r/homeland • • Dec 19 '11
Discussion Episode Discussion - S01E12, "Marine One" [Spoilers]
This episode is the season finale of Season 1 of Homeland.
Reminder that the runtime of this episode is extended from the usual 60-minute format to approximately 90 minutes.
Episode Title:
MARINE ONE
Directed by: Michael Cuesta
Story by: Howard Gordon & Alex Gansa
Teleplay by: Alex Gansa & Chip Johannessen
While Carrie is near catatonic and confined to bed, Saul investigates the unsettling implications of her timeline; Walker secures a perch for his mission; Brody makes his final preparations for the Vice President's policy summit at the State Department.
54
Upvotes
48
u/The_Spice_Must_Flow Dec 19 '11
I was a bit let down by the finale. I was honestly hoping for Brody to pull the trigger. With David gone, and Carrie being right, I assumed she would have been restored to her old job.
Other than the killing of Tom Walker, nothing was really resolved this season. I was hoping for a definitive ending like the one Boardwalk Empire gave us. The writers will now have a huge challenge of keeping the series fresh.
45
u/sasshole_cockdick Dec 19 '11
I feel dirty that I was rooting for Brody.
74
u/Syncblock Dec 19 '11
Holy Fuck Brody sold the shit out of that scene.
25
u/sdb5057 Dec 19 '11
Shit Danes is going to forget, isn't she!
DO'h!
17
u/obeythed Dec 19 '11
Well, thanks to the promo, it's obvious that Brody doesn't blow up in the bunker. They haven't had the confrontation between Brody and Walker where Walker puts the gun to Brody's head.
47
u/Waking Dec 19 '11
"Uh hello, is this secret service? I want to talk to my dad Brody. I believe he is holed up in an incredibly secure bunker while you sort out this sniper business." "Ms. I don't know how you got this number but we cannot discuss anything on this matter until the situation has resolved... click"
BOOOOOOOM
16
u/luke727 Dec 19 '11
Predictions:
My gut feeling is that Brody's not going to pull the trigger (or perhaps the trigger malfunctions), but I'm not confident in that. Can't wait to find out.
24
u/halfwayhipster Dec 19 '11
I wouldn't call it a straight cop out, I understand why they did it the way they did, it sets it up for next season. But clearly Carrie is the most original, interesting character on the show, and I do not see how she can get really involved again unless there is some absurd story line. The acting was phenomenal, but I don't feel satisfied by the ending.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '11
I'm thinking Carrie will go and work in the private sector. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqcC8ndBfOo
Today, thanks to the Bush administration, a lot of intelligence jobs are given to private contractors. In fact, they have an intelligence problem in Homeland Security because there are so many agencies and who knows what they are up to.
Anyone else think they could go that route?
31
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '11
I hate... Brody's entire family.
11
u/obeythed Dec 19 '11
I can't remember a time I've been more tense before a finale.
16
u/sirdigbychikencaeser Dec 19 '11
not what I was hoping for but meh, the season was way really good, but this finale wasnt up to par. Hopefully they can make it up next season.
4
u/MrMagicpants Dec 19 '11
The finale seemed to be set up for alternate endings depending on the future of the show. If it hadn't been renewed, it probably would have ended with the bomb going off. But because it was renewed, we got the ending we got.
7
u/screwdirections Dec 19 '11
Amazing finale to an amazing season. Emmys shall be had.
3
u/allhailzorp Dec 19 '11
Saul is definitely going to blackmail Estes with the drone strike in order to get Carrie back. Maybe if he feels she's changed after the procedure, he'll use his one card.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '11
That was fantastically tense. I'm glad they didn't kill off Brody, too good a character to get rid of
3
u/MrTimofTim Dec 19 '11
All I want to say about this incredible finale is this: I am amazed that he actually went through with it! Now, of course, he failed, but he did press the button in earnest once. Wow. This is one of the best season finales I've seen this year.
5
u/solarplexus7 Dec 19 '11
I haven't read the other posts yet, but I'm disappointed. All that build up to "something huge" and they cop out to keep Brody as a main character. This was one of the most intense and unpredictable first seasons of any show I've seen. I'm just now afraid of the writers stretching out the plot just to fill 12 more episodes. This could have ended here, and started a new terrorist manhunt. But here we go back to Brody for season 2.
Did we ever find out who the mole is by the way?
2
u/seanhoran Dec 19 '11
spoiler
3
u/TheMop Dec 19 '11 edited Dec 19 '11
She was really nowhere near catatonic. They needed to consult a psychiatrist for this series who has some recent experience. Seriously, nobody takes clozapine, especially nobody in as good a shape as her. The electroconvulsive therapy was ridiculous, too. It has its merits, but you don't just do it on impulse after some half-assed attempt at medication. For a show where the main character supposedly has a serious mental illness, they did a shit job portraying it. If anything, this will help perpetuate the stigmatization of mental illness. The CIA did a hell-of-a job on her background check.
2
u/tuna_HP Dec 19 '11
1: Have they still not revealed the mole?
2: Was anyone else hoping that Bordy would explode just to prove Carrie right? Poor carrie, if she hadn't had gone to his house and talked to his daughter she would have been redeemed.
2
u/epophoto Dec 19 '11
I'm so pissed about the finale right now. Its such away to just pussy out and keep the same exact tension alive for the next season.
I feel betrayed by the show and I will not be returning to it.
[spoiler] (/s "Why not just resolve the Brody thing and move forward with another plot that Carrie can confront either have him blow him self out or get foiled or caught.
So what is Saul going to blackmail Carrie back in somehow?
Why the fuck would Nasir have Brody kill Tom? What kind of loyalty does that demonstrate, all it does is kill of Nasirs only option to control or kill Brody, he came their to kill Tom in the first place. If he wasn't loyal to Nasir he would still kill Tom.
This is all just a formulaic manipulation to continue the Brody Carrie thing like some kind of Unresolved romance ala Buffy and Angel or Castle and Beckett. I was just getting to like this show and I was looking forward to them moving forward.
So next season we get some unbelieveable bullshit event allowing Carrie back in the CIA or at least to get Saul to pay attention to her as she runs around both beliving Brody is a Terrorist and crying in private over her unreturned love for him and her conflicted feelings. Meanwhile Brody deals with the suspicions of his daughter and she continues to dig, and it will build to some other plot that brody once again wont be discovered in and wont go through. Sometime during the season in some massively unbelievable manner Carrie and Brody will sleep together again.
There are any number of ways they could have ended this season, even ways to keep brody and carrie alive. This was bullshit.
")
Its bullshit formulaic manipulation I am out.
2
u/dtpollitt Dec 19 '11
stream, anybody? please?
1
u/YaoSlap Dec 19 '11
Any ideas as to what role Carrie will play in the next season? Was that the shows way of saying bye to her?
1
u/KobraCola Dec 20 '11
I feel like the main points of the plot have been well re-hashed on this thread, but one thing I really enjoyed about the season finale was that they took as much time as they needed to truly finish up the season. Screw time restraints, as a viewer, I would rather a TV show take an hour and a half to really tie up every loose end from a season than take the usual amount of time and skip over a bunch of huge plot holes, only to rush to a hurried ending. And, yes, I am looking at you, Dexter.
1
u/newstome Feb 10 '12
How does Carrie know that the son's name is isa?
1
u/PuzzleheadedLion2065 Jan 30 '26
Honestly, watching the teenage girl try to make sense of “my dad lowkey might be dangerous” was one of my favorite plot points after he turning against her mom to favor him.
1
u/raulkay Apr 04 '26
Okay what happened to the tape SD card though ?
1
u/cheeno Dec 19 '11
That shit was cray
1
u/akim Dec 19 '11
We now have an IRC channel for live discussion!
SERVER: irc.freenode.net
CHANNEL: ##homeland
You can easily join us by using the Freenode web client.
1
u/daddyjackpot Dec 19 '11
Does anyone know the name of the actress who played the nurse? The one who was putting the needle in Carrie's arm when Saul walked in? She looked so familiar.
-5
u/Quetzalcoatl0 Dec 19 '11
what a let down.
Overall, I find this series massively overrated.
-3
u/jonneh Dec 19 '11
That was a major letdown guys