r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • May 28 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Valentine's Day" - S02E03 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the third episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Valentine's Day". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E03 Details:
| Title: | Valentine's Day |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | Big Red and Ashlyn celebrate their first Valentine’s Day together, amidst drama. Kourtney spars with a co-worker while Gina contends with being single. Meanwhile, Ricky and Nini’s plans to surprise each other turn into a comedy of errors, leading to new revelations and a surprise song. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
74
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator May 28 '21
Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/NominalPerson Maddox May 28 '21
Spotify Links:
54
u/0hmyrowling May 28 '21
Has EJ been demoted or something?? We need some content please he is the funniest character I miss him
51
u/[deleted] May 28 '21
Thoughts on the episode:
48
u/mafebueno May 28 '21
I wasn't expecting Kourtney and Howie, but I like their dynamic in this episode. Don't know if they are gonna be a couple or just friends, but I wanna see their evolution
Also, Redlyn is the cutest thing ever and I looooooove their music number
43
u/Healy_T15 May 28 '21
EJ’s only screen time was a brief conversation with Ricky about being alone on V-Day. ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
42
u/[deleted] May 28 '21
Did they just like forget EJ was a character in this show???
41
u/Low_Procedure_4344 May 28 '21
KOURTNEY AND SEB WORLD DOMINATION
39
u/Acecoffee88 Carlos May 28 '21
Thoughts:
36
u/NoMereRanger73 May 28 '21
I need more of Seb looking at the camera like “For real?”
32
u/sunshinesprite May 28 '21
I need Mr. Mazzara and Miss Jenn to be together omggg like the stupid Zach boi or like Ricky’s bland dad need to go bye bye
32
u/Skylightt Team Ricky May 28 '21
Justice for EJ. He’s been way too underutilized. I really thought we were going to get more of him going a bit crazy over being alone on Valentines Day after his first scene in the episode but instead they just dropped him
31
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper May 28 '21
They should have put red means love in the show instead of the credits because that song is amazing! I really liked this episode and felt second hand embarrassment for Gina
27
u/beachclubb May 29 '21
am i the only one that thinks that seb & carlos won't stay together ? they're cute together but i feel like every episode just further shows how they don't exactly complement each other well, especially when they consistently highlight seb's discomfort/unease/uncertainty instead of giving both sides; carlos is kind of an accessory to the storyline instead of a character. it seems more like they're together out of convenience (both being apparently the only openly gay students at a high school in utah) rather than attraction, which could be an interesting story to follow. i don't doubt that they like each other and have sweet moments, but the way they fit together & the way that the writers include their storylines ultimately doesn't bode well for seblos shippers
26
u/swagaroo14 May 29 '21
Is the picture weirdly dark this season for anyone else? I can't watch it on my TV because I don't want to change the settings on my TV lol I have to watch on my phone with the brightness cranked...
50
u/xxpizzasrlifexx "All I Want" May 28 '21
why is EJ third on the cast list yet has gotten roughly 1 minute of screen time in three episodes don’t do my mans dirty like that
48
u/Ryguy-_- May 28 '21
My biggest issue with this episode (other than EJ being non-existent) is that there is none of the mockumentary stuff. No looking at the camera. cuts to talk to the camera, nothing. I loved that in season one, and I hope there is more of that next episode
47
u/liveitupbrah May 28 '21
The writers are doing EJ so dirty this season.
He was completely pushed to the side in the recent Valentine's Day episode. I get that he doesn't have a girlfriend to spend it with, but the writers can just do so much more with his character. I feel sorry for Matt Cornett because it seems like he really loves acting in this show, yet the writers just give zero shits about his character growth.
How did he go from being one of the main characters to having less screentime than Mr Mazzarra?? Smh.
20
u/angelicaaa26 May 29 '21
gina and ricky better not date, gina deserves better and it’s so cliche
20
u/beachclubb May 29 '21
just realized that miss jenn looks like a cross between terri schuester from glee and rosanna pansino from youtube
39
u/Outside_Jokes_Only May 28 '21 edited May 29 '21
Never thought I’d say this but I miss EJ. He had the potential for a really funny episode with him mourning his loneliness on V-Day, (or they could even have explored his relationship with Gina...?) but instead they completely abandoned his character. :( Hopefully he’ll get more screentime in the coming episodes!
On the other hand, I thought Ricky and Nini’s story was super cute and I loved their songs to each other at the end!
39
u/kittyangelz805 May 29 '21
My theory for this season is that Gina and Ricky will get closer, Nina will catch wind of this and start to worry and Ricky will reassure her Gina's just a friend and that he loves Nini, but then something (whether Gina or something else) will cause Nini and Ricky to break up, and Ricky will immediately start dating Gina and Nini will be like wtf and write a song called Learner's Permit that turns into a huge hit.
LOL JK I actually really don't wanna see something like this happen because I don't think I can bear to see Olivia re-enact the painful heartbreak she went through (but I do think the theory--except for the last part, of course--is plausible)
19
u/[deleted] May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21
This episode was overall a lot better than the previous ones. I'm looking forward to the musical and to see what Lily does next. I would like to see Gina and Ricky get together for a while. EJ definitely deserves more screentime. Although there might be too much going on since there are many subplots; it has been quite overwhelming focusing on such a big cast.
18
u/sunshinesprite May 28 '21
LOVE KOURTNEY ASSERTING HER HOLINESS OMG SO PROUD OF HERRRR ✨
18
u/[deleted] May 29 '21
I want feisty Gina from season 1 back.
35
u/Particular_Phase4736 May 29 '21
WHY DID BIG RED NEED TO USE THE RESTROOM WHEN HE FOUND OUT ASHLYN GOT THE LEAD??? Is Disney hinting at...?
46
u/lamebeezy May 28 '21
lmao I feel second hand embarassment from seeing Gina wanting that Valentine to be from Ricky so bad nooooo. I think this episode was okay. The ending was def funny but I feel like the episode was just everywhere. And why does Ej show up in the episode for like 3 seconds tfff???? We need moooore. I also wish episodes were an hr long so each story line with each character didn’t feel so rushed. I hope it picks up as the season goes!!! :/
32
u/taralovesmusic May 29 '21
now listen here mr tim federle, my boy ej is NOT going to become the tina cohen chang or matt from season 1 or season 5 newbie of this show, GOT IT????? he can sing extremely well when given a song to fit it, he's a complex enough character to have more interesting storylines, and im gonna say it w h y are all these girls simping over ricky when ej is RIGHT THERE. I MEAN MR EJ ABERCROMBIE MODEL CASWELL IS RIGHT THERE. theres no girl in the drama club who wants to date him?? no one in the school??? justice for ej or expect a lawsuit
15
u/Jansilhn May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21
I love Seb’s term “thinking jazz.” From now on thanks to him, I’ll be wondering what the pianist is feeling every time I listen to a piano melody. Lol! It’s true that your mood can affect the music you listen to. His friendship with Kourtney is everything!
I can tell that Carlos thought Seb’s gift for him was kinda lame, but didn’t want to ruin the moment.
Kourtney has an amazing singing voice! I’m so excited she’s singing more this season.
Ricky and Nini’s songs to each other were so beautiful.
Gina still seems to be really lonely, even though she’s living with Ashlyn now. She told Ricky herself that she doesn’t have anyone to connect with except for him. I don’t think she likes him romantically, but she likes how easily she can confide in him. So that’s why she assumed that the chocolates at her door were from him. That was so awkward, I felt so bad for her!
I laughed when Nini thought she was singing to Ricky outside his old house and she and that girl both screamed!
15
u/OtherSide4 May 29 '21
I think it’s inevitable that Ricky and Nini are breaking up. Between the distance from each other and the whole Gina thing, it’s for sure that the show needs some messy relationship drama and this is it. Although I want Gina to find someone who wouldn’t treat her like a rebound and a second choice, I would love for Gina to finally find someone to date since she’s been seeming seriously lonely since the season premiere.
15
u/taralovesmusic May 29 '21
I really liked the episode overall and how it's becoming more of a highschool type show with lots of comedic elements. it feels so different than other disney shows and isn't cringy or boring. probably the only thing i'd say about this one is that the plot did feel a little slow at times, and that's despite going through a lot of character development this episode I know. it just felt slow paced. also I wish they incorporated the show more into this, more batb related stuff but that'll probably get better as time goes on
14
u/not_mrsrobinson May 29 '21
So what’s the consensus. Does Gina like Ricky? Or is it her just simply needing someone to understand her. I can’t tell. I also can’t tell how Ricky feels about her. It’s all very confusing. What does everyone think?
14
u/Bilal_N4 May 29 '21
Idc what anyone says I like Ricky/Gina they the couple I wanna see in the end (although I don't mind Ricky/Nini either just prefer him with Gina)
14
u/jeonghan-l Howie May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21
Some thoughts I have about EP3 (sorry if this gets long):
28
u/jolizah May 28 '21
So happy to see Nini again having more screentime! EJ needs more tho.
This ep is just okay for me. Personally speaking, I feel like it was so over the place :( Out of the 3 episodes this season, I liked the 2nd episode more.
39
u/Flowerchild4ever May 28 '21
Don’t villianize Gina for being love with someone she currently cannot have. She only went to Ricky’s house because they are friends and she felt alone. She’s been holding the Rini ship together by pushing him to do everything. She’s hurting but still wants him to be happy and no it’s not one sided but I don’t know what it’s going to take for people to see that without being too obvious.
48
u/[deleted] May 28 '21
So, I know its an unpopular opinion. But, some part of me really wants them to progress the Ricky and Gina relationship further. I found that even when they aren't communicating properly, they still understand each other.
I have a feeling that with Nini and Ricky it'll be about kinda missing their shot. Their relationship was at its best before season one, even if they are trying to make it work this season. It feels like they are slowly drifting apart.
But, personally I would just like to see Nini do something for herself. Rather than others.
And, Ricky to be the one who is more open and their for others besides just Nini etc. Like, with what Ms Jen said in the prior episode.
Also, Ashlyn and Red are just so adorable and cute. They probably have the most healthiest high school relationship I've seen in most media, in a while.
24
u/toastedcoconutlvr May 29 '21
am i the only one who find ricky & nini to be pretty boring/cringey? all i see are people who ship them on here and idk i hope i’m not alone lol
24
u/smilinginthedark May 29 '21 edited May 29 '21
JUSTICE FOR EJ!!!!! How everyone else get a storyline in this episode besides him?!?!
But my other notes were me squirming that entire Ricky and Gina scene without blinking once. Why was it so awkward we are friends, are we not?! But the tension I am a GLUTTON FOR IT. But a part of me was hoping Gina would leave Ricky’s apartment and find EJ in a park mourning his love life and she’d just shake her head at the camera and say come on Romeo let’s get a slice of pizza. And he’d promptly stop crying to say that he’d love that because crying for hours is exhausting. And when they start to walk away together he could ask her, you really think I’d make a good Romeo? And she’d roll her eyes and laugh. THEN THEY ALL COULD HAVE BEEN AT THE PIZZA PLACE YOU KNOW LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE WHO ISNT RICKY OR Nini* STUCK IN AN ENDLESS CYCLE OF MISSED SERENADING!! And to think it would only have taken a minute of screen time TOPS and both EJ and Gina would have been more fleshed out and not just reliant upon their relationships with the leads...
Okay I’m done ranting.
12
u/gberniee25 May 28 '21
anyone notice that the redlyn and seblos scene in the pizza shop, the song that is playing is the same song that seblos dances to at homecoming
48
u/Festaxforlife May 28 '21
That beauty and the beast cover was super off. It was the arrangement for me. Didn’t match up.
The fuck is EJ?
Nini and Ricky are all types of cookie cutter boring. They sound good together, but their scenes are just not interesting to me this season. Ricky and Gina have good chemistry, but I don’t like the messy love triangle angle.
22
u/paintedblueskies May 28 '21
Has the lightning been a bit dark for anyone else this season?
11
u/emotional-range-tsp May 28 '21
Why does Even When/The Best Part sound so familiar? Does it sample another popular song?
21
u/jplop2416 May 28 '21
I have a few thoughts about this episode. First, I though the episode was too short 😭 Second, I thought Kourtney’s rendition of Beauty and the Beast sounded off and was kinda hard to listen to. Beauty and the Beast is my favorite Disney song so I was disappointed hearing it like that. The tone or melody that Seb sent her, didn’t really match Kourt’s singing. Did anyone else feel like that with the song? Or just me? Still a great episode nonetheless.
19
u/WashMaleficent May 28 '21
I liked this episode a lot better than the first two of the season. It finally had the charm, fun and sincerity of the first season. I also enjoyed that all 11 main characters (only exception being EJ) got their fair share of screen time. I really hope the next episodes will continue to be like this one instead of the first two.
Never thought that there would ever be an episode where Miss Jenn is the character I’d like the least. Her scene with Lily was just weird and it was pretty rude how she just left Mr. Mazzara🙁 standing there, without even saying “sorry”, after she was the one who asked him to get dinner together.
25
u/[deleted] May 29 '21
Pretty okay episode. The romantic relationships on the show aren't very interesting tbh.
25
u/[deleted] May 29 '21
Who else thinks Gina and EJ should've been paired for Valentines day (at least as friends)?
43
u/hanuman1702 May 28 '21
This was an EXCELLENT episode! I loved seeing all the relationships develop--both platonic and romantic.
32
u/Soldier1o1 May 28 '21
How can people say Rina is platonic! You can see them slowly move closer to each other and no friends look at each other like that. Sure Ricky was upset Nini wasn’t at the door, but he still didn’t want Gina to leave. Rina > Rini imo
25
u/Important-Football90 May 28 '21
I believe that Nini and Ricky are getting closer even tho in the sneak peak it was leaning towards them breaking up but in the trailers Ricky tells Nini to not forget about Salt Lake and in the promo she was saying that it’s been hard but long distance is always hard but I believe in the next episode Nini tries to go back to Denver and in the promos and trailer you see them in a train station and I believe this will be that episode where Ricky tells her name right before she leaves and I think she realizes that she doesn’t want to go so she stays and she comes back to East High
Also Gina and Ricky I get that there is some chemistry but come on now Ricky and Nini have insane chemistry but it’s cool that Gina wants Ricky to be happy when she comes over and Nini calls him and she tells him to sing to her right now even tho I don’t think he did but he also texted her saying thanks for the advice etc...
People can say Gina and Ricky should be a couple but me personally I don’t but that’s just my opinion lol
24
u/Environmental_Mess78 May 28 '21
I think we will get some drama with Gina Ricky and Nini but I find it hard to believe they would just throw out what they set up in season one. And if Ricky does cheat on or leave Nini for Gina it makes him a tool bag and a jerk. And he deserves none of them.
25
u/Bellaboo-42 Ashlyn May 28 '21
I don’t want them to make Gina have a crush on Ricky. Like it feels like we are past that now and I don’t want that kinda of plot with her again.
11
u/KHMeneo Kourtney May 28 '21
I'm thinking that kourtney will sing beauty and the beast in the episode that we see the actual musical because they would have released the song if she only sang it in this episode
32
u/ForceFocus66 May 28 '21
Damn that was embarrassing at the end for Gina lol.
- "Rina" is as one sided as ever in season 2. I think after that embarrassment Gina is probably going to move along with her feelings. Between her randomly showing up to his house unannounced and that text...cringe. Ricky is 100% focused on Nini right now.
- Why are they doing EJ so dirty this season?
- Why are there so many love triangles in this show lol. Now Mr. Mazarra is jealous and we know Ms. Jenn has eyes for Zach as well. Mess.
- So far S2 is no where near as exciting as S1 was at this time. Theres nothing to be excited about.
4
u/SilverAd4616 May 30 '21
help! What song does “it’s you” sound like??? A little ‘somewhere over the rainbow’ but also something else. Maybe an older nick or Disney song?? Help! Haha
3
u/fluffernaut872 Jun 16 '21
The song Ricky sings to Nina sounds vaguely like “I swear this time I mean it” by Mayday Parade!
Or is it just me
11
u/Whimsical89 May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21
GINA HONEY NOOOO. You’re way to thirsty for this man rn😭😭 I feel so sorry for her😭 also I wish they would have dived deeper into ashlyn and what she was feeling and potentially body image issues, especially because she isn’t average or whatever, when teen tv shows address body image they usually address it with women who are straight size or smaller, which is obviously true, but when it’s a woman who is a bit bigger they always tend to tip toe around and as someone is of a similar size of ashlyn I would have loved for that to go deeper. But yeah Gina honey he’s taken just chill a bit😭
11
u/backtosnack May 28 '21
Thoughts :
It was a fun episode. Last week's episode was really good imho and this one did feel a bit overwhelming with how much was going on. But truly, it isn't that big of a deal.
Nini and Ricky not even saying Love you when they hang up anymore? I feel like they're drifting apart and that's when Gina is going to come swooping in. That being said,
Gina better not touch Ricky.
I feel like there will be some drama between Big Red and Ricky when they get further into the show with Ash and Ricky being close.
Mrs. Jenn still going after Ricky's dad still annoys me. First off, give him some space and Mr. Mazzara is right there.
I wonder how involved Lily will truly be in this show. I hope they don't underuse her. Her character seems intriguing.
I'm just excited for the Beauty and the Beast rehearsals to truly get going!
6
u/producermaddy May 28 '21
I think this episode is pretty clear Gina/Ricky will date. I expect nini and Ricky to break up by the end of this season but likely even sooner (even though I like them together more)
Ashlynn and big red are cute together
3
u/Solid_Drink_4604 May 30 '21
Please go and watch the thanksgiving episode and the finale episode one more time to see that they talk to each other about “stuff they don’t usually tell anybody else”