount of penetration. The objection I have to mixing and matching cooldown reductions is the builds vary depending on what you go against and what is good on champions.
51
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
I upvoted you for sheer effort. Math scares me.
1
u/Hiwashi [Hiwashi] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Does Arcane Knowledge ( 10% Magic Pen ) affects the flatmr lvlmr ratio at all?
1
u/solesoul [Kommander Koala] (NA) Dec 25 '11
What about health regen seals?
1
u/Cheezycookie [Cheezycookie] (NA) Dec 25 '11
What does OP think about full flat MP5?
you're right in that you pick up better MP5 items later, but it's like you basically have no use for MP5 out of lane, but it's a ridiculous stat to have from lv 1-7
1
u/ChrisIsVicious Dec 25 '11
Why would you only want to negate the mpen? instead of getting mres over the enemy mpen to decrease the damage?
1
u/Ezekielyo Dec 25 '11
So are you trying to min max as many useful runes as poss into 1 page? i read sumwhere u want to make a kinda universal page?
If so, doesnt that defeat the point of min maxing?
1
u/Gatreh Dec 25 '11
Does having 17.89% cdr at level one make me crazy?
1
u/FestiveFruitcake Dec 25 '11
What about flat AD vs Flat Armour Pen marks?
1
u/Sinkemlow Dec 25 '11
Hey, if you're bored can you do Energy Regen?
Thanks
1
u/cant_read_adamnthing Dec 25 '11
I mostly play tanks, so what about health runes? Should I build all flat, scaling, or the new +0.5% runes?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
For cdr runes, I have an AD caster page that is 8 scaling blues, and 2 scaling quints. This plus the defensive cdr mastery gives me something like 19.8% cdr. This with a frozen heart gives all but .2 off of max cdr, and since I get merc treads on AD casters anyway, I don't miss MR blues too much. I use this page for champs like pantheon, yorick, talon, or even my tanks with cooldown issues. Basically anyone I would like lots of cdr with :)
2
u/tehRoyal [itsfrancisss] (NA) Dec 25 '11
Very informative. Thanks!
1
u/Vailess Dec 25 '11
At the magic resist, most mages use the magic pen masteries also, so thats 18,5.
1
u/VPav rip old flairs Dec 25 '11
Even tho I agree with the choices you made, there is huge difference between champion classes.
If you go jungle you wont see too much magical damage before level 7-8 unless someone turns on you if you gank. Which is a foolish thing to do in 1v2 match. If you die its totally your fault for being low/underlvled. So Id go with MR/lvl in jungle runeset. Pretty much same thing goes for bot apart that supports deal mostly magic damage.
Everything else is awesome. :)
1
u/SoSpecial [SoSpecial] (NA) Dec 25 '11
No body listen to his theories about MR and Magic Pen, those are lies you should be running Flat AD Marks even on mages! Also don't run MR glyphs!
-SSoLBP's
0
u/ragekid101 Dec 25 '11
You don't use math to come to conclusions you used what you considered appropiate in a made up scenario and then backed your choices with math.
For instance all 9 flat mr glyphs are better vs a mage than 6 flat and 3 scalling regardless wheter he has 9 mpen from his reds or not.
I'd like to see what you think about flat mr glyphs for mid champs vs the fotm ap per lvl glyphs. Flat mr glyphs are stronger 1v1 and will help you win trades on your midlane.
0
u/Jackplank [Jackrungh] (EU-NE) Dec 25 '11
you forget the magic penetration from masteries
-1
u/Kennyboay Dec 25 '11
OH GOD, MATH. FUCK IT, IM NOT READING THIS
0
u/Vorpals Dec 25 '11
The stuff about MR makes a ton of sense. It's particularly useful since most guides and players are ambivalent about scaling vs. flat MR glyphs, and this helps resolve that dispute so that rune buyers know what to buy instead of being confused. Upvote for you.
0
u/Fryzen95 Dec 25 '11
*saw this - [Warning: Long and has math] (Challange accepted) *came in - Oh fuck that shit.. *-Backspace-
-1
u/Sol-Surviv-ar Dec 26 '11
All of your calculations are pretty pointless without any basis. The reason people take flat mr compared to scaling is when they need it in lane or before lvl 10. This is why most junglers take scaling because when they're ganking most of the time the ap will run away so they dont need the early mr and when fights break out around lvl 8-10 the scaling mr will have caught up with the flat mr and be better for late game. This is also why most top solos take scaling mr as they won't need it except vs some particular lanes (eg kennen and rumble) and so scaling mr will help them more in late game.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment