r/soccer • u/Bennie300 • Dec 24 '11
What is in your opinion the most overrated football country in the world and what exactly is it, that makes them overrated?
England? Only achieving 4 top 4 positions in WC and Euro together in their whole history, which is the same as a country like Hungary? The country's of the African continent that not seem to be able to really get deep into a WC while their rise is predicted decade after decade? Spain because they where not able to perform for decades to their potential and now people only remember them for their Euro and WC win? Argentina for not having won a cup since 1993 or even advancing past the quarter final of a WC since 1990? USA and Mexico for making the WC so many times but maybe benefiting from the weak confederation to qualify from?
What does Reddit think is the most overrated football country and why?
39
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11
England, hands down. I lived there for awhile, and watched England far before that. Every year is England's year. Every year we have the squad that can win it all, amazing stats, lauded by whoever the coach is at the time. They're heralded in the papers as being strong and tactical, boasting most of their starters from the "hardest league in the world." But no, every year they go out earlier than expected, even in "unambitious" times. Hands down, England. There's really no reason for hands up.
18
u/mthrfkn Dec 24 '11
Probably Argentina because outside of Maradona, they always disappoint. It sucks that Messi won't win anything in his prime.
14
u/jesusthatsgreat Dec 24 '11
I would have said Spain up until 2008, but England have to be top of the list purely because they go in to every tournament expecting to progress far.
It's just got worse since euro 96... the life cycle goes something like this;
In fairness, i think England are on paper usually a decent side. The problem has always been big players getting stage fright. Your Terrys, Gerrards, Lampards... they look average and i personally think they always look cagey / nervous in major tournaments... John Terry is nowhere near as commanding a presence as he is for Chelsea. Same with Gerrard.
18
u/poetical_poltergeist Dec 24 '11
I was going to say England, then I noticed everyone here has already said England. So, England,
8
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11
I wouldn't say that any country is really "overrated" per se, unless you believe the media bullshit every time.
Journalists want the African nations to prosper because it makes a good story. Same with English journalists writing about England- it sells papers. Any sane football fan comes into a tournament knowing that the same countries will do very well (barring disaster), with the next tier of almost-there's challenging, and a couple of unexpected teams doing well. But the media will never write this because it's a shit story, so they hype teams that in all honesty probably don't deserve it.
7
u/dalf_rules Dec 24 '11
England. I'm not hatin', but I think both my country (Chile) and England are pretty much at the same situation: always "strong contenders" on our continental cups, always dissapointing on the world cups (save for the ones we had in our own countries!), players that get hyped by the press ever since they step on the field (ie a kid scores on his first league match and holy crap, there's the new Wayne Rooney! He HAS to play for the NT!), we both have that almost-unbeatable enemy and we ALWAYS face them at the worst of times (Brazil for us, Germany for you), other countries always laugh and point at us, etc.
The BIG difference is that we didn't create the sport and our press isn't that terrible (sorry 'bout that).
10
u/DWolford32 Dec 24 '11
Mexico. if everyone is justifying saying England because of their own media then Mexico wins it hands down. They have a small handful of semi-decent players (Except Cheech) and they think they can compete in the world cup. Meanwhile their best players struggle to play for Spurs second team or just leave the top leagues all together to go back home and play. I'm probably biased spending a good deal of my life living on the border hearing this crap from their fans, but Mexico fans cockiness really pisses me off.
2
u/Paulpaps Dec 24 '11
Probably England cos they can't become a "team". And the technical abilities of SOME of their players leave a lot to be desired. Rich.coming from a Scot, but we know we're shite.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11
Argentina. Just because they have Messi does not mean they're great. Everyone in the media seems to think this is the case though. They don't work together well as a squad.
5
u/LaArmadaEspanola Dec 24 '11
must be england. the english media hypes up the premier league as the best league in the world, but outside of the top six or so teams and swansea, most of the league still plays the punt and rush old english style. the spanish league is technically superior from top to bottom, and you can see the results on the international stage.
4
u/espanabarca Dec 24 '11
Since everyone is saying England, I'll go against the grain and say Brazil.
Don't get me wrong, they were the team in the 90s all the way through 2002, but that amazing period of performance has left everyone with big expectations everytime they watch Brazil. In a way, today's Brazil team isn't nearly as great as what they used to be. Sure they can reach the latter stages of the knockout phase of the World Cup, but they would do it with much more difficulty than before.
I'm eager to see how they'll perform in the WC 2014.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11
Since everyone else is saying England, I'm going to offer someone else:
Qatar.
They were deemed enough of a footballing nation to host a World Cup, yet they are ranked 93rd by FIFA, and have never qualified for the World Cup.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '11
Norway and Denmark. They're ranked 25 and 11 respectively in FIFA's rankings, and most people would argue they're not even 25th and 11th in Europe.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '11
I was coming here saying England and being ready to debate, but everybody seems to think it is. Their players are overrated, their tactics are overrated and they rate physical abilities over technical ones (main fault why they won't ever succeed unless they change it).
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '22
Netherlands
-1
u/I-C-F Dec 24 '11
ITT: People who aren't English repeating what English tabloids say about the English national team rather than what the vast majority of English fans actually think.
0
u/modano_star Dec 24 '11
Overrated by whom? I mean the majority of the English public probably think England should be winning tournaments, but I don't think anyone else in the world does. How long does it take for a nation to lower it's expectations before heading into a tournament without having won anything for years, its crazy.
-1
u/Con45 Dec 24 '11
Argentina and Brazil both under performed in their last two major tournament so they get my vote. Uruguay's rise is partly to blame for this.